We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 28
18 ached Ns)
NCERT CLASS XI INDIAN
CONSTITUTION AT WORK
et 1 Sl cS =
|8 aca PANS)
Tce oit a}
2
OC a mT na me eer)
Poona Cte ee ECG Cee en = ara
law and order and lock after the welfare of the people. The Constitution
ensures that they work in coordination with each other and maintain a
eee ee een Cae eee aL nes
legislature are interdependent: the legislature controls the executive, and, in
eo anes
Ree On Cn a Runny
Peet eg ere18 ache TNs)
Mae Mela = Clay
The word executive means _a body of persons
Pee ened eae Reece eee? tS
wie Site BAC
Who is in charge of the administration of your school? Who takes ans
Peace Cee CL ean Rec el a Me cae eae tee (eer
office holder has to take decisions and implement those decisions, We call this,
CeCe CC Ce aCe eee en ae]
the top that will take policy decisions or the big decisions and supervise and
coordinate the routine administrative functioning
Re ee Re oe ee RC RR ola ee Ray
some office holders implement those decisions in actual day-to-day
ee ete18 aca PANS)
In the case of government also, one body may take policy decisions and decide
about rules and regulations, while the other one would be in charge of
implementing those rules. The organ of government that p Pe ea
eden en ee nae keer
What are the principal functions of the executive? Execulive is the branch of
government responsible for the implementation of laws and policies adopted by
the legislature. The executive is often involved in framing of policy. The official
Pe ee eee De ee et ee ee es
Gee nee ea eee Ce eg
presidents, prime ministers and ministers. I also extends to the administrative
machinery (civil servants). While the heads of government and their ministers,
Pct ee eer ce eae ce ome a hy
as the political executive, those responsible for day to day administration are
Pel eee econ8 aca PANS)
: < fotus
What are the different types of Executive? eas}
a ao a
ys His a
ey ee
aac
ulate
Chcled,
pisos18 acta PANS)
eee aL = Cea OM I ola co)
the constitution of Sri Lanka was. CC) Co RCE macy
many iaicbaccl, Uinibs io coun ef esto Petra, aca
‘Prt gr kere ecg eee nent ta
(ee oan es ele ie ee
ee CRU CR CU eR ae
|r efron iba perpen fete a gineres i eee a ft
Ce ee UCM RL oC MCh RS
Prime Minister, or ministers. Apart from being the elected Head of State and the
ce ee A eR ee UM a)
ets / E vm ee
A
rc x
ON ea loa
Plead
el re aoe
a anzd
Const: Counc f
sgetibeenteess
EG cud aaratd
ETN ee ao oad8 acta PANS)
Decne a cst Mun a
eran Re Rn ee aca es)
Ce ee eee Sat ae eae Ce
‘experience had shown that in the parliamentary system, the executive can be
Pree ese ea
Indian Constitution wanted to ensure that the government would be sensitive to
public expectations and would be responsible and accountable, The other
Oc Cue ee ea
Pe eee eet ee eee
Nae ice ae I dd
Cee ee a my
coe ee oe Reem eam tn emt
eg eee Cae ee eee ee ee eae ee
Pere eo aay Pipe sn a ear oe eng
ensure That the executive will be answerable to and controlled by the legislature
‘er people's representatives, So the Constitution adopted the parliamentary
SC aa Ae ee Sea18 acta PANS)
od
Cee RRS CU OR Ra ld
state of India and the Prime Minister and the Council of Mi
a nS
a Ra ee a Wn
Governor and the Chief Minister and Council of Ministers.
Oa Ree Cece can Ratan anc anc) rere}
President. In reality, the President exercises these powers through the Council of Coll
Ministers headed by the Prime Minister. The President is elected for a period of a
five years. But there is no direct election by the people for the office of dee
President, The President is elected indirectly. This means that the president is ete
See nea ennai eee eer oN Meccan Bn = Ma ah
SRC ere
ee Cae ee ee eer CR it
ere SR a e ee c ees
‘The President can be removed from office only by Parliament by following the
procedure for impeachment. This procedure requires a special majority as
explained in the last chapter. The only ground for impeachment is
‘the Constitution,
Pees
.8 aca PANS)
Power and position of President
Kiticle 74 (1): There shall be a Council of Ministers with the Prime Minister at the head to aid and
‘advise the President who shall in the exercis4 ‘of his functions, act in accordance with such advice.
Provided that the President may require t reconsider such advice....., and the
President shall act in accordance wi tendered after such reconsideration.
aA WhoO BYJU'S
cts
IAS8 Eta PANS) res
ceca Rm a CoC
+ On the basis of the above discussion can we infer that the President has no discretionary power under
any circumstances? This will be an incorrect assessment. Constitutionally, the President has a right to be
informed of all important matters and deliberations of the Council of Ministers. The Prime Minister is
obliged to furnish all the information that the President may call for. The President often writes to the
Eee eurnt PetCo eR COE ecient necting
"We did not give him any real power but we have made his
Pee eee eae eae eed
Ceol Beet emia ee ice a eae)
ee Cee
cae
Jawaharlal Nehru CAD, Vol. VI, p. 7348 aca PANS)
Besides this, there are at least three situations where the President can
exercise the powers using his or her own discretion. In the first place, we
have already noted that the President can send back the advice given by i
the Council of Ministers and ask the Council to reconsider the decision.18 ache TNs)
Rr Me Co
ST eg eoe Ne hare OM Tes (Ce eet aT)
i eS
passed by the Parliament
js
rt oe
Poa
Raid
Ream GSL 8 ache Ns)
Then, the third kind of discretion arises more out of poli
Cece a ea eae Ted
\
Tele Ee aoor Pua
coe cee rrr
SMMC et Ce meeC eciec ny anh) ee erent Bd Sasa
Tea ees oe eel Saeed
State legislatures are not part of the com
President may be removed frém his office by a resolution of the Rajya % rn
Ren CCM nue eee ieee Re ACM eel acti st Mad en tod Le ue
eet eee Ie Uist Aeurimrn Nm Me eRe aT (cu
takes over the office of tre Presid Oe RC
eee Cea carmen ate ec Care ee
The Vice President acts as the President only until a new President is
Prater Fi18 acta PANS)
ster and Council of Ministers
TT)
No discussion of government or politics in India, would normally take
place without mentioning one office: the Prime Minister of India. Can you
Fee R ae ean Oa nee gece uence ite
the President exercises his powers only on the advice of the Council of
ea eee oe Rm
Therefore, as head of the Council of Ministers, the Prime Minister
See eee ae ce eee eee ce
re
Poti1B NS}
SMart then ae Coa
Te Um ecto OCs Tcl
Beemer atime um ieee
ee enue enum ene d
cabinet minister, minister of Stale or depuly minister. In the
EO CL eS eC mae MuCLe
from their own party or coalition. The Prime Minister and all
the ministers have to be members of the ,Parliament. If
someone becomes a minister or Prime Ministef without being
Seen ier ae ee ae ne
SeanScr
Size of the Council of Ministers
+ Before the 91st Amendment Act (2003), the size of the Council of
nee ance Ree hee ence aes eT
requirements of the situation. But this led to very large size of the
Council of Ministers. Besides, when no party had a clear majority,
een cee ena Cet So ea eae ied
Degen eat eae a ee eaten eed
eee ee ae Oe ee mT
Rane e neha Cer ee ora
Carat nee eon Ie ett ie mae eer eg
exceed 15 percent of total number of members of the House of the
Peesea nee a cos
1 ay
i
oy1B Ns}
oe een poe enc en ete ee eee
eS ea eee Cae a aie ene te ee
ee SO tesa enna hee keene eg ine ee ie
eee ea Beene eR iC some enna es
Poe a eae Onan ie eee ee eg ey
ae oe ee eter en Nec ee mee caer eer
eens1B NS} ,
GC ORCC ere eae eT ae ete
Pa Lee
ister
Ce Re ee eu Ral et
has taken the oath of office. The death or resignation of the Prime
Minister automatically brings about the dissolution of the Council of
Ministers but the demise, dismissal or resignation of a minister only
eC Cielete tho ait MMI ee RM aL ask
the Council of Ministers on the one hand and the President as well as
CCU RU ee ee CCR eal an cre
Pt. Nehru to describe him as ‘the linchpin of Goverment’. It is also the
RT eae Melee Maa LR Com
Sree Cd CM MOC eae LoL Te MR COMLALY
Cree MO UM esc stone Moog el Ce Teay
BU Mat M Uae mE No Me eee els eco aa oe [OCU LAL
Crees Teese eta acura8 aca PANS)
Sa ee eee mea te
ORE ener te aos ica
Boer eae aCe ie ea
Sabha, command over the bureaucratic
ee Ce a att eee ene
Poa ia ea ae clea a
BP eae ere iat On are RCL
CeCe Eanes f1B oa Ns)
However, the power which the Prime Minister wields and
actually puts into ufé depends upon the prevailing
political conditions8 aca PANS)
Permanent Executive: Bureaucracy
NSM ay lh Mat Me oom Ma aU
NT =o MON LMA Me SC UA COL LAT
Prime Minister, the ministers and a large organisation called
Ria AUER Col ego ALATA Lhe LaT tp ALY
underline the difference between this machinery and the
military service, it is described as civil service. Trained and
Ae Aen Cn acm acucuin ole come mers
government are assigned the task of assisting the ministers
in formulating policies and implementing these policies.18 NS)
In a democracy, the elected representatives and the ministers are in
charge of government and the administration is under their control and
Aeon ee erga CeCe eat eee ios
Pee ee tte eee cat
Reena Dee eee eee ance ee etic a ge ene re
RSC ne te ees Rs ART a ee a)
eee see Mec ear mer icc Mena nee ie
PTCA ee Serie ree
also expected to be political js means that the bureaucracy
will not take any political posifiston policy matters. In a democracy, it is
Case CR ee once ieee mC
government wants to opt for new policies in the place of policies of the
Romeo eC ie Re tan eee nC MCe ant acer)
Cree ca DARL Oat ae Wier ane coe aay
drafting the policy and in its implementation
Bie eau os18 hachbal rN)
The Indian bureaucracy today is an enormously complex system. It consists of the
ee
and managerial staff running public sector undertakings. Makers of our Constitution
A eS ae ye ae te eS!
were aware of the importance of the non-partisan and professional bureaucracy.
They also wanted the members of the civil services or bureaucracy to be impartially
selected on the basis of merit. So, the Union Public Service Commission has been
entrusted with the task of conducting the process of recruitment of the civil servants
for the government of India. Similar public service commissions are provided for the
eee on en eee eae ea eke cee ee ence nam iced
een orien ina ea are
COT Utes ere ee)
of the Supreme Court.
While efficiency and merit are the norms for recruitment, the Constitution also
Ce eee eee ene eee ae
‘opportunity to be part of the public bureaucracy.8 aca PANS)
Persons selected by the UPSC for Indian Administrative Service and Indian Police Service constitute the
backbone of the higher level bureaucracy in the States. You may know that the collector of a district is the
most important officer of the government at the disirict level. Do you know that the collector is normally an
IAS officer and that the officer is governed by the service conditions laid down by the central government? An
IAS or IPS officer is assigned to a particular State, where he or she works under the supervision of the State
government. However, the IAS or IPS officers are appointed by the central government, they can go back into
the service of the central government and most importantly, only the central government can take disciplinary
action against them. This means that the key administrative officers of the States are under the supervision
and control of the central government. Apart from the IAS and the IPS officers appointed by the UPSC, the
administration of the State is looked after by officers appointed through the State Public Service Commissions.
a
eietieenen ise ate a
’ Un \ et
Lh — we
nd oe Ree ES ate BSCR
eget) pee ae acon
ere eke a)
ene)8 NS)
a eee era ea ete Ree ee te eg
Pee et he eee nto ae eee tent
pee ee ere ede eee eee ean eel Reet
eee ea eee tice oan un Ro cae
Pe eee eae an Ie ee eee ec orn ae ee
PP ee no ee ceo mee em eee sits
ee CnC een Cee Ce rae Recomm ito
ROC Re eet a eee emo aes
the politician, Though the Constitution has created independent
machinery for recruitment, many people think that there is no provision
meer eee ee ee ce
eR aie Cem ete one he eae eae nce)
oon tce cect cic eee ices eee my
There is an expectation that measures like the Right to Information may
Der vane eee eee ets
a a Sa
Fs8 aca PANS)
, ore ON
forte lero) te v7
eC coh Cae ce re an)
government. The executive enjoys greater powers compared to
Ome aL acn Me aa Ce ee eager
Pe er en Ree oem ey
Pe sen iean et nm oases ie Mcrae atte
Pee eect ee aCe eee co Tea
Pere en mean Ce ei Co carte
constitutional limits over the exercise of powers and democrat
politics have ensured that execufive organ cannot become
Prt) sae