Keep Your Eye On Prize
Keep Your Eye On Prize
                                               E
                                                       lectronic technologies are      Chen, & Hooever, 2006). However,
                                                       playing an increasing role in   evidence of successful AAC use is
                                                       mediating patterns of social    tempered by sobering statistics
                                               interaction within the classroom.       regarding limited communicative
                                               This trend includes augmentative        functions, barriers to successful
                                               and alternative communication           implementation, and system
                                               (AAC) systems, like the device used     abandonment (Johnson, Inglebret,
                                               by Sam from the opening vignette.       Jones, & Ray, 2006; Lund & Light,
                                               The advent of lightweight smart         2007). One area that remains
                                               tablets with a diversity of             particularly challenging is the
                                               communication-oriented                  successful integration of AAC
                                               applications at a fraction of the       systems within sustained social
                                               price of traditional AAC devices        interactions for children with
                                               increases the accessibility and         speech-language impairments (cf.
                                               potential application of such devices   Mellman, DeThorne, & Hengst,
                                               in the classroom.                       2010). Given the increasing
                                                    AAC in general has proven          availability of AAC systems and the
                                               effective for many children in regard   documented limitations in regard to
                                               to decreasing challenging behavior,     successful implementation across
                                               enabling communication of wants         everyday contexts, this article aims
                                               and needs, and supporting speech        to highlight the importance of
                                               development (Millar, Light, &           integrating AAC within a broad
                                                                                       communication framework. In direct
                                                                                       relation to the Initial Special
                                                                                       Education Professionals in Early
                                                                                       Childhood Special Education/Early
                                                                                       Intervention (Birth to Eight)
                                                                                       Standards (Council for Exceptional
                                                                                       Children, 2007), this article provides
                                                                                       a theoretical framework (Standard I,
                                                                                       ICCKI) to guide special education
                                                                                       practices toward embedding learning
                                                                                       opportunities in everyday activities
                                                                                       (Standard V, ECSES3) by
                                                                                       structuring social environments to
                                                                                       promote successful communicative
                                                                                       interactions (Standard V, ECE5S4)
                                                                                       particularly for children who utilize
                                                                                       AAC (Standard VI, ICC6K4).
                                                                                            The field of communication
                                                                                       sciences and disorders has long
                                                                                       differentiated speech and language
                                                                                       as separate but related processes
                                                                                       that refer to the sensory-motor and
                                                                                       linguistic skills of an individual,
                                                                                       respectively. This stands in contrast
                                                                                       to communication, which refers
          “
                             caregivers of children who are              2007). For example, when a speaker
                             largely “nonverbal,” parents often          in a conversation stumbles over a
                             tell us they want their children to         word, he or she may substitute
 If you think of your own    speak so that they can share ideas          gestures or actions for the missing
                             and know what their children are            word, or listeners may fill in words
 experiences, you have       thinking. One mother shared with            for the speaker, or in some cases, the
                             us that in her dreams, she and her          word is simply left out and the
probably noticed that the    son with limited verbal abilities can       conversation goes on without it.
                             “know each other’s minds.”                  Among familiar communication
degree of success in your    Inherent in these messages from
                             caregivers is a longing not so much
                                                                         partners, this happens so smoothly
                                                                         that, as long as the point gets across
     communicative           for speech and language, per se, but
                             for successful communication.
                                                                         and the conversation continues, we
                                                                         do not even notice how such success
                                  To help us understand what is          was achieved. Successful
 interactions depends on     involved in supporting successful           communication depends on the
                             communication for all children,             coordination of people and resources.
what you are doing, whom     including those who use AAC                      Finally, understood as a social
                             technologies, we draw here on               accomplishment, communication is
 you are interacting with,   sociocultural and practice theory           supported through the shared
                             approaches to child development             histories people bring to their
the resources available to   and learning (e.g., Bruner, 1996;           interactions with each other (e.g.,
                             Cole, 1998; Wells, 1999). These             best friends, strangers) and to the
you, and the nature of the   approaches offer a useful theoretical       activities at hand (e.g., playing a
                             framework that defines                      video game). In this sense, successful
  relationships you have     communication as a social
                             accomplishment, not as an isolated
                                                                         communication grows out of
                                                                         repeated opportunities for people to
                             individual ability or a set of testable     work together. If you think of your
built up with people over    skills. Seen as a social                    own experiences, you have probably
                             accomplishment, we understand               noticed that the degree of success in
          time.              communication as always occurring           your communicative interactions
          ”
                             within specific activities for specific     depends on what you are doing,
                             purposes (e.g., answering a teacher’s       whom you are interacting with, the
                             question, sharing small talk with           resources available to you, and the
                             friends). Successful communication          nature of the relationships you have
                             is then tied to how well those              built up with people over time.
                            Table 1
                            A Summary of the 4 Principles and Guiding Questions Associated With a
                            Framework of Communicative Competence
                            Principle                                      Guiding question
                            1. Support social interaction within          What is/are the relevant activities at hand?
                                meaningful activity
                            2. Share responsibility for successful        How do I collaborate with this child to support
                                interactions                                successful communication and participation?
                            3. Encourage multiple forms of                What resources are available to us in this
                                communication                               moment to support communication?
                            4. Draw on shared histories and build for     How can we draw on familiarity to support
                                future interactions                         current and future communication?
          “
                            perceived and “taken up” very                    children’s goals? How can we better
                            differently depending on whether                 align the children we are supporting
Within the framework of     the activity is book reading during
                            circle time versus a group sing-along
                                                                             with the activities taking place?” As
                                                                             an example, one of the teacher’s key
                            of Yankee Doodle Dandy, with the                 activities was shared book
     communicative          lyrics “Yankee Doodle went to                    interaction during circle time, which
                            London, just to ride a pony, stuck a             included transitioning and engaging
competence, caregivers,     feather in his hat, and called it                the children in book reading.
                            macaroni!” In the sing-along, Sam’s              Consequently, her responses to the
teachers, therapists, and   production would likely be taken up              children were shaped by her goal of
                            as direct participation in the activity,         fostering successful interaction and
 peers are all seen as      whereas during the preparation of                participation within that activity. In
                            book reading, Sam’s production                   this example, the primary goal is
 partners with the child,   appeared to be taken up as an act of             participation in the circle time
                            silliness by many of the children and            activity, not ensuring “correct device
  working together to       as a potential disruption by the
                            paraprofessional. Note that in this
                                                                             use” or even “making sure everyone
                                                                             is quiet.”
accomplish activities and   book reading versus sing-along
                            example, the actual word being
                                                                                  For children who use AAC, one
                                                                             advantage of identifying participation
                            produced (i.e., macaroni) is not                 in the activity as the goal is that it
communicate messages.       different, but its meaning is                    maximizes the options for how
          ”
                            interpreted differently based on the             successful communication can be
                            activity. Consequently, the guiding              accomplished. Looking again at the
                            question for those of us supporting              opening vignette, the children are
                            a child who uses AAC is “What is/                participating in the activity in a
                            are the relevant activities at hand?”            variety of ways, both verbally and
                                  When thinking about the                    nonverbally: for example, shouting
                            relevant activities, it is important to          out numbers, looking toward the
                            note that multiple goals and                     teacher, and raising their hands. There
                            activities are always at play. In                is no one correct way to participate in
                            thinking about the opening vignette,             the activity. Recognizing the diverse
                            the guiding question leads us to ask,            ways children can participate in the
                            “What is the teacher trying to                   meaningful activities at hand (e.g.,
                            accomplish here? What are the                    speech, eye gaze, gesture, device use)
                   “
                                                 identified, then it becomes clearer     their partners go about the
                                                 how to support the child’s successful   collaborative work of interpreting
       When the focus is on                      participation. Within the framework
                                                 of communicative competence,
                                                                                         communicative acts within the
                                                                                         activity, whether the form of that
                                                 caregivers, teachers, therapists, and   communicative action is a spoken
               successful                        peers are all seen as partners with     syllable or a selected symbol.
                                                 the child, working together to               Recognizing the shared
     communication, the form                     accomplish activities and               responsibility for successful
                                                 communicate messages. As partners,      interactions highlights the need for
      is reduced to its proper                   our actions should be guided by the     communication partners of children
                                                 question, “How do I collaborate         who use AAC to receive explicit
      place of being a means                     with this child to support successful   time and training on the relevant
                                                 communication and participation?”       device(s). Such training often takes
     toward an end, rather than                  Taking the opening vignette as an       the form of basic familiarity with
                                                 example, Sam selected the word          the system, including how to
            the end itself.                      “macaroni” on his device, but it did
                                                 not appear to be interpreted as
                                                                                         program it, and how to support its
                                                                                         use. Given enough familiarity with
                   ”
                                                 communicative by his teacher within     his device, the paraprofessional in
                                                 the carpet time activities. Instead,    the opening vignette could have
                                                 she chose to ignore his production,     supported Sam’s participation by
                                                 even though when a different child      helping him raise his hand and
                                                 later spoke out of turn she reminded    finding a relevant response to the
                                                 that child to raise his hand. When      rhyming task on his device.
                                                 applied to the opening vignette then,   Providing relevant models of
                                                 this principle of collaboration leads   message-focused AAC use is
                                                 us to ask, “What does the child         commonly viewed as best practice
                                                 bring to the interaction? What do       within the recent AAC literature
                                                 his or her communication partners       (Binger & Light, 2007; Harris &
                                                 bring, myself included? How can I       Reichle, 2004; Mirenda & Brown,
                                                 help align what the child brings to     2009; Romski & Sevcik, 2003),
                                                 the expectations of this                often referred to as “aided language
                                                 community?”                             stimulation” or “augmented input.”
                                                      A framework of communicative       A framework of communicative
                                                 competence encourages us to assume      competence suggests that children
                                                 relevant meaning from children’s        need to be socialized into using and
                                                 actions and respond accordingly,        responding to AAC, and this
                                                 something that parents are often        requires opportunities for them to
                                                 willing to do even with the youngest    observe AAC being used to
                                                 of children (cf. Dunst & Lowe,          communicate. In sum, the process of
                   “
                                                 most pressing when the child is using      and concerns that access to AAC
                                                 it in a way that is disruptive, such as    will negatively affect speech diminish.
                                                 when Sam blurted out “macaroni”            In sum, requiring any individual to
     In addition to drawing on                   in the opening vignette. However,          rely on one form of communication
                                                 instead of immediately restricting a       is “unnatural” and limits his or her
        shared histories, our                    child’s access to the device, we           ability to be a flexible and robust
                                                 would encourage caregivers and             communicator. Consequently,
     current interactions should                 professionals to consider the device       children who use AAC and their
                                                 as one of many important                   communicative partners are
       be paving the way for                     communicative resources within the
                                                 interaction and consequently turn to
                                                                                            encouraged to use all available
                                                                                            resources to foster successful
          successful future                      other options for shaping the
                                                 interaction, such as reminding him
                                                                                            interaction and participation in the
                                                                                            activity at hand, including their
                                                 that it is not time to talk about food     familiarity with one another.
              interactions.                      (see revised vignette at the end of
                   ”
                                                 this article).                             Draw on Shared Histories and
                                                      In addition to implications for
                                                                                            Build for Future Interactions
                                                 device accessibility, recognizing
                                                 multiple forms of communication                 One of the key resources
                                                 also diversifies opportunities for         communication partners often have
                                                 caregivers and professionals to            at their disposal, particularly
                                                 support Sam’s participation in the         caregivers, is familiarity and
                                                 group. Device use, though powerful         sustained relationship. In addition to
                                                 in certain contexts, can be                being distributed across people and
                                                 burdensome in others (Johnston,            resources, communicative
                                                 Reichle, & Evans, 2004; Sigafoos &         competence is also distributed across
                                                 Drasgow, 2001). Recognizing the            time. Present interactions are
                                                 legitimacy of multiple modalities          influenced by memories of the past
                                                 allows the AAC user and his or her         and plans for the future, which can
                                                 partners’ flexibility to use other         make familiarity a critical asset. As
                                                 communicative forms as the                 such, our interactions with children
                                                 circumstance allows.                       who use AAC should be shaped by
                                                      Recognizing AAC as one of             the question, “How can we draw on
                                                 many available resources also helps        familiarity to support current and
                                                 highlight the potential benefits of        future communication?”
                                                 AAC for children who have already               For all of us, familiar
                                                 developed, or are expected to              communication partners are able to
                                                 develop, spoken language.                  complete our sentences, anticipate
                                                 Specifically, there may be clear           our needs, and read our seemingly
                                                 advantages in using AAC for children       idiosyncratic behavior. Such
                                                 who have developed spoken language         familiarity should be viewed as a
                                               Authors’ Note
                                                   You may reach Laura Segebart DeThorne by e-mail at lauras@illinois.edu
                                               References
                                               Binger, C., & Light, J. (2007). The effect of aided AAC modeling on the
                                                   expression of multi-symbol messages by preschoolers who use AAC.
                                                   Augmentative and Alternative Communication, 23, 30-43.
                                                   doi:10.1080/07434610600807470