A. Record Feb 2023
A. Record Feb 2023
RESTORATION
RENOVATION
02 2023 $11.99 architecturalrecord.com
Design & Pre-Construction Service
Calla® Shapes for DesignFlex® with JLC-Tech® T-Bar Flex® Lights & Price® Diffusers > BWI Thurgood Marshall Airport - Baltimore, MD > JMT Architecture - Hunt Valley, MD
CORPORATE
CHIEF HR & INFRASTRUCTURE OFFICER
Rita M. Foumia
CHIEF PRODUCTION OFFICER
Vincent M. Miconi
ARCHITECTURAL RECORD (ISSN: Print 0003-858X Digital 2470-1513) February 2023, Vol. 211, CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER
No. 02. record is published 12 times annually, monthly, by BNP Media II, LLC., 2401 W. Big Beaver Rd., Lisa L. Paulus
Suite 700, Troy, MI 48084-3333. Telephone: (248) 362-3700, Fax: (248) 362-0317. CHIEF CREATIVE OFFICER
Michael T. Powell
Annual rate for print: US $44.99, Canada $84.99, and Foreign $149.00. Annual rate for digital: $19.00.
CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER
Single Copy sales: $12.00.
Nikki Smith
Printed in the U.S.A. Copyright 2023, by BNP Media. All rights reserved. The contents of this publication CHIEF EVENTS OFFICER
may not be reproduced in whole or in part without the consent of the publisher. The publisher is not Scott Wolters
responsible for product claims and representations. PANEL AND RESEARCH DIRECTOR
Ariane Claire
Periodicals Postage Paid at Troy, MI, and at additional mailing offices.
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to: ARCHITECTURAL RECORD, P.O. Box 1514, Lincolnshire,
IL 60069.
BNP MEDIA: (248) 244-6400
CANADA POST: Publications Mail Agreement #40612608. GST account: 131263923. Send returns
(Canada) to IMEX Global Solutions, P.O. Box 25542, London, ON N6c 6B2.
CHANGE OF ADDRESS: Send old address label along with new address to ARCHITECTURAL
RECORD, P.O. Box 1514, Lincolnshire, IL 60069. WEBSITE: architecturalrecord.com. SUBSCRIBER SERVICE: For subscription information or
service, please contact Customer Service at: Phone: (800) 952-6643; Email: AR@omeda.com SINGLE
FOR SUBSCRIPTION INFORMATION OR SERVICE, PLEASE CONTACT CUSTOMER SERVICE AT: COPY SALES: www.architecturalrecord.com/scs. If the Post Office alerts us that your magazine is
Local Phone: (847) 504-8163; Toll Free: (866) 501-7541; Fax: (847) 291-4816. undeliverable, we have no further obligation unless we receive a corrected address within one year.
REPRINTS: reprints@bnpmedia.com.
EDITORIAL OFFICES: (646) 849-7124. 350 Fifth Avenue, Suite 6000, New York, NY 10118.
BNP Media Helps People Succeed in
WEBSITE: architecturalrecord.com. Business with Superior Information
PRINTED IN USA
THE INVISIBLE WALL SYSTEM
Get wall-like R-values — with the aesthetic and daylighting benefits of glass.
With VacuMax™ vacuum insulating glass (VIG) by Vitro Architectural Glass, it’s possible to achieve R-values as high
as R16 in a nominal 1-inch insulating glass unit. VacuMax™ VIG — the ultimate thermal insulation in a window.
5
A R C H ITE C T G R I S K E LI S YO U N G H A R R E LL / P H OTO F U N G I M E D IA
ILLUSIONS® +
GLOW ™
INVITE
LIGHT
SEAMLESSLY
CAPTIVATING LIGHTING.
COMPLETE INTEGRATION.
IN THIS ISSUE
Photo courtesy of Heritage Marble Tile
Exploring Innovations in Exterior Ceramic Tile Site Selection Criteria for Commercial-to-Residential Conversions
Sponsored by Coverings 2023 Sponsored by The Steel Institute of New York
CREDIT: 1 AIA LU/HSW; 0.1 ICC CREDIT: 1.25 AIA LU/HSW; 1 GBCI CE HOUR; 1 PDH
Photo courtesy of Forms+Surfaces Photo courtesy of Garden on the Wall® Photo courtesy of Joto-Vent System USA, Inc.
ACADEMY SPOTLIGHT
To receive credit, you are required to read the entire article and pass the quiz. Visit ce.architecturalrecord.com for complete text and to take the quiz for free.
*All Architectural Record articles and presentations count toward the annual AIA continuing education requirement. All sponsored exams are available at no charge and are instantly processed, unless otherwise noted.
8 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
THERE’S ONLY ONE
METAL PARTITION
WHERE PRIVACY IS
TRULY INTEGRATED.
INTRODUCING
ASI’S PROPRIETARY,
INTEGRATED PRIVACY™
SYSTEM FOR METAL
PARTITIONS.
NEW IN WEBINARS
Photo courtesy of TVA Architects Photo courtesy of CETRARUDDY ARCHITECTURE Photo courtesy of CO Architects
Photo courtesy of Inpro Corporation Photo courtesy of Benjamin Moore & Co. Photo courtesy of Latreille Architectural Photography
NEW IN MULTIMEDIA
Photo courtesy of Vitro Architectural Glass Photo courtesy of Boston University Photo courtesy of @Fred Golden
Photo courtesy of © Ben Rahn/A-Frame Photo courtesy of Bison Innovative Products Photo courtesy of XPEL
NEW IN PODCASTS
Photo courtesy of Huber Engineered Woods, LLC Photo courtesy of © Chad Davies Photo courtesy of Blackwell Architects
Photo courtesy of Ross Barney Architects Photo courtesy of Jakitsch/Gardner Architects Photo courtesy of Selldorf Architects
*All Architectural Record articles and presentations count toward the annual AIA continuing education requirement. All sponsored exams are available at no charge and are instantly processed, unless otherwise noted.
This course is part of the Metal Academy. This course is part of the Mastering Movement™ Academy.
10 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
™
Arborisa
Biophilic Acoustic Cloud System
Transport inhabitants to a natural oasis and bring the great outdoors inside with Arktura’s new line of
expansive woodland inspired acoustic baffles.
Infinite Possibilities
AS RECORD ENTERS its 133rd year of publication, in a media land-
scape vastly changed even in just the last decade, and I take on the role
of editor in chief, the opportunities to present and discuss architecture
are boundless. With record’s expanding platforms, we aim to be a vital
resource for everyone in the profession, from leaders to those new to it.
For students of architecture, there are no limits to what you can
design. Studio is an opportunity to stretch your imagination as far as it
can go, where the suspension of disbelief allows us to imagine how both
the discipline and the profession may go beyond their conventional
limits. More often than not, projects are imagined from scratch, the site
a blank canvas upon which to build whatever novel form you desire.
12 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Find Transcend Lineage
near you.
L I N E A G Eª
Although Trex Transcend Lineage is designed to be cooler than most other composite decking products of a similar cost, on a hot sunny day, it will get hot.
On hot days, care should be taken to avoid extended contact between exposed skin and the deck surface, especially with young children and those with special needs.
© 2023 Trex Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Trex® is a federally registered trademark of Trex Company, Inc., Winchester, Virginia
Reimagine the Outdoor Experience
Interface Inc. Headquarters, Atlanta GA | architect: Perkins & Will | photographer: ©Nick Merrick
ROOFTOP DECKS PLAZAS GREEN ROOFS POP-UP PARKS WATER FEATURES DECK SUPPORTS WOOD TILES
CONCRETE & STONE 2CM PAVERS PAVER SUPPORT TRAYS ARTIFICIAL TURF GRATING SITE FURNISHINGS
In architectural photography there is always a distinction to be made between recording facts and doing so
in such a way that the viewer can see them.
―Cervin Robinson, architectural photographer
PHOTOGRAPHY: CERVIN ROBINSON. BUILDING IDENTITIES, CLOCKWISE FROM TOP, LEFT: TRIBUNE BUILDING (RICHARD MORRIS HUNT, 1875; DEMOLISHED); E.V. HAUGHWOUT & CO.
BUILDING (JOHN P. GAYNOR, 1857); PENNSYLVANIA STATION (MCKIM, MEAD & WHITE, 1910; DEMOLISHED); CHRYSLER BUILDING (WILLIAM VAN ALEN, 1930); ALL IN NEW YORK.
15
HOUSE of the Month
A SECOND HOME IN STOWE, VERMONT, SPEAKS TO THE VERNACULAR OF ITS MOUNTAINOUS SURROUNDINGS. BY LAURA RASKIN
VERMONT is synonymous with self-reliance ner Stephen Kredell, decided to do the same. Leod, he handed the architect a programmatic
and innovation, says Middlebury-based archi- (McLeod Kredell Architects was a 2020 diagram—a square divided into four. While
tect John McLeod, from its founding as an record Design Vanguard.) It was not a de- neither expected the final residence would be a
independent republic whose constitution parture from the firm’s work—houses, retail box, the sketch was “beautiful in its simplicity
forbade slavery to the nonconformists it proud- establishments, and school buildings that and clarity,” says McLeod. Inspired by the
ly claims as its own—Robert Frost, snow- celebrate simple purist forms. But it was an initial site visit, McLeod began drawing, ulti-
PHOTOGRAPHY: © DAVID SUNDBERG/ESTO;
boarding pioneer Jake Burton, and ice-cream opportunity to quietly protest the growing mately flipping the box inside out. “What
makers Ben and Jerry among them. spate of out-of-context luxury lodges and broke it open was realizing that, by creating
The architecture of the place followed suit, commercial projects that have burgeoned in these four rectangular boxes, you had three
adapting to natural phenomena like the Green Vermont’s mountain towns. sides to each box with views and light.”
KATE CARTER (OPPOSITE)
Mountains and Champlain Valley, with their Composed of four wings that stretch out in Sitting gently on the site and eschewing the
dairy farms and logging camps. Given the the cardinal directions and meet at a central excesses of resort culture, the house perches on
opportunity to design a house in Stowe (also open-air courtyard, the glue-laminated timber a moderately sloped clearing surrounded by a
the birthplace of Alpine skiing) for a New house on concrete slab is organized on an blanket of hardwoods and spruce trees rib-
York–based lawyer with a passion for the arts 8-foot grid to optimize the layout and mini- boned with trails.
and outdoors, McLeod, with consulting part- mize waste. When the client engaged Mc- Each clear-span wing is uniquely positioned
16 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
1 PORTE-COCHERE
2 ENTRY
3 LAUNDRY
4 COURT
17 14 5 KITCHEN
13
6 LIVING
7 DINING
8 DECK
17
HOUSE of the Month
18 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
40,000 happy listeners!
DET ILED
an original podcast, powered by Gābl Creative
Profile
Reimagine What Light Can Do
Landscape Forms |
A Modern Craft Manufacturer
LANDSCAPE
AN AERIAL TREE WALK IS THE CENTERPIECE OF A REIMAGINED BOTANICAL GARDEN IN PORTLAND, OREGON. BY RANDY GRAGG
into a grow ing drain and question mark in the plied, but Richard Hartlage and Sandy Land Morphology. “What you need is some-
city budget. So in 2014, Portland Parks & Fischer of the newly formed Seattle firm thing extraordinary to get people to come.”
Recreation (PPR) released an RFQ for a Landscape Morphology “threw a bold sche- Once hired, Hartlage and Fischer’s team
modest master plan update and a $1.3 million matic design on the table,” according to PPR (with Olson Kundig as consultant) continued
new entry garden and parking lot. The major project manager Ross Swanson. coloring outside the scope’s pinched lines,
agenda: give Leach a new, more prominent “We basically argued, ‘Why are you build- turning the original job into a $32 million
front door and a push toward stronger admis- ing more parking?’ ” recalls Hartlage, a vet- vision and a recently completed $12.6 million
sion- and event-driven financial performance. eran plantsman and executive director of first phase.
Top local and regional landscape firms ap- several botanical gardens before founding The master plan is a horticultural and
21
LANDSCAPE
1 MAIN ENTRY
2 GREENHOUSE
6 WOODLAND HILLSIDE
The tree walk has an open grate underfoot 5
(above). An open-air event space is the first of 7 GIFT SHOP
8 9 PARKING
architectural dreamscape featuring every-
thing from a native oak savanna to individual 9
gardens that highlight aquatics, moss, chro-
ma, physics, and children’s learning. Guided
by Hartlage’s deep experience with the fi-
nancial realities of public gardens, each area Early in the team’s work, Hartlage’s goal fundraisers, who, together, found the govern-
features carefully right-sized spaces for class- for “something spectacular” emerged: an ment grants and private donations for the
es, weddings, and other income generators— aerial tree walk. The first concept cantile- nearly tenfold increase in budget.
all phased and, for the right price, named. vered from hillside into treetop. Leach’s Visitation has doubled since the tree walk
Underlying botany and spreadsheets are steering committee quickly dubbed it the opened in March 2021. (The pandemic de-
two architecturally muscular transects. East to “diving board” as too architecturally alien and layed any reliable metrics of rentals and class-
west is the “cultural,” bracketing the Leaches’ the out-and-back experience too boring. The es.) The meadow now blossoms in an immer-
modest Arts & Crafts house (now a gift shop team then developed a circular stroll between sive kaleidoscope of 200-plus species. The tree
and meeting center) with various more formal land and treetops. Finally, after a Hartlage/ walk’s ellipse offers a sweeping horizontal
PHOTOGRAPHY: © LAND MORPHOLOGY
display gardens. South to north is the “envi- Fischer drawing session: an oval. “It’s more contrapuntal to the treetops’ soaring staccato.
ronmental,” versions of natural habitat rising elegant,” Hartlage says. “At the widest points, Seen from below, the tree walk’s thick sup-
from a major creek to a large new pollinator you can host a gathering or a plein air paint- porting columns read like kinfolk to neighbor-
meadow. It terminates with an Olson Kundig– ing class, but as it narrows at the highest ing Douglas firs. Underfoot, the walkway’s
designed open-air event space (completed) point, you get a sense of excitement and a open grate pairs function (self-cleaning) with
and, should the remainder of the master plan little peril.” The tree walk and a large con- the excitement of levitating 35 feet off the
be executed, with high-performance buildings necting pollinator meadow—and a small ground—a good analogy for the leap beyond
for offices and more events, all ethereally parking lot—became the hook that quickly the parking lot that Leach Botanical made
wrapped in sustainably harvested lath. captured the imaginations of politicians and with Land Morphology. n
22 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Timeless aesthetics,
intuitive operation
and robust engineering.
Automatic,
Universal Roll
Towel Dispenser.
Roll with it at
Bobrick.com/Spec-and-Roll/
GUESS THE ARCHITECT
WIN AN IPAD MINI
Sponsored by:
01 13 14 15
CAMPAIGN
BEST IN CLASS WINNER HONORABLE MENTION
01 Armstrong Ceiling Solutions 04 Bison Innovative Products 06 NanaWall Systems
Zban Advertising 05 CRL 07 National Terrazzo &
02 ASI Group Mosaic Association
Ganton 08 Vitro Architectural Glass
02 03 16 17 18 19 20 21
03 Landscape Forms Pipitone
SPREAD
BEST IN CLASS WINNER HONORABLE MENTION
09 Armstrong Ceiling Solutions 12 Armstrong Ceiling Solutions 14 Armstrong Ceiling Solutions
Zban Advertising
10 Fortress Building Products
Zban Advertising
13 CRL
Zban Advertising
04 05 22 23 24 25 26 27
Brandner Communications, Inc.
11 Vitro Architectural Glass
Pipitone
SINGLE PAGE
BEST IN CLASS WINNER HONORABLE MENTION
15 American Institute of Architects 23 Bison Innovative Products 34 ASI Group 06 07 28 29 30 31 32 33
16 ASI Group 24 Bobrick Washroom Equipment Ganton
Ganton Pipitone 35 Bison Innovative Products
17 ASI Group 25 Cosentino Group 36 Bradley
Ganton 26 Feeney Inc. KSS Marketing
18 Bobrick Washroom Equipment ER Marketing 37 CRL
Pipitone 27 Goldbrecht 38 Landscape Forms
19 Landscape Forms 28 Humboldt Sawmill Company, LLC 39 Landscape Forms
20 Louis Poulsen USA Mighty Media Partners 40 National Terrazzo &
21 Neolìth 29 Kalwall Mosaic Association
22 Rocky Mountain Hardware 30 NanaWall Systems 41 Neolìth
31 National Terrazzo & 08 09 34 35 36 37 38 39
Mosaic Association
32 PureEdge Lighting
33 Westlake Royal Building Products
Planit
10 11 12 40 41
• Advertise in the 2023 March or April print editions of Join us virtually in 2023 for a panel discussion on what
Architectural Record (full page or larger) our jury of architects look for in advertising. This is the
best opportunity to receive feedback on your marketing
– OR – efforts from your exact target audience.
• Run digital ads between now and the end of March Contact your sales representative to reserve
on architecturalrecord.com your space today!
architecturalrecord.com/adawards
KB310-SSRE-MBLK KB301-SS KB310-SSRE
27
Record TRIBUTE
28 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Where Your Vision
Meets Our Expertise
Terrazzo is a handcra ed building material; its primary
components are assembled on the construction site.
For 100-years, the contractor members of the National
Terrazzo and Mosaic Association have brought integrity
and skill to countless installations. The NTMA has
the expertise your project needs. Find specifications,
information, color samples, contractor and supplier
members at www.ntma.com or call 800-323-9736.
The Charles, Atlanta Installing contractor: Pierre Construction Group Architect: Lord Aeck Sargent
Distributor: Commercial Roofing Specialties GC: Brasfield & Gorrie Photo: hortonphotoinc.com
IL: 800 PAC CLAD MD: 800 344 1400 TX: 800 441 8661 GA: 800 272 4482 AZ: 833 750 1935 WA: 253 501 2450 PAC-CLAD.COM | INFO@PAC-CLAD.COM
Guess the Architect Contest
ENTER NOW! A monthly contest from the editors of RecoRd asks you to guess
the architect for a work of historical importance.
PHOTOGRAPHY: © DOMENICO LUCÀ VIA WIKIMEDIA COMMONS (TOP); LEONARDO FINOTTI (BOTTOM)
The Tancredo Neves Integrated Center for Public Education (Centro Integrado de
Enseñanza Pública, or CIEP) was designed by Oscar Niemeyer. Niemeyer, working
with Rio de Janeiro governor Leonel Brizola, created a standardized design for the
CIEP program that was used in the construction of hundreds of new public schools in
the 1980s and 1990s.
By entering, you have a chance to win an iPad mini. See the complete rules and entry form
online at architecturalrecord.com/guessthearchitect.
31
Keep the sash.
Improve the glass.
Pilkington Spacia™
The thermal performance of conventional double glazing in the same thickness as a single
pane for historical restoration.
more worthwhile, then, is to ask why rather The architect deconstructs the neologism, Ventanas™ PANEL style: Walnut modularArts, Inc.
70
66 64
60
58
54 52
58
50
51 53 52
48
40
30
20
D J F M A M J J A S O N D
2021 2022
INQUIRIES BILLINGS
34 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
765432105/.-,+733/-1*)546,('&%$#",%! !("&,!(,"$(,,&,!,$ ,"!"&(,"
&"('(,'&",! ,%&,5%"&,!(,!",!,$(,"" ",&! ,!",&"$,$"(! ,
$ ,#$ ,",'(","&!#$,&! $,&,"&"$,,"!"&(,!,# &"((!",(&" ,
, (!,$ ,",#&,$#"(, $'&$,# #&"",",/"(",%"$'&"(,$",!,$ ,!"$,
&" $!&,&$&,%&,# #&"",$(,&! $,($(, &"#$(,# #&"",($!&(,$ ,$# !"(,
(",765432105/.-,+733/-1*)546,%&,$(! ,&"('(,'&,#!" (,!,$ &"#!$"
Rainbow Effect
Floor coverings are seeing a resurgence in
color with uplifting pastels, calming
neutrals, and bold and contrasting hues.
BY SHEILA KIM
Expanded iQ Collections
Tarkett recently refreshed and expanded its iQ Granit collection of homogeneous vinyl
sheet and tile flooring with new colorways and the North American introduction of the
coordinating iQ Eminent and Eminent Unisense styles, which feature terrazzo-like
patterns at various scales. Shown here: the new iQ Granit Yellow Brick, Red Brick, and
Red hues; the iQ Eminent in Light Beige; and the iQ Eminent Unisense in Dusty Yellow.
tarkett.com
Opus Abstracts
Karndean has launched a new
capsule collection within its
Opus glue-down luxury vinyl
line. A grouping of abstracted
takes on familiar materials—
Astrum
from stucco and stone to
A modern take on travertine, the Supergres
textiles and timber—Opus
Astrum porcelain-slab collection combines a
Abstracts has a 20mil wear
variety of scales with an updated neutral
layer and comes in a wide
palette and a choice of matte or anti-slip
range of formats, in both
surface finishes, to fit with contemporary
subdued and deep colors such
architecture. The slabs are offered in sizes of
as Burnt Sienna and Black Iron
up to 48" square, in crosscut or vein-cut
(shown).
styles, and in one of four colorways.
karndeancommercial.com
supergres.com
Quotes
Known for painting bold
geometric graphics, artist
Alain Biltereyst lends his
signature style to Kvadrat for
a new rug collection. The
Quotes rugs are handwoven
of pure New Zealand wool and
available in sizes ranging from
5' 11"x 7' 10" to just over 13' x
16½'. Custom colors are also
available.
kvadrat.dk
36 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Stones at Large
This porcelain tile collec-
tion from Crossville
simulates marble in three
tones and four different
scales, from 4" x 12" to
48" square, the largest of
which creates a high-end
look by minimizing visible
grout lines. Applicable to
both floors and walls,
Stones at Large can be
specified with a polished
or unpolished finish. A
coordinating 2"-square
mosaic is also offered.
crossvilleinc.com
Fresco Valley
New to Interface′s biophilic-themed offerings is
Fresco Valley, a collection of three LVT designs
that mimic patterns derived from nature—such as Heritage
Ridge (above)—each in six colorways. The 4.5mm- To celebrate its 30th
thick product is carbon neutral and both anniversary, American
GREENGUARD Gold and FloorScore certified. mosaic company New
interface.com Ravenna has unveiled
the Heritage collection.
The designs are inspired
by the manufacturer’s
own design history of
producing traditional
patterns that reference
ancient Roman and
Tunisian palaces, and by
more current trends,
including the creation of
ombred and saturated
patterns.
newravenna.com
Spatial Palette
Eco-conscious architects
rejoice: this Patcraft
series employs a new
platform to make a fully
recyclable 100% PET
Spacia Collection product, backing includ-
Mannington Commercial’s latest LVT release
ed. The result is a hybrid
comprises 68 wood, 28 stone, and 20 abstract
12" x 48" plank boasting
patterns in tile or plank formats, many of which
the performance of a hard
coordinate with the manufacturer’s other LVT
surface while providing
products. As an example, Spacia in Windsor Oak
comfort underfoot. The
(above, at left) is paired with Mannington’s Color
planks feature a cross-
Anchor LVT in Stone Wash (above at right).
hatch design in 16
manningtoncommercial.com
heathered colorways.
patcraft.com
37
Record NEWSMAKER
38 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
A lot of it is just people making noise. I’m
not a trained preservationist, but I sure as hell
know good spaces. I sure as hell understand
how people circulate, and how you can make
connections that leave visitors with a coherent
experience, and how you make mechanical
systems work in spaces that weren’t meant to
have the kind of sophisticated setup we re-
quire nowadays. Many of the people who
have complained about the Frick did so be-
cause they were neighbors and didn’t want to
have construction for two years.
People objected to the removal of the
round music room. You can get upset about
this removal of some original fabric. But what
you get in return is tremendous. Of all the
spaces in the building, the music room was in
the way of connecting the library with the
collection. These changes enable us to make a
much better connection for the entire com-
plex, for linking scholarship with the museum
itself.
Selldorf Architects’ proposals for London’s National Gallery (above) and the Frick Collection (bottom).
At the Sainsbury Wing, you have to contend
again with VSB, specifically Denise Scott
Brown, who has been extremely vocal about more concerned about her legacy being intact edged there is a need for the building to
her displeasure with your proposal. and fully represented—she came back and change. She would always ask, “Why does it
I appreciate Denise Scott Brown. And she complained about the removal of the pergola. have to change? Why do you have to make
is someone who has always felt that she wasn’t She kept saying that it was the “beloved Sainsbury the main entrance?” It was hard to
recognized enough. I don’t know what that’s pergola.” I couldn’t remember anybody “be- have an exchange.
like; I didn’t work alongside a husband whose loving” it, but she apparently did. And I If I turn to the argument of precedent, I
charisma is such that everybody was on their accept that. should use Denise’s own terminology. In one
knees. Her life story is compelling and inter- With VSB’s Sainsbury Wing, which of her books or lectures, she showed these two
esting, and she never fails to remind us that opened in 1991, the challenge is bigger, be- drawings on yellow stickies, one of a glove,
she was trained as an urban planner. So, with cause it’s a Grade I listed building. The most and the other of a mitten. She used these
San Diego, I felt she enjoyed my positive frustrating aspect is that Denise and I never cartoons to say that you cannot anticipate
response to her thinking about La Jolla as a got to a point in the many, many, many, what is going to happen in the course of time
place. Yet I was quite surprised that—maybe many—can I say a few more times “many”?— and that buildings need to be flexible enough
because she is many years older and much conversations that we had where she acknowl- to go with change. Whereas the glove stood
for specificity, the mitten was more akin to
the Postmodern architecture VSB had pro-
moted, which incorporated a representation of
something, along with a great deal of flexibil-
ity behind it.
39
Record NEWSMAKER
SEE FLOORING
differently
View looking south in the Sainsbury ground floor, with the original
rusticated wall along the Grand Staircase.
they queue in the rain or in the sun, whatever the case may be. What
we’re proposing is to create an enclosed, transparent security vestibule
that allows people to enter at a much faster pace, without the kind of
transgressive intervention of guards and equipment.
WHEN THE Toronto-based architecture stages, the roof caved in. “We told him he was revive a historic building while adding offbeat,
firm Giannone Petricone Associates (GPA) was mad,” recalls Sorbara’s son-in-law Sol Korn- contemporary touches.
DOUBLESPACE (OPPOSITE, TOP)
asked by Greg Sorbara—a former Canadian gold, who later changed his mind and left the Pina Petricone and Ralph Giannone, the
politician and finance minister—to renovate the software business he helped found to become husband-and-wife team who in 1995 founded
Royal Hotel, an 1879 Victorian building he and the Royal’s general manager. Sorbara wanted to the firm—known for sleek urban towers and
his family had bought in Picton, Ontario, in create a gathering spot on Main Street for exuberant retail and restaurant projects, as
2013, the architects knew they had their work locals and tourists visiting Prince Edward well as sophisticated houses, furniture, and
cut out for them. The central staircase was County, an agricultural area known for its food lighting—enjoy working at many different
carpeted with moss, and, early in the planning and wine. The architects saw an opportunity to scales. The architects redesigned the existing
42 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
The restaurant’s
ceiling reinterprets a
Victorian rosette as
the 22-foot-diameter
underside of a
mushroom (above).
Rippling plaster
hotel with 28 guest rooms, a café, three bars, a restaurant, Upon entering the lobby, the open-all-day Counter Bar
encircles ceiling
lights in the Parlour spa, gym, and sauna. Outside, a redbrick garden terrace is on the left. The floor and bar are white oak, as are fins
(top, right) and a overlooks a fourth bar and a patio with a fireplace, and at the ceiling. Beyond the bar, the marble and bronze
column near the also leads to a swimming pool. Nearby, the hotel’s stables check-in desk (upholstered in a quilted traditional floral
reception desk were turned into the Royal Annex, an “abstracted farm- fabric) sits on a marble mosaic “carpet” set into the oak
(right). house” that contains five rooms. floor. At the top of a large column, a ring of light illumi-
GPA’s approach to the project was a mixture of conser- nates a rippling plaster ceiling rosette, which alludes to
vation and innovation. The facade was landmarked from water damage that had occurred throughout the hotel—
the second floor up, but the first floor had been altered. part of the architects’ strategy of invoking “sublime decay.”
The architects restored the upper facade while recreating Across from the bar, the Parlour is a lobby lounge for
the front balustrades on the lower portion in expanded gathering and working where a large GPA-designed cabi-
metal mesh. net houses the Convertible Bar. A fireplace surround was
43
INTERIORS
44 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
The Office Unplugged.
Introducing B+N’s solution for the new Hybrid Workplace: Rolling Office.
Battery-driven or Plug-and-Play 120v. Easily rolled to create collaboration areas.
Reconfigured without tools, without electricians, and with minimal manpower.
Visit us on the web to see more inspiration and detailed information
on just how Rolling Office can support the way we work now.
www.BNind.com
© B+N Industries Inc. 800.350.4127 Meet Taboroid™: battery-powered, a PET felt pad, and storage.
BEFORE IT’S
April 18 – 21, 2023
Orlando, Florida
TRENDING, IT’S
The ultimate destination for breathtaking
“wow” moments, Coverings boasts the largest
and most impressive display of tile and stone in
North America. Explore the latest trends from
around the globe that deliver the quality, luxury,
AT COVERINGS
and visual appeal your customers demand.
With a fresh idea at every turn, there is always
a bold innovation to discover, a new partner to
connect with, and a planet-friendly product to
be specified. No matter your client, you’ll find
the perfect source of tile and stone inspiration
and knowledge at Coverings 2023.
PHOTOGRAPHY: COURTESY GOTTSCHO-SCHLEISNER, LIBRARY OF CONGRESS PRINTS & PHOTOGRPAHS DIVISION (LC-G612-39053 &
CORRIDORS of the
Throughout much of the 19th century,
hospital were lined
LC-G612-39091), VIA MARY KAY JUDY; NEW YORK CITY HEALTH & HOSPITALS CORPORATION, DUNN DEVELOPMENT (OPPOSITE)
“miasmas” or even lapses in moral judgment with observation
were often thought to cause tuberculosis windows (above).
(sometimes called consumption). The formu Each wing of the
lation of germ theory in the 1880s, however, hospital terminated
helped medical professionals understand the with a solarium,
where patients
disease’s communicable nature, spreading
could undertake
through the air much like influenza or “heliotherapy” (left).
Covid19. Until pharmacological treatment
was commonplace, doctors turned to archi
tects for a solution: “taking the cure” meant
isolation from others in tuberculosis sanatori
ums with plenty of exposure to the sun and
fresh air. This translated into dedicated facili
ties far from dense urban centers, with balco
nies or terraces wide enough to accommodate
bedridden patients, proper orientation, and
ample glazing, as well as all the auxiliary
spaces necessary to maintain hygiene (and style (he was, perhaps deridingly so, nick sium proposed for Manhattan’s Morningside
sanity) for patients who often needed months named “the last Roman”). But the extent of Park (never built, following the violent pro
or years to fully recover. Aino and Alvar Pope’s involvement is not fully understood— tests at Columbia University in 1968).
Aalto’s Paimio Tuberculosis Sanatorium he died only a few months into the project, “Ample wholesome food, fresh air, regu
(1933) is perhaps the most notable example, and its art moderne character seems much lated amounts of sunshine, rest” are what
and certainly one Triboro’s architects would more akin to the diverse repertoire of his patients of the Triboro could expect, accord
have known. successors Otto Eggers and Daniel Higgins, ing to record in August 1938, when the
The commission to build Triboro was who later designed the Georgianstyle magazine published plans and a rendering of
granted in early 1937 to American architect Silliman College at Yale University; a mod the building, then breaking ground. Tripar
John Russell Pope, famous for his large public erne auditorium at Indiana University; and tite organization and clear axiality are com
buildings and penchant for the neoclassical the highly controversial Modernist gymna plemented by distinctly moderne details:
48 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
rounded corners, semicircular solariums with
ribbon windows, cascading rooftop terraces,
and a central prow with a bowed window bay.
Though the buff brick-and-limestone struc-
ture is 10 stories tall, the plans reveal its long
and narrow nature, allowing patients equal
access to the sun. This horizontality is fur-
ther stressed by long cantilevered balconies
and brick reveal courses at the base.
Today, the former hospital is known as the
T Building. “It doesn’t look like affordable
and supportive housing, but it is,” says
Maggie Poxon, Dunn Development’s project
manager, as she spirited me around, punch
list in hand, “but only after years of painstak-
ing work.” Decades of water infiltration, ad
hoc interventions, and rampant disregard
resulted in widespread spalling, boarded-up
windows, collapsing ceilings, and an infesta-
tion of raccoons. The hospital had fallen into
such a decrepit state that film crews used it to
depict the fictional Arkham Asylum in the
television series Gotham.
Initial redevelopment plans for market-rate
senior housing were derailed by the 2007–8
recession, and, in 2012, a proposal to convert
the building entirely into housing for people collaborated on nearly 30 low-income housing windows, were still intact. On the other hand,
experiencing homelessness prompted outcry. projects with SLCE, engaged community restoring the Schuster two-way structural
“The community board went wild,” says stakeholders and organized tours of those system—fireproofed steel with terra-cotta
SLCE partner Saky Yakas. Many from the buildings to quell skepticism and build trust. block and reinforced-concrete infill—proved
neighboring residential enclave Parkway “First, we listened. But we also presented a lot an arduous, if expensive, challenge. Without
Village called for the building’s demolition of demographic and economic data that chal- many redundancies, the “grid is sacrosanct. If
(ironic, given that community’s history as lenged their assumptions,” says Dunn presi- one of the ribs is cut, the entire span needs to
former worker’s housing for United Nations dent Martin Dunn. Under the final agree- be reinforced with steel,” Poxon explains, and
staff, many of whom were people of color and ment, the city’s public-hospital system the discovery that the hospital had cut holes
had difficulty finding housing elsewhere in continues to own the T Building and its site, through it came with an unexpected $1.5 mil-
the city). “The project was a political football. but a 99-year ground lease was extended to lion price tag.
The Landmarks Preservation Committee the developer in exchange for the building’s To finance the $84 million construction
didn’t want to landmark it, either” says Judy, rehabilitation, including 12,800-square-feet cost, Dunn Development turned to two
who, alongside architectural historian Kerri of office space for the adjoining Queens federal tax-incentive programs. The Federal
Culhane, got the building on the National Hospital Center. Historic Preservation Tax Incentive, adminis-
Register of Historic Places instead. In some ways, the rehabilitation effort tered by the National Parks Service in coordi-
But, in 2014, the city selected Dunn, a benefited from the building’s neglect. When nation with each State Historic Preservation
Brooklyn-based developer, to rehabilitate the construction began in July 2019, most of the Office (SHPO), and the Low-Income Hous-
243,000-square-foot hospital as 125 units of original materials, including marble in the ing Tax Credit (LIHTC) program, adminis-
affordable housing and 75 units of supportive lobby, bronze grilles, terrazzo floors, teak tered by the U.S. Department of Housing &
housing. The developer, which previously handrails, glass and tile blocks, and steel sash Urban Development in coordination with
various state and local agencies, which allo-
THE ARCHITECTS
cate $8 billion in tax deductions for projects
published a rendering of every year, together funded $53 million, with
the 550-bed hospital in tax benefits passed on to equity investors.
the August 1938 issue of Balancing the competing interests of these
Record (left). The T two programs—retaining historically signifi-
Building is oriented cant architectural elements from the hospital
toward the southwest,
guaranteeing ample
and providing housing that doesn’t feel insti-
sunlight inside (above). tutional to tenants (who must make 60 per-
cent or less of the Area Median Income)—
was no easy feat. “Meeting the Secretary of
the Interior’s standards and allowing the
49
FIRST LOOK
10
7 8 9 5 5 9 8
6 3 4 4 4 4 4 4 3 6
5 1 5
2 2
1 1
flexibility needed for new proposed uses can be a pretty nuanced con- Merchants Block Association, which assists residents transitioning out
versation,” says Olivia Brazee, historic-site restoration coordinator at of homelessness with on-site case managers and recreation aides.
the New York SHPO. For example, observation windows, which al- Nonprofit ChaShaMa will offer affordable studio spaces to artists, who
lowed nurses to monitor patients from the hallways, were integral to will in turn teach classes. Other amenities include a ninth-floor com-
the original program. Many had been covered in the decades leading up munity room (once a small theater for visiting thespians, to keep pa-
to the renovation, and they would not have satisfied residential fire- tients in high spirits), along with a computer lab (the hospital’s former
safety codes had they been fully restored. The solution came in the medical library), on-site laundry, and a fitness center. Outside, amid a
form of “a frame that recalled the presence of a window,” Brazee says, pollinator garden designed by NV5, children can enjoy a playground.
where the nonprofit Photoville will install artwork on a rotating basis. And there is free Wi-Fi building-wide—“this fourth utility is an issue
Maintaining the original 10-foot-wide corridor, also a requirement, of equity. Dunn Development provides supportive-housing tenants
pushed SLCE to be creative with apartment layouts, which needed to with Chromebooks, and social services train tenants how to use them,” PHOTOGRAPHY: COURTESY DUNN DEVELOPMENT.
contend with the locations of existing windows, mullions, and access to Poxon says. With only minor work on the community center left, the T
balconies. The units range from studios to three-bedroom apartments, Building is already 100 percent occupied.
creating a mix of household sizes. “A more diverse community is a Dunn Development received over 37,000 applications through the
stronger one,” Dunn points out. NYC Housing Portal. Those numbers can be interpreted as an indica-
Significantly, had the former hospital been demolished, current tion of the project’s appeal, but they also highlight the extreme, contin-
zoning only permits the construction of a four-story residential build- ued need for more affordable housing. New construction isn’t the only
ing. “Here, historic preservation preserved density as well,” Dunn adds. way to meet that need—adaptive reuse has an important role to play. The
The former hospital’s auxiliary spaces were also easily repurposed T Building not only stands as an example that underutilized buildings
for amenities or to aid supportive housing (which is housing comple- can be made into durable, dignified housing, but it shows what’s possible
mented by on-site social services). Telephone booths and fluoroscopy when architects, developers, preservationists, policymakers, and commu-
rooms were converted into a suite of offices for the Church Avenue nity stakeholders work together in a way they seldom do. ■
50 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
CLOSE UP
52 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Leighton House has only been expanded
some 7,000 square feet, to just under 80,000
square feet. But these modifications are tips
to icebergs of institutional reorganization.
The most visible component of the renova-
tion work—done by international firm
BDP—to Leighton House, one of London’s
great hidden architectural treasures, is simply
a new entrance, inlaid with a sunburst of
black ceramic detailing, inserted into the
Perrin Wing. It redirects visitors from the
front door, with steps, that Frederic Leighton
and his many guests used, to an approach
that now meets contemporary standards of
accessibility.
Even the largest new component is small.
To the rear now is a brick-clad rotunda, 30
feet high and 20 feet at its widest. Containing
a staircase and elevator, it nestles into the last
unobtrusive exterior space in the large gar-
den, from which the two-story cylinder of
circulation can be seen, providing symmetry
with the dome of the fabled Arab Hall on the
west wing of the building. Hidden within
Leighton House, however, BDP—whose
heritage projects include current work on the
Houses of Parliament—created approximate-
ly 2,700 square feet of additional floor space,
largely in a newly excavated basement, which
provides a new drawing gallery, extra bath-
rooms, conservation, and teaching rooms.
It is the latest stage of a steady expansion.
Frederic Leighton (born in 1830 into a
wealthy family) built his house as an endlessly
expanding work of art, made to display his
collections, which includes work by his con-
temporaries as well as an astonishing range of
Middle Eastern tiles. In close collaboration
with the architect George Aitchison, he
created, in stages beginning in the 1860s,
what is still a pavilion of Victorian eclecti-
cism. Its rear facade is a particular joy, a
collage of wrought-iron balconies and domes,
with a north-facing winter garden. Leighton
was possibly the most active or powerful
president of the Royal Academy in its history,
and there is much to be told about Leighton
and his milieu; many members of his circle
bought houses in the vicinity (as a current
exhibition details.)
Gainsborough’s House, conversely, is a
simple Georgian rowhouse in a cheery Suffolk
market town. The relatively modest home in
which Thomas Gainsborough was born in
A cylindrical brick addition to Leighton House
(opposite) contains a helical stair with a
handpainted mural inspired by the poet Rumi
(top). The renovation allows more room for
exhibition (right).
53
CLOSE UP
A new café occupies the central space on the narrow building for the much larger paintings extension primarily allows some of Gains-
ground floor of Leighton House. that Gainsborough made after moving to borough’s more famous works to be properly
London and becaming (arguably) Britain’s exhibited in the same vicinity as his earlier
1727 became a museum in 1956, dedicated to greatest-ever portraitist. ones. The ground floor of the new structure is
his origins—unlike Leighton’s, which conveys To do just that, museum specialists clad in knapped flint and is drawn back
the culmination of a major artistic career. The ZMMA have built a new three-story gallery slightly from the street. The protruding upper
former’s life is discernible only in flashes, as in building. It sits behind the original house, at two stories of the building are clad in red
the long stretch of glazing he added to the the end of a connecting row of three buildings brick, a commitment less to immediate con-
north-facing studio, to provide light ample down a side street, which the museum owns text than to local materials. (The handmade
enough for painting his wealthy clients. It has and that contain a shop, café, and print studio bricks were produced two miles away.)
always been a struggle to find space in the (refurbished as part of the recent works). The Instead of using flint as an inlay to brick as
54 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
is traditional, the division highlights the scale tions and articulating the cultural relation- The ground floor of the new structure at
of the upper floors, and the building looms ships that the east of England has with the Gainsborough’s House is clad in knapped flint
over the side street somewhat (although the rest of the country and continental Europe. and topped by an upper level of local brick.
scale does address an old silk factory immedi- The new elements are not just about ex-
ately to the west of the extension; Sudbury is panding the museum: they also improve However, “access” can also mean access to art.
historically the center of Britain’s silk indus- access, an ongoing issue with historical build- The new gallery space here has the security
try). The new build accommodates an addi- ings. As with Leighton House, the most and environmental controls that will allow
tional 3,500 square feet of exhibition space, in prominent new component at Gainsborough the institution to borrow the best work—as
four galleries, across three floors. With it, provides better circulation; to make it wheel- they have done with several of Gainsbor-
Gainsborough’s House has become a regional chair-accessible, the ancient floorboards had ough’s finest society portraits, displayed in a
art gallery, capable of hosting touring exhibi- to be dropped and the garden relandscaped. stunning room clad in green damask silk, on
the ground floor.
In addition, the extensions have enabled a
larger internal reorganization of the respec-
tive museums. The curatorial result is that the
museums’ famous former inhabitants can be
understood within the artistic culture that
they worked in while also expanding the
repertoire of the museum.
Significantly, both museums have incorpo-
rated new gallery space dedicated specifically
to drawing, a medium that in our digital age
is engaging new audiences, enchanted perhaps
1928 & 1955 2022
Perrin Wing, In-Fill and escape stair Removal of escape stair and addition by the immediacy of how a simple pencil or
of circulation cylinder
charcoal line on a page can conjure up new
worlds. In the case of Gainsborough’s House,
55
CLOSE UP
PHOTOGRAPHY: © HUFTON+CROW (2, AND OPPOSITE, TOP); JEFF SPICER (OPPOSITE, BOTTOM)
7
10 9 8
the gallery has been created on the house’s creative approach of revealing the spirit of the
second floor following the rehang. One of the past. And while it is notable that BDP has a
11 12 7 many charms of Gainsborough’s House is high level of in-house technical expertise (in
that the old dwelling remains a gallery rather terms of lighting, for example), and ZMMA
than a simulacrum of a domestic space has a long expertise in dealing with the tech-
0 30 FT.
GROUND FLOOR PLAN
10 M.
(whereas Leighton House was always a gallery nical requirements of gallery spaces such as
that one man lived in). One of the eight ventilation and natural light, they have each
gallery rooms in the house is currently given been asked to channel the spirit of the origi-
1 TICKETING/RECEPTION 8 STUDY ROOM over to the work of Cedric Morris, who ran nal rather than preserve its fabric literally.
2 EXHIBITIONS GALLERY 9 HISTORIC HOUSE an unlikely art school in the 1930s nearby, This has matched a new curatorial ap-
3 GAINSBOROUGH ENTRANCE through which Lucian Freud passed. proach. The two museums are not intended to
GALLERY 10 PAINTING ROOM It is an exciting time for preservation in the make the lives of their former owners any
4 PRINT WORKSHOP GALLERY UK. British practitioners in the field used to more legible as chronological histories or
5 CAFÉ 11 CEDRIC MORRIS treasure the fabric of ancient buildings above remote historical lives, but to explore how life
GALLERY all else, after the precepts of William Morris, and art intermingle—how individual artists
6 COURTYARD
7 SHOP
12 EARLY GAINSBOROUGH who valued repair above renovation. For a influence the world around them, and are
GALLERY long time, the British have eschewed the more influenced by it. n
56 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
The unusual
basketweave pattern
of the brick on the
Gainsborough’s
House addition is
visible from street
level (opposite,
bottom). Its irregular
sawtooth roof stands
out amid the Suffolk
market-town
surroundings
(opposite, top), and
results in striking
galleries (above).
Visitors explore the
Gainsborough Gallery
(right).
57
TOGETHER
WE CAN BUILD A BETTER FUTURE
NET ZERO
CARBON MANUFACTURING BY 2030
50
REDUCTION
IN PRODUCT CO2INTENSITY
FROM SUPPLY PARTNERS
BY 2030
ZERO EMISSION
COMPANY CARS BY 2025
RENOVATION,
RESTORATION,
ADAPTIVE REUSE
60 Quay Quarter Tower
Sydney | 3XN
76 Building 12
San Francisco | Perkins&Will
CONTINUING EDUCATION
To earn one AIA learning unit (LU), including one hour of health,
safety, and welfare (HSW) credit, read the “Renovation, Restoration,
Adaptive Reuse” section (pages 59 to 88), and complete the quiz
at continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com. Upon passing the test,
you will receive a certificate of completion, and your credit will be
automatically reported to the AIA. Additional information regarding
credit-reporting and continuing-education requirements can be found
at continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com.
Learning Objectives
1 Outline a range of adaptation, renovation, and expansion
approaches, from discreet insertions within historic fabric
to complete aesthetic and structural overhauls of existing
buildings.
2 Explain why renovation and adaptation reduce carbon emissions,
when compared to new construction.
PHOTOGRAPHY: © ADAM MORK
59
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
THE 50-STORY Quay Quarter Tower (QQT) overlooking Sydney’s structure, reusing 95 percent of its core and 65 percent of its beams,
world-famous harbor is clearly contemporary. With its twisting geom- columns, and slabs. The scheme, developed in partnership with architect
etry, its cantilevering blocks that appear to reach toward the water, and of record BVN, more than doubles usable floor area, to 1.1 million
its jazzy gridded facade, the 676-foot-tall office building stands out as a square feet. But, most notably, at least from a climate perspective, the
distinctly recent addition to the city’s quickly changing skyline. upcycling strategy saved 12,000 metric tons of embodied carbon—
However, despite this aura of newness, QQT is not new, or not en- greenhouse-gas emissions equal to those produced, the architects say, by
tirely so. The skyscraper is the product of the adaptation and expansion 8,800 flights between Sydney and Copenhagen.
of a 46-story tower completed on the prime Central Business District For AMP Capital, 3XN’s client and QQT’s owner and anchor
(CBD) site in 1976 and no longer considered attractive to tenants, due to tenant, retaining as much of the older structure as possible was a re-
its too-small floor plates. The recent $600 million transformation—de- quirement, one outlined in its 2014 design competition brief. However,
signed by Danish firm 3XN—retains nearly all the existing tower’s AMP’s interest in building reuse was not prompted by the potential
60 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
QUAY QUARTER Tower rises from a prime
harborside Central Business District site
(opposite and this image).
61
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
62 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
THE TOWER’S site slopes up from the harbor
(right) to the main entry on Bridge Street
(opposite, top), allowing for a multilevel lobby
(opposite, bottom).
63
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
View from
lobby
New New
Existing Existing
AXONOMETRIC
DEMOLITION AND CONSTRUCTION PLAN DIAGRAMS
DIAGRAM
FLEX-FLOOR DIAGRAM
64 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
THE ORIGINAL 1970s tower (opposite, far left)
had closely spaced, view-obstructing perimeter
columns, in contrast to QQT’s vertical villages,
with their stunning harbor vistas (right).
65
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
66 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
67
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
Disappearing Act
KAAN Architecten discreetly inserts a contemporary addition inside a Beaux-Arts museum.
BY ANDREW AYERS
68 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
FOUNDED BY Napoleon in 1810, the ciple was to respect the building for what it is
Koninklijk Museum voor Schone Kunsten and bring it back to its original state.” Like
Antwerpen (Royal Museum of Fine Arts Charles Garnier at the Paris Opera (1860–75),
Antwerp, or KMSKA) houses a world-class Winders and Van Dijk followed classic Beaux-
collection that includes 16 Rubenses, six Van Arts theory when designing their museum.
Dycks, countless paintings by early Flemish First, they made it a freestanding monument in
masters, Belgium’s most extensive James the middle of a giant square, not only for
Ensor holdings, and much, much more. In temple grandeur but also to reduce fire risk.
1890, the KMSKA moved to its current, Next, at the exact center of their composition,
purpose-built home in the new neighborhood they placed the dominante, a space embodying
of Het Zuid, of which it was the centerpiece. the building’s raison d’être—for Garnier the
The fruit of a forced marriage between the auditorium, for Winders and Van Dijk the
joint winners of a design competition, Jean- Rubens and Van Dyck halls. Around the
Jacques Winders and Frans Van Dijk (who dominante, they lined up the remainder of the
reputedly hated each other), the eclectically program in logical axial succession: a public-
ornamented Beaux-Arts temple dominates its entrance sequence directly borrowed from the
surroundings. Already too small by 1925, Paris Opera (external temple steps, vestibule,
when it was first reconfigured, the building monumental stairwell); exhibition areas laid
was again refurbished in 1976. Untouched and out like long galleries in a stately home and
unloved in the quarter century that followed, grouped around four large light wells; and
it had become a creaking, leaking liability by another vestibule/staircase sequence at the rear,
the turn of the millennium. A 2003 call for accessing administrative offices. Again in
ideas, with a brief both to renovate and ex- keeping with Beaux-Arts rationalism, Winders
pand, produced a winning master plan by and Van Dijk divided their museum into three
Rotterdam-based KAAN Architecten. Closed levels: tall, top-lit painting galleries on the
in 2011, the revamped KMSKA finally re- uppermost floor; side-lit sculpture galleries on
opened 11 years later, in September 2022. the second floor; and a ground-floor storage
“The original architecture is so strong,” says podium that included a fire-, flood-, and
Dikkie Scipio, the KAAN partner who led the bomb-proof bunker into which the Rubenses
$109 million transformation. “Our first prin- and Van Dycks could be lowered via traps (a
PHOTOGRAPHY: © SEBASTIAN VAN DAMME
SET WITHIN a large civic square, the museum embodies Beaux-Arts principles of urban place-
making and has been a landmark since opening in 1890 (left). A grand lobby welcomes visitors on
entering (above).
69
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
70 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
precaution deemed necessary in light of the long history of armed conflict
in the Benelux region).
“In the century following inauguration,” says Scipio, “all sorts of clutter
was introduced.” Parts of the main gallery sequence were divided up,
either to gain display walls or to squeeze in supplementary back-of-house
activities, and extra accommodation added in the light wells. KAAN’s
first step was to strip all that out—a huge job in itself, involving asbestos
removal and the hand demolition of a nuclear-bomb shelter—to recover
the logic of the 1890 plan. “The original concept was fantastic, but then
PHOTOGRAPHY: © SEBASTIAN VAN DAMME (OPPOSITE, 2); STIJN BOLLAERT
they messed it up!” laughs Scipio. There remained the question of the
24,000 square feet of new gallery space—a 40 percent increase—requested
in the competition brief. “We felt the extension had to be invisible from
the outside,” explains Scipio. “Otherwise, you destroy the building.” This
meant the only place to put it was in the light wells and on the roof. “It’s
like a table with four legs,” she continues, “except the tabletop is U-shaped,
to skirt round the skylights of the Rubens and Van Dyck halls.”
Such discretion is not only uncharacteristic for architects—see Zaha
Hadid’s Antwerp Port Authority enlargement just downriver (record,
November 2016)—it is far more complex to achieve than Scipio’s descrip-
tion suggests. First, the steel-framed addition comprises four levels orga-
nized as a new, separate circuit: the skylit top-floor galleries, ideal for
paintings; below them a technical floor, containing climate-control
equipment for the entire building; then a floor of low-ceilinged galleries
for fragile and small-scale works; and, at the level of Winders and Van
Dijk’s second floor, high-ceilinged monumental halls for large-scale
works. Second, to match the quality of the historic museum, KAAN AXONOMETRIC OF NEW INSERTION
71
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
decided that all the new galleries must be naturally lit, which involved
cutting light shafts through the middle levels of their extension. Last,
there was the question of visitor flow: to avoid a U-shaped circuit with
two dead ends, KAAN played with the poché, widening original
walls—including the one between the Rubens and Van Dyck halls—to
run stairs and passages within them. Highly complex, the slotting of
new into old recalls a Chinese 3D puzzle.
Where the historic visitor route is concerned, the architects trans-
ferred the library and coat check to the ground floor, installed a new
spiral stair linking the coat check to the main vestibule, and moved the
restaurant and the museum shop/cafeteria to either end of the latter,
creating a new, logical entrance sector. Restored to its 1890s configura-
tion and appearance, Winders and Van Dijk’s gallery circuit now sports
rich colors based on paint-scratch samples and teems with a multitude
of original details that have been cleaned, repaired, or remade where
necessary. Furthermore, KAAN cut concealed slits through certain
walls to allow large-scale paintings to move between rooms, and re-
THE ADDITION, which is not visible from the street, includes 198 built all the skylights to bring them up to modern standards. The firm
north-facing triangular skylights. also replaced the HVAC with an innovative new system that forces
11
14 14
1 8 8
10
8 9
8 15 15
15
A 6 A
3
8 8 12 14 8
6
8 8
8 8 15
14
4 5 5 8 8 4
14 14
0 50 FT.
GROUND-FLOOR PLAN SECOND-FLOOR PLAN
15 M.
14 14
9
12
14
8
12
0 50 FT.
SECTION A - A
15 M.
14
0 50 FT.
3 TICKETS & INFO 10 STAFF 17 VAN DYCK HALL
THIRD-FLOOR PLAN
15 M. 4 CAFÉ/RESTAURANT 11 MUSEUM SHOP 18 ATELIER
5 KITCHEN 12 GRAND HALL 19 CANYON STAIR
6 COAT CHECK 13 AUDITORIUM 20 GALLERY FOR
FRAGILE ART
72 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
NEW GALLERY skylights bounce daylight off angled white surfaces
(above). A new level with low ceilings and reduced light was inserted
between existing floors to accommodate small and fragile pieces of art
(right).
“art-friendly” air down from the cornice over the paintings, after which
it mixes with “human-friendly” air rising from the floor, and exits via
the ceiling. Dissimulating all the ducts and vents, which the historic
galleries were not designed to contain, was a tour de force, as was the
widening of walls to contain hidden stairways and passages. In the Van
Dyck hall, for example, the wall moved forward 7 feet, pushing the
elaborate gilded ceiling moldings with it; along with cutting and re-
joining them, the architects had to redimension the skylight. Despite
their magnitude, KAAN’s interventions remain invisible to the unini-
tiated. “I’m so proud to have completed a job where it looks like noth-
ing happened,” says Scipio.
In contrast, self-expression reigns unchallenged in the new galleries.
“I felt you could only fully respect the strength of the historic building
PHOTOGRAPHY: © SEBASTIAN VAN DAMME
if you answered it with equally strong architecture that didn’t try to say
‘I’m better than you,’ ” explains Scipio. “How do you do that? By de-
signing the complete opposite and keeping it entirely separate.” To
underscore the through-the-wardrobe transition, the entrances to the
new galleries (located on the second floor, in the hallways beyond the
monumental stairwell) take the form of fat pivoting-wall sections.
Once over the threshold, you suddenly find yourself in snowy Narnia,
an abstract, all-white world whose high-gloss resin floors reflect the
daylight streaming down from 92 feet above. “Most of the canvases
73
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
here were painted in natural light,” says Scipio, “so it’s of such value to aggressive spotlessness” and a “snowstorm” brightness that eventually
bring it in. Though you must treat it carefully, to protect the artworks.” “becomes strenuous.” But nonspecialists seem to like the revamp, an
This is why KAAN’s 198 triangular skylights face north, bouncing important consideration for a museum looking to broaden its appeal
daylight off their inclined white surfaces to achieve a diffuse effect. and increase attendance. “I never experienced this before,” confides
The new upper galleries are reached either by elevators or monu- Scipio, “but people in Antwerp reach out to me in the street and say,
mental stairways—another cue picked up from the old building but, ‘Thank you for the museum. We’re so happy.’ Ordinary people, of
again, modernized, most spectacularly with a 103-step canyon ca- course,” she laughs, “not architects.” n
denced by serried ranks of wall-mounted strip lights. Such dazzling
Dutch aesthetics have proved controversial in the sophisticated world Credits COST: $109 million
of Belgian architecture, known for its subtle approach to materials and COMPLETION DATE: September 2022
ARCHITECT: KAAN Architecten
renovation (“Star Wars,” sniffed an associate member of the Robbrecht — Kees Kaan, Vincent Panhuysen,
en Daem team that designed new KMSKA furniture). Despite some Dikkie Scipio, principals; Walter Sources
soigné detailing—marble treated so the slabs remain whole, for ex- Hoogerwerf, senior project leader
ELASTOMERIC ROOFING: ADCO
PHOTOGRAPHY: © STIJN BOLLAERT
ample—Carlo Scarpa this is not. Dialogue between new and old fabric ENGINEER: Royal Haskoning DHV
COPPER ROOFING: Lion
(structural)
has been categorically shut down, while the restoration of Winders and GLAZED ROOFING: Deforsche
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: THV
Van Dijk’s galleries, though ingenious and meticulous, is a form of Artes Roegiers; Artes Woudenberg CABINETWORK: Kulapro
heritage make-believe whose ambiguities and ironies are neither ex- FLOOR AND WALL TILE: Vitra
CONSULTANTS: Architectenbureau
plored nor even acknowledged. Furthermore, flexibility of display is Fritz (restoration) LIGHTING: Phillips; Bega; Luceplan;
precluded—Impressionist paintings, for example, being forced to CLIENT: Flemish Department of Trilux; LTS; Nemo; DKN Kreis; Ixilum;
contend with a gleaming and anachronistic white cube. Kristian Vis- Culture, Youth and Media Etap
trup Madsen, in a generally positive Artforum review, wrote of “an SIZE: 323,000 square feet ELEVATORS: Hugo de Jongh
74 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
A LONG, narrow stair takes visitors to top-floor
galleries (opposite, left). A gallery for 21st-
century art is topped by a light well (opposite,
right). A spiral stair connects the street level to
the second floor (this image).
75
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
Raising Expectations
Perkins&Will lifts an old pier building in San Francisco to accommodate climate change and new
economic realities.
BY JOHN KING
PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRUCE DAMONTE
76 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
EVEN IF you didn’t know the backstory, the gaunt steel
hulk of Building 12 at San Francisco’s Pier 70 would reso-
nate as a triumph of historic preservation—one that forges
an enticing amalgam of new makerspaces and offices from
a vast monolith built to fabricate ship hulls during World
War II.
The triumph is even more compelling when you grasp
the most startling aspect of all: this three-story behemoth
with 1.5-acre floor plates was lifted 10 feet into the air
before its recent renovation began.
The higher position responds to sea-level-rise projections
for the Pier 70 area, which mostly consists of reclaimed land
that in the early 20th century turned tidal marshes into the
site of one of the West Coast’s largest shipbuilding facili-
ties. Many neighboring industrial structures were torn
down in the decades after Bethlehem Steel closed its opera-
tions here in 1982. Building 12 is intended as the atmo-
spheric centerpiece of what is envisioned as a 28-acre
mixed-use district including 2,000 housing units and nine
acres of public space.
This flavorful role—adding patina and blue-collar grit to
what otherwise will be a 21st-century development—ex-
plains why such care was put into an 82-year-old rusty relic
77
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
6 6
STACKING DIAGRAM
1 1 1
0 30 FT.
SECTION A - A
10 M.
A
1 7 6
1 6
6
1 5 4
1
5
6
3
1 2
6 6
0 50 FT.
FIRST-FLOOR PLAN SECOND-FLOOR PLAN THIRD-FLOOR PLAN
15 M.
3 GROCER 6 MAKERSPACE
78 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
CONTRACTORS lifted the entire 1941 building 10 feet to accommodate rising waters, working 6 inches at a time over a five-week period (above, left and
right). New roads and outdoor common spaces were built at the new height, as large pits at the original level wait for future development (top).
Measurements were recalibrated each time, and the cycle was re- gouges that date from the 1940s, when steel plates were wheeled in on
peated—a process that took nearly five weeks before the 2,000-ton trains, then lifted up by gantry cranes attached to ceiling rails and
structure was high enough to build a new concrete foundation beneath lowered onto the floor once the train cars left. From there, blueprint-
PHOTOGRAPHY: COURTESY PLANT CONSTRUCTION COMPANY, L.P. (3)
it, one that exceeds sea-level-rise projections through 2100 for this like tracings done in the workspace above were placed atop the plates,
stretch of the San Francisco Bay shoreline. Only then was dirt trucked which were cut as needed for assembly into hulls outside.
in to create a new ground plane matching the roadbeds alongside the Adding to the visual drama, a new 13-foot-high steel mezzanine
structure, which already were set at the planned height. floats above portions of the central bay. This will remain open to the
Enter Building 12 now, and nothing about its topographic transfor- public, a vantage point for anyone visiting Building 12’s innards to
mation is apparent. The structure’s rugged simplicity is what casts a shop, attend an event, or simply gawk.
spell—starting with your entrance through the steel frame of Building A second level—framed in steel with concrete floors and connected
15, which was built as an annex during World War II and now survives by catwalks that match the mezzanine—has been inserted on the east
in skeletal form, with its columns and trussed roofline forming an open and west sides of the central bay, 9 feet above the mezzanine, and will
canopy outside Building 12’s southern entrance. hold the light-industrial space required by city zoning. The top floor is
The first level, with its 39-foot-high ceiling running through the original and flooded with natural light from the jagged roof ’s clere-
central bay north to south, is especially striking; at present there are no story windows. This area will be conventional office space, its airy
interior walls, just the thick columns with their supporting trusses up expanse softened by ceilings of tongue-and-groove slats of Douglas fir.
high. The intent is to leave the ground floor largely open as a makers’ There are a few contemporary design touches, such as grand entrances
marketplace. The columns’ fat rivets are visible, as are the nicks and framed in steel, coated with a rich red paint that’s the same as what has
79
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
80 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
ENORMOUS clerestories and perimeter windows
flood the top floor with daylight, creating an
attractive setting for future office tenants.
81
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
82 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Credits
ARCHITECT: Perkins&Will — Dwight Long,
Ariane Fehrenkamp, project team
HISTORIC ARCHITECT:
Architectural Resources Group
ENGINEERS: Nabih Youssef Structural
Engineers (structural); Maffei Structural
Engineering (structural seismic analysis);
Degenkolb Engineers (constructing); Point
Energy Innovations (m/e/p); BKF Engineers (civil)
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Plant Construction
LIFTING SUBCONTRACTOR:
Bigge Crane & Rigging
CONSULTANTS: S9 Architecture (retail);
Tucci Lighting (lighting); DN&Co. (graphics and
wayfinding); Vibrasure (acoustics); Teecom
(telecom); RDH (building envelope)
CLIENT: Brookfield Properties Development
SIZE: 230,000 square feet
COST: withheld
COMPLETION DATE: August 2022
Sources
BUCKLING RESTRAINED BRACES: Corebrace
CURTAIN WALL: Kawneer
BUILT-UP ROOFING: Soprema; Georgia Pacific
DOORS: DCI; Smoke Guard Systems; ActivWall
GLASS: Vitro
83
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
Power Play
O’Neill McVoy Architects orchestrates a topographical playscape inside a former electric plant.
BY LEOPOLDO VILLARDI
PHOTOGRAPHY BY PAUL WARCHOL
84 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
“WE’RE ALL children at heart,” laughs Carla Precht, founding THE “CLOUD” hovers above the early-learner area (left). CLT walls,
director of the Bronx Children’s Museum. “The building was close translucent acrylic, and gentle shifts in elevation define the museum’s
to the water, and it looked like a castle—I thought it had all the interiors (above).
makings of a wonderful space for kids,” she adds. After 10 years of
operating out of a purple school bus as a “museum without walls,” missioned by the Department of Design & Construction to overhaul
in December the institution moved into a long-awaited brick-and- the top floor. But the bright, in-your-face polychromy typical of chil-
mortar home and opened its doors to the public. Now it doesn’t just dren’s museums is noticeably absent from the interior architecture—in-
have wheels—it has walls. stead, a subdued palette, natural materials, and winding walls engage
The Bronx Children’s Museum occupies the upper floor of a power- the senses. It’s a grown-up approach to design for children.
house that once supplied refrigeration and electricity to the borough’s “The kids are coming from apartments, schools, and streets that are
nearby terminal market. Built between 1925 and 1929, the market was all orthogonal. We wanted to create a new kind of space that was open
the first of its kind in New York and intended as a model for the sale of to their imagination,” says McVoy. Set within the 13,660-square-foot
perishable goods in other boroughs. Today, only the powerhouse still rectangular floor plate of the existing powerhouse, curvilinear elements
stands—and with four crenellated turrets and arched brick corbeling, meander, bifurcate, and reconverge to form a topographical playscape
its castle-like form indeed invites curiosity. In 2010, the building was of thematic spaces that flow one into the other. “When the children
outfitted with a green roof, high-efficiency insulation and fixtures, and walk in with their parents, it’s clear that they just want to begin explor-
first-floor office space for the New York City Department of Parks & ing,” O’Neill adds.
Recreation. Three years later, O’Neill McVoy Architects, led by the From the welcome area, young patrons can go in many different
husband-and-wife team of Beth O’Neill and Chris McVoy, was com- directions. One route takes them past the “cove,” a niche with an inhab-
85
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
itable rabbit hole, and up a small set of stairs to the natural sciences area.
Here, the floor has been raised almost 5 feet to make sweeping views of
the Harlem River accessible to the museum’s diminutive constituents.
The sound of trickling water accompanies the panorama—Waterways,
an interactive 35-foot-long exhibit by Boss Display that features a minia-
ture version of the Bronx’s Old Croton Aqueduct, invites playful splash-
ing (willing participants borrow raincoats). Perceptive visitors might
even see, through the bottom of the basin, a window offering a glimpse
into the cove beneath them. “Water connects us all,” Precht says, a
theme that figuratively flows through much of the museum. As kids
amble about interactive exhibits and terraria showcasing native flora and
fauna, they eventually find themselves in the “Turret Gallery,” a vertical
column of space curated by Natalie Collette Wood that stretches upward
into one of the building’s towers. Dichroic film on clerestory windows
and a torrent of suspended crystals scatter iridescent light onto an assort-
ment of woodland-themed furniture—an arrangement that would please
any young reader of Alice in Wonderland. (At night, the four turrets are lit
from within, emitting a soft purple glow.)
In the community arts area, the interior architecture takes a back seat
as the birthplace of hip-hop comes to life with a casita by artist Charles
George Esperanza, as well as caricatures of various storefronts and
portraits that pay homage to Bronx streetscapes and borough natives
including actor Sonia Manzano, Supreme Court Justice Sonia
Sotomayor, and playwright Richard Abrons. With 15-foot ceilings, the
architects squeezed in a mezzanine-level “loft” under another of the tur-
AXONOMETRIC rets, where children can survey the entire museum and gather for artist-
1 LOBBY
6 2 WELCOME AREA
10
3 THE “COVE” (BELOW)/NATURAL
4 SCIENCES AREA (ABOVE)
5 5 COMMUNITY ARTS
9
6 THE “LOFT”
2
7 STROLLER PARKING
8 STUDIO
3
8
9 RESOURCE ROOM
1
11 10 OFFICES
11 TURRET GALLERY
0 20 FT.
FLOOR PLAN
6 M.
86 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
THE BRONX Children’s Museum (opposite) anchors the
north end of Mill Pond Park. Inside (above and right),
O’Neill McVoy Architects explore a subdued palette.
87
CEU RENOVATION, RESTORATION, ADAPTIVE REUSE
one afternoon polishing edges to perfect the finish, too). Fabric duct- CHILDREN as well as artwork can inhabit the “cove.” Artist Rachel
work evokes a playful spirit and catches light against a pale blue acousti- Sydlowski’s Invisible River is a dimensional silkscreen using UVA pigment.
cal ceiling. Floors are covered with end-grain red oak tiles that make
legible the oft-taught biology lesson that tree rings can be counted to began. Despite the curious difference between the artists’ and archi-
age trees. “And everything was designed from the vantage point of a tects’ approaches, the new Bronx Children’s Museum offers up a multi-
child,” O’Neill says. sensory feast for voracious kids. Just ask them—on departure, they
The most noticeable material choice is the curving, knotty spruce complete an “exit poll” on a magnetic board. Judging from the results,
cross-laminated timber (CLT). Today, CLT is most often used as a the kids are having a blast! n
mass-timber building’s primary structure, but O’Neill McVoy
Architects deployed it to create walls, guardrails, floor planks, benches,
Credits SIZE: 15,676 square feet
frames, and stair stringers that were inserted within the powerhouse’s
ARCHITECT: O’Neill McVoy COST: $14 million
existing envelope. These elements not only have their own independent Architects — Beth O’Neill, Chris COMPLETION DATE:
structural properties, but are more slender than typical stud-and-dry- McVoy, principals; Ruso Margishvili, December 2022
wall construction. It’s also the first use of curved CLT in the United associate in charge; Richard Stora,
project architect
States, explains Sebastian Popp, technical director at Austria-based Sources
ENGINEERS: Silman (structure);
KLH, which manufactured the Forest Stewardship Council–certified CLT: KLH
Plus Group Consulting Engineering
CLT components. Although walls with shallow curves can be pro- (m/e/p) WINDOWS: NanaWall
duced flat and bowed in situ, more complex geometries require vacuum GENERAL CONTRACTOR: GLASS: PPG; Walker Glass;
forming—a process used by Ray and Charles Eames to produce bent- A Quest Corporation Pilkington; Technical Glass Products
plywood furniture. These components were produced oversized and CONSULTANTS: Tillotson Design ACRYLIC: 3Form
milled to final dimensions (plus or minus 2 millimeters) on a CNC Associates (lighting); ADS Engineers
(LEED consultant); TM Technology LIGHTING: Ketra; Feelux; LED
machine, giving the designers an opportunity to incorporate pebble- Partners (AV/IT/Security) Linear; Ecosense; Soraa
shaped apertures and making installation easier and more cost effec- ACOUSTICAL CEILINGS:
CLIENT: NYC Department of Design
tive. If scuffed, the wooden walls can be sanded and refinished. and Construction, Bronx Children’s Sonacoustic
With very few dead ends, visitors inevitably end up where they Museum DUCTWORK: Ductsox
88 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Minneapolis, MN
May 10-12 | Live & Virtual
gettingtozeroforum.org
Join us at the
premier event
on building
decarbonization!
Take advantage of Early Bird pricing and register by 2/13!
Learn more at: www.gettingtozeroforum.org/registration
CHECK OUT OUR FEBRUARY WEBINARS
FEBRUARY 15, 2023 @ 2:00 PM EST FEBRUARY 28, 2023 @ 2:00 PM EST
Durability by Design Amplify Change: Designers
CREDITS: 1 AIA LU/ELECTIVE; 0.1 ICC CEU as Sounding Boards
Science teaches us that matter moves from order to disorder. CREDITS: 1 AIA LU/ELECTIVE; 0.1 ICC CEU
Amazingly, the same thing can happen to buildings! What once was
sparkling and new can eventually slide into disrepair. Design thinking can be applied to everyday activism. As creative problem
solvers, we catalyze change by improving the environments where
Building owners could simply surrender to it, or they can proactively people live, work and play. We can extend this momentum beyond
take a stand and fight for their buildings. They can choose products that billable work to volunteer activities that promote social justice. In this
protect the interior from damage in the first place. presentation, learn how to leverage your resources and apply your
professional skills to community engagement. Using geniant + Eastlake
Architects and interior designers can also slow the hands of time by Studio’s Sounding Boards as a case study, explore how individual
thinking long term and specifying door and wall protection products … designers and firms can amplify change using the tools of our trade.
to not only preserve their design, but also as a service to building owners
long after the ribbon is cut. LEARNING OBJECTIVES:
1. Examine their internal assets and external network, merging
LEARNING OBJECTIVES:
resources into a valuable tool kit.
1. Explore how the proper installation of wall protection materials –
2. Delineate tasks based on expertise and skill sets, treating the
when specified with standard wall construction options –
community based action as a design project with a clear process
determines their effectiveness in interior applications.
and objective.
2. Recognize when to specify wall cladding vs. targeted wall protection.
3. Evaluate the process to pivot as needed, continuing to ask
3. Examine the best-practice options for achieving effective and questions, evolve, improve, and iterate.
aesthetically pleasing interior protection.
4. Recognize the broad benefits of the action: short term, long term,
4. Discover strategies to successfully design for the long term by for the community, and for your firm.
avoiding the trap of first- cost value engineering.
91
LIGHTING
PHOTOGRAPHY: © 818
A cross section of the new open-plan hall (above) reveals how daylight, combined with strategically placed luminaires, lights the circular steel-and-
aluminum escalier d’honneur that penetrates the heart of the building (previous page).
92 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
8'18" created
custom solutions
for the Galeries
Mazarine (above)
and Mansart
(opposite) that
highlight ceiling
art while, for
reading and
workrooms (right),
devising discreet,
functional
lighting.
93
LIGHTING
Credits
ARCHITECT: Atelier Bruno Gaudin — Bruno
Gaudin, Virginie Bregal, principals; Raphaële Le
Petit, Olivier Peyrard, project architects
LIGHTING DESIGNER: 8'18" — Georges Berne,
Emmanuelle Sébie
ENGINEER: EGIS
CONSULTANT: Eiffage Energie Systèmes
(lighting contractor)
CLIENTS: French Ministries of Culture;
Education; and Higher Education, Research and
Innovation
OWNER: Bibliothéque Nationale de France
PHOTOGRAPHY: © 818 (BOTTOM)
Sources
LIGHTING: Secante; Modular Lighting
Instruments; LED Linear; Regent Lighting; DGA;
SPX Lighting; OPTYLED; Delta Light
94 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
LIGHTING
Light Fall
Loisos + Ubbelohde
BY JOANN GONCHAR, FAIA
95
LIGHTING
96 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Find these and many more available Lunch & Learn presentations at
ce.architecturalrecord.com/ee
Illuminating Trends
These new systems and fixtures were designed for a
variety of building needs and aesthetics.
BY SHEILA KIM
AJ Garden
Midcentury Modern Danish architect Arne
Jacobsen is known for several now iconic prod-
LittleOnes Micro Doubles
ucts, among them the AJ floor and table lamps
USAI follows up its LittleOnes “bare-
for Louis Poulsen, which the Denmark-based
ly there” recessed lighting with
company is taking outdoors with the launch of AJ
Micro Doubles, which uses the same
Garden. Available in a black finish, the lamp
technology to power a pair of tiny
comes in two heights—3½" for path and 272∕3" for
fixtures within a single housing.
ambient illumination—with spike, base, or anchor
Offered in downlight, adjustable,
mounting options.
and wall-wash formats, or a combi-
louispoulsen.com
nation, it delivers up to 1600 lumens
though 1¼" apertures.
usailighting.com
98 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD F E B R UA R Y 2 0 2 3
Woods Collection
LightArt’s new collection may look
like authentic timber, but it is really
composed of parent-company
3form’s eco-friendly Varia resin,
which is both lighter in weight and
easier to clean. The fixtures are
available in wood-grain finishes,
Holly including walnut and white oak,
Resembling a cluster of supersize grapes, Unika Vaev’s plain or with one of two laser-cut
Holly provides a touch of whimsy, along with sound patterns, and on three of LightArt’s
control, for this sculptural grouping of 9¾" diameter styles—I/O Drum, Cigar Pendant,
globe lights and acoustical-felt-covered spheres. and LA2 Three Beam (shown).
Vertical and horizontal configurations are both offered, lightart.com
as are acoustical-only versions in three felt colors:
Anthracite, Light Grey, and Terracotta.
unikavaev.com
99
CONTINUING EDUCATION
In this section, you will find two compelling courses highlighting creative solutions for tomorrow’s buildings brought to you by industry leaders.
CONTINUING EDUCATION
Read a course, and then visit our online Continuing Education Center at ce.architecturalrecord.com to take the quiz free of charge to earn credits.
p102
p104
CATEGORIES
PM PRODUCTS AND MATERIALS RR RENOVATION AND RESTORATION SU SUSTAINABILITY
RE RESIDENTIAL SI SITE INFRASTRUCTURE DESIGN
Courses may qualify for learning hours through most Canadian provincial architectural associations.
101
EDUCATIONAL-ADVERTISEMENT
CONTINUING EDUCATION
as pandemic stop-gaps to a
long-term shift in design.
0.1 ICC
C
3. Describe installation options for
eramic tile has a long history in ar- details the health, safety, well-being, and
exterior tile that promote more durable,
chitecture, but recent technologies sustainability reasons these tiles are becom- sustainable, and safe applications.
and design innovations have given ing so popular. This article is a topline look 4. List examples of how thicker tile
it new life in outdoor spaces. The latest tile at various tile types and why they are the (2cm and 3cm) specification can help
solutions come at a time when residential ideal solution for outdoor applications. improve the sustainable qualities of
and commercial outdoor living spaces have Gain access to more detailed information, a project to support goals for green
evolved from makeshift solutions meant as as well as case studies, on Coverings’ com- building and health and wellness for
pandemic stop-gaps to a long-term shift in prehensive Tile Academy online. occupants.
design. And now, homeowners and com-
mercial developers are demanding durable LAYING THE GROUNDWORK To receive AIA credit, you are required to
yet fashion-forward exterior designs. This FOR INNOVATION read the entire article and pass the quiz.
course will look at exterior application Tile is one of the best products to provide Visit ce.architecturalrecord.com for the
trends, gauged porcelain paver standards, a combination of durability and livability complete text and to take the quiz for free.
the latest in pedestal systems, 2cm and 3cm for exterior walls, walkways, pool decks, AIA COURSE #K2301P
tiles, and other new technologies, and it outdoor kitchens and water features in an
CONTINUING EDUCATION
durability needs but provide many of the
necessary components for sustainable and
healthy building qualities for occupants. In
this section, we will discuss tiles made from
porcelain, ceramic, and glass and how their
unique attributes make them a good fit for a
variety of outdoor designs.
Porcelain Tiles
Porcelain tile has evolved over many centu-
ries since its use in the construction of the
Porcelain Tower of Nanjing in 15th century
China and its periodic use in European
palaces. These days, porcelain tile technol-
ogy allows for a variety of residential and
commercial applications, including modern
outdoor spaces.
Porcelain tile is a prime material for
exterior design. It is created with fine, dense
clay and fired at high temperatures, making Adjustable paver supports are one technology that supports different formats and thicknesses
it highly durable. Its ability to withstand to achieve the necessary height in outdoor applications.
severe weather conditions, including freezing
temperatures, makes it an appropriate choice
for any climate. That same quality of durabil- and walkways. In addition to inherent made of glass can be used in pools, foun-
ity makes it popular for high-traffic areas resistance to UV, fire, and stain, many tains, fireplace surrounds, outdoor showers,
in both commercial and residential spaces, options are available for added traction to spas, and as accent walls on outdoor decks
including entryways and other transitional make products slip resistant. and bars. Glass tile has a variety of practi-
spaces between indoor and outdoor areas. And cal qualities that make it a good choice for
because tile is used with aesthetics in mind, it’s Ceramic Tiles outdoor spaces including low maintenance
important to note that durability isn’t just the Ceramic is the oldest form of tile and still requirements, durability, stain resistance
ability to maintain its structure and function; one of the most popular. Once made by and being easy to clean. Glass tile can also
porcelain tile retains its appearance even hand, ceramic tiles were fashioned together provide an aesthetic and ambience, since
under heavy use. Porcelain tile, like ceramic from wet clay and dried in the sun or fired light reflection off glass can create a mood
tile, can be selected in a variety of colors and by kiln. They have many applications and or sense of movement.
textures with seemingly endless possibilities, because they are durable and affordable, Glass tile is often also used for back-
thanks to digital printing technology. They they are often used in both residential and splashes or as shower tile. As a decorative
can provide the realistic look of natural wood, commercial projects. Glazed ceramic tiles material, glass tile can be used as framing
stone or concrete, without the upkeep those have the added ability to protect against or to reflect light and make a space feel
materials require. stains and damage compared to other larger. New technology in glass tiles has
Porcelain tile is nonporous, which means materials. In general, ceramic has a natural emerged that enhances appearance, func-
it won’t harbor bacteria or suffer issues of resistance to fire, frost, and moisture. Like tion, and durability, making it an option
too much water absorption, such as crack- porcelain tiles, ceramic tiles can withstand for certain outdoor applications.
ing. It has a water absorption rate of less heavy traffic and severe weather, such as
than 0.5%, making it useful in wet environ- freezing temperatures. Like porcelain,
ments, inside or outside. Its nonporous qual- ceramic tiles are appropriate for any climate.
ity also allows it to be cleaned easily, even in Ceramic tiles are also easy to clean and
outdoor spaces, which makes it both more maintain. Erika Fredrickson is a writer/editor focusing on
hygienic and able to maintain its appearance technology, environment, and history. She frequently
without the need for polishing, waxing or Glass Tiles contributes to continuing education courses and
sealing. Some outdoor applications include Glass tiles are a good material for adding publications through Confluence Communications.
outdoor flooring, pool surrounds, patios, style to outdoor spaces. Tiles and mosaics http://www.confluencec.com
Coverings is the preeminent event for the ceramic tile and natural stone industry in North America. Join us April 18-21,
2023 to discover 800 global exhibitors from more than 30 countries, breathtaking product innovations, invaluable insights,
and crucial industry connections you need to grow your business. www.coverings.com
103
EDUCATIONAL-ADVERTISEMENT
T
3. Apply features of existing commercial
he COVID-19 pandemic and ensuing a boom may be slower to start than some
buildings to new residential uses.
workplace changes have increased have hoped, but may gain momentum in the
4. Explain how creating voids in an
attention to an enduring anomaly foreseeable future, given a set of appropriate existing structure can develop
in the national built environment: a glut of policy and economic incentives and prudent- amenities and how transferring the
commercial space coexisting with a hous- ly imaginative choices of prospective sites. usable area to new stories atop a
ing shortage. The question has naturally Commercial real estate markets softened building can require structural support.
arisen: Can some of the former resources dramatically when large numbers of office 5. Discuss how relations between
be repurposed to address the latter need? workers, unprotected by vaccines until a commercial building and its
Architects with experience in adaptive December 2020, began working remotely. As surrounding community can increase
reuse add a corollary question: Can the many workers and employers have discovered or decrease suitability for residential
conversion.
transformation of commercial properties to the feasibility of work from home or hybrid
residences yield desirable homes, buildings, schedules, demand for office space as the
neighborhoods, and cities? pandemic wanes has not sprung back to pre- To receive AIA credit, you are required to
The first question, commentators suggest, pandemic levels. Coldwell Banker Richard read the entire article and pass the quiz.
has been answered “yes, theoretically” more Ellis (CBRE) reported a national commercial Visit ce.architecturalrecord.com for the
complete text and to take the quiz for free.
often than “yes, and here's the living proof: vacancy rate of 17 percent in the third
a boom in conversion projects.” Reflection quarter of 2022, continuing to rise as new AIA COURSE #K2301B
on the second question explains why such supply outstrips demand, with class A space
CONTINUING EDUCATION
vacancy rates surpassing suburban for the
past two quarters (CBRE, 2022). A Jones Lang
LaSalle report on the same period calculated
the national vacancy rate at a record 19.1
percent (Jones Lang LaSalle, 2022).
Business Insider recently labeled today's
conditions an “office apocalypse,” with
pre-pandemic occupancy rates of 95 percent
now falling below 50 percent (Skandul, 2022).
Collateral effects have lowered multiple
variables reflecting business districts' vigor: Figure 1. Percentage increases in adaptive-reuse apartments in 2020-2021 became higher
not just office occupancy and commercial than in new apartments. Source: RentCafe analysis of Yardi Matrix data (Neculae, 2022).
real estate values but employment, foot
traffic, business spending, transit ridership,
public services, and property-tax revenues tracking rising numbers of conversions buildings are sometimes associated with
for cities nationwide. Apocalyptic rhetoric is since 2010, has offered roughly comparable federal tax credit opportunities or reductions
not limited to journalistic contexts; the same figures, noting that offices have overtaken in local parking requirements, McLane
term appears in a detailed report by scholars at hotels as the leading target type despite a adds. Another benefit is that the conversion
NYU and Columbia Business Schools, posted COVID-related rise in hotel conversions process is generally less physically disruptive
on the Social Science Research Network, (Miller, 2022). Office conversion is most to a neighborhood than new construction.
calculating that remote work had caused “a common in “larger, more historic cities,” “Projects of this nature,” he says, “are op-
$413-billion value destruction” in the U.S. with 1,000 to 2,000 conversions seen in portunities to fix the wrongs that we've done
commercial office sector (Gupta et al., 2022). Philadelphia, Washington, D.C., Cleveland, to our downtowns and revitalize them.”
The idea of converting commercial real Chicago, and Los Angeles. Curiously, the John Cetra, founding principal of New
estate to residential has the intuitive appeal NAA's report says little about New York York firm CetraRuddy, has worked on several
of solving two problems at once: helping City's conversions, though these have of the city's most prominent conversion proj-
to relieve the housing shortage in high- become prominent through media cover- ects and sees this sector as ripe for expansion.
demand urban areas and adding new forms age, the Skyscraper Museum's “Residential “People are not using office space to the same
of value to spaces that have been neglected, Rising” exhibition on downtown degree that they had been before COVID,”
abandoned, or rendered less marketable. Manhattan's transformations since the he says, recounting a recent client conversa-
Research suggests that residential adaptive 1990s, and city government's creation of an tion about an office building undergoing
reuse is indeed rising, with about 28,000 Office Adaptive Reuse Task Force in July extensive renovation. “We've been working
new rental units nationwide between 2022. Such conversions, one should note, on the plans for over a year, and we have
January 2020 and December 2021, 11,000 still represent a relatively small phenomenon no new tenants lined up. So they're calling
of which (about 40 percent) were in the within the real estate context, contrasting me and saying, 'What can we do with this
office-to-residential niche (Kolomatsky, with 791,081 newly constructed rental units building? Can we look at that quickly and see
2022), increasing at a faster rate than new nationwide during 2020-2021, according to if it's a viable candidate for either mixed use
apartments (Neculae, 2022) (see Figure 1). RentCafe (see Figure 1 above). or total conversion to residential use?' So, I
Other building types chosen for conver- Converted office buildings, particularly think we're going to see more.”
sion during these years included factories from before World War II, offer dwellers In practice, some sites and building
(15.5 percent), hotels (12.8 percent), and an array of advantages, says James McLane, categories are well-suited to this form of
warehouses (9.0 percent), followed by health AIA, director of technology at Page & adaptive reuse, while others look promising
care, educational, and religious buildings. Turnbull, a San Francisco-based firm from afar but turn out to be cases of wishful
(These figures are from the real estate re- focusing on renovation and preservation. thinking when analyzed in detail.
search group RentCafe, which studies Yardi Their formal lobby spaces and corridors are
Matrix data on conversions into residential character-defining features; they often have
buildings with at least 50 units; smaller- ground-level commercial spaces with high
scale conversions, assuming these are above ceilings, readily adapted into amenities such Bill Millard is a New York-based journalist who has
zero, logically imply that RentCafe's counts as fitness centers, cafés, or mobile work cen- contributed to Architectural Record, The Architect's
are conservative, possibly underestimates.) ters; many have balconies, tall story heights Newspaper, Oculus, Architect, Annals of Emergency
The National Apartment Association, and windows, and narrow floorplates. These Medicine, OMA's Content, and other publications.
The Steel Institute of New York is a not-for-profit association created to advance the interests of the steel
construction industry by helping architects, engineers, developers, and construction managers develop
engineering solutions using structural steel construction. www.siny.org
105
Architectural Record is looking for the best
CALL FOR ENTRIES emerging architecture firms from around
the world to feature in our 2023 DESIGN
2 02 3
MARCH 1, 2023
GREAT LAKES CABIN, MORLOCK ISLAND, CANADA, BY 2022 VANGUARD LECKIE STUDIO.
PHOTOGRAPHY: © KYLE CHAPPELL
DATES & Events PVDF ORE FINISHES
ROOFING, SIDING, THERMAL & MOISTURE PROTECTION
NEW | GREEN | $$
PAC-CLAD | Petersen
PAC-CLAD Ore finishes provide designers with
Upcoming Exhibitions alternatives to expensive and unpredictable
natural metals. These PVDF finishes add an
elegant finishing touch to any project.
Mirror Mirror: Reflections on Design at Chatsworth Product Application
Bakewell, England • 16 unique finishes
• Available on wall and
March 18–October 23, 2023 roof panels, coil and sheet
Built in the late 16th century, the stately home of Chatsworth has been • Available on steel and aluminum
800-231-6074 • GRIFFOLYN.COM
DATES & Events
Parables for Happiness Vanguard winners CO Adaptive and Only If. conference will feature 800 exhibitors from
London Each project will be shown with a new video over 30 countries. Visitors can explore a wide
Through June 23, 2023 by Brooklyn-based filmmaker Hudson Lines, variety of displays, as well as participate in
Yinka Illori is a British-Nigerian artist and specially produced for the exhibition. See industry learning sessions and networking
designer known for his colorful public art moma.org. opportunities. See coverings.com.
installations. The Design Museum in London
showcases 100 works by Ilori ranging from Events Getting to Zero
artworks, photographs, and furniture to May 10–12, 2023
textiles, books, and personal possessions that Modernism Week 2023 Minneapolis
highlight the effect of his North London Palm Springs, California Held both virtually and in person, this forum
upbringing and his Nigerian heritage. See February 16–21, 2023 will gather over 500 leading policymakers,
designmuseum.org. This annual celebration of Modernist design architects, and other industry professionals to
and architecture features more than 350 share perspectives and collaborate on zero-
Architecture Now: New York, New Publics events in a variety of locations throughout energy and zero-carbon solutions to decar-
New York Palm Springs, including home and garden bonize the built environments. For more
Through July 29, 2023 tours, films, and lectures. This year’s keynote information, see gettingtozeroforum.org.
The Museum of Modern Art has announced presentation wil be by Morphosis principal
a new exhibition series that will showcase Thom Mayne See modernismweek.com. Concéntrico 09
work from emerging architects who are inno- Logroño, Spain
vators in the field. The inaugural exhibition Coverings April 27–May 2, 2023
will highlight 12 recently completed projects Orlando The six-day architecture and design festival
throughout New York, from architecture April 18–21, 2023 returns for its ninth iteration this year with a
firms including Adjaye Associates, nArchi- The largest international tile and stone event roster of events, installations, and exhibitions
tects, SO – IL, and record’s 2022 Design in the United States, this year’s Coverings throughout the city of Logroño. Featured are
RESIDENTIAL RISING: Lower Manhattan since 9/11 39 Battery Pl, New York
IN THE GALLERY AND ONLINE
skyscraper.org
Custom Doors
design proposals and concepts that celebrate honors excellence in photographic interpreta- for Every Project
the public realm and civic life. For more, see tions of the built environment. Winning
concentrico.es/en. entries will be published in record and
exhibited at the 2023 AIA conference in
Competitions April. See aia-stlouis.org.
Radio Frequency
Performance Hybrids
AvAilAble At advancelifts.com
1-800-THE-DOCK www.KriegerProducts.com
Earn up to
2 AIA LUs
RecordontheRoad.com
Advertisers Index
Advertiser Page Advertiser Page Advertiser Page
Advance Lifts INC 109 B+N Industries, INC. 45 Landscape Forms, INC. 20
Architectural Record - ACE Mentor 100 Bobrick Washroom Equipment INC 23 National Terrazzo & Mosaic Association 29
Architectural Record - Design:ED Podcast CVR3 Getting to Zero, a program of Skyscraper Museum, The 108
Goldbrecht 3
TREX Company 13
Architectural Record - February Webinars 90
WR Meadows 35
Armstrong World Industries, Inc. CVR2, 1 Koala Kare Products 26
Publisher is not responsible for errors and omissions in advertiser index. R Regional Insert
111
SNAPSHOT
Tomas Rossant & BJ Siegel Marianne McKenna Andy Cohen & Diane Hoskins
Ennead & Juno & Shirley Blumberg Gensler
KPMB
Now all DESIGN.ED Podcasts will offer AIA LUs. Listen to conversations with design legends and emerging stars
while earning CEUs. After listening to the podcast, visit https://continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com/podcasts
and take a quick quiz to earn one learning unit towards your license requirements.
Check out our top 6 podcasts from 2022, which have been approved for AIA LUs, at
https://continuingeducation.bnpmedia.com/podcasts.
PLATINUM SPONSORSHIP:
www.architecturalrecord.com/designed-podcast
SUBSCRIBE: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | iHeartRadio FOLLOW: Instagram
Foot traffic and maintenance work on a commercial rooftop without cover
board protection can lead to costly puncture damage. Specify DensDeck®
Roof Boards to strengthen your roofs and your reputation.
Don’t let preventable damage hold anyone back. See how your
buildings can be ready for anything at DensDeck.com/StopCallbacks.
©2023 GP Gypsum. DensDeck and the Georgia-Pacific logo are trademarks owned by or licensed to GP Gypsum.