CBP 8403
CBP 8403
(REACH)
Contents:
1. What is REACH?
2. Chemical industry in the UK
3. REACH and the transition
period
4. Negotiating a future
relationship
5. UK REACH: Regulating
chemicals in the UK
6. UK access to EU market
Contents
Summary 3
1. What is REACH? 5
1.1 Why is REACH significant? 6
1.2 How does REACH work? 6
1.3 How do non-EEA countries trade chemicals with the EU? 8
2. Chemical industry in the UK 9
2.1 Summary 9
2.2 Chemical products trade 10
2.3 Employment by region 10
3. REACH and the transition period 11
3.1 REACH and the Withdrawal Agreement 11
3.2 Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland 11
4. Negotiating a future relationship 13
4.1 Participation in the ECHA? 13
4.2 An Annex on chemicals in the EU-UK trade agreement? 14
4.3 Stakeholder commentary 16
Industry stakeholders 16
Concerns about lowering chemical safety standards 17
Advantages of a separate UK system? 18
4.4 Economic impact of Brexit scenarios on the chemicals industry 19
5. UK REACH: Regulating chemicals in the UK 21
5.1 Legislation 21
Environment Bill 2019-21 22
5.2 UK REACH: key features 23
5.3 Commentary on the UK REACH regime 26
Parliamentary debate on the REACH EU Exit SI 2019 26
Data submission deadlines 26
Concerns about animal testing 28
Scientific advice and oversight 28
HSE and Environment Agency resources 29
5.4 REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020 30
5.5 UK Chemicals Strategy 32
6. UK access to EU market 35
Summary
What is REACH?
REACH is the main EU legislation for the regulation of chemicals in the EU (the
Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals Regulation). It is a
single market measure applying in the European Economic Area (EEA), which includes the
EU in addition to Norway, Iceland and Lichtenstein.
REACH requires substances that are manufactured in or imported into the EEA to be
registered with the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA). It then provides a regulatory
framework to control or restrict the use of hazardous substances based on those
registrations.
REACH is important for improving the protection of human health and the environment
from hazardous chemicals and for facilitating trade in chemicals across the single market.
The UK chemical industry
The chemical industry is a key manufacturing sector in the UK, accounting for 9% of total
UK goods exports. Trade in chemicals is highly intertwined with the EU; 57% of chemical
exports in 2018 went to EU Member states, and 72% of chemical imports came from the
EU. Further, chemical products are used in many other manufacturing sectors.
Brexit implications and challenges
REACH is an example of EU legislation that is not straightforward to copy across into UK
law. This is because the regulation relies on the integrated role of the ECHA and is closely
tied to the single market.
REACH is a regulatory requirement for trade that impacts many UK manufacturing sectors
that rely on chemicals. Manufacturing industries often have complex supply chains with
chemicals crossing UK-EU borders many times.
REACH in the transition period
Following the UK’s withdrawal from the EU on 31 January 2020, REACH continues to
have effect in the UK until the end of the transition (or implementation) period according
to the Withdrawal Agreement. However, the HSE will no longer participate in ECHA
decision making.
REACH after the transition period?
The UK Government has stated that the UK would not participate in the EHCA or the EU
regulatory framework for chemicals after the transition period. Instead the Government
proposes to put in place a separate UK REACH regime. Chemical and manufacturing
industry stakeholders continue to call for an agreement with the EU that ensures
frictionless trade and regulatory consistency, ideally as close as possible alignment to
REACH. The Government has proposed that the agreement could include an annex on
chemicals with provisions for data sharing and cooperation.
A UK REACH
REACH would be retained in domestic legislation at the end of the transition period
(currently expected to be 31 December 2020). Secondary legislation has been passed that
would amend REACH in the UK to make it work in a UK-only context from that point.
The UK REACH Regime was initially designed to establish a UK-wide market for chemicals
applying to all chemical substances manufactured and imported into the UK. The Health
4 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
and Safety Executive (HSE) would be established as the UK Chemicals Authority, taking
over the functions of the ECHA. Under the Northern Ireland Protocol, however, the EU
REACH Regulation will continue to apply to Northern Ireland after the end of the
transition period, while UK REACH will regulate the access of substances to the market in
Great Britain, as set out in the REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020.
The Government says that the proposed UK REACH regime replicates the EU system as
closely as possible, maintaining the fundamental aims and purposes of REACH including
high standards of health and environmental protection. However, industry and
environmental stakeholders have raised concerns that the UK REACH regime is not
workable in practice, would be costly for industry and lacks transparency.
The Environment Bill 2019-21 contains provisions that would give the Secretary of State
powers to amend the UK REACH regime with the exception of certain listed protected
provisions.
5 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
1. What is REACH?
REACH – the Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of
Chemicals Regulation (No 1907/2006) – is the main EU legislation for
the regulation of chemicals in the EU. 1 It is a single market measure that
applies throughout the European Economic Area (EEA), this means EU
Member States as well as Norway, Iceland and Lichtenstein.
REACH requires substances that are manufactured in, or imported into,
the EEA to be registered with the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA),
along with safety information about the chemical and its uses. 2 This is
referred to as the “no data, no market” principle – without providing
the necessary safety data, companies cannot place their products on the
market. REACH then provides a system for controlling or restricting the
use of hazardous substances based on this data (see section 1.2).
REACH has several aims, including:
• to protect human health and the environment from the risks that
can be posed by chemicals;
• to place responsibility onto industry (manufacturers and importers
of chemicals) for understanding and managing the risks
associated with the use of chemicals;
• to allow free movement of chemicals and substances in the EEA
market, while also enhancing innovation and competitiveness in
industry;
• to minimise animal testing by promoting the use of alternative
methods of safety assessment and by facilitating data sharing of
testing results. 3
REACH is managed by the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA), based
in Helsinki. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) is the enforcing
authority in the UK, and the Department of Environment, Food and
Rural Affairs (Defra) is the lead Government department with overall
policy responsibility across the UK.
How were chemicals regulated before REACH?
REACH came into force in June 2007. Prior to REACH, chemicals
regulation across the single market was a patchwork of different
regulations with different rules for “new” and “existing” chemicals. 4
REACH was developed to have a single system of rules for all chemicals
across the single market. Significantly, REACH placed the burden of
undertaking risk assessments for substances onto industry, rather than
on public bodies. 5
1
There is also specific EU legislation for certain types of chemicals (such as biocides
and cosmetics) and for the labelling and packaging of chemicals. For background
information, see the Library briefing paper: Chemicals Regulation (11 August 2016).
2
In quantities of more than 1 tonne and there are some specific exclusions, for
example, radioactive substances and some naturally occurring low-hazard
substances. See: HSE, What is REACH? [accessed 31 July 2018]
3
Health and Safety Executive, What is REACH? [accessed 22 August 2018]
4
European Commission, REACH in brief, February 2007.
5
European Commission, REACH in brief, February 2007.
6 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
6
European Chemicals Agency, REACH registration statistics, accessed 13 February
2020.
7
ECHA, Understanding REACH, [accessed 11 September 2018].
8
European Chemicals Agency, How to avoid unnecessary testing on animals, accessed
20 September 2018.
9
ECHA, Registration [accessed 26 February 2020].
10
European Chemicals Agency, REACH registration statistics and infographic [accessed
14 February 2020].
7 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
11
ECHA, Registration: Data Sharing [accessed 26 February 2020].
12
ECHA, Registration: Data Sharing [accessed 26 February 2020].
13
These substances are included on the ECHA “Candidate List of Substances of Very
High Concern for authorisation” but are not listed in the regulation.
14
ECHA, Committee for Risk Assessment, Committee for Socio-economic Analysis,
Member State Committee, [accessed 10 March 2020].
8 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
15
European Chemicals Agency, Only Representative, [accessed 22 April 2020].
16
Swiss Common Notification Authority for Chemicals Website, Chemicals Legislation
and Guidelines, [accessed 22 April 2020].
17
Chemical Watch, Turkey publishes law modelled on REACH, 29 June 2017.
18
European Chemicals Agency, Cooperation with peer regulatory agencies, [accessed
27 February 2020].
9 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
Sources: ONS, GDP Low level aggregates; Business Register & Employment Survey; Business counts;
HMRC, UKTradeInfo;
Industry defined as SIC code 20; Trade is for SITC product code 5, excluding 54 (pharmaceuticals)
Note: Economic output is Gross Value Added; Trade is goods only; Businesses excludes small
businesses with no employees and turnover below the VAT threshold (£85,000).
19
Industry defined as Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) code 20: the
transformation of organic and inorganic raw materials by a chemical process and the
formation of products.
20
In terms of Gross Value Added (GVA); Source: ONS, GDP Low Level Aggregates
Tables, February 2020
21
ONS, Business register and employment survey, 2019; data table 2.
22
Excludes small businesses with no employees and turnover below the VAT threshold
(£85,000). ONS, Business counts, 2019, via Nomis database
23
HMRC, UK Trade Info database, SITC code 5 (chemical and related products),
excluding SITC code 54 (pharmaceutical products). Accessed December 2020
10 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
Source: ONS, Business Register and Employment Survey, 2019 (via NOMIS and Northern Ireland
data tables).
24
ONS, Business register and employment survey, 2019; data table 2.
11 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
25
Withdrawal Agreement, Article 128(6). HSE, Regulating chemicals (REACH) during
the transition period, accessed 18 February 2020. See also the Library briefing paper
on the October 2019 Withdrawal Agreement (18 October 2019) that describes
institutional arrangements in the transition period.
26
Article 7, Protocol on Ireland/Northern Ireland
12 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
4. Negotiating a future
relationship
The exact nature of the UK’s chemicals regulation regime, and the
extent of any cooperation with the ECHA, after the end of the transition
period will ultimately depend on the outcome of the ongoing future
relationship negotiations between the UK and the EU. 27
For general background information, see the Library briefing paper on
The UK-EU future relationship negotiations: process and issues
(CBP8834, 2 March 2020), The UK-EU future relationship negotiations:
Level playing field (CBP 8852, 19 June 2020) and Library Insight What is
happening in the UK-EU future relationship negotiations? (7 April
2020).
27
PQ1750, 23 January 2020 [European Chemicals Agency]. HSE, REACH during the
transition period [accessed 10 March 2020]
28
PM’s Office, Our approach to the Future Relationship with the EU, 27 February
2020; 79 Council Decision authorising the opening of negotiations with the United
Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland for a new partnership agreement, 25
February 2020.
29
HC Deb 26 February 2020, c157WH.
30
HC Deb 26 February 2020, c157WH.
14 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
31
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, 34th Report of Session 2019-21, 19
November 2020, HL Paper 172, para 14
32
Prime Minister’s Office, PM speech on our future economic partnership with the
European Union, 2 March 2018; HM Government, The Future Relationship between
the United Kingdom and the European Union, 12 July 2018, Cm 9593.
33
CIA, UK and EU chemical industry welcome draft Brexit agreement, 22 November
2018.
34
House of Lords, Select Committee on the European Union, Energy and Environment
Sub-Committee, Brexit: Chemical Regulation, 2017-19, HL215, 7 November 2018,
para 20.
15 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
35
PM’s Office, Our approach to the Future Relationship with the EU, 27 February
2020.
36
HM Government, Draft UK Negotiating Document Annexes to the Draft Working
Text for a Comprehensive Free Trade Agreement Between the United Kingdom and
the European Union, May 2020
37
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, 34th Report of Session 2019-21, 19
November 2020, HL Paper 172, para 17
38
Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006, Article 120.
16 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
39
Draft text of the Agreement on the New Partnership with the United Kingdom, 18
March 2020, Section 6: Article LPFS.2.30, paragraph 2 [accessed 22 April 2020].
40
Chemical Business Association, Regulatory alignment vital for chemicals sector, 27
January 2020 [accessed 19 February 2020]; British Coatings Federation, BCF Blog -
Brexit and a Future Trade Agreement with the EU, 23 January 2020.
41
Chemical Industries Association, Chemical Industry making Brexit work for the UK and
the EU press release and position paper (PDF), 14 February 2020; UK-EU Negotiations,
25 February 2020.
42
CIA and Cefic, REACH related issues in the future relationship between the EU-27 and
the United Kingdom (PDF), February 2020.
43
HL Deb 16 March 2020, c1275.
44
CIA and Cefic, UK-EU Negotiations press release and joint views on the future
relationship negotiations (PDF), 25 February 2020.
17 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
45
CIA and Cefic, UK-EU Negotiations, 25 February 2020.
46
Chemical Business Association, CBA welcomes potential access to chemicals
database, 4 March 2020.
47
CIA and Cefic, UK-EU Negotiations press release and joint views on the future
relationship negotiations (PDF), 25 February 2020.
48
HC Deb 26 February 2020 cc157-159WH.
49
US trade deal ‘could flood Britain with toxic cosmetics’, Jamie Doward, The
Observer, 21 March 2020; Global Justice Now, How a US-UK trade deal threatens
our protection from hazardous chemicals, Kate Young, 11 November 2019
[accessed 22 April 2020]
50
CHEMTrust, Brexit and Chemical Protections, [accessed 26 February 2020]; Greener
UK, Briefing for Commons Second Reading of the Environment Bill (PDF), February
2020.
51
Letter to Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on GB REACH,
from CHEM Trust et al, 7 October 2020
18 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
52
House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee, Toxic Chemicals in Everyday
Life, 2017-19, HC 1805, 16 July 2019, para 26.
53
HC Deb 26 February 2020 c155WH and HC Deb, 25 February 2019, c89.
54
HL Deb 26 March 2019, c1741.
55
PQ 7151, 4 February 2020 [Chemicals: Regulation].
56
HL Deb 16 March 2020, c1273 and 1275.
57
HC Deb 26 February 2020, c257WH.
58
Brussels criticised for delays in banning toxic chemicals, Matthew Taylor, The
Guardian, 11 June 2018 [accessed 5 September 2019].
59
ECHA Newsletter, REACH compliance – an Agency priority for 2019, 21 February
2020l; Why two thirds of REACH registrations could be breaking the rules, Gareth
Simkins, ENDS Report [subs only], 6 June 2019.
60
House of Lords, Select Committee on the European Union, Energy and Environment
Sub-Committee, Oral evidence: The future of REACH regulations post-Brexit, 18 July
2018, Q26.
19 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
applying this principle in the future and there are many other
examples where we might want to diverge. 61
The Institute of Economic Affairs argued in September 2018 that
withdrawing from REACH would provide an opportunity to implement
“pro-competitive regulation”. 62 A European Commission report from
October 2016 considered the impact of REACH on international
competitiveness of the EU industry in comparison to regulations in
China, Japan, the USA, Canada, and South Korea. 63 It concluded that
“REACH does have a minor negative impact on the competitiveness of
the EU industry in relation to their third-country competitors” although
extent of this varies between different market situations and countries.
In terms of cost to place a new chemical on the market, the EU fell
within the middle of the range of countries considered, with costs being
higher than in the US but less than compared to Canada, Japan and
China.
61
HL Deb 16 March 2020, c1273.
62
Institute of Economic Affairs, PLAN A+ Creating a prosperous post-Brexit U.K., 24
September 2018.
63
European Commission, Impacts of REACH and corresponding legislation governing
the conditions for marketing and use of chemicals in different countries/regions on
international competitiveness of EU industry, October 2016.
64
HM Govt, EU Exit: Long-term economic analysis (PDF), November 2018, p 59, figure
4.5
20 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
5. UK REACH: Regulating
chemicals in the UK
The Government has been clear that it does not seek to participate in
the EU REACH framework. Therefore, subject to any cooperation
arrangements agreed, at the end of the transition period the UK will
become a third party to REACH. This means:
• A separate UK regime for regulating chemicals must be
established (called UK REACH) and
• UK companies’ EU-based registrations would become invalid and
UK companies must take action to continue to supply to EU
markets (see Section 6 below).
5.1 Legislation
At the end of the transition period (formally on ‘implementation period
completion day’) REACH would be retained in domestic legislation as
retained direct (principle) EU legislation in accordance with the EU
(Withdrawal) Act 2018 (as amended). 65 This means that the version of
REACH that is operative immediately before implementation period
completion day would be retained in UK law. This would include the
lists of restricted chemicals contained in the REACH Annexes and the
substances contained on the ECHA’s Candidate List for substances of
very high concern. 66
Secondary legislation was passed in March 2019 that would amend the
retained EU REACH Regulation in the UK to make it work in a UK-only
context: The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019
(as amended).” 67 This Statutory Instrument (known as the ‘REACH EU
Exit SI’) would come into force on implementation period completion
day (currently 31 December 2020). It was made under section 8 of the
EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018, which provides the power to correct
“deficiencies” in legislation arising from withdrawal from the EU.
Together, the EU REACH Regulation (as retained EU law) as amended by
the REACH EU Exit SI will, for the purposes of this paper, be referred to
as the “UK REACH regime”.
Section 5.2 sets out the key features of the UK REACH regime;
commentary is provided in Section 5.3.
65
Section 3 of the EU (Withdrawal) Act 2018 (as amended). For further information
see Library briefing on the Constitutional implications of the Withdrawal Agreement
legislation (Section 8), 20 February 2020 and the Library Briefing on the new EU
Withdrawal Agreement Bill, 6 January 2020.
66
The Candidate List is not contained in the REACH regulation itself but maintained by
the ECHA. The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (SI
2019/758) (as amended), Schedule 1 paragraph 46, inserts a requirement for the
HSE to include on its Candidate List all substances included on the ECHA’s candidate
list immediately before implementation period completion day.
67
The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019 (SI 2019/758) (as
amended).
22 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
The Government has since laid two amending instruments to amend the
REACH EU Exit SI to correct technical gaps raised by industry:
• The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) (No. 2) Regulations
2019 (SI 858/2019, made on 11 April 2019) – this fixes a gap that
left some firms not covered by the transitional provisions. 68
• REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) (No. 3) Regulations 2019
(SI 1144/2019, made on 2 July 2019) – this instrument concerned
a gap regarding authorisation applications that are pending a
decision by the European Commission. 69
The Explanatory Memoranda for each SI provide further details. 70
The Government also laid and approved the REACH etc. (Amendment
etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020 in early December 2020 (see section 5.4
below for discussion)
Environment Bill 2019-21
The Environment Bill 2019-21 contains provisions that would give the
Secretary of State powers to amend the UK REACH regime by
regulations. There are certain listed protected provisions which would
not be amendable by regulations, such as Article 1 on the aim and
purpose of REACH and Article 5, the “no data no market” principle,
amongst others.
The Government states that this power is required to ensure a “smooth
transition” to a UK chemicals regime following the UK’s departure from
the EU, and to keep the legislation up to date in the future. 71 However,
the provisions have prompted concerns from environment groups and
some MPs about the potential for divergence between UK and EU
regimes (see Section 4.3 above). 72 For example, Greener UK called for
additional articles to be added to the protected list:
We are concerned about granting the Secretary of State such a
sweeping power to amend the main UK REACH text, as this could
be used to reduce the level of protection for the public and the
environment from hazardous chemicals. [...]
We will be examining the individual REACH articles in depth to
establish which ones should be added to the protected list. As a
minimum, we believe that Article 33 on information in the supply
chain and a right to know for consumers should be added to the
protected list. 73
The Bill has completed its Committee stages in the House of Commons
and is awaiting a date for the Report Stage.
68
For further information, see: Explanatory Memorandum for SI 858/2019 and DEFRA
makes ‘Rolls-Royce’ amendment to UK-REACH, ENDS Report, Gareth Simkins, 24
June 2019
69
For further information, see: Explanatory Memorandum for SI 1144/2019 and
DEFRA makes ‘Rolls-Royce’ amendment to UK-REACH, ENDS Report, Gareth
Simkins, 24 June 2019.
70
Explanatory Memorandum for SI 858/2019; and Explanatory Memorandum for SI
1144/2019.
71
Defra, Environment Bill: Policy Statement, 30 January 2020, section 7.
72
HC Deb 26 February 2020, c150; Greener UK, Briefing for Commons Second
Reading of the Environment Bill (PDF), February 2020.
73
Greener UK, Briefing for Commons Second Reading of the Environment Bill (PDF),
February 2020, page 22.
23 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
74
Explanatory Memorandum, para 7.9-7.10.
75
Letter from Cabinet Secretary for Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform to
the Scottish Parliament Environment, Climate Change & Land Reform Committee,
27 November 2018. Available on the Scottish Parliament webpage: Statutory
Instruments - European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 [accessed 31 January 2019]
76
Welsh Government, Written Statement, 11 January 2019. Available on Welsh
Assembly webpage WS-30C-076 - The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit)
Regulations 2019 (“2019 Regulations”) [accessed 31 January 2019].
24 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
77
PQ243377 15 April 2019 [Chemicals: Regulation].
78
HC Deb 26 February 2020.
79
PQ453, 22 October 2019.
80
Explanatory Memorandum, Para 13.1.
81
The legislation currently reads that the transition periods begin on “exit day”
(defined as 31 January 2020). It is expected that data submission dates in the REACH
EU Exit SI will be updated in due course to be refer to “IP completion day” rather
than “exit day”. See: Burges and Salmon, The road to UK REACH - what happens
next?, Simon Tilling, 17 February 2020.
25 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
A different notification timeframe is therefore provided for companies importing substances from the
EEA. The deadlines for submitting information to the UK Chemicals Agency under this scenario,
however, were recently amended by the REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2020:
• within 300 (rather than the original 180) days, companies would be required to notify the HSE of
the substances they import from the EEA, including basic information about the substance and
its safe use;
• a full information package to support the registration would be required and has been extended
to run in a “phased manner by 2, 4 and 6 years. This would mean a total of 2, 4 and 6 years +
300 days to supply the full information. The phasing will operate by reference to tonnage bands
and hazard profile, with the highest tonnages and most significant hazards coming first”. 82
Under the previous deadlines, all registrants (irrespective of tonnage band) were required to
submit full information within two years. The staggered registration period will start from 28
October 2021.
82
Explanatory Memorandum, Draft REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit)
Regulations 2020, para 7.10
83
Explanatory Memorandum, para 7.13.
84
The REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019, Schedule 1, Part 10.
The legislation currently reads that the HSE must publish the statement within 3
months of “exit day” having not yet been amended to take account of the regime
coming into force on implementation period completion day.
85
Burges Salmon, UK-REACH and the new appeal system after Brexit, 1 April 2019
and Chemicals regulation: government reveals blueprint for UK REACH, 14 January
2019.
26 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
86
HC Deb 665, 25 February 2019 [Exiting the European Union (Consumer Protection)]
87
HL Deb, 796, 26 March 2019 [REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations
2019]
88
HL Deb, 796, 26 March 2019 c1755.
89
Chemical Business Association, CBA survey confirms industry’s concerns about UK
REACH post Brexit, 18 February 2019 [accessed 5 September 2019].
27 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
90
Chemical Industries Association and Cefic, REACH related issues in the future
relationship between the EU-27 and the United Kingdom (PDF); 14 February 2020;
Ready for Brexit, interview with Richard Carter, BASF Plc UK and Ireland, undated,
accessed 19 February 2020; Chemical Industry Association, A costly challenge for
the UK chemical industry under a ‘no-deal’ Brexit, 24 September 2018, accessed 5
November 2018.
91
What a grand chemistry experiment reveals about Brexit, The Economist, 12
December 2020
92
Brexit may put some chemicals out of GB’s Reach, Chemistry World, 2 December
2020
93
Alliance of Chemical Associations, Letter to Therese Coffey MP dated 31 October
2018 [accessed 5 November 2018].
94
HC Deb 26 February 2020 c159WH.
95
HC Deb 26 February 2020.
96
Delegated powers memorandum to the Environment Bill 2019-20 (PDF), 29 January
2020, para 521.
28 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
97
Letter from Rebecca Pow MP Parliamentary Under Secretary of State, Defra, to Rt
Hon Philip Dunne MP Chair of the Environmental Audit Committee, 2 September
2020
98
House of Lords, Select Committee on the European Union, Energy and Environment
Sub-Committee, Brexit: Chemical Regulation, 2017-19, HL215, 7 November 2018,
para 31 and 35; HC Deb 26 February 2020.
99
Chemical Industries Association, Chemical Industry making Brexit work for the UK
and the EU press release and position paper (PDF), 14 February 2020; UK-EU
Negotiations and joint views on the future relationship (PDF), 25 February 2020.
100
HC Deb 26 February 2020, c158WH.
101
HL Deb 16 March 2020, c1273.
29 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
are not replicated in the UK regime, arguing that this could result in less
transparent decision making. 102
A group of organisations, including CHEM Trust, Friends of the Earth
and Breast Cancer UK, wrote jointly to the Secretary of State for
Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in October 2020, expressing
concern that the scrutiny mechanisms in UK REACH were “inadequate”:
There are currently inadequate mechanisms for oversight and
scrutiny and for stakeholder engagement and public participation.
This would result in a more closed and less transparent system
than ECHA’s, that would be more susceptible to industry
lobbying. By comparison, the committee structure within ECHA
helps to ensure its work can be challenged and the best
information is available for these discussions, helping to avoid
mistakes and to ensure that decisions are made more
independently and transparently. 103
In its July 2019 report on Toxic Chemicals in Everyday Life, EAC
recommended that the HSE, in its statement on how it will comply with
the duty to commission external scientific advice, should “outline a
formal role in the substance evaluation process for the Committee on
Toxicity and Hazardous Substances Advisory Committee. It should also
establish a forum for engagement with stakeholders.” 104 In response to
the Committee, the Government stated that existing stakeholder
mechanisms, such as the UK Chemicals Stakeholder Forum would
continue under the new regime. 105
HSE and Environment Agency resources
There have been concerns raised about whether the HSE and the
Environment Agency (EA) would have the financial and staffing
resources to manage the additional regulatory responsibilities of the UK
REACH regime. 106 For example in the February 2020 Westminster Hall
debate, Shadow International Trade spokesperson Bill Esterson raised
the question of the extent to which the HSE would replicate the ECHA’s
workload:
Concerns have also been raised about the capacity of the HSE and
the legal framework it will follow. It could either repeat the work
of ECHA or rely on the work ECHA has carried out. The former
would be hugely expensive, time consuming and dependent on a
level of scientific expertise that may not be available. The latter
could leave it open to challenge on the grounds that it should not
102
CHEM Trust, CHEM Trust challenges UK Government on Brexit pesticides plans, 13
June 2019; House of Lords, Select Committee on the European Union, Energy and
Environment Sub-Committee, Brexit: Chemical Regulation, 2017-19, HL215, 7
November 2018, para 37-38; HC Deb 665, 25 February 2019 c89.
103
Letter to Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs on GB REACH,
from CHEM Trust et al, 7 October 2020
104
House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee, Toxic Chemicals in Everyday
Life, 2017-19, HC 1805, 16 July 2019, para 140.
105
Government Response to the Committee’s Twentieth Report of Session 2017–19,
HC 160, 19 October 2019, para 132 and 133.
106
Burges and Salmon, The road to UK REACH - what happens next?, Simon Tilling, 17
February 2020; HL Deb 16 March 2020, c1310; HL Deb, 796, 26 March 2019
[REACH etc. (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019;
30 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
107
HC Deb 26 February 2020, 151WH.
108
HC Deb 665, 25 February 2019 c93.
109
HC Deb 665, 25 February 2019 c78, 96.
110
Burges and Salmon, Chemicals regulation: government reveals blueprint for UK
REACH, 14 January 2020, accessed 21 February 2020.
111
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, 34th Report of Session 2019-21, 19
November 2020, HL Paper 172, para 21
112
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, 34th Report of Session 2019-21, 19
November 2020, HL Paper 172, para 22
113
Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee, 34th Report of Session 2019-21, 19
November 2020, HL Paper 172, para 25
114
HL Deb 8 December 2020 c1158
31 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
115
HL Deb, 8 December 2020 c1156
116
HL Deb, 8 December 2020 c1156
32 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
117
HL Deb 8 December 2020 c1179
118
Defra, 25 Year Environment Plan, 11 January 2018.
119
House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee, Toxic Chemicals in Everyday
Life, 2017-19, HC 1805, 16 July 2019, para 132-133.
33 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
18. The Chemicals Strategy will set out our approach to the safe
and sound management of chemicals. It will take account of the
Chief Medical Officer’s recommendations to consider the impact
of chemicals and chemical mixtures on human health. It will
incorporate the Government’s priorities for our domestic
regulation and reflect our future relationship with the EU. We are
committed to maintaining the UK’s existing high standards in the
safe and effective regulation of chemicals after we leave the EU.
19. The Strategy will also address concerns related to endocrine
disruptors (EDCs) and the use of potentially toxic substances in
furniture and household goods.
In February 2020 the Government stated that it was engaging with a
range of stakeholders and that a Call for Evidence would be published
in the spring. 120 Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Defra
Victoria Prentis stated in February 2020 that the Strategy would “aim to
drive sustainability, circularity and innovation in the chemicals industry,
while protecting human health and the environment from harmful
chemical exposure”. 121
Specialist Environmental news journal ENDS Report reported in April
2020 that Defra’s the work on the chemicals strategy had been delayed
due to the coronavirus outbreak. 122 In response to a Parliamentary
Question on the development of the Chemicals Strategy, the Defra
Minister, Rebecca Pow, explained that work on the Strategy was
underway:
It will build on a robust statutory regime and our international
obligations and set out direction of travel on important policies.
The next key milestone is the Call for Evidence in 2021. It will help
inform the development of a draft Strategy for consultation. 123
EU Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability
On 14 October 2020, the European Commission adopted the EU
Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability. 124 It proposes actions to:
• account for the cocktail effect of chemicals when assessing
risks from chemicals
• phase out the use of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances
(PFAS) in the EU, unless their use is essential
• boost the investment and innovative capacity for
production and use of chemicals that are safe and
sustainable by design, and throughout their life cycle
• promote the EU’s resilience of supply and sustainability of
critical chemicals
120
PQ13970, 17 February 2020.
121
HC Deb 26 February 2020.
122
Coronavirus: DEFRA pauses work on Chemicals Strategy as HSE changes inspection
regime, Simon Pickstone, ENDS Report [subs only], 6 April 2020, accessed 7 April
2020.
123
PQ 123726 [on Chemicals], 9 December 2020
124
The Commission states that it invites the European Parliament and the Council to
endorse the strategy and to contribute to its implementation, see European
Commission, Communication From the Commission to the European Parliament, the
Council, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the
Regions, Chemicals Strategy for Sustainability. Towards a Toxic-Free Environment.
COM(2020) 667 final, 14 October 2020
34 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)
125
Brexit may put some chemicals out of GB’s Reach, Chemistry World, 2 December
2020
35 Commons Library Briefing, 17 December 2020
6. UK access to EU market
At the end of the transition period, UK companies wishing to export
chemicals to the EEA single market would still need to comply with EU
REACH (and any other relevant regulations) and, in the absence of a
preferential trade agreement, pay a tariff.
Only companies based in the EEA may register directly with the ECHA.
This means that after the end of the transition period, UK-companies’
EU REACH registrations would become invalid. To preserve EEA market
access, UK companies would need to transfer their registrations to an
EEA-based entity before the end of the transition period. This may be an
affiliate/subsidiary company or an “only representative” agent (see
section 1.3 of this paper).
The ECHA has explained that setting up a company “on paper” is not
enough to satisfy REACH registration requirements:
A registrant is responsible for the substances covered by their
registrations. This means that the responsible staff and relevant
documentation must be present at the address of the registrant –
setting up a company on paper only in the EU-27 or EEA is not
sufficient. 126
Alternatively, without a valid REACH registration, the obligation for
compliance with REACH would fall to the importer of the substance (i.e.
UK chemical companies’ EEA-based customers).
The European Commission reported that as of mid-August 2019, 52%
of UK REACH registrants had transferred their registrations to an EU27
entity. 127 The Chemical Business Association highlighted in April 2018
that a significant number of their member companies were planning to,
or had already, created subsidiaries in other EU member states to ensure
access to the EU market. 128
The ECHA’s webpage on the UK’s Withdrawal from the EU provides
advice for UK and EU companies and is updated on a regular basis.
UK Government guidance for industry can be found on gov.uk (How to
comply with REACH chemical regulations) and on the Health and Safety
Executive’s Brexit webpages (Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and
restriction of Chemicals (REACH) regulation at the end of the transition
period).
126
ECHA, UK Withdrawal from EU: UK-based REACH registrant [accessed 22 April
2020]
127
European Commission, Finalising preparations for the withdrawal of the United
Kingdom from the European Union on 1 November 2019 (“6th Brexit Preparedness
Communication) 4 September 2019, page 7.
128
Chemical Business Association (CBA), Growing Concerns On EU Market Access Post-
Brexit, 27 April 2018 [accessed 27 July 2019].
36 End of Brexit transition: chemicals regulation (REACH)