Credit Risk Management 2017
Credit Risk Management 2017
1
CRM determines the quality of the credit portfolio and assists in minimizing potential losses.
To achieve this objective, CRM formulates appropriate credit policies and procedures for the
Bank to ensure building and maintaining quality credits and an efficient credit process.
Sonali Bank Ltd. has established Asset-Liability Management Committee (ALCO) to
determine the maximum risk exposure. ALCO also assesses recommends and controls cross
border/country risk.
To manage the Non-Performing Loans (NPL), Sonali Bank Ltd. has a comprehensive
remedial management policy, which includes a framework of controls to identify weak
credits and monitoring of these accounts.
1.3 Guidelines for CRM by Bangladesh Bank & Sonali Bank’s Practice
A typical credit risk management framework in a bank may be broadly categorized into
following main components:
a) Board oversight
c) Organizational structure
2
1.5 Objectives of the study
Preparation and presentation of this report contains few specific objectives. These are:
To have a sound understanding of credit risk management system and procedure followed in the
Sonali Bank Ltd.
To analyze in detail the credit risk management process of the bank and to make
recommendations if needed.
To get knowledge about the effectiveness of loan and sanction procedure that is
conducted on the evaluation of credit risk.
To have a general idea about the credit risk management performance of this bank.
3
Lake of published materials.
Some problems create confusions regarding verification of data.
It was very difficult to collect the information from various personnel for their job
constraint.
As some of the fields of banking are still not covered by our courses, there was
difficulty in understanding some activities.
The time is insufficient to know all activities.
And as it was my first work and inexperience was a problem. So, there may be
some personal mistake in the report.
4
CHAPTER 2: OVERVIEW OF THE ORGANIZATION
Mission: Dedicated to extend a whole range of quality products that support divergent
needs of people aiming at enriching their lives, creating value for the stakeholders and
contributing towards socio-economic development of the country.
5
2.4 HIERARCHY
Chairman
Board of Directors
Officer
6
2.5 Core Business Services:
Corporate Banking
Project Finance
SME Finance
Remittance
Lease Finance
Consumer Credit
Trade Finance
Loan Syndication
Foreign Exchange Dealing
International Trade
NGO-Linkage Loan
Consumer Credit
Investment
Government Treasury Function
Money Market Operation
Rural and Micro credit
Capital Market Operation
Special Small Loan
Other Services:
7
The followings are their most recent online services:
Ancillary Services,
Locker Service,
Automation Status,
8
2.7 SWOT Analysis of Sonali Bank
Strengths
Opportunities
The bank can offer more innovative types of services then other banks
Since Sonali Bank Ltd. has so many branches it can easily influence the banking sector.
Being a large Bank it can provide large investment.
Threats
9
Chapter 3: LITERATURE OVERVIEW
Review of literature of any research is very important because it provides a scope for
reviewing the stock of knowledge and information relevant to the proposed research. In
this chapter some selected studies reletad to credit risk managment.
Rajagopal et al. (1996) made an attempt to overview the bank’s risk management and
suggests a model for pricing the products based on credit risk assessment of the
borrowers. He concluded that good risk management is good banking, which ultimately
leads to profitable survival of the institution. A proper approach to risk identification,
measurement and control will safeguard the interests of banking institution in long run.
. Froot and Stein (1998) found that credit risk management through active loan purchase
and sales activity affects banks’ investments in risky loans. Banks that purchase and sell
loans hold more risky loans (Credit Risk and Loss loans and commercial real estate
loans) as percentage of the balance sheet than other banks. Again, these results are
especially striking because banks that manage their credit risk (by buying and selling
loans) hold more risky loans than banks that merely sell loans (but don’t buy them) or
banks that merely buy loans(but don’t sell them).
Treacy and Carey (1998) examined the credit risk rating mechanism at US Banks. The
paper highlighted the architecture of Bank Internal Rating System and Operating Design
of rating system and made a comparison of bank system relative to the rating agency
system.
Bagchi et al. (2003) examined the credit risk management in banks. He examined risk
identification, risk measurement, risk monitoring, and risk control and risk audit as basic
considerations for credit risk management. The author concluded that proper credit risk
architecture, policies and framework of credit risk management, credit rating system, and
monitoring and control contributes in success of credit risk management system.
Khan, A.R. et al. (2008) illustrates that Credit risk is one of the most vital risks for any
commercial bank. Credit risk arises from non performance by a borrower.
10
Chapter 4: Materials and Methods
To identify the implementation, supervision and monitoring practices interview with the
employee and extensive study of the existing file and practical case observation was
done.
a. Primary Sources:
Practical desk work.
Face to face contact
Relevant file study as provide by the concerned officer.
B. Secondary Sources
Financial Statements & Auditors' report of Sonali Bank Ltd., 31 December 2016.
Disclosure on Risk Based Capital (Basel-II), December 2016.
Annual Report (2020) Sonali Bank Ltd.
Risk Management Guidelines for Banks, by Bangladesh Bank.
Sonali bank website
Through internet browsing
11
4.3 Sources of Credit Investigation
Loan application
Financial statements (profit and loss account, Balance sheet, cash flow statement).
Study of accounts.
Market reputation.
CRG.
Report from CIB.
Personal interview.
Personal visit.
For investigation the manager or the officer who is in charge of the credit department
have to enquiry about followings
A through credit risk assessment should be conducted prior to the sanctioning of credit
facilities. They must conduct necessary KYC (Know Your Customer) part on the
customer and money laundering guidelines must be followed.
Following risk areas in the credit proposal should be addressed and assessed before
sending to Head Office.
1. Borrower Analysis:
a. Share holding
b. Education
d. Experience – success history
e. Net worth
f. Age etc.
2. Industry Analysis:
a. Industry Position/Threat/Prospect.
b. Risk factors pertaining to the industry.
c. Borrower's position / share in the industry.
d. Strength, weakness of the borrower compared to the competitors etc.
3. Supplier/ Buyer Risk Analysis
Concentration on single/few buyer/supplier is addressed.
13
7. Seasonality of demand
8. Debt to equity Ratio
9. Historical financial analysis:
12. Account
a. For existing customer the repayment history, credit turnover, study of account
statement
b. If the customer is proposed to be migrated from other Bank, statement of account from
present Banker is required
Allied deposit with our Bank.
Other business with our Bank.
13. Security:
a. A current valuation of collateral security by Professional Enlisted Surveyor be obtained
with photograph and site map. Collaterals within command area of the respective branch
location are preferred. Third Party property and vacant land should be discouraged.
b. Loans should not be considered based solely on collateral.
c. Adequacy and extent of Insurance coverage should be assessed. Insurance Policy
should be obtained from approved Insurance Company. Premium should be paid through
14
Bank, duly stamped money receipt be obtained. Insurance Policy be held by the Bank.
The Policy be renewed in time. Letter of authority be obtained from the customer to debit
account to pay premium for renewal/enhancement of the policy.
14. Succession issue:
Margin, volatility of business, high debt (Leverage / gearing), over stocking, huge
receivables with long aging, rapid expansion, new business line, management change,
lack of transparency should be addressed.
15. Adherence to credit guidelines:
a. It should be clarified whether the customer is agreeable to comply with guidelines in
respect of regulatory requirement and Bank's policy requirement.
b. Any deviation be clearly identified and maintained.
16. Mitigating Factors:
Risk factors are identified and side by side mitigating factors of those risks should
also be mentioned to justify the proposed facility.
On the basis of investigation the branch manager will prepare a credit report as per
format provided by their head office. After preparing credit report banks ask for loan
documentation.
a. What is documentation?
As other commercial banks one of the main functions of Sonali bank is to extend credit
facilities of its valued customers. The credit facilities are given against varies types of
securities. These are mainly:
Personal i.e. credit worthiness of the proposed borrower and guarantor.
Moveable i.e. FDR, shanchaypattra goods and commodities balance of deposit A/C etc.
Immoveable i.e. land building etc.
15
Before rendering credit facilities bank has to create charge over the securities through a
number of agreements .papers etc. which are called documents.
b. Purpose of document
The entire purpose of the document is that reliance can be place up on the truth of the
statement contains in them. Mainly three questions may be examined when document is
produced in the court.
The documents should correctly be taken by the bank in order to crate required charges
on the securities defectively in favour of the bank the proper and correct documentation is
essential from the point of view of the safety of the banks interest.
4) Execution
In presence of manager
In one sitting and with indelible ink
Any correction altercation etc. must be authenticated with full signature
Correctly dated
If several pages execution must put their full signature in all pages
Witness
5) Registration.
16
4.6 Loan classification
The measurement of credit risk is a vital part of credit risk management. To start with,
banks should establish a credit risk rating framework across all type of credit activities.
Among other things, the rating framework may, incorporate:
17
Financial risk Financial condition
Profitability
Capital structure
Present and future cash flows
The credit administration function is basically a back office activity that supports and
controls extension and maintenance of credit. While developing credit administration
areas, banks must ensure: The efficiency and effectiveness of credit administration
operations, including monitoring documentation, contractual requirements, legal
covenants, collateral, etc. The accuracy and timeliness of information provided to
management information systems; the adequacy of control over all "back office"
procedures; and compliance with prescribed management policies and procedures as well
as applicable laws and regulations. Banks need to enunciate a system that enables them to
monitor quality of the credit portfolio on day-to-day basis and take remedial measures as
and when any deterioration occurs. Such a system would enable a bank to ascertain
whether loans are being serviced as per facility terms, confirm the adequacy of
provisions, and establish that the overall risk profile is within limits established by
management and compliance of regulatory limits. Monitoring procedures and systems
should be in place so as to provide an early signal of the deteriorating financial health of
a borrower.
18
monitoring as well as possible corrective action, classification and/or provisioning.
Establishing an efficient and effective credit monitoring system would help senior
management to monitor the overall quality of the total credit portfolio and its trends and
helps to reassess credit strategy/policy accordingly before encountering any major
setback.
The banks credit policy should explicitly provide procedural guideline relating to credit
risk monitoring. At the minimum it should lay down procedure relating to:
The roles and responsibilities of individuals responsible for credit risk monitoring; The
assessment procedures and analysis techniques (for individual loans & overall portfolio)
Concentration risk generally designates the risk arising from an uneven distribution of
counterparties in credit or any other business relationships or from a concentration in
business sectors or geographical regions which is capable of generating losses large
enough to jeopardize an institution's solvency. Credit concentrations of a bank may be
pre-planned and part of its business philosophy. However, banks should make greater
efforts to identify and limit concentration risk or to demand appropriate risk premiums.
Each bank should have effective internal policies, systems and controls to identify,
measure, monitor and control credit risk concentrations (CCR). Banks should minimize
concentration risk possibilities rather than providing capital cover. However, BB reserves
the right to require higher levels of capital for individual banks with excessive
concentration risk.
19
CHAPTER 5: RESULT AND DISCUSSION
To understand how effective CRM practices is I have identified some aspects which are
core to risk management. The analysis was carried out in the following aspects:
Credit risk in the Sonali Bank Ltd.'s portfolio is monitored, reviewed and
analyzed by the Credit Risk Management (CRM) committee to minimize potential
losses and ensuring efficient credit process.
They have identified the types of risks and disclosed in the BASEL II disclosures
according to the BRPD Circular no-09 dated 31st December 2008.
The gross credit risk exposure has grown to BDT 38453.81 crore on balance sheet
as of December 2012.
Credit quality is standard due to their sound credit risk management system.
They have made sufficient provisions for NPAs, NPIs and depreciation.
Volume of off-balance sheet exposures is BDT 19692.61 crore in 2016.
Sonali Bank Ltd. has its own Credit Risk Management guidelines in terms of Core
Risks Management guidelines of Bangladesh Bank. The Bank also follows other
instructions/guidelines of Bangladesh Bank in this regard.
The bank decides on how much risk to take based on their risk appetite as well as
government guidelines.
To manage the Non-Performing Loans (NPL), Sonali Bank Limited has a
comprehensive remedial management policy, which includes a framework of
controls to identify weak credits and monitoring of these accounts constantly.
20
5.2 The credit risk faced by the bank
So, in short, the bank's board of directors and senior management are responsible for
ensuring that the bank have appropriate credit risk assessment processes and effective
internal controls. Bank have a system in place to reliably classify loans on the basis of
credit risk. Bank's credit risk assessment process for loans provides the bank with the
necessary tools, procedures and observable data to use for assessing credit risk,
accounting for impairment of loans and for determining regulatory capital requirements.
21
5.4 Overall performance of Sonali bank LTD.
Capital structure:
Qualitative Disclosures (Disclosure on Risk Based Capital, Dec 2016)
Core capital of Sonali Bank Limited comprises of fully paid up capital against ordinary shares,
statutory reserve and general reserve created out of profit, retained earning etc, and
supplementary capital include General provision & assets revaluation reserve. Eligible Capital of
Sonali Bank Limited on the basis of Audited Balance Sheet of 31 st December 2016 has been
calculated as per Basel-II guidelines as shown below.
Qualitative Disclosures:
Sonali Bank Limited is very much aware of maintaining Capital to support its current and future
activities.
22
Tab-2: Quantitative Disclosures
Table-3: Total Gross credit risk exposures broken down by major types of credit
exposures
(Tk in crore)
23
15 Loan under SB agro based industrial scheme 1111.81 1111.81
16 Working capital to agro based industries (hypo) 1169.52 1169.52
17 Working capital to agro based industries (pledge) 672.11 672.11
18 Agricultural loan 4180.98 4180.98
19 Micro credit 1221.84 1221.84
20 LIM( Loan Against Imported Merchandise) 202.24 202.24
21 LTR ( Loan Against Trust Receipt) 2825.00 2825.00
22 Forced loan 2441.59 2441.59
23 Loan for LC under WES 0.01 0.01
24 Loan against inland bill 348.45 348.45
25 Current account barter ( Debit balance) 93.26 93.26
26 Bridge finance 262.45 262.45
27 Small business loan scheme 115.22 115.22
28 Lease finance 14.89 14.89
29 Probasi karmo sangsthan prokolpo - -
30 Consumer loan 2289.17 2289.17
31 Term to freedom fighter 928.87 928.87
32 Education loan 20.18 20.18
33 Foreign education loan program .81 .81
34 SME finance ( term loan service) 57.65 57.65
35 SME finance (term loan to industries) 28.05 28.05
36 SME finance( working capital wing) 1630.57 1926.02630.57
37 Bills discounted and purchased 926.02 926.02
38 Others - 232.94
total 38453.81 38665.27
Off- balance sheet exposure solo consolidate
1 Letter of guarantee 231.26 231.26
2 Irrevocable letters of credit 18775.02 18775.02
3 Bills for collection 686.33 686.33
4 Others -
total 19692.61 19692.61
24
Tab-4: industry or counterparty type distribution of exposures, broken down by major
types of credit exposure
(Tk in core)
Tab-5: Residual contractual maturity breakdown of the whole portfolio, broken down by
major types credit exposure
(Tk in crore)
25
months
10 More than 3 months but not more than 6 52.35 52.35
months
11 More than 6 months 21.62 21.62
Total 926.03 926.03
26
organization. I worked in the absence of officer this really made continuous cash flow to
bank to customer and sometimes from customer to bank. A continuous cash flow really
helps in achieving its objectives and goals. So, giving me the opportunity both the bank
and myself became benefitted.
27
CHAPTER 6: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
From the above discussion and my insight investigation I would like to conclude the
followings
6.1 Conclusion:
Sonali Bank Ltd. is much different in any terms. Its activities are vast and in cases unique
to any other bank. Its deposits and loans are huge compared to other banks. It finances
government projects, provides unique services to people in need, even in places it works
as central bank. This Bank often make decision for the welfare of general public despite
risk of credit exposure.
The bank has established a sound credit risk management and credit risk mitigation
policy. Compliance with Basel II norms helps the Bank to improve their profitability
through better credit risk management systems.
From the discussion in this report, it has become clear that credit risk management is a
complex and ongoing process and therefore Banks or any financial institutions must take
a serious approach in addressing these issues.
6.2 Recommendation:
The failure of commendable banks occurs mainly due to bad loans, which occurs due to
inefficient management of the loans and advances portfolio. Therefore any banks must be
extremely cautious about its lending portfolio and credit policy. In the light of the above
findings, following recommendations are proposed:
.
The credit sanction procedure should be made quicker since competition is very hard in
today's business world. People do not want to wait for three to four weeks on an average
to get a loan which is even protected by security.
Decision making process can be made more decentralized.
28
The bank should emphasize on reducing the classified and non-performing credits
by concerted efforts.
In the credit department, strict supervision is necessary to avoid loan defaulters.
Bank official should do regular visit to the projects.
Central monitoring system should be more active to maintain classified loan to a
minimum level.
Filing is a very important component of proper documentation. It has to be dealt
with importance.
To attract more clients should sought new marketing strategy.
Politically influenced Lending or project finance should be checked.
29
REFERENCES
Altman, E.I., Haldeman, R.G., and Narayanan, P. (1977). Zeta analysis: A new model to identify
b bankruptcy risk of corporations. Journal of Banking and Finance, 1, 29–54
Carey, M. (2001). Dimensions of credit risk and their relationship to economic capital
requirements.
In Prudential supervision: what works and what doesn’t (ed. F. Mishkin).
Arminger, G., Enache, D. & Bonne, T. (1997). Analyzing Credit Risk Data: A
Comparison of Logistic Discrimination, Classification Tree Analysis, and Feed
forward Network. Computational Statistics, Vol. 12, Issue 2, p. 293-310
Altman, E. I. and Saunders, A., (1998), ―Credit risk measurement: Developments over
the last 20 years‖, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 21, pp. 11-12 and 1721-
1742.
30
31