Index Numbers for Economists
Index Numbers for Economists
Structure
    10.0    Objectives
    10.1    Introduction
    10.2    Steps in Construction of Index Numbers
            10.2.1 Select~onof Base Period
            10.2.2 Choice of a Suitable Average
            10.2.3 Selection of Items and their Numbers
            10.2.4 Collect~onof Data
    10.3    Method of Construction of Index Number
            10.3.1 Relative Methods
            10.3.2 Aggregative Methods
            10.3.3 Quantity or Volume Index Numbers
    10.4    Merits of the Various Aggregative Measures
    10.5    Tests for Index Numbers
            10.5.1 The Time Reversal Test
            10.5.2 The Factor Reversal Test
            10.5.3 The Chain Index Number and Circular Test
    10.6    Cost of Living Index Number (CLI) or
            Consumer Price Index Number (CPI)
    10.7    Worked Out Examples
    10.8  Let Us Sum Up
,   10.9 Keywords
    10.10 Some Useful Books
    10.11 Answers or Hints to Check Your Progress Exercises
    10.0 OBJECTIVES
    After going through this Unit, you will be able to :
       define index numbers; and
       construct and calculate them.
    10.1 INTRODUCTION
    An "index" in the common sense of the word is an "indicatof' and no more than
    that. "Index numbers" or "indices" are forms of the plural, but they all mean the
    same thing.
    An mdex number represents the general level of magnitude of the changes between
    two (or more) periods of time or places, in a number of variables taken as a whole.
    In this definition, the word ''variable" refers to numerical variables which can be
    measured in quantity, such as the prices of commodities. For example, we may
    like to&ompare the price level of an article between 1980 and 1990 or between
Index Numbers,     Mumbai and Kolkata. Let us consider the yield of rice in 1985 and in 1990 as
Time Series and
Vital Statistics   50,000 and 60,000 tons respectively. The year 1985 is taken as base;for
                   camparison of yields, that is 1985 = 100. The corresponding figure for 1990 will
                      60,000
                             100 = 120.~his   is a s~nglecommodityindex number in its simplest form,
                   being just a relative number. In practice, however, we deal usually with a number
                   of commodities for the construction of an index-.
                   Index numbers are ratios that are usually expressed as percentage in order to avoid
                   awkward decimals. Thus if one commodity costs 45 paise in 1970 and Rs. 1.50
                   in 1974 the ratio would be
                   It is not always the case that the comparison should be over time, but most common
                   types of index numbers measure changes over time. Similarly, index numbers may
                   be constructed for studying changes in any variable, such as intelligence, aptitude,
                   efficiency,production, etc.,but the time series of prices is perhaps most frequently
                   used. Our subsequent discussion on index numbers will therefore be made with
                   special reference to prices of commodities. The principles of construction are,
                   however, quite general in nature, and may thus be applied to other areas of interest.
                   There are various uses of price index numbers. The wholesaleprice index number
                   indicates the price changes talung place in wholesale markets. On the other hand,
                   the consumer price index number or the cost of living index number tells us
                   about the changes in the prices faced by an individual consumer. Its major
                   application is in the calculation of dearness allowance so that real wage does not
                   decrease; or in comparing the cost of living in, say, different regions. It is also used
                   to measure changes in purchasing power of money. The reciprocal of a general
                   price index is known aspurchasingpower of money with reference to the base
                   period. For example, if the price index number goes up to 150, it means that the
                   same amount of money will be able to purchase 1001150 = 0 67 times or 6796
                   of the volume of goods being purchased In the base period.
                   10.2.1 Selection of Base Period
                   Sincc index numbers measure relative changes, they are expressed with one
                   selc:tt.xl sitaatiotl ( r p 2 ~ o dplace
                                                      .      ztc ) as 100 This is called the base or the
                   I , . I +           ii  , .            t.ui~bersFor example. a date 1s first chosen
                                                   "~c,:~eu
                   and all ~h:ui,cs drc I;: :~surcd5nn; li, Th2 base may be one ,lay such as with lndcx
                   of retail prices. the avcrage of n year or the average of a period
While selecting a base period the following aspects should be taken into               Index Numbers
consideration:
1) The base date must be "normal" in the sense that the data chosen are not
   atlisted by any irregular or abnormal situationssuch as natural calamities, war,
   etc. It is desirable to restrict comparisons to stable periods for achieving
   accuracy.
2) It should not be too back-dated as the patterns of trade, imports or consumer
   preferences may than* considerably if the time-span is too long. A ten to
   twenty year interval is likely to be suitable for one base date, and after that
   the index becomes more and more outdated. Greater accuracy is attained for
   moderate short-run indices than for those covering greater span of time.
3) For indices dealing with economic data, the base period should have some
   economic significance.
10.2.2 Choice of a Suitable Average
An index number is basically the result of averaging a series of data (e.g., price-
relatives of several commodities). There are, however, several ways of averaging
a series:mean (i.e., arithmetic mean), mode, median, geometric mean and harmonic
mean.
The question naturally arises as to which avaage to chose. The mode has the merit
of simplicity, but may be indehte. The median suffers h m the same limitations.
Moreover, neither of them takes into account the size of the items at each end
of a distribution. The harmonic mean has very little practical application to index
numbers. As a result, mode, median and harmonic mean are not generally used
in the calculation of index numbers. Thus, the arithmetic mean is most commonly
used. However, the geometric mean is sometimes used despite its slight difficulty
in calculation.
10.2.3 Selection of Items and their Numbers
The number and kinds of commodities to be included in the construction of an
index number depend on the particular problem to be dealt with, economy and
ease of calculations. Various practical considerations determine the number and
kinds of items to be taken into account. For a wholesale price index, the number
of commodities should be as large as possible. On the other hand, for an index
meant to serve as a predictor of price movement rather than an indicator of changes
over time, a much smaller nurnber of items may be adequate. Care should, however,
be taken to ensure that items chosen are not too few which make the index
unrepresentative of the general level. A fixed set of commodities need not also
be used for a very long period as some items lose their importance with the passage
of time and some new items gain in significance. In general, the commodities should
be sensitive and representative of the various elements m the pnce system.
10.2.4 Collection of Data
As prices often vary from market to market, they should be collected at regular
intervals fiom various representative markets. It is desirable to select shops which
are visited by a cross section of customers. The reliability of the index depends
greatly on the accuracy of the quotations given for each constituent item.
    111dex Numbers,
    T i m e Series a n d     10.3 METHOD OF CONSTRUCTION OF INDEX
    V i t a l Statistics .
                                  NUMBER
                             Varioys methods of construction of index numbers are as follows:
                             1) Relative methods
I                               a) Simple average of relatives
                                b) Weighted.average of relatives
                             2) kggregative methods
                                a) Simple aggregative fonnula
                                b) Weighted aggregative formula
                                   1) Laspeyres'index
                                   ni Paasche's index
                                   ii) Edgeworth-Marshell's index
                                     iv) Fisher's ldeal index.
                             10.5.1 Relative Methods
                             If we record prices of a variety of commodities at a given date and at a later date
                             record the prices of similar items, the change in price can be simply expressed
                             as a percentage of the new compared with the old for each commodity. This
                             provides us with price relatives and if weights are available the next step will be
                             to multiply the relatives by the weights. Finally, an index number can be produced
                             if we add together the weighted relatives and calculate an average.
                             It is unrealistic to assume that the consumption of each commodity has been equal.
                             So most indices take account of the proportions of each item actually used. This
                             method of weighting shows the relative importance of each in the series.
                             index = 100 C
                                          i=1
                                                ("k)
                                                k
The most suitable weights to use are the value of each item, Gvhich is denoted by
w, for the i-th commodity. One may use the value of base year quantities sold
at the base year prices (w,, =p,q,,)or current year quantities sold at current prices
(wl,= pl,q,,)or any other value as weights. The weights can also be a set of
constant factors derived rationally.
A weighted arithmetic mean of price relatives using base year values as weights
is given by
                        CP"XW~
            index =                xl00                                           .....(10.2)
                           C wo
omitting suffix i for simplicity. It may be noted that base year weighting preserves
continuity, but loses "up-to-dateness" in the course of time.
Example 10.1: The table below presents the average fares per railway journey.
Using 1948 average = 100, calculations are made according to base year weights.
index =
            CP-xw,
              Po
                          x 100                                                  ......(10.3)
                                                                                                >   -
               C zo,,
Example 10.2: The table below shows the average fares per railway journey.
Using 1948 average = 100, calculations are made according to current year
weights.
Index Numbers,
Time Series a n d
                    Class of            No. of Fare (Rs.)                       Weights        Price
Vital Statistics    ticket       '    passenger                                              relative
                                     journeys in
                                       1948 in
                                       millions  1948     1969
                                         (4.)    @.)      (P,)                 w,, = P,4,     P--(Pp./     l?wn
                                                                                            P,)X 100
                                          1296430
                               index = -
                                       2793
                                            = 464.17
                                                                                                             ..
                    The weights used should be actual quantities bought or sold, and these are kept
                    unchanged until such time as the index requires to be revised.
                    There are mmy formulae for weighted aggregative index, but depending on the
                    w e of weights used, we discuss four indices which are commonly used.
a) Laspeyres' index                                                                       lrdex Numbers
If we use base period quantities (9,) as the weights in the general weighted
aggregative index formuIa (10.5), we get what is known as Laspeyre's
formula (L).
It can be seen that this index has fixed base year quantity as weights (qJ and is
equivaIent to a arithmetic mean of price relatives given at formula (10.2). Thus,
we can also write (10.6) as
b) Paasche's index
If we use current year quantities (9,) as weights in the general aggregative index
formuIa (10.5), we get what is known as Paasche's fonnula (P).
where qn (actually q,,, q,,   .... q,) are the quantities bought or sold in the current
period.
c) Fisher's Ideal Index
An index number obtained as geometric mean (i.e., square mt of the product)
of indices obtained by Laspeyres' and Paasche's formulae, satisfies certain
important properties (to be discussed la&), is known as fsher's ideal fohnula
d) Edgeworth-Marshall Index
If the mean of the base period and the current periodquantities is used as weight,
1-e.,
     1
w = ?(go + q11, we get what is known as a compromise formula of Edgeworh-
Marshall index.
Index Numbers,                                                     Table 10.1:
T i m e Series e n d
V i t a l Statistics
                                           Illustrative calculations of Laspeyres', Paasche's,
                                               Edgeworth-Marshall's and Fisher's indices
                                    Base Year               Current Year
                                      (1970)                     (1980)
                       Item        Price   Quantity        Price     Quantity
                                   @J          (40)        Q'J         (43         Po40     Pn40    P04n        Pn4,
                                                                                  1154
                       1) Laspeyres' price index = a                   x 100 = -xl00=104.72=105
                                                             CP ~ B O             1102
                                                           Lpn4n                 850
                       2) Paasche's price index =                 xlOO=-x100=110.97=111
                                                             P04n      766
                       Note that for the same price change different formulae provide different values.
                       oreo over,  when prices are increasing, Laspeyres' index gives the lowest value
                       while Paasche's index gives the highest value. Therefore, it is often said that
                       Laspeyres' index is an under-estimate while Paasche's index is an over-estimate
                       of true price change.
                       103.3 Quantity or volume Index Numbers
                       We can get a quantity or vglume index number, which measures and permits
                       comparison of quantities of g W , h m corresponding price index number formulae
                       simply by replacing p by q and q by p.
                                                      4,
                       1) Quantity relative = -X            O0
                                                      40
                                                                                                    [go   11k
                                                                                                                          Index Numbers
    ...................................................................................................................
2) Discuss the various problems involved in construction of index numbers with
   particular reference to price indices.
    ...................................................................................................................
3) The following are the prices of six different commodities for 1983 and 1984.
   Compute the price index by (a) aggregative method, (b) average of price
   relatives method by using arithmetic mean.
          Commodities                    Price in 1983 (Rs.)                   Price in 1984 (Rs.)
                   A                                  40                                     50
                   B                                  50                                     60
                   C                                  20                                     30
                   D                                  50                                     70
                   E                                  80                                     80
                   F                                  100                                    110
                                                                                                                                     I?
Index Numbers,
Time Series .rod
                   4) Calculate Fisher's Ideal Index Number h m the following group of items.
Vital Strtistles
                                                          Base Year                                     Current Year
                           Item No.                    Price      Quantity                              Price    Quantity
                                                     (in Rs.)      (in kg)                            (in Rs.)    (in kg)
...................................................................................................................
                   The Laspeym' index calculation is simpler, since this uses the base period quantities
                   as weights which are not difficult to get and the denominator needs calculating only
                   once. But in this index a rise in prices tends to be overstated, since it does not
                   take into account corresponding falls in demand or changes in output. Indices such
                   as Paasche's, on the other hand, use current period quantities as weights which
                   are difficult to get and the weights need to be constructed afresh for every year.
                   Moreover, Paasche's index tends to understate the rise in prices because it uses
                   cunmt weights.
         The Laspeyres' index is probably more commonly used, since it is convenient to          Index Numbers
         employ fixed weights. But with the passage of time the weights are rendered out
         of date. For example, in 1970 the number of TVs in Calcutta was nil. In 1990,
         there are more TVs than refrigerators. The Paasche' s index uses the preferable
I
         current weights, but since up-to-date information on quantity of goods produced
,I       or consumed or marketed or distributed are not r d l y obtained, the Laspeyres'
i        index has a great advantage.
         Symbolically,
                IonX In,= 1
         where Ion= index number for period n with the base period 0
              In,= index number for period 0 with the base period n.
         1f frob 1975 to 1982 the price changes from Rs. 4 to Rs.16, the price in 1982
         is 400 percent of the price in 1975, and the price in 1975 is 25 percent of the
         price in 1982. The product of the two price relatives is 4 x 0.25 = 1. The test
         is based on the analogy that the principle, which holds good far a single commodity,
         should also be true for the index number as a whole.
         There are five methods which do satis@the time reversal test. These are:
         1) Simple geometric mean of price relatives
         2) Aggregative indices with fixed weights
     I
         3) Edgeworth-Marshall formula
         4) Weighted geometric mean of price relatives if fixed weights are used
         5) Fisher's ideal index
On the other hand, Fisher's ideal index satisfies this test, as shown below. I
                                       C P , ~C~Q ~ PX-OZqnpn
                                     x-X-
                                       Cpoqn      CQOPO    Zqopn
                   Example 10.3: We show with the following data that the Fisher's ideal index
                   satisfies the factor reversal test:
                                                                                               Index Numbers
                   Price (Rs.)                No. of units
                                                                    pogo   pnqo   Po%   pnqn
     Item        1983 1989 1983 1989
                 @d, @,I (qJ GI,,)
        I           6          10          50           56          300    500    336   560
       11           2           2         100          120          200    200    240   240
       III          4           6          60           60          240    360    240   360
       IV          10          12          30           24          300    360    240   288
       V            8          12          40           36          320    480    288   432
    Total                                                           1360   1900   1344 1880
Price Ratio: $ =
Quantity Ratio: Ip =
                Cpnqn-     1880
              = --- -
                         '
Value Ratio: IY            -
                C p o q 0 1360
            1880
           --
            1360
        = I, which shows that the test is satisfied.
Using a suitable index number formula (say, Laspeyres' index), link indices, defined
as follows, are first calculated: Link index = Index number with previous period
as base. The chain index is obtained by multiplying link indices progressively. Thus,
the chain index number Ion     for period n Gith base period 0 is given by
............................................
I, = I , , x I , , x .....      X I ,     ,    .   X   I   .   ..
lndex Numbers,         Example 10.4: The calculation of chain index numbers is illustrated with reference
Time Series and
V i t a l Statistics   to the following data:
                                 Year             Link index          Chain index (Base 1970 = 100)-
                       Thus, the chain index numbers for the years 1971 to 1973 with 1970 as the base
                       are 80, 96 and 72 respectiv.ely.
                       Circular Test: The circular test is an extension of time reversal test over a number
                       of years. It states that the chain index for the year 1973, calculated above, starting
                       fiom the base year 1970 will be same as the index number directly calculated with
                       fixed base period of 1970. In symbols,
                                                                                        1
                       I,, X I,, X..... X                   = 1. (Notice that Ion= -)
                                                  , ) n x In,
                                                                                      Lo
                       Considering an aggregate index with fixed weights
                       Fisher's ideal index does not satisfy this test. It has been proved that no index
                       satisfies both the factor reversal and the circular tests.
                       Check Your Progress 2
                       1) Compute the chain index number with 1980 prices as base fiom the following
                          table giving the average wholesale prices of commodities A, B and C for years
                          1980 - 84
2) Construct Fisher's Ideal Index number fiom the following data and show that
   it satisfies Factor and Time Reversal Tests.
The common method for obtaining the consumption basket is to conduct a family
living survey among the population group for which the index is to be constructed.
Prices of selected items are also collected from various retail markets used by
consumers in question. It may be noted that each of the above broad groups
contains several sub groups. Thus, 'food' includes cereals, pulses, oils, meat, fish,
egg, spices, vegetables, fruits, non-alcoholic beverages, etc. 'Miscellaneous'
includes such items as medical care, education, transport, recreation, gifts and many
Index Numbers,     others. When more than one price quotation is collected for a single commodity,
Time Series and
Vital Statistics   a simple average is taken. Index number is constructed for each of the five groups
                   using weigkieu average of the price group; the weights used are proportional to
                   the expsn&ture on the consumed item by an average family. Next, the overall index
                   (CLI) is computed as an weighted average of group indices, the weights being
                   again the proportional expenditure on differ& groups (e.g. 50 per cent on food).
                                   PO~O
                   where      =   -
                                  C poqo ,is the weight of a group index.
                   The CLI or consumer price index (CPI) numbers have significant practical
                   implications and extensive public use. Its use as a wage regulator is the most
                   important. The dearness allowance of the employees are primarily determined by
                   this index. When wages or incomes are divided by corresponding CLI, the effect
                   of rise or fall of prices is eliminated. This is known as the process of deflation,
                   which is used to find 'real wages' or 'real income'. As mentioned earlier the
                   reciprocal of CLI measures the purchasing power of money.
                                              -
                   Index (food) = X W X ( P . +PO)xloo
2) Compute Paasche's price index number for 1980 with 1975 as basc from
   the following data:
a) Aggregative method
Index number for 1980 (base 1970 = 100)
~ v e r a ~ gprice
              k per unit in 1980
                                 xlOO
Average price per unit in 1970
Example 10.8: Calculate price index numbers fiom the following information, using
(a) weighted aggregative formula, and (b) weighted arithmetic mean of price
relatives:
                   Example 10.9: Given below are the data on prices of some consumer goods and
                   the weights attached to the various commodities. Calculate price index numbers
                   for the year 1971 (base 1970 = 1OO), using (a) simple average, and (b) weighted
                   average of price relatives.
                                                                          Price (Rs.)
                     Commodities             Unit                  1970             1971                  Weights
                     Wheat                   Kg.                    0.50                0.75                2
                     Milk                    Litre                  0.60                0.75                5
                     Q3                      Dozen                  2.00             2.40                   4         ,
                     Sugar                   Kg.                    1.80             2.10                    8
                     Shoes                   Pair                   8.00            10.00                    1
                                                                          Z ( P / ) ~ ~ O O 637
                   a) Simple average of price relative index =
                                                                                Po        -
                                                                                          -      -
                                                                                                = 127.4
                                                                                 k           5
                                                                 C I w 2466
                   b) Weighted average of price relative index = -= --      - 123.3
                                                                 cw     20
                   Example 10.10: On the basis of the following data, calculate the wholesale price
                   index-ber   for the five groups combined.
                    Food                                      .     50                         24.1
                    Liquor and tobacco                              2
                    Fuel, power, light and lubricants               3
  Industrial raw materials                16                   256                 Index Numbers
                                2 Iw
We compute: General index = -
                                2w
where I = Group index, and w = Group weight
                                       22391
Index number of wholesale prices =     -100
                                             - 223.91
Example 10.11 :Annual production (in million tons) of four commodities are given
below:
Calculate quantity index numbers for the 2 years 1954 and 1955 with 1950 as
base year, using (a) simple arithmetic mean, and (b) weighted arithmetic mean of
the relatives.
                  42
Commodity B:     -x 100 = 175
                  24
i:*dex Numbers,        Quantity relatives for 1955 with 1950 = 100
Time Series and
Vital Statistics
                                         68
                       Commodity C: -x 100 = 136
                                         50
                       Example 10.12: From the following price (p) and quantity (y) data, compute
                       Fisher's ideal index number.
                                                          --                       ----
                       Commodity            1970 (Base Year)             1978 (Current Year) -
                                          Price       Quantity          Price           Quantity
Calculations for Fisher's ideal index:                                                  Index Numbers
                                          470
Laspeyres' price index = -
                         x p n q Ox 100 = -x  100 = 124.34 = 124
                         ~ P ~ B O 378
                                            476
Paasche's price index     E p n 4 nxlOO=-xlOO=
                         =-                              123.96=124
                           E poqn           384      .
                    Quantity index =
                                       C(qn 1 go)x 100 x w   -- 146652 = 92
                                               Cw                  1590
                    C                  35        40       50              70         2450      2800
                    Total                                                            10730    12500
I
    Using po,p,, and go, we can find Laspeyres' index as
                             C ~ n 4 xlOO=-
    Laspeyres' price index = -       0     42.00x 100 = 109.
                              Po90         390.0
                                            O g n )xloo
    4) Marshall-Edgeworth index = ~ P . ( Y +
                                         Cpo(90 + 9 , )
                        504.2+ 450.1
    Required index =                 xl00=49.1.
                       1025.9+ 916.3