| Page No.
Date
NOTE S
Onendibg contuoueN began
Studus
hEhe debeodomont O0cabita0iam
Uds
Maudce Doobb
Another Maexit Scho0as chollengec
Ehe Bheis o Dobb.Dobb a9%Qued thatE
Ehe deciine á Feudalism wos t e
AOU0E O anex Contkadictiohs uthu
he EOudagmode QA bcductin. This
exb mtin CAOQNO co00edTnne9
Contsadiction mcdoQ
Phuia SUeeZy akuethot declireo
FOudolm_uapsiinaoioduetothe
OranNiOn OcommeaaQ tconomy thot um
dikecky oated to goouth a Treadee
uohichoctedaAanertona0 dinaluin agent
This htep&Okation i uua00y Toameda
macket 0c coMmeXiad ndiaR Ehe
ekchanao-kplations' beraectiue
2Non-mO At SChOQas_aKO HJ Habakkuk
Laduie.
MH. POxan oEmmmnu Le RO
wa0lo9Atoin_makesc
RA Emu EmMahueQ
thisaphiach-
signilicant conteubutiom in
uO0gAcd-raade be«apecte
i m l p o c t a r t F o c t O Rn Fyr
POALdation i an
theecDnon
nch imLeAe d e c e a e
dembgeaph
Thb Tntecheekotion ia Toemed an 0en
modeo os Nthunian medel
Page No.
Date
Anothex HO%I cho0a9Robet erenrek .
bo boaught-tNO Leanaiticncleboteinthe 1gtos
the 198_
He talKabutEno coasA GEUuggle intis
debate
MagLthimce haa naE FLOuided Hhe Hhengol
Txansition.HohanoE0kcHen muchonthid
Toplc
He beOUidO 2ateMtue DDtA to cobitalim-
OR mekcodti0o cluty.
Second0y He gae lmfoAtance aexhanaion o
maketozouthoR Citie
He Ox Þlains Hhe b9o-coDditians that
alouSome
bnducOAA tO becoroe cabitalishg ohe coasation
EeOstpmoio9uty o QoduceAA PAmtha
Ehem Unto paohORtIOeN une OabauxeA
heepanion oR Mecoti0e aculuty Eused
Eo eem emMucts ntn commaditiey bititdoo
not indicote houa labourba ier bacomOA a
Cm dihHenco aLL Qaus teey an
Soial clatians a poductin
Fok maL Hne commadinied laba1 LA Hhe
Onlu SAuxceo Hhe copita0iat Su A Na0ue
He SuAgest
OQ
EbOt LnUiOten Eugne Sthat
CabitaðiNY doo ndt omogO LabeLseahoPase.
tes
Hhe Icen olt indutrual
the 0ate-eighteeMthcontuay
AccoRding to Macr Lndistota ecacabtaln-
LdouelDSon th ee Foctoak
PageNo. .
Date
4PoiateaDCSshih.ol means o
Rise o bOUgO beDduEO
cooCKindol madlec
3Eixtame Og Uiaae Oabous
TnOe FoameaEhe basis
becoRiE OCLui@Oticn un aß oduEim >
0orgun
oR Copitaliam pemasily coocene
Lith Ehe extaboiahment o Lho stsuuctusol
bro-0oMitio cother than Uthdetaiiec
mechahiam othatCreatedthaeno bee
=Comition
Tnne ontaadicionmodo
NOueice Doabb bkOuIde est exonaki
FOR Hhe Cocline op foudalimThikarid
genera9 dexoihe as konpert KeOntica
penkechue unne Lonteadictianmcde.
e0ated
Fodnebb huo key o0emnt
Tanubon op Foudalismtoeececabitalao
49Spom oL b&0duckim eting on ER
ea00ou
Cabitaliam(abOAd on higedwage laboer
OmOJeNCe ol MOcantclas.
baiA
eca a0AE Thee EOMmedtho
DduCtion beniE accumulatian thED
Qong u n
I n e o L o g o F o d o b b t h e aeuelopmOr
CapiitaliamÉa 00A Lnto dilleAOAt ST
Page No.
Date
chasocteizedby EA9eued omatusut Ac
LaSpec ic made & peoductiaHitcanndt be
datedock tothe FOst Signso tne ateAkaxes
Lo Oasge Scoe Teadung Ee omOknere
ele oÓLCat Oe cla
Tho lpitaisE peiOd haAto coincideuith
lchanges Un-ehe maceo þDductinEmt is
ldikecL Suubasdination al bcoducetoa_
cabitaisE
Heni PsLoneAcc.tnhim beginning a-
CapONLm date back totheDEh(entuay
Dohn iocate ta beainning intne LAtes hb0p
cenhs Easly Baut althe ontrie
uhen capita0 bopanto penetsatebrducbon
On conidexaboe ccale According En Dabb th
Con LUeNepeiaa e O u`han Teode
uioaardigealE.
TmIA douelcment uNNeHthee un Hhe Foemo
udpotLOed ko eONmcably mahised Nelation
betuen-Hno cabitalist houage eatn@is
0k 00-dee0gped Eoemo Suboedination
OdmONtic hGndirkaE woKeA tnacapitaliE
theougn the Co-called huting-out sten2
uuhat 0ed to the dec0ine op FOudalism ih
Mauice Dobb depihoAFOudalism aA asatem
economy
O Se-SuuRicient notuxal socto-ecomomic
H TCeata i t þsuimaguil as a
Teade Manou dealnga
Syptem in uihich
bat totally abNenE but Odrupled a
O NO
Page No.
Date
ORatdlySmadLe
Acc,to nir ÞOacee in the ecao
Foudalim.da
ulhico econOmi SutemuudOr-
SpteMune
SEatus authoU
ae
Oau aociatecl uithland ToNLre
0customoguyughts. AnLnedisect
baunducet i
undeCigotion to_ouDuido
cectantépoktiaO.ORHe
Oabousto hixSupesioa poduce oghi
Dobb
egakAEhA
thCOLRanM CAtem admOAt
Henists Ehatunde
ident icad_
tho Pouda mado op
pooductiomanobQigc.tion
isalLoaus blaced ona
poducez
Indehedent OP hiADIAOUe byFdce
besa o poLDeHMay
mLOLtakyStxengtn
buehe FOLUdaQ QnRd o boAxONec
feuaa QSocia0 cutom becouke o
FoRceaQ Qau bacKect byEhe
Tne booduckian U
ummeddiate eeccgeneta0My Foa-the
Fo tae vi00age athe houehcOd aa
Acc.to makoicocommunly
Dobb
need
Ouke Rodney Hitn manyathe2
Kohachiko ToKabashi.
Eic HObaboudn. Tt(AanNtona0
Oelationhie o Hhe Feudal made o
bonduction thOt detOuminethe
Cixnegotion oLCuuDiaQ SyAtem
SAdence Lcicote that itOAtne
Lneiciencu siapabi0ityo Foudalim
ibcumde d bnductionJthatFailad
tOSotL tnd mateico derandl Face
bQaceusoniit qzowng heed o the
eOlg claaA Ea nhand
Date
IheLauw
Stationo&w
Shabe o
9KQUenue
bucduCiL kd maegun o r
SuKhlus
peoditkt la
cauOa Beotbacted
LOhich
makenasysterMheRgCIent_0aLwhaoductiwi
oD theminaiaecohan nc&eaaed nee
enue EO UXA eELacontaaLOiA
Lthe nableA th9eDuGh cOAtydianlay&
Ouih Fease
Supodting uieLOS A dobb
hachia Takahashi adOiNNistshat gezdmLAA
he existeme Foamo QabauK Ln Eeudal modo
ORpaduction
s aehceuaa the TcanAeRance on thelabouu
thebakantFamilto Hhe Qand ozd.Cchis-
uathe CuxHlua)toiohat uas Hequined Fog
he beaont Fami ttKefOÁNcLn siecto
Fconuc Kep&odluCtion.
The ucblus OabousCauld be uMcddisecHy m
0andOn9da demPbneo i t coLQd bo TcanNSred
h Form.ol kent okmeneuo inanothe e
BcentuieA deadingtoasoiou declir-
Ln FQudalincome
me Sizes demAbNelando Lotda heganto
Shink ax come parto demn wane n
o Qeanhed to peanants CcaR A)
Some b0tsol akgibeO OandC fokext eg)
weke bLought un oCultiationdueto Food
OMOHue KequLAomoht.A 00 +heg Oee
Sumbtoms o c i l s oL FeudaluÁm
bobb aQuOAHhat heed Foe additiOnaO lesh
plaean incee0ed bko9e OnbeocekO.
Cse4)
Page No.
Date
9adua00y eochedl a boint WhgO
LEbecome unedukobRe
he ecmomic mieuy bouotioKed t0 mas
imugation.The AeNpde totne-Feuda
hoity-tothe feudaQ csuiNa uasied i n
aiaReent posutAo Esuope.
Eg-In Some þarts Qike oNCe)-ehe.
LLd weReFakcedto gie concONsiN-
t o getaun Ser Oabaur
Thi neant the metigotiono seuLCe
bukden
>AT Ge same Tume Subsitution oQ
ConteactuaQ ee00tinahipuuithraõney
umenE
FOda0 KexpOhe UuaN Ún the fokmo
hteing o FeudaQ buKdenspadopkk-
O Em ieo`uLeAO CtOchmenton
Sorato Fouaa extatexy ecoptueA
Fugituwes) ce-imbaiticn op euiOe
lokorgotions asLtapeed ineat-euok
Ouice dexCibe) n e boicd mthe
beganning op the omeagerce o Feudae
cINin L8odte L5 unt estabishmeht
TndutiOdiotim
He cdeNuhes Hhin p0Ruc aATeanitim
Aaoichobabaun Sudbota aKQument.og
aobb.
He bointed OuEthatre TRonitim Om
padutiba
the FeudaQ tiothe cqbitollEmodeo
opment
a s hignlywnouen denel
hotastzaightpouuaud a a c e -
Page No..
Date
The CapitalSE CQementS UEN feuda0i i hausS
t obeco
me Stong enough EOXtEdecdine o
fOudalNm The cA OPeudalDmalauabe
herODtOduancea Secti) O he bouKaeoLN
ldeLcldpment uEhun Bne Feud SAtem
E Hobdbaun)Ehedonite Tiumbh ol
lcabitalNmA eNected HhiaughtheIrdubsio_
Amezcian pEe (oenh ReuQution
MaxKot Cordeuc Ecplanakian IModo0
PhuoSuucezu ImmanLieo
Out Hne ole a) makKot.d Lla000xxtein beim
in Ehe.decline dp FoLdalismecmnaeOconom
Cabitc0ism in Someuhot the.suNe OL-
di00ekentuaua
nis eplaandikect0y
ieLK o Dobb can0icta uiththe
othe&S iuNO ondoPO Hho innes
Contsadictionexp2anation
As obkobed tothia
SuNeezyadptsamaseKeE=
Centuic abheAacH ca0 Ied the
maketP as tie
commorciaQ madeQ
SuDeezObiecta to Dados Ideatpicotidn ol
t h SOLLdoM Foudalin
abuntecchangeabie Texma
Dabb had depined feudaliam by
keueading tho
chaeacteitics o serldom-an ohligatlcd aced
Cnthe_ADducez b EaKe p Tndieendent op hin
Qun vpition to tulO COCtaino conam ic dead
Oanove Alpad.
Page No
Date
llpcbh Saus Feudasm
in hich Soapaom asan econonnic SIstem
lol SociaQ UOSENG AKOdomiOntFoum
u
sc0atins opcduiction,agarized
a9OuN manaiaQ etate.
Tn Such a Septem
ynot be abent hecontents ma9Kket
but they played no
detooemihing ole un Ehe eutpoNeA DK
oethode o muction.
he excchange LHeMkms
þexapectie oL
SubeeZy derineA cobitaliam
baduotm EOL LX0Rt ana sLpem
orcome that depeda tneognmaaketss
ay cnintEEn tma
T&ode axEd dioson oR
Qabou
He agQuey tbat S e
feucol eocietj una
aSiptem aL bodluckim fog Ae.
ecisted no lntexmldimamic Iheie -
StimuQate Odng-tekna goLOthEmt unLd_
Oeae alone Ehe capob0t o expanion
intocaþitalunm, T&nomig
Bcctobim)tne iae A xchange
Ehat0ed to monetiaotion economy
betuueen
Foudo0 002da the alelbtions
ma Somehaou heasgnt
O FOuCadLsm, Sygha0@ed he diolutin
Page No.
Date
NACCsdug to SuCZYDObB haAhater0ainthe
sOsonz eabioiti o Feudaluam oothez
OdJ Dobb badnoE.exp2anthe carge.coitant.
cmcactex cRFeudaQan
Sueezyios Dobb concopton Eoudalism ia
deiected he aLaue tmt some So%domb Can_
be a basta Sstem uuhich aee
Dobb EeudalianmequaOto nott EOudO0.foz
Serdombut nct-Eo
Suneezy Accto Suneezy the
LbVtNudOio bi Dobb ÚLo comcebto0 Eoudaliim
Suneoz ha pauhteda out JDLo0itic
tnat aacto Dobb TOa.
EtueKoX ol Eeudalism uiich
nike þosiad O exstec Hh9 ghQUt-
Feudalism.L
DAZegadLbe inteestap.se1
ia9
ocektain Reguona Euope
FuKope)theo tuO FeauOA
bangae ati0e cothe
CexpeciaoyAsteun
becae inteduHh
Ln caNO op Ehan decliniguhich
uOOxteAnEuer9, Suoeezu bapEen
Dobb Fo not guiuing bONriticised
baopez erarotion
diwezaian. Suoeezy adeex Ear thin
n a basantic coa Luith-Ebe obb ne pobuOit
toecabe thei Feuda0 tbe Seccoudd un aay
Fo Eeudol CiyN cbligption c nA animb.
Acc.to SuNeOziy Dobh bad b0en ahRe to
tne 9iNO OTounA Os G excblain.
CO uithin-he EeudaG
Suptemthenhisthesu a interaQ CauAation
Fok decQine aR FeudaAm_Sti00 bo
delendedTacade=
notvey t b Fact0t FoL udciO 00e hence
the LNe t touhs Cold nOt be Lhtroena0
Page No.
Dete
The Qoca0 uielage
weRe vesy michmoKeA itinekae peddieM
Once h e past o Feudal ecrcry.
þéadoum Stage unA
heRe uaa aquarnkotúe
Shit.
TAars-shipment
Acc.ta SaKs4
there aal dAekee blw
muket bdcHn Foe
bRductio FoRUL. Specdadi2aton
a egionaQwise uas nat done
Another ning urs diuiion
olakcuRGNLa
baNc o Specialization op Kegin..Acc to
Sueezythe begrnning o ecchange econors
Led to Ehe aduento mmey,b l FeudoL LcAds
Sueezy akguestatthúuns Uwbat led to
decdine o eeudadism. Sueozy hos Citiced
Dobb E0K Not. being able tn exbain the stakke
chakackes o FoLcadim.Ho ado cuiticised
him FoK natpenuiding intoematieno the
changeleane in feudl Sqptom.He End Dotb
tbexib delectie a0so he Sais +bat Come Foum
which a s e
ocepdom canexint in Sptems
not EOudoQ.
eezHderinOs capitalim as a GiatemnoR-
pDaluckion Foc baot Lhaougb maseKet ercharg
Emt oebenda goinint echational TLade
b0se diuision oD Oaboue Accto SacezytLD-
ctiskOoEeudalim uore faundthsoigna
he Feudao þesiod
ODizegaLd intproxt o se
Page No.
Date
Pauo SLeezy tooKaboutcomaaditi braduuction.
The beiod ol Tamnition uannot FOrdoQ ot captalist
ILunrthe peecapit0int commodit paduction
inwentern euNAeThe E0-captalistcomoadit
booducticn. Acc to SueezyitUn the eoutho
Commodity pk00ucAian EL t unclefemuned
FeudaO_
oLnducicn Oatee ee paae Lhe qAd Fa
Suco aR Feudalism. IL
oductim daer peeparaFoRunthe qaouthoR CTamodit
copitaQim
oditinct Foce Othis
citicied SuoeezuEas Ube taNDition.Dobb baa
Eopean Feudalim neecd theUAthotuestexn
oquired EA the Some exte%naQ
EoLce
dismation
Dadbhaauon feidalim a n Fouda0sm ACGto
a
+endance aA cane Stab0e it a00
ne oigina the nccdecn
TauanlIenanmieg uD9Ad Siptom une
ladlgIstoin He dAey not KoA-
eccopt tne vieuxEhat
eotionc aboduCEioncopitaOia Laan a setoA
ctate instend uo Sociao
eristig ihinthe nation
amctuge' SetO deine
Sociao captaditiam caitalimuns
unithintho noticn Stote ae0ationn o acucticnexitng
a auO& Ld natead ue deie
StemThid capita0in
empl&e umichueie dieLont Pm ekstunhQe
cabitolat uDAd ptem uniliedoDitica0 buttne
Oabau oP, dullan bdue ita
baiintermtionca
UniuenAad
Helation, Te omeOheD masket exchanae
ina baticaa Reeage Qabu9
nOtiomalSoting tn Eusudo had
moiket ecnrnomy bld Aige2ent.egion
a t the
Ceht re
