Enzyme Electrodes
Enzyme Electrodes
Oehme F (1991) Liquid electrolyte sensors: potentiometry, Ross JW, Riseman JH, and Kruger JA (1973) Potentiomet-
amperometry, and conductometry. In: Göpel W, Hese J, ric gas sensing electrodes. Pure and Applied Chemistry
and Zemel JN (eds.) Sensors. A Comprehensive Survey, 36: 473–487.
vol. 2, ch. 7. Weinheim: VCH. Veselý J and Štulı́k K (1987) Potentiometry with ion-
Riley M (1979) Gas-sensing probes. In: Covington AK (ed.) selective electrodes. In: Kalvoda R (ed.) Electroanalytical
Ion-selective Electrode Methodology, vol. 2, ch. 1. Boca Methods in Chemical and Environmental Analysis, ch. 6.
Raton, FL: CRC Press. New York: Plenum.
Enzyme Electrodes
M Mascini and I Palchetti, Università degli Studi di of sensors based on field-effect transistor (so called
Firenze, Firenze, Italy ion-selective field-effect transistor, ISFET).
& 2005, Elsevier Ltd. All Rights Reserved. Nowadays, ion-selective sensors are constructed
using various advanced methods such as thick- and
thin-film technology. A thick-film sensor comprises
Introduction layers of special pastes (thickness 10–50 mm) deposit-
ed onto an insulating substrate; the method of film
Potentiometric enzyme electrodes form a large group
deposition is the screen-printing technique. Thin-film
of catalytic biosensors, resulting from a thin layer of
electrochemical transducers are built up by the suc-
enzyme integrated within or intimately associated
cessive deposition and patterning of dielectric and
with a potentiometric transducer. The enzyme gene-
conductive materials, on top of an optically flat and
rates a reaction that enables determination of the
polished substrate. The deposition of the thin metallic
substrate (the target analyte), providing a highly
films (thickness 10–200 nm) is generally carried out
selective and sensitive method for the determination
by classical evaporation or sputtering of a solid metal
of a given, ionic or nonionic, substrate. The deter-
source; then, photolithography and other techniques
mination of the electrode potential gives a direct in-
can be envisaged to pattern the electrode material.
dication of the concentration of the analyte. The
Using these technologies, microfabricated arrays of
signal obtained is proportional to the logarithm of
sensors and biosensors have been developed.
the concentration, following the Nernst law.
Interesting features of potentiometric transducers
are simplicity of instrumentation (only a potentio-
meter is needed), low cost, selectivity, and the non-
General Features of Enzyme
destructive nature of the analytical procedure.
Electrodes
Potentiometric Transducers Biosensor Assembly
Guilbault and Montalvo were the first, in 1969, to In order to prepare the biosensor, the enzyme has to be
detail a potentiometric enzyme electrode. They de- immobilized in the form of a thin layer at the surface
scribed a urea biosensor based on urease immobi- of the transducer. Among the several methods for im-
lized at an ammonium-selective liquid membrane mobilization available, the following are the most
electrode. Since then, over hundreds of different ap- generally employed: (1) physical entrapment within
plications have appeared in the literature, due to the an inert polymeric membrane (in this case the enzyme
significant development of ion-selective electrodes is mixed with a monomer solution, which is then poly-
(ISEs) observed during the last 30 years. The elec- merized to a gel – polyacrylamide gel, starch, agar
trodes used to assemble a potentiometric biosensor gel, etc., thus trapping the enzyme) or behind a
include glass electrodes for the measurement of pH membrane (in this case the enzyme solution is simply
or monovalent ions, ISEs sensitive to anions or cat- confined by an analyte permeable membrane, such as
ions, gas electrodes such as the CO2 or the NH3 a dialysis membrane, as a thin film covering the in-
probes, and metal electrodes able to detect redox dicator electrode; this method is also called micro-
species; some of these electrodes useful in the con- encapsulation); (2) covalent bonding of the enzymes
struction of potentiometric enzyme electrodes are on membranes or surfaces activated by means of bi-
listed in Table 1. functional groups or spacers, such as gluteraldehyde,
In the 1980s, ion-selective membranes were used carbodiimide (when the enzyme is bound to the solid
for the first time as the molecular recognition element support using a bi- or multifunctional agent, such as
ION-SELECTIVE ELECTRODES / Enzyme Electrodes 521
gluteraldehyde, which forms a bridge between electrode; (2) diffusion of the substrate through the
biocatalytic species or proteins, the technique is membrane to the enzyme-active site; (3) a reaction
also called cross-linking or reticulation); and (3) im- occurring at the active site; (4) product formation in
mobilization on commercially available activated the enzymatic reaction and its transport through the
membranes such as Immunodyne produced by membrane to the surface of the electrode; and (5)
Pall Industries, or Ultra-Bind produced by Gelman measurement of the product at the electrode surface.
Sciences. The first step, transport of the substrate, is most
Several enzymes can be immobilized within the critically dependent on the stirring rate of the solu-
same reaction layer, in order to increase the range of tion, so that rapid stirring will bring the substrate
possible biosensor analytes, provide efficient regene- very rapidly to the electrode surface. If the membrane
ration of enzyme cosubstrates, or to improve the is kept very thin using highly active enzymes, then
biosensor selectivity by decreasing the local concen- steps (2) and (4) are eliminated or minimized; since
tration of electrochemical interfering substances. step (3) is very fast, the response of an enzyme elec-
Generally, the technique of chemical immobiliza- trode should theoretically approach the response
tion (covalent bonding) is preferred. This procedure time of the base sensor. Many researchers have
improves the enzyme stability and defines a diffusion shown experimentally that one can approach this
layer where the product, formed by the catalytic ac- behavior using a thin membrane and rapid stirring.
tion of the enzyme, diffuses partly to the electrode
surface and partly back to the bulk of the solution;
therefore, by defining the steady state one obtains Analytical Features of Enzyme
a reproducible potential value. However, the real Electrodes
advantage of the enzyme immobilization through
Concentration Range
chemical bonding is the lifetime of the final probe,
which can reach 6–12 months. The maximum concentration of substrate that can
An enzyme electrode operates via a five-step pro- be measured with an enzyme electrode is governed
cess: (1) transport of the substrate to the surface of the by Km (the Michaelis–Menten constant). If the
522 ION-SELECTIVE ELECTRODES / Enzyme Electrodes
Table 2 Km values reported for soluble enzymes and maximum concentration values of the linear concentration range reported for
each biosensor probe
Urease Urea 10 10
Glucose oxidase Glucose 7.7 35
L-Amino acid oxidase Leucine 1.0 10
Invertase Sucrose 0.45 1
Alkaline phosphatase p-Nitrophenylphosphate 0.1 1
Lactate oxidase Lactate 0.7 20
Pyruvate oxidase Pyruvate 1.7 2
Creatininase Creatinine 0.33 1
Acetylcholinesterase Acetylcholine 0.09 1
Uricase Uric acid 0.017 1
a function of stirring rate related to the amount of 49 in order to obtain complete conversion of NH4þ
substance brought to the electrode surface and to its into NH3, and to obtain a shorter response time of
reactivity. Hence, for fast response times and steady the electrochemical probe. However, few enzymes
states, a fast but constant rate of stirring of the can function at such high pH, so a compromise is
substrate solution is recommended. necessary. With the carbon dioxide sensor, the sam-
ples should be kept at pH o5 to obtain a complete
Substrate Concentration conversion to carbon dioxide of hydrogencarbonate;
The rate of enzymatic reaction increases with sub- however, these low pH values often interfere with the
strate concentration; for example, in the case of a enzyme reaction, and a compromise is necessary be-
cyanide electrode coupled with immobilized b-gluco- tween optimum pH for enzyme activity and optimum
sidase enzyme, a response time of 20 s for 10 1 pH range of response of the probe.
mol l 1 amygdalin and 1 min for 10 4 mol l 1
Temperature Effect
amygdalin is obtained. Rather than waiting until an
equilibrium potential is reached, the rate of potential The effect of increasing temperature is twofold: an
change ðDE=DtÞ can be measured, the result being increase in the rate of reaction gives faster response
proportional to substrate concentration. time and a shift in the equilibrium value due to
variations in the equilibrium constant. Electrochemi-
Enzyme Concentration cal sensors of the gas-permeable membrane type
There is a twofold effect on increasing the enzyme (ammonia and carbon dioxide) lead to an additional
activity in the layer that is in close proximity to the effect, since the gas membrane and the features of the
electrode surface. First, a complete conversion of diffusion are sensitive to temperature variations. De-
the substrate into products will be ensured; second, spite the above considerations, a classical bell-shaped
the response time of the electrode will be affec- curve is almost always obtained when recording the
ted. The increase in the amount of enzyme affects the response of the probe as function of temperature.
thickness of the membrane. This results in an in- Room temperature, or 251C (controlled to 70.21C is
crease in the time required for the substrate to diffuse recommended), is often employed when using an
through the membrane. Hence, for the best results, it electrochemical probe, although when using a gas
is recommended that an enzyme of as high an activity permeable membrane control to 70.11C is required.
as possible is used in order to ensure rapid kinetics by
Thickness of the Enzyme Membrane
achieving the thinnest possible membrane.
The time required to reach steady-state potential
pH Effect reading is dependent on the enzyme layer thickness
Every enzyme has an optimum pH at which it is most because of the diffusion parameter for the substrate
active and a certain pH range within which it does to reach the active sites of the enzyme and of the
not exhibit reactivity. The pH ranges of immobilized electroactive species to diffuse through the mem-
enzymes are different from those of soluble enzymes brane to the sensor. A mathematical model relating
because of the microenvironment. Highly negatively the thickness of the membrane, d, the diffusion co-
charged carriers create a lower pH at the boundary efficient, D, the Michaelis constant, Km, and the
layer between the carrier and the bulk solution. maximum velocity of the enzyme reaction, Vmax, has
Thus, the enzyme is in a more acidic environment been developed:
than the bulk solution. The reverse occurs with
Vmax d2 =DKm ¼ V
positively charged supports. Even for uncharged
supports, the overall charges of the enzyme may be
sufficient to cause changes in the apparent pH where V compares the rate of chemical reaction in
optimum. However, in general, the greater the charge the membrane with the rate of diffusion through the
on the support, the greater is the effect, particularly membrane. Larger V indicates faster enzyme cataly-
with charged substrates. The optimum pH should be sis relative to the diffusion process.
used for obtaining the fastest response, but this is not Membranes as thin as possible are recommended
always possible because the electrode sensor may not for the best results, and this is helped by the use of a
itself give the optimum response at the pH of the highly active enzyme.
enzyme reaction. Therefore, a compromise is usually
Effect of Additional Membranes
necessary. This is especially important for the am-
monia and carbon dioxide electrodes. For ammonia Besides the enzymatic reacting layer, many biosen-
electrochemical sensors, samples should have a pH sors, especially designed for biological or clinical
524 ION-SELECTIVE ELECTRODES / Enzyme Electrodes
Others, such as penicillinase, will promote the re- nonactin, a neutral carrier, as the base sensor, together
action of many substrates. Thus, ampicillin, naficillin, with immobilized urease in a polyacrylic gel was used.
penicillin G, penicillin V, cyclibillin, and dicloxacillin
Creatinine
can be determined with a penicillinase electrode.
D- and L-amino acid oxidases are even less selective. Creatinine is another diagnostic indicator of kidney
The former, when coupled to an electrode, responds function. Creatinine can be measured immobilizing
to D-phenylalanine, D-alanine, D-valine, D-methionine, purified creatininase (reaction [II]) onto nylon net
D-leucine, D-norleucine, and D-isoleucine, while the and coupling it with an ammonia gas electrode:
latter responds to L-leucine, L-tyrosine L-phenylala-
! NH3 þ creatine
Creatininase
nine, L-tryptophan, and methionine. Creatinine ½II
For samples containing several substrates, a prelimi- The residual ammonia of blood serum can be
nary separation should be considered or the total must removed using an enzyme reactor system, consisting
be determined. In the case of L-amino acid assay the of soluble NADPH and a-ketoglutarate, with gluta-
use of decarboxylating enzymes acting selectively on mate dehydrogenase immobilized on nylon tubes; this
different amino acids is an attractive possibility, and system is effective in removing 98% of the ammonia
enzyme electrodes of this type are known for L-tyro- present in human blood and urine samples in 50 s. The
sine, L-phenylalanine, and L-tryptophan. These sensors entire process was carried out in a single flow stream.
will be coupled with a carbon dioxide base sensor.
Enzyme inhibitors also need to be taken into ac- Glucose and Sugar Electrodes
count. These include heavy metal ions, such as silver, An iodide-selective electrode can be used to measure
mercury, and sulfydryl-reacting organic compounds, glucose concentration. The measurement is based on
such as p-chloromercuribenzoate (due to their reac- reactions catalyzed by glucose oxidase (GOx) (reac-
tion with the free S–H groups at the active site of tion [III]) and peroxidase (POx) (reaction [IV]):
many enzymes, especially the oxidases).
! gluconic acid þ H2 O2
GOx
Glucose þ O2 ½III
Examples of Enzyme Electrodes þ POx
H2 O2 þ 2I þ 2H ! 2H2 O þ I2 ½IV
Based on ISEs
The highly sensitive iodide sensor monitors the de-
Table 1 lists enzyme electrodes that have been pre-
crease in the iodide activity at the electrode surface.
pared for analysis of common substrates together
The assay of glucose was performed both in a stream
with the enzyme used, the sensor, and the range of
and at a stationary electrode. Pretreatment of the blood
concentrations determinable. The most important
sample was required to remove interfering reducing
features of some of these are described here.
agents such as ascorbic acid, tyrosine, and uric acid.
Urea Moreover, pH electrodes can be used to detect the
gluconic acid formed by the GOx reaction.
Urea is a diagnostic indicator for kidney function.
Urea can be potentiometrically determined following Amino Acids
the enzymatic reaction of the enzyme urease (reac- Enzyme electrodes have been widely used for the assay
tion [I]) coupled with a variety of potentiometric of amino acids in clinical analysis since several amino
transducers such as the pCO2 electrode, the pNH3 acids (tyrosine, phenylalanine, tryptophan, methio-
electrode, the pH electrode, and the pNH4 electrode: nine) are important diagnostic health indicators.
The transducer can be an ammonium ISE ionophore
H2 N2CO2NH2 þ H2 O ! CO2 þ 2NH3
Urease
½I (nonactin-based), a gas sensor for ammonia or carbon
dioxide, and an iodide-selective sensor. The latter can
The products of the enzymatic reaction given above be coupled with the enzymes L-aminooxidase (L-AOx)
also dissociate: and peroxidase (e.g., coimmobilized in a polyacryl-
amide gel), which catalyses reactions [V] and [VI]:
CO2 þ H2 O2HCO
3 þH
þ
NH3 þ H2 O2NHþ
4 þ OH ! H2 O2 þ other products
L-AOx
L-Phenylalanine ½V
The first urea electrode was prepared in 1969 by þ POx
H2 O2 þ 2I þ 2H ! 2H2 O þ I2 ½VI
immobilizing urease in a polyacrylamide matrix on
nylon or Dacron nets. These nets were then placed Specific sensors for phenylalanine, tyrosine, gluta-
onto a glass cation-selective electrode. To improve the mine, lysine, and methionine have been described in
selectivity, an ammonium-ion selective electrode with the literature.
526 ION-SELECTIVE ELECTRODES / Clinical Applications
Clinical Applications
U E Spichiger-Keller, Centre for Chemical Sensors and the recognition process. Fiber optical sensors have
Chemical Information Technology, Zurich, Switzerland been developed in response to the need for selective,
& 2005, Elsevier Ltd. All Rights Reserved. reliable sensors for medical use, especially for pa-
tient-near offline or continuous in vivo monitoring,
This article is reproduced from the first edition, pp. 2341–2353,
& 1995, Elsevier Ltd., with revisions made by the Editor. related to the problems inherent in electrochemical
methods. Also, optical test kits for blood ions
are commercially available. However, electrodes of-
fer a broad field of applications in patient-near-moni-
Introduction toring as well as in large automated biochemistry
An ion-selective electrode (ISE) is a chemical sensor analyzers.
that can quantitatively and reversibly measure an ion Ion-selective electrodes introduced in chemical
activity based on a potentiometric transduction of instruments are most frequently based on liquid