Unit 5 Family Influences
Unit 5 Family Influences
Deprivation
Trauma
Neglect
Abuse
Attachment
Separation
Inadequate parenting style
e Marital discord
Divorce
Maladaptive peer relations
Communication style
Family burden
Emotional adaptation
Expressed emotion and relapse
Deprivation Spa
Bowlby used the term maternal deprivation to refer to the
separation or loss of the mother as wellas failure to develop an
attachment.
Bowlby used the term maternal deprivation' to refer to separation
from an attached figure, loss of an attached figure and failure to
develop an attachment to any igurey. These each have different
effects, argued Rutter. Inparticular Rutter distinguished between
privation and deprivation.
Michael Rutter (1981)Areued that if achild fails to develop
an attachmentthis is privatíon, whereas deprivation refers to the
loss of or damage to an attachment.
Depri vation might be defined as losing something in which a
person once had, whereas privation might be defined as never
having something in the first place,
Privation 0ccurs when there is afailure to form an attachment to
any individual,
carers (which wasperhaps
because the child has a series of different
the case for many of Bowlby's juvenile thieves)
or family
discord prevents the development of attachment to any
figure (as Rutter proposed).
when separated from afamiliarPrivated children do not show distress
figure, which indicates alack of
attachment.
From his survey
su of research on
likely to lead initially to clinging,privatior, Rutter proposedthat it is
attention-seeking andindiscriminatedependent behavior,
matures, an inability to keep rules, formfriendliness,
lasting
then as the child
evidence of anti-social relationships,
feel guilt. He also found Or
affectionless psychopathy, and disorders of language,behavior,
Rutter arguesdevelopment and physical growh. intellectual
that these problems are not due solely tothe lack of
tOa mother figure, as attachment
Bowlby claimed, but to factorS such as the lack
intellectua! stimulation and social experiences which of
provide. In addition, such problems can be attachments normally
development,with the right kind of care. overcome later in the child's
Manyof the 44 thieves in
childhood, and had probablyBowlby' sstudy had been moved around alot during
never formed an attachment. This
they were suffering from suggested that
privation, rather than
suggested was far more deleterious to the deprivation, which Rutter
study on the long term effects of children. This led to a very important
(1989). privation, carried out by Hodges and Tizard
Trauma
/their characteristics
the presence of other mental health conditions
prious exposure to traumatic events
thelype and characteristics of the event
Vtheir or events
background and lapproach to handling emotions
$ Emotional and
A person who has psychological
experienced responses
Denial
trauma may feel:
/Anger
Fear
Sadness
Shame
Confusion
anxiety
depression
INuiiuless
V Guilt
Hopelessness
Irritability
difficulty concentrating
They may have
they feel, or emotional outbursts, find it
the withdraw from others. difficult to cope with
traumatic event in their mind, areFlashbacks, where a perSon how
common, as are relives
Physícalan responses
Along with nightmares.
as:
emotional reaction, trauma can
heduacies cause physical
V digestive symptoms symptoms, such
/fatigue
racing heart
Sweating
/ feeling jumpy
J
Sometimes, a
someone feels person
as will also
may make it thoughto they areexperi
in aence
difficult sleep. hyperstatearousalof, or when
constant
alertness. This
JIndividuals may also go on to develop other mental health issues, such as
depression, anxiety,
causes of trauma:
/bullying
/ harassment
/physical, psychological, or sexual abuse
/ sexual assault
/ traffic collisions
/ childbirth
/ life threatening illnesses
/ sudden loss of a loved one
/ being attacked
Vbeing kidnapped
acts of terrorism
/natural disasters
/war
Traumatic events can be isolated or repeated, ongoing events. A person can
also experience trauma after witnessing something traumatichappening to
Someone else.
People have different reactions to traumatic events. For example, those who
live through the same natural disaster can respond very differently despite
experiencing the same event.
inter-generational trauma is defined as a traumatic event that began yearS prior
which individuals
to the current generation and has impacted the ways in
For exampBe, the
within a family understand, cope with, and heal from trauma.
mental health
patriarch of a family may suffer from an untreated severe
behaviors toward his daughter.
disorder which causes him to engage in harmful
This daughter, having endured years of emotional and psychological abuse,
now has her own amily but has not
been able to release herself
and emotionally) from the torture she endured. As a result,
(psychologically patriarch which leads
same behaviors of the
She begins toexhibit many of the These behaviors, including
exhibiting similar behaviors.
to her ownchildren generations. These unhealthy
of coping, continue for
aystunctional ways raising children within the family.
a "nomal" way of
behaviors then become
lntengeneational trauma can negatively impact families as aresult of:
V
V Unnesolved emotions and thoughts about a traumatic event
V Negative repeated patterns of
Untreatedor poorly treated behavior including beliefs about
VPoor
V parent -chi ld relationshios emotional attachment
and
par ent
substance abuse or severe mental illness ing
Compl icat ed
Content attitudepersonal ity traits or personality disorders
with the ways things are within the
family
Neglect
Neglect, also referred to as
relaies specifically to a neglection, describes
for. ver's failure to meetmithestreatment
person they provide carecaregi and
chiwhenldren,it neglect can also referThough most basic needs of the
cOmes to elder care. to the often associated with
People who have been through mistreatment of acults. especial y
attachment
law issues, feelings of neglect may be more likely to
care,requi res
and caregiversto to proviisdoleataiochild'
n, anxiety, and experience
depression.
" Incaregiver supervi
many
does sion the degree that it food, shelter,
not meet these keeps
s
them cl
safe. othing, health
ways, abuse and needs, they are When a
treatment of
and dependent individuals, considered
neglect are similar; both negligent.
involve the care and
lasting
distinct negative effects for their harmful
differences victims. behaviors from caregivers,
between the two that However,
impact how eachthereis are some
The Child
Prot
intentioionalnallharmecti v e Servi ces
y, knowito ang1y, or recklessiy causidefines
Law (CPSL) addressed.
emot child abuse as
child,
includes harm, sexualeither by acting or failing ng pilysictoai, sexual, or
the other bodilyhand, may not alwaysexplbeoitation, or mental act. Abuse
declining physical health of a intentional. For exampl injury. Neglect, on
e, the
unindinvtiedntualional's ly neglect their children. Or, in thecausecasethemof to
caregiver could
ithem to deteriorating mental state
neglect elder neglect, an
brought
TYPES OF NEGLECTself-care without realizing it.
on by aging
may lead
there are four main types:
1 Physical: Failure to provide necessities like food, shelter, clothing,
standard medical care, supervision, and safety.
2. Educational: Failure to ensure school age children are enrolled in school,
home schooled, or provided specialized educational training where
appropriate.
3. Emotional: Failure to attend to psychological care and emotional needs.
4, Medical: Failure to allow for necessary medical treatment recommended
bymedical professionals; depending on the state, this may also include
mental health treatment.
The National Adult Protective Services Association (ÑAPSA) outlines
the following types of adult or elderly neglect:
I. Physical: Failure to meet the medical, hygienic, or dietary needs
necessary to an individual's physical health.
I. Emotional: Failure to accommodate or account for an individual's
emouonai weii-being by beiiing, ignoring, ur prevening then1 íron1
seeing family or friends.
III.Abandonment: Failure to fulfillcaregiver duties by forsaking expected
responsibilities or failing to arrange for care in the case of caregiver
absence.
IV. Financial: Failing to fulfil financial obligations, like paying
utilities and rent, to ensure the stability and safety of an individual.
V. Self-neglect: Failure of seniors and adults to meet their own physical,
psychological, emotional, and financial needs to the point that their
safety and well-being are threatened.
Abuse
another human being
Abuse refers to harmtul or injurious reatment ot
psychological/emotional,
that may include physical, sexual, verbal, coexist with neglect,
intellectual, or spiritual maltreatment. Abuse may
dependent person's basic physical
which is defined as failure to meet a
and/or desertion. Neglect is
and medical needs, emotional deprivation,
sometimes described as passive abuse.
Attachment
Results: The monkeys engaged in bizarre behavior such as clutching their own
bodies and rocking compulsively. They were then placed back in the company
of other monkeys.
To start with the babies were scared of the other monkeys, and then became
very aggressive towards them. They were also unable to communicate or
socializc with other monkeys. The other monkeys bullied thcm. They indulged
in self-mutilation, tearing hair out, scratching, and
biting their own arms and
legs.
Harlow concluded that privation (i.e., never forming an
permanently damaging (to monkeys). The extent of the abnormal attachment bond) is
reflected the length of the isolation. Those kept in behavior
were the least affected, but those in isolation for three months
isolation for a year never recovered the
effects of privation.
2. Infant monkeys reared with
from their mothers immediatelysurrogate mothers - &monkeys were
after birth and placed in cages with separated
wire and one covered in soft terTyaccess
two surrogate mothers, one made of to
cloth. toweling
Four of the monkeys could get milk
from the wire mother and four from the
cloth mother. The animals were
studied for 165 days.
Both groups of monkeys spent more
had no milk). The infant time with the cloth mother (even if
would only go to the wire mother she
Once fed it would return to the when hungry.
cloth mother for moSt of the day. If
frightening object was placed in the cage the infant took
a
mother (its safe base). refuge with the cloth
This surrOgate was more effective in decreasing the youngsters fear. The intant
would explore more when the cloth mother was
present.
This supports the evolutionary theory of attachment, in that it is
the sensitive
response and security of the caregiver that is important (as
provision of food). opposed to the
The behavioral differences that Harlow
had groWn up with surrogate mothers and
observed between the monkeys wh0
those with normal mothers were;
a) They were much more timid.
b)They didn't know how to act with
other monkys.
c) They were easily bullied and
wouldn'tstand up for themselves.
d) They had difficulty with
mating,
e) The females were
inadequate mothers.
Harlow concluded that for a monkey to develop
interactionwith an object to which they can clingnomally s/he must have some
during the first months of
life (critical period).
Clinging is a natural response - in times of stress the monkey runs
to which it normally clings as if the to the object
clinging decreases thestress.
He also concluded that early maternal
but that its impact could be reversed indeprivation leads to emotional damage
monkeys if an attachment was made
before the end of the critical period.
However, if maternal deprivation lasted after the end of the critical
no amount of exposure to mothers or peers could alter the period, then
that had already occuned. emotional damage
Harlow found therefore that it was social deprivation rather than
matermal
deprivation that the young monkeys were suffering from.
Mary Ainsworth and the "Strange Situation"
During the 1970's, psychologist Mary Ainsworth conducted further research
into John Bowlbys attachment theory in a study that came to be known as
the
strange situation".The study involved observing children between the ages of
12 to 18 months responding to asituation in which they were briefly left alone
and then reunited with their caregiver (Hutchinson, 2009).
Based on these observations, Ainsworth concluded that there were three major
Styles of attachment: secbre attachment, ambivalent-insecure attachment,, and
avoidant-insecure attachment (Ainsworth, 2009). Afourth style was
by Ainsworth's colleague Mary Main with Ainsworth's approval. ,added late
he fist style is "'secure attachmenf". A childin this category willexplore
teely while the caregiver is present. This includes engaging strangers.
However, when the caregiver leaves the child, it becomes visibly upset and
stops interacçng with the stranger. When the caregiver comes back, the child
calms down and starts interacting again.
The secondstyle is "anxious-resistant insecure attachment." Thiscategory is
more dramatic. Even when the caregiver is present, the child is anxious when a
Stranger is around, and becomes upset when the caregiver leaves. When the
caregiver returns,the child is resentful and resistant to attention.
The third style is anxious-avoidant insecure
he benavioi äTsUciated wiui çis styie acis
attachment. Achild who exhibits
indinierent io aiyoie
strangers and the caregiver alike are ignored and receive little pltscit, iie
represents a disengaged relationship between thechild and attention. This
(Ainsworth, 2009). caregiver
The last style is
style often have "disorganized/disoriented attachment" Children
caregivers that experienced something traumatic exhibiting this
that left them suffering from depression. The after the birth
will usualy cry when the caregiver leaves, anddisorganized/disoriented child
then freeze or fall to the floor
when the caregiver returns. When strangers are
upset and confused.
present, the child is slightly
Dollard and Miller (1950)suggested that the attachment was due to drive
reduction. Hunger and cold have a strong motivating affect on the child,
driving the child to satisfy its need by eating or seeking warmth. Obtaining
reward for
food or warmth results in drive reduction which in itself provides
the child.
as primary drives and foad and
Hunger and cold (discomfort) are referred tosupplying
primary reinforcers. The person the food and warmth
warmth are with the food and warmth and acts as
(usually the mother) becomes associated the child wants the
attachment occurs because
a secondary reinforcer. The warmth.
person providing the food and
child is cold and hungry it cries. This is unpleasant for the
Note: When the child
is likely tofeed and cuddle the child. The
mother (punishment) whonegative reinforcer for the mother (something
Stopping crying acts as away). Negative reinforcers make the mother's
a
unpleasant has been taken
behaviouw, fecding and cuddling, more likely in future!
In both classical and operant explanations the
attachment is formed
chld secks the person providing the food.
Evaluaion
because the
Anmumber of studies tell us that food is not relevant to
attachment formation:
Glasgow Babies: the infants form their primary
though in many cases she was absent for much ofattachment with mum even
would be providing the food. the day andother people
Separation
Effects of separation
Robertson & Bowlby [1952] believed that short- term separation from an
attachment figure leads to distress. They formed three progressive stages of
distress [PDD model]:/
Protest
V Child cries, screams and protests angrily when parent leaves.
V They will try to cling on the parent to stop.
Despair
V Child appear to be calmer but still upset.
V Often seems withdrawn and uninterested in anything.
Detachment
V Child engage with others.
V Reject the caregiver on return and show anger.
4J TIEIVESSTUDY
ICD -DISORDER SEPARATION ANXIETY
MODELS:
/Psychodynamic
Focus areas:
Emotional relationship
Unidirectional model
Attitudes
Atitudes (Parental attribute)-
emotional relationships betweenInividual differences in the
Emotional tenor of the family milieuparents and children spor
parent-child
(Baldwin, relationship and that
determines lavi
Flaw of the theory: influences the child's the
measuring behaviour.There1948;is no0rlmeans
ansky, of1949; Schaefer,the development
1959;
studying attitude Symonds, 1939)
/
> MOLAR LEVEL (Schaefer
without
Particular (1959)
categories pract
on theices were grouped
of their conceptually into
processes. (Baldwibasis potential to alter broader
n, 1948; Orlansky, emoti&onal
1949; Schaefer
Bell,
1958; Symonds, 1939).
/ Punitive-ness
/Autonomy granting
V Expression of
affection
Using fear to control
/ Ignoring
/ Child as a burden
/ LEARNING MODEL
/
Focused on parental practices rather than attitudes.
/ Differences in child development reflect
differences in the learning
environment (Sears, Maccoby, &Levin, 1957: Whiting &Child, 1953)
EXAMPLES: practices such as use of physical punishment, tolerance of
masturbation, sanctions against aggression, failure to enforce rules, and rules
for use of common living areas.
V LjVE-jR0ENIED VIS ÜBJECI-OR*E0NTED STYLES
Lincerstanding narents
rational
Yes Do not exert
sufficient
cognitive effort to
understand their parents'
actions