Lec 03 Words
Lec 03 Words
Word Meaning
Francis Bond
Division of Linguistics and Multilingual Studies
http://www3.ntu.edu.sg/home/fcbond/
bond@ieee.org
Lecture 3
https://bond-lab.github.io/Semantics-and-Pragmatics/
Creative Commons Attribution License: you are free to share and adapt
as long as you give appropriate credit and add no additional restrictions:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
HG2002 (2021)
Overview
HG2002 (2021) 1
Revision:
Meaning, Thought and
Reality
HG2002 (2021) 2
Referential View
Speaker Refer
Say
Expression Referent
Denote
HG2002 (2021) 3
Representational View
Refer Concept
Speaker
Denote Represent
Say
Expression Referent
HG2002 (2021) 4
Two types of naming
ã The description theory: Names are like short hands for de-
scriptions:
William Shakespeare = “the playwright who wrote Hamlet”
HG2002 (2021) 5
Mental Representations
ã Introduce concepts
â Represented by Necessary and Sufficient Conditions
â Prototypes
∗ Concepts are organized in groups around a prototype
∗ These have typical members (remembered as exemplars)
∗ prototypes have characteristic features
∗ Some categories (concepts) seem to be more psycholog-
ically basic than others: basic level categories
HG2002 (2021) 6
What is Deixis
HG2002 (2021) 7
Spatial Deixis
HG2002 (2021) 9
Social Deixis
HG2002 (2021) 10
Linguistic Relativity
ã The idea behind linguistic relativity is that this will effect how
you think
HG2002 (2021) 11
Word Meaning
HG2002 (2021) 12
Defining word
HG2002 (2021) 13
ã Why do we need a definition for word?
Psychological reality People can divide language into words
Phonological contours People pronounce words as unit
Orthographic practice Many languages put spaces between
words (although this practice only began around 600 CE for
Latin, and did not spread to all European languages until as
late as the 1600s)
â Some put them between phrases (Korean)
â Some words include spaces New York, ad hoc
HG2002 (2021) 14
Bloomfield’s grammatical definition
HG2002 (2021) 15
Problems with defining
word meaning
HG2002 (2021) 16
Definitional Semantics
HG2002 (2021) 17
Definitional Semantics: pros and cons
ã Pros:
â familiarity (we are taught to use dictionaries)
ã Cons:
â subjectivity in sense granularity (splitters vs. lumpers) and def-
inition specificity
â circularity in definitions
â consistency, reproducibility, …
â often focus on diachronic (historical) rather than synchronic
(current) semantics
HG2002 (2021) 18
Starting at the Beginning ...
19
Distinguishing Polysemes
HG2002 (2021) 20
Lexical Relations
HG2002 (2021) 21
Words/Concepts are related in many ways
ã Hyponymy/Hypernemy
ã Synonymy
ã Antonymy (Opposites)
ã Meronymy
â Member-Collection
â Portion-Mass
â Element-Substance
HG2002 (2021) 22
Hypernymy and Hyponymy
HG2002 (2021) 23
Properties of hypernymy/hyponymy
ã Asymmetric
ã applies only to lexical items of the same word class
ã applies at the sense level
ã Transitive: dog1 ⊂ mammal1 ⊂ animal1
ã Not all nodes are lexicalized
neutral (Hyper) male −balls female child
sheep ram wether ewe lamb
cow bull steer cow calf
goose gander goose gosling
snake
horse stallion gelding mare foal: colt/filly
ã Can you do this for pig, cat or chicken? ?
ã Can you give an example of this in another language? ?
HG2002 (2021) 24
Synonymy
HG2002 (2021) 25
Near Synonymy
HG2002 (2021) 26
ã Permissible differentiation via clarification:
Here is a grain, or granule, of the substance.
* The cover is green, {or,that is to say} purple.
and contrast:
Here is a grain or, more exactly, granule
* He likes alsations, or more exactly, spaniels
HG2002 (2021) 27
Properties of synonymy
ã Symmetric
ã ≈ converse of polysemy
HG2002 (2021) 28
Antonymy (opposites)
(6) dead/alive
(7) pass/fail
(8) boiling/hot/warm/tepid/cool/cold/freezing
(9) like HG2002/fascinating/interesting/dull/boring/
(10) ascend/descend
HG2002 (2021) 29
(11) up/down; right/left
(14) Monday/Tuesday/…/Sunday
in WordNet: day of the week ⊃ weekday, weekend
(15) LMS/English/Chinese/…
Context dependent
HG2002 (2021) 30
Meronymy
HG2002 (2021) 31
Member-Collection
(16) tree–forest
(17) sheep–flock
(18) fish–school
(19) book–library
(20) member–band
(21) musician–orchestra
(22) student–class
HG2002 (2021) 32
Portion-Mass
(23) drop–liquid
(24) grain–sand/salt/truth
(25) sheet/ream–paper
(26) lump–coal (or just about anything)
(27) strand–hair
(28) rasher–bacon
HG2002 (2021) 33
Domain (lexical field)
35
Wordnet
HG2002 (2021) 36
WordNet
HG2002 (2021) 38
Psycholinguistic Foundations of WordNet
39
Word Meaning as a Graph
entity
instrument agent
HG2002 (2021) 41
Synonyms for a dead Parrot
From the “Dead Parrot Sketch”, also known as the “Pet Shop
Sketch” or “Parrot Sketch”, originally in Monty Python’s Flying Cir-
cus, first performed in the eighth episode of the show’s first series,
”Full Frontal Nudity” (7 December 1969).
HG2002 (2021) 42
Derivational Relations
HG2002 (2021) 43
Diathesis Alternations
ã Causative/inchoative alternation:
Kim broke the window ↔ The window broke
also the window is broken (state)
ã Conative alternation:
Kim hit the door ↔ Kim hit at the door
Levin (1993) 44
Diathesis Alternations and Verb Classes
Levin (1993) 45
ã Corollary: we can predict the syntax of novel words we are
given the semantic class for
Levin (1993) 46
Agentive Nouns
47
Agentive Nouns in Other Languages
HG2002 (2021) 50
Color Terms
See also: http://wals.info/chapter/133: Colour Terms by Paul Kay and Luisa Maffi 51
Core Vocabulary
en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Appendix:Swadesh_list 52
I, You, we, this, that, who, what, not, all, many, one, two, big,
long, small, woman, man, person, fish, bird, dog, louse, tree,
seed, leaf, root, bark, skin, flesh, blood, bone, grease, egg, horn,
tail, feather, hair, head, ear, eye, nose, mouth, tooth, tongue,
claw, foot, knee, hand, belly, neck, breasts, heart, liver, drink, eat,
bite, see, hear, know, sleep, die, kill, swim, fly, walk, come, lie, sit,
stand, give, say, sun, moon, star, water, rain, stone, sand, earth,
cloud, smoke, fire, ash(es), burn, path, mountain, red, green, yel-
low, white, black, night, hot, cold, full, new, good, round, dry,
name
en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Appendix:Swadesh_list 53
Natural Semantic Meta Language
X feels unhappy=
sometimes a person thinks something like this:
something bad happened to me
I don’t want this
if I could, I would do something
because of this, this person feels something bad
X feels like this
Wierzbicka (1996) 54
The Semantic Primitives
HG2002 (2021) 55
Acknowledgments and References
ã Images from
â the Open Clip Art Library: http://openclipart.org/
â Steven Bird, Ewan Klein, and Edward Loper (2009) Natural
Language Processing with Python, O’Reilly Media
www.nltk.org/book
HG2002 (2021) 56
*
References
Francis Bond and Ryan Foster. 2013. Linking and extending an open mul-
tilingual wordnet. In 51st Annual Meeting of the Association for Com-
putational Linguistics: ACL-2013, pages 1352–1362. Sofia. URL http:
//aclweb.org/anthology/P13-1133.
HG2002 (2021) 57
Francis Bond and Ryan Lim Dao Wei. 2019. Generating derivational relations
for the Japanese wordnet: The case of agentive nouns. In 2019 Pacific
Neighborhood Consortium Annual Conference and Joint Meetings (PNC),
pages 1–7.
Tuan Anh Le, David Moeljadi, Yasuhide Miura, and Tomoko Ohkuma. 2016.
Sentiment analysis for low resource languages: A study on informal Indone-
sian tweets. In Proceedings of The 12th Workshop on Asian Language Re-
sources, page 123–131. Osaka.
Beth Levin. 1993. English Verb Classes and Alternations. University of Chicago
Press, Chicago, London.
HG2002 (2021) 58
Hazel Shuwen Mok, Eshley Huini Gao, and Francis Bond. 2012. Generating
numeral classifiers in Chinese and Japanese. In Proceedings of the 6th
Global WordNet Conference (GWC 2012). Matsue. 211-218.
Luís Morgado da Costa and Francis Bond. 2016. Wow! what a useful extension
to wordnet! In 10th International Conference on Language Resources and
Evaluation (LREC 2016). Portorož.
Luís Morgado da Costa, Francis Bond, and František Kratochvíl. 2016. Linking
and disambiguating Swadesh lists: Expanding the open multilingual word-
net using open language resources. In GLOBALEX 2016: Lexicographic
Resources for Human Language Technology (Workshop at LREC 2016).
Portorož.
HG2002 (2021) 59
Puzzles with WordNet. Final year project, Linguistics and Multilingual Stud-
ies, Nanyang Technological University.
HG2002 (2021) 60