Commerce Project
Commerce Project
It launched a program called Classmate Ideas for India challenge. This was a
part of the company's centenary initiative. The nationwide program would invite
ideas of the youth who have the potential to transform India. Classmate Ideas
for India challenge plans to reach out to 2.5 million students across 30 cities,
500 schools and 200 colleges across the country. The CII-ITC Centre of
Excellence for Sustainable Development, WWF India, the Tony Blair Faith
Foundation, Janaagraha and the Akshaya Patra Foundation among others are the
program partners for the event. The program will encourage the finalists with an
internship with relevant program partners, besides cash prizes and other
rewards.
Faber-Castell [Introduction]
Faber-Castell AG is a manufacturer of pens, pencils, other office
supplies (e.g., staplers, slide rules, erasers, rulers) and art supplies, as well as
high-end writing instruments and luxury leather goods. Headquartered in Stein,
Germany, it operates 14 factories and 20 sales units throughout the globe. The
Faber-Castell Group employs a staff of approximately 8,000 and does business
in more than 120 countries. The House of Faber-Castell is the family which
founded and continues to exercise leadership within the corporation. Faber-
Castell manufactures about 2 billion pencils in more than 120 different colours
every year.
Faber-Castell was founded in 1761 in Stein, Germany, by cabinet maker Kaspar
Faber (1730–1784) as the A.W. Faber Company. It has remained in the Faber
family for eight generations. The company expanded under Kaspar Faber's
great-grandson, Johann Lothar Freiherr von Faber (1817–1896), and his wife,
Ottilie Lothar opened branches in New York (1849), London (1851), Paris
(1855), and expanded into Vienna (1872) and St. Petersburg (1874). The
company also began offering products other than pencils, opening a factory
in Geroldsgrün, Bavaria, where slide rules were produced, a slate factory
in Geroldsgrün, and producing ink and paint in Noisy-le-Sec, near Paris.
In 1898, Lothar's granddaughter and heiress, Ottilie "Tilly" von Faber, married
Count Alexander zu Castell-Rüdenhausen, and the couple became progenitors
of the Faber-Castell family. Seven years later, the company began producing a
new line of pencils, called "Castell"; over the next few years, this line developed
recognizable branding, featuring the green colour of the pencils (chosen to
match the colour of Alexander's military regiment), a logo depicting a castle,
and the motif of two jousting knights, which was used on packaging and in
advertising. This motif originated with a painting, commissioned by Alexander,
of two knights jousting with pencils, and would eventually become the
inspiration behind the company's current logo. 1908 saw the release of the
Polychromos coloured pencils, which continue to be made and widely used
today.
MARKETING MIX
Marketing mix is defined by the use of a marketing tool that combines a number
of components in order to harden and solidify a product’s brand and to help in
selling the product or service. The marketing mix, also known as the four P's of
marketing, which refers to the four key elements of a marketing strategy:
Product, Price, Place and Promotion.
PRODUCT
Products are commodities and services that solve problems and satisfy the needs
of consumers. A product can be tangible (clothes, vehicles, etc.) or intangible
(services like house cleaning, etc.) The type of product impacts its perceived
value, which allows companies to price it profitably.
PRICE
Price is the cost of a product or service. Price is the cost of the product that the
consumer pays. Price is the most critical element of a marketing plan because it
dictates a company’s survival and profit.
The price should be set up in such a way that it is affordable for the customers
and yet profitable for the business. Pricing can have a significant impact on the
overall success of a product.
For example, if you price your product too high for your targeted audience, then
very few of them will likely purchase it. Similarly, if you price your product too
low, then some might pass it up simply because they are concerned it might be
of inferior quality. To determine a profitable price for your product, it is
important to determine the target audience and the price they are willing to pay
for your product.
PLACE
Place involves choosing the place where products are to be made available for
sale. The primary motive of managing trade channels is to ensure that the
product is readily available to the customer at the right time and place. Alike
price, finding the right place to market and sell your product is a key factor in
reaching your target audience.
Digital transformation has evolved how products are sold -- online, small local
shops or global producers. If you put your product in a place that your target
customer doesn’t visit—whether online or offline— then you will likely not
meet your sales target.
To determine the best place to market and sell the product is by researching the
digital and physical places the target audience views and consumes information.
PROMOTION
Promotion is the main force in the marketing mix as it publicises the product
and makes it popular among the masses. Many companies incur losses due to
insufficient or bad advertising.
PRODUCT
Classmate offers a wide variety of stationery items starting from the best quality
notebooks to pencils, pens, mathematical instruments, erasers, sharpeners and
art stationery.
Their notebooks comes in various designs and themes. Each cover has a theme
on it and information related to that particular theme on the inside. With Ozone-
treated, elemental chlorine free paper, their notebooks and environment friendly
and provides improved quality and shelf life. Classmate Pulse is a new range of
notebooks that comes with stylish, vibrant, and trendy covers suitable for youth.
From Marvel to 3D covers, you can explore a variety of cover designs that
satiates the thirst for knowledge. Catering to the Gen Z, Classmate Pulse
notebook, with all its exquisite features, is a notebook that defines a generation.
You can also customise your own cover page by going to their official website,
selecting your specifications regarding the notebook, adding the picture you
want in your cover page and making the online payment. They deliver these
notebooks to the given address as soon as possible.
Classmate’s Geometry Box is made to provide precision and perfection. With
its die-casted metal instruments and self-centering mechanism, it gives you
maximum accuracy while you draw. Available in various designs, Classmate
Geometry Box stands as your ideal choice for drawings and measurements. It is
also the only brand which provides a mechanical pencil in its geometry box
which attracts customers and increases the sales rate.
PRICE
The objective of classmate is to maximise market share and for that they sell
their products at a reasonable price. According to the Nine Price Quality
Strategies Classmate follows a High Value strategy by providing high product
quality and charging a medium price for its products. They also keep a check on
the competitor cost and provide better quality products are prices almost the
same as its competitors.
Their pencils range from INR 3-40 per unit and pens from INR 5-20 per unit.
Their Classmate Octane Gel pen that costs Rs. 10 is one of the most famous
among students for its smooth writing and its Japanese waterproof ink, it also
comes in various colours to attract customers.
Their bestseller’s is their Stationery bag which consists of 12 of their products
including their notebooks, colours, pens, pencils, etc at Rs. 500. Their
notebooks are eco-friendly and their normal 200 pages long notebook costs Rs.
65 and their Classmate Pulse Notebook for 300 pages costs Rs. 120. Their
customised notebooks are also very reasonable as they provide 6 notebooks (at
least) at Rs. 431. They also provide regular discounts for customers.
PLACE
ITC has an unmatched distribution network. Its products are available in more
than 4 million retail stores in India. A strong distribution shows its marketing
mix place strategy. ITC is constantly trying to reduce the lead time and to make
the products reach to the retailers as quickly as possible.
Classmate’s products are targeted across rural and urban areas across the
country. They started their sales by selling their products in the rural areas first
but now they cover both the rural and urban areas.
Classmate products are distributed through multiple channels to maximize
accessibility. This includes traditional retail channels such as stationery stores,
supermarkets, and convenience stores and also wholesalers who sell the
products in bulk to consumers and other retailers.
Additionally, Classmate leverages online distribution channels through e-
commerce platforms like Amazon and Flipkart to reach a broader customer base
and facilitate convenient purchases.
PROMOTION
Classmate employs various promotional tactics to raise brand awareness and
stimulate demand for its products. Promotions are undertaken with the tagline
“You are one of a kind”. They use TV Advertisements, hoardings, posters and
banners, social media and newspaper to advertise their products and have
become India’s No. 1 notebook brand.
Early in its launch, Classmate understood the importance of traders as
influencers in over 75% of consumer purchase decisions. Trade members were
made brand ambassadors and were educated about the brand’s superiority,
instilling in them a sense of pride for selling the best product in the market.
Classmate quickly expanded its distribution footprint, gaining word of mouth in
trade and increasing consumer awareness of new launches. The brand relied
only on point of sale and other below-the-line advertising media to generate
consumer awareness for the first five years. Over the years, promotional
strategy evolved including traditional media like television, print, radio, cinema
and press. The brand steadily improved its brand salience and product
perception scores, outshining its closest competitors.
The brand has invested in marquee school contact programmes including
Classmate Young Author Contest and Classmate Spell Bee contest. Finishing its
tenth season in 2017-18, Classmate Spell Bee contest is the largest of its kind in
the country, reaching over 3.25 lac students in 30 cities and more than 1,000
schools.
PRODUCT
Faber-Castell is renowned for its diverse range of high-quality writing
instruments, art supplies, and office products. The company's product portfolio
includes classic wooden pencils, premium fountain pens, markers, colored
pencils, mechanical pencils, erasers, sharpeners, and various art supplies such as
paints, pastels, and sketching tools. Faber-Castell's products are known for their
durability, performance, and innovative features, making them a preferred
choice among artists, students, professionals, and enthusiasts worldwide.
They believe that every child develops at their own unique pace, which is why
they offer age recommendations for their products. The age recommendations
for children’s range (indicated by the red packaging) are listed on the relevant
packaging. The information is based on the average requirements and demands
of children in the relevant age class.
For “3+”, they take into account habitus and motor skills: infants initially pick
up objects and pencils in the fist or cross-grip. To suit this gripping position,
they make crayons that are conducive to the first simple drawing movements.
Their products comply with the international ISO standards 12757-2 (ballpoint
pens), 14145-2 (rollerball pens) and ISO/DIS 27688-2 (GEL pens). The
standards define the behaviour of the stroke under the influence of precisely
defined chemicals or testing methods, which can be used in a counterfeiting
process. The key thing is that writing cannot be removed without visible traces.
PRICE
Faber-Castell products are excellent in quality and are available at surprisingly
affordable prices. The pricing strategy varies from product to product depending
on its type, quantity and size. The brand adopts market penetration strategy to
cater to a wide array of customers from professionals, children and artists.
Their art products are their bestsellers and their normal connector pen set which
contains 25 colours costs Rs. 150. They also sell sustainable crayons and add 2
free crayons to attract customers. Their wooden pencil set (pack of 10) costs Rs.
60 and contains a free sharpener in it as well.
Some of its products may be priced higher than those of competitors, customers
perceive the value in Faber-Castell's reliability, performance, and longevity. The
company's pricing strategy reflects its commitment to delivering exceptional
products and experiences, targeting consumers who prioritize quality over price.
To incentivize larger purchases and enhance customer loyalty, Faber-Castell
employs bundling and promotional pricing strategies. They may bundle related
products together, such as pencils, erasers, and sketchbooks, offering cost
savings compared to purchasing items individually.
They also offers various discounts to customers like seasonal discounts, cash
discounts, promotional discounts and discounts through quantity. The products
sold online are also available at a cheaper rate as compared to retail stores .
PLACE
Faber Castell being the huge brand it has its presence across the globe. It uses a
retailing and wholesaling method to penetrate different segments of a consumer
base. The product this brand offers can be found in bookstores, supermarkets,
stationery stores and mini markets. The company works with a network of retail
partners to showcase its products and provide customers with hands-on
shopping experiences. They also directly sells its items directly to its end user if
the order amount is big in quantity. The company uses a push strategy to induce
intermediaries to buy the product.
Faber Castell has its own distribution channel and hence are able to offer their
products at an unbelievably economic process. They also sell their products
online to increase market penetration. With the word moving to an online
platform all the products by this brand can be found in online websites like
Amazon, Itsy Bitsy, Flipkart, eBay, etc. which helps increase the consumer base
of the product and helps consumers globally to know about the products.
Faber-Castell also targets institutional customers such as schools, universities,
and businesses through its institutional sales division. The company offers bulk
discounts and customized solutions to meet the unique needs of institutional
buyers.
By leveraging a diverse range of distribution channels, Faber-Castell ensures
that its products are readily available to customers wherever they shop, thereby
maximizing its market reach and sales potential.
PROMOTION
Faber Castell uses traditional marketing strategies to promote its brand like
digital print, television, cinemas, newspaper, magazines, advertisement on
public transportation, billboards along the road, social networking site etc. It
also gives out free samples to people, twin packs, buy one get another item free
sort of strategies as its sale promotion means.
Faber-Castell is one of the industry’s oldest manufacturing brands and has
received several medals, awards, and exhibition certificates. Creativity and
innovation have been the company’s mantra, reflected in its products and all
its advertising strategic marketing campaigns.
With all the points noted, I personally would prefer Classmate over Faber-
Castell. Firstly, Classmate has a large variety of products which are durable and
sustainable and they offer all of them at a reasonable price and with regular
discounts. I personally am a very big fan of their notebooks and stationery
because they are user and pocket-friendly. Secondly, Classmate products are
easily accessible even in the smallest of retail shops whereas if I have to buy a
Faber-Castell product, I will have to visit a departmental store or a bigger
stationery shop. Classmate products are also available in loose whereas Faber-
Castell products usually come in packs and consumers have to buy the entire
pack even if it might not be completely useful for them and they will eventually
spend more as the products are also a little expensive.
That being said, Classmate and Faber-Castell both are leading brands in the
stationery world and are able to attract customers with their own products,
quality and marketing strategies. They both offer products that a person looks
for according to their needs.
PROJECT 2: SWOT ANALYSIS
MAMAEARTH
INTRODUCTION:
They started the business with an initial investment of around INR 90 lakh from
their own pockets. The brand became a massive hit in the market and has gained
over 1.5 million customers so far.
Mamaearth is under its parent entity Honasa Consumer Limited. Varun Alagh,
cofounder and CEO of Mamaearth, holds 34.30% stake in the company with a
total of 10,67,37,650 shares, as per its latest shareholding pattern. Ghazal
Alagh, the other promoter of the startup, holds 3.23% stake. Together, the
promoters and promoter group hold 37.60% stake.
The second biggest shareholder in the startup is venture capital firm Sequoia,
which holds a total of 24.01% stake. Sequoia holds 51, 60,000 equity shares or
19.48% stake in Honasa Consumer Limited through its SCI Investment VI fund.
The venture capital (VC) giant holds another 4.53% stake or 28, 50,900 shares
through its SCI Investment III fund.
On the other hand, Fireside Ventures Fund currently holds 10.39% stake or 18,
44,700 shares in the company. The other major shareholders in Honasa
Consumer Limited are Stellaris, with 9.5% stake; Sofina, with 9.49% stake;
Rishabh Harsh Mariwala, holding 2.93% stakes; and Evolvence India Fund III,
with 1.1% stake.
CAPTIAL:
They started the business with an initial investment of around INR 90 lakh from
their own pockets. 2 years back, in January 2022, while raising a $52 million
investment from Sequoia, Mamaearth was valued at $1.2 billion, exactly a year
later, the company is seeking a target market capitalization of $3 billion (about
Rs 24,000 crore) with the size of its IPO.
Honasa Consumer Ltd, the owner of the popular beauty and personal care
brand, is planning to launch Mamaearth IPO. It filed the Draft Red Herring
Prospectus (DRHP) for its IPO on December 30, 2022, with SEBI. It is planning
to raise Rs 400 crores from a fresh issue with a face value of Rs 10 each. The
company is looking to raise Rs 2,400 crore through the IPO.
Apart from this, promoters and other investors, and the brand ambassador
(Shilpa Shetty Kundra) are selling around 4.7 crore shares through an Offer for
Sale (OFS).
PROFITABILITY:
Ghazal and Varun Alagh-led D2C ecommerce unicorn Mamaearth turned
profitable in the financial year ending March 31, 2022. The startup, which
entered the unicorn club in earlier this year, posted a net profit of INR 19.8 Cr
on a standalone basis in FY22 as against a net loss of INR 1,332.2 Cr in FY21.
Mamaearth is also closing on touching the INR 1,000 Cr revenue mark. Its total
income rose 101% to INR 952.4 Cr in FY22 from INR 472.1 Cr in the previous
financial year. The Tiger Global-backed start-up’s revenue from operations rose
2X to INR 931.7 Cr from INR 459.9 Cr in FY21.
In FY24, Mamaearth wants to focus on improving its margin from 3.7% to 10-
15%, even if it means foregoing growth, say investors. The delayed IPO may
materialise next year. Mamaearth was last valued at $1.2 billion. It’s likely to
seek a valuation of $1.5-2 billion on listing, say investors and bankers.
Investment firm Sofina, which owns 9.5% in Mamaearth and is the largest
selling shareholder highlighted in the DRHP, won’t be satisfied with a limited
upside.
SWOT ANALYSIS
Strengths: These are the internal factors that give an organization a competitive
advantage. Some examples of strengths that a company may have are a strong
brand reputation, unique product features, low production costs, or a highly
skilled workforce.
Weaknesses: These are the internal factors that can put an organization at a
disadvantage. Examples of weaknesses that a company may have are poor
management, outdated technology, lack of innovation, or high debt levels.
Opportunities: These are the external factors that a company can take
advantage of to grow and expand. Examples of opportunities are market growth,
changes in customer preferences, emerging technologies, or a shift in
regulations.
Threats: These are the external factors that can negatively affect a company's
performance. Examples of threats are competition, economic downturns,
changes in consumer behaviour, or natural disasters.
It is important to note that the strengths and weaknesses are internal factors,
while opportunities and threats are external factors. A SWOT analysis can help
a company develop strategies that leverage its strengths and opportunities while
addressing its weaknesses and threats.
STRENGTH:
Social Responsibility:
Made safe certification: Mamaearth received the Made safe Award from
the American Non-Profit organisation and became the first Asian brand to
receive it.
WEAKNESS:
Pricing: Mamaearth's products are priced slightly higher compared to
other brands in the market. This may make it difficult for the brand to
attract price-sensitive consumers.
OPPOURTUNITIES:
THREAT:
The Mamaearth business model is strong and the company is poised for
long-term success. The company has a great product line-up, a solid
customer base, and is constantly innovating. Additionally, Mamaearth is
well-funded and has a bright future ahead.
The company's efficient manufacturing process and supply chain allow it
to keep costs low and pass on savings to its customers.
Additionally, Mamaearth’s focus on quality and safety sets it apart from
its competitors. Looking to the future, Mamaearth plans to continue
expanding its product range and reach more customers.