Report Kigongo Claire
Report Kigongo Claire
BY
KIGONGO CLARE
2017/FEB/MEMP/M222657/DIST/KYE
OF
NKUMBA UNIVERSITY
MAY 2018
i
DECLARATION
I, Kigongo Clare, declare that this dissertation is my own original work, and it has never been
presented to any University or Institution for the award of any academic qualification.
KIGONGO CLARE
2017/FEB/MEMP/M222657/DIST/KYE
ii
APPROVAL
This is to certify that this dissertation has been submitted with my approval as a supervisor.
Signature…………………………………………….Date…………………………………
SUPERVISOR
ii
DEDICATION
This piece of work is dedicated to my children Gloria, Michael, Charles, Maria and Mark
whose time of parenting was limited during the period of my studies, my late parents,
Ssaalongo and Nnaalongo Costantino Kyazze Nalumoso for the foundation and love for
education they instilled in me which is always pushing me to acquire more knowledge. Last
but not least, to my supervisor Dr. Simon Peter Ongodia who greatly encouraged and
supported me tirelessly during this research and the presentation of this dissertation. May
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
I am specifically delighted to thank my brothers, sisters and my relatives who have been my
rock through the hard times. My beloved friends; Mr. Ssaka Roberts, Mr. Ssekyambalo
Joseph, Mr. Balinda Kasim, Mr. Mabirizi Mohammed, Ms. Asaba Kamida and Hajji Lukooya
Ssekabira Abdul who have patiently endured the challenging times and born with all the
times we have gone through together, with a constant cheer; all of you have always
encouraged me greatly. My special thanks also go to my supervisor, Dr. Ongodia for his
encouragement, patience, good and professional guidance. I would also like to thank, my
classmates and lecturers at the university, who have been a source of continuous
encouragement and academic growth. I am indebted to all the people whose guidance made
this study a success. I would like to thank them here as I will not be able to mention all of
iv
Contents
DECLARATION ............................................................................................................................................II
APPROVAL ...................................................................................................................................................II
DEDICATION...............................................................................................................................................III
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.......................................................................................................................... IV
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES............................................................................................................ VII
ABBREVIATIONS / ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................ VII
ABSTRACT................................................................................................................................................ VIII
CHAPTER ONE............................................................................................................................................. 1
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................... 1
1.1 BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY ......................................................ERROR! BOOKMARK NOT DEFINED.
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE..................................................................................................................... 1
THEORETICAL PERSPECTIVE................................................................................................................. 3
v
3.8 DATA ANALYSIS .................................................................................................................................. 22
3.9 ETHICAL CONSIDERATIONS TAKEN INTO ACCOUNT............................................................... 22
REFERENCES ............................................................................................................................................. 39
APPENDICES .............................................................................................................................................. 40
APPENDIX 1: QUESTIONNAIRE FOR TEACHERS, STUDENTS, PARENTS, HEAD TEACHERS,
AND DIRECTOR OF STUDIES ................................................................................................................. 40
APPENDIX 1I: INTERVIEW SCHEDULE FOR TEACHERS, STUDENTS, PARENTS, HEAD
TEACHERS AND DIRECTORS OF STUDIES ......................................................................................... 43
vi
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES
ABBREVIATIONS / ACRONYMS
FY Financial Year
HM Headmaster
SH School
vii
ABSTRACT
The study was to examine the effect of school environment on students’ academic
performance in Girl child among Secondary school students of Mubende District. It was
guided by the following objectives; to establish how availability of good teachers influences
students’ academic performance in Girl child, to assess the effect of school environmental
factors on student’s performance in Girl child and to determine how adequacy of teaching
The study employed both qualitative and quantitative approaches. The Questionnaire was the
main instruments of data collection in addition to interview guide and document review. The
students’ academic performance. It was concluded that presence of human resources had
The study recommends school administrators too properly and appropriately plan for human
resources and scholastic materials in schools and also emphasize that timetables are
respected. Rewards need to be more pronounced and given enough awareness so as to enable
students comprehend them better. School timetables need to provide time for counseling and
offenders.
viii
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.0 Introduction
In this chapter the researcher will explore: background of the study, statement of the problem
Historical perspective
improving the population’s various skills as well as raising awareness on various issues of
government of Uganda through the Ministry of Education, Good, Technology and Sports
passed a policy compelling all secondary schools to make good subjects compulsory at
ordinary level. According to the DEO Mubende District, there has been an observed decline
This was in view of helping Uganda’s future generation to compete favorably with the rest of
the world in the field of industrialization and scientific development. In spite of the policy,
good subjects which include physics, Girl child, biology and mathematics, have been poorly
done (Bukenya, 2007). Muwonge (2008), reported that the failure rate in Girl child was at
66.8% in the O-level national examinations sat in 2007. Evidence from previous
1
examinations indicates that the situation was no better in all good subjects but more
This high failure rate in Girl child subject has raised many questions in the minds of students,
parents, teachers and the nation at large. The basic questions posed have been; is the students’
high failure rate due to teachers’ negative influence on the students (teacher’s capacity to
motivate students towards learning Girl child, teachers’ negative attitudes toward learners,
and teachers’ methods of teaching)? Could it be due to poor students’ personal motivations /
low intrinsic motivations towards study and academic achievements in Girl child subjects? Or
is it due to unfavorable learning environmental factors in schools, like the lack of laboratories
text books, and good teachers and a discourage record of failing in Girl child subject
(Wosijja, 2008).
According to the reactions of students’ after release of national results of secondary school
examinations, indicate that teachers have an influence on their performance (Atuhaire and
Kulubya, 2004). According to Arthur Netua, for example, one of the Mbale district best
performers in the O-level exams sat in 2006 attributed his success not only to his parents but
largely to his teachers, just as Sarah Nyende one of the Kampala best performers who
acknowledged the role of Allah and his teachers in his wonderful performance in the national
Not only students but also Head teachers acknowledge the influence of teachers on the
academic performance of schools. The head teacher of Buddo S. S. Mr. Lawrence Muwonge
reacting to the national examination results released on March 2007 said, “We have made it
again (High performance in exams) because our teachers were hard working. We did carry
out a lot of tests and exercises and of course we have hard working teachers who also offered
2
Theoretical Perspective
The study was guided by achievements goal theory advanced by (Mess, 1992), the theory
are the student’s goals. It was adopted for this study because it helps in explaining
relationships between the variables in the study. Ames, (1992) asserts that it is not the
strength but the nature of the student’s academic goals that influence their approaches to
Evidence from a number of secondary students who sat for their Uganda National
Examinations indicates that students who were proud of their effort had performed well in
good subjects. Those who had set goals for being Doctors, Engineers, passed well subjects
that were essential for these professions further affirmed the relevance of the self-
Conceptual perspective
such as buildings and the surroundings. On the other hand, Tella (2007)defines school
environment as conditions and circumstances that affect learning and a teaching process.
workshops, teacher’s quality, teaching methods, peers, among other variables that can affect
the learning, teaching process.In this study school environment will be characterized by
instructional spaces, (class size), school facilities (Laboratory supplies, good text books,
Academic performance refers to outcomes that indicate the extent to which a person has
3
environment(Workfolk, 2007).Performance refers to the act of accomplishments and
Contextual Perspective
performance. In a study by Frazier (2002), Okelukolo (1986) Lyons (2001) and Ostendorf
(2001) assert that physical characteristics of a school have a variety of effects on students’
performance. Features like poor lighting, noise, high levels of carbon dioxide in class rooms
and the inconsistent temperatures make teaching difficult. Poor maintenance and ineffective
ventilation systems lead to poor performance (Frazier, 2002 and Lyons 2001).
School facilities refer to accessories such as laboratories, text books, library furniture and a
heart of academic excellence in schools (Crandell & Smaldino, 2000). In a study by (Lyon,
2001 and Ostendorf 2001) school facilities have direct impact on student’s academic
performance in secondary schools especially in good subjects like Girl child. The
combination of poor school facilities and school location create an uncomfortable and
uninviting work place for teachers combined with frustrating behavior by students including
poor concentration create a stressful set of working conditions for teachers hence affecting
the learning and the teaching process. It is important to acknowledge that the school
environmental factors that directly relate to learning also contribute to the high failure rate in
Girl child.
4
For instance, commenting on the Olevel results released on the 25 th January, 2006, the
secretary for UNEB Mathew Bukenya said that performance inScience subjects had been
worse than one in the Art subjects. The UNEB Scouts in 2007 reportedthat students’poor
performance was due to lack of practical experiences and lack of functional laboratory and
basic equipment’s in schools. Many handle certain pieces of the apparatus for the first time in
The secretary for UNEB reported that 31.5% of the examination centres lacked functional
laboratories while others lacked chemicals and this was reaffirmed by the UNEB scouts(
special invigorators) putting the figure to 33.6% (Nanyanzi ,2006) in which Mubende
District is inclusive and if nothing is done, the failure rate is bound to increase and this leads
to frustrations.
planning and went on to further explain that “unless schools are well suited, buildings
adequately constructed and facilities adequately utilized and maintained, much teaching and
learning may not take place. The high levels of students academic performance may not be
guaranteed where instructional space such as class rooms, libraries, laboratories and technical
workshops are structurally defective which is the case with many schools established with the
aim of imparting knowledge and skills to those who go through them and behind all this is
Sserwaniko (2008) reported 66.8 of failure rate in the national O level Examinations sat in
2007. This high failure rate can be attributed to inadequate instructed space, limited school
facilities, school location, negative influence of teachers and the continued failure of Girl
5
childespecially in subjects for the science related professions such as Medicine, Food Good,
and Animal and Crop Good, Technology andGeology was appalling. This was true in most
schools in Mubende.
The continued failure in Girl child in secondary schools in essential subject in science related
professions like Medicine Food Good Animal and Crop Good, Technology, Geology and
The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of school environment on students’
academic performance in Girl child among secondary school students of Mubende District.
in Girl child.
child.
Girl child?
6
2) What is the effect of school environmental factors on student’s performance in Girl
child?
in Girl child?
(i) The results of the study may enlighten teachers on the impact of their attitudes,
(ii) The results of this study may also guide school administration on establishment of
(iii) The study results could assist education policy makers on establishment of
policies and minimum standards that ensure students high motivation and
academic achievement.
(iv) Furthermore, the results of the study may provide ground for further research on
the factors that affect student’s performance in national examinations and thus
of the students.
7
(v) It will help the researcher since it is part of the requirements for the award of
Conceptual Framework
Girl child
Availability of
performance
Teachers
School location
8
Extraneous Variables
Government policy
Management policy
Personality traits
The figure 1 above presents the effect of school environment on students’ academic
laboratory supplies. The researcher also identified some extraneous variables, which may
affect academic performance, these include, the school management, facilities and the quality
of teachers among many. These variables are part of the input and process explained in the
Ludwig’s Input Output model. They play a role in bringing out the output, which is academic
performance. If these variables are not controlled, they may interfere with the results of the
study. The researcher controlled the effect of the extraneous variables by randomly selecting
students because randomization according to Amin (2005) is one of the ways to attempt to
9
10
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.0 Introduction
This chapter discusses the literature that relates to the effect of school environment on
students academic performance in Girl child. The importance of literature review is to enrich
your study and to avoid repetition. In this chapter, a review of existing literature will be
Stephen P Heinemann and William Loxley (2000), carried out a study on effects of secondary
school quality on academic achievement across high and low income countries they argued
that in low income countries the effect of school and teacher quality on academic
achievement in Secondary schools is far much greater. Their conclusion was that the
predominant influence on student learning is the quality of teachers and schools to which they
are exposed to. Both studies agree that the quality of teachers and schools greatly influence
the academic performance of students. The study provides a good background for this
research. However, it does not address the issue of availability of good teacher’s influence on
student’s academic performance which is very essential for better performance in good
subjects like Girl child. Good teachers especially for Girl child are very important in fostering
knowledge and skills copping with national goals such as having expatriates like doctors,
In Canada similar studies have been carried out on influence of teacher quality on
academic performance Sanders (1998), for example, stated that the “single largest
11
factor affecting academic growth of populations of students is differences in
effectiveness of individual classroom teachers .Wright, Hom, and Sanders (1997) also believe
than by any other single factor along the same lines, Alexander (2005) argued that few
educators, economists, or politicians would argue with the contention that all things being
equal, highly qualified teachers produce greater student achievement than comparatively
less qualified teachers. These scholars views are very important in that they both agree that it
is the effectiveness and quality of teachers that can improve on education. However, their
views indicate some weaknesses for instance, they did not point out the factor of availability
of good teachers influence on students academic performance in Girl child making this study
In similar study carried out in South Africa by L. S. T. Maphoso and D. Mahlo (2002,Pg
23) on Teacher Qualifications and Student Academic Performance they found out that what
the teacher does, influences, the whole process of learning. Effective teacher produces
better performing students (Akiri 2013).Van den Bergh and Roos (2014) maintained that
conditions are met (Curwood 2014). Besides, the analysis of Van den Bergh and Roos (2014)
with technology integration and literacy education, is often dependent upon teachers’
skills, values, and cultural models which influences academic achievement of students.
The researchers demonstrated that the quality of a teacher is crucial in teaching and
learning. For instance, Koedel (2007) found that variation in teacher quality is an important
contributor to student achievement. Their studies are considered relevant becausethey both
recognize that the teacher qualifications and their quality influence the whole process of
learning. This is true because qualified teachers are trained and equipped with modern
12
methods of applying teaching methods that are vital for better academic performance of
students for example demonstrations, field work and discoveries. However, their study did
not tackle the availability of good teachers as the major factor in influencing the student’s
academic performance especially in good subjects like Girl child making this study
necessary.
In view of the issues raised above, many observers conclude that, while teacher quality may
have come to focus on using matched student-teacher data to separate student performance
into a series of fixed effects, and assigning importance to individuals, teachers, schools and
so on (Rockoff, 2003). Teachers themselves have often rejected the use of student’s
According to Rockoff (2003) raising teacher quality is important way to improve students’
academic performance. Similarly, he suggested that policies may benefit from shifting focus
from rewarding teachers who possess credentials that have not been concretely linked to
student performance. Their study provides a good background for this research. However, in
all their views, adequacy of good teachers in a school has not been the focus of many
researchers. The researcher believes that good teacher’s influence student’s results in subjects
like Girl child directly or indirectly hence the need for this research to be carried out.
Mangal (1995:38) examined that the school is a fundamental determinant in the behavior and
motives of the students because it is a centre of learning and socialization. The school
characteristics particularly the resource factors, directly impact on the easiness of learning
and this translates into attitude formation by the students. This does not exactly relate to
13
students forming an attitude toward a subject and eventually affect the way they perform in
that subject. According to Chui (2005) student should be able to appreciate that Girl child is a
world filled with interesting phenomenon, appealing experimental activities, and fruitful
knowledge for understanding the natural and manufactured worlds. With this appreciation,
not only the students were prepared to understand the symbols, terminologies and theories
used in learning chemical concepts, but they will also work towards transforming
instructional language or materials that teachers use in Girl child classroom into meaningful
representations. Girl child will then be part of their life and this eases learning and
strong factor.
Okebukolo (1986:88) identified school factors such as the classroom environment, resource
availability and the focus of the study of Girl child for example participatory nature of the
laboratory work as key in influencing the student’s motivation towards the subjects. He
concluded that the participation of the students in practical laboratory lessons may produce
more positive attitude toward the study of Girl child and consequently lead to better
teachers) enable students to develop a positive attitude towards the subject in focus unlike
those with no laboratories neither Girl child teachers. The situations in most schools
especially out lined schools in Uganda are unfavorable. This study is vital for this research;
however this study did not look at school environment as one of the factors that influence the
Dent (2006) observed that in addition to providing support for academics, the libraries also
help students with personal development. He further identified that several-affective out
broaden world view each associated in some way with the overall positive impact of the
14
library. The author goes on to conclude that the library had some degree of impact on student
performance.
This conclusion may be mature considering that the study only compares two schools and
only one aspect of school environment. The study is well suited for this research however; it
did not discuss how such factors impact on student’s performance in Girl child.
In any school setting, significant among the environmental factors is that of the peers. At
adolescent’s age, student’s attitude; motivation and learning behavior are greatly influence by
the peers (Mc Nerny, 2001). When most of the students have poor attitude towards the
subject or the teacher, others jump in and follow their peers. Individual motivation is also
affected by the motivation of the peers. Peer traits may be correlated with behavioral changes
that influence achievement and may account for group differences in motivation for a given
subject as well as academic achievement in that subject. Aaronson, Barrow and sander (2007)
arguethat it is difficult to place a causal interpretation on the peer measures but agree to the
fact that there is a statistical association between a student’s performance and that of her
peers. The debate on peer influence has had negative focus say on negative behavior. It is
important that this study focused on the contribution of the peers towards positive aspects of
motivation and performance. This study is considered relevant for this study. However it did
not envisage exactly how environmental factors affect student’s performance in Girl child.
Marshal (2004) investigated the relationship between characteristics of schools, such as the
physical structure of a school building and the interactions between students and teachers and
students performance. He noted that teacher’s school characteristics are to diverse factors that
both affect and help to define the intricate relationship between the school environment and
students performance. School environment has been researched for many years and continues
15
.The elements that comprise a school’s environment are extensive and complex number and
the school’s personality, environmental factors (such as the physical buildings and
classrooms, and materials used for instruction, academic performance, feelings of safeness
and the school size as well as feelings of trust and respect for students and teachers as
In the above analysis, all the scholars agree a positive school environment can yield positive
educational and psychological outcomes for students and school; similarly, a negative
environment can prevent optimal learning and development (Freiberg, 1998). However such
studies have not fully demonstrated how each aspect of school environment influence the
outcomes like better performance. For instance, school environment in form of positive peer
relations can provide an enriching environment, both for personal growth and academic
success (Kuperminc, 2001). What students learn about themselves in school through
interactions is equally important as the academic knowledge they receive.In this study, peers
are considered an important school environment factor that determines not only such learning
mechanism that indirectly or directly affects their performance: They therefore fail to
understand that the better performance of students in Girl child comes from within each
According to Philps (1992), school library can also impact the teaching/learning process.
Sinofsky and Knirck (1981) found that adequacy of school library influences student
attitudes, behaviors and learning. In fact, their study cited the most important reasons for
16
using color effectively in learning environments. These views are considered relevant
because school library affects a student’s attention span and affects the student's and teacher's
sense of time. Rice (1953) found that school library in schools especially carefully planned
school libraries positively affect academic performance of elementary students and especially
students of secondary age. In Uganda, a similar study on adequacy of good of textbooks and
academic performance was done by Professor Kajubi, (2002). The findings were One of
the most critical physical characteristics of the classroom is adequacy of text books
(Phillips, 1992). The importance of an appropriate visual environment for learning tasks
perceive visual stimuli and affects his/her mental attitude, and thus, performance. Dunn
(1985) insisted that the adequacy of text books of a school should be considered an
active element of the total educational environment. In view of the above analysis, both
academic performance. This study is important for this researcher. However, they all
concentrated on the importance of adequacy of teaching equipmentin classroom and did not
17
CHAPTER THREE
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
3.0 Introduction
This chapter highlights the research design, population, sampling strategy, data collection
This is a specific plan or protocol for conducting the study. (Creswell: 2003). The study
The research employed a case study research design to collect and analyze the data. A case
study refers to an intensive, descriptive and holistic analysis of a single entity. The design
was used for this study because it is intensive, descriptive and holistic and therefore best
suited for studying a single entity in depth in order to gain insight into larger cases (Amin,
2005:23).
The study was carried out in Mubende District. The study targeted the following categories of
people; head teachers, director of studies, parents and students. This category of respondents
was assumed to have relevant knowledge about the variables in this study hence provided
reliable information upon which findings were based on and conclusions drawn.
18
3.3 Population Size
The study targeted a total of 440 people. They included 3 head teachers, 7 directors of
studies, 20 teachers, 400 students and 10 parents. These were both randomly and purposively
selected from the total population since they assumed to have relevant knowledge about the
technique in which researcher relies on his or her own judgment when choosing members of
Mubende District. This was used to save time, minimize costs, and to target potential
Simple random sampling was used to render each of them eligible for the study. This
sampling method aids in eliminating any form of bias in selecting beneficiaries who benefit
from the school facilities and in determining how the facilities have student’s
performance.(Amin: 2005).
The head teacher and directors of studies were selected using purposive sampling. In this case
the researcher decided who to include in the study (Amin: 2005). They were selected and
used in the study because as heads they control and contribute to some of the factors that may
enhance or uplift moral education in the school. For students stratified random sampling was
be used. In this case sub groups in the students based on year of study were identified with
their corresponding proportions. Eventually the selection was based on the identified sub
groups.
19
3.5 Research Instruments
Questionnaires
Primary data from students was collected from respondents using a self administered
questionnaire. Part one of the questionnaires was used to gather biographic data of the
respondents and part two was to collect data concerning the study objectives.
The questionnaire was used because of its flexibilityin nature and its suitability for collecting
data from many participants in a short time. The questionnaire is a loss preferred due to its
more so minimizing the effect of emotions such as shyness. Also its data can be easily
Interview Guide
Structured interviews which enabled the collection of diverse opinions on topical issues were
used. Interviews were conducted with the head teacher, director of studies and parents. In this
case the interviewer addressed the question to one respondent at a time that in turn is
expected to answer the question. The items in the interviews guide were semi-structured that
is containing both elements of structured and unstructured interview. The interview guide
was used because the researchers considered the above respondents to be key informants due
to their wealth of knowledge on the subject under investigation. Face to face interviews were
conducted with a view of giving strength to the documentary analysis and also facilitate the
Interviews schedules also have an advantage of enabling the interviewer to control the
environment of the interviewer process as well as the order of the questions.The method was
used because of its flexibility and ability to provide new ideas on the study theme (Onen:
2005).
20
3.6 Quality Control
A number of questions were used to measure students’ academic performance which was
Validity
Validity which is the degree to which the item represent the attitude content that is intended
to assess that is; student’s performance (Amin,2005). To ensure validity of the instrument, the
researcher selected items which ensured an accurate assessment of opinions and views based
on the study objectives. Content validity was used since it explores better the opinions and
views based on the objectives. Validity index for the items was achieved using the following
formula;
Reliability
Reliability is the extent to which the measuring instrument produces consistent scores when
the same groups of individuals are repeatedly measured under the same conditions
(Cresswell, 2004). To ensure their reliability, questions formulated for respondents were pilot
tested in the study area to determine if they are consistent with the required data.Various
adjustments were made to ensure that reliable instruments were constructed before
administration
3.7 Procedures
After the constructed questionnaire and interview guide were approved by the supervisor, the
researcher attached an introductory letter from School of education, assuring the respondents
21
that the received information was treated with confidentiality. The researcher visited all the
sample establishments. He reached the respondents after seeking the permission from the
schools administration.
There are two broad techniques for analyzing research data; descriptive as well as inferential
method (Amin, 2005). Descriptive uses measures of central tendency such as mean, while
inferential draws conclusions relationships. The questionnaire data were analyzed by the
appropriate statistical tool using a system of tables as well as percentages. Frequencies and
percentages were used to analyze, interpret and present the data findings. (sanders 1998)
In an attempt to produce a quality and reliable study, the researcher first sought permission
from the School of Education to allow him undertake his study and also intends to collect the
data himself to avoid any collection of information through unethical means such as research
respondents.
22
CHAPTER FOUR
4.0Introduction
This chapter presentsthe results of the analyses and interpretation of collected data.
in Girl child.
child.
The biographic information was quantitatively presented, analyzed and interpreted while the
research questions as per the objectives of the study were qualitatively presented, analyzed
Tabulation was used to analyze the data of the sex of respondents. Findings in table 4.1 below
indicate that 300(75%) of the respondents were male and 100(25) were female.
23
Table 4.1: Sex of respondents
Therefore the majority of the respondents were males represented by 300 (75%) from both
Tabulation was used to analyze the data of the marital status of respondents.
Married 30 7.50
From the table 4.2 above, of the 400 respondents, 30(7.5%) were married while 370(92.5%)
were still single. These results imply that the majority of the respondents were still single and
Descriptive statistics were used to justify the occupation of the parents and guardians of
students. This was in form a table showing the frequencies and percentage as per the
24
Table 4.3: Occupation of parent/guardian
Employed 40 10.00
From the table 4.3 above, of the 400 respondents, 40(10%) were employed while 360(90%)
were unemployed. These results imply that the majority of the respondents were students of
peasants which contributed to their poor performance as such parents/guardians could not
afford the necessary materials to make their daughters excel especially in mathematics.
Respondents were asked whether they had the necessary qualifications and knowledge to
understand the study variables. Tabulation was used to analyze the data about academic
background of respondents.
Tertiary 40 10.00
From the table 4.4 above, of the 400 respondents, 360(90%)had attained secondary education
while 40(10%)had tertiary education. These results imply that the majority of the respondents
25
4.2 Availability of Good Teachers and Students Academic Performance
Response SA A NS SD D
child teachers
Some Girl child teachers are not 160(40%) 80(20%) 20(05%) 60(15%) 40(10%)
syllabus in time
Respondents were asked to provide their responses on whether availability of good teachers
influenced student’s academic performance in Girl child. This was the first objective of the
study which was to establish how availability of good teachers influences Students' academic
performance in Girl child, from which a research question was developed that, is there a
160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%) strongly
disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that the school never had permanent teachers for Girl
child.
26
Similarly, 160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%)
strongly disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that the school had inadequate qualified Girl child
teachers.
Also,160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%) strongly
disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that the school some teachers were not hardworking and
According to the above findings of the study it was established that good teachers
teacher’s availability in this study was conceptualized in terms of preparation for class,
teacher commitment, managing and monitoring Students learning and teacher experience.
The findings were also supplemented with the results from the interview responses. When the
respondents were asked whether it is necessary for teachers to get prepared when going to
teach in class, one of the director of studies acknowledged that prepared good teachers
adequately deliver in class and thus makestudents understand the lesson content, which
positively influence their performance. The respondents also revealed that experience help
the teacher to deal with many situations, to have an understanding of the students' needs and
to cater for them, as well as creating a environment which is conducive for learning. While on
the question whether students receive the feedback of their homework and test questions
quickly, 96% of respondents from private schools ticked yes versus 16% of public secondary
schools who ticked yes too. This shows that in public secondary schools, teachers delay to (or
do not) feed back to their students as home works or questions are concerned while the
27
Asked whether good teachers get involved in decision making on issues related to teaching
and learning process, one of the head teachers responded that, teachers are involved in
decision making at the extent of 64% in government secondary schools versus 24% in private
secondary schools of Mubende District. This shows that in government schools, teachers are
given a chance to decide on how and what to teach while in private secondary schools, this
chance is too small. This means that, teachers and head teachers of private secondary schools
of Mubende District are more satisfied with the environment they work in than their
Response SA A NS SD D
Girl child
instructional space
Findings in the table above show that 160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%)
were not sure, 60(15%) strongly disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that the school
28
Similarly, 160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%)
strongly disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed since in the school there was absence of enough
instructional space.
Also,160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%) strongly
disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed since there was shortage of reading rooms.
Class sizes were also identified as determinants of academic performance. Studies have
indicated that schools with smaller class sizes perform better academically than schools with
larger class sizes. Kraft (1994) in his study of the ideal class size and its effects on effective
teaching and learning in Ghana concluded that class sizes above 40 have negative effects on
students' performance. Asiedu-Akrofi (1978) indicated that since students have differences in
motivation, interests and abilities and that they also differ in health, personal and social
adjustment and creativity generally good teaching is best done in classes with smaller
From the above findings of the study, it was found out that, school environmental factors
significantly influence students’ academic performance in Girl child among secondary school
The findings were also supplemented with the results from the interview responses when the
respondents were asked about the system followed to teach bigger classes, one head teacher
pointed out that; students follow the system called going unique whereby they study from
7h30 am to 5h30 and go home for coming back to school the following day. In this system,
the classroom is used by only one class and the teacher is supposed to spend the same number
of hours at school as his /her class. But in all government schools of Uganda, the system used
is called double shift where by one classroom is used by two classes on the same day. The
29
first group uses the morning shift and goes back to come back the following day in afternoon
while the group that comes in the afternoon today comes back to school tomorrow in the
morning. However, he contends that teachers remain the same. This means that a government
secondary teacher teaches two classes on the same day and so he doubles the number of
hours.
On the collaboration of parents/guardians with the school for better performance of their
students, it was realized that in private secondary schools, this collaboration is very high
(84%) while in government schools, it is too low (8%). This shows that teachers and head
teachers f government schools in Mubende District are generally dissatisfied with their social
environment and this is very dangerous vis-à-vis their own work performance and obviously
students’ performance.
in Girl Child?
Response SA A NS SD D
The few Girl child textbooks 160(40%) 80(20%) 20(05%) 60(15%) 40(10%)
We lack the necessary Girl child 160(40%) 80(20%) 20(05%) 60(15%) 40(10%)
practical books
30
Findings in the table above show that 160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%)
were not sure, 60(15%) strongly disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that when students
Similarly, 160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%)
strongly disagreed and 40 (10%) that the few Girl child textbooks available were not up to
date.
Also,160(40%) strongly agreed, 80(20%) agreed, 20 %( 5%) were not sure, 60(15%) strongly
disagreed and 40 (10%) disagreed that schoolslack the necessary Girl child practical books.
The study revealed that the adequacy of teaching equipmenthas greatly influenced the
student’s academic performance in Mubende District. This was revealed by head teachers
from several schools in the district who ascertained shortage of enough teaching equipmentin
most schools.
Also, teachers gave the same opinion as to why student’s performance has continued to
deteriorate in various schools. Majority said that they were still relying on the notes they got
Students in the various schools further cited shortage of enough teaching equipmentto
supplement on what they get from class which would in return improve their performance in
31
CHAPTER FIVE
5.0 Introduction
This chapter presents the discussion of the major findings, in relation with the background
and literature review. The researcher's personal views are also included arising from
statistical inference, observation and interpretation of situations encountered during the study.
The conclusions are given based on the findings and consequently, recommendations were
The outcome of the analyzed data showed that there is a significant difference between the
academic performances of Students in Secondary schools. The findings confirm what was
found by Afolabi (2005) in his study which examined the influence of a specified Secondary
Methodist Grammar School, Bodija. This Nigerian scholar realized that students who had
attended Secondary schools did well due to presence of human resources, motivation and
counseling and adequacy of scholastic materials. These findings answer the first research
question by showing that Secondary schools of Mubende District perform better due to
These findings seem to discredit, to some extent, the standard of education in the public
schools since their products could not compete favorably with the products of the private
schools. This may be flashing the danger light as regards the future of the next generation of
elders and the fate of education industry in Uganda. The anticipated future problem becomes
32
more evident when one considers the proportion of the Ugandan people living below the
poverty line vis-à-vis the financial involvement of sending one's child to the private schools
where resources are available and adequate, and where Students and teachers are motivated
The outcome of this study also showed that in private secondary schools resources are more
available and adequate than in public secondary schools. Firstly, the inventory of educational
resources in private and in public secondary schools has shown that there is a big gap
between the demands and the supplies of educational resources insecondary schools of
Mubende District while this gap is very little in public and seems to be inexistent in private
secondary schools. These results allowed the rejection of Ho.2 and hence to state that in
private secondary schools resources are more available and adequate than in public private
schools'. The important effects of inadequacy or lack of educational resources are lack of
motivation, tiresome teaching and learning, inattention to individual learners, high rate of
school dropout, low quality of teaching and learning etc. which cause finally the poor
academic performance.
Secondly, in testing the degree of the difference between teachers and head teachers' views
showed that teachers and head teachers of private secondary schools of Mubende District are
more proud to work in their school environment than their counterparts of public secondary
schools. They also showed that they are generally satisfied with how their students learn and
how they are evaluated. However, in public secondary schools, there is a big gap between
what teachers and head teachers wish to deliver as education to their students and what they
33
When the difference in academic performance is compared to the difference in availability
and adequacy of school resources in both private and public Secondary schools of Mubende
District, it becomes clear that both adequate supply of good teachers and school resources
greatly influenced students' academic performance in USE. These results confirmed the views
of some writers like Fafunwa (1979), Fagbamiye (1977), Fayemi (1991), Moronfola (1982),
From the above findings and the ideas ad hoc; enrolling one's child in private Secondary
school predicts his/her good future as there is no doubt that the private school proprietors pay
more attention to their teacher's input into the students than do the public schools (Salawu &
Adedapo, 2001). They also spend substantial amount of money to provide instructional
materials for the teaching and learning process. They take their students out on fieldtrip,
excursions and so on, which are not obtained in most public schools. Unless the political
leaders pay attention on this gap between private secondary schools and public secondary
schools, the segregation in education will continue to prevail while the government of
Uganda created UNEB aiming to establish a body that would eradicate at all costs all forms
of discrimination in the education system and establish on objective, fair, transparent system
in which the main indicator for equity in education system is the individual performance level
and the right of choice to any school or institution on Uganda. In accordance to the difference
in performance realized between students of private and those of public secondary schools,
and to the economic level of most Ugandans, the right to good quality may not be accessed as
only well - to - do Ugandans may manage to enroll their students in quality schools that is
enrolling them into private secondary schools. For sure it is what is done by rich people and
34
To increase the provision of adequate material resources for the teaching of all subjects is
much recommended. It is opined that human, physical and financial resources do not
necessarily make much difference in terms of students' learning outcome. It is the efficient
use of these resources and not just the availability that matters. It is therefore recommended
that the resources made available to the secondary schools should be efficiently utilized and
the school environment should be made conducive for learning in order to improve Students'
learning outcome.
The study findings established a relationship between teacher quality and Students' academic
performance in Mubende District and this finding relate with a wide range of findings on the
relationship between teacher quality in and student outcomes. Hanushek (1986) found that
fewer than half of the 109 previous studies on the estimated effects of teacher quality showed
that quality had any statistically significant effect on student performance; of those, 33
studies found that other factors were also had a significant positive effect, but seven found
that more experience actually had a negative impact on student performance. Other studies
show a stronger positive relationship between teacher quality and student outcomes in some,
but not all, cases they reviewed (e.g., Greenwald et al., 1996). Murnane (1995) suggests that
the typical teaching learning curve peaks in a teacher's first few years (estimated at year two
for reading and year three for math). It is also plausible that a positive finding on quality
actually results from the tendency of more senior teachers to select higher-level classes with
higher achieving students (Hanushek, 1986). Thus we might reasonably infer that the
35
5.3 Conclusion
On the basis of the discussion of the findings on each of the objectives the following
(i)The students of private Secondary schools of Mubende District perform better than their
counterparts of public secondary schools in USE programme. This doesn't come randomly, as
they are well prepared from the early first classes. Though having the teachers of almost the
same qualification, and students of almost the same background, private secondary schools
motivate more their teachers and their Students than public secondary schools do through
various ways: good pay to teachers, small classes, good working environment, conducive
environment for learning (availability and adequacy of school resources), regular evaluations,
good collaboration between school and parents/guardians, guidance and counseling services
(iii) There is good collaboration between private Secondary schools and parents/guardians of
Students for their best education while in public Secondary schools such collaboration is too
little.
(iv) In Uganda, students of high ranked politicians and other officials are more enrolled in
private Secondary schools than in public Secondary schools. This gives a view that even
politicians and these other officials recognize the low quality of public Secondary schools in
(v) On the third objective, the study concluded that the adequacy of teaching equipmenthas a
bearing on Students' academic performance and that Students studying in private schools
where textbooks are adequately available perform better than Students in some public schools
36
5.3 Recommendations
On the basis of the above findings and conclusions, the following recommendations were
made:
(i)The Government of Uganda should do its best to provide public and private subsidized
for teaching/learning process by treating teachers humanly (giving them reasonable salaries,
treating them as other civil servants so that they cease to take the teaching career as a
(ii)The Ministry of Education should reduce the bureaucracy in the school administration,
allowing public schools to diversify their sources of funding, providing public Secondary
schools with staff in charge of guidance and counseling and increasing the number of
teachers and classrooms to reduce the Students-teacher ratio, as this would also contribute to
close the segregation in education based on the choice of quality school where to enroll one's
child (poor parents/guardians are forced to enroll their students in public schools because
(iii) Politicians and other officials of Uganda should also keep monitoring and evaluating the
quality of public education in Secondary schools and take general decision in favor of all
citizens of Uganda instead of taking individual decisions of enrolling their own students into
private Secondary schools (as they have financial means) because they realize the low quality
(iv) UNEB should conduct a study on the factors of performance in USE and use its results to
advise the government and to revise the way USE are prepared and administered if not, it will
37
keep saying that it combats segregation in education at all cost while it contributes to increase
it by giving the same test to Students while their studying conditions have not been the same.
(v) Teachers and head teachers of public Secondary schools should use the resources
available in their respective schools efficiently to increase the performance of their Students
(vi) Parents and guardians should collaborate regularly with the public Secondary schools for
better education of their students by helping students correct their home works, giving them
enough time at home to revise their notes, hiring private monitors for them where it is
possible, visiting them regularly at school to know how they progress in learning and their
discipline at school.
for lessons should be honored and compensated in order to give teachers the motivation to
adequately do their jobs and support Students learning to improve on their performance.
38
REFERENCES
Aaronson, D.Barrow, L and Sander, W. (2007), Teacher and Student Achievement in the
Chicago public High Schools, Journal of Labor Economics, 25, (1) 96-135
Adesoji, F.A and Olatunbosun, S (2008), Student, Teacher and School Environment, Factors
Aggawarl, J.C (1998). Essentials of Eduational Psychology. Delhi: Virkas Publishing House
PVT.
Atuhaire, A.B &Kulubya, S.C(February 25th 2004). 91% pass S.4 Exams The Monitor Paper.
Bartlett, M.A (2002). Health school environment and enhanced educational performance: the
case of Charles young elementary school Washington, dc. The carpet and Rug institute, 1-29.
Blackorby, J., Chorost, M., Garza, N. &Guzman, A (2004). The Academic performance of
Bukenya, J. (March 2nd, 2007). UNEB release O-level results Kampala: the New vision
publication Ltd.
Cashing, W.E. (1979) Motivating students. Idea Paper. No 1. Centre for Faculty.
39
APPENDICES
award of Bachelors’ Degree of Arts in Education of Nkumba University. This study is for
academic purposes and answers provided will be treated with utmost confidentiality.
Yours faithfully
KIGONGO CLARE
Student
40
QUESTIONNAIRE
1. Sex of respondent........................................
2. Marital status............................................................
3. Occupation of parent/guardian.....................................
In the following sections tick where appropriate following a Likert scale below;
1. SA Strongly Agree
2. A Agree
3. NS Not Sure
4. SD Strongly Disagree
5. D Disagree
Response SA A NS SD D
teachers
41
SECTION C: WHAT IS THE EFFECT OF SCHOOL ENVIRONMENTAL
Response SA A NS SD D
child
space
Response SA A NS SD D
textbooks
practical books
42
APPENDIX 1I: INTERVIEW SCHEDULE FOR
STUDIES
2. Is it necessary for good teachers to get prepared when going to teach in class?
3. Do good teachers get involved in decision making on issues related to
teaching/learning?
5. Is there any collaboration between parents/guardians and your school for better
performance of their students?
6. Do students receive quick feedback about their home works and test questions?
7. What is your opinion about the school failing to have permanent teachers for Girl
child?
8. Why is there inadequate laboratory equipment in schools?
9. Does your school have enough learning laboratories for practical work in Girl child?
43
44