Juuurnal Biotek
Juuurnal Biotek
1, 156–162
# The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Public Health Association.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/),
which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckad201 Advance Access published on 12 December 2023
...............................................................................................................
An analysis of COVID-19 vaccination campaign
in Ukraine
Tetiana Vasylivna Mamontova
Correspondence: Tetiana Vasylivna Mamontova, Physiology Department, Poltava State Medical University,
23 Shevchenko Str., 36011 Poltava, Ukraine, Tel: þ38 (0) 50 67 67258, e-mail: mamontova-tv@ukr.net
Introduction throughout the country. During the period of war, there were se-
curity issues, destruction of the system, and chains of timely delivery
vaccination, divided by the number of vaccine doses [one dose and [16% population of Ukraine; Me—85.35; (IQR 24.55–165.2)] and
all doses according to the vaccination protocol (full vaccination)] 18 799 women per 100 000 persons [19% population of Ukraine;
with distribution by gender, age group and type of vaccine. The Me—103.73; (IQR 25.14–195.5)].
age groups of COVID-19 vaccinated persons were divided into The analysis of the age structure revealed inequality in the distri-
intervals as follows: 12–15, 16–19, 20–39, 40–49, 50–59, 60–69, bution of COVID-19 vaccines due to a significant decrease in the
70–79 and 80þ. The state of epidemiology and vaccination against number of vaccinated persons among children and adolescents
COVID-19 was assessed according to indicators calculated per under 19 years and elderly persons over 70 years, regardless of the
100 000 population. number of vaccine doses received (figure 2c and d).
Statistical analysis of data was carried out using the program COVID-19 vaccines were received by the least number of children
‘STATISTICA 10.0’ (StatSoft, Inc., USA). Descriptive analysis, in aged from 12 to 15 years: 54 per 100 000 persons [0.05% population
the form of the sum, median (Me) and interquartile range (IQR), of Ukraine; Me—0.8; (IQR 0.42–3.6)] vaccinated with the first dose,
was used for various epidemiological or vaccination indicators, as 46 per 100 000 persons [0.5% population of Ukraine; Me—0.42;
they have outliers, for some indicators frequency, and percentages (IQR 0.35–4.37)] with the second dose. While elderly persons over
were used. Chi-square statistics (v2) were used to test the difference 80 years were insufficiently immunized with COVID-19 vaccines:
between two independent groups. A P value below 0.05 was consid- 702 per 100 000 persons [0.7% population of Ukraine; Me—3.1;
ered a statistically significant limit. (IQR 1.19—6.2)] vaccinated with the first dose, 641 per 100 000
[Me—421.6; (IQR 238.2–539.3)], on the other hand, vaccinated with Biotech) had the highest share. The overall assessment of the situ-
the CoronaVac vaccine (Sinovac Biotech) by 1.3 times less with the ation revealed an insufficient level of COVID-19 vaccination to
first dose—11 709 per 100 000 persons [Me—237.9; (IQR 108.6– achieve ‘herd immunity’ among the population of Ukraine. The
296.9)] and by 1.4 times less with the second dose—11 079 per obtained results can have significant implications for determining
100 000 persons [Me—238.9; (IQR 139.5–328.5)]. further directions for improving the strategy of the vaccin-
In general, the administration of the first and second doses of ation campaign.
COVID-19 vaccines followed the recommended immunization
schedules. It was found that at the beginning of the immunization, Discussion
there was a tendency to shift toward a delay with an average dur-
ation of 4 weeks (from 16 to 19 weeks 2021) between the first and COVID-19 vaccination has significantly altered the course of the
second doses of the Comirnaty vaccine (Pfizer/BioNTech, pandemic, saving tens of millions of lives worldwide; however, it
BNT162b2) (figure 3b and c). has also posed a substantial challenge for governments, public health
The analysis of COVID-19 vaccination trends in Ukraine during systems and the population. Understanding the impact of vaccin-
2021 revealed that despite the steady increase in rates, 36% and 35% ation on the course of the COVID-19 pandemic at a country level is
of the country’s population received the first and second doses of a complex task, given the heterogeneous access of countries to vac-
vaccines, respectively. Among the five types of COVID-19 vaccines, cines combined with measurable outcomes, variability within the
Comirnaty (Pfizer/BioNTech, BNT162b2) and CoronaVac (Sinovac target cohort, vaccine dosing, development of vaccination
COVID-19 vaccination campaign in Ukraine 159
infrastructure, changing landscape of circulating SARS-CoV-2 virus among the population of Ukraine during the fourth wave of the
strains, implemented national quarantine restrictions, and even pandemic (6th week).
more so, especially the impact of armed conflicts. However, an ana- The priority list for COVID-19 vaccine access in Ukraine recom-
lysis of the vaccination strategy may be important for assessing the mends a predominant focus on professionals (healthcare workers;
effectiveness of the COVID-19 immunization program and identi- social workers; persons and workers living in long-term care facili-
fying ways for its optimization. In this study, trends and the deploy- ties; military personnel; employees of critical state security struc-
ment strategy of the vaccination program implemented in Ukraine tures; teachers and employees in the field of education; persons
to protect citizens from the SARS-CoV-2 virus have been who are in places of restriction of freedom and employees of these
investigated. structures) but provided for taking into account age (60 years and
The start of the COVID-19 vaccination campaign in Ukraine was older) and health status (adults aged 18–59 with concomitant dis-
characterized by a slow start (8th week of 2021), as it began shortly eases who are at risk regarding the development of complications
before the increase in the second wave of morbidity and mortality of and the occurrence of death).1,10 An additional measure to strength-
the pandemic (12th week of 2021) among the country’s population. en vaccination efforts was the MOH of Ukraine’s approval on 7
This situation was caused by numerous disputes between govern- October 2021 of a list of professions for which COVID-19 vaccin-
ment officials that arose over the purchase of the first doses of ation is mandatory, encompassing employees in educational institu-
vaccines and the clarification of logistical mechanisms for supply, tions and executive authorities (both central and regional).11
which required storage of the vaccines in ultra-low temperature cold The demographic analysis of COVID-19 vaccinations reveals an
equipment.9 The pace of the vaccination campaign significantly imbalance by age and gender categories, showing a decline in the
accelerated by the 42nd week of 2021, on the eve of the third proportion of men and older individuals receiving both first and
wave of the pandemic, which was marked by a record-high mortality second doses. According to the MOH of Ukraine data, during the
rate (45th week of 2021—4622 people per week) for the entire period 10th week of 2020–21st week of 2021, women prevailed in the num-
of the COVID-19 pandemic in Ukraine. In general, in 2021, the ber of confirmed COVID-19 cases (59.5% of persons), and the
population of Ukraine was vaccinated against COVID-19 with the elderly over 70 years—in the number of deaths (52.5% of persons).1
first dose of 36% persons and with the second dose of 35% persons. The results showed that women were more willing than men to be
The target indicators declared from the beginning of the COVID-19 vaccinated against COVID-19, despite high levels of distrust in the
vaccination program for 2021, which is 50% of the country’s popu- safety and efficacy of vaccines among women at the start of the
lation, were not achieved. The level of morbidity at the beginning of campaign.12 The national vaccination program considered the ele-
2022 reached its record high, amounting to 24 942 new weekly cases vated risks for specific age groups and suggested vaccination for
160 European Journal of Public Health
Figure 3 The dynamic of COVID-19 vaccination in Ukraine: common cases with one and two doses (a); different types of vaccines with one
dose (b); different types of vaccines with two doses (c), 100 000/population
COVID-19 vaccination campaign in Ukraine 161
those over 80 years during the second stage and for those aged 65– It relies on the country making the latest figures on administered
79 years old during the third stage. The vaccination data for the doses available in a timely manner. Also, Ukrainian
elderly reveals a concerning trend: In 2021, one and two vaccine organizations provide daily or weekly updates on the different
doses of vaccine received by only 2.31% and 2.24% of persons aged web platforms that complicate the interpretation of reported data.
between 70 and 79 years, respectively, and a mere 0.7% and 0.64% of In Ukraine, access to COVID-19 vaccination data was closed with
those above 80 years, respectively. These data show that the vaccin- the beginning of the war on 24 February 2022. This affected the
ation coverage target for persons aged 60 years or more (9 978 194 accuracy and comprehensiveness of our analysis in assessing the
persons, 24.1% population of Ukraine)1 was not achieved. The low speed of the vaccination rollout after the onset of the war. It’s im-
level of COVID-19 vaccination among the elderly serves as a clear portant to acknowledge this limitation and interpret the results
signal to strengthen the targeted monitoring and information on the within this context.20
vaccination of this age group. Analyzing the data, it can be concluded that since the beginning
The President and Government of Ukraine made significant
of the deployment of the COVID-19 vaccination campaign, Ukraine
efforts to promote the vaccination program and obtain COVID-19
has been faced with solving several problems related to the procure-
vaccines. Already in March 2021, the campaign was forced to over-
ment, receipt of vaccines and the establishment of communication
come a high level of distrust among the population, which, accord-
within the country. Notwithstanding having signed contracts to sup-
ing to the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) and the
References 11 Website: Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Ministry of Public Health of Ukraine. Order No.
2153 from 04.10.2021. On the approval of the List of professions, industries, and
1 Website: Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Ministry of Public Health of Ukraine. Order
organizations whose employees are subject to mandatory preventive vaccinations.
No. 3018 from 24.12.2020. On the approval of the roadmap for the introduction of a
Available at: https://www.kmu.gov.ua/news/moz-zatverdilo-perelik-profesij-dlya-yakih-
vaccine against the acute respiratory disease COVID-19 caused by the SARS-CoV-2
shcheplennya-proti-covid-19-ye-obovyazkovim. (12 August 2023, date last accessed).
coronavirus and mass vaccination in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in
Ukraine in 2021—2022. Available at: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/rada/show/ 12 Toshkov D. Explaining the gender gap in COVID-19 vaccination attitudes.
v3018282-20#Text (13 August 2023, date last accessed). Eur J Public Health 2023;33:490–5.
2 Website: Resolution of the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine. No. 95 from 02.08.2021. 13 Website: UNICEF. ‘03.03.2021. Infodemic’ of COVID-19 disinformation bad for
Some issues of state registration of vaccines or other medical immunobiological Ukrainians health, study for UN finds. Available at: https://www.unicef.org/
drugs for the specific prevention of acute respiratory disease COVID-19, caused by ukraine/press-releases/infodemic-covid-19-disinformation-bad-ukrainians-health-
the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, under obligations for emergency medical use. study-un-finds (13 August 2023, date last accessed).
Available at: https://www.kmu.gov.ua/npas/deyaki-pitannya-derzhavnoyi-reyestra 14 Zoaib Habib T, Ennab F, Matiashova L, et al. Double trouble: COVID-19 vaccine
ciyi-vakcin-abo-inshih-medichnih-immunobiologichnih-preparativ-dlya-t80221 misinformation amidst conflict in Ukraine. Ann Med Surg (Lond) 2022;
(13 August 2023, date last accessed). 80:104127.
3 Holt E. COVID-19 vaccination in Ukraine. Lancet Infect Dis 2021;21:462. 15 Website: Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine. Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine
4 Haque U, Naeem A, Wang S, et al. The human toll and humanitarian crisis of the Resolution No. 1272 from 9.122021. Some issues of assistance within the
7 Hill M, Vanderslott S, Volokha A, Pollard AJ. Addressing vaccine inequities among 17 Website: UNICEF. 18.05.2021. This week, Ukraine is receiving almost half a million
Ukrainian refugees. Lancet Infect Dis 2022;22:935–6. more doses of the COVID-19 vaccine as part of COVAX. Available at: https://www.
unicef.org/ukraine/press-releases/ukraine-receive-close-half-million-doses-covid-
8 Website: UNICEF. 16.04.2021. Ukraine received the first vaccines against COVID-
19 as part of the COVAX mechanism. Available at: https://www.unicef.org/ukraine/ 19-vaccine-under-covax-week. (13 August 2023, date last accessed).
press-releases/covax-arrival-ukraine (13 August 2023, date last accessed). 18 Website: State Expert Center of the Ministry of Health of Ukraine. COVID-19
9 Website: Freedom Radio. The battle for the vaccine against COVID-19: Ukrainian vaccination. OMIRNATYTM from Pfizer, Belgium. Available at: https://www.dec.
departments are arguing about the purchase, and the EU and the US are already gov.ua/materials/somirnaty%ef%b8%8f-vid-pfajzer-belgiya/?role=ua. (12 August
vaccinating. Available at: https://www.radiosvoboda.org/a/vaccine-covid-19- 2023, date last accessed).
ukraine-scandal-moz-vaccination/31035602.html.(12 August 2023, date 19 Xu K, Wang Z, Qin M, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the effect-
last accessed). iveness and safety of COVID-19 vaccination in older adults. Front Immunol 2023;
10 Matiashova L, Isayeva G, Shanker A, et al. COVID-19 vaccination in Ukraine: an 14:1113156.
update on the status of vaccination and the challenges at hand. J Med Virol 2021; 20 Korolchuk O, Vasiuk N, Klymkova I, et al. COVID-19 vaccination under conditions
93:5252–3. of war in Ukraine. Asian Bioeth Rev 2023;15:259–81.