Handedness and Hand Joint
Changes in Rheunlatoid Arthriti
                                                                                                                        Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
(dominance, goniometry, deformity, joint protection)
Betty Risteen Hasselkus                K. K. Kshepakaran                       Margaret   J. Safri t
This study investigates the rela-            ormal skeletal alignment and      weakening of the periart cular sup-
tionship of hand use to the
deforming hand Joint changes of
                                       N    joint function in the human
                                       body depend on the integrity of the
                                                                               porting structures, and uscle im-
                                                                               balance are all conseque ces of per-
rheumatoid arthritis. Measure-         internal structures of the joint and    sistent destructive syno itis in the
ments of metacarpophalangeal           the balance of external forces acting   joints of the digits, the t umb, the
lateral mobility, loss of metacar-     on the joint. The persistent in-        metacarpals, the carpal, and the
pophalangeal hyperextension,           flammatory process of rheumatoid        distal forearm.
thumb metacarpophalangeal              arthritis (RA) is destructive to the       A wide variety of a sessment
range of motion, and lateral pinch     bony and soft-supporting intrinsic      techniques has been us d to mea-
strength were statistically com-       structures of an involved joint. The    sure hand deformity nd joint
pared across dominant and non-         resulting pain and altered biome-       changes. The three mos common
dominant hands of 51 adult sub-        chanics predispose the joint to an      measurements are grip strength,
Jects who had definite or classical    imbalance of its external muscle        range of motion, and pinc strength;
rheumatoid arthritis. Incidence of     forces (I, 2).                          however, the kaleidosco e of other
boutonniere and swan neck                 The synovial joints of the hands     assessments in the literat re include
deformities and distal Tadioulna       are typically involved in rheuma-       roentgenograms, cada r dissec-
laxity was also recorded. Results of   toid arthritis and, in time, fre-       tions, measurements of and span
a multivariate analysis of variance    quently display characteristic joint    and thumb web angle, h nd profile
of the difference scores between       deformities and changes in func-        tracings, finger-palm pints, joint
dominant and nondominant mea-          tional capacity. Bony erosions.         circumference measurem nts, finger
sures were not significant. The                                                flexor strength measures, nd dolor-
authors concluded that the rela-       Betty Risteen Hasselkus, M.S.,          imeter measurements of ain (3-11).
tionship of hand use to Joint de-      OTR, is Clinical Associate Profes-      A number of studies i clude test
struction is not yet clearly defined   sor, Occupational Therapy Pro-          items of function suc as tying
and further study is needed. Impli-    gram, University of                     knots, cutting wire, and buttoning
cations for treatment principles of    Wisconsin-Madison.                      (5, 12, 13). It is also ossible to
Joint protection are presented.                                                record categorical data s ch as pres-
                                       K. K. Kshepakaran, M.Ed., OTR,          ence of specific deformiti s, nodules,
                                       was formerly Assistant Professor,       tendon dislocations or r lUres, in-
                                       Occupational Therapy Program,           trinsic muscle tightness, c epitation,
                                       Unwersityof Wisconsm-Madlson.           muscle atrophy, palmar erythema,
                                                                               and triggering (5,9).
                                       Margaret]. Safrit, Ph.D., is Pro-          It has been suggeste that the
                                       fessor, PhYSical Education and          structural changes secon ary to RA
                                       Dance, University of                    combine with the forces i volved in
                                       Wisconsin-Madison.                      the use of the hand t produce
                                                           The Amerzcan Journal of Occupational T erapy           705
deformity 3, 14-19). Ellison, Flatt,
and Kelly ive equal weight to the         Table 1
deforming forces of usage and to the      Descriptive Data: Hand Changes and Dominance in Patients with Rheumatoid Arthritis
laxity of su porting joint structures                     Difference                                   Max.          MinI.
(18). Flatt ater states, "There must      Variables'    Between Means        S.D.          S.E.M.   Difference    Difference
be aberrati ns of structure or func-      V1                   .2373         5.9101         .8276    16.0000      -11.5000
                                                                                                                                 Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
tion to ini iate the deformity." (14,     V2                 - .1275         4.2812         .5995    12.0000      -13.0000
p 266) Hak tian and Tubiana, how-         V3                   .0784         5.0014         .7003    16.5000      -13.0000
ever, con ude that the external           V4                   .9314         7.5326        1.0548    20.0000      -19.0000
forces of and use are only sec-           V5                  4.9020        10.6212        1.4873    40.0000      -15.0000
ondary to issue destruction in the        V6                  4.5098        14.0205        1.9633    55.0000      -22.0000
productio of deformity in the             V7                  3.3137        12.3523        1.7297    60.0000      -30.0000
rheumatoi hand (19).                      V8                  3.0980         9.5315        1.3347    50.0000      -13.0000
   Anum r of investigators have           V9                 -5.0588        18.5477        2.5972    45.0000      -60.0000
addressed he relationship of hand         V10                  .2980         3.0887         .4325    11.5000       - 8.5000
use to joi t change in rheumatoid
                                          N = 51
arthritis b comparing dominant
                                          'V1 - V4 = MCP lateral mobility for digits 2-5
and nond minant hand data (3, 9,
                                          V5 - V8 = limited MCP extension for digits 2-5
20, 21). T ey primarily studied the
                                          V9 = Thumb MCP range of motion
developm t of ulnar drift at the
                                          V10 = Lateral pinch strength
metacarpo halangeal (MCP) joints
in the rh matoid hand. Kemble
demonstra ed significantly larger         that seek to reduce the joint stresses       the assumption that the dominant
angles of Inar drift at the MCP           of daily hand use are based on the           hand is subjected to greater stress
joints of d minant hands than those       theory that the forces involved in           during daily activities than the
of nondo inan t hands, and further        the use of the hand contribute to            nondominant hand, this study was
stated, on the basis of X-ray data,       structural joint changes and disease         designed to test the hypothesis that
that hand ominance "determines            activity, thus fostering deformity           the dominant hand demonstrates
metacarpa head erosions and ulnar         (16,17,22-24). However, the equiv-           significantly greater clinically
drift defor ity." (3, P 240) (italics     ocal results cited in the studies cited      observable joint changes than the
for emphas' s) Fearnley earlier stated,   above mandate the need to further            nondominant hand in rheumatoid
"In other ise symmetrical cases           clarify the issues involved in the           arthri tis.
with ulna deviation more marked           relationship between hand use and
on the rig t, the greater use of the      hand joint changes in rheumatoid             Methods
right han will explain the defor-         arthri tis.                                  Subjects for this study were 51 out-
mity." (20, 132) Treuhaft et al. (9).        The purpose of this study was to          pa tien ts who had defini te or classi-
however, oncluded that the joint          investigate the effects of hand use          cal rheumatoid arthritis as diag-
changes 0 each hand in their sub-         on the deforming joint changes of            nosed by a physician. Subjects had
jects were arly identical, and Lush       rheumatoid arthritis. Clinically             no other connective tissue disease
concurred that there "appeared to         observable hand joint changes were           and no history of upper extremity
be no corre ation between the degree      statistically compared across domi-          surgical procedures. Ages ranged
to which t e hand was used or the         nant and nondominant hands of 51             from 22 to 79 with a mean age of
natureoft epatient'sworkandthe            adult subjects who had definite or           54.15 years. There were 29 males
developme t of ulnar deviation."          classical RA (25). In addition, cate-        and 22 females.
(21, p 220)                               gorical data on digital deformities             Measurement Criterza. An assess-
   Occupa ional therapists have           and dist al radioulna laxity were            ment battery measuring lateral lax-
traditional y taught joint protec-        obtained. Based on the theory that           ity of the MCP joints in digits 2-5,
tion to R pa tien ts in an effort to      the stresses involved in the use of the      loss of hyperextension of the MCP
mmimize he dynamic deforming              hand contribute significantly to             joints in digits 2-5, thumb MCP
forces of t e diseased hand. Treat-       joint changes and deformity in               joint range of motion, and lateral
ment prin iples of joint protection       rheumatoid arthritis, and based on           pinch strength was administered to
706   Nov mber 1981, Volume 35, Number 11
Table 2
Correlation Matrix of Hand Measurements: Rheumatoid Arthritis
                                                                  (N= 51)
                                                                                                                    ROM of     Lateral
                         MCP Lateral Mobility                              Limitation of MCP Extension            Thumb MC     Pinch
                                                                                                                                         Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
             V1           V2          V3                 V4         V5            V6          V7           V8         V9        V10
         ~
V1          oooo
V2          .3747            .0000
V3          .3068    I       .3841          .0000
V4          .1794            .2363          .408      1.0000
                                                                  ~
                                                                   oooo~
V5          .0756            .1455         -.0247      .2050
 V6         .1747            .3265          .14023602              .6498
                                                                     .0000
 V7         .1750            .3270          .19323928              .6297    II    .8091      .0000
 V8         .1117            .2417          .15403454              .6953          .6910      .837        1.0000
 V9         .0776        -.0646             .0349     -.0486      -.0662         -.2106     -.0799       -.0042     1.0000
V10       -.0163             .0761         -.0203     -.1793      -.0765         -.1892     -.1566       -.0167     -.1414     1.0000
r of .273 significant at p   ~   .05, df = 49
each of the 51 subjects by the i nves-              formity was defined as 10° or greater      on both hands of each of t e 51 sub-
tigators. The presence or absence of                loss of extension of the proximal          jects. Differences between group
swan neck and boutonniere defor-                    interphalangeal (PIP) joint in one         means using all the varia bles were
mities and distal radioulna joint                   or more digits on the hand. Swan           used to test for the main effect of
laxity was also recorded.                           neck deformi ty was defined as 10° or      dominance.
   Lateral laxity of the MCP joints                 greater hyperextension of the PIP             Descriptive data from t e MAN-
was measured with a two-axis goni-                  joint in one or more digits. The           OVA are presented in Tatle I. The
ometer as described previously by                   presence of radioulna joint laxity         overall difference in clini ally ob-
Hasselkus, Kshepakaran, Houge, et                   depended on testing for the" spring-       servable joint changes between
al. (26). Swezey states that collateral             board" or "piano key" sign (24).           dominant and nondomin" nt hands
ligament laxity is the primary com-                    Analysis and Treatment of the           was not statistically Sl nificant
ponent of ulnar drift (I). The two-                 Data. The data were analyzed using         (F(lO, 41 = 1.3037); P =.261). Thus
axis goniometer enabled the investi-                a multivariate analysis of variance        the joint changes measur d in the
gators to measure the passive range                 (MANOVA). The ten dependent                dominant hands were no signifi-
of radial/ulnar movement at the                     variables were passive MCP lateral         cantly different from those neasured
MCP joint while maintaining the                     mobility of digits 2-5, passive MCP        10 the nondominant ha ds. The
joint in flexion, that is, the joint                hyperextension of digits 2-5, pas-         hypothesis that the domin~nt hand
position in which the collaterallig-                sive thumb MCP range of motion,            demonstrates significantl greater
aments are normally taut (14, 17,                   and lateral pinch strength. The in-        clinically observable join changes
19).                                                dependent variable was hand dom-           than the nondominant ~and 10
   Loss of hyperextension at the                    inance. Difference scores between          rheumatoid arthritis was not sup-
MCP Joints (defined as 20° of mo-                   dominant and nondominant mea-              poned.
tion beyond 0°) and range of motion                 sures for each variable were used to         The correlation matrix ( f the dif-
of the thumb MCP were measured                      test the hypothesis. Distal radioulna      ferences bet ween the mea 1S of the
passively with a small finger goni-                 joint laxity and boutonniere and           ten variables is presented ir Table 2.
ometer that had been cut away to its                swan neck deformities of the digits        With an r of .273, the trongest
aXIs to facilitate better clearance                 were descriptively analyzed.               intercorrelations appear i 1 Trian-
over bony prol u berances. An OSCO                                                             gle II, that is, the measure of MCP
pinch meter was used to measure                     Results                                    hyperextension in digits -5. The
lateral pinch force (27).                           The results of this study are based        highest coefficient, .8377 f r V ,IV R,
  The presence of boutonniere de-                   on the measurement of 10 variables         indicates a very strong relationship
                                                                         The American Journal of Occupational Ther py             707
between oss of MCP hyperexten-
sionindi it4anddigit5.Similarly,          Figure 1
                                          Digital deformities and radioulna laxity
the corre tion coefficient of .8091
for Vr/V indicates a strong rela-
                                                                                            :> :~:~:::NANT
tionship between hyperextension
measures in digits 3 and 4. In fact,
all coeffi ients in Triangle II are
                                                   12
                                                                                           I   BILATERAL
                                                                                                                             Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
                                                   10
high, su gesting significant rela-           (f)
                                             f-
tionships between the loss of hyper-         U
                                             w
                                             ..., 8
extensio measures on all digits.             CD
                                             ~
Triangle outlines the correlation            (f)
coefficie ts for the measure of MCP          ~     6
                                             0
lateral m bility in digits 2-5. The          n::
                                             w
highest c efficient in this group is         CD    4
                                             :2
.4083 for /V j, that is, the relation-       ~
                                             z
ship the b tween MCP lateral mobil-                2
ity meas rements in digits 4 and 5.
   Freque cy of digital deformities
                                                   0
and dista radioulna joint laxity in                     RADIOULNA         BOUTONNIERE      SWAN NECK
dominan , nondominant, and bi-                           LAXITY
la teral ha ds is depicted in Figure I.
Of the 51 ubjects, a total of 16dem-      gle response." (William C. Mann,           and ulnar-deviated posture. Ellison,
onstrated radioulna laxity, 23 had        Multivariate Analysis Institute, 1980      Flatt. and Kelly (18) also relate MCP
boutonni redeformities,and 14 had         AOTA Conference, 515 Stockton              subluxation to ulnar drift, focusing
swan nee deformities. No pattern          Kimball Tower, Buffalo, New York           on the deforming forces of the
of domi ant side involvement              14214.)           _                        altered line of pull of the intrinsic
emerged; in fact, radioulna laxity           The dependent variables in this         muscles and the extrinsic extensors.
was clear y more prevalent on the         study-MCP lateral mobility, loss           Other studies provide further evi-
nondomi ant side.                         of MCP hyperextension, thumb               dence for a strong relationship
                                          MCP range of motion, and lateral           between loss of MCP hyperexten-
Discussi n                                pinch strength-were selected on            sion and ulnar drift (3, 6,14,20). In
The results of this study on the rela-    the basis of their logical inter-          addition, prolonged synovitis of the
tionship between handedness and           relatedness in both the disease            most commonly involved joint of
hand joi t changes in RA did not          pathology and the theoretical dy-          the thumb, the MCP joint, leads to
support he hypothesis that the            namic forces of deformity in the           joint instability and the classic
dominan hand demonstrates sig-            rheumatoid hand. Smith et al. (16)         thumb deformities described by
nificantl greater joint destruction       link loss of MCP hyperextension            Nalebuff (28). Laxity of the MCP
than the ondominant hand. Thus,           and MCP lateral mobility together          thumb joint and the laxity of the
a clearcut elationship between hand       via the flexor forces exerted by the       MCP joint of the index finger com-
use and the clinically observable         long finger flexors during hard            bine to result in a diminished pinch
jointcha ges measured in this study       grip and pinch activities. In the dis-     force (3, 4, 18). Thus the dependent
was not monstrated.                       eased hand, the flexor tendons tend        variables chosen for this study did,
   It is ssumed, when using a             to bowstring volarly and ulnarly at        in the authors' judgment, form a
MANOV for analysis of data, that          the mouth of the flexor tunnel at the      logical though unproven set.
the depe den t varia bles are rela ted    MCP joints. As the supporting lig-            The correlation matrix gives val-
and that hey form a logical, con-         aments become weakened and elon-           uable clues on why the test of the
ceptually meaningful set. "Multi-         gated by the rheumatoid process,           mean differences among all the var-
variate a alysis treats the data as a     the volar and ulnar pull of the long       iables between dominant and non-
whole a d considers correlations          flexors during hand use becomes            dominant hands was not statisti-
among m asures," and the data are         more and more forceful and the dig-        cally significant. The correlations
handled s "related aspects of a sin-      its gradually move into a subluxed         represc.1t the strength of the rela-
708        ember 1981, Volume 35, Number 11
tionship of the difference scores        of loss of MCP hyperextension than       weak pinch and finger flexion
between the dominant and non-            ulnar deviation in his hand study,       forces. Neither of these ariables
dominant hands for each variable.        so that the two variables do not         was considered in this st dy. The
With 49 degrees of freedom, a corre-     necessaril y occur in concert. Res-      use or nonuse of a cane or other
lation coefficient (r) of 273 is a       nick (6) and Shapiro (15) both           walking aid might have roved to
value significantly different from       strongly implicate radial rotation       be another important va iable in
                                                                                                                                Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
zero. The higher the correIa tion, the   of the wrist in ulnar deviation of the   producing significant ha d defor-
greater the evidence of a meaning-       digits. Shapiro described the in-        mity; this information            as not
ful strong relationship in the prac-     creased ulnar-volar force of the long    recorded. Further, one mig t specu-
tical sense.                             flexors at the MCP joints with the       late that persons with rh umatoid
   While a number of the variables       wrist in radial rotation and the         arthritis tend to shift muc of their
demonstrate high correlations (espe-     mechanical advantage this gave to        activity from a painful ommant
cially V j - V~), many do not. Most      the ulnar intrinsics, upsetting the      hand to a less painful non ominant
surprising were the low intercorre-      normal delicate balance of the deep      hand, thus somewhat e ualizing
lations between many of the mea-         muscles during hand activity (15).       the resulting stress during and use.
sures of MCP lateral mobility and           Ellison, Flatt, and Kelly (18) cite   A number of subjects co mented
those of loss of MCP hyperexten-         evidence tha t hernia tion of the pro-   on this phenomenon.
sion. Further, the authors had ex-       liferating synovium first occurs at         The Measure of Me Lateral
pected to find a strong correlation      the weakest anatomical pointof the       Mobility. In retrospect, th method
between lateral pinch strength and       extensor expansion, that is, between     used to measure MCP coli terallig-
MCP lateral mobility, and these          the extri nsic extensor and the radial   ament laxity may have co tributed
coefficients were very low. Passiv       intrinsic insertion. Such a hernia-      to the nonsignificant res Its. The
range of motion of the thumb MCP         tion changes the radial intrinsic        total range or arc of ra io/ulnar
did not correlate highly with any        line of pull so that the radio/ulnar     movement of the MCP jo'nt in the
other variable.                          balance is lost. The lumbricals are      flexed position was recor ed as the
   To investigate the effect of the      all radial intrinsics and, according     indication of collateral igament
lack of relationship between many        to Eyler and Markee (29), the most       laxity. The assumption w s that as
of the variables on the overall F        important function of the lumbri-        the arc of movement incr ased, so
value, twO separate MANOVAs were         cals is to stabilize the MCP joint.      did the angle of ulnar d ift. It is
run-one on the four variables that       Habtian and Tubiana state that it        possible that this is not so. t may be
measured loss of MCP hyperexten-         is conceivable that "capsular and        that the range of laxity eaches a
sion, and one on the four variables      ligamentous attenuation without          certain point and stabi izes, al-
that measured MCP lateral laxity.        involvement of the intrinsic mus-        though its anatomical position
The results of lhe tWO separate          cles could produce a hand with very      continues to drift ulnarw rd. A 30°
MANOVAs were (F(4,47) = 2.6371);         little ulnar-drift deformity." (19, p    arc of radio/ulnar move ent may
P = .046) for the :VICP hyperrexten-     314) Thus, the impact of persistent      be positioned in the midi' e of the
SlOn variable and (F(4,47) = .2571); P   synovitis on the integrity of the        articulation, or it may be from 10°
= .904) for the Mep lateral mobility     intrinsic muscles and the sub-           to 40° of ulnar deviation. he total
variable. This suggests that domi-       sequent implications on develop-         arc of movemen t is the sa       , bu t the
nance is a major source of variance      ing deformity need further investi-      second arc represents a           ore ad-
in the loss of MCP hy! erextension,      gatiol . A review of the factors that    vanced stage of ulnar drift. n Lush's
although its role in Mep lateral         contribute to ulnar drift, as well as    study of ulnar deviation, 1J percent
mobility continued to be statisti-       other hand deformities, is provided      of the deviated digits could 10 longer
call y nonsignifical t.                  by Swezey (I).                           be pa. sivel y returned to th midline
   Other Factors to Consider. While         Kemble (3) found significantly        (21). Fearnley (20), in outl ning the
a high correlation between M P           larger angles of ulnar drift, greater    thlee ·tagesofuJnardeviati n,stated
collateral ligament laxity and loss      loss of M P extension, and weaker        that the progression i toward
of MCP hyperextension is supported       pinch in sero-positive hands than        gradual loss of the abili ty t acti vel y
by a number of studies, the issue is       ero-negalive hands, regardl ss of      or passively correct to the midline.
far from clear. l'reuhaft et al. (9)     dominance. f: e also found duration      If su h is the case, a gre tel' degree of
demonstrated a higher perc ntClge        of illness strongly correlated vith      UII at leviation woulJ not necessar-
                                                             The Amnican Journal of Occupational The apy                 709
ily be ref ected in a greater total arc      Acknowledgments                                14, Flatt A: Care of the Rheumatoid Hand,
of lateral movement.                         Theauthors gratefully acknowledge                  St. Louis: C,V. Mosby Co" 1974, 3rd
   Impllc tions for Occupational             the assistance and su pport of Walter              Edition, Chap 10
                                                                                            15,Shapiro JS: A new factor in the etiol-
Therapy The results of this study            R. Sundstrom, M.D., and Judy                       ogy of ulnar drift, Clin Orthop 68:32-43,
have im lications for occupational           Spray, Ph.D.                                       1970
therapy ractice in rheumatology.               This study was supported by the              16.Smith EM, Juvinall RC, Bender LF,
                                                                                                Pearson JR: Flexor forces and rheuma-
The theo ies of joint protection are         following grants-University of
                                                                                                                                             Downloaded from http://research.aota.org/ajot/article-pdf/35/11/705/50895/705.pdf by VA Library Network, Huertas College on 10 April 2024
                                                                                                toid metacarpophalangeal deformity.
based on linical observation, intui-         Wisconsin-Madison: HilldaleTrust                   JAMA 198:150-154, 1966
             logic. One concept im-          Fund-School of Allied Health                   17. English CB, Nalebuff EA: Understand-
                                                                                                ing the arthritic hand. Am J Occup
              the principles of joint        Professions; Graduate School Re-                   Ther 25:352-359, 1971
             is that specificjoint stress    search Fund #100099; Graduate                  18. Ellison MR, Flatt AE, Kelly KJ: Ulnar
            ily activity can result in       School Academic Computer Funds                     drift of the fingers in rheumatoid dis-
                                                                                                ease. J Bone Joint Surg 53-A:1061-
increase disease activity and can            #42009; Instrumentation Systems                    1082,1971
foster joi t destruction and deformi-        Center; Interdisciplinary Geriatric            19. Hakstian RW, Tubiana R: Ulnar devia-
ty. Patie t education includes in-           Training Grant-CHS-VA #2C (75)                     tion of the fingers, The role of joint
                                                                                                structure and function, J Bone Joint
struction to avoid activities that           IV -500406                                         Surg 49-A:299-316, 1967
require ard grip and pinch, that                                                            20, Fearnley GR: UI nar deviation of the
                                                             REFERENCES                         fingers. Ann Rheum Dis 10-11 126-
subjectj intligamentsand tendons              1. Swezey RL. Dynamic factors in defor-           136,1951-52
to twisti g and stretching, that                 mity in the rheumatoid arthritic hand.     21. Lush B: Ulnar deviation of the fingers,
            longed tension around a              Bull Rheum Dis 22:649-656, 1971-1972           Ann Rheum Dis 11 :219-221, 1952
                                              2. Swezey RL, Fiegenberg OS: Inappro-         22, Cordery J: Joint protection, A respon-
            that rota te the digi ts in an       priate intrinsic muscle action in the          sibility of the occupational therapist.
ulnar di ection. Resting splints,                rheumatoid hand. Ann Rheum Dis                 Am J Occup Ther 19:285-293, 1965
adapted elf-care equipment, pre-                 30619-625, 1971                            23. Smith RD. Polley HF' Rest therapy for
                                              3. Kemble JVH: Functional disability in           rheumatoid arthritis. Mayo Clin Proc
scribed r st and exercise, and work              the rheumatoid hand. Hand 9:234-241,           53:141-145,1978
simplific tion are all modes of                  1977                                       24. Melvin JL: Rheumatic Disease: Occu-
treatmen that are employed in oc-             4. Dickson RA, Nicolle FV: The assess-            pational Therapy and Rehabilitation,
                                                 ment of hand function, Hand 4:207-             Philadelphia: FA Davis Co., 1977, Chap
cupation I therapy (22-24, 30, 31).              214,1972                                       14,19
   The st dy was done in an attempt           5. Swanson AB, Mays JD. Yamauchi Y: A         25.Ropes MW, Bennett GA, Cobbs S,
to test th s theory of joint stress-             rheumatoid arthritis evaluation record         Jacox RF, Jessar RA: 1958 Revision of
                                                 for the upper extremity. Surg Clin North       diagnostic criteria for rheumatoid
that is, to explore the predIctability           Am 481003-1013,1965                            arthritis, Bull Rheum Dis 9:175-176,
of joint estruction and deformity             6, Resnick 0: Inter-relationship between          1958
and to scertain to what degree                   radiocarpal and metacarpophalangeal        26, Hasselkus SR, Kshepakaran KK, Houge
                                                 joint deformities in rheumatoid arthri-        JC, Plautz KA: Rheumatoid arthritis: a
actual da a confirm or fail to con-              tis J Can Assoc Radiol 27:29-36, 1976          two-axis goniometer to measure meta-
firm the heory. The data in this              7, Ingpen ML, The quantitative measure-           carpophalangeallaxity, Arch Phys Med
study fail d to support the hypothe-             ment of joint changes in rheumatoid            Rehabil62:133-135,1981
                                                 arthritis. Ann Phys Med 9:322-327,1968     27. Kellor M, Frost J, Silberberg N, Iverson
sis, there y failing to support the           8. Peskett EB: Hand assessment-a real-             I, Cummings R: Hand strength and
theory th t links joint stress and               istic reappraisal. Hand 9:135-139, 1977        dexterity. Am J Occup Ther 25:77-83,
hand c anges in rheumatoid                    9. Treuhaft PS. Lewis MR, McCarty OJ: A           1971
                                                 rapid method for evaluating the struc-     28, Nalebuff EA: Diagnosis, classification
arthritis.                                       ture and function of the rheumatoid            and management of rheumatoid thumb
   The i terrelationships between                hand, Arthritis Rheum 14:75-85, 1971           deformities, Bull Hosp Joint Dis 29:119-
the forces involved in the use of the        10, Boardman PL, Hart FD: Clinical mea-             137,1965
                                                 surement of the anti-inflammatory          29, Eyler DL, Markee JE: The anatomy and
hand an the joint changes of                     effects of salicylates: rheumatoid             function of the intrinsic musculature of
rheumato'd arthritis are very com-               arthritis. Brit Med J 4:264-268, 1967          the fingers, J Bone Joint Surg 36-A:1-
plex and need more precise and               11, Brown ME: Rheumatoid arthritic hands,           10,1954
                                                 Tactual-visual evaluation approaches.      30, Partridge REH, Duthie JJK: Controlled
careful st dy to become better de-               Am J Occup Ther 20: 17-22, 1966                 trial of the effect of complete immobili-
fined, bot operationally and con-            12, Greenseid DZ, McCormack RM: Func-              zation of the joints in rheumatoid
ceptually. Although the pnnClples                tional hand testing: a profile evalua-         arthritis, Ann Rheum Dis 22:91-99,1963
                                                 tion Plast Reconstr Surg 42:567-571,       31 Gault SJ, Spyker JM Beneficial effect
of hand j in t protection make sense             1968                                            of immobilization of joints in rheuma-
logically nd intuitively, they are           13, Carthum CJ, Clawson, KD, Decker JL,             toid and related arthritides: a splint
not yet str ngly supported by clear-             Functional assessment of the rheuma-            study using sequential analysis, Arthri-
                                                 toid hand, Am J Occup Ther 23:122-             tis Rheum 12:34-44, 1969
cut empir cal data.                              125,1969
710          mber 1981, Volume 35, Number 11