Cat Food Comparison Chart
Cat Food Comparison Chart
Protein % 50-54 55 50 thing you’d think of. And you’d be right. That’s
because they all have one thing in common;
Fat % 22-26 24 22 they are made of basically meat and fat and
almost no carbohydrates. The cat food you
Carbs - digestible 3-4% ZERO Less than 5% choose should match Mother Nature’s nutrient
profile for small creatures and should be at least
50% protein (from animal sources not plant proteins), a balanced fat level of 20% - 24% and should contain no more than 5%
digestible carbs. (Diabetic cats should never have digestible carbohydrates in their food.) The body composition of a Juvenile
mouse is what we believe to be the perfect nutrition for your obligate carnivore.
Ingredients in red on the chart below are comprised of cereal grains, fruits, vegetables, grasses, plant proteins, forage material
and/or other ingredients that contain plant protein. Plant based ingredients that are included as sources of non-digestible dietary
fiber are exempt and not shown in red (examples Tomato Pomace, Beet Pulp, Cellulose, Guar Gum and Pea Fiber). Potato Starch,
although a plant material, is not shown in red because it contains no plant proteins. However it is still important that the total amount
of digestible carbohydrates in the diet remains less than 5%, matching the body composition of a juvenile mouse.
YOUNG AGAIN PHILOSOPHY: The Young Again Philosophy is that digestible carbs in excess of 5% should not be fed to obligate
carnivores like your cat. Young Again also believes that you should feed free choice and not have to restrict feed or portion control
your cat to promote proper weight.
Chart 1 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again
Innova EVO Nature’s Variety Solid Gold Orijen Cat
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Wellness Core
should not be fed Turkey/Chicken Instinct Indigo Moon and Kitten
Cat Food Cat Food
to cats
Deboned
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Turkey Chicken Meal Deboned Turkey Chicken Meal
Chicken
Ingredients
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 9.87 Not Available Not Available 7.5 7
Moisture % max 10 10 10 10 11 10 10
4.63% 6.64% 13.95% 19.12%
0%-Trace 8.47% 17.57%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE Company *NFE *NFE
Grain-Free *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free Supplied Calculated Calculated
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 2 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again Taste of the Wild Blue Buffalo
Orijen 6 Blue Buffalo
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Taste of the Wild Canyon River Wilderness
should not be fed Fresh Fish Wilderness
Cat Food Cat Food trout/salmon Kitten
to cats
Deboned Deboned
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Deboned Salmon Chicken Meal Trout
Chicken Chicken
Ingredients
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 7 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
4.63%
0%-Trace 18.5% 20.67% 33.07% 22.22% 20.15%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis
Grain-Free *NFE Calculated *NFE Estimate * NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 3 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red Felidae
are plant products Young Again Young Again Now
Grain Free Acana Wild Now Wellness
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Turkey/Duck
should not be fed Cat and Kitten Praire Feast Adult Kitten Health
Cat Food Cat Food Kitten
to cats Pure Elements
Deboned Deboned
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Deboned Turkey
Turkey Chicken
Pork Protein Pork Protein
Ingredients
2nd ingredient Turkey Meal Russet Potato Potato Flour Potato Flour Chicken Meal
Concentrate Concentrate
Deboned
3rd ingredient Poultry Fat Poultry Fat Lamb Peas Peas Rice
Chicken
Natural Chicken Deboned
4th ingredient Potato Starch Potatoes Potato Potato Ground Barley
Flavor Walleye
Tomato Pomace
5th ingredient Herring Meal Potato Protein WhiteFish Meal Dried Egg Pea Fiber Ground Rice
(source of fiber)
Cellulose
6th ingredient Herring Meal Peas Peas Canola Oil Dried Egg Chicken Fat
(source of fiber)
Natural Chicken
7th ingredient Fish Oil Chicken Fat Chicken Fat Pea Fiber Tomato Chicken Flavor
Flavor
Fruit/Veggies/
NO NO YES YES YES YES YES
Grasses
Protein % min 55 50 39 35 33 31 36
Fat % min 24 22 20 20 20 18 18
Crude Fiber %
4 4 1.5 3 2.5 2.5 3
Analysis
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 8 Not Available 6 6.5 6.5
Moisture % max 10 10 9 10 10 10 11
4.63% 22% 25% 33.07% 26.65%
0%-Trace 29.45%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE Company *NFE Company *NFE *NFE
Grain-Free *NFE Calculated
Grain-Free Supplied Supplied Calculated Calculated
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 4 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again Eukanuba
Eagle Pack Natural Balance Natural Balance Iams ProActive
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Kitten
should not be fed Kitten Ultra Premium Ultra Premium Health - Kitten
Cat Food Cat Food Chicken
to cats
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Chicken Chicken
Chicken
Pork Protein Pork Protein Ground Chicken
2nd ingredient Chicken By Product Corn Meal
Concentrate Concentrate Brown Rice By Product Meal
Ingredients
Meal
Chicken
3rd ingredient Poultry Fat Poultry Fat Chicken Fat Brown Rice Corn Meal Corn Meal By Product
Meal
Natural Chicken Corn Gluten
4th ingredient Potato Starch Barley Corn Grits Corn Grits Animal Fat
Flavor Meal
Tomato Pomace
5th ingredient Herring Meal Ground Corn Oatmeal Lamb Beet Pulp Beet Pulp
(source of fiber)
Cellulose Anchovy and Brewers Dried Egg Ground
6th ingredient Herring Meal Chicken Fat
(source of fiber) Sardine Meal Rice Product Sorghum
Natural Chicken Dried Egg
7th ingredient Fish Oil Dried Beet Pulp Duck Meal Animal Fat Animal Fat
Flavor Product
Fruit/Veggies/
NO NO NO YES NO NO NO
Grasses
Protein % min 55 50 34 34 34 36 33
Fat % min 24 22 21 18 21 22 21
Crude Fiber %
4 4 3.8 3 2.5 2.5 3
Analysis
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 Not Available Not Available 7 7 7
Moisture % max 10 10 10 10 10 10 10
4.63% 23.25% 26.87%
0%-Trace 25.01% 28.93% 26.35%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE *NFE
Grain-Free *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Calculated
Grain-Free Calculated Calculated
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 5 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red Purina One
are plant products Young Again Young Again Iams NUTRO Max Cat NUTRO Complete Purina One
Beyond
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Healthy Naturals Roasted Chicken Natural Choice Smart Blend
should not be fed Chicken Whole
Cat Food Cat Food Chicken Kitten Growth Kitten Healthy Kitten
to cats Oat Meal
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Chicken
Chicken
Pork Protein Pork Protein Chicken Corn Gluten Corn Gluten
2nd ingredient By Product Chicken Meal
Ingredients
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 7 7 Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 10 10 10 12 12
19.63%
4.63%
0%-Trace 33.07% 27.90% *NFE Estimate 21.66% 33.29%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis
Grain-Free *NFE Calculated *NFE Calculated 22% Starch Company *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free
Supplied
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 6 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again Hills Science
Pro Plan Kitten Pro Plan Selects Royal Canin Royal Canin
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Diet
should not be fed Chicken – Rice Natural Adult Kitten 34 Siamese
Cat Food Cat Food Kitten-Indoor
to cats
Chicken
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Chicken Chicken Meal Chicken Meal By Product
Meal
Ingredients
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 12 12 8 10 Not Available
4.63% 27.3%
0%-Trace 20.08% 23.25% 27.8% 28.71%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE Company
Grain-Free *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free Supplied
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 7 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again Blue for Cats
Science Diet Life’s Purina Cat Chow Blue for Cats
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Healthy Growth
should not be fed Adult Original Abundance Naturals Indoor Health
Cat Food Cat Food for Kittens
to cats
Chicken Deboned Deboned
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Chicken Meal
By Product Meal Chicken Chicken
Ingredients
max
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 Not Available 6.5 Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 Not Available 10 12 10 10
4.63% 37.8%
0%-Trace 27.38% 26.42% 24.28% 35.65%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE Company
Grain-Free *NFE Calculated *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free Supplied
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 8 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again Purina Cat Chow Science Diet Chicken Soup Natural Balance
Meow Mix
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Complete Sensitive for Cat Lovers Pea and Duck
should not be fed Original
Cat Food Cat Food Formula Stomach Soul - Adult LID
to cats
Poultry Ground Yellow
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal Brewers Rice Chicken Peas
By Product Meal Corn
Pork Protein Pork Protein Corn Gluten Corn Gluten
Ingredients
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 12 12 Not Available 10 10
4.63% 36.8%
0%-Trace 31.18% 36.99% 29.97% 38.23%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis *NFE Company
Grain-Free *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free Supplied
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.
Chart 9 of 9 REGULAR Cat Food Brand
Ingredients in red
are plant products Young Again Young Again
Friskies Indoor 9 Lives
that we believe Zero Carb 50/22 Whiskas
should not be fed Delights Plus Care
Cat Food Cat Food
to cats
Poultry Ground Yellow Ground Yellow
1st ingredient Chicken Meal Chicken Meal
By Product Meal Corn Corn
Pork Protein Pork Protein Ground Yellow Corn Gluten Corn Gluten
Ingredients
2nd ingredient
Concentrate Concentrate Corn Meal Meal
Chicken By Poultry
3rd ingredient Poultry Fat Poultry Fat Brewers Rice
Product Meal By Product Meal
Natural Chicken Corn Gluten Meat & Bone
4th ingredient Potato Starch Ground Wheat
Flavor Meal Meal
Tomato Pomace
5th ingredient Herring Meal Beet Pulp Soybean Meal Animal Digest
(source of fiber)
Cellulose Natural Chicken
6th ingredient Herring Meal Beef Tallow Animal Fat
(source of fiber) Flavor
Natural Chicken Turkey Meat & Bone
7th ingredient Fish Oil Animal Fat
Flavor By Product Meal Meal
Fruit/Veggies/
NO NO NO NO NO
Grasses
Protein % min 55 50 31.5 30 31
Fat % min 24 22 9.5-11.5 9 9
Crude Fiber %
4 4 6 5 3
max
Analysis
Total Dietary
9 9 Not Available Not Available Not Available
Fiber %
Ash % max 6.6 6.2 Not Available Not Available Not Available
Moisture % max 10 10 12 12 12
4.63%
0%-Trace 33.82% 39.1% 40.16%
Carbohydrate % Lab Analysis
Grain-Free *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate *NFE Estimate
Grain-Free
* NFE Company Supplied = pet food company has supplied the carbohydrate level of their diet.
* NFE Calculated=pet food Company Supplied Guaranteed Analysis for Protein, Fat, Fiber, Moisture and Ash which can then be added together and subtracted from 100 to calculate the estimated
carbohydrate contents of the food or NFE.
* NFE Estimate = Companies have supplied the percent of protein, fat, fiber and moisture in the diet but did not supply the Ash Content. We have estimated the Carbohydrate content of these diets by assuming an ash
content of 7%. Typical ash content for almost all cat foods is usually between 6-10%.
All information was taken from Individual company websites between Sept 8th- Sept 22, 2011. We will update this information when any company supplies us with newly published data.