Rooting Ability of Cocoa
Rooting Ability of Cocoa
net/publication/325547363
CITATIONS READS
5 2,111
5 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Rose Caspa on 27 August 2018.
Authors’ contributions
This work was carried out in collaboration between all authors. Author KMDK designed the
experiment, carried out the research and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. Author DTT initiated
the concept, designed the experiment, performed the statistical analysis and wrote the article. Author
RGC wrote the article with literature searches. Authors GYAB and LJB designed the experiment,
wrote the protocol and managed the analysis of the study. All authors read and approved the final
manuscript.
Article Information
DOI: 10.9734/AJAHR/2018/40168
Editor(s):
(1) Fatemeh Nejatzadeh-Barandozi, Department of Horticulture, Faculty of Agriculture, Azad Islamiz University of Khoy, West
Azarbayjan, Khoy, Iran.
Reviewers:
(1) Bado Souleymane, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences, Austria.
(2) R. Mahalakshmi, India.
Complete Peer review History: http://www.sciencedomain.org/review-history/23865
ABSTRACT
Aims: This study aimed to evaluate the rooting ability of stem cuttings of eight-year-old cocoa
th
hybrids disseminated in the 5 agroecological zone of Cameroon.
Study Design: The experiment was a 6 x 2 x 3 randomised complete block design with three
replications.
Place and Duration of Study: The study was conducted at the multipurpose agricultural research
station Nkoemvone – Ebolowa from February to September 2017.
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
Methodology: The studied factors were six genotypes (G1 = IMC67 x SNK 64, G2 = SNK 620 x
MA 12, G3 = T79/501 x SNK 109, G4 = T79/501 x SNK 64, G5 = SNK 413 x UPA 143 and G6 =
UPA 143 x SNK 64), two Cutting types (C1 = Orthotropic and C2 = Plagiotropic) and three rooting
hormone concentrations (H1 = 2 tablets per liter of water, H2 = ½ tablet per liter of water and H3 =
1 tablet per liter of water). Rooting ability was evaluated by assessing percentage of rooted
cuttings, number of root per rooted cutting and the length of the longest root per rooted cutting.
Results: Analysis of variance results indicated that genotype, hormone concentration and most of
their interactions were highly significant while cutting type was not significant on the measured
traits. The best rooting was obtained with genotype G4 for all the measured parameters. It was
shown in this experiment that genotype G4 could be propagated using Rhizopon hormone, with a
concentration of ½ tablet per litre of water and plagiotropic cutting type. This is also noticed in their
interaction terms, where genotype G4/Hormone concentration 2 and 3 were the best combinations
for all parameters.
Conclusion: Significant differences among genotypes are an indication that different genotypes
may require different conditions for their propagation. As such investigations into the requirement
for the propagation of the other genotypes should be considered in the future.
Keywords: Theobroma cacao; vegetative propagation; hybrid; cutting type; rooting; hormone
concentration; 5th agroecological zone.
2
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
3
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
Table 1. Mean values of percentage of rooted cuttings, number of root per rooted cuttings and
the length of the longest root per cutting among genotypes
4
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
hormone concentration H3 (1 tablet per litre of cutting and the length of the longest root with
water). Results of ANOVA revealed that both orthotropic and plagiotrophic cuttings each
hormone concentration had a highly significant producing 6 roots per cutting and 8.1 cm for the
effect on number of roots with P = 0.000. There length of the longest root at 5%, with P = 0.87
was no significant difference in root number (Table 3).
between ½ and 1 hormone tablet per litre of
water, which induced the greatest number of 3.4 Interaction Effect between
roots with mean values of 6.53 ± 2.83 and 6.33 ± Genotype/Hormone Concentration on
2.86 respectively. The least number of roots was the Percentage of Rooted Cuttings,
produced by hormone concentration H1 with 2 the Number of Roots and Length of
tablets per litre of water (Table 2).
the Longest Root
ANOVA results reveal that hormone
concentration had a significant effect on length of Significant interaction effect was found in
the longest root at the level of 5 % with P = 0.000 genotype/hormone concentration on the number
(Table 2). It was observed that the longest root of rooted cuttings (P = 0.012) and the length of
length was induced by ½ and 1 hormone tablet the longest root (P = 0.00). There was no
per litre of water, which showed no significant significant effect on the percentage of rooted
difference at the 5% level, with mean root lengths cutting and the results could not be reported
of 9.19 ± 4.17cm and 9.18 ± 4.41 cm. further. The highest mean number of root per
rooted cutting was obtained from the interactions
3.3 Effect of Cutting Type on the between genotype 4 and hormone
Percentage of Rooted Cuttings, concentrations 2 and 3, which showed mean root
Number of Root and Length of the per cutting as 10.7 and 10.5 respectively (Fig. 2,
Longest Root 3). This was followed by genotype 4/ two tablets
per litre of water (8.8 mean roots). For the mean
According to the ANOVA results, cutting type had number of roots genotype, 4 was highest in all
significant influence on the percentage of rooted the concentration applied. Genotype 5/hormone
cutting at 5 %, with P = 0.025 with plagiotrophic concentration 1 had the lowest mean number of
cuttings showing the highest (70.37 ± 15.55) roots with 2.9. It was shown that hormone
percentage of rooted cuttings. Cutting type had concentration 1 recorded the lowest mean
no influence on the number of roots per rooted number of roots for all the genotypes.
Table 2. Mean values of percentage of rooted cuttings, number of root per rooted cuttings and
the length of the longest root per cutting among hormone concentrations
Table 3. Mean values of percentage of rooted cuttings, number of root per rooted cuttings and
the length of the longest root per cutting among cutting types
5
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
The longest roots were induced by interactions and Lass [3], reported that differences in cocoa
between genotype 4/concentration 2 and 3, with genotypes lead to differences in their rooting
mean root lengths of 14.6 and 14.8 cm abilities. The fact of having obtained the best
respectively (Fig. 4, 5). Other interesting results rooting parameters with hybrid T79 / 501 x
came from interactions between genotype SNK64, T79 / 501 x SNK 109, UPA 143 x SNK
3/concentration 3 (12.4 cm), genotype 64, could be explained by the fact that in these
3/concentration 2 (12.2 cm), genotype hybridizations the African clones are involved
4/concentration 1(12cm). On their part, (SNK : Cameroonian clone, and T79 / 501:
interactions between genotype 6/concentrations Ghanaian clone), thus corroborating with the
3, 2 and genotype 3/concentration 1 each observations of [26], who reported that
produced longest roots of about 10 cm. Amazonian high clones such as UPA 143, and
those belonging to the Trinitario group such as
4. DISCUSSION T79 / 501 and the SNK, are more efficient during
cuttings, and therefore root better. For the effect
The results obtained on the genetic potential give of hormone concentration, it was also observed
us information on the effectiveness of the that the higher hormone concentration had a
differences in the rooting of the cuttings from the negative impact on the percentage of rooted
difference in the genetic potential of the hybrids. cuttings whereby hormone concentration H1 (2
Current literature on cocoa propagation does not tablet per litre of water) had the lowest (61.25 ±
provide information on the rooting of cuttings 12.67) mean percentage of rooted cuttings. In
taken from hybrids, as cuttings are often the test of the effect of concentration on the
collected mostly from clones. Similar results were rooting of cuttings, the results showed that the
obtained by Hall [26]. Toxopeus [27], and Wood concentration of the rhizogenic hormone solution
Fig. 3. Age of rooted cuttings, a) Genotype 3/Two Rhizopon tablets per litre of water b)
Genotype 3/½ Rhizopon tablet per litre of water c) Genotype 4/1Rhizopon tablet per litre of
water
6
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
a b c
has indeed a consequence on the rooting; these economically important, but also reduce plant
results corroborate those from the [28, 27]. Wood production failures that sometimes occur when
and Lass [3] and Essola et al. [24] experiments, the hormone is missing or being not easily
which reported that hormones are one of the accessible.
important factors influencing the rooting of
cuttings; having obtained better rooting results at The observation of the non-significance of the
the lower concentrations of 1 and 0.5 tablets per rooting differences of cuttings according to
liter rather than the highest concentration of 2 whether they are orthotropic or plagiotropic, is in
tablets per liter, may be due to the fact that the line with the results obtained by Murray [30] cited
hormone used is based on auxin, slowing the by Lockwood [31], who reported that the root
activity of stimulation of rhizogenesis, due to an system of cocoa plants grown from rooted
excessive concentration of auxin, as underlined plagiotropic cuttings is similar to that of seedlings
by Charvet-Candela [29]. However, the non- grown from seeds. Several authors [32, 33, 8],
significance of the rooting results recorded for report that the plants resulting from the rooting of
hormone solution concentrations of ½ tablet per plagiotropic cuttings adopt a bulky canopy in
liter and 1 tablet per liter both gave better results, culture and have a low resistance to lodging and
it would be sensible and recommendable for water stress, this being explained in that these
users of Rhizopon, opting for the lowest plants do not develop a taproot, unlike plants
concentration, ½ tablet, which could not only be resulting from the cutting of orthotropic branches;
7
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
in the case of this study, these pivotal roots have for all the measured parameters, while no
not been observed on orthotropic cuttings that significant effect between genotype and cutting
have been experimented; this could be explained type. With the increasing demand of planting
by the stage of root development, perhaps not materials in this zone of Cameroon it is
advanced enough to be able to distinguish recommended on the basis of this work carried
between lateral roots and pivoting roots. These out to evaluate the cutting ability of cocoa hybrids
same authors as well as Lee [34] emphasized to clone the cocoa hybrids by cuttings. This will
that this lack of taproot is a disadvantage for not only reduce the time it takes for stock plants
cultivation, especially during periods when to flower but also reduce the problems with
rainfall is not sufficient; However, Boulay [35] sophisticated equipment required by manual
considers that this lack of root actually affects pollination.
little the mineral nutrition of the plant, because
the cocoa tree is a humicole species, which have ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
nearly 85% of its roots grouped in the surface
horizon in the first 25 cm approximately. The first author is grateful to IRAD Nkoemvone
Interaction effects have never been studied in for permitting him assessed their structure used
propagation techniques in cocoa and comparison their facilities and work staff during the internship
can only be done using some tropical forest and period.
fruit trees. Significant interaction effect between
genotype and hormone (NAA) in rooting ability of COMPETING INTERESTS
P. santalinoides was reported by Dembele et al.
[36]. Authors have declared that no competing
interests exist.
5. CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
The present study focused on the evaluation of
the rooting ability of hybrids of cacao in the wet 1. Whitlock BA, Bayer C, Baum D.
forest zone with bimodal rainfall in Cameroon, Phylogenetic relationships and floral
where it was necessary to test the influence of evolution of the Bettnerioideae
the genetic potential, the concentration of (“Sterculiaceae” or Malvaceae S.1) based
Rhizogen hormone solution (Rhizopon) and on sequences of the chloroplast genre
cutting types on the rooting of the cuttings. ndhF. Systematic Botany. 2001;26:420-
Testing these effects showed that all the cocoa 437.
hybrids that have been the subject of this 2. Niemenak N, Cilas C, Rohsius C,
experiment can indeed be propagated Bleiholder H, Meier U. Lieberei R.
vegetatively by stem cuttings. However, more Phenological growth stages of cacao
specifically, the number of buds emitted, the plants (Theobroma sp.): Codification and
percentage of rooted cuttings, the number of description according to the BBCH scale.
roots emitted and the length of the longest root Annals of Applied Biology. 2010;156:13-
emitted vary greatly depending on the hybrid. 24.
Hybrids T79 / 501 X SNK 64, T79 / 501 X SNK 3. Wood GAR, Lass RA. Cocoa. 4th edition,
109 and UPA 143 X SNK 64 gave better results, Blackwell Science Ltd. London, UK; 1985.
unlike the hybrids SNK 413 X UPA 143, which 4. Mossu G. Le cacaoyer. Maisonneuve et
gave unsatisfactory results. The concentration of Larose, Paris: 9-15 et 1990:140-145.
the solution of the hormone used has an effect French.
on the rooting of the cuttings with the best rooting 5. Babin R. Contribution à l’amélioration de la
obtained for concentration 0.5 tablet of Rhizopon lutte contre le miride du cacaoyer
per liter. It was noticed that among the Sahlbergella singularis Hagl. (Hemiptera :
concentration used, a uniform trend could be Miridae). Influence des facteurs agro-
found, the lowest concentration having the écologiques sur la dynamique des
highest values for all the measured parameters. populations du ravageur. Thèse de
Thus, indicating higher concentrations may be Doctorat de l’Université de Montpellier III,
detrimental for the propagation of these hybrids. Département Biologie Ecologie
However, the conclusion will need more Environnement Montpellier: France; 2009.
experimental procedures with higher French.
concentrations. There was an interaction effect 6. Atlas. Atlas de l’Intégration Régionale en
between genotype and hormone concentration Afrique de l’Ouest; 2007. French.
8
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
9
Kamga et al.; AJAHR, 1(2): 1-10, 2018; Article no.AJAHR.40168
© 2018 Kamga et al.; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium,
provided the original work is properly cited.
Peer-review history:
The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
http://www.sciencedomain.org/review-history/23865
10