Culture 1
Culture 1
Anuroopa Mahajan
Introduction
This article discusses the relation-
ship between talent management The term ‘talent management’ has
and organizational culture. Talent been in use for more than two decades
management is associated with now. It is being defined differently by
various human resource practices researchers and practitioners. Organiza-
and is gaining importance in or- tions are adopting various practices of
ganizations in order to achieve talent management focusing on differ-
competitive advantage. Organiza- ent aspects such as leadership develop-
tional culture is developed by ment, employment stages, organizational
leaders in the organization which processes based on the present chang-
encompasses core values and be- ing business environment. This is needed
liefs. Different types of organiza- so that organizations can develop com-
tional culture that exist in organi- petitive advantage and talented employ-
zation is discussed, such as bu- ees drive this advantage. Therefore tal-
reaucratic, entrepreneurial clan ent management is needed to focus on
and marketing along with strong the talent of the organization, who are
and weak cultures. Organizational most skilled and experienced employees.
culture is associated with various In this paper we will be discussing tal-
functions and one of them is ef- ent management and its relationship with
fective talent management. Orga- organizational culture in light of current
nizational culture is also associ- corporate milieu.
ated with business strategy to gain
competitive advantage. Latest The culture of an organization rep-
trends in business scenario with resents the way things are done in the
respect to organizational culture organization. It mainly revolves around
have also been discussed. the behavioral patterns and relationships.
Culture is developed over a period of
time in the organization by the people
Anuroopa Mahajan is Research Fellow, Indian
Institute of Management, Kashipur Uttarakhand,
who work for it. To create a dynamic
India. E-mail:anuroopa.efpm2014@iimkashipur.ac.in. culture organization’s core values and its
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 471
Anuroopa Mahajan
472 The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019
Relationship of Talent Management with Organizational Culture
of talent management such as talent ac- of the organization. In this way organi-
quisition, leadership development, per- zational cultures are created by
formance management and building cul- leaders,what leaders pay consideration
ture. Berger and Berger (2009) have ar- to, what actions are rewarded or pun-
ticulated about talent management in ished and distribution of resources is
their handbook. They have inferred from under consideration(Caver & White,
their research, consulting assignments 2013).
and from inputs of eminent authors, that
talent management is required to cre-
Invisible layer is built within, it is
ate a culture for success in the organi-
deeply embedded within the orga-
zation. It is based on certain factors such
nization and includes common val-
as the internal beliefs, which includes
ues, beliefs or faith and norms of
core principles, values and mutual op-
the organization.
portunities of an organization and its
employees, talent strategy of the orga-
nization which specifies the types of Culture is two tiered – one the vis-
employee organization would be invest- ible layer or characteristics and sec-
ing in and talent management system, ond the invisible. Visible characteris-
processes and procedures. tics include external features such as
building, furniture, dress code, behav-
To sum up the importance of talent iors, processes and regulations.
management, it is vital for human re- Whereas invisible layer is built within,
source department to place right talent it is deeply embedded within the orga-
at the right place and right talent is the nization and includes common values,
biggest asset for an organization (Ramco, beliefs or faith and norms of the orga-
2012). Organizations thus should focus nization (Schein, 1990).Organizational
on managing the talent: most skilled and culture depends upon many factors,
experienced individuals. For organizations such as the type of business an organi-
retaining talent is of ultimate importance zation is in, its products and custom-
to stay ahead of the competitors ers, its size and location and methods
(Serendi, 2015). of operation (Rowe, et al., 1994).
Hellriegel and Slocum (2010) in their
Types of Organizational Cultures book Organizational Behavior have
elaborated on typology of organizational
Leaders outline the vision and mis- culture and have pointed towards four
sion for an organization – define and dif- types of organizational cultures viz. bu-
ferentiate the organization. Leaders take reaucratic culture, clan culture, entre-
the responsibility to model and reinforce preneurial culture and market culture.
the behavior that helps to accomplish or- These cultures develop in the organi-
ganizational goals and to ensure they zation depending on their focus on
are creating and cultivating a culture that forms of organization attention and con-
promotes engagement of talent segment trol orientation (Fig.1).
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 473
Anuroopa Mahajan
474 The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019
Relationship of Talent Management with Organizational Culture
lowing this culture are able to react Rowe et al (1994) have elaborated on
quickly to the change and adapt be- cultural environments that exist in organi-
cause individuals are encouraged and zation based on their value system, norms
rewarded for their initiatives, flexibil- and organization’s orientation whether it
ity and for growth prospects. Such is technical or social. Four types of cor-
organizations have their attention fo- porate cultures identified by them include
cused externally and control orienta- Productive Culture, Quality Culture, Cre-
tion is flexible in order to nurture in- ative Culture and Supportive Culture. Pro-
novation and change. ductive culture is present in those organi-
zations where orientation is technical and
4 Market Culture – Achievement of fi-
stress is given on efficiency, consistency
nancial and market oriented goals is
and performance. This type of culture
the primary focus of this culture. The
resists change. The Quality Culture fo-
relationship between employee and
cuses on problem solving and effective
organization is contractual where
planning for the organization’s growth.
terms and conditions are agreed upon
Such organizations can accept change
and hence formal control orientation
when it occurs as they are flexible in their
is quite strong. Since employee is ex-
approach. Achievement of individual is of
pected to perform the set standard of
great value and organization has techni-
output, organization has to give remu-
cal orientation. The Creative Culture is in-
neration based on the same. Competi-
novative and entrepreneurial and is in-
tiveness and a profit gaining attitude
clined towards risk taking and initiating
persists in the entire organization as
change. Organization with Creative Cul-
better performance of employees is
ture values individual achievement and is
rewarded in the form of increased
social in orientation. The Supportive Cul-
remuneration (Hellriegel & Slocum,
ture has teamwork, cooperation and rein-
2010, Cameron & Quinn, 2011).
forcement of it values as characteristics.
Similarly Terrence Dean and Allan Organization focuses on performance and
Kennedy (2000) have also discussed cor- has social orientation. Thus they are able
porate culture as strong and weak cultures. to give a quick and ready response to the
A strong culture is composed of deeply held change.
core values and beliefs. It is also supported
by all members of the organization. Cer- Organizational Culture & Talent
tain features of strong culture are a com- Management
mon shared philosophy, consideration of
individuals, recognition of protagonists, be- Brown (1995) associates several
lief in ritual and ceremony, well framed, functions with organizational culture such
informed and understood informal rules and as conflict resolution, control and coor-
expectations. On the other hand a weak dination, motivation and competitive ad-
culture is not supported by members of vantage. Greenberg and Baron (2003)
organization as it is not deep rooted in the differ in their opinion, regarding functions
value system of the organization.. of organizational culture, from that of
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 475
Anuroopa Mahajan
Andrew Brown (1995). They say culture not necessarily associated with only one
provides a sense of identity, generates type of culture, rather there will be dif-
organizational commitment as well as ferent cultures depending upon the na-
commitment to the mission of the orga- ture of task to be performed, determined
nization and reinforces standards of be- goals, external environment, rules and
havior. They also emphasize that culture regulations, policies and types of individu-
influences employee attitude and behav- als employed in the organization at that
ior in the organization which results in point of time. Thus, organizational cul-
better commitment of employees to- ture has association with the employees
wards organization and higher perfor- of the organization and vice – versa.
mance is delivered.
Organizational culture is one of the
determinants of effective talent manage-
Culture influences employee atti-
ment as discussed by Wilska (2014) (Fig.
tude and behavior in the organiza-
2).Along with managerial staff who men-
tion.
tors the young talents in the organization,
personnel department takes care of all
Organizations have to face certain ex- the human resource activities, skills and
ternal (outside the organization) and in- competencies to identify the right talent,
ternal (within the organization) challenges systems of management and leadership
which call for a culture of external adap- style, corporate image in the market and
tation, internal integration and anxiety re- allocated budget for talent management
duction. For external adaptation organi- programs. Corporate culture that pro-
zations have to develop a strategic mis- motes learning and development of hu-
sion statement, set critical goals, which is man capital is very crucial for effective
facilitated by employee empowerment and talent management. Corporate cultures
establish planning and control system, so where managerial staff is constantly in-
that proactively organization can take volved at all levels in development of tal-
adaptive measures.Control system helps ent has a huge impact on overall talent
in evaluating the measures. Internal inte- management process in the organization.
gration can be achieved by having a com-
mon language, understood by all employ-
Corporate cultures where manage-
ees, which helps to develop bonding within
rial staff is constantly involved at
the organization. To increase accountabil-
all levels in development of talent
ity and responsibility, inclusive criteria
has a huge impact on overall tal-
should be used wherein all the employees
ent management process in the
are included in organizational activities.
organization.
Cross function team building helps in de-
veloping peer relationship (Hayden, 1986).
Wilska (2014) also talks about suc-
It is argued by Lesley Willcoxson and cession planning, future leaders, reiter-
Bruce Millet (2000) that organizations are ating that corporate culture, in form of
476 The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019
Relationship of Talent Management with Organizational Culture
traditions and procedures, plays a cru- ment, links organization’s success directly
cial role. She also points out that com- to commonality among talent manage-
munication is essential for effective tal- ment, employee engagement and organi-
ent management. Good communication is zational culture. He says the causal link
important for creating a pleasant envi- among the three is powerful. He gives a
ronment and conveying values of the or- comparison with rowing crew’s connec-
ganization, this helps in maintaining em- tion between rowers, oars and scull. Tim
ployee loyalty towards organization. defines talent management using compo-
Ewelina concludes by saying that talent nent of commitment to recruit, retain and
management is gaining strategic impor- develop the talented employees of the
tance for organizations to achieve com- organization. This commitment can be
petitive advantage (Wilska, 2014).Align- enriched by effective employee engage-
ing organizational culture with business ment, wherein employee invests time,
strategy is of importance for gaining com- energy, skills, knowledge and creativity
petitive advantage. There are organiza- in the direction set by the organization.
tions who promote innovation like Apple Organizational culture contributes to-
and Google. Employees are rewarded wards employee engagement, as culture
when their innovative ideas strike a jack- is composed of values and behaviors that
pot but they are not penalized for a con- contribute towards the environment of
structive failure. Such organizations en- the organization.
courage employees to think creatively,
innovatively and share their ideas (Caver Organizational culture impacts three
& White, 2013). talent management components – recruit-
ment, development and retention. Recruit-
Tim Wright, a professional coach in ment is the first point of contact for a can-
talent engagement and culture improve- didate with the organization. This process
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 477
Anuroopa Mahajan
478 The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019
Relationship of Talent Management with Organizational Culture
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 479
Anuroopa Mahajan
480 The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019
Relationship of Talent Management with Organizational Culture
The Indian Journal of Industrial Relations, Vol. 54, No. 3, January 2019 481
Copyright of Indian Journal of Industrial Relations is the property of Shri Ram Centre for
Industrial Relations, Human Resources, Economic & Social Development and its content may
not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's
express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for
individual use.