Text 5
Text 5
Parenting styles are the general patterns of behaviors and attitudes that parents
exhibit toward their children. Different parenting styles can have different
effects on children's development, health, and well-being. In this article, we will
review the four main parenting styles: indulgent, authoritarian, authoritative, and
uninvolved, and discuss how they are practiced and perceived in Zambia, a sub-
Saharan African country with diverse cultural and socioeconomic contexts. We will
also explore the implications of parenting styles for early childhood development
(ECD), which is crucial for children's cognitive, emotional, social, behavioral,
and physical development. Finally, we will provide some recommendations for
promoting positive parenting practices that support optimal child development in
Zambia.
According to Baumrind (1967, 1971), who first proposed the concept of parenting
styles, there are two dimensions of parenting: responsiveness and demandingness.
Responsiveness refers to the extent to which parents are sensitive, supportive, and
responsive to their children's needs and emotions. Demandingness refers to the
extent to which parents have expectations, rules, and standards for their
children's behavior and performance. Based on these two dimensions, Baumrind
identified three parenting styles: authoritative, authoritarian, and permissive.
Later, Maccoby and Martin (1983) added a fourth style: uninvolved. These four
parenting styles are briefly described below:
• Authoritative parents are balanced and flexible with their children. They have
reasonable rules and expectations, and they enforce them with consistent and fair
consequences. They are responsive to their children's needs and emotions, and they
value independence and individuality. Authoritative parents are warm and
supportive, and they provide guidance and structure. Children of authoritative
parents tend to be confident and competent, as they are encouraged to explore and
learn. They have high self-esteem and self-regulation, as they are taught to
respect themselves and others. They have good social and academic skills, as they
are able to cooperate and communicate effectively (Baumrind, 1967, 1971; Maccoby &
Martin, 1983).
• Authoritarian parents are very strict and demanding with their children. They
have many rules and expectations, and they enforce them with harsh punishments.
They are unresponsive to their children's needs and emotions, and they value
obedience and conformity over individuality and autonomy. Authoritarian parents may
be cold and hostile, or they may be warm and caring. Children of authoritarian
parents tend to be obedient and respectful, but they may also be fearful and
anxious. They may have low self-esteem and self-expression, as they are afraid of
making mistakes and displeasing their parents. They may have difficulty coping with
stress and challenges, as they lack problem-solving and decision-making skills
(Baumrind, 1967, 1971; Maccoby & Martin, 1983).
• Permissive parents are very lenient and permissive with their children. They
have few rules and expectations, and they rarely enforce consequences. They are
responsive to their children's needs and desires, but they do not provide much
guidance or structure. Permissive parents may be affectionate and supportive, or
they may be indifferent and neglectful. Children of permissive parents tend to have
low self-control and self-regulation, as they are used to getting their way. They
may also have low self-esteem and academic achievement, as they lack motivation and
discipline. They may have difficulty respecting authority and following social
norms (Baumrind, 1967, 1971; Maccoby & Martin, 1983).
• Uninvolved parents are detached and indifferent with their children. They have
few or no rules and expectations, and they rarely monitor or supervise their
children's activities. They are unresponsive to their children's needs and
emotions, and they value their own interests and well-being over their children's.
Uninvolved parents may be neglectful and abusive, or they may be overwhelmed and
depressed. Children of uninvolved parents tend to be insecure and unhappy, as they
feel unloved and unwanted. They may have low self-esteem and self-control, as they
lack support and guidance. They may have poor social and academic outcomes, as they
lack skills and resources (Maccoby & Martin, 1983).
There is limited research on parenting styles in Zambia, but some studies have
explored the traditional and contemporary parenting practices and perceptions of
Zambian parents and children. For example, a study by UNICEF and the Ministry of
General Education (MoGE) in 2018 investigated the traditional parenting and child
care practices in 10 districts across five Zambian provinces, using qualitative
methods such as interviews and focus group discussions. The study aimed to inform
parenting programs intended to promote optimal ECD outcomes by understanding the
cultural context in which children develop. The study found that Zambian parents
have diverse and complex parenting practices and beliefs, influenced by various
factors such as ethnicity, religion, education, gender, location, and socioeconomic
status. The study also identified some common themes and patterns across the study
districts, which are summarized below:
Parenting styles are the general patterns of behaviors and attitudes that parents
exhibit toward their children. Different parenting styles can have different
effects on children's development, health, and well-being. In this article, I will
discuss the following four parenting styles in comprehensive details, giving the
advantages and disadvantages to each, as well as how it works, with relevant
examples from Zambia, Africa and globally where necessary:
• Indulgent
• Authoritarian
• Authoritative
• Uninvolved
Indulgent Parenting
Indulgent parenting, also known as permissive parenting, is a parenting style in
which parents are very lenient and permissive with their children. They have few
rules and expectations, and they rarely enforce consequences. They are responsive
to their children's needs and desires, but they do not provide much guidance or
structure. Indulgent parents may be affectionate and supportive, or they may be
indifferent and neglectful.
• Children may develop a strong sense of independence and self-reliance. They have
more freedom to explore their interests without parental interference.
• Children may have high self-esteem and confidence, as they are valued and
accepted by their parents.
• Children may have good social skills and relationships, as they are exposed to
diverse people and situations.
• Children may be more creative and innovative, as they are encouraged to express
themselves and try new things.
• Children may have low self-control and self-regulation, as they are used to
getting their way. They may have difficulty following rules and boundaries, and may
act impulsively or irresponsibly.
• Children may have low academic achievement and motivation, as they lack
discipline and direction. They may struggle with time management, organization, and
goal-setting.
• Children may have difficulty respecting authority and following social norms, as
they are not taught to consider the rights and feelings of others. They may be
rebellious, defiant, or aggressive.
• Children may be more vulnerable to peer pressure and risky behaviors, such as
substance abuse, sexual activity, or delinquency, as they seek excitement and
validation from others.
How It Works
Indulgent parenting works by giving children a lot of freedom and autonomy, but not
enough guidance and structure. Indulgent parents tend to be more like friends than
authority figures to their children. They may use praise, rewards, or bribes to
influence their children's behavior, rather than rules, expectations, or
consequences. They may also avoid conflict or confrontation with their children,
and may give in to their demands or wishes. Indulgent parents may have a warm and
loving relationship with their children, but they may also neglect their children's
needs or development.
Examples
Some examples of indulgent parenting are:
• A parent who lets their child stay up late, watch TV, play video games, or eat
junk food whenever they want, without any limits or restrictions.
• A parent who buys their child expensive gifts, clothes, or gadgets, even if they
cannot afford them or if the child does not need them, just to make them happy or
to avoid tantrums.
• A parent who does not monitor or supervise their child's homework, schoolwork,
or extracurricular activities, and does not help them with their academic or
personal goals.
• A parent who does not set or enforce any rules or boundaries for their child,
such as chores, manners, or curfews, and lets them do whatever they please, without
any consequences or accountability.
• Lack of time or resources to provide adequate care and supervision for their
children, due to work, poverty, or other challenges.
Some examples of indulgent parenting in Zambia, Africa, or other parts of the world
are:
• A parent who lets their child skip school, roam the streets, or join gangs,
without any intervention or protection, due to poverty, violence, or corruption.
• A parent who spoils their child with material possessions, money, or privileges,
without any expectations or responsibilities, due to wealth, status, or influence.
• A parent who does not teach their child about their culture, religion, or
values, and lets them adopt foreign or modern lifestyles, without any respect or
appreciation, due to globalization, migration, or assimilation.
• A parent who does not involve their child in their family, community, or
society, and lets them live in their own world, without any connection or
contribution, due to individualism, technology, or consumerism.
Authoritarian Parenting
Authoritarian parenting, also known as strict parenting, is a parenting style in
which parents are very strict and demanding with their children. They have many
rules and expectations, and they enforce them with harsh punishments. They are
unresponsive to their children's needs and emotions, and they value obedience and
conformity over individuality and autonomy. Authoritarian parents may be cold and
hostile, or they may be warm and caring.
• Children may be obedient and respectful, as they are taught to follow rules and
authority. They may have good manners, morals, and ethics, as they are taught to
distinguish right from wrong.
• Children may have high academic achievement and performance, as they are pushed
to excel and succeed. They may have good study habits, concentration, and memory,
as they are trained to work hard and focus.
• Children may be safe and protected, as they are kept away from harm and danger.
They may have good physical health, as they are disciplined to eat well, exercise,
and avoid risky behaviors.
• Children may be fearful and anxious, as they are exposed to stress and pressure.
They may have low self-esteem and self-expression, as they are afraid of making
mistakes and displeasing their parents.
• Children may have poor social and emotional skills, as they are not allowed to
express their feelings or opinions. They may have difficulty coping with stress and
challenges, as they lack problem-solving and decision-making skills.
• Children may be rebellious and defiant, as they resent their parents' control
and dominance. They may seek freedom and autonomy, and may engage in oppositional
or deviant behaviors, such as lying, cheating, or breaking rules.
How It Works
Authoritarian parenting works by imposing a high level of control and discipline on
children, but not providing enough warmth and responsiveness. Authoritarian parents
tend to be more like dictators than leaders to their children. They may use
threats, criticism, or physical force to influence their children's behavior,
rather than praise, rewards, or explanations. They may also ignore or dismiss their
children's needs or emotions, and may expect them to obey without question.
Authoritarian parents may have a rigid and strict relationship with their children,
but they may also have a loyal and obedient relationship with them.
Examples
Some examples of authoritarian parenting are:
• A parent who sets and enforces a strict schedule for their child, such as waking
up, eating, studying, sleeping, etc., without any flexibility or variation.
• A parent who punishes their child severely for any misbehavior, such as hitting,
yelling, or grounding, without any warning or justification.
• A parent who does not allow their child to have any choices or preferences, such
as what to wear, what to play, or who to be friends with, and makes all the
decisions for them.
• A parent who does not listen to or respect their child's feelings or opinions,
and tells them what to think, feel, or do, without any consideration or
explanation.
• Respect for tradition or authority, as they believe that parents know best and
children should obey and honor them, according to their culture, religion, or
values.
• Fear for survival or security, as they face threats and challenges from poverty,
violence, or corruption, and want to protect and prepare their children for a harsh
and competitive world.
• Desire for success or achievement, as they have high expectations and standards
for their children, and want them to excel and prosper in their education, career,
or life.
• Influence from family, community, or society, as they follow the norms and
practices of their peers, elders, or leaders, and want to fit in and conform to
their expectations and demands.
• A parent who beats their child with a stick, belt, or wire, for any mistake or
disobedience, such as failing an exam, talking back, or staying out late, as a form
of discipline or correction.
• A parent who forces their child to marry, work, or join a group, against their
will or consent, such as an arranged marriage, child labor, or a cult, as a form of
obligation or duty.
• A parent who forbids their child to pursue their interests or passions, such as
music,
Authoritative Parenting
Authoritative parenting, also known as democratic parenting, is a parenting style
in which parents are balanced and flexible with their children. They have
reasonable rules and expectations, and they enforce them with consistent and fair
consequences. They are responsive to their children's needs and emotions, and they
value independence and individuality. Authoritative parents are warm and
supportive, and they provide guidance and structure.
• Children may have high social and academic skills, as they are encouraged to
cooperate and communicate effectively. They have good problem-solving and decision-
making skills, as they are involved in setting and achieving their goals.
• Children may be happy and healthy, as they are supported and nurtured by their
parents. They have good emotional and physical health, as they are able to express
their feelings and cope with stress.
• Children may be rebellious and defiant, as they may test their limits and
challenge their parents' authority. They may seek more autonomy and independence,
and may resist their parents' guidance or influence.
How It Works
Authoritative parenting works by providing a balance of control and responsiveness
to children, but not too much or too little of either. Authoritative parents tend
to be more like mentors than managers to their children. They may use praise,
rewards, or explanations to influence their children's behavior, rather than
threats, criticism, or physical force. They may also listen to and respect their
children's needs and emotions, and may negotiate or compromise with them.
Authoritative parents may have a warm and respectful relationship with their
children, but they may also have a firm and consistent relationship with them.
Examples
Some examples of authoritative parenting are:
• A parent who sets and enforces a reasonable curfew for their child, such as 10
pm on weekdays and 12 am on weekends, and explains the reasons and benefits of
having a curfew, such as safety, health, and performance.
• A parent who rewards their child for good behavior or achievement, such as
giving them praise, money, or privileges, and also imposes consequences for bad
behavior or failure, such as taking away their phone, TV, or allowance.
• A parent who allows their child to have some choices and preferences, such as
what to wear, what to play, or who to be friends with, but also sets some limits
and guidelines, such as appropriate, safe, and respectful choices.
• A parent who listens to and respects their child's feelings and opinions, and
encourages them to express themselves and share their thoughts, but also teaches
them to be respectful and empathetic to others' feelings and opinions.
• Awareness and education, as they learn about the effects of parenting styles on
child development and well-being, and adopt positive parenting practices that
support optimal child development.
• Support and guidance, as they receive help and advice from their family,
community, or society, such as NGOs, media, or government, that offer parenting
programs, resources, or policies that encourage and facilitate authoritative
parenting.
• A parent who enrolls their child in an ECD program, such as the Parenting for
Lifelong Health (PLH) program, which is a low-cost, evidence-based parenting
program that aims to prevent violence, improve health, and enhance child
development, by teaching parents positive parenting skills, such as praise, play,
problem-solving, and communication (Cluver et al., 2018).
• A parent who advocates for their child's rights and participation, such as the
Child Rights Clubs (CRCs), which are groups of children and young people who learn
about and promote child rights, such as education, health, protection, and
expression, in their schools, communities, and society (UNICEF Zambia, 2019).
• A parent who supports their child's interests and passions, such as the Barefeet
Theatre, which is a Zambian NGO that uses art and creativity to empower and educate
vulnerable and marginalized children and youth, such as street children, orphans,
and refugees, by providing them with opportunities to express themselves, learn new
skills, and access services and resources (Barefeet Theatre, 2020).
• A parent who respects and appreciates their child's culture and identity, such
as the African Children's Stories (ACS), which is a global initiative that collects
and publishes stories written by African children, about their lives, experiences,
and dreams, in their own languages and voices, to celebrate and preserve their
culture and diversity (African Children's Stories, 2020).
Uninvolved Parenting
Uninvolved parenting, also known as neglectful parenting, is a parenting style in
which parents are detached and indifferent with their children. They have few or no
rules and expectations, and they rarely monitor or supervise their children's
activities. They are unresponsive to their children's needs and emotions, and they
value their own interests and well-being over their children's. Uninvolved parents
may be neglectful and abusive, or they may be overwhelmed and depressed.
• Children may have high creativity and innovation, as they are not constrained by
rules or expectations. They may have more opportunities to discover and pursue
their interests and passions, without any interference or pressure.
• Children may have high empathy and compassion, as they are exposed to hardship
and suffering. They may have more awareness and appreciation of the needs and
feelings of others, and may be more willing to help and support them.
• Children may be insecure and unhappy, as they feel unloved and unwanted. They
may have low self-esteem and self-control, as they lack support and guidance.
• Children may have poor social and academic outcomes, as they lack skills and
resources. They may have difficulty forming and maintaining relationships, as they
lack trust and attachment. They may also have low academic achievement and
motivation, as they lack direction and feedback.
• Children may be vulnerable and at risk, as they are exposed to harm and danger.
They may have poor physical and mental health, as they lack care and protection.
They may also engage in risky or deviant behaviors, such as substance abuse, sexual
activity, or delinquency, as they seek attention and validation from others.
How It Works
Uninvolved parenting works by providing a low level of control and responsiveness
to children, but not enough or too little of either. Uninvolved parents tend to be
more like strangers than caregivers to their children. They may use neglect,
abandonment, or abuse to influence their children's behavior, rather than rules,
expectations, or consequences. They may also ignore or reject their children's
needs or emotions, and may prioritize their own needs or problems. Uninvolved
parents may have a distant and cold relationship with their children, but they may
also have a chaotic and hostile relationship with them.
Examples
Some examples of uninvolved parenting are:
• A parent who leaves their child alone at home, without any food, water, or
supervision, while they go to work, drink, or gamble, without any concern or care
for their child's safety or well-being.
• A parent who does not provide their child with any basic needs, such as
clothing, shelter, or health care, and lets them suffer from hunger, cold, or
illness, without any help or intervention.
• A parent who does not show any interest or involvement in their child's life,
such as their school, hobbies, or friends, and does not communicate or interact
with them, without any affection or attention.
• Physical development: Parenting styles can affect children's growth, health, and
survival. For example, authoritative parents may provide their children with
adequate nutrition, health care, and protection, which can enhance their physical
development. Uninvolved parents may neglect or abuse their children, which can
impair their physical development.
• Learn about the effects of parenting styles on child development and well-being,
and adopt positive parenting skills, such as praise, play, problem-solving, and
communication. These skills can help parents to influence their children's behavior
and performance, while also listening to and respecting their children's needs and
emotions.
• Seek help and support from family, community, or society, such as NGOs, media,
or government, that offer parenting programs, resources, or policies that encourage
and facilitate positive parenting. These programs, resources, or policies can help
parents to overcome the challenges and barriers that they face, such as poverty,
violence, or corruption, and to access the opportunities and benefits that they
deserve, such as education, health, or protection.
• Cluver, L., Meinck, F., Steinert, J. I., Shenderovich, Y., Doubt, J., Romero, R.
H., ... & Gardner, F. (2018). Parenting for lifelong health: A pragmatic cluster
randomised controlled trial of a non-commercialised parenting programme for
adolescents and their families in South Africa. BMJ Global Health, 3(1), e000539.
https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2017-000539
• UNICEF & Ministry of General Education. (2018). Traditional parenting and child
care practices in Zambia.