We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 9
Relation between the Union
and the States
In India, the Central Government and the
State Government are in a relationship, and
when they both work together, the country
functions properly.
The Indian nation is said to be a federation
with a unitary bias. Part XI of the Indian
Constitution, that is Article 245 to Article
263, deals with Centre-State relations.The financial relationship between the Centre
and states is covered in Part XII of the Indian
Constitution. Article 280 deals with the
mandate provision for setting up the Finance
Commission.
Indian Constitution: Federal In Form But
Unitary In Spirit: Article 248: The phrase
“unitary bias” arises because residuary
powers to legislate on the matters not
enumerated in the central, state, or
concurrent list subjects are given to the
Centre under Article 248.DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
STATE AND CENTRAL
GOVERNMENT
State Governments:
Operates in particular states or regions of a
country.
e As specified by the Constitution of the State
List subjects, rule, and make laws on issues
like public order, police, local government,
agriculture, ete.
Have their legislative bodies enact special laws
for the states.
e Is headed by the Chief Minister who is in
charge of administration of the state affairs.
¢ The CM ought to supervise and control the
state’s level of expenditure and revenue.
e National law is applicable within a state, and
hence state agencies need to implement their
policies within such limits.Central Government (Union/Federal
Government):
¢ Operates on a national level and administers
the whole nation.
The union government makes laws on union
list topics under the Constitution such as
defense, foreign relations, and banking among
others.
Has a bicameral parliament comprising Lok
Sabha, the lower house (House of the People)
and Rajya Sabha, the upper house (Council
of States).
The prime minister is the executive head and
the person of the highest authority in the
country. He is responsible for national
administration.
Develops, and executes policies at the national
level. Controls and monitoring of state
governance under the constitution.
Supports national budgets, finances,
interstate, and foreign issues.10 reasons why the Indian
central government is
powerful than state
governments
The Centre was made more powerful than
states can be recognised from the following
points:-
1. Single Citizenship
There is no state citizenship. Every Indian has
the same rights of citizenship, no matter in
which state he resides.
2. The Centre Can Change the Name And
Boundaries Of StatesArticle 3 gives the Central Government the
right to change the name and boundaries of
states.
3. Single Unified Judiciary
In India, the Supreme Court and High Courts
form a single integrated judicial system. To
ensure the uniformity of the laws, they are
placed in the concurrent list.
4. Uniquely In Emergencies
Under the Constitution, the President of the
Republic has been given emergency powers
under Article 352, Article 356, and Article
360.5. Common All India Services
The Constitution has certain special provisions
to ensure the uniformity of the administrative
standards. These services include IAS, IFS,
IPS, JES, and many others.
6. Inequality Of Representation In the Council
of States
There is bicameralism in India, but states
have not been given equal representation.
Here the state with more population will have
higher representation than smaller ones.
Note: In government, bicameralism is the
practice of having two legislative or
parliamentary chambers.7. Appointment Of Governors
The President appoints the Governor, and
this enables the Union Government to exercise
control over the State Administration.
8. The Office Of Comptroller and Auditor
General
The office of CAG comes under the central
government, but his concern is not only with
the accounts and auditing of the union
government but also states.
9. Centralized Electoral Machinery
The President appoints the body of the
Election Commission. He is in charge ofconducting elections not only to Parliament
but also to the state legislatures.
10. Financial Dependence Of States
In a federation, states should be financially
self-sufficient to ensure maximum autonomy.
But in India, the states depend on the Centre
for all development. It is the centre that gives
grants to the states.