Flood MGT in Nigeria
Flood MGT in Nigeria
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
Abstract
This paper revisits flooding problems in Ibadan Metropolis, in the past fifty years, especially the most recent
flood of August 2011. Flood disasters can be attributed to the unnecessary risks people take when they
encroach on flood plains. There will be no flood disasters if human beings stayed away from the flood plains.
The methodology adopted for the flood investigations includes site visits, interviews of affected inhabitants,
and analyses of flood data collected during the field investigations. These investigations were complemented
with review of past records of flooding, and interpretation of satellite imagery of flood affected areas,
especially for inaccessible areas, to produce flood hazard maps.
Results of the spatial analysis of flooding in the 11 local government areas of Ibadan indicate that 26,553
buildings were constructed within the statutory set back to the rivers and streams while 2,105 were flooded.
Large scale encroachment into the river floodplains was observed throughout the area. The major cause of
flooding in Ibadan Metropolis is due to uncontrolled urbanization of the area.
The Nigerian Meteorological Agency (NIMET) predicted that there will be very heavy rains and flooding in a
number of states in Nigeria in 2012. In Oyo State, Ibadan is specifically mentioned as a city to experience
flooding. This emphasises the urgent need to put in place measures to facilitate effective management of the
anticipated floods to prevent the re-occurrence of the damage and losses of the 2011 disaster.
Key words: Hydrology, Urban Floods, Flood Mapping, Flood Insurance, Flood Management, Emergency
           Response, Waste Management
Introduction
Hydrology and Floods
Water covers over seventy percent of the surface of the earth. Hydrology is the study of the
occurrence, distribution, movement, and properties of water on the earth and their
                                                                                                              65
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                               66
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
surfaces or by other natural and man-made hazards which destroy soil and vegetation that
can absorb rainfall.
After any rainfall, some of the water is retained on the soil and may form ponds. Some of
the water infiltrates into the soil, some evaporates, and any excess water moves along the
land surface as surface runoff. Flooding occurs when the soil, stream channels and man-
made reservoirs cannot absorb or contain all the water. A flood that occurs suddenly, with
little or no prior signs, is called a flash flood and is due to intense rainfall over a relatively
small area.
Flooding is inevitable, resulting from the natural rainfall-runoff process. Flooding is a natural
phenomenon and the magnitude of floods is periodic. The periodicity of floods implies that
every year some area surrounding the river (on both sides) is flooded. Every other period,
(two, five, ten, fifty, one hundred and even a thousand years) is associated with increasing
areas around the river which gets inundated. Areas inundated by floods adjacent to the river
or stream are known as flood plains. Flood occurrences may be due to natural or
anthropogenic (man-made) factors.
In a study of the flooding problems in Lagos State, Adeloye and Rustum (2011) indicated
that climate change is not the culprit but anthropogenic factors The investigation revealed
that, contrary to popular wisdom, climate change or unusually high rainfall is not the
primary cause of the flooding problems in Lagos. Rather, increased urbanisation, lax
planning laws in relation to the erection of buildings in flood plains and the inadequacy of
storm drainage facilities in the city are to blame .
Man does not have much control over the natural causes of floods, such as the magnitude
and frequency of rainfall (and associated floods), except perhaps to avoid encroachment
into the natural flood plains to prevent flood disaster. However man has total control over
the anthropogenic causes of floods, such as limiting construction or development on
natural flood plains, eliminating blockages from the natural flood plains to allow free
passage of flood water and increasing the capacity of hydraulic conveyance structures to
conveniently carry flood flows. Conventional wisdom dictates that man should stay away
from flood plains or appreciate the RISKS associated with encroaching on the flood plain.
Flood disasters are associated with the unnecessary risks people take when they encroach
on the flood plains. There will be no flood disasters if human beings stay away from the
flood plain.
Physical Setting
Location
Ibadan is located in south-western Nigeria and is the capital of Oyo State. Ibadan is centred
about latitude 7o 25’ North and longitude 3o 5’ East (Figure 2) and is located approximately
145 km north of Lagos. It is situated close to the boundary between forest and grassland,
which makes it a melting point for people and products of both the forests and grassland
areas. Ibadan is regarded as the largest indigenous city in tropical Africa.
Since its founding in the 1800s, Ibadan has played a prominent role for people living in the
south-west of Nigeria. It was the capital of the old Western Region, when Nigeria had only
three regions. The territory of the old Western Region has since been divided into seven
states and a sizeable part of the present Lagos State belonged to the old Western Region.
Ibadan hosts the premier university in Nigeria (The University of Ibadan) which was
                                                                                               67
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                             68
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
rainfall months, average temperatures are relatively high, between 24°C and 25°C, while
annual fluctuation of temperature is about 6°C.
Most areas of Ibadan are covered by the rain forest and derived savannah. Growth and
development have, however, led to significant loss of vegetation. The wetlands are
threatened by urban expansion into the wetlands and rural areas. The thick, low-lying
forests are prone to flooding as observed in areas like Ajibode, National Institute for
Horticultural Research (NIHORT) and Oke Ayo along the course of River Ona.
Methodology
The methodology adopted for the flood investigations includes site visits for physical
inspection of the affected areas; interviews of affected inhabitants, review of past reports
and records of flooding in the area; and analyses of flood data collected during the
investigations.
During the fieldwork component of the investigation, apart from the physical inspection of
damaged structures and infrastructures, the team demarcated flooded areas and
determined depths of flooding. This flood plain mapping in the field was complemented
with analysis and interpretation of satellite imagery of the flood affected areas, especially
for inaccessible areas, to produce a flood hazard map.
The records and reports of past floods in the metropolis were reviewed as part of the
present exercise. Data were collected on climate, drainage infrastructures, physical
planning, and applicable laws and regulations for flood control in Ibadan metropolis.
Discussion of Results
History of Flooding in Ibadan Metropolis
Ibadan has recorded varying degrees of flooding. For instance, there were flooding in the
watersheds of Ogunpa and Kudeti streams (one of the two major streams in Ibadan) in
1955, 1960, 1961, 1963, 1969, 1978 and 1980. The flooding of 1969 is unique because it
resulted from a mere 25.4 mm rainfall (Akintola, 1981). An accurate assessment of the
havoc caused by floods in Ibadan over the years is difficult to obtain (CBN, 1999). However,
a number of official estimations have been made at different points. For instance, the losses
arising from the flood disaster of August 1980 in Ibadan were estimated at N300.0 million
while the number of lives lost was put at 500 people (Akintola, 1994). Between 1995 and
                                                                                          69
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
1998, over 12 million Naira, were estimated to have been lost to floods in Ibadan (NEMA,
undated). Table 3 shows the history of the most recent thirteen flood events in Ibadan.
The rain gauge at the IITA recorded an all time high of 187.5mm rainfall on August 26, 2011
which started at 16.40 hr until 20.00 hr with intermittent drizzling until 23.00 hr
accompanied by wind speed as high as 65 km/hr. IITA reported that the rainfall was most
intense between 18.10 hr and 19.20 hr when 75% or 140.63 mm of the rain fell. This is an
average rainfall intensity of 127.84/hr (National Water Resources Institute, 2011).
Conclusion
The study found out that the major cause of flooding in Ibadan Metropolis is uncontrolled
urbanization of the area, such that some of the houses are built during the dry season on
what constitutes the river bed itself. Large scale encroachment into the river floodplains was
observed throughout the area. Most of the culverts, bridges and other hydraulic structures
which were designed and constructed several years ago are no longer adequate to convey
the present runoff arising from increased urbanization of Ibadan Metropolis. The excessive
siltation of the rivers and stream beds has tended to reduce the carrying capacity of these
hydraulic conveyance structures.
                                                                                            70
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
Indiscriminate dumping of refuse and solid wastes is a major problem constituting blockage
of river courses, stream channels and artificial drainage channels. The problem of improper
waste management must be solved to eliminate this cause of flooding.
It was discovered that the upper part of Ogunpa River had been heavily silted from Ashi area
through to the Agodi Gardens Reservoir/Lake which was reportedly dredged last in 2008.
The silting of the river had led to blockage of the concrete culverts built across the river all
along its course. Channelization of the rivers within the city has not been completed and the
completed portions are not well maintained to be free of obstructions.
Ibadan Metropolis has, for a long time, suffered varying degrees of flood disasters with
extremely high externalities due to an array of factors, the most prominent of which could
be attributed to human behaviour. The rainfall of the 26 th August 2011 and associated flood
disaster was very devastating based on the level of social, economic and ecological
destruction, therefore requiring concerted and decisive actions to prevent future re-
occurrence. Conventional wisdom dictates that humans should stay away from flood plains
or appreciate the RISKS associated with encroaching on the flood plain. Flood disasters are
associated with the unnecessary risks people take when they encroach on the flood plains.
There will be no flood disasters if human beings stay away from the flood plain and stop
dumping solid wastes in stream and river channels. Furthermore, the floods will not go away
and their impacts and severity will increase in the future if corrective steps are not taken.
Recommendations
The Nigerian Meteorological Agency (NIMET) has predicted that there will be very heavy
rains and flooding in a number of states in Nigeria in 2012. In Oyo State, Ibadan is
specifically mentioned as a city to experience flooding. This emphasises the urgent need to
put in place measures to facilitate effective management of the anticipated floods to
prevent the re-occurrence of the damage and losses of the 2011 disaster.
Arising from this study, based on the findings in the field, as well as the need to protect the
environment, the human population and livelihoods from unmitigated flood disasters in
future, the following recommendations are hereby suggested:
    1. Create public awareness and sensitization on the real dangers of flirting with
        floodplains.
    2. Government must enforce compliance with physical planning and development
        regulations within Ibadan Metropolis. There should be immediate stoppage of all
        kinds of development in all flood prone areas in the 11 LGAs in Ibadan region.
    3. Strictly enforce the provisions of the relevant sections of the Oyo State Solid Waste
        Management Authority Law, (Oyo State of Nigeria, 2008), especially Schedule B (xiv)
        as it affects construction or placement of structures on roadside and public drainage
        channels or pedestrian walkways by shop operators.
    4. Review existing laws and regulations on delimitation of set-backs to conform to the
        natural flood plain of the rivers.
    5. Government should ensure that drains, gutters and surface water bodies are de-
        silted throughout Ibadan metropolis to allow for the free flow of urban storm water
        and runoff. This should be an on-going programme.
    6. Government should embark on immediate reconstruction of damaged culverts,
        bridges and other hydraulic structures, especially in flood ravaged areas.
                                                                                             71
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
   7. All the major rivers and their tributaries must be de-silted and dredged prior to the
       onset of the rainy season. This should be an on-going programme.
   8. Review existing laws on streams and river set-backs to accommodate the natural
       extent of river flood plains of the streams and rivers for flood control, in view of
       urbanization.
   9. Government should embark on the preparation of a Master (Development Plan) for
       Ibadan Metropolis taking into consideration the use of flood prone areas within
       stream/river setbacks for:
       a. Urban and peri-urban agriculture;
       b. Recreation;
       c. Wildlife and Ecosystem Conservation; and
       d. Intra-city water transportation (boating on Rivers Ona and Ogunpa).
   10. Study the road network in Ibadan and provide alternative routes to communities
       prone to flooding, especially for those with only one access road linking them with
       nearby communities.
   11. Government should adopt Public-Private-Partnership strategy in waste management
       and assist the Private Refuse Contractors to improve waste collection and disposal
       throughout Ibadan Metropolis.
   12. One of the most potent preventive measures against flooding is vegetation.
       Government should adopt a policy of “Greening” the Ibadan Metropolis through
       planting of trees, shrubs and ornamental plants. This will reduce runoff hence
       flooding, preserve soil moisture and reduce the rate of atmospheric warming.
   13. Government should establish an Environmental Monitoring System within the
       context of an Environmental Management Information System (EMIS) pioneered by
       the Sustainable Ibadan Project (SIP), to provide real-time data for environmental
       planning and flood forecasting.
   14. In order to minimize losses arising from flood disasters, government should
       collaborate with stakeholders such as the Nigerian Insurance Association (NIA) and
       National Insurance Commission (NAICOM) amongst others, to design and promote a
       State-wide Flood Insurance Programme. This is the practice and requirements for
       development in flood prone areas in Canada, France and the United States. In
       Nigeria, there is also an extant legislation on compulsory acquisition of Property
       Insurance. Implementation of this programme would reduce the compensation
       payable by government when disasters occur in future.
   15. Complete the River Ogunpa Channelization Project and also channelize the major
       streams and rivers, and construct embankments along the main river channels to
       reduce flooding. This should be an on-going programme or initiative.
   16. Government should establish sustainable integrated flood management and
       emergency response system.
   17. Identify and relocate all permanent structures, within the natural flood plain (50 and
       100 years) of the streams and rivers, outside the natural flood plain of the streams
       and rivers, in line with international best practices for flood prone areas.
   18. Prepare a Flood Emergency Management Plan for Ibadan Metropolis as a matter of
       urgency.
                                                                                          72
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
   19. Government should equip appropriate agencies with human and material resources
       for Emergency Response to flooding and other natural disasters.
   20. The preceding recommendations will require an appropriate institutional framework
       for effective implementation. At present, the agencies that will implement the
       recommendations contained in this study are scattered throughout the government
       structure. It may be necessary to establish an Inter-Ministerial Implementation
       Committee or create a Public-Private Partnership Framework for implementation
       and sustainability of the flood management ideals presented here.
Acknowledgement
The authors of this paper, who were appointed into the Oyo State Task Force on Flood
Prevention and Management, by His Excellency, the Executive Governor of Oyo State,
Senator Ishaq Abiola Ajimobi, wish to acknowledge persons and organisations that funded
or facilitated the collection of data presented in this paper.
First and foremost, we thank the Executive Governor of Oyo State, His Excellency, Senator
Ishaq Abiola Ajimobi, for appointing us into the Task Force and for providing funds, as well
as the political and logistic support in carrying out the assessment on Flood Prevention and
Management arising from the flooding which ravaged Ibadan City on 26 th August 2011. We
thank the Deputy Governor, His Excellency, Chief Moses Adeyemo, the Secretary to the
State Government, Alhaji Waheed Olajide and other members of the State Executive
Council, especially the Commissioner for Physical Planning and Urban Development, Ms
Kafayat Adeojo, the Commissioner for Works and Transport, Alhaji Yunus Akintunde, the
Commissioner for Justice, Barrister Adebayo Ojo, and the Commissioner for Finance, Mr.
Zacheaus Adelabu Adedeji, for their various support and commitment to the task of Flood
Prevention and Management in Ibadan Metropolis.
We also wish to thank Professor Ademola Ariyo of the Department of Economics, University
of Ibadan, who is the Vice Chairman of the Oyo State Economic Management Team, for
initiating the ideas that led to the flood assessment project, the composition of Task Force
members and for sharing his expertise with the Team throughout the two-and-a-half
months that the assignment lasted. We appreciate the Commissioner of Police of Oyo State
for releasing his officers and men to provide security for members of the Task Force during
the field work to the various sites affected by the flooding. We appreciate the support given
by the Directors of the eleven (11) Local Planning Authorities namely: Tpls. Opasina,
Akinlabi, Ogunjimi, Olutade, Kareem, Sangodoyin, Amodeni, Adisa, Apampa and Olofa, as
well as their Technical staff, who participated actively in the laborious field survey to
demarcate the extent of the flooded areas, within a short period of three weeks. We thank
Tpl. Adeyemi, Tpl. S. B. Taiwo, Tpl. Dayo Ayorinde, Messrs Oyeniyi, Adeleke, Akande and
Ilori, all of the Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban Development for supervising the field
assistants.
We sincerely appreciate the efforts of the 20 Postgraduate Students of GIS and the 13
Undergraduate Students from the Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University
of Ibadan, in data collection, analysis and the subsequent production of maps of the 11 LGAs
showing the flooded buildings based on the coordinates recorded in the field using
Geographical Positioning System (GPS) equipment. We thank Mr. S. K. Ojolowo of the
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Ibadan, for his participation in
                                                                                            73
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
the field work and preparation of maps and production of report. We are also very grateful
to the Departments of Geology, Geography, and Urban and Regional Planning, University of
Ibadan, for hiring out some of the GPS used for the field work.
References
Adeloye, A. J. and Rustum, R. (2011). Lagos (Nigeria) flooding and influence of urban
          planning, Urban Design and Planning, Volume 164, Issue DP3, 185 – 187.
Akintola, E. O. (1994). Flooding phenomenon. In M. Filani, E. O. Akintola and Ikporukpo
        (Eds.), Ibadan Region. Ibadan: Department of Geography, University of Ibadan.
Aweto, A.O. (1994). Soils. In Filani, M.O. et al. (eds.) Ibadan Region. Chapter 5, pp. 49-57.
          Rex Charles Publishers, Nigeria.
Ayeni, M.O.A. (1994). The metropolitan area of Ibadan; its growth and structure. In Filani,
          M.O. et al. (eds.) Ibadan Region Chapter 7, pp. 72-84. Rex Charles Publishers,
          Nigeria.
CBN, (1999). Urbanization and related socio-economic problems in Ibadan Area, Research
          Department Occasional Paper No. 25, 80 pp.
Central Council of Ibadan Indigenes (CCII) (2011). Blue print on the physical development for
        Ibadan Metropolitan area. Paper submitted to the Oyo State Government, July.
D’Hoore, L.J. (1964). Soil Map of Africa. CTA, Lagos.
Fabiyi , O. O. (2006). Urban Land Use Change Analysis of a Traditional City from Remote
        Sensing Data: The Case of Ibadan Metropolitan Area, Nigeria. Humanity & Social
        Sciences Journal, 1 (1): 42-64.
Fourchard, 2003. The Case of Ibadan, Nigeria, Institut Francais de Recherche en Afrique
        (IFRA), University of Ibadan, 27 pp.
Government of Oyo State (2011). Government of Oyo State report on the Assessment of the
        26th August 2011 Flood Disaster in Ibadan Metropolis. 78 pp. Report prepared for the
        Government by the Oyo State Task Force on Flood Prevention and Management.
        Members: B. Wahab, T. Agbola, O. Ajayi, F. Olokesusi, M. Gbadegesin, S. Taiwo, O.
        Kolawole, A. Muili, M. Adeola, G. Olutade, F. Shiji and N. Abiola.
Hinderer, A. (1872). Seventeen years in the Yoruba Country, London.
Hopkins, B. (1965). Forest and Savanna. Heinemann, Ibadan.
Mabogunje, A.L. 1962. Yoruba Towns. University of Ibadan Press, Ibadan, Nigeria.
Millson, A. W. (1891). The Yoruba Country, West Africa. Proceedings of the Royal
        Geographical Society, 13: 577-91.
National Water Resources Institute (2011). Report of Assessment of the 26th August 2011
        Ibadan Flood Disaster, Oyo State, Nigeria. NWRI, Mando Road, Kaduna, 16 pp.
NEH (2007). National Engineering Handbook, National Engineering Handbook Hydrology
        Chapters, Natural Resources Conservation Service, United States Department of
        Agriculture (cover).
NEMA (2007). Mainstreaming Disaster Risk Reduction into Sustainable Development in Nigeria,
      Vols. 1 & 2. National Emergency Management Agency, Abuja.
NEST (1991). Nigeria’s threatened environment: A national profile. Nigeria: (Nigeria
      Environmental Study Action /Team).
                                                                                          74
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
Oyo State of Nigeria (2008). Oyo State Solid Waste Management Authority Law, 2004.
      Supplement to Oyo State of Nigeri a Gazette, No. 9, Vol. 33, of 5 th June, 2008- Part A.
      Ibadan: Government Press.
Wahab, B. (2011). Ibadan: A rapidly growing city in need of a Master Plan. Paper read at the
      Architects’ Congress/Annual General Meeting organized by the Nigerian Institute of
      Architects, Oyo State Chapter, held at Penrose Event Centre, Obafemi Awolowo
      Avenue, Old Bodija Estate, Ibadan, July 7.
                                                                                           75
Hydrology for Disaster Management
 Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
Table 5: Analysis of Flooded Buildings and those within River/Stream Set-backs in the Eleven
       LGAs of Ibadan
S/No.     Local Government                  No.    of Buildings No. of Buildings River/Stream
                                            within      Statutory Flooded on August Length (km)
                                            Setback                  26, 2011*
1.        Akinyele                          2,527                    382                    435.57
2.        Egbeda                            2,703                    332                    229.30
3.        Ibadan North East                 4,621                    228                     41.17
4.        Ibadan North                      3,290                    260                     33.23
5.        Ibadan North west                 4,543                    162                     60.09
6.        Ibadan South East                 2,435                     55                     47.69
7.        Ibadan South West                 3,931                    369                     75.35
8.        Ido                                368                      78                    888.65
9.        Lagelu                             913                      68                    274.15
10.       Oluyole                            366                      63                    663.01
11.       Ona-Ara                            856                     108                    420.43
          TOTAL                             26,553                   2,105                  3,168.64
Source: Field Survey Conducted by Task Force in October 2011
               *The number of flooded buildings within the most affected areas of the city covered
               during the survey was a little below 10% sample of the number of buildings within
               the statutory set-back from the surface water bodies.
                                                                                                       76
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                 77
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                 78
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                 79
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
                                                                                 80
Hydrology for Disaster Management
Special Publication of the Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences, 2012
http://www.unaab.edu.ng
81