Deals of the Week
11:00AM Saturday, November 2nd, 2024
In the know quiz
Sydney
Today
15 °/ 22 °
Sign UpLog In
news.com.au — Australia’s leading news site
National
World
Lifestyle
Travel
Entertainment
Technology
Finance
Sport
Shopping
Technology
Online
Social
‘Violent chaos’: Fears grow for US election as disinformation spreads online
All eyes are on social media as the US election looms, with experts warning the
country could soon descend into devastating violence.
Jamie Seidel
Jamie Seidel
@JamieSeidel
6 min read
November 2, 2024 - 10:05AM
18 Comments
|
This is a modal window.
Video not found
Technical details :
This video was not found
Fake accounts. AI-manipulated footage. Foreign algorithm-bending bots. And a
proprietor who openly endorses the most extreme of conspiracy theories.
All eyes are on social media platform X as fears grow next week’s US Presidential
election could degenerate into violent chaos.
Especially because anyone who wants to can cash in on it.
A BBC investigation has found many X (formerly Twitter) users who share and
generate election misinformation are being paid thousands of dollars in revenue by
the controversial billionaire Elon Musk’s company.
/
Duration 1:53
Fullscreen
Click to unmute
dailytelegraph.com.au
Can celebrity star power tip the scales in the US Election?
In the 2024 US election, rallies for both candidates are more star-studded than
ever. Kamala Harris... See more
And a Wall Street Journal study has revealed even brand new accounts with no
declared political interests or leanings are being flooded by aggressively pro-
Trump posts.
“If that cringe, dingbat, zero-votes, airhead Kamala Harris is able to cheat enough
to win the presidency the USA is over,” an anonymous user named “catturd2”
pronounced. This somehow managed to appear in almost all 14 of the Journal’s
freshly created accounts.
The revelations come as political analysts voice their concerns that new,
sophisticated manipulation tactics are at play on social media for the 2024
election campaign.
And it’s all about generating doubt.
It’s all about generating doubt. Picture: Ian Maule/AFP
It’s all about generating doubt. Picture: Ian Maule/AFP
Generative AI chatbots, generative AI images and generative AI footage.
And social media algorithms are still as unusually eager to promote hostile,
contentious and fake content to unwilling users as they were during the contentious
2019 election campaign.
“Every day brings new examples of fake campaign-related pictures, videos, and
narratives,” warns Brookings Institution analyst Darrell West.
“So, we shouldn’t be surprised on election night if we see false narratives seeking
to affect people’s belief about election integrity and the true winner of the
race.”
All eyes are on social media platform X, Elon Musk’s company, as fears grow next
week’s US Presidential election could degenerate into violent chaos. Picture: Jim
Watson/AFP
All eyes are on social media platform X, Elon Musk’s company, as fears grow next
week’s US Presidential election could degenerate into violent chaos. Picture: Jim
Watson/AFP
Alternate truths
“In recent weeks, there have been false images of Kamala Harris in a swimming suit
hugging convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, an AI-generated video of a young
man saying he was sexually abused by Tim Walz 30 years ago, a fraudulent Fordham
transcript for Donald Trump claiming he had a barely passing 1.28 grade point
average,” West reported.
Then there are the conspiracy theories accusing Trump of staging his assassination
attempts for sympathy and pronouncements that US hurricane disaster relief funding
had been diverted to illegal immigrants.
None of the above was true.
A fake image of US Vice President Kamala Harris has been circulated. Picture: Jon
Cherry/Getty Images/AFP
A fake image of US Vice President Kamala Harris has been circulated. Picture: Jon
Cherry/Getty Images/AFP
In the fake image, she was in a swimming suit while hugging convicted sex offender
Jeffrey Epstein. Picture: HO/Florida Department of Law Enforcement/AFP
In the fake image, she was in a swimming suit while hugging convicted sex offender
Jeffrey Epstein. Picture: HO/Florida Department of Law Enforcement/AFP
But that didn’t stop the claims from spreading like wildfire across social media
platforms.
However, the Wall Street Journal study has found that, in the final sprint towards
the November 5 polls, its posts paved the way for accusations of a rigged election
result that have floated to the top.
“They are getting ready to CHEAT!” Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump
blared in a September 23 post on his Truth Social account – a company he owns.
Similarly, false claims boosted by Musk’s personal account on his X platform are
gaining maximum exposure. But he’s also personally contributing to the fire hose of
falsehoods: “Michigan has more registered voters than eligible citizens!? Is that
true?” he posted while boosting an anonymous (but revenue-earning) political
account.
Michigan has more registered voters than eligible citizens!? Is that true
@CommunityNotes? https://t.co/f7Q2iCZdQ7
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) October 19, 2024
It is. But not in the election-rigging manner Musk infers. The state is not allowed
to remove inactive voters (through death, disability or migration) until after each
election cycle.
Musk went on to declare “this is crazy” in response to another anonymous – and
demonstrably incorrect – allegation that not-for-profit organisations were
“harvesting” hundreds of thousands of post-in ballots from among the homeless.
His company’s algorithms boosted both false claims to generate tens of millions of
views.
The Institute for Strategic Dialogue (ISD) believes similar posts – many of which
share fake images of 2024 voting ballots alongside passports of foreign countries
(including the defunct Nazi Germany and Soviet Union) – are being boosted across X
in the lead up to the election.
“The claims appear to be part of an effort to mislead voters by playing on recent
fearmongering about noncitizens casting ballots in the presidential election,” it
reported.
“These accounts appear co-ordinated, with the largest account referring to the
network as ‘my group’ and many of the accounts posting identical language and
images.”
Many falsified images are being shared on the platform X. Picture: Kirill
Kudryavtsev/AFP
Many falsified images are being shared on the platform X. Picture: Kirill
Kudryavtsev/AFP
Priming chaos
“In contested elections, candidates sometimes have political incentives to claim
victory before there is independent and objective evidence of winning,” warned the
Brookings Institution’s West.
“There should be no victory speeches taken seriously by anyone until there is
actual evidence of triumph because that simply would be an effort to claim the
moral high ground for coming legal and political battles.”
Turnout for the 2024 election is expected to be high. And that’s spurred attacks on
the integrity of the US postal ballot and voter registration systems.
And widespread expectation of rapid results means all sides will be deeply
suspicious of any delay. And they’re being encouraged to take matters into their
own hands.
“If it turns out to be a very close election in 2024, as is expected right now,
that uncertainty will spawn disinformation,” West added.
A key example is likely to be Pennsylvania.
It’s one of the swing states that appears evenly tied in the polls.
Republicans generally vote on the day. More Democrats tend to vote via post.
In 2020, this long-observed trend appeared once again in real-time vote counting.
Nevertheless, some seized it as evidence of vote rigging. Investigations later
found all claims to be without basis.
“The risk in 2024 is that disinformation agents either from the United States
and/or abroad will repeat those claims, and those accusations will sound believable
to sceptical voters,” West warned.
Supporters of Donald Trump during the Capitol riots on January 6, 2021. Picture:
Alex Edelman/AFP
Supporters of Donald Trump during the Capitol riots on January 6, 2021. Picture:
Alex Edelman/AFP
“Both sides will be watching vote casting and tabulations and filing legal claims
based on their observations … It will be easy for either side to promote false
narratives if the ballots take several days to process.”
Such narratives have already been appearing for several months.
“These people are trying to get [illegals] to vote,” Trump said during the
September presidential debate, an accusation levelled at Democrat hopeful Kamala
Harris.
“And that’s why they’re allowing them to come into our country.”
Recent polls show some 88 per cent of Republican voters are concerned mass illegal
voting will apply to the upcoming election. That’s despite recent law changes and
multiple state and federal investigations.
So much so that one in five agreed to a survey question asking if Trump should
“declare the results invalid and do whatever it takes to assume office” should he
lose.
Pennsylvania is a swing state that’s evenly tied in the polls. Picture: Jeff
Swensen/Getty Images North America via AFP
Pennsylvania is a swing state that’s evenly tied in the polls. Picture: Jeff
Swensen/Getty Images North America via AFP
‘I want to believe’
AI-generated “bot” content has been tracked spreading in reach and number across X
in particular for several years, added University of Sydney communications expert
Dr Timothy Koskie.
And it is targeting willing ears.
“Research has indicated that many people will knowingly spread misinformation if it
aligns with their views or paints them in a particular light,” he said.
“While claims of ‘fake news’ might raise images of deeply invested conspiracy
theorists, its spread and reception is often down to simple inattention or its
presence on a preferred source.”
And those who indulge in disinformation are being rewarded. Changes early in
October to X payment policies mean the number of views of individual posts – not
just exposure to display adverts – will earn users payment. Controversial election
posts are both topical and being boosted by X’s algorithms.
“Many social media sites allow users to make money from their posts or to share
sponsored content,” the BBC report reads.
AI manipulated footage is spreading. Picture: iStock
AI manipulated footage is spreading. Picture: iStock
“But they often have rules which allow them to demonetise or suspend profiles that
post misinformation. X does not have guidelines on misinformation in the same way.”
And the Wall Street Journal analysis of X’s social media content-boosting
algorithms shows it has been primed to reward such content.
“Less than a third of unique posts seen by the Journal’s accounts were political in
nature. But X’s algorithm re-upped political posts so often that they accounted for
about half of the total posts,” the report stated.
“The majority of the political posts X served the bots were from conservative
figures and pro-Trump accounts.”
X has yet to respond to either the BBC or Journal reports.
The US Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ONI) has reported that
foreign powers do not appear to be attacking the integrity of US voting systems, as
they had in previous years.
More Coverage
Trump’s weird move days before election
Student caught in voter fraud bombshell
Instead, the focus of propagandists and hackers backed by hostile nations –
including China, Iran and North Korea – was to “undermine trust in the integrity of
the election and election processes, as well as to further exacerbate divisions
among Americans”.
The July report specifically pointed the finger at Russia as the “predominant
threat to US elections”. But it had been “working to better hide its hand” than it
had in the 2016 campaign.
Jamie Seidel is a freelance writer | @JamieSeidel
Read related topics:
Donald Trump
Kamala Harris
US Democratic Party | 2024 Election News & Updates
US Republican Party | 2024 Election News & Updates
Join the conversation (18 Comments)
news
Sign Up
Log In
Sign Up
Registration
Connect
In The Know Quiz
Newsletters
Competitions
About us
Welcome to news.com.au
The Team
Our Values
Code of Conduct
Shopping
Coupons
Help and Support
Contact us
FAQ
General Feedback
Advertise with us
Standards of Practice
Site Map
Licensing & Reprints
Our News Network
Kids News
The Daily Telegraph
Herald Sun
The Courier Mail
Our Partners
Kidspot
Body+Soul
realestate.com.au
FoxSports
CODE Sports
Our Apps
A NOTE ABOUT RELEVANT ADVERTISING: We collect information about the content
(including ads) you use across this site and use it to make both advertising and
content more relevant to you on our network and other sites. Find out more about
our policy and your choices, including how to opt-out.Sometimes our articles will
try to help you find the right product at the right price. We may receive payment
from third parties for publishing this content or when you make a purchase through
the links on our sites.
Privacy policy
Relevant ads opt-out
Cookie policy
Terms of use
Nationwide News Pty Ltd © 2024. All times AEDT (GMT +11). Powered by WordPress.com
VIP
