Understanding Hadith Compilation
Understanding Hadith Compilation
Hadith:
The Arabic word Hadith literally means ‘statement’ or ‘talk’. In Islamic terminology, the term Hadith (plural,
Hadiths, or Ahadith) refers to reports of statements or actions of Prophet Muhammad(S.A.W), or of his tacit approval
or disapproval or something said or done in his presence.
Sunnah:
The Arabic word of Sunnah (plural; Sunnan) literally means a clear and well trodden path. In Islamic
terminology Sunnah demotes the practice of Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) that he taught and practical instituted as a
teacher of the Shariah and the best exemplar. The Sunnah of Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) includes his specific words,
Habits, Practices, Listen approval and dealing with friends, family and government.
Sunnah and Hadith are used alternatively in certain cases and differently in certain cases:
Whatever is narrated from the messenger of Allah(May the blessings and peace of Allah be upon him),
whether it is saying, act or approval of a certain act then it is called Sunnah and it is also called Hadith.
The books which report the narrations tracked back to the messenger of Allah(May the blessings and peace of
Allah be upon him) and to the companions and the statements of the righteous predecessors are called the
books of Sunnah and the Books of Hadith.
Sunnah refers to the frequently repeated act of the messenger of Allah(May the blessings and peace of Allah
be upon him) of his companions or their followers, but the Hadith is used in what is narrated, done or
approved by the messenger of Allah(May the blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) ever for one time.
The word Sunnah is used while talking about a certain recommended act, where as the word Hadith is used
while talking about the weak and authentic narration from the messenger of Allah(May the blessings and
peace of Allah be upon him).
Page 1 of 14
COMPILATION AND PRESERVATION OF HADITH
The age of the Prophet and his companions:
In the beginning when the Quran was being revealed the Prophet forbade the companions to write
anything from him other than the Quran. So they might not mix the Quran with the saying of the Prophet. But
later, He allowed his companions when he becomes confident that they would be able to distinguish between
the Hadith and the Quran. He therefore encourages them to write down his saying. He said to Abdullah bin
Umers “write down from me by God nothing comes out of my mouth except the Truth”.
In the farewell pilgrimage the Prophet said “He, who is present here shall carry his message to the one
who is absent”. On another occasion his said “may Allah give freshness to a servant who hears my saying,
keeps it in ,memory and preserved it and communicate it” (Mishkat).
The Hadith literature was preserved mostly in the memory and the hearts of the companions of the Prophet,
however some the Ahadith were written down and recorded.
1. Letters, laws and treaties which were dictate by the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) himself and were preserved in
his time.
2. Collection of Hazrat Aisha(R.A) compiled by Urwah Bin Zubair(R.A).
3. Book of Jabir Bin Abbdullah(R.A).
4. Collection of Anas Bin Malik (R.A).
5. Collection of Abdullah Bin Abbas (R.A)
6. Collection of Hazrat Ali (R.A).
7. Sahifah Sahiha compiled by Hammam Bin Munabah from Abu Hurraira (R.A)
8. Sahifa Sadiqah compiled by Abdullah Bin Umer(R.A).
Caliph Umer bin Abdul Aziz distributed circulars to the Muslims cities, in which he requested theologians
to collect and compiles Ahadith from whatever they could find them. In addition to the Ahadith, the
verdicts and saying of the companions and the tabieen and regions’ opinions of the Prophets family were
collected.
The fundamental principles of Islamic jurisprudence were enunciated and compiled. The most
authoritative first a collection of Ahadis in the period was Almuatta, compiled by Imam Malik bin Anas
(93 AH / 712 AD- 179 AH / 795 AD). Who is also known to be the founder of the Maliki School of
thought.
Numerous collections of Ahadith were prepared by many scholars from various angles, and different methods
were adopted for the arrangement of the material.
Two models were mainly adopted in first category; Hadith traced to each companion was put together under
his name, no matter was their theme may be such a collection is called Musnad. Therefore the titles of
chapters are Musnad of Abu Bakar, Musnad of Abu Hurraira, Musnad of Aisha, Musnad of Imam Ahmed bin
Humble etc.
Page 2 of 14
The second category of Ahadith is grouped into chapters and sub chapters according to them. For instance
chapters on purity, prayers, fasting, zakat, Hajj, marriage, so on. The best known works of his types are, Al-
muatta compiled by Imam Malik bin Anas.
Name of author: Abu Abdullah Muhammad bin Ismail. Place of birth: Bukhara (Uzbakistan), 194 AD /
810 AD.
Place and date of death: khartank, A village in Samarkand, Uzbakistan, 256 AH / 870 AD.
Al- Jami Al-Sahi Al-Bukhari was compiled by Imam Muhammad bin Al-Bukhari. After the Holy Quran it
is the most Authentic book.
Imam Bukhai Narrates “I saw the Prophet in a dream and it was as I was standing in front of him. In my
and was a fan with which I was protecting him. I asked some dream interpreter, who said to me ‘ you will
protect him from lies’. This is what compelled me to produce the Sahi Ahadith“.
Its compiler travelled though out the Muslim world including Iran, Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Makkah and
Madinah. For nearly 40 years of the collection of Ahadith.
He selected nearly 7397 Ahadith from 600,000 traditions. He compiled them in into 90 chapters according
to the subject matters. His criteria to accept a Hadith was very tough. It took 16 years to complete his
book.
Page 3 of 14
2. Al-Jami Al-Sahi Al-Muslim
Sahi Muslim in one of the six major Hadiths books. It is the second most Authentic Hadith collection
after Sahi Al-Bukhari, and is Highly acclaimed by Muslims. It was collected by Muslims Ibn-al-Hajjaj,
also known as Imam Muslim.
The collector of the Sahi Muslim, Imam Muslim, (Muslim Ibn-al Hajjaj), was born into a Persian family
in 204 AH (817 AD) in Nishapur (In modern day Iran) and died in 261 AH (874 AD) in the city of his
birth.
He travelled widely to gather his collection of Ahadith (plural of Hadith), including two areas now in Iraq,
the Arabian Peninsula, Syria and Egypt.
Out of 300,000 Hadith which he evaluated, approximately 4,000 were extracted for inclusion into his
collection.
Muslim consider in the second most authentic Hadith collection after Sahi Bukhari.
Sahi Muslim is divided into 43 books, containing a total of 7190 narrations.
3. Al-Jami Al-Tirmizi
6. Sunan Nisaai
Name of the Author: Abu Abdur-Rehman Ahmed Ibne Ali
Place and date of Birth: Nasa (Tukemenistan), 215 AH / 830 AD.
Place and date of Death: Jerusalem 303 AH / 915 AD.
Places visited to seek knowledge: He went to the four corners of the Islamic world and then settled in
Egypt.
Other Books: (i) Al-Mujtaba (ii) Ad-Dwafa wal Matrukur (iii) Musnad Ali (iv) Musnad Malik.
1. The Kitab al-Kafi is a twelver Shi’ah Hadith collection compiled by Muhammad Ya’qub Kulyani. It is
divided into three sections.
(a) Usul al-Kafi which is concerned with the principle of religion.
(b) Furu al-Kafi, which is concerned with the details of religious law.
(c) Rawdat al-Kafi, which is concerned with various religious aspects and includes some writings of the imams.
In total al-Kafi comprises 16,199 narrations however, as with al Shi’ah and Sunni Hadith books, every single
Hadith must be individually examined through the science of Hadith.
Page 5 of 14
2. Man la Yahdhuruhu’l Faqih is a Hadith collection, by the famous Twelver Shi,ah Hadith scholar Abu Jafar
Muhammad Ibn Ali commonly known as Al-Shaikh Al Saduq. The literal translation of the title Man la
Yahdhuruhu al Faqih is for him not in the presence of a Jurisprudent. Man la Yahdhuruhu’ al Faqih is mainly
concerned with Furoo al-Din. The book is meant to be a reference book to help ordinary Shiah Muslims in
the practice of the legal requirements of Islam. Generally, the Island (chains of the narrations) are absent.
3. Tahdhib al-Ahkam is a Hadith collection, by the famous Twelver Shi,ah Hadith scholar Abu- Abu Ja’far
Muhammad Ibn Hassan Tusi commonly known as Sheikh Tusi Tahdhib al-Ahkam could be translated as
“the refinement of the laws as Discussed in terms of the explanation of the sufficiency”. The original intension
of Al-Tusi had been to write a commentary on Al-Muqni’a of al-Mufid. However he makes it clear in his
introduction that his work would only concern the practical regulations for carrying out the Shariyah, the holy
law of Islam. He said “ I went first to the preceded it, which were about the Unity of Allah(Tawheed), Justis
(Adl), Prophet hood(Nabuwat) and the immamah, because the explanation of these would be too lengthy, and
also because it was not the intension of this book to elucidate the principles of religion (al-Usul).
4. Al-Istibsar is the forth book of Shi’a Hadith. It was written by Abu Jaf’ar al Tusi. It covers the same field as
Tahdhib al-ahkam but is considerably smaller. Al-Tusi mentions that his colleagues, after seeing the size of
Tahdhib al-Ahkam considered: It would be useful that there should be reference book which a beginner could
use in his study of jurisprudence, or one who has finished, reminding himself, or the intermediate(student) to
study more deeply. Thus (so that) all of them could obtain what they need and reach their soul’s desire, what
is connected with different traditions would be set in an abridged way. Therefore they asked me to summarize
it (Tahdhib al-Ahkam) and devote care to its compilation and abridgement, and to begin each section with an
introduction about what I relied on for the legal decisions and traditions in it.
Page 6 of 14
METHODS USED BY MUHADDITHUN (COMPILERS OF AHADITH)
TO ENSURE THE AUTHENTICITY OF AHADITH
The compilers of six authentic books applied a very strict criterion in selecting the Ahadith for their books.
They did not accept any Hadith that did not meet the set criteria. They checked the chain of narrators as well
as the text.
Every Hadith is divided into two parts, the first part the Sand (chain of narrators) and the second is the
Matn(text of Hadith). This is explained through the following Hadith, Muhammad bin Al-Muthanna reported
from Abdul Wahab from Ayub from Abu Killabah, from Malik that the Prophet said, “Pray as you have seen
me offering prayer”.(Agreed upon)
The first part which mentions the chain of transmitters is the Sanad and the second part which the body or text
is the matn. The Muhaddithan assessed both parts of the Hadiths scrupulously.
In short Hadith researchers paid critical attention to the science of biographies and criticism (Asma’ al Rijal)
of the Hadith narrators in each generation. And so, narrators of Hadith (Isnad) were subjected to severe tests
and were graded according to varying degrees of reliability and genuineness depending upon their character,
religious reputation and orientation, depth of knowledge, and the soundness and accuracy of the memories.
Page 7 of 14
MAJOR TYPES OF AHADITH
Hadith Nabavi
The Arabic word Hadith literally means ‘statement’ or ‘talk’. In Islamic terminology, the term Hadith(plural:
Hadith or Ahadith) refers to reports of statements or actions of Prophet Muhammad(S.A.W), or of his tacit
approval or disapproval of something said or done in his presence. For instance “Actions depend on
intensions”
Hadith Qudsi
The word of Allah reported by the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) is Hadith Qudsi or divine Hadith. Hadith Qudsi does
not form a part of the Holy Quran. Unlike the Holy Quran, Hadith Qudsi does not need to be recited, nor
forms a part of the words of Allah of which he has taken the responsibility to protect till the day of judgment.
For Instance, the Prophet (P.B.U.H)narrated that Allah says, “Pride is my clock and greatness my robe, and he
who competes with me in respect of either of them I shall cast into hell in fire.”
The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) is the first narrators in Divine Hadith while in Hadith e Nabvi, companion is the
first narrator.
As far as the first classification is concerned, the traditionists have divided the traditions into three classes,
according to the degree of reliability based on the perfection of imperfection of the chain of their transmitters.
Also they saw whether the text had any hidden defects.
The acceptance of rejection of the particular Hadith by the companions, the followers and their successors
was also taken into consideration.
1. Hadith Sahih (Authentic): If all the narrators in the Sanad fulfill the conditions stipulated, the Hadith is
named as Sahih. {Narrated ‘Ali: The Prophet said: “do not tell a lie against me for whoever tells a lie
against me(intentionally) then he will surely enter the Hell-fire.”}
2. Hassan (Approved): It is like Sahih Hadith except the some of its narrators have been found defective in
memory in companions with the narrators of Sahih Hadith.
3. Daeef Hadith(week): If any of the narrators in the Sanad was known to have had any of the following
faults, that Hadith is named as Daeef.
4. Maudu Hadith: Fabricated of forged Hadith is named as Maudoo. This type of Hadith is completely
rejected by the Jurists. “Seek knowledge, even if you have to go to China”. This Hadith has been classed as
Maudu Fabricated Al-Baani Fabricated narrations are not even considered to be Hadith at all.
Page 8 of 14
With regard to their acceptance, the Ahadith have been divided into two most important
Classes
1. Mutawatir: It is a Hadith reported by a large number of people in different times whose agreement on a
lie becomes inconceivable.
2. Ahaad(Single): Ahaad are those whose isnad is broken or whose traditions are less widely accepted and
therefore are regarded as less authentic but if their narrators were regarded as honest they were accepted
otherwise rejected.
Page 9 of 14
The Musannaf Compilation:
The need for a compilation was a systematic arrangement (chapter and subject) that facilitated legal decisions
became paramount. This was especially evident since the Sahifa type of Hadith was inadequate as a manual that
enhanced legal rulings. And so, by the middle of the second century A.H. the next type of Hadith emerged.
This second stage known as musannaf (literally, compiled together) was put together in an orderly and classified
manner. The Ahadith of this type were divided into chapters according to their subject matter, generally based on
legal themes.
In the musannaf class of Hadith, the compiler narrated the Hadith text (matn) through a chain of attributed to
companions, successors and other leading jurists.
The compiler in many cases, also included his own comments. These additional textual materials made legal
decisions easier than the sahihfah type. Moreover, each chapter of the nusannaf was devoted to a special theme,
primarily of a legal nature.
The main critisism leveled against the musananf compilation was that it focused essentially on legal matters, thus
subordinating the study of the prophetic tradition as a general source of guidance its own right in defense to legal
demands and preference.
In addition, the subject matter of the musannaf traditions was limited since it did not cover all aspects of the
Muslim life but focused mainly on legal themes.
The Importance of Hadith is increased for the Muslims by the fact that the Prophet Muhammad not only taught
but also took the opportunity of putting his teachings into practice in all the important affairs of life. The life of
Holy Prophet (S.A.W) is model of excellence for behaviors of all times. Therefore it was extremely necessary to
compile and preserved the authentic Ahadith for the future generations of Muslims.
Page 10 of 14
SIGNIFICANCE OF HADITH IN THOUGHT AND ACTION
IN ISLAM
Unless and until we follow Sunnat it is not possible to carry out the commands, injunctions and guidelines of the
Holy Quran. For Example: the Quranic Injunction is to “Keep up prayer and pay Zakat” but no details thereto
have been laid down in the Holy Quran. What is prayer?, when and how it is to be offered?, what parameters have
to adhered to while offering the salat have not been spelled out in the Holy Quran? It was the Holy Prophet
(S.A.W) by his own action and saying gave all details pertaining to prayer. Likewise all details relating to
collections and distributes of zakat too were provided by the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) and not the Quran.
Along with the Holy Quran, Obedience of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) have been enjoyed upon the believers by
Allah Almighty. The Holy Quran Says:
“O’ Ye who believe! Obey Allah, and Obey the Messenger, and those of you who are in authority’ and if Ye
have a dispute concerning any matter , refer it to Allah and the Messenger” (4:59)
The Sunnat of the Holy Prophet (PBUH) gives rules relating to all aspects of life the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) gave
his people a religion which thoroughly practiced. He founded a sate which he administered, he laid his armies in
different encounters, and he married and maintained a family. In all theses, whatever he did and the way he did
became part of the Shariah, and hence a must for us all to follow as such.
The deeds, behavior, character and conduct of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) of Islam furnish a role model of his
followers. The Holy Quran say “Verily in the Messenger of Allah Ye have a good Example for him who
looked until Allah and the last day….”(33:21). It Is repotted in Al-Bukhari that the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) said:
“Surely, I was only sent to complete the most noble character traits”. According to an oft quoted tradition,
when a person asked Hazrat Aisha about the conduct of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) many years after his death, she
Said ”Have you not read the Quran? His conduct (Khulq) was the Quran ”
For he neither said anything or did anything of his own accord. The Holy Quran says: ”I follow only that which
is inspired in me from my lord.”(7:203)
Islam’s not only aims to purify the individuals who make the society but also strengthen the foundation of the
Muslims community from within, emphasizing the message of love, cooperation’s ,brotherhood, kindness and
mercifulness and to each other. A large set of Ahadith in compasses these two types of behaviors wherein the
Sunnat provides practical demonstration of how an individual can become an asset for the Muslim society by
displaying kindness to his relatives, concern for his neighbors, affection and support for the poor’s and the
orphans, mercy towards the infirm and servants, compassions for the young, respect for the elderly sympathy for
the grieved and cheer for the depressed.
Page 11 of 14
words. Indeed, the Holy Prophet (S.A.W), through his life and actions rendered the Holy Quran easier to understand.
The meaning of Qura’nic Verse and their applications have to be understood in the light of his sayings, actions,
practices, explanations which are the second source of Islamic Jurisprudents from which the teaching of Islam are
drawn. Allah Almighty has delegated legislative powers to the Holy Prophet (S.A.W). The Quran makes the Prophetic
Sunnah as mandatory for Muslims. The Quran Say, ”Obey Allah and Obey the Prophet”.
It is not every Hadith that is a source of Law. To qualify Sunnah / Hadith as a source of law. It is necessary that the
acts must have a legal content. The purpose of the saying or acts of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) should be related to the
law of its elaboration.
Where some Hukam is not mentioned in the Quran and Holy Prophet (S.A.W) decides it according to its own wisdom,
it becomes a source of law making.
The legislative function of Sunnah with respect to the Holy Quran or the relationship between Quran and Sunnah can
be discussed as under:
Like the Quran, the Sunnah also forms legislation. It enjoins and prohibits, it establishes religious obligations and
determines lawful and unlawful.
1. The Sunnah / Hadith discusses or Emphasizes the laws, which are similar to that of the Holy Qur’an. These
laws approve the laws of Holy Quran such as the obedience of the parents, false evidence, murdering of a
person and the moral values.
2. The commandments in the Holy Quran and generally unelaborated from. The Sunnah elaborates these
commandments of the Holy Qur’an such as rate of Zakat, method of Hajj, method of prayer and some other
similar commandments. (Explain)
3. The Holy Quran gives general commandments / rules. The Sunnah restricts or qualifies these commandments.
Allah permits trading in the words “Allah permits trading…..”(Al-Baqarah: 228). It is a general
commandment but the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) particularized it by prohibiting some kind of trading for
example he forbade from trading of the thing which is absent or trade of unlawful (Haraam) goods such as
wine etc.
4. The Sunnah / Hadith may add or supplement the legal provision of the Qur’an. For example, the Quran
prohibits marriage of two sisters with one man at the same time and Sunnah prohibits marriage with maternal
of parental aunt of wife at the same time.
5. Some laws do not exist in the Holy Qur’an; the Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H) himself gave these laws. It is so
because Sunnah itself is a source of a Shariah law and the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) has the authority to make
laws.
Page 12 of 14
The division of inheritance for Muslim is clearly mentioned in the Quran but nothing is stated about Non-
Muslim relatives. The Prophet said “ A Muslim cannot inherit from a Non-Muslim, nor a non-Muslim can
inherit from a Muslim.” (Agreed)
To conclude, I can say, that Sunnah is second primary source of Islamic law. It is interlinked with the Quran in so far
as it restricts its general meaning or qualifies its absolute texts or explains its difficult words.
They should direct their efforts towards observing justice and helping fellow members in all possible ways in
order to demonstrate their conduct of belonging to the same community.
The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) has given instructions about the duties and rights of rulers and their subjects. Muslim
leaders should be fair, honest, just and kind towards their public and they should be respected and obeyed and
given full support in all affairs which they conduct according to the teachings of Islam. The Holy Prophet (S.A.W)
says “Who so obeys my commander, obeys me and who so obeys the commander disobey me” (Al-Muslim)
Muslim rulers should make the life of common people comfortable, dignified and respectable without regard to
color, ethnicity, gender or any other discrimination and favoritism. The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) has instructed the
rulers with these words “Be Gentle and don’t be hard and cause rejoicing and do not alienate”.
According to Islamic faith all believers are bounded together by common faith in Islam. They therefore constitute
a single family or brotherhood where all members are familiar to each other regardless of geographical, racial,
linguistic, barriers. The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) said “The Muslim society is like a body in respect of mutual
love and sympathy, if a limb in a body suffers pain, the whole body responds to it by sleeplessness and
fever”.
Muslims must work for the welfare of their brothers. They must stand by each other and help one another at the
time of need and support each other morally and financially. They should protect the honor and dignity of another
Muslim
Each and every member of the Muslim community should be ready to put his brother before his own self in
ordinary and routine matters of daily life. The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) said “The best among you is he who is
source of benefit for others.
Looking after the poor, widows and less privileged members of the society is as meritorious as striving in the way
of Allah or worship of Allah at night and fasting at day time.”One who manages the affairs of the widow and
the poor man is like the one who exerts himself in the way of Allah, or the one who stands for prayer in the
night or fasts in the day.” (Al-Hadith)
Members of Muslim community are also required to make individual and collective efforts to suppress any evil
that is seen to grow in the society. “Whosoever of you sees an evil action let him change it with his hand, and
if he is not able to do so then with his tongue and if he is not able to so then with his heart and that is the
weakest of faith”.
All Muslims should preach, give advice and warn other of evil consequences of their evil deeds. They should
encourage and motivate peoples to do good actions. However, if they are able to do so, at least they should
consider it evil in their heart and hate it. Muslims must stop evil otherwise they will be punished.
Page 13 of 14
A Muslim is not only required to assist one who is the victim of injustice and wrong doing, but also try to stop the
one who is committing it and strive with all his energy to bring about the rule of justice and righteousness for all
propel.
By practicing the teachings of the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) we can make this world a place of peace, love and
harmony.
First of all the Holy Prophet (S.A.W) teaches us to follow the faith of Islam full and with dedications. He tells us
that we must be sincere in the teachings we believe in and in the things we do. We must live our lives as obedient
Muslims to Allah and his Prophet. We should believe and act according to the discipline of Islam.
The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) has emphasized upon Muslims to perform obligatory religious duties like prayer,
fasting, Zakat, Hajj. We as Muslim must differentiate between lawful and unlawful. We believe that without the
establishment of prayers (salah) and observance of the sawm(fasting), it is impossible to avoided a hellfire. Prayer
is second pillar of Islam; it was the first act of worship that was made obligatory. The prophet (PBUH) said
“between the moment and the disbelief is discarding prayers” (Ahmed)
The Quran is the book of guidance. It covers all the aspects of life, social, religious, moral, ethical, political,
financial etc. Muslim individuals are not enjoyed only to recite and study but also ponder over the meanings of
Quran. The Holy Prophet (S.A.W) said,” the best amongst you is the one who studies Quran and teaches it”
Therefore we should not only recite and learn the Holy Quran but also grasp its meanings and mould our lives
accordingly to get rewards.
Islam attaches great importance to the dignity of manual labor and confers great reward for lawful earning. The
Holy Prophet (S.A.W) says, “No one eats better food than which he eats out of the work of his hand” neat,
clean, lawful, honest earning through labor and hard works makes the living of a person laudable. This actually is
the way, the Prophets earned their living. This also promotes independence and self sufficiency and does not leave
one’s survival at the mercy of other.
Muslims individuals are commanded not only to behave kindly but also to speak kindly during monetary
transactions such as buying and selling, lending money or borrowing it.
Page 14 of 14