Evaluation of Wastewater Quality Treated by The Step of The City of Errachidia (Morocco)
Evaluation of Wastewater Quality Treated by The Step of The City of Errachidia (Morocco)
DOI 10.3233/AJW230036
Abstract: The objective of this study is the physico-chemical and bacteriological characterisation of raw and
purified wastewater from the WWTP of the city of Errachidia, Morocco, during the year 2020, in order to evaluate
the effectiveness of wastewater treatment. of the wastewater treatment plant, of the aerated lagoon type, and see
their reuse in irrigation. The average monthly results of the physico-chemical analyses of treated wastewater
carried out from January to December 2020 are as follows: BOD5 = 94.45 mgo2/l; COD = 339.32 mgo2/l; SS
= 87.67 mg/L. The results show compliance with the general limit values for the discharge of Moroccan surface
water, which protects the environment. Thus, the bacteriological results show the presence of various germs with
average annual values where faecal coliforms (CF) are 680 CFU/100 ml; total coliforms (CT) are 2810 UFC/100
and faecal streptococci are 46 UFC/100 ml, which remain below the limit values recommended by Moroccan
irrigation standards (CF < 1000 UFC/100 ml), which allows their exploitation and their reuse in irrigation.
Key words: Treated wastewater, aerated lagoon, WWTP of the city of Errachidia, physico-chemical parameters,
bacteriological parameters.
*Corresponding Author
40 Ouhammi M. et al.
Table 1: Physico-chemical parameters of raw and treated wastewater at the inlet and outlet of the treatment plant
of Errachidia during the year 2020
Parameters Month T°C TSS (mg /L) COD (mgo2/l) BOD5 (mgo2/l)
January Between 14.9 120 650 298
Output 10 90 227 90
February Between 18 188 792 360
Output 17 100 240 88
March Between 20 145 744 320
Output 17 75 242 70
May Between 25 156 922 391
Output 26 86.5 202 125
June Between 24 91.5 393.6 220
Output 25 70 280 171
July Between 25 413.5 930 460
Output 25 47 203 121
August Between 18.5 325 960 451
Output 19 78 220 100
September Between 19 140.5 721.3 364
Output 19 98.14 464.6 142
October Between 20 160 1131.3 129
Output 20 100.5 498 25
November Between 21 165 1368 251
Output 20 105 608 31
December Between 21 145 1114.6 393
Output 20 104.5 548 76
Average Output 19.81 86.78 339.32 94.45
surface or ground water Output 30 100 500 100
discharge limit values
(2018) Morocco.
Figure 3 : Variation in average COD values at the Figure 4: Variation of average BOD5 values at the inlet
plant outlet. and outlet of the plant.
outlet of the STEP are lower than those found at the carbon pollution and whose values can reach 70.47%,
STEP of the city Dar El Gueddari, Morocco (Ayyach on the one hand. On the other hand, these recorded
et al., 2016) from the month of January to August but values of the BOD5 at the outlet c omply with t h e
from the month of September to December these COD general discharge limit values of Moroccan surface or
values are higher than those of the output of STEP of underground water.
the city Dar El Gueddari.
Using the results of Table 1, the COD/BOD5 ratio Suspended Solids (Figure 5)
for the wastewater entering the WWTP is less than three All of t h e mineral and organic particles contained
(COD/BOD5<3) indicating biodegradable effluent while in waste w ater represent suspended solids as well.
the COD/BOD5 ratio is higher to three (COD/BOD5 Knowledge of the concentration of colloidal elements in
sup to 3) for the months of October to December, and wastewater is important to assess the effect of pollution
therefore their biodegradability is difficult, this is due on the aquatic ecosystem. The amount of suspended
to the nature of the effluent resulting from the activity matter at the entrance varies between 91.5 mg/L and
of small industrial units connected to the network of 413.5 mg/L, with an average of 186.31 mg/L, which
sanitation, same thing for the COD/BOD5 ratio at the remains lower than that found in 2014 (Chaouki et al.,
exit of t he STEP, These values show us an average 2014) The concentration at the outlet varies between
reduction of the aerated basins with respect to carbon 47 mg/L a nd 104.5 mg/L, with an average of 86.78
pollution, which reaches an average value of 66.4% mg/L. These SS values at the outlet of the STEP meet
which is lower than that found in 2013 (Chaouki et al., the general discharge limit values for Moroccan surface
2014), which is 83%. However, these COD values of or groundwater.
the purified waters recorded remain in conformity with The abatement rates of organic pollution parameters
the general limit values for the discharge of superficial which are 70.47%, 60.21% and 44.02%, respectively,
waters or depths of Morocco. for BOD5 , COD and SS indicate that the treatment
efficiency of WWTP is better for BOD5, average for
Biochemical Oxygen Demand (Figure 4) COD and low for suspended solids. The low reduction
The bioc h emical oxygen dem a nd is the quantity of of suspended solids is explained by a malfunction of the
oxygen u s ed for the degrad a tion of decomposable
and biod e gradable organic m atter by biochemical
processes (Rodier, 2016). The concentrations of BOD5
at the entrance to the WWTP in the city of Errachidia
(Morocco) vary between 129 mg/L and 460 mg/L, these
values are similar to those found in Agadir, Morocco
(Mansir e t al., 2021) and l ower than those found at
the WWTP in the city of Dar El Gueddari, Morocco
(Ayyach et al., 2016). The average values at the outlet
vary between 25 mg/L and 171 mg/L with an average
Figure 5: Variation of average TSS values at the inlet and
of 94.45 mg/L. These values at the outlet tell us about
outlet of the station.
the best abatement of aerated pools with respect to
Evaluation of Wastewater Quality Treated by the Step of the City of Errachidia (Morocco) 43
Table 2: Abatement rate in % of raw and treated indicating faecal contamination. The average total
wastewater of the Errachidia wastewater treatment coliform (TC) load is around 56026.90 germs per
plant during the year 2020 100 ml. For faecal coliforms (CF), the average values
are 9080 germs per 100 ml. Faecal streptococci (SF)
Monthly reduction in % BOD5 COD TSS
represent 1095 germs per 100 ml. The CF/SF ratio is
(mg/L) (mg/L) (mg/L)
greater than 1, which means that the faecal pollution of
January 69.79 65.07 25
wastewater in the city of Errachidia is of human origin.
February 75.55 69.69 46.88 According to Table 3, we note that the total coliforms
March 78.12 67.47 48.27 at the outlet of the station vary between 17800 and 28
May 68,03 78.09 44.55 CFU/100 ml, while the faecal coliforms vary between
June 22,27 28,86 23.49 3700 and 16 CFU/100 ml with an average of 680
July 73.69 78.17 88.63 CFU/100 ml, and faecal streptococci vary between
180 CFU/100 ml and 5 CFU/100 ml, with an average
August 77.82 77.08 76
of 46 CFU/100 ml. These values are comparable to
September 60.98 35.58 30.14 those found in the wastewater treatment plant of the
October 80.62 55.98 37.07 city of Agadir (Morocco) for filtered wastewater (CF)
November 87.64 55.55 36.36 and (SF) for purified wastewater (Mansir et al., 2021)
December 80.66 50.83 27.93 and do not exceed the Moroccan s t andard for water
Abatement allowance 70.47 60.21 44.02 intended for irrigation, which allows us to deduce that
and % also the treatment carried out in the finishing basins
generates yields lower than the values required by the
screening system which allows the waste to pass into standards WHO and Moroccan (SEEE-2007) which is
the anaerobic basin. Similarly, the temperature plays less than 1000 CFU per 100 ml. Also deduced from
a very important role in the reduction of the organic the values shown in Table 3 for total coliforms (CT)
load. it is noted that if the temperature at the WWTP that the calculated purification efficiency of the winter
inlet increases, the organic load decreases at the WWTP season is 82.27% while that of the summer season is
outlet and vice versa, hence its importance in reducing 97.92% where the effective role of temperature, thus
the organic load. This importance of temperature in for faecal coliforms (CF), the purification efficiency
the reduction of the organic load is also highlighted calculated for the winter season is 91.38% and that of
in a study on the purification of wastewater by natural the summer season is 90.80%, and therefore there is a
lagoons (Onifade, 2011). Thus the value of the average slight difference between the two values of purification
abatement rate for the winter season for B OD5 is efficiency. T hese winter and sum m er puri f i c ation
70.83%, and that of the summer season is 7 4.48%, efficiency c a lculated for total c oliform s a nd faecal
likewise, the values of the average abatement rate for coliforms remain lower than those found in the WWTP
the winter season for SS is around 40.05%, then that of of the city of Oujda (eastern Morocco) which is close
the summer season is 64.92% (Table 2), and therefore, to 100% (Rassam et al., 2012).
the reduction rate for the summer season f or BOD5
and SS is greater than that of the winter season. Hence Conclusion
the importance of temperature in reducing the organic
load. Thus the reducti o n rates of the pol l uting load The evaluation of the physico-chemical and
between raw effluents and treated effluents for COD, bacteriological parameters of the wastewater from
BOD5 and SS for the WWTP in the city of Errachidia the Errachidia treatment plant during the year 2020
which uses aerated lagoon treatment remain lower than shows that: The abatement yields with the aerated
those found in Mediona Casa Blanca, Morocco which lagoon reached average values of 70.47 %, 60.21%
globally exceeds 90% with a very efficient treatment and 44.02%, respectively, for B O D5, COD and SS
system which is Biological Membrane Reactor (BMR) and remain lower than those fou n d in 2014 for the
(Nahli et al., 2016) same station (82%, 83% and 88%) (Chaouki et al.,
2014). As for faecal contaminat i on indicator germs,
Faecalgerms their reduction is 92.51% for total coliforms; 94.98%
The results of bacteriological analyses at the entrance for faecal coliforms and 95.79% for faecal streptococci
to the treatment plant reveal the presence of germs (Table 3) as well.
44 Ouhammi M. et al.
Table 3: Average values of total coliforms; faecal and faecal streptococci of wastewater at the inlet and outlet of the
treatment plant of Errachidia during the year 2020
The quality of the treated water from the station chiffré, Ministre d’équipement ,transport ,logistique et
complies with the general limit values for
the discharge de l’eau ,Ministre d’énergie –Mines et développement
of Moroccan surface or underground water. Aeration durable, du ministre de tourisme, transport aérien,industrie
systems and the adaptation of micro-organisms to the et l’économie sociale n° 3286-17 du 13 hijja 1438 (4
degradation of organic matter. As a result, the quality of Septembre 2017) fixant les valeurs limites générales de
purified water allows its reuse in agriculture (Category rejet dans les eaux superficielles ou souterraines. Bulletin
A) according to the classification table of purified water .Officiel. n° 6641du 22 janvier 2018. Maroc
intended for irrigation (S.E.E.E-2007, Morocco)). But it Ayyach, A., Fathallah, R., Hbaiz, E.M., Fathallah, Z., Chouki,
is advisable to adopt a tertiary treatment and disinfection H. and A. El Midaoui (2016). Physico-chemical and
to obtain treated water of acceptable microbiological bacteriological characterization of wastewater treatment
quality for reuse in irrigation, allowing the protection of plant in the city DAr El Gueddari (Morocco). Larhyss
agricultural users and consumers of crops (WHO, 2012). Journal, 28: 65-85.
Chaouki, H., Elwatik, L., Ramchoun,Y., Fath-Allah, R.,
Ayyach, A., Fathallah, Z., El Midaoui, A. and E. Hbaiz
(2014). Etude des performances épuratoires de la technique
References du lagunage aéré appliquée à la station d’épuration de la
ville d’Errachidia-Maroc. Afrique Science, 10: 173-183.
Arrêté conjoint du ministre de l’intérieur, du ministre de DIRECTIVE 91/271/CEE (1991).Traitement des eaux
l’industrie, investissement ,commerce et Economie résiduaires urbaines. Journal Officiel, 135: 40-52.
Evaluation of Wastewater Quality Treated by the Step of the City of Errachidia (Morocco) 45
El Kettani, S. and M. EL Azzouzi (2006). Prévalence des et des eaux ménagères, Vol. 4 : Utilisation des excréta et
helminthes au sein d’une population rurale utilisant des eaux ménagères en agriculture.
les eaux usées à des fins agricoles à Settat (Maroc). Ounoki, S. and S. Achour (2014). Evaluation de la qualite
Environnement, Risques et santé, 2: 99-106 physicochimique et bacteriologique des eaux usees
JesúsVillalobos, G., Vialle, C., Sablayrolles, C., Montrejaud- brutes et epurees de la ville d’ouargla: Possibilite de leur
Vignoles, M., Amalric, J.-P., Desmolles, M., Vignoles, C., valorisation en irrigation, Larhyss Journal, 20: 247-258.
Gallien, P. and C. Albasi (2019). Study of the performance Rassam, A., Chaouch, A., Bourkhiss, B. and M. Bourkhiss
of a filter medium consisting of a layer of hemp shives (2012). Performances de la dégradation de la matière
on a layer of olive pomace in the treatment of domestic organique par lagunage aéré dans la station d’épuration des
wastewater: Scale-up from biofiltration pilot to full-scale. eaux usées de la ville d’Oujda (Maroc oriental). Bulletin
Journal of Water Science, 32: 1. de la Société Royale des Sciences de Liège, 81: 121-125.
Mahdad, T. and A. Lacherai (2014). Contribution à Rhoualem, F., El Hadiri, H., Oukour, N., Taouil, H.,
l’amélioration d’épuration des eaux usées dans une step. Arouyaa, K. and S. Ibn Ahmed (2022). Physico-chemical
Mater. Environ. Sci., 5(S1): 2052-2059. characterization of leachate from the Moulay Abdallah
Mandi, L. and Ouazani (2013). Water and wastwater technical landfill center (Morocco). Journal of Ecological
management in Morocco: Biotechnologies application. Engineering, 8: 241-248.
Sustainable Sanitation Practice, 14: 9-16. Rodier, J. (1996). L’analyse de l’eau: eaux naturelles,
Mansir, I., Oertlé, E. and R. Choukr-Allah (2021). Evaluation eaux résiduaires, eaux de mer, chimie, physicochimie,
of the Performance and Quality of Wastewater Treated by microbiologie, biologie, interprétation des résultats, Paris
M’zar Plant in Agadir, Morocco.Water, 13: 954. (France), Dunod, p. 1384.
Merhabi, F., Amine, H. and J. Halwani (2019). Evaluation Rodier, J. (2016). L’analyse de l’eau naturelle, eaux
de la qualité des eaux de surface de la rivière Kadicha. résiduaires, eau de mer, 10e éd. Denod, Paris, 1.
Journal Scientifique Libanais, 1: 10-34. Sadhana, K., Madhavi, D. and B.T. Rao (2021). Typological
Nahli, A., Sakhraoui, N., Hebabaze1, S., Hmimidi, C., Brand, bacteriological quality of the Gharb water table-Morocco.
C., and M. Chlaida (2016). International Journal of Recent Trends in Multidisciplinary
Membrane biological treatment and agricultural reuse of Research, 01: 36-41.
Mediouna wastewaters (Casablanca, Morocco), J. Mater. Secrétariat d’Etat auprès du Ministère de l’Energie, des
Environ., 7: 40-49. Mines, de l’Eau et de l’Environnement, chargé de l’Eau et
OMS (2012). Directives OMS pour l’utilisation sans risque de l’Environnement : Norme de qualité des eaux destinée
des eaux usées, des excrétas et des eaux ménagères- à l’irrigation, S.E.E.E (2007) Maroc.
Volume II, utilisation des eaux usées en agriculture. Shakir, E., Zahraw, Z. and A.H.M. Al-Obaidy (2017).
Organisation Mondiale de la Santé, p 26 . Environmental and health risks associated with reuse of
Onifade, T.U. (2011). Evaluation des performances et wastewater for irrigation. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum,
optimisation technique de la station d’épuration de 1: 95-102
Bobo-Dioulasso (Burkina Faso). Mémoire de master en Soude, M.K., Bothon, F.T.D., Deguenon, H.E.J., Koudoro,
ingénierie de l’eau et de l’environnement, Fondation 2ie, Y.A., Agbangnan, D.C.P., Mama, D. and D.V. Wotto
p50. (2018). Physicochemical and bacteriological analyzes
Organisation Mondiale de la Santé (2012). Directives OMS of wastewater from some Cotonou hotels, International
pour l’utilisation sans risque des eaux usées, des excréta Journal of Innovation and Applied Studies, 23: 227-234.
Asian Journal of Water, Environment and Pollution
Volume 20 Number 1 January, 2023
Contents
Editorial i
q Snapshots ii