National Trends in Clinical Outcomes of Endovascular Therapy For Ischemic Stroke in South Korea Between 2008 and 2016
National Trends in Clinical Outcomes of Endovascular Therapy For Ischemic Stroke in South Korea Between 2008 and 2016
https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2020.01928
                                                                                                      30
2010),” when stent retrievers were rarely used; “transitional                                         25                                                                                     1,500
statuses of cerebral hemorrhage, disability, and death as poor Total ET 3-month mortality 1-year mortality
outcomes. SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) Cerebral hemorrhage Home discharge Disability
cerebral hemorrhage within 30 days gradually decreased from                       ties, and use of tissue plasminogen activator, the risk of death
6.8% in 2008 to 1.8% in 2016. Furthermore, the rate of dis-                       and disability were significantly lower in the MT and transi-
ability was 36.8% in 2008 and 21.7% in 2016.                                      tional periods than in the non-advanced MT period. Logistic
   A period-based analysis revealed that the patients’ average                    regression analysis adjusted for the same covariates revealed
age and the prevalence of risk factors increased gradually dur-                   the MT period was an independent predictor of home discharge
ing the study period. The highest proportion of comorbidities                     (Supplementary Table 1).
and Charlson comorbidity index was noted in the MT period.                           In agreement with other studies,3,4 our analysis of the na-
The rate of home discharge increased and the mortality rates                      tionwide data showed that the patients treated with ET had
decreased continuously from the non-advanced MT period to                         better outcomes in the MT period than in the non-advanced
the MT period. Additionally, the ratio of the patients receiving                  MT period. Over time, the baseline prognostic characteristics,
surgery for cerebral hemorrhage after ET decreased during the                     reflected by age and comorbidities, got worse; however, the
study period. The rate of disability after ischemic stroke also                   outcomes of the patients generally improved; this was sup-
showed a significant decrease from the non-advanced MT pe-                        ported by the annual trend analyses (Supplementary Table 2).
riod to the MT period (Table 1). The 1-year survival rate tended                     In this study, the rates of mortality, disability, and cerebral
to increase from the non-advanced MT period to the MT period                      hemorrhage decreased with the increased application of ET.
(P<0.0001) (Figure 2). After adjusting for age, sex, comorbidi-                   The 3-month mortality rate in the MT period observed in the
Table 1. Baseline characteristics and outcomes of patients according to the period of endovascular therapy adoption
                                                                                                              Standardized difference (%)
                                 Non-advanced      Transitional                               Non-advanced MT Non-advanced MT
Characteristic                                                      MT period         P                                         Transitional period
                                   MT period          period                                      period and         period
                                                                                                                                  and MT period
                                                                                              transitional period and MT period
Number                                3,028           4,113            5,360
Male sex                          1,691 (55.8)    2,246 (54.6)     2,968 (55.4)     0.5619           2.490              0.951                –1.539
Age (yr)                         69.00±10.70     70.97±10.81      71.08±11.02      <0.0001         –18.294            –19.158                –1.032
   <60                              630 (20.8)      706 (17.2)       931 (17.4)    <0.0001           9.293              8.753                –0.541
   60–69                            785 (25.9)      938 (22.8)     1,251 (23.3)                      7.270              6.003                –1.267
   70–79                          1,124 (37.1)    1,519 (36.9)     1,850 (34.5)                      0.390              5.436                 5.045
   ≥80                              489 (16.1)      950 (23.1)     1,328 (24.8)                    –17.563            –21.507                –3.935
Hypertension                      2,119 (70.0)    3,192 (77.6)     4,125 (77.0)    <0.0001         –17.410            –15.857                 1.548
Diabetes mellitus                   975 (32.2)    1,807 (43.9)     2,574 (48.0)    <0.0001         –24.346            –32.713                –8.211
Dyslipidemia                      1,147 (37.9)    2,400 (58.4)     3,648 (68.1)    <0.0001         –41.861            –63.435               –20.234
Atrial fibrillation               1,411 (46.6)    2,137 (52.0)     2,861 (53.4)    <0.0001         –10.734            –13.588                –2.844
Ischemic heart disease              798 (26.4)    1,465 (35.6)     2,007 (37.4)    <0.0001         –20.136            –23.964                –3.791
Chronic kidney disease              202 (6.7)       373 (9.1)        427 (8.0)      0.0011          –8.913             –4.975                 3.950
CCI >5                            1,255 (41.4)    2,410 (58.6)     3,427 (63.9)    <0.0001         –34.812            –46.233               –10.982
Intravenous tPA                   1,025 (33.9)    1,283 (31.2)     2,032 (37.9)    <0.0001           5.674             –8.472               –14.160
   3-month mortality                777 (25.7)      903 (22.0)     1,045 (19.5)    <0.0001           8.709             14.784                 6.068
   1-year mortality               1,046 (34.5)    1,239 (30.1)     1,414 (26.4)    <0.0001           9.461             17.808                 8.322
   Cerebral hemorrhage (I61)        195 (6.4)       152 (3.7)        133 (2.5)     <0.0001          12.536             19.264                 7.023
   Cerebral hemorrhage              149 (4.9)       112 (2.7)        102 (1.9)     <0.0001          11.481             16.681                 5.458
    (operation)
   Disability                     1,016 (33.6)   1,092 (26.5)     1,254 (23.4)     <0.0001          15.320              22.653                 7.292
   Home discharge without    1,086 (35.9)        1,632 (39.7)     2,233 (41.7)     <0.0001          –7.873             –11.916               –4.034
    events
   Home discharge and re-ad-    48 (1.6)             71 (1.7)        67 (1.3)       0.1938          –1.105               2.836                 3.934
    mission within 30 days
   Home discharge and death    113 (3.7)            99 (2.4)        109 (2.0)      <0.0001           7.686              10.163                 2.535
    within 30 days
Values are presented as number (%) or mean±standard deviation.
MT, mechanical thrombectomy; CCI, Charlson comorbidity index; tPA, tissue plasminogen activator.
                              0.85
                               0.8                                                                            vanced MT period is likely attributed to the increasing use of
                              0.75                                                                            MT. However, we had no data on the proportion of patients
                               0.7
                                                                                                              treated with MT during the transition period and our interpre-
                              0.65
                               0.6
                                                                                                              tation is not supported by formal analysis.
                              0.55                                                                               In conclusion, our analysis of nationwide insurance data ver-
                               0.5                                                                            ified that the rates of mortality and disability associated with
                                     0     1    2     3      4    5     6      7     8   9   10    11    12
                                                                                                              stroke have decreased with the increasingly widespread adop-
                                                          Follow-up duration (mo)
                                                                                                              tion of stent retrievers.
Number at risk
Non-advanced MT period 3,028 2,484 2,383 2,306 2,251 2,193 2,152 2,121 2,089 2,055 2,030 2,003 1,982
Transitional period
MT period
                       4,113 3,531 3,386 3,280 3,210 3,141 3,100 3,048 3,008 2,956 2,923 2,899 2,874
                       5,360 4,670 4,503 4,394 4,315 4,247 4,196 4,144 4,097 4,051 4,014 3,986 3,946          Supplementary materials
                                 Non-advanced MT period            Transitional period            MT period   Supplementary materials related to this article can be found
                                                                                                              online at https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2020.01928.
Figure 2. Kaplan-Meier curve of 1-year mortality in the patients treated
for ischemic stroke by the period of endovascular therapy adoption
(P<0.0001). MT, mechanical thrombectomy.
                                                                                                              References
                                                                                                                1. Powers WJ, Derdeyn CP, Biller J, Coffey CS, Hoh BL, Jauch EC,
current study was higher than that reported in a meta-analysis                                                     et al. 2015 American Heart Association/American Stroke As-
of pivotal clinical trials,6 but it was lower than that reported in                                                sociation focused update of the 2013 guidelines for the early
a real-world data study.7 The 3-month mortality rate during                                                        management of patients with acute ischemic stroke regard-
the transitional period was similar to that reported by a study                                                    ing endovascular treatment: a guideline for healthcare pro-
performed around the time when stent retrievers were intro-                                                        fessionals from the American Heart Association/American
duced.8 We could not verify the clinical data from this claim                                                      Stroke Association. Stroke 2015;46:3020-3035.
data; therefore, we used disability registration data following                                                 2. Ko SB, Park HK, Kim BM, Heo JH, Rha JH, Kwon SU, et al.
cerebral injury rather than modified Rankin Scale (mRS) to                                                         2019 Update of the Korean clinical practice guidelines of
evaluate patient prognosis. The ratio of patients with an mRS of                                                   stroke for endovascular recanalization therapy in patients
3–5 (vs. 0–2) at 3-months in the meta-analysis of clinical stud-                                                   with acute ischemic stroke. J Stroke 2019;21:231-240.
ies and real-world data was higher than the rate of patients                                                    3. Rai AT, Crivera C, Kalsekar I, Kumari R, Patino N, Chekani F, et
with cerebral injury-related disability among the patients in the                                                  al. Endovascular stroke therapy trends from 2011 to 2017
national database used in our study.6,7 This difference could                                                      show significant improvement in clinical and economic out-
possibly because some patients with an mRS of 3–5 at 3                                                             comes. Stroke 2019;50:1902-1906.
months would have returned to their daily lives after rehabili-                                                 4. Stein L, Tuhrim S, Fifi J, Mocco J, Dhamoon M. National
tation. When patients survive with a disability after a stroke                                                     trends in endovascular therapy for acute ischemic stroke:
event, their direct medical costs and indirect social costs in-                                                    utilization and outcomes. J Neurointerv Surg 2020;12:356-
crease.9 Therefore, verifying decreases in the number of such                                                      362.
disabled patients is meaningful.                                                                                5. National Health Information Database. National Health In-
   This study has several limitations. We used insurance claims                                                    surance Service. https://nhiss.nhis.or.kr/bd/ay/bdaya001iv.do.
data rather than well-designed clinical trial or prospective reg-                                                  2019. Accessed September 4, 2020.
istry data. Therefore, we were unable to adjust for detailed and                                                6. Goyal M, Menon BK, van Zwam WH, Dippel DW, Mitchell PJ,
important prognostic factors such initial National Institutes of                                                   Demchuk AM, et al. Endovascular thrombectomy after large-
Health Stroke Scale scores, occlusion sites, recanalization sta-                                                   vessel ischaemic stroke: a meta-analysis of individual patient
tus, and interval from symptom onset to recanalization. In ad-                                                     data from five randomised trials. Lancet 2016;387:1723-
dition, we were unable to verify the precise number of patients                                                    1731.
who received ET in the period when solitaire stents, the most                                                   7. Wollenweber FA, Tiedt S, Alegiani A, Alber B, Bangard C, Ber-
                                                                       This work was supported by the National Health Insurance Ilsan Hospital grant
                                                                       (2019-1-167). This study used NHIS-NHID data (2019-1-167), provided by Na-
                                                                       tional Health Insurance Service (NHIS). The authors alone are responsible for the
                                                                       content and writing of the paper.
https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2020.01928
                                         Adjusted HR and OR for age, sex, comorbidities, and use of tissue plasminogen activator.
                                         HR, hazard ratio; OR, odds ratio; MT, mechanical thrombectomy; CI, confidence interval.
1http://j-stroke.org
2
                                         Supplementary Table 2. Baseline characteristics and outcomes of patients according to the calendar year
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Cochran-Armitage
                                         Characteristic                          2008              2009            2010            2011                2012          2013           2014           2015           2016
                                                                                                                                                                                                                               trend test, P
                                         Number                                   869              1,000          1,159            1,356               992          1,093          1,359          2,059          2,614
                                         Male sex                             502 (57.8)        556 (55.6)     633 (54.6)       760 (56.0)         545 (54.9)    590 (54.0)     724 (53.3)    1,115 (54.2)   1,480 (56.6)        0.5631
 http://j-stroke.org
                                         Age (yr)                            68.29±10.88      69.37±10.54      69.21±10.68     69.84±10.61         70.69±10.78   71.77±11.02   71.72±10.78    70.82±10.99    71.29±11.08
                                            <60                               202 (23.2)        193 (19.3)     235 (20.3)       252 (18.6)         181 (18.2)    179 (16.4)     210 (15.5)     360 (17.5)     455 (17.4)        <0.0001
                                            60–69                             227 (26.1)        280 (28.0)     278 (24.0)       344 (25.4)         217 (21.9)    231 (21.1)     295 (21.7)     491 (23.8)      611 (23.4)        0.0043
                                            70–79                             305 (35.1)        352 (35.2)     467 (40.3)       505 (37.2)         376 (37.9)    387 (35.4)     513 (37.7)     724 (35.2)     864 (33.1)         0.0084
                                            ≥80                               135 (15.5)        175 (17.5)     179 (15.4)       255 (18.8)         218 (22.0)    296 (27.1)     341 (25.1)     484 (23.5)     684 (26.2)        <0.0001
                                         Hypertension                         554 (63.8)        705 (70.5)     860 (74.2)     1,026 (75.7)         776 (78.2)    855 (78.2)    1,084 (80.0)   1,562 (75.9)   2,014 (77.0)       <0.0001
                                         Diabetes mellitus                    251 (28.9)        311 (31.1)     413 (35.6)       559 (41.2)         433 (43.6)    508 (46.5)     633 (46.6)     956 (46.4)    1,292 (49.4)       <0.0001
                                         Dyslipidemia                         272 (31.3)        373 (37.3)     502 (43.3)       701 (51.8)         565 (57.0)    677 (61.9)     914 (67.3)    1,364 (66.2)   1,827 (69.9)       <0.0001
                                         Atrial fibrillation                  390 (44.9)        466 (46.6)     555 (47.9)       689 (50.8)          511 (51.5)   558 (51.1)     736 (54.2)    1,119 (54.3)   1,385 (53.0)       <0.0001
                                         Ischemic heart disease               165 (19.0)        280 (28.0)     353 (30.5)       436 (32.2)         364 (36.7)    400 (36.6)     516 (38.0)     766 (37.2)     990 (37.9)        <0.0001
                                         Chronic kidney disease                61 (7.0)          69 (6.9)        72 (6.2)       108 (8.0)            80 (8.1)     107 (9.8)     133 (9.8)      160 (7.8)      212 (8.1)          0.0312
                                         CCI >5                               269 (31.0)        424 (42.4)     562 (48.5)       728 (53.7)         564 (56.9)    681 (62.3)     864 (63.6)    1,267 (61.5)   1,733 (66.3)       <0.0001
                                         Intravenous tPA                      290 (33.3)        337 (33.7)     398 (34.3)       426 (31.4)         313 (31.6)    318 (29.1)     497 (36.6)     751 (36.5)    1,010 (38.6)       <0.0001
                                            3-month mortality                 236 (27.2)        273 (27.3)     268 (23.1)       306 (22.6)         219 (22.1)    232 (21.2)     287 (21.1)     389 (18.9)     515 (19.7)        <0.0001
                                            1-year mortality                  316 (36.4)        365 (36.5)     365 (31.5)       414 (30.5)         295 (29.7)    322 (29.5)     393 (28.9)     534 (25.9)     695 (26.6)        <0.0001
                                            Cerebral hemorrhage (I61)          77 (8.9)          65 (6.5)        55 (4.7)        64 (4.7)            35 (3.5)      36 (3.3)       38 (2.8)       44 (2.1)       66 (2.5)        <0.0001
                                            Cerebral hemorrhage                59 (6.8)          36 (3.6)        54 (4.7)        48 (3.5)            25 (2.5)      23 (2.3)       30 (2.2)       42 (2.0)       46 (1.8)        <0.0001
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Seo et al.
                                             (operation)
                                            Disability                        320 (36.8)        323 (32.3)     373 (32.2)       415 (30.6)         253 (25.5)    253 (23.1)     359 (26.4)     500 (24.3)     566 (21.7)        <0.0001
                                            Home discharge without            311 (35.8)        357 (35.7)     418 (36.1)       537 (39.6)         394 (39.7)    424 (38.8)     541 (39.8)     825 (40.1)    1,144 (43.8)       <0.0001
                                             event
                                            Home discharge and re-ad-          14 (1.6)          18 (1.8)        16 (1.4)        23 (1.7)            15 (1.5)      22 (2.0)       16 (1.2)       29 (1.4)       33 (1.3)         0.2068
                                             mission within 30 days
                                            Home discharge and death           50 (5.8)          42 (4.2)        21 (1.8)        38 (2.8)            21 (2.1)      24 (2.2)       36 (2.6)       35 (1.7)       54 (2.1)        <0.0001
                                             within 30 days
                                         Values are presented as number (%) or mean±standard deviation.
                                         CCI, Charlson comorbidity index; tPA, tissue plasminogen activator.
https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2020.01928
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               National Trends in the Era of Endovascular Therapy
Vol. 22 / No. 3 / September 2020
Supplementary methods                                               within 30 days of discharge because their prognosis was ex-
                                                                    pected to be poor even if they experienced recurrence or were
Study population                                                    rehospitalized for rehabilitation.
We used data from the Korean National Health Insurance da-             Poor outcomes were defined as cerebral hemorrhage after
tabase, which has data on 97% of the South Korean popula-           the procedure, significant disability, and death. To identify the
tion. We extracted all insurance claims data of patients aged       incidence rate of cerebral hemorrhage, we screened patients
>45 years who were hospitalized due to cerebral infarction          with insurance claims of ICD-10 code I61 as the main diagno-
(International Classification of Diseases, 10th revision, code      sis, as the first subdiagnosis, or with a procedure code related
[ICD-10 code]: I63) as the main or first subdiagnosis between       to cerebral hemorrhage within 30 days of ET. The procedure
2007 and 2017. After considering the washout and follow-up          codes used for screening were N0322 (burr Hole), N0333 (cra-
periods, we excluded data from the years 2007 and 2017. Fur-        niectomy), and S4756/S4622 (hematoma removal). We tracked
ther, we sorted the claims data by procedure codes related to       deaths within 3 months and 1 year of ET using mortality data.
thrombectomy and determined whether a tissue plasminogen            In South Korea, the registration of disability is possible when at
activator (tPA) was used during thrombectomy in these pa-           least 6 months have passed from the time of the stroke event,
tients by referring to the Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical          permitting patients to register for the cerebral injury disability.
Classification System code B01AD02 or product code                  We further excluded patients who received ET in 2017 as we
653500661.                                                          could not track their deaths within 1 year or their status of dis-
   We classified the patients based on tPA use and the period       ability registration for cerebral injury from the selected data.
when endovascular therapy (ET) was performed. It was estimat-       Consequently, we analyzed patients and outcome variables by
ed that off-label stent retrievers were used in South Korea be-     year and then conducted a comparison analysis based on the
tween October and December of 2010. Even though its usage           non-advanced MT, transitional, and MT periods.
was officially approved, stent retrievers were not reimbursed by       We identified the comorbidities (hypertension, diabetes mel-
the South Korean National Health Insurance between May              litus, dyslipidemia, and atrial fibrillation) that could increase
2013 and July 2014. Therefore, we categorized the period when       the risk of stroke and, thus, affect the prognosis and the risk
stent retrievers were rarely used as the “non-advanced MT peri-     factors of patients from the insurance claims data prior to ET
od (January 2008 to December 2012)”; when we could not pre-         treatment and during hospitalization for ET. We analyzed the
cisely identify stent retriever usage as the “transitional period   Charlson comorbidity index of patients to verify the influence
(January 2011 to July 2014)”; and when the insurance claim          of comorbidities on death.
data verified the frequency of stent retriever use as the “MT pe-
riod (August 2014 to December 2016).”                               Statistical analysis
   This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of     SAS version 9.4 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) was used for
the National Health Insurance Service Ilsan Hospital (NHIMC         data analysis. To compare descriptive statistics and the fre-
2019-01-006).                                                       quency of risk factors, one-way analysis of variance and the
                                                                    chi-square test were used. To compare the distribution of base-
Outcome and covariates                                              line covariates between the analysis periods, we used the stan-
Good outcomes were defined as discharge of patients to their        dardized differences test. To confirm the difference in the incli-
homes after 30 days without significant issues such as death        nations of the outcome variables by year, we performed the
or rehospitalization. To screen patients with good outcomes,        Cochran-Armitage trend test. We performed a time-dependent
we tracked the insurance claims of patients who were dis-           Cox proportional hazard regression analysis to identify the risk
charged home after hospitalization for stroke treatment. To in-     factors for death and cerebral injury disability. To identify the
crease the reliability of good outcomes, we excluded patients       factors related to home discharge, multiple logistic regression
who had died within 30 days of discharge and those who had          analysis was used. P-values of <0.05 for the two-sided tests
claimed rehospitalization under either ICD-10 code I63 or I61       were considered to indicate statistical significance.
https://doi.org/10.5853/jos.2020.01928 http://j-stroke.org 3