Majima 1985
Majima 1985
The reactions of hematite in aqueous hydrochloric acid, perchloric acid, and sulfuric acid solutions
with or without the addition of common or uncommon salts were studied using monosized particulates
in a well-stirred reactor and dilute solid concentration to obtain fundamental details of the reaction
kinetics. The experimental rate data suggest that the entire leaching reaction is controlled by a chemical
process. The leaching rate of hematite was seen to be first order with respect to hydrogen ion activity,
a(H+), in hydrochloric acid or perchloric acid solutions, with or without the addition of common salts,
while the rate was of a half order in sulfuric acid solutions with or without the addition of sodium
sulfate. A theoretical analysis showed that the anions next to the surface in the double layer were
chloride ion and perchlorate ion in hydrochloric acid and perchloric acid solutions, respecuvely, and
sulfate ion in sulfuric acid solutions, with or without the addition of sodium sulfate. The fact that the
leaching rates of hematite were quite different in various acids having identical a (H +) values indicates
the importance of anion adsorption. The dependency of the leaching rate upon a (H § appeared to be
controlled by adsorbed anions next to the surface in the double layer.
o5
2
III. E X P E R I M E N T A L RESULTS O
ffl 1.0
A. Dissolution Rate Curves i:5 4
The effects of acid concentration on the quantities of iron
leached by hydrochloric and sulfuric acids at various time 3
intervals are shown in Figures 1 and 2, respectively. The 0.5
general curvature of the plots of iron leached against time,
shown in these figures, varies markedly for different acids.
In hydrochloric acid solutions, particulate hematite dis-
solved at a constant rate except in the initial stage of dis- 0.1
solution. Similar experiments with sulfuric acid solutions
101 [ I I I
o 60 120 180 240
t Temp : 328 K Time / rain
9 to : 600 rpm C(HC[) Fig. 2--Typical example of hemaUte leaching curves in sulfuric acid
/ mol.d m-: soluUons at 328 K.
. _ ~ ~ / 1.5
B. Kinetic Limitations
The effect of temperature on the leaching rate of hematite
in both hydrochloric acid and sulfuric acid solutions was
0, o_
examined. Figure 3 is an Arrhenius plot showing a greater
0 ,
0 60 120 180 240 temperature dependence of reaction rate for leaching in hy-
Time/rain drochloric acid than in sulfuric acid. It also shows that at
Fig. 1 --Typical example of hematite leaching curves m hydrochloric acLd higher temperatures the rate is greater in 1 mol" dm -3
solutions at 328 K H2SO4 than in 1 mol 9 dm -3 HCI. In a 1 mol 9 -3 HCI
'E 10.0 E 2
~h 1 mol. d r'n-3H2SO~
'C~
77.7 kJ.mol ' O
O
E
O
rY
t"t"
O1
o 10.5 ~ : 600rprn ~'x~ -
0 : 1 rnob dm~H2SO4 ~ ' ~%x, 10 200
i 400 600
[] : 1 mobdm3HCI xOxx to / r p m
Fig. 4 - - E f f e c t of agitation speed on leaching of hematite.
I I J I I
3.00 3.05 3,10 3.15 3.20 3.25
I"-1 / 10-3K-1 ! 1
/ |
Fig. 3--Arrhemus plot for hematite leaching m hydrochloric acid and 2.12 Temp 328 K O//O
sulfuric acid solutions.
O
u ~: 0.6
"6
~, 2.0
O C~
E oOZ,,
o O
'O 9 : HCI04 § NoCIO 4
0.2 ~ I) : HCIO4 § NQC[
n- 1.0 13~'~ (]l: HCIOj,~Na2S04
\ ~ z~ : H2S04. Na2S04
0 ,n : H2SO4. NaCI
I I I I
0 1 2 3 4
Salt Concentration / tool.din -3
0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 Fig. 8 - - A c t i v i t i e s o f hydrogen ions in ] tool 9 dm 3 acid solutions con-
C(H2SO 4) I t o o l . d i n -3 taining c o m m o n salts
Fig. 6-- Effectof sulfuricacid concentrationon rate of leachingof hema-
tite in sulfuric acid solutionsat 328 K.
acids containing their common sodium salts are depicted
in Figure 8.
acid, sulfuric acid, and perchloric acid were determined at
The activities of hydrogen ions in hydrochloric acid, sul-
298 K as a function of acid concentration.
furic acid, and perchloric acid solutions sharply increase
The measured values of hydrogen ion activity are shown
with an increase in molarities of these acids. The activities
in Figures 7 and 8. In Figure 7 the activities of hydrogen
of hydrogen ions in l tool 9 dm -3 of hydrochloric acid and
ions in various acids are plotted against acid concentrations.
perchloric acid solutions containing common salts and
The activities of hydrogen ions in 1 mol- dm -3 of three
1 mol" dm -3 of sulfuric acid solution containing sodium
chloride also increase with an increase in molarities of salts
I [ I I
added. The activity of hydrogen ions in 1 tool 9 dm -3 of
sulfuric acid and perchloric acid solutions containing so-
Temp 298 K dium sulfate, however, decreases with an increase in mo-
larity of the salt.
The leaching rates of hematite in hydrochloric acid and
sulfuric acid solutions at 328 K as shown in Figures 5 and
6 are replotted against corresponding values of hydrogen ion
activity at 298 K in Figures 9 and 10. The clear relationship
between hydrogen ion activity and the leaching rate of he-
matite in perchloric acid solutions is also demonstrated in
Figure 9. The first order dependence of the rate of leaching
"l- of hematite in hydrochloric acid and perchloric acid solu-
v
O tions on hydrogen ion activity was deduced from this study,
O~ while the half order dependence of leaching rate on hydro-
O
gen ion activity was observed for the leaching of hematite in
sulfuric acid solutions.
Compared to the leaching rate of hematite in sulfuric acid
and hydrochloric acid solutions, the rate of hematite leach-
O 9 HCI ing m perchloric acid is low as can be expected from the
results shown in Figures 9 and 10. In other words, per-
9 " HClO~, chloric acid leaches hematite very slowly. If the dissolution
reaction of hematite in an acid solution is controlled simply
H2SO4
by the action of hydrogen ions, the same leaching rate
-1 should be obtained if the leaching rates in different acid
solutions having the same level of a(H +) are compared.
I I I
However, the leaching rates of hematite differ greatly ac-
0 1 2 3
cording to the acids used. The dependence of leaching rate
Acid Concentration tool.din -3 on a(H § in sulfuric acid solution is different from that
Fig. ? - - A c t x v i u e s of h y d r o g e n ions m aqueous acid soluuons in hydrochloric acid and perchloric acid. Furthermore,
10-9 9 : NaCI
O : HCI
HCI. //0 OAS~
: HcIo
9 HC~- :
IE 9 H;SOi 9 N c l ~
'E
E u 10-i0
0
o. i0_i0
~'~: E
I11
0 c'r"
E 2
2-
10-'~2 IIII I I I I IIIi I 1 I I l 11111 I the hydrogen ion activity of the sulfuric acid solution. The
i0 -I 100 101 effect of the addition of sodium chloride to 1 mol 9 dm -3
a(H ~ ) H2504 solutions was also examined. The concentrations of
Fig. 9 - - Effect o f h y d r o g e n ion activity on rate o f l e a c h i n g o f h e m a m e in sodium chloride in the solutions were adjusted to be 0.5,
h y d r o c h l o r i c or p e r c h l o r i c acid s o l u t i o n s at 3 2 8 K. 1.0, and 2.0 mol 9 dm -3. Hydrogen ion activity of the sul-
furic acid solution was increased by the addition of sodium
we must note that strong solutions of hydrochloric acid chloride, and this resulted in an increase in leaching rate. It
leach hematite more rapidly than equivalent solutions of should be noted that the characteristic leaching behavior of
sulfuric acid; at low concentrations sulfuric acid is the more hematite in these solutions deviates from that in sulfuric acid
active reagent. solutions with the addition of sodium chloride; the leaching
rate of hematite tended to approach that of the hydrochloric
D. Effect of the Addition of Soluble Salts acid solutions. In order to obtain a fuller understanding of
the role of anions in hematite leaching, the effects of the
Hematite leaching was found to be enhanced by the ad- addition of sodium chloride and sodium sulfate on the rate
dition of sodium chloride to aqueous hydrochloric acid of leaching of hematite in 1 tool 9 dm -~ HC104 were inves-
solutions or sodium perchlorate to aqueous perchloric acid tigated. Figure 11 shows these experimental results. The
solutions. The activities of hydrogen ions of hydrochloric three solid lines in this figure indicate log R - a(H +) re-
acid and perchloric acid solutions increased with the addi- lationships of hematite leaching in hydrochloric, perchloric,
tion of the common salts of each acid. Leaching experiments and sulfuric acid solutions. The circles on each line indicate
were made in 1 tool. dm -3 HC1 solutions containing so- the leaching rate in each acid solution whose concentration
dium chloride at concentrations of 0.1, 0.5, and 1.0 tool 9 was 1 tool" dm -3. The addition of sodium chloride to
dm -3. This relationship between the rate of leaching and 1 mol 9 -3 HCIO4 solution resulted in a sharp increase in
a(H § in the presence of sodium chloride is graphically the rate of leaching despite the small increase in hydrogen
presented in Figure 9. It was found that the accelerated ion activity as shown in Figure 11. For example, the leach-
effect of leaching due to the addition of sodium chloride ing rate of hematite in perchloric acid containing 1 mol"
could be attributed to an increase in a ( H +) as is obvious dm 3 NaC1 increased by a factor of 15 compared to that of
in this figure. Similar results were obtained for the leaching the same solution without sodium chloride. By adding so-
of hematite in 1 tool 9 dm -3 HC104 with the addition of dium chloride to the perchloric acid solution, the leaching
sodium perchlorate. rate of hematite tended to approach that of the hydrochloric
The effect of the addition of sodium sulfate to sulfuric acid solution. Again, the leaching rate of hematite in per-
acid solutions was also examined. Leaching experiments chloric acid solution containing sodium sulfate approached
were made in 1 tool 9 dm -~ HzSO4 solutions whose sodium that of sulfuric acid despite the decreased hydrogen ion
sulfate concentrations were 0.1, 0.5, and 1.0 tool 9 dm 3. activity of the solution.
As is obvious in Figure 8, the addition of sodium sulfate
to 1 tool 9 dm -3 H2SO4 resulted in a lowering at hydrogen IV. DISCUSSION
ion activity. Experimental results are plotted on a log R -
a ( H +) plot, shown in Figure 10. As can be seen in this It is important to elucidate the role of anions in the
figure, the function of sodium sulfate is simply to decrease leaching of hematite in order to obtain a fuller understanding
{ 3.1
leachant. On the other hand, the concentration of Fe(III)
after the leaching experiments was usually less than 1 x
10-~ tool 9 dm -3. The formation constants of Fe(III) chloro-
2.0 and Fe(IIl) sulfato-complexes at the ionic strength of zero
and 1.2 are reported, respectively, as shown in Table II. 2~
E By using these values, the concentrations of Fe(III) sulfato-
~.10-1 and Fe(III) chloro-complexes in the solutions after leaching
were calculated as listed in Table III. In this table, the
figures on the upper line indicate the results obtained using
complex formation constants at zero ionic strength, and the
figures on the lower line indicate the results at the ionic
Temp : 328 K 1
strength of 1.2. As can be seen in this table, Fe(SO4)~- is
to : 600 r p m a principal complex ion in 1 tool. dm -3 H 2 8 0 4 solution
10 -II tIll [ I I I Illll I I I I IIIII I and l tool 9 dm -3 H2SO4 solution containing 1 mol 9 dm -3
10-1 100 101 Na2SQ. The concentrations of Fe(SO4);- in both solutions,
a(H') however, are far less than those of bisulfate and sulfate ions.
Fig. l 1 - - E f f e c t of the addition of soluble salts on rate of leaching of No significant amount of other complex anions exists in
hemame in 1 tool 9 dm 3 HCIO4 solutions at 328 K. Numerals shown those solutions. In 1 mol" dm -3 HC1 solutions with or
beside e, u and 9 indicate concentrations of NaCIO4, NaC1, and Na.,SO~ without the addition of sodium chloride, although FeC1] is
added in tool - dm the most predominant complex at an ionic strength of 1.2,
FeC1; is the most predominant among complex ion species,
showing no indication of the formation of complex anions.
of the overall leaching mechanism. This study showed that
Therefore, it seems reasonable to assume that the important
the leaching rates of hematite differed greatly with different
anions are bisulfate and sulfate ions in sulfate systems,
acids as leachants although their hydrogen ion activities were
chloride ions in chloride systems, and perchlorate ions in
adjusted to the same value. Also, the addition of sodium
perchlorate systems.
chloride or sodium sulfate to a perchloric acid solution re-
The concentration of ions at any point in the double layer
suited in a sharp increase in the leaching rates as shown in
can be calculated according to Boltzmann's distribution re-
Figure 11. From these observations, it is hypothesized that
adsorption of anions onto the mineral surface may directly lation, Eq. [3]
determine leaching rate. It has been impossible to apply a n = n ~ exp(-zeto,/kT) [3]
rigorous equilibrium concept to the mineral-solution inter-
face where the dissolution is actually occurring. However, where n is the concentration of ions in the double layer at
theoretical considerations of an equilibrium concept would any given point, n ~ is the concentration of ions of the same
provide useful information on the driving force of the reac- species in the bulk solution, and tO, is the potential at the
tion which appears at the interface. point under consideration in the double layer.
The potential on the surface of hematite is determined by A general way to estimate the magnitude of tO, at the
both the hydrogen and hydroxyl ions. B2r definition, the plane where the adsorbed anions lie has not been estab-
magnitude of the surface potential tOois controlled by the pH lished: however, the values of tO, must lie between the sur-
of the bulk solution. The total double layer potential tOo in face potential tOo and the zeta potential, ~', the potential
the mineral surface is generally given by ]7 located at the slipping plane. The distance between the inner
Helmholtz plane and the hematite surface in hydrochloric sulfate ions act as counter ions when the solution contains
acid solutions must be different from that in sulfuric acid sulfuric acid or sodium sulfate.
solutions, since the ionic radii of dehydrated anions are quite As shown in Figure 11, the rate of hematite leaching in
different from each other. In regard to defining 0,, Gaudin dilute sulfuric acid solutions was greater than that in hydro-
and Fuerstenau 23 took the mean value of 00 and ~r as 0~ in chloric acid solution of equivalent concentration. If we
their study of quartz flotation with a cationic collector. In the consider 0.0l m o l . dm 3 acid solutions, the total double
current study, we have assumed that 0, is the average of tO0 layer potential should be about +278 mV, and thus 0, =
and ~', according to Gaudin and Fuerstenau, although the 139 mV. The concentration of sulfate ions in the double
actual 00 values for chloride and perchlorate ions or bi- layer next to the hematite surface is about two hundred times
sulfate and sulfate ions might be different. The zeta potential larger than that of chloride ions according to Eq. [4]. This
of hematite in strong acid solutions is considered to be fact may account for the faster leaching of hematite in sul-
nearly zero; thus the value of 0~ is assumed to be about furic acid than hydrochloric acid in dilute solutions.
00/2. Thus we obtained ~p, = 198 mV at pH 0.
Sulfuric acid is diprotic and ionized to bisulfate and sul-
fate ions. While the first ionization is almost complete, the V. CONCLUSIONS
second ionization is incomplete. Therefore we should de- The leaching of monosized particulate hematite in aque-
termine whether the bisulfate or sulfate ion is the actual ous hydrochloric acid, perchloric acid, and sulfuric acid
absorbed species on the hematite surface. Applying Eq. [3] solutions was studied kinetically. The experimental rate data
to both the concentrations of monovalent and divalent an- show that the over-all leaching reaction is controlled by a
ions in strong acid solutions, the following expression can chemical reaction process. The leaching rate of hematite is
be obtained: first order with respect to a ( H - ) in hydrochloric acid or
perchloric acid solutions with or without their common salts
log(nL/n2) = log (n~/n~) - (zl - z2) "2'
, ,
added, while it is of a half order in sulfuric acid solutions,
2.303RT two/ ~ [4]
with or without the addition of sodium sulfate,
where nl/n2 is the ratio of concentration of monovalent The potential at the hematite-solution interface was deter-
anion to that of divalent anion next to the surface at 298 K, mined by hydrogen ions in acid solutions. A theoretical
and nT/n~ is the value of n~/n2 in the bulk solution. The analysis shows that the anions next to the surface in the
second ionization constant, K2, of concentrated sulfuric acid double layer are chloride ions and perchlorate ions in hydro-
at 298 K is reported to be 14 chloric acid and perchloric acid, respectively, while they are
sulfate ions in sulfuric acid solutions, with or without the
tog/(2 = log 0.0102 + 2 . 0 3 6 V ~ / ( 1 + 0.4X/I) [5]
addition of sodium sulfate. The fact that the leaching rates
where I is the ionic strength. By using this ionization con- of hematite were quite different in various acids having the
stant, we calculate the concentration of sulfate and bisulfate same a (H") indicates the importance of anion adsorption. It
ions in the bulk solution at pH 0 to be 0.22 mol 9 dm 3 and should be noted that the dependency of the leaching rate
0.58 tool. dm -3, respectively. The substitution of these upon a(H +) appears to be controlled by adsorbed anions
values into Eq. [4] yields nl = 0.001n2. This calculation next to the surface in the double layer.
indicates that the concentration of sulfate ion next to the
hematite surface is far greater than that of bisulfate ion.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Although Warren and Devuyst proposed the leaching
mechanism of oxides in sulfuric acid by introducing the The authors wish to express their thanks to Dr. Shinnosuke
adsorption of both bisulfate and sulfate ions, the calcula- Usui, Professor of the Research Institute of Mineral Dressing
tion results shown above do not support their mechanism. and Metallurgy, Tohoku University, for his helpful sugges-
Based on these findings, we may assume that chloride and tions. The authors also acknowledge receipt of financial
perchlorate ions are adsorbed as counter ions next to the support from the Ministry of Education of Japan in the form
surface of hematite in hydrochloric acid and perchloric acid of a Scientific Research Grant (Grant No. 56470051),
solutions, respectively, while sulfate ions instead of bi- which enabled this work to be performed.