Dissertation Final
Dissertation Final
OBJECTIVES
To study about the historical overview of both temple and church architecture.
Explore the ideologies ,planning and design components of hindu temple architecture
and church architecture in Kerala.
Analyze the syncretism between them in specific.
Evaluate the influence of hindu temple architecture on Kerala churches with an
example.
LIMITATIONS
Analysis is limited to study of one church only.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
What are the similarities and differences in the elements and spatial
organization between Hindu temples and Kerala churches?
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
DEVELOPING AIM AND
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
CONCLUSION
2. LITERATURE STUDY
2.1 HINDU TEMPLES
The evolution of temple worship in Kerala began with early tribal
societies worshipping natural elements like the Sun, Rain, fire,
animals, and plants for protection and sustenance. Over time, worship
evolved to include spirits, Indian mythology, and legendary figures
who attained divinity.
The construction of temples in Kerala, often attributed to Lord
Parasurama, dates back potentially 5000 years, although recorded
temple history starts from around the 8th century CE. Archaeological
surveys classify temple construction into three phases: Early (800-
1000 CE), Medieval (1001-1300 CE), and Late (1301-1800 CE).
Kerala temples were not only places of worship but also cultural
centers fostering arts like koothu, koodiattom, mohiniyattam,
Kathakali, and ritual arts such as Kalamezhuthu and theyyam. These
temples played a crucial role in the cultural and artistic development
of the region
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
CLASSIFICATION OF TEMPLES
Rock-cut temples, among the earliest forms of temples, were inspired by Buddhist cave temples.
Predominantly found in southeastern Kerala, these temples reflect the continuation of similar
architecture from Tamil Nadu under the Pandyas. Constructed before the 8th century, an example is
the Thrikkoor Shiva Temple built in the 8th century. NALAMBALAM
MANDAPA
NAMASKARA
MANDAPAM
BASIC LAYOUT
During the 8th to 10th centuries, temples developed with a single shrine known as the Srikovil.
Typically, a porch (mandapa) is attached to the shrine, and a detached namaskara mandapa is built
in front of it. The Srikovil is enclosed by a circumambulatory area called the nalambalam. Key
elements of these temples include the namaskara mandapa and balikkal.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
PHASES OF EVOLUTION
3-STORIED TEMPLES
In the middle phase of temple architecture, temples featured four functional doors on each cardinal
direction, with windows for subdued lighting. Sometimes, pseudo doors were used instead of
functional ones. This phase also saw the development of storied temples, such as the Peruvanam
Siva Temple, which is a unique example with three stories—two lower stories of square plan and a
third story of octagonal form.
TEMPLE COMPLEX
In the final phase (1300-1800 A.D.), temple architecture became more complex. Key additions
included the Vilakkumadam, a structure with rows of oil lamps beyond the Nalambalam, and the
balikkal enclosed within a pillared structure. A deepastambham (lamp post) was also added in front
of the balikkal mandapam.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
KERALA CHURCHES
Church is a religious building used for public Christian worship. It may even be
a particular Christian organization, typically one with its own clergy, buildings,
and distinctive doctrines. But this is not the biblical understanding which is
more a body of believers than anything else. The word 'church" comes from
the Greek word ekklesia which means 'an assembly of the 'called-out ones.
For all Christian believers, the church is the body of Christ, of which He is the
head. The body of Christ' is composite concept, They are:
1. the universal church consisting of all those who have a personal relationship
with Jesus Christ as they believe that they obtained Salvation through faith in
Him
The members of the universal church should seek fellowship with local
believers for learning and practicing their faith through a local church.
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
ORIGIN OF CHURCHES
It is believed that Christianity was introduced to Kerala by St.Thomas,the
Apostle, who visited Kerala in 52 AD to spread the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
There is a small section of the present day Christians in Kerala who
consider themselves as the pure descendants of those came with
St.Thomas. There were also conversions to Christianity during
subsequent periods and through the efforts of missionaries. The advent
of the Portuguese in the 16th century gave a boost to the growth of
Christians in Kerala under Roman Catholic missionaries, the most
significant one being St. Francis Xavier. As several European missionaries
also came to Kerala the non-Catholic Christian population also grew both
in number and diversity.
READING MATRIX
Year
of
Book/ Major theme of Methodolo Your understanding
Sl..No Title of reading and author publi
Paper the paper gy used from reading
catio
n
It explores the
historical period when
the Dutch East India
Company established
The Dutch Power in Kerala, 1729- its dominance in the The book provides a
1758 by M. O. Koshy,Mittal region of Kerala in Archival comprehensive look at the
1. Publications,
Book 1989
India. The book details research Dutch influence in Kerala during
the political, economic, this particular period in history.
and cultural impact of
the Dutch presence in
Kerala during the years
1729-1758.
It explores the
architectural elements
of Syrian Christian The paper helps us understand
Pre-colonial elements and post- churches in Kerala. The the rich architectural heritage of
Archival study
colonial elements in the Syrian study focuses on the Syrian Christian churches in
2 Christian churches of Kerala" by
Paper 2018
pre-colonial and post-
Case study,
Kerala and the historical factors
Observation
Rakhi Mariam Johnson colonial influences on that have contributed to their
the design and unique design.
construction of these
churches,
READING MATRIX
Year
Book of
Major theme of Methodology Your understanding
Sl..No Title of reading and author /Pap publi
the paper used from reading
er catio
n
Explores the
architectural facades
of churches in Kerala
during the Renaissance The paper provides
period. It delves into valuable insights into the
Renaissance Church Facades of the design and Observation, Live cross-cultural influences on
3 Kerala: Seeds of Cross Cultural Journal 2019 construction of these case studies, the Renaissance church
Alliances by Rakhi Mariam Johnson church facades, Archival research facades in Kerala and the
highlighting the cross- artistic collaborations that
cultural alliances and occurred during this period.
influences that shaped
their ornate and
intricate features.
1. Ideologies / Concept
2. Planning Layout
3. Spatial Arrangement
4. Spatial Quality and Light
5. Roofing Style and Massing
6. Scale and Proportion
7. Materials used
8. Decorative elements
9. Social and Cultural influences
3. PARAMETERS
From the above studies and research papers, these parameters were listed to
explore and analyze the architectural components, similarites , dissimilarities and the
the interaction between Hindu temple architecture and church architecture in Kerala.
1. Ideologies / Concept
2. Planning Layout
GOPURAM CHURCH TOWERS
3. Spatial Arrangement DHWAJA STHAMBAM DEEPASTHAMBAM
4. Spatial Quality and Light
BALIKALU KALKURISSU
IDEOLOGY/ CONCEPT
In Viswakarmaneeyam, a famous treatise on architecture, the Early church buildings were just a rectangular hall. Later it
temple structure is built on the concept of Sthoola Sarira included the Sanctuary (madubaha) and the nave
(gross body) (palliyakom).
TEMPLE AS THE BODY OF THE DIETY The general concept on the design of churches is based on
According to this concept, the Garbhagraha corresponds to the three crucial periods in the life of Jesus Christ
the head of the deity. The Arthamandala (the space where BAPTISMAL PULPIT &
FRONT ALTAR
Bali Pitas of dieties are located. (I) THE BAPTISM,
His face- The Namaskar Mandapa (where Vedic chanting (II) THE PUBLIC LIFE
is done),
His throat or neck - The inner Pradakshina Vazhi and (III) THE CRUCIFIXION.
Nalambalam together [ Yagasala (where vedic sacrifice is
done)], Liturgically these are expressed in:
His Hands - Thidappalli (Temple kitchen) etc - otherwise the Baptismal Font TABERNACLE
IDEOLOGY/CONCEPT
In short, each space within the outer wall of the temple The planning of the early churches evolved on the
represents the body part (Sthoola Sarira) of the concept of THE CROSS
principal deity. .
The cross is the central symbol of Christianity,
TEMPLE AS THE BODY OF THE DIETY
representing the crucifixion of Jesus Christ and His
sacrifice for humanity's salvation. It is a powerful
reminder of Christ's love and redemption.,
It also provided practical benefits, such as additional
space for altars, chapels, and processional routes
Nave -(the long arm of the cross),
Transepts- (the shorter arms),
SECTIONAL VIEW
Apse -(the head of the cross).
ELEVATION VIEW
TRANSEPTS
NAVE
APSE
PLANAR VIEW
IDEOLOGY/CONCEPT
Temples and churches both serve as places of worship, community gathering, and
spiritual reflection. Temples, often associated with Hinduism, Buddhism, and other
Eastern religions, typically feature intricate architecture, multiple deities, and rituals
like offerings and festivals.
Churches, central to Christianity, often have a simpler architectural style, with a focus on the cross,
altar, and sacraments like communion and baptism. Both spaces emphasize devotion and moral
teachings but differ in religious practices, iconography, and architectural styles. Temples often have
a more diverse set of rituals and deities, while churches focus on the worship of one God and
community prayer.
Churches and temples, though rooted in different religious traditions, share common ideological
elements.
Both are sacred spaces devoted for the only purpose of worshiping God.
A common gathering space for the believers to gather together and worship God.
HINDU TEMPLE ARCHITECTURE KERALA CHURCH ARCHITECTURE
GENERAL LAYOUT
Hindu temples are commonly oriented to the east,
facing the rising sun. This direction is associated with
new beginnings, purity, and the deity Surya (the Sun
God).
1 1. Garbagraha,
2. Ardhamandapa,
4 2
3. Mahamandapa,
The churches are oriented to face east, with is a deeply
4. Inner Prakara,
rooted tradition in Christian architecture, symbolizing
3 5. Gayathri mandapa,
the resurrection, Christ’s return and light.
6. Garudalvar Shrine,
5 6a. Mukhamandapa,
6 7. Dwajasthampa,
9 7 8. Balipitha,
8
9. Outer Prakara,
10
10. Main Entrance with Gopura,
11 11. Temple Tank,
PLANNING LAYOUT
Hindu temples and Kerala churches share several architectural features in their planning layouts.
Both often follow a symmetrical and geometric design, emphasizing balance and harmony.
They typically include a central sanctum (garbhagriha in temples, altar in churches) as the focal point.
Courtyards or open spaces are common, providing areas for gatherings and rituals.
Walking is highlighted in both the styles. The public has to walk around the temple complexes. Highlighting
tthe connection between God & public elements while in churches, beleivers walk inde through the linear
churches, connection with only God
SPATIAL ARRANGEMENT
SPATIAL ARRANGEMENT
(iii) Altar and Pulpit
2. Sopanam
The Altar is the sacred space in a church where the priest
Sopanam are the steps leading to the Garbha-Griha
performs the Mass, while the Pulpit, a raised stand beside
(sanctum sanctorum) of a temple. Positioned in front of
the Altar, is where the priest preaches to the
the Garbha-Griha, they are typically designed in odd
congregation.
numbers and come in two types:
Direct Flight of Steps: These areas typically occupy the
Lateral Entries: eastern part of the madubaha, and
3. Namaskara Mandapa sacred objects for rituals are kept in a
This is an open space with stone columns supported be decorated cupboard behind the Altar.
wooden roofs. It is ally smaller than the Sanctus
(iv) Alcove for Idols (Roopakoodu)
Santorum. This although, is not an essential face of the
Roopakodu in a small area is formed by part of the wall
temple complex bur it seen in most of the temples.
being hollowed, for keeping statues and icons of sons. It
b)Second Enclosure (Chuttambalam/Nalambalam)
could even be in a wooden gopuram with or without glass
Valiambalam: Main hall for rituals.
sides.
Thidappali: Area for preparing and storing offerings,
located northeast as per Vastu Shastra.
Nilayara: Storage rooms.
Sub-shrines: Smaller shrines for subsidiary deities.
Main Entrances: Important entry points to Nalambalam
HINDU TEMPLE ARCHITECTURE KERALA CHURCH ARCHITECTURE
SPATIAL ARRANGEMENT
c) Third Enclosure (Vilakkumadam) (vii) Baptismal Font
The third enclosure, called Vilakkumadam, features The baptismall fonts are basins used for carrying out
fixed lamps made of iron or brass, lit during evenings the sacrament of Baptism
and special occasions, and is typically found in major
temples.
Flag Post: Used during festivals. inform the time of worship, to call together people
KALASAM
PYRAMMID SHAPED ROOF In Kerala churches, the traditional roofing style was
EAVES influenced , gabled roofing in terracotta tiles and
wood .
ROOFING & MASSING
Gabled roofing in churches influenced by temple architecture in Terracotta tiles and woodwork, sloping
roof is characterized by the climatic conditions , heavy monsoons in Kerala.
]
In churches, wall surface
than the wall surface.
is greater than roofing
] structure.
Domed coniical
roofing,a Church roofs not only protect the interior but
buddhist also symbolize the heavens, creating an
influencee. uplifting, spiritual atmosphere for worshippers.
HINDU TEMPLE ARCHITECTURE KERALA CHURCH ARCHITECTURE
OPENINGS
Temple doors are predominantly made of high quality Arched doors and windows, with intricate wooden
wood and adorned with brass/bronze carvings on the surface of doors depicting stories of
embellishments.Doors often have intricate carvings that The Bible. Stained glass windows , reflect light inside
depict scenes from Hindu mythology and some have and also appeals to the aesthetic beauty of the inner
Dwarapalakas (guardians) on either side . church.
DHWAJA STHAMBHA
Dhwaja Sthambha is erected in front of the Sree Kovil. GABLED ROOFING
It is believed that worshipping the dwaja is equal to It is an integral part of Kerala temple architecture, reflecting
worshipping of the main deity of the temple. Also it is a the region's adaptation to its climate, adherence to cultural
custom to hoist a flag in the Dwaja-stamba when the and spiritual principles, and the influence of historical
temple festivals have started. interactions. This architectural element not only serves
practical purposes but also enhances the beauty and
uniqueness of Kerala's temples
INFLUENCE OF KERALA TEMPLE ARCHITECTURE ON KERALA
CHURCH ARCHITECTURE:
HISTORY
ELEMENTS
BALIKALU IN TEMPLES
ELEMENTS
ELEMENTS
Similar elements have been used in the temple and church. It Simialr concept is taken for
is used to hoist flags during festivals and significant religious Deepasthambham in churches.
events, symbolizing the temple's active status and inviting
devotees. The flagstaff represents a connection between the
temple and the heavens, and its presence signifies the
temple's sanctity and divine presence.
KERALA TEMPLE PALIYEKARA CHURCH
ROOFING
Traditional Kerala
architectural elements
combined with European
influences. The roof
features a sloping,
gabled structure,
typically covered with WOOD RAFTERS USED
red clay tiles IN THE ROOF CEILING
KERALA TEMPLE PALIYEKARA CHURCH
SPATIAL ARRANGEMENT
Altar Aisles
Dim litted interiors inspired from traditional Kerala
architectural styles can seen in the temples of The interiors of the church has
SOCIO-CULTURAL INFLUENCES
come together to
KOOTHAMBALAM
religious places and eat
together, cultural
activities, festivals etc
were done.
KERALA TEMPLE PALIYEKARA CHURCH
MATERIALS
Stone, wood , laterite and terracotta tiles were the Facade made of
original materials used in Kerala traditional temple laterite stone walls.
architecture from the oldern days.It is also suitable with decorative
for the climatic conditions of Kerala. motifs, that reflect
on the influence of
traditional Kerala
craftsmanship.
DECORATIVE ELEMENTS
SPATIAL ARRANGEMENT
ALTAR INSIDE ATTIC OF THE CHURCH PALIYAKAM (NAVE ) AISLES IN THE CORRIDOR
Despite the differences in religious symbolism and function, both the temple and the church
share a commitment to creating spaces that evoke spirituality, communal gathering, and
aesthetic beauty. The comparative analysis underscores the dynamic interplay between
different architectural traditions and highlights the unique synthesis that characterizes Kerala's
built heritage. This study thus contributes to a deeper understanding of how religious
architecture in Kerala is a reflection of cultural confluence, adaptability, and shared heritage.
However, the study has also highlighted the distinct differences that set these architectural
styles apart. The symbolic and functional elements unique to each faith are clearly present,
reflecting the distinct religious practices and beliefs of Hinduism and Christianity. The
adaptation of Hindu architectural principles to meet the liturgical requirements of Christianity
has resulted in a harmonious blend of forms that respect the traditions of both religions.
The findings of this research underscore the importance of cultural exchange and religious
coexistence in the evolution of architectural styles. The Paliyekara St. George Orthodox
Church, with its rich tapestry of architectural influences, serves as a beacon of Kerala's diverse
cultural heritage and its history of mutual respect between different religious communities.
CONCLUSION
The study found that Paliyekkara Church exhibits several architectural features inspired by
Hindu temple design, such as sloping roofs, intricate wood carvings, and the use of
courtyards. These elements, traditionally seen in the Sri Vallabha Temple, have been
adapted to suit the liturgical needs of the church while retaining their cultural
significance. The influence of the local culture is evident in the church’s incorporation of
natural materials, decorative motifs, and spatial organization, fostering a sense of
continuity and harmony within the community.
Similarity of spaces and elements are well evident in Kerala churches, which is a strong
influence from Kerala Architecture and temple architectural styles
Similarity of spaces and elements are well evident in Kerala churches, which is a strong
influence from Kerala Architecture and temple architectural styles