Development and Performance
Development and Performance
net/publication/362698227
CITATIONS READS
0 622
5 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Saheed Abiola Olaoye on 15 December 2022.
Authors’ contributions
  This work was carried out in collaboration among all authors. All authors read and approved the final
                                                                                          manuscript.
                                                                                                      Article Information
                                                                                          DOI: 10.9734/JERR/2022/v23i12762
                                                                                                    Received 06/09/2022
                                                                                                   Accepted 12/11/2022
  Original Research Article
                                                                                                   Published 19/11/2022
ABSTRACT
 An extruding machine for the production of floating fish feed was designed and fabricated.
 Performance evaluation of the fabricated floating fish feed extruding machine was done. The
 design of the hopper; shaft, barrel, screw and die of the machine were done using standard
 equations. Effect of extrusion parameters which are moisture content (20% 25%, 30%, 35%, and
 40%) die size (2 mm, 4 mm, 6 mm, 8 mm and 10 mm) and screw speed (150 rpm; 200 rpm, 250
 rpm, 300 rpm and 350 rpm) on expansion ratio, floatability, specific mechanical energy and
 efficiency were evaluated. The result shows that moisture content has significant effect on all the
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022
                               Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
 variables, as highest expansion ratio of 32% was obtained at 30% moisture content and 6 mm die
 size. Highest feed floatability was 97% at 30% moisture content and 6 mm die size. The highest
 specific mechanical energy of the machine was 30 kJ/kg at 40% moisture content and 4 mm die
 size. Die size variation also shows high impact on the machine performance, showing highest
 efficiency of 83% at 10 mm die size and 250 rpm while the floatation rate was 98% at 6mm die
 size. Screw speed has significant effect on efficiency having the highest as 85% at 150 rpm and
 floatability of 93% at 150 rpm while the specific mechanical energy of 29 kJ/kg was the highest at
 350 rpm. Operation condition was at its best at 30% moisture content; 6 mm die size and 150 rpm
 of screw speed. The feed moisture content, machine die size and screw speed have significant
 effect on the performance of the machine. Careful selection and combination of these factors will
 give optimum performance of the machine during extrusion of resin.
Keywords: Extrusion; floating fish feed; expansion; screw speed; die size.
Demand for aquaculture produce for human                   2.1 Material Selection and Production
consumption has been on the rise in the past                   Planning
decades which as necessities, the need to
improvise quick method of feeding for fishes, in           In the Table 1 are the summary of the design
which pelleting the feed will be of good                   prerequisites and materials used in the
advantage, most fish feed in America are in                fabrication of the machine component. All
pellet to improve the quality of aquaculture Anon          materials were sourced locally after which
[6]. On the other hand, pelleted feeds produce             examination was conducted on each of the
from pelletizer cannot give the expected quality           component, to locate point and position they will
of feed. Feed produced by pelletizer will sink             occupy. The below information was used to carry
immediately on water; while that of extruder will          out production plane and later assembly plane.
surly float on water as a result of gelatinization         Electrodes; hammer, block, sniper, welding
during processing - for aquaculture to consume it          machine, cutting machine, grinding machine,
conveniently. According to Behnke [7], floating            drilling machine, hack saw, vise and lathe
fish feed from extruder is considered better than          machine, are the machine tools and equipment
sinking feeds because of it physical and                   used in fabrication and construction of this
nutritional benefits. Its physical benefits ranges         machine.
                                                      49
                                 Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
The design of this machine was done by putting into consideration of all mathematical constraints
being the dependent of engineering principles, inclusion of cost analysis and consideration of couple
with accessibility, ease of operation, stress and strain, durability, works and efficiency. The design of
this machine was divided into two sections:
Volume of the hopper = volume of a frustum of a                  Mass of hopper = density of mild steel ×
pyramid + volume of a cub                                        volume of the hopper
(1) (5)
                                                         50
                                 Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
The flow factor f can be determined with the use              2.2.1 Determining mass flow rate of the
of known factors that determine the flow factor,                    symmetrical hopper
angle Θ, wall friction, internal friction and the
semi included angel of the metal.                             The discharge rate of the symmetrical hopper
                                                              was obtained by the use of Jenike, [10] equation.
                                                   (7)
                                                                                                                       (11)
                                                   (8)
                                                              Where:
Coefficient of friction between the surface of the
hopper and the feed materials is expressed in                                                                      o
                                                                  θ is semi included angle of the hopper ( )
terms of angle of phase θ that is                                 m is discharge rate (Kg/ sec)
                                                                   o                           3
                                                   (9)               is the bulk density (kg/m )
                                                                                                    -2
                                                                  g is gravity acceleration (9.807ms )
Δy and Δx are effective angle internal friction rise              B is w (m), m = 0 in symmetric hopper
and run respectively.                                             Area A = width W x Length L
                                                                                                                       (12)
                                                  (10)
    =                                                         The stress acting on the hopper is given in the
                                                              assumption below by Jassen [11]
                                                                                                                       (13)
To get the wall friction angle from the rise and
run chart of [9]
                                                              g is the gravity constant to convert conversion
                                                              factor and w is the maximum width of the hopper.
(14)
                                o,
The semi included angle = 28 H= 2.47 and the
flow factor ff = 1,84 was obtained from [9]
(15)
Where:
                                                                  P is power in watts,
                                                                  F is rotational force acting on the shaft in
The minimum width of the symmetrical slot outlet                  newton (N)
hopper is 0.1161 (W × L)
                                                         51
                                 Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
                                                  (16)
                                                                                                                     (24)
    M is mass of rotating shaft (kg)
    a is angular acceleration of the shaft part               Where        is 4.0 for slow abrasive material,
                                                                                                    o
          -2
    (rad/s )                                                  inclination angle of conveyor ( ) is 0
(19) (25)
(22)
                                                 (23)
                                                              2.2.5 Determining the velocity ratio of the
Where;                                                              chain drive
    Q is capacity of screw conveyor                           The velocity ratio of the chain was determining
    S is the screw pitch                                      with the use of this equation
    n is speed of conveyor-loading efficiency
    p is free bulk density of the material                                                                           (28)
    c is loading factor depending on the inclined
    angle to the horizontal for slow flowing                  Where;
    abrasive material it was recommended that
                                                                 N1 is the speed of rotation of smaller
    S = 0.8D, = 0.125, C = 1our recommended
                                                                 sprocket in rpm
    minimum and maximum speed of conveyor
                                                                 N2 is speed of rotation of lager sprocket in
    is between 50 – 500rpm.
                                                                 rpm
                                                                 T1 is number of teeth in the smaller sprocket
                                                                 T2 is number of teeth on the larger sprocket.
                                                         52
                                Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
2.2.6 Determination of chain length and its                  and being converted to heat energy that
      center distance.                                       transform the extrude – the work done by the
                                                             machine on the extruder which also called
The length of the chain was calculated from the              specific mechanical energy of the machine.
use of this equation;
(29) (33)
                                                 (30)        Where;
                                                                   is the torque (Nm)
    K = 64                                                       SS is screw speed (rpm)
                                                                 Fr is feed rate (kg/h)
Therefore; the length of the chain is
                                                             Calculation of machine torque was done with the
                                                             use of this equation.
(34)
                                                        53
                              Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
process, by reducing the surface area of the              of the composition before, during and after
component. Mixing of the component was done               extrusion.
mechanically for uniform and appropriate mixing
                                                     54
                                                                  Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION                                                                      The floatability of the extrude produced from the
                                                                                               machine was affected by moisture content. It has
3.1 Effect of Moisture Content on                                                              significant effect on the floatability of the feed at
    Expansion       Ratio,    Floatability,                                                    0.05 level of significant, while 97% highest
    Specific Mechanical Energy and                                                             floatability was recorded at 30% moisture content
    Efficiency of the Machine                                                                  and the lowest at 40% moisture content of 66%
                                                                                               value; this is in agreement with Khater et al. [14]
Expansion ratio is the rate at which the extrude                                               in their research on floation. Specific mechanical
expanded in relative to the die size, varying the                                              energy was also significantly affected by
level of the moisture content and die size while                                               moisture content; the lowest SME was obtained
the screw speed is kept constant. Moisture                                                     at 30% and the highest at 40% moisture content
content of the resin played important role in the                                              17 kJ/kg and 30 kJ/kg respectively. This is in
rate at which expansion takes place. The                                                       consonance with what Daood et al. [15]
expansion ratio increased initially as the moisture                                            observed in their research work. The highest
content increases but later decreases with                                                     efficiency of the machine is 87% which was
increase in moisture content. The highest rate of                                              obtained at 30% moisture content and 6 mm die
expansion was 32% which occurred at 30%                                                        size; while the lowest is 70% obtained at 40%
moisture content and 6 mm die size; while the                                                  moisture content. This is in-line with what Ojomo
lowest was 18% at 40% moisture content,                                                        et al. [16] came about in their research on
supported by Alam et al. [13], Olaoye et al. [4].                                              palletization.
                                                                                                                      100
                              35                                                                                                                                       2mm
                                                                                 2mm
   Eexpansion Ratio(%)
Floatability Ratio(%)
                              30                                                 4mm                                                                                   4mm
                                                                                                                       90
                                                                                 6mm                                                                                   6mm
                              25                                                 8mm
                                                                                                                       80                                              8mm
                                                                                 10mm
                              20                                                                                                                                       10mm
15 70
                              10
                                        20        25    30    35          40                                           60
                                                                                                                             20         25        30        35    40
                                             Moisture Content(%)
                                                                                                                                    Moisture Content(%)
                                                                                                                      90
                                   35
 Specific Mechanical Energy
                                                                                                                      85
    Requirement(kJ/kg)
Efficiency(%)
                                   30
                                                                                2mm                                   80                                               2mm
                                                                                4mm                                                                                    4mm
                                   25
                                                                                                                      75
                                                                                6mm                                                                                    6mm
                                   20                                           8mm                                   70                                               8mm
                                                                                10mm                                                                                   10mm
                                                                                                                      65
                                   15
                                                                                                                            20     25        30        35    40
                                             20    25   30   35      40
                                                                                                                                 Moisture Content(%)
                                                  Moisture Content(%)
                                                                                         55
                                                                                          Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
3.2 Effect of Die Size on Expansion Ratio,                                                                            die size while the highest was recorded at 10mm
    Floatability,   Specific   Mechanical                                                                             die size (Fig. 3).
    Energy Required and Efficiency
                                                                                                                      3.3 Effect of Screw Speed on Expansion,
Expansion ratio of the resin was affected by the                                                                          Floatability,  Specific  Mechanical
differences in die sizes as we varied the die sizes                                                                       Energy Requirement and Efficiency
during our research work. The highest expansion
ratio of 31% was recorded at 6mm die size while                                                                       The variation in screw speed shows differences
the lowest expansion ratio of 19% was obtained                                                                        in responses on the variables considered. The
at 2 mm die size; this is in similarity with the                                                                      expansion ratio does not show much difference
result of Abubakar et al. [17]. Likewise; the                                                                         at different level of screw speed. The highest
floatability ratio was at the zenith at 6 mm die                                                                      expansion rate was observed at 150 rpm and
size of 98% while the lowest was at 10 mm die                                                                         30% moisture content while the lowest was
size of 77% value, this is intad with Khater et al.                                                                   recorded at 250 rpm and 40% moisture content
[14]. Specific mechanical energy consumption of                                                                       32% and 20% respectively. Though; the effect of
30 kJ/kg was the highest at 2 mm die size, while                                                                      screw speed on expansion ratio was insignificant
the lowest 17 kJ/kg at 10 mm die size Saheed et                                                                       at 5% level of probability. Oduntan and Koya
al. [18] in their research work reported similar                                                                      [20] had similar result at screw speed less than
result. Efficiency of the machine increase as the                                                                     150 rpm. The highest floatability ratio of 93% was
die size increases from 2mm to 10 mm, this is in                                                                      recorded at 150 rpm while the lowest floatability
corroboration with what Ojo et al., [19] reported                                                                     rate of 79% was observed at 300 rpm, Olaoye et
that the lowest efficiency was obtained at 2mm                                                                        al. [4] also obtain a similar result. The specific
                             35                                                                                                                100
    Expansion Rate(%)
                                                                                                                                               95
                                                                                                                       Floatability Ratio(%)
                             30                                                                      150rpm
                                                                                                     200rpm                                                                  150rpm
                                                                                                                                               90
                             25                                                                      250rpm
                                                                                                                                                                             200rpm
                                                                                                     300rpm                                    85
                             20                                                                                                                                              250rpm
                                                                                                     350rpm
                                                                                                                                               80                            300rpm
                             15                                                                                                                                              350rpm
                                                                                                                                               75
                             10                                                                                                                      2    4    6   8    10
                                                         2       4       6        8       10                                                             Die Size(mm)
                                                                 Die Size (mm)
                                                   35                                                                                          85
               mechanical energy riquired(kJ/kg)
                                                                                                                                               81                            150rpm
                                                   30
                                                                                                                        Efficiency(%)
                                                                                                       150rpm                                                                200rpm
                                                                                                                                               77
                                                   25                                                  200rpm                                                                250rpm
                                                                                                       250rpm                                  73
                                                                                                                                                                             300rpm
                                                   20                                                  300rpm
                                                                                                                                               69                            350rpm
                                                                                                       350rpm
                                                   15                                                                                          65
                                                             2       4        6       8        10                                                    2   4    6    8    10
                                                                                                                                                         Die SIze(mm)
                                                                             Die Size (mm)
                                                                                                                 56
                                                                        Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
                      35                                                                                                                              95
     Expansion Ratio(%)
                                                                                                                              Floatability Ratio(%)
                                                                                                                                                      90
                      30
                                                                                                       20%                                                                                  20%
                                                                                                       25%                                            85                                    25%
                      25
                                                                                                       30%                                                                                  30%
                                                                                                                                                      80
                      20                                                                               35%                                                                                  35%
                                                                                                       40%                                            75                                    40%
                      15                                                                                                                                     150 200 250 300 350
                                     150     200         250           300           350
                                                                                                                                                                 Screw Speed(rpm)
                                                         Screw Speed(rpm)
                                                                                                                              90
   Specific Mechanical Energy
29 20%
                                                                                       Janse
                                27                                                                                                                                                          25%
                                                                                                              Efficiency(%)   85
                                                                                                       20%
                                                                                                                                                                                            30%
             (kJ/kg)
25
                                           Janse Janse
                                                                                                       25%                    80                                                            35%
                                                                                                       30%
                                23
                                21                             Janse
                                                                             Janse                     35%                    75
                                                                                                                                                                                            40%
                                                                                               Janse
                                                                                                       40%
                                19                                                                                            70
                                       150      200       250          300           350                                                                   150   200     250   300    350
                                             Screw Speed(rpm)                                                                                                          Screw Speed(rpm)
mechanical energy 29 kJ/kg was the maximum at                                                                     die size. Specific mechanical energy was at the
350 rpm which may be as a result of increase in                                                                   lowest at 30% moisture content and die sizes 6,
torque required, this is in contrast with what                                                                    8 and 10 mm. The efficiency of the machine was
stated by Folasayo and Zhongjie [21] stated that                                                                  best at 30% moisture content and 6 mm die size.
energy consumption of single screw extruder has                                                                   Die size has significant effect on expansion ratio
the lowest specific mechanical energy of 20                                                                       according the result, 6mm die size is the most
kJ/kg was obtained at 250 rpm. Efficiency was at                                                                  efficient die size on this machine, due to it
the highest point of 88% at 150 rpm while the                                                                     optimization on the variables considered.
lowest was 72% at 350 rpm. This result is similar                                                                 Variation in screw speed gave different response
to what Salawu et al. [22] observed in their own                                                                  on the variable considered, resulted to an
research work. Idowu et al., [3] gave a                                                                           outcome that 150 rpm was the best speed of
consonance result in their experiment stating the                                                                 operation for the machine.
significance of screw speed on the performance
of fabricated decorticating machine.                                                                              COMPETING INTERESTS
                                                                                                                  Authors have                                      declared   that   no competing
4. CONCLUSION                                                                                                     interests exist.
The design, fabrication and performance                                                                           REFERENCES
evaluation of the floating fish feed extruding
machine was done. The result of the                                                                               1.                                  Moscicki L, Mitrus M, Wojtowicz A.
performance evaluation shows that moisture                                                                                                            Technika ekstruzjiw przetw_orstwie rolno-
content has significant effect on expansion of                                                                                                        spo zywczym (in Polish), PWRiL,
which the highest value was at 30% moisture                                                                                                           Warszawa; 2011.
content and 6mm die size. Highest floatability                                                                    2.                                  Moscicki L, Wojcik S, Plaur K, van
was recorded at 30% moisture content and 6 mm                                                                                                         Zuilichem DJ. Extrusion cooking to
                                                                                                             57
                                                  Olalusi et al.; J. Eng. Res. Rep., vol. 23, no. 12, pp. 48-58, 2022; Article no.JERR.90252
                improve the animal feed quality of broad 13. Alam MS, Kaur J, Khaira H, Gupta K.
                beans. Journal of Food Engineering.              Extrusion and Extruded Products, Food
                1984;3(4):307-316.                               Science and Nutrition. 2016;56:132-
            3.  Idowu DO, Olaoye SA, Owolabi EO,                 140.
                Adebayo JM. Effect of Hydrothermal Pre- 14. Khater ESG, Bahnasawy AH, Ali SA.
                Treatment on Snake Gourd Seed Shelling.          Physical and Mechanical Properties of Fish
                International     Journal     of     Current     Feed Pellets. Journal of Food Processing
                .Microbiology and Applied Science.               & Technology. 2014;5:879-881.
                2019;8(2):1848-1858.                         15. Daood VM, Morad M, Afify MK, Kaddour U.
            4.  Olaoye SA, Owoseni OT, Olalusi AP.               Study on Some Engineering Parameters
                Optimization of Some Physical and                Affecting the Performance of Fish Feed
                Functional Properties of Extruded Soybean        Pelleting Machine. Misr J. Ag. Eng.
                Crud Residue-Base Floating Fish Feed.            2007;24(2):259-282.
                Turkish Journal of Agricultural Engineering 16. Ojomo AO, Agbetoye LAS, Ologunagba
                Research (TURKAGER). 2022;3(1):31-50.            FO. Performance Evaluation of a Fish
            5.  Leszek M, Dick J. Extrusion-Cooking and          Feed Pelletizing Machine. ARPN Journal
                Related Technique WILEY-VCH Verlag               of Engineering and Applied Sciences.
                GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim; 2011.                 2010;5(9):88-97.
                ISBN: 978-3-527-32888-8.                     17. Abubakar MY, Momoh AT, Ipinjolu JK.
            6.  Anon,       Feed      milling    equipment       Effect of pelletizing machines on floatation
                developments. World Grain, Sosland               and water stability of farm-made fish feeds,
                Publishing Company, Woroster Park,               International Journal of Fisheries and
                Surrey, England. 1991;9(8):15-19.                Aquatic Studies. 2016;4(3):98-103.
            7.  Behnke KC. Department of Grain Science 18. Saheed AO, Olanrewaju TO, Olufunso OO.
                and Industry, Kansas State University,           Effect of drying temperature on the
                Manhattan, Kansas, USA, and was edited           proximate composition of soybean crude
                and published in Feed Tech. 2001;5(4).           residue-base fish feed. International
            8.  Karaj S, Müller J. Optimizing mechanical         Journal     of      Food     Science    and
                oil extraction of Jatropha curcas L. seeds       Biotechnology. 2022;7(2):40-47.
                with respect to press capacity, oil recovery 19. Ojo ST, Olukunle OJ, Aduewa TO,
                and energy efficiency. Ind. Crops Prod.          Ukwenya AG. Performance Evaluation of
                2011;34:1010-1016.                               Floating Fish Feed Extrude Journal of
            9.  George G. Chase, Hopper Design. The              Agriculture and Veterinary Science.
                University of Akron, Solids Notes.               2014;7(12):103-113.
                2010;10:10-1-12.                             20. Oduntan O, Koya O. Effect of speed, die
            10. Jenike AW. Storage and Flow of Solids,           sizes and moisture contents on resin.
                Utah Engineering Experiment Station,             Research of Agricultural Engineering.
                University of Utah, Salt Lake City, USA          2015;61:1262-1270.
                Bulletin No. 123 (Revised edition 1970); 21. Folasayo          F,    Zhongjie    H.   Energy
                1964.                                            Consumption and Efficiency in Single
            11. Janssen LPBM, Noomen GH, Smith JM.               Screw Extrusion Processing of Selected
                The temperature distribution across a            Starchy Crops. Journal of Natural Sciences
                single screw extruder channel. Plast.            Research. 2015;5(12):12-18.
                Polym. 1975;43:135–140.                      22. Salawu AT, Isiaka M, Suleiman L.
            12. Spivakovsky A, Dyachkov V. Conveyors             Development of an Oil Extraction Machine
                and related equipment. Translated from           for Jatropha curcas Seeds. Journal of
                the Russian by Don danemanis, Peace              Scientific Research & Reports. 2015;6(4):
                Publishers; 1966.                                313-328.
            _______________________________________________________________________________
            © 2022 Olalusi et al.; This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution
            License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any
            medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
                                                        Peer-review history:
                                    The peer review history for this paper can be accessed here:
                                         https://www.sdiarticle5.com/review-history/90252
58