Caste Gender Intersectionality
Caste Gender Intersectionality
Theory and Practice in Language Studies, Vol. 14, No. 6, pp. 1796-1802, June 2024
DOI: https://doi.org/10.17507/tpls.1406.20
Abstract—This research explores the dynamic relationship between gender and caste in the select novels of
Bama, a prominent Tamil Dalit writer. Drawing on feminist and Dalit literary theories, this study analyzes
Bama’s novels, Karukku and Sangati, to reveal the nuanced ways in which gender and caste intersect that
shape the lives of Dalit women. Through close readings of Bama’s narratives, the article highlights the
systemic violence, discrimination, and marginalization faced by Dalit women. She fearlessly scrutinizes the
role of family, church, school, and government in inflicting both physical and psychological harm on the Dalit
community. She emphasizes the need for collective struggle against this systemic favoritism as the key to
individual liberation. Bama’s literary work brings to the fore the critical importance of comprehending the
complex interplay between gender and caste in the context of oppression. Through her writing, she illuminates
the agency and unwavering determination of Dalit women as they strive for social justice and equality.
I. INTRODUCTION
The intersection of gender and caste has enslaved the inner voice of women in Dalit community in India. Women and
Dalits have been targets of violence instituted and practiced by upper castes and patriarchal structures. Any violation of
hierarchy by Dalits or women is handled only by resorting to violence by the dominant structures of power. Dalit
writers, in Tamil like Bama, probe how these institutions operate against Dalit women. Bama’s literary works in Tamil
Dalit fiction, known as writing from the margin, represent a groundbreaking and transformative contribution. As a Dalit
woman, Bama brings her unique perspective to the forefront, unfolds her personal and professional experiences while
exploring the various contexts that shape her life. Through her writing, she vividly portrays the intersectionality of her
identity as a Dalit, highlighting the compounded marginalization she faces due to her gender, social class, and religious
background, “thereby creating their (dalit) consciousness and dalit identity among the dalits” (Aziz, 2015, p. 78). In her
literary works, Bama utilizes the lexicon and vernacular expressions of marginalized communities.
Bama’s novels, including Karukku and Sangati, often commence by delving into the childhood experiences of the
protagonists. Ruchi Tomar states that, “Dalit women’s voices have been muted and kept in silence. Hence, there is a
need to articulate their visions and build their own praxis sand theory” (Tomar, 2021, p. 1). In a similar vein, Bama
herself began these narratives by recounting her own childhood. During her school years, Bama faced mistreatment and
discrimination based on her caste and race. The ugliness and stigma associated with untouchability puzzled her, as she
witnessed her community being disregarded and despised by both teachers and classmates. Like many other Dalit girls,
she was relegated to the last bench of the classroom, symbolizing the marginalization they endured.
In the early 1990s, Bama played a significant role in the examination of the interconnections between gender and
caste in the lives of Dalits by actively engaging with the discourse of Dalit literature. Dalits need to have a political
consciousness or enlightenment, not just more degrees from universities. If Karukku upholds education, Sangati
foregrounds organized agitation. The paper intends to analyze the intricate ways in which gender and caste intersect in
the lives of Dalits and underscores the violence, discrimination and violence faced by dalit women in particular in
Bama’s Karukku and Sangati. As Mangalam says, “An inquiry into the modes of violence against Dalit women as
represented by Dalit writers would bring to focus the complex intersection of caste and gender principles as they
operate in our society” (Mangalam, 2023, p. 11).
II. OBJECTIVES
The objectives of this research are to analyze the portrayal of female characters within the Dalit context, exploring
how caste hierarchies influence their experiences, identities, and agency. Additionally, it seeks to examine the ways in
which Bama’s narratives challenge or reinforce prevailing societal norms and contribute to a deeper understanding of
the multifaceted relationship between gender and caste in contemporary Indian literature.
III. METHODOLOGY
This study adopts a multidisciplinary approach that integrates qualitative content analysis of Bama’s novels. The aim
is to identify prevalent themes and character portrayals concerning the dynamics of gender and caste. Furthermore, a
comparative analysis is conducted to juxtapose Bama’s depictions with pertinent theoretical frameworks from gender
studies and caste studies. This analysis aims to illuminate the intricate interactions between gender and caste identities,
employing intersectionality as a guiding concept.
Because we are born into the Paraiya jati, we are never given any honour or dignity or respect. We are stripped
of all that. But if we study and make progress, we can throw away these indignities. So study with care, learn
all you can. If you are always ahead in your lessons, people will come to you of their own accord and attach
themselves to you. Work hard and learn”. (Bama, Karukku, 2017, pp. 17-18)
The counsel from Bama’s older brother left a deep and lasting impact on her. She was resolute to show herself and
achieve her goals. From the day her brother spoke to her, she worked tirelessly in her studies, pouring all her heart and
soul into her education. She was determined to be the best student in her class. Bama writes: “In fact, because of that,
many people become my friends, even though I am a Paraichi” (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 18). During her educational
journey, Bama constantly encounters a stark reminder of her marginalization through the persistent presence of
untouchability wherever she ventures.
B. Patriarchy and Caste
Bama discusses how women in her community are subjected to oppression not just from the upper-caste individuals
but also from men within their Dalit community. Bama reflects on the rigid gender roles and expectations placed on
women, their lack of agency, and the discrimination they face, both within their homes and in the broader society.
Bama’s personal experiences and observations as a woman within the Dalit Christian community provide a lens through
which she explores the intersection of caste and gender discrimination. “What Bama faces in the society is that Dalits
are denied self – respect and identity. They are refused to be recognized as a part of the mainstream society and are
thrown out of the space. They are treated as untouchables and are considered impure because of their occupation
associated filth are dirt. Moreover, they are considered ‘outcaste’ because they fall outside the four fold caste system i.e.
Brahman, Kshatriya, Vaishya, shudra and are excluded from the Vedas. In the name of caste and social hierarchical
system, the Dalits are exploited” (Pandit, 2019, p. 13844).
Dalit women occupy the lowest rung of the social hierarchy, facing multiple forms of oppression: caste, class, and
gender. They are forced to fight for survival, facing discrimination and violence from their own community. Dalit
women work alongside men, but they receive lower wages and less respect. They are also more likely to be subjected to
sexual harassment and assault. At home, Dalit women face the additional challenges of early marriage, absence of
education, and health issues related to childbearing at a young age. Their position in society is still deplorable, and they
suffer greatly for being both Dalit and female. They are not spared from anguish and harassment, and their lives are
often characterized by struggle and hardship.
The novel is a powerful indictment of patriarchy and its oppressive impact on Dalit women, who is forced to endure a
lifetime of suffering and humiliation at the hands of men, both within and outside of her community. Bama (2017), on
the violence and exploitation of Dalit women by men of upper castes writes, “My father used to say that if a Dalit
woman is beaten, it is not a crime. He said that it is like beating a dog” (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 15). Further asserts
that “The upper-caste men would come and stare at the Dalit women while they were bathing in the river. They would
make lewd remarks and gestures. Sometimes, they would even try to molest the women” (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 20).
Patriarchy is embedded in Dalit culture and traditions. She is forced to marry at a young age, even though she does
not want to. She is also expected to obey her husband and father without question. It is used to justify the violence and
exploitation of Dalit women and limits the opportunities and choices available to women. She emphasizes the need for
Dalit men to become allies in the struggle for gender justice, highlighting the importance of collective liberation within
oppressed communities. Bama underscores the need for dismantling not only caste-based hierarchies but also gender-
based inequalities.
Dalits face caste discrimination in every aspect of their lives, including their search for jobs and housing. Bama
secures a teaching position in a school, but she soon realizes the harsh reality of caste discrimination. Her colleagues are
reluctant to accept her education because she is a Dalit. To her dismay, Bama also encounters caste discrimination
within the convent institutions. She observes, “Before they became nuns, these women take a vow that they will live in
poverty. But that is just a sham. The convent does not know the meaning of poverty” (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 77).
Further, she states, “It is only the upper-caste Christians who enjoy the benefits and comforts of the Church ... And if
Dalits become priests or nuns; they are pushed aside and marginalized first of all, before the rest go about their business”
(Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 80). Bama reveals the discrimination meted out to her by the Telugu nuns who look down
upon Tamils. Bama declares that, “I began to understand, little by little, that in that order, Tamil people were looked
upon as a lower caste. And then among Tamils, Parayas were a separate category” (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 24).
Bama recounts her personal experiences in the village she originated from, highlighting how even the concept of
worship underwent a complete transformation based on one’s caste. Power and authority act as a major role in this
dynamic, and the belief in God takes on a curious form, influenced by wealth and influence. Even if individuals change
their religion, their circumstances and treatment remain unchanged. The higher class Christian people enjoy the benefits
provided by the church, while the ignorance of the Dalits is exploited, serving as a capital for their caste. This
exploitation allows them to establish thriving businesses and further benefit their own caste.
I felt in my heart that I could go and speak directly to God without their intervention. I could no longer believe
that God could only be reached, as they taught us, through prayer learned by rote, thorough pious practices,
through the novena and the rosary. I came to realize that you could see God through the mind’s eye, in nature
and in the ordinary events of every day. So all the rituals that I had followed and believed in so far suddenly
began to seem meaningless and just a shame. The desire to become nun fell away from me entirely at this time.
(Bama, Karukku, 2017, p. 102)
C. Liberation and Solidarity
Bama’s perspective on education centers on its role in liberating the Dalit community. According to her, education
functions as a means of resistance and empowerment, providing a voice to those who have been marginalized in society.
Karukku is not solely a tale of despair. It also illuminates the fortitude and tenacity of Dalit women who come together
to challenge the oppressive system. Her work emphasizes the importance of solidarity, as the characters in the novel
strive for collective liberation. In Karukku she comments in her afterword to the First edition,
Because I live by myself in this society, without supports of my own such as a family, a husband and children,
I have to face many problems. But even though there are a thousand difficulties which beset a Dalit woman
living on her own, yet the truth is that in my position as an independent woman, there are many opportunities
for me to spend my life usefully, and especially, to work for the liberation of Dalits. (Bama, Karukku, 2017, p.
137)
Karukku serves as a powerful plea to Dalits, urging them to break free from the chains of caste and religious
oppression. Bama’s transformative journey in the book renews her belief in the potential of education to liberate
individuals from manipulative communal systems. Bama emphasizes the importance of solidarity among Dalits and
marginalized communities. She describes the support and unity within her community, which enables them to confront
and challenge the oppressive forces that seek to keep them subjugated. The book illustrates the strength and resilience
of the Dalit community when they come together to fight for their rights and dignity. Bama’s writing also highlights the
role of women in fostering solidarity within the community, challenging the patriarchal norms that exist in both castes
Hindu and Christian contexts.
observed that boys exploit their circumstances, and when women dare to protest, they are unjustly stigmatized as
promiscuous individuals. The story of Mariamma serves as a striking example of this phenomenon. Mariamma, who is
the narrator’s cousin, bears witness to the pervasive issue of sexual harassment experienced by Dalit women, along with
their struggles to assert themselves in the face of such atrocities. In Mariamma’s case, Kumaraswamy, a landlord
belonging to an upper caste, attempts to molest her, yet she finds herself unable to voice her objections against him. She
thought that, “He’s upper caste as well. How can we even try to stand up to such people?” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 20).
But Kumarasami accused the guiltless girl who tried to save his face: “When she went innocently to get some water, he
seized her hand and pulled her inside. Frightened out of her wits, she left everything and ran home, hardly knowing how
she escaped” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 20).
The author also highlights the disdainful treatment Dalit women receive from upper-caste women. In this regard, she
shows a parallel between the lifestyles of these women and those of the Paraiyar community. Bama embraces a sense of
pride in emphasizing that the women in her community, unlike their counterparts, work diligently and earn their own
income, thus achieving a measure of economic independence without relying solely on their husbands. Despite enduring
physical and mental subjugation to men, these women find ways to resist and assert themselves by vocally expressing
their frustrations through shouting and hurling obscenities. The author astutely notes that outcry and shrieking function
as survival strategies for these women. She earnestly wishes for them to recognize their inherent “self-worth, honour,
and self-respect” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 68).
B. Gender Based Discrimination
Sangati underscores the gender discrimination experienced by Dalit women from an early age. Female infants are
consistently deemed inferior and receive lesser care. Bama raises the issue of gender bias by saying, “If a boy baby cries,
he is instantly picked up and given milk. It is not so with the girl. Even with breast-feeding, it is the same story; a boy is
breast fed longer, with the girl, they bear them quietly, making them forget the breast” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 7). The
narrator highlights the early distinctions in the treatment of boys and girls. Girls are discouraged from speaking loudly
or expressing hearty laughter. They are not permitted to lie on their backs or stomachs while sleeping and are expected
to maintain a posture with their heads lowered as they walk. Bama writes, “Even when our stomachs are screaming with
hunger, we mustn’t eat first. We are allowed to eat only after the men in the family have finished and gone” (Bama,
Sangati, 2005, p. 29).
Bama depicted inequality in payment between men and women, portraying women as workers who earn wages in
occupations such as agricultural labor and construction work. However, they are consistently received lower pay than
their male counterparts. Bama comments that, “The women, in any case, whatever work they did, were paid less than
men. Even when they did the very same work, they were paid less. Even in the matter of tying up firewood bundles, the
boys always got five or six rupees more. And if the girls tied up the bundles but the boys actually sold them, they got
the better price” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 18).
Satyendra Prasad Singh (2016), while interpreting about gender discrimination, points out that, “Maikkanni is the
first girl to climb into the factory bus and rushes to find a window seat. But the boy from Kakkalayakudi, who arrives
later, pushes her away and grabs all the window seats. She is also beaten by her father for money and then by the maistri
Annaacchi in the factory for throwing away two match- box labels” (Singh, 2016, p. 153).
Bama offers a critique of both patriarchy and casteism within the church. She strongly condemns the church's
regulations on divorce and its subtle religious methods to subjugate women. In her view, parish priests show little
regard for women’s autonomy in choosing their life partners and often assign them to the least desirable roles within the
church. The narrator, despite her efforts, is never granted access to the sacristy. In contrast, even the youngest boys,
newly born, are permitted entry, while the church authorities consistently deny this privilege to girls. She points about
the plight of Dalit women, “In the fields they have to escape from upper-caste men’s molestations. At church, they must
lick the priest’s shoes and be his slaves while he threatens them with tales of God, Heaven, and Hell. Even when they
go to their own homes, before they have had a chance to cook some kanji or lie down and rest a little, they have to
submit themselves to their husband’s torment” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 35).
C. Resistance and Empowerment
Bama’s narrative goes beyond the mere depiction of suffering experienced by Dalit women, serving as a testament to
their resilience and active agency in challenging oppressive structures. Throughout the novel, she emphasizes the
importance of education and empowerment as a means to challenge and overcome discrimination. Bama pictures their
plight: “Everywhere you look, you see blows and beatings, shame and humiliation” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 118).
Bama consistently shows concern for Dalit women, persistently urging them to stand up and confront the challenges: “If
we continue to be frightened, everyone will take advantage of us. If we stand up for ourselves without caring whether
we die or survive, they’ll creep away with their tails between their legs” (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 66). The primary
cause of suffering among Dalits is the absence of access to education. Bama also implores her community to adopt
certain measures to bring an end to these issues. She appeals them to treat both boys and girls alike, showing no
difference between them as they grow into adults. Throughout history and across various cultures, the role of women in
society has varied widely. However, a consistent theme across most societies is the lack of equal status and recognition
for women compared to men.
Bama passionately advocates for the empowerment of girls, emphasizing the importance of granting them freedom.
She inspires them to recognize and embrace their inner strength and vitality. She opines that, “there will come a day
when men and women will live as one, with no difference between them; with equal rights. Then injustices, violence
and inequalities will come to an end, and she is sure that the saying ‘Women can make and women can break” (Bama,
Sangati, 2005, p. 123). The writer encourages the womenfolk that, we must bring up pour girls to think these new ways
from an early age. We should educate boys and girls alike, showing no difference between them as they grow into
adults (Bama, Sangati, 2005, p. 123).
In Sangati, Bama skillfully offers a reflective glimpse into the emotions of Dalit women, highlighting their struggles
and advocating for transformation and improvement in various areas of their lives. These areas include addressing sex
and gender discrimination, promoting equal opportunities in the workforce, and fighting for education rights. The
narrator, taking on the role of both an all-knowing narrator and a directing force, effectively shapes the incidents and
events in the story, while also shedding light on the bygone facets of the Dalit people through a diverse range of
characters. This narrative technique contributes to the overall development of the novel. Bama emphasizes that the
responsibility for uplifting the hopeless women in her community rests solely on the women themselves. She recognizes
that no outside help can truly transform their lives, and it is essential for Dalit women to take control of their own
destinies. The novel vividly portrays the grueling toil and menace faced by Dalit women, which perpetuates a tradition
of violence that permeates throughout the story. This theme underscores the urgent need for societal change and serves
as a driving force behind the events in the novel.
VI. CONCLUSION
According to S.K. Paul’s (2007) observations, Dalitness serves as a catalyst for conflict and confrontation “Dalitness
is a matter of appreciating the potential of one’s total being. Thus, individual, culture, social burden, and Dalitness
cannot be isolated ... For this new Dalit individual, social and cultural freedom has come because of his self-elevation
and self-identification” (Paul, 2007, p. 35). In both Karukku and Sangati, Bama skillfully brings to the forefront the
layered forms of domination experienced by women. She delves deep into the habitual tasks performed by Dalit women,
both within the confines of their homes and in the outside world. Bama critically examines how violence against Dalit
women is not only perpetuated but also legitimized and institutionalized by various powerful entities such as the state,
family, religious institutions, and upper-caste communities. Through her fiction, Bama vividly portrays the arduous
labor undertaken by Dalit women and the systematic subjugation they endure within their homes and beyond. They face
sadistic treatment not only from upper-caste landlords, the panchayat, and the police but also from Dalit men within
their households. Bama depicts Dalit women chiefly as laborers who enter the workforce from a young age and
continue to toil throughout adolescence, womanhood, middle age, and even into their elderly years, persisting until their
final moments. Regrettably, their tireless efforts often go unnoticed and unappreciated by both their own community
and society at large, leaving them subjugated at every possible juncture.
Bama’s depiction of the life journeys of Dalit women is emblematic of the broader battle for empowerment and the
pursuit of a life of dignity within the Dalit community. Through her narratives, she sheds light on the challenges faced
by Dalit women at various stages of their lives, offering insights into their unacknowledged contributions and the
obstacles they confront. Her powerful storytelling helps as a window into the ongoing struggle for empowerment within
the Dalit community, highlighting the need for understanding and recognition of their unique experiences. It provides a
meticulous portrayal of the trials faced by Dalit women, their triumphs, and their aspirations, ultimately documenting
the broader striving for empowerment in social, economic, and political spheres within the Dalit community.
Bama’s writing explores the profound impact of a success-driven and consumerist society on children. She expresses
deep concern for the well-being of young individuals who suffer the consequences of societal obsession with
achievement and materialism. Amongst these children, Dalit students become particularly vulnerable targets for
mockery, disapproval, and disgrace due to their social background. Bama shines a spotlight on the systemic biases and
prejudices that perpetuate such mistreatment, emphasizing the urgent need for social change and a more inclusive
education system that uplifts and nurtures all children, regardless of their caste or social group.
To conclude, this research has endeavored to illuminate the intricate and dynamic intersection between gender and
caste within the narratives of Bama’s two novels. A comprehensive analysis of her works revealed the profound
complexities, struggles, and resilient voices that characterize this intersection. The significance of Bama’s novels lies
not only in their literary merit but in their ability to serve as a window into the lived experiences of individuals whose
lives are entangled in the web of gender and caste-based discrimination. The findings reveal that Bama’s narratives
challenge preconceived notions and stereotypes, offering a nuanced perspective on the multifaceted relationship
between gender and caste. It is evident that these issues are not isolated but deeply interwoven, shaping the social fabric
and individual identities of her characters.
REFERENCES
[1] Aziz, Sohel. (2015). Dalit consciousness and dalit identity in K.A.Gunasekaran’s The Scar. Indian Dalit autobiographies,
marginalized voices, edited by Bijinder Singh, Author Press, 78-87.
[2] Bama. (2017). Karukku. Trans. Lakshmi Holmstrom, MacMillan.
[3] Bama. (2005). Sangati. (Events). Trans. Lakshmi Holmstrom, Oxford University Press.
[4] Jayaprakash, Shalini. (2016).Writing dissent: Reading Bama’s life writing. Studies in Dalit literature: Bama a Dalit Feminist,
edited by R.K. Dhawan & Sumita Puri, Prestige Books International, 49-57.
[5] Prasad Singh, Satyendra. (2016). Feminism in Bama’s Sangati. Studies in Dalit literature: Bama a Dalit Feminist, edited by
R.K. Dhawan & Sumita Puri, Prestige Books International, 49-57.
[6] Mangalam, B. (2023). Dalit fiction in Tamil 1989-2022. Representation of Dalit women: A critical perspective. World view.
[7] Pandit, Moonmoon. (2019). Representation of marginalization in Bama’s Karukku. Think India Journal, 22(14), 13836-13848.
[8] Paul, S.K. (2007). Dalitism: Its growth and evaluation. Dalit literature: A critical exploration, edited by Amarnath Prasad and
M.B.Gaijan, Sarup & Sons, 17-46.
[9] Sharma, Priti. (2015). Caste, Gender, Resistance Dichotomy and Dalit’s Feministic Quest: An Insight into Bama’s Sangati.
Indian Dalit Autobiographies: Marginalized Voices, edited by Bijinder Singh, Authors Press, pp. 186-187.
[10] Singh, Kanwar Pal. (2021). Bama’s Sangati: A traumatic chain of gender discrimination. The Creative Launcher, 6(5), 72-79.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53032/tcl.2021.6.5.09.
[11] Tomar, Ruchi. (Ed.). (2021). Dalit feminism: Mapping exclude voices in literature. Namya Press.
[12] Thenmozhi, A. (2022). Dalit women oppression by double patriarchies in Bama’s karukku and sangati. Writings on feminism:
From margin to centre, edited by Daleleer Kaur, D. Ramkumar Varma and Sapna Desai, Authors Press, pp. 60-67.
A. Thenmozhi. is an Associate Professor in English at Government Arts College, Dharmapuri, Tamil Nadu. She obtained her
Ph.D. in English from Periyar University in Salem in 2019. Her areas of research focus on Dalit Literature and Gender studies. With
teaching experience of 20 years, she has authored a chapter in a book and also edited a book. Her works have appeared in UGC care
and other reputed journals.