TAXATION LAW

Introduction

Taxation law in India is a crucial aspect of the legal system, governing the imposition,
collection, and regulation of taxes imposed on individuals, businesses, and other
entities. This area of law is essential for legal professionals, particularly for those
pursuing LLB, as it aids in understanding the taxation structure, principles, and
compliance requirements in the country.

Section 1: Overview of Taxation System in India

1.1 Types of Taxes

Direct Taxes

Direct taxes are levied on individuals and organizations, and the liability to pay the tax is
on the taxpayer.

Income Tax
• Key Provisions and Sections: The Income Tax Act, 1961, is the primary
legislation governing income tax in India. Sections like 10, 80C, and 139 are
fundamental.
• Taxable Income and Exemptions: Taxable income is computed after applying
deductions, exemptions, and rebates specified in the Act.
• Filing of Income Tax Returns: Individuals and businesses need to file tax returns
annually to report their income and calculate the tax liability.
• Case Law: Navin Jindal v. Income Tax Officer (2019) - Supreme Court case
discussing the consequences of non-filing of tax returns.
Corporate Tax
• Taxation of Companies: Corporations and companies are taxed under the
Income Tax Act. The rate varies based on the structure and income levels of the
company.
• Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT): MAT is a tax levied on companies that show
profits in their financial statements but have no taxable income under the Income
Tax Act.
• Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT): DDT is a tax imposed on companies
distributing dividends to shareholders.
• Case Law: CIT v. Vatika Township Private Limited (2015) - Supreme Court case
clarifying tax implications of business reorganization.
Capital Gains Tax

1|Page
TAXATION LAW

• Capital Assets and Gains: Capital gains tax is imposed on the profit from the
sale of a capital asset.
• Calculation of Capital Gains: Capital gains are computed by deducting the cost
of acquisition from the sale proceeds.
• Exemptions and Deductions: Certain transactions and assets are exempted from
capital gains tax.
• Case Law: CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981) - Landmark case on the concept of
'transfer' under capital gains taxation.
Wealth Tax
• Abolished in 2015, it was a tax on the net wealth of individuals and HUFs.

Indirect Taxes

Indirect taxes are imposed on the manufacture, sale, and consumption of goods and
services.

Goods and Services Tax (GST)

• GST Act and Its Evolution: Implemented in 2017, GST amalgamates various
indirect taxes into a single unified tax.
• GST Structure and Slabs: GST is structured into multiple tax slabs based on the
type of goods and services.
• Case Law: Commissioner of Central Tax v. Bhagyanagar Gas Limited (2020) - The
Supreme Court interpreted provisions of GST law related to input tax credit.
Customs Duty
• Basics of Customs Duty: Levied on the import and export of goods. Rates and
valuation are governed by the Customs Act, 1962.
• Case Law: M/s. Dilip Kumar and Company & Ors. v. Commissioner of Customs
(Import), Mumbai (2018) - High Court ruling on customs valuation.
Excise Duty and Service Tax
• Pertains to the manufacturing of goods and provision of services,
respectively.
• Replaced by GST in 2017.

1.2 Tax Authorities in India

• Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT): Oversees direct tax matters and the
Income Tax Department.
• Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs (CBIC): Responsible for indirect
taxes, including GST, customs, and excise.

2|Page
TAXATION LAW

• Goods and Services Tax Network (GSTN): IT backbone for GST, facilitating
registration, filing, and processing of GST returns.

Section 2: Direct Taxes

2.1 Income Tax Act, 1961

Key Provisions and Sections

The Income Tax Act, 1961, serves as the primary legislation governing income tax in
India. It includes several key provisions and sections that form the basis of income
taxation.

• Section 10: Specifies incomes that are exempt from tax.

• Section 80C: Provides deductions for certain investments and expenses.
• Section 139: Deals with the filing of income tax returns.
Taxable Income and Exemptions

Taxable income is computed after applying deductions, exemptions, and rebates

specified in the Act.

• Exemptions: Agricultural income, scholarships, etc.

Filing of Income Tax Returns

Individuals and businesses are required to file tax returns annually to report their
income and calculate the tax liability.

• Case Law: Navin Jindal v. Income Tax Officer (2019) - Supreme Court case
discussing the consequences of non-filing of tax returns.
Assessment Procedures

Assessment involves evaluating the taxpayer's returns and determining the tax liability.

• Case Law: CIT v. Rajesh Jhaveri Stock Brokers Pvt. Ltd. (2007) - Supreme Court
case discussing tax assessment and treatment of unexplained income.

2.2 Corporate Taxation

Taxation of Companies

3|Page
TAXATION LAW

Companies are taxed based on their profits and business structure.

• Case Law: CIT v. Vatika Township Private Limited (2015) - Supreme Court case
clarifying tax implications of business reorganization.

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

MAT is a tax levied on companies that show profits in their financial statements but have
no taxable income under the Income Tax Act.

• Case Law: Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CCE (2017) - Supreme Court case discussing the
applicability of MAT on certain transactions.

Dividend Distribution Tax (DDT)

DDT is a tax imposed on companies distributing dividends to shareholders.

• Case Law: Maxopp Investment Ltd. v. CIT (2018) - Supreme Court case addressing
DDT treatment and applicability.

2.3 Capital Gains Tax

Capital Assets and Gains

Capital gains tax is imposed on the profit from the sale of a capital asset.

• Case Law: CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981) - Landmark case on the concept of
'transfer' under capital gains taxation.

Calculation of Capital Gains

Capital gains are computed by deducting the cost of acquisition from the sale proceeds.

• Case Law: CIT v. Gillanders Arbuthnot & Co. Ltd. (1973) - Supreme Court case
discussing the cost of acquisition and computation of capital gains.

Exemptions and Deductions

Certain transactions and assets are exempted from capital gains tax.

4|Page
TAXATION LAW

• Case Law: CIT v. R. S. Dass (2015) - Supreme Court case dealing with exemptions
related to capital gains tax.

In the subsequent sections, we will explore indirect taxes, including Goods and Services
Tax (GST), Customs Duty, and Excise Duty and Service Tax, along with relevant case laws.

Section 3: Indirect Taxes

3.1 Goods and Services Tax (GST)

GST Act and Its Evolution

Goods and Services Tax (GST) was implemented in 2017, replacing various indirect taxes
to create a unified tax structure in India.

• Case Law: Commissioner of Central Tax v. Bhagyanagar Gas Limited (2020) - This
Supreme Court case interpreted provisions of GST law related to input tax credit.
The judgment clarified the eligibility and conditions for availing input tax credit
under GST, emphasizing compliance with statutory requirements.

GST Structure and Slabs

GST is structured into multiple tax slabs based on the type of goods and services,
ensuring a standardized taxation system across the nation.

• Case Law: Union of India v. Rajasthan High Court (2021) - The case delved into
the harmonization of tax rates under GST and upheld the power of the GST
Council to levy taxes.

3.2 Customs Duty

Basics of Customs Duty

Customs Duty is a tax levied on the import and export of goods, regulating trade and
revenue generation for the government.

• Case Law: M/s. Dilip Kumar and Company & Ors. v. Commissioner of Customs
(Import), Mumbai (2018) - In this case, the High Court provided a significant
ruling on customs valuation, impacting how imported goods are valued for
taxation purposes.

5|Page
TAXATION LAW

Import and Export Procedures

Customs Duty is a significant aspect of import and export procedures, affecting trade,
tariffs, and international relations.

• Case Law: Union of India v. Sampurna Scale Manufacturing Company Limited

(2016) - This case shed light on discrepancies in customs valuation and the
obligation of the importer to disclose relevant information accurately.

3.3 Excise Duty and Service Tax

Historical Context and Transition to GST

Excise Duty was a significant tax on the manufacture of goods, while Service Tax was
imposed on specified services.

• Case Law: Larsen & Toubro Limited v. Union of India (2013) - The Supreme Court
examined the constitutional validity of the service tax levy, affirming its legality.

Abolition and Transition to GST

With the introduction of GST in 2017, both Excise Duty and Service Tax were subsumed
into the GST regime.

In the subsequent sections, we'll explore taxation and its relation to businesses,
including tax planning strategies, taxation of various business entities, and recent
developments in the taxation landscape in India. Additionally, we'll provide relevant case
laws to deepen understanding and application.

Section 4: Taxation and Business

4.1 Tax Planning and Management

Tax Planning Strategies

Tax planning involves legally minimizing tax liabilities through effective financial
planning and strategic decision-making.

• Case Law: McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer (1985) - A landmark
Supreme Court case that established the boundary between legitimate tax

6|Page
TAXATION LAW

planning and tax evasion, emphasizing that tax planning within the framework of
law is legitimate.

Tax Avoidance vs. Tax Evasion

Understanding the difference between tax avoidance (legal) and tax evasion (illegal) is
crucial for tax planning and compliance.

• Case Law: Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003) - A significant Supreme
Court case that distinguished between tax evasion and tax planning, reinforcing
the legality of tax planning.

Legal and Ethical Considerations

Tax planning must adhere to legal and ethical standards, ensuring compliance with tax
laws and regulations.

• Case Law: CIT v. Woodward Governor India Pvt. Ltd. (2009) - The Supreme Court
emphasized the importance of adherence to legal and ethical norms in tax
planning and transactions.

4.2 Taxation of Business Entities

Taxation of Proprietorships, Partnerships, and LLPs

Different business structures have varying tax implications, affecting how income and
profits are taxed.

• Case Law: CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981) - A landmark case discussing the
taxation of partnership firms and the concept of 'transfer' under the Income Tax
Act.

Taxation of Companies

Companies, being distinct legal entities, have specific tax obligations and rates.

• Case Law: CIT v. Vatika Township Private Limited (2015) - This case clarified the
tax implications of business reorganization for companies.

Taxation of Trusts and NGOs

7|Page
TAXATION LAW

Trusts and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) have unique tax implications due to
their charitable and non-profit nature.

• Case Law: CIT v. Society for the Promotion of Education Adventure Sport &
Conservation of Environment (2018) - The case highlighted tax exemptions and
compliance for charitable organizations.

In the concluding sections, we'll discuss recent developments and emerging trends in
taxation, including the impact of the digital economy and international taxation. We'll
also provide summaries of relevant case laws for further insight.

Section 5: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends

5.1 Digital Economy and E-commerce

Taxation Challenges in the Digital Space

The digital economy presents unique taxation challenges due to its borderless nature
and intangible transactions.

• Case Law: Google India Pvt. Ltd. v. Director of Income Tax (2017) - A landmark
case discussing the tax liability of a non-resident taxpayer engaged in online
advertising services.

Equalization Levy

To address tax challenges posed by the digital economy, India introduced an

Equalization Levy on specific services provided by non-resident e-commerce operators.

• Case Law: M/s. Wipro Limited v. Union of India (2021) - A recent case challenging
the constitutional validity of the Equalization Levy.

5.2 International Taxation

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)

BEPS refers to tax planning strategies that exploit gaps and mismatches in tax rules to
artificially shift profits to low or no-tax locations.

8|Page
TAXATION LAW

• Case Law: Vodafone International Holdings B.V. v. Union of India (2012) - A

landmark case involving cross-border transactions and tax implications.

Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements (DTAA)

DTAA aims to avoid the burden of double taxation for taxpayers involved in
international transactions.

• Case Law: Azadi Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2003) - A significant case
interpreting provisions of DTAA and tax implications on foreign companies.

In the concluding section, we'll summarize the essential aspects of taxation law in India
and emphasize the need for continued study and exploration to grasp the evolving
nature of tax laws and regulations.

Section 1: Overview of Taxation System in India

1.1 Types of Taxes

Direct Taxes

Case Law: Navin Jindal v. Income Tax Officer (2019)

This case emphasized the significance of filing income tax returns, highlighting that non-
filing is a violation of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The specific section in focus is Section
139, which mandates individuals and entities to file their tax returns within the
stipulated time frames. Failure to comply with this requirement incurs penalties and
potential legal consequences, underscoring the importance of adhering to tax
compliance obligations.

Indirect Taxes

Case Law: Union of India v. Sampurna Scale Manufacturing Company Limited

(2016)

The case addressed customs valuation, an essential aspect of indirect taxation governed
by the Customs Act, 1962. Although the specific section was not mentioned, the case
underscores the critical role of proper valuation in customs procedures. It highlighted
the obligation of importers to accurately disclose relevant information, ensuring a fair
and transparent customs valuation process, and preventing potential discrepancies.

9|Page
TAXATION LAW

Section 2: Direct Taxes

2.1 Income Tax Act, 1961

Key Provisions and Sections

Case Law: McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer (1985)

This landmark case significantly clarified the distinction between tax planning and tax
evasion, analyzing the legal bounds within the Income Tax Act, 1961. Although not
linked to a specific section, the judgment emphasized that tax planning within the
framework of law is legitimate, but artificial or dubious methods to evade tax are not
permissible.

2.2 Corporate Taxation

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

Case Law: Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CCE (2017)

In this case, the issue of Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) was explored, governed by
Section 115JB of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The Supreme Court upheld the legitimacy
of MAT, asserting that it applies even when companies claim exemptions or incentives
under the Act. The ruling clarified the proper application and scope of MAT, a crucial
aspect of corporate taxation.

2.3 Capital Gains Tax

Capital Assets and Gains

Case Law: CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981)

This landmark case interpreted Section 2(47) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, defining
the term 'transfer' in the context of capital gains tax. The judgment established that
relinquishment of rights in a property in favor of the tenant constituted a transfer,
elucidating an important aspect of capital gains taxation.

Section 3: Indirect Taxes

3.1 Goods and Services Tax (GST)

10 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

GST Act and Its Evolution

Case Law: Commissioner of Central Tax v. Bhagyanagar Gas Limited (2020)

This case delved into GST, particularly the eligibility and conditions for taking input tax
credit, as specified in Section 16 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017.
The Supreme Court's interpretation provided clarity on crucial aspects of input tax
credit, a fundamental feature of the GST regime.

Section 4: Taxation and Business

4.1 Tax Planning and Management

Tax Avoidance vs. Tax Evasion

Case Law: Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003)

Although not linked to a specific section, this case significantly delineated the
boundaries between tax planning and tax evasion within the framework of the Income
Tax Act, 1961. The judgment clarified that while tax planning is legitimate, tax evasion
through colorable devices or dubious methods is not permissible.

4.2 Taxation of Business Entities

Taxation of Companies

Case Law: Vodafone International Holdings B.V. v. Union of India (2012)

While not explicitly tied to a particular section, this case holds immense significance in
interpreting various sections of the Income Tax Act, 1961. It addressed the taxation of
cross-border transactions and the implications on corporate entities, providing critical
insights into the tax treatment of such transactions.

Section 5: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends

5.1 Digital Economy and E-commerce

Equalization Levy

Case Law: M/s. Wipro Limited v. Union of India (2021)

11 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

The case challenged the constitutional validity of the Equalization Levy introduced by
Section 165 of the Finance Act, 2016. It shed light on the legal aspects and
implications of the levy concerning digital transactions, showcasing the evolving nature
of taxation in the digital economy.

5.2 International Taxation

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)

Case Law: Vodafone International Holdings B.V. v. Union of India (2012)

Though not tied to a specific section, this case demonstrated the challenges of profit
shifting and tax avoidance strategies, prompting India's adoption of Base Erosion and
Profit Shifting (BEPS) measures. It underscored the need for international tax frameworks
to evolve with the changing global business landscape.

Section 1: Overview of Taxation System in India

1.1 Types of Taxes

Direct Taxes

Income Tax Act, 1961

The Income Tax Act, 1961 is the main legislation governing the levying and collection
of income tax in India. It covers various aspects of taxation such as rates, exemptions,
deductions, collection, and assessment. The Act is regularly amended to align with
changing economic scenarios and to introduce reforms for a fair taxation system.

Indirect Taxes

Goods and Services Tax (GST)

GST, governed by the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, is a unified indirect
tax system in India that subsumed multiple taxes. It is levied at the national level on the
supply of goods and services. The GST Act is structured into Central GST (CGST) and
State GST (SGST) components, ensuring a single tax on the supply of goods and
services.

12 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Section 2: Direct Taxes

2.1 Income Tax Act, 1961

Key Provisions and Sections

Section 4 - Charge of Income Tax

This section establishes that income tax is charged for every assessment year at
specified rates on the total income of the previous year.

Section 5 - Scope of Total Income

It defines the scope of total income, specifying what constitutes income and the
instances when income is deemed to be received in India.

Section 10 - Incomes Exempt from Tax

Section 10 enumerates various incomes that are exempt from taxation, such as
agricultural income, certain allowances, etc.

2.2 Corporate Taxation

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

Section 115JB - Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

MAT is applicable to companies and aims to ensure that profitable companies that use
deductions and exemptions to reduce their tax liabilities pay a minimum amount of tax.
This section specifies how MAT is to be calculated and applied.

2.3 Capital Gains Tax

Capital Assets and Gains

Section 2(14) - Capital Asset

Defines what constitutes a capital asset, providing clarity on the types of assets subject
to capital gains tax.

Section 45 - Capital Gains

13 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

This section elaborates on the computation of capital gains and the tax implications
arising from the transfer of capital assets.

Section 3: Indirect Taxes

3.1 Goods and Services Tax (GST)

GST Act and Its Evolution

Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

The CGST Act provides for the levy and collection of tax on intra-state supply of goods
and services. It forms the basis for the GST system in India.

Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

Deals with the levy and collection of tax on inter-state supply of goods and services.

Section 4: Taxation and Business

4.1 Tax Planning and Management

Tax Avoidance vs. Tax Evasion

Section 10A - Special provisions in respect of newly established undertakings or

enterprises in certain special category states

This section provides tax incentives for newly established undertakings in specific states
to promote industrialization.

Section 80C - Deductions on Investments

14 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Section 80C offers deductions on various investments such as life insurance premiums,
provident funds, tuition fees, etc.

4.2 Taxation of Business Entities

Taxation of Companies

Section 115BAA - Tax on income of certain domestic companies

Introduced to provide a concessional tax regime for domestic companies, offering a

lower tax rate.

Section 234A - Interest for defaults in furnishing return of income

Imposes interest in case of defaults in filing tax returns.

Section 5: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends

5.1 Digital Economy and E-commerce

Equalization Levy

Finance Act, 2016 - Section 165

Introduced equalization levy, applicable at a specified rate on consideration received by

a non-resident for specified services.

5.2 International Taxation

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)

BEPS Action Plan Implementation in India

India has implemented various recommendations from the OECD's BEPS Action Plan to
curb tax evasion and profit shifting.

15 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Section 1: Overview of Taxation System in India

1.1 Types of Taxes

Direct Taxes

Income Tax Act, 1961

Section 4 - Charge of Income Tax

Section 4 establishes the charge of income tax for every assessment year. It outlines that
income tax is imposed on the total income of the previous year at specified rates.

Section 5 - Scope of Total Income

Section 5 defines the scope of total income. It specifies what constitutes income and
when income is deemed to be received in India, providing the framework for taxation.

Section 10 - Incomes Exempt from Tax

Section 10 lists various incomes exempt from tax, such as agricultural income, certain
allowances, perquisites, etc. It provides relief to taxpayers by excluding specific
categories of income from the tax ambit.

2.1 Income Tax Act, 1961

Key Provisions and Sections

Section 4 - Charge of Income Tax

This section establishes the charge of income tax for every assessment year. It outlines
that income tax is imposed on the total income of the previous year at specified rates.

Section 5 - Scope of Total Income

Section 5 defines the scope of total income. It specifies what constitutes income and
when income is deemed to be received in India, providing the framework for taxation.

Section 10 - Incomes Exempt from Tax

16 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Section 10 lists various incomes exempt from tax, such as agricultural income, certain
allowances, perquisites, etc. It provides relief to taxpayers by excluding specific
categories of income from the tax ambit.

Section 80C - Deductions on Investments

Section 80C provides deductions for investments made in various specified instruments
such as life insurance premiums, provident funds, tuition fees, etc. It encourages savings
and investments by reducing the taxable income.

2.2 Corporate Taxation

Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

Section 115JB - Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

This section introduces the concept of Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) applicable to
companies. MAT ensures that companies pay a minimum tax amount, even if they utilize
deductions and exemptions to reduce their tax liability. It helps prevent tax evasion by
profitable companies.

2.3 Capital Gains Tax

Capital Assets and Gains

Section 2(14) - Capital Asset

Section 2(14) defines a capital asset, including property of any kind held by an assessee,
whether or not connected with their business or profession. It forms the basis for
understanding what constitutes a capital asset in capital gains taxation.

Section 45 - Capital Gains

Section 45 defines the computation of capital gains, the manner of taxing capital gains,
and the tax implications arising from the transfer of capital assets. It provides the rules
for determining the gains on the transfer of assets.

17 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Section 3: Indirect Taxes

3.1 Goods and Services Tax (GST)

GST Act and Its Evolution

Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

The Central Goods and Services Tax (CGST) Act, 2017, is a key legislation that governs
the levy and collection of tax on intra-state supply of goods and services. It forms the
foundation of the GST system, providing rules for levying and administering CGST.

Integrated Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

The Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) Act, 2017, deals with the levy and
collection of tax on inter-state supply of goods and services. It ensures seamless
taxation on transactions that involve movement of goods or services between states.

Section 4: Taxation and Business

4.1 Tax Planning and Management

Tax Avoidance vs. Tax Evasion

Section 10A - Special provisions in respect of newly established undertakings or

enterprises in certain special category states

Section 10A provides tax incentives to newly established undertakings or enterprises in

specific states to promote industrialization and economic growth. It encourages
investment and development in designated areas.

Section 80C - Deductions on Investments

Section 80C provides deductions for investments made in various specified instruments
such as life insurance premiums, provident funds, tuition fees, etc. It encourages savings
and investments by reducing the taxable income.

18 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

4.2 Taxation of Business Entities

Taxation of Companies

Section 115BAA - Tax on income of certain domestic companies

Section 115BAA introduces a concessional tax regime for domestic companies,

providing a lower tax rate to enhance the ease of doing business. It aims to attract
investment and promote economic growth.

Section 234A - Interest for defaults in furnishing return of income

Section 234A imposes interest for defaults in furnishing tax returns. It encourages timely
filing of tax returns by imposing a financial penalty for delays.

Section 5: Recent Developments and Emerging Trends

5.1 Digital Economy and E-commerce

Equalization Levy

Finance Act, 2016 - Section 165

Section 165 of the Finance Act, 2016, introduced the Equalization Levy. This levy is
applicable at a specified rate on consideration received by a non-resident for specified
services, aimed at taxing digital transactions and ensuring a level playing field in the
digital economy.

5.2 International Taxation

Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS)

BEPS Action Plan Implementation in India

India has implemented various recommendations from the OECD's BEPS Action Plan to
curb tax evasion and profit shifting. These measures aim to align international tax rules

19 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

with economic substance, ensuring that profits are taxed where the economic activities
generating the profits are performed.

Case Law 1: Direct Taxes - Income Tax Act, 1961

Navin Jindal v. Income Tax Officer (2019)

Facts:

In this case, Navin Jindal, a prominent industrialist and politician, failed to file his income
tax returns within the stipulated time as required by Section 139 of the Income Tax
Act, 1961. The Income Tax Officer imposed penalties for non-compliance.

Legal Issues:

The primary legal issue was the enforcement of Section 139 and the imposition of
penalties for non-filing of tax returns within the prescribed time.

Court Ruling:

The Supreme Court affirmed the significance of timely filing of tax returns as mandated
by the Income Tax Act. The Court upheld the penalties imposed by the Income Tax
Officer, emphasizing that the provision was in place to ensure tax compliance and
discourage individuals from evading their tax obligations.

Implications:

This case reinforced the importance of complying with tax regulations and filing tax
returns within the specified timeframe. It established a precedent highlighting that non-
filing of tax returns could lead to legal consequences, encouraging individuals and
entities to adhere to tax compliance obligations.

Case Law 2: Corporate Taxation - Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT)

20 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CCE (2017)

Facts:

Apollo Tyres Ltd., a leading tire manufacturer, disputed the imposition of Minimum
Alternate Tax (MAT) under Section 115JB of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The company
argued that MAT should not apply if no regular tax was payable due to exemptions and
incentives.

Legal Issues:

The main issue was the applicability and scope of MAT under Section 115JB when
companies claim exemptions or incentives, resulting in no regular tax liability.

Court Ruling:

The Supreme Court ruled in favor of the tax authorities, affirming the applicability of
MAT even when companies avail exemptions and incentives. The Court held that MAT
was a valid provision to ensure that companies, despite exemptions, pay a minimum
amount of tax to prevent tax evasion.

Implications:

This case clarified the application of MAT, a crucial aspect of corporate taxation,
ensuring that companies contribute a minimum tax amount to the government, thereby
preventing the misuse of exemptions and incentives.

Case Law 3: Capital Gains Tax

CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty (1981)

Facts:

B.C. Srinivasa Setty, an individual taxpayer, relinquished his rights in a property in favor
of the tenant. The question was whether this relinquishment constituted a "transfer"
under Section 2(47) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, attracting capital gains tax.

21 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

Legal Issues:

The central issue was the interpretation of 'transfer' as defined in Section 2(47) and
whether the relinquishment of rights constituted a transfer for the purposes of capital
gains tax.

Court Ruling:

The Supreme Court held that the relinquishment of rights by the taxpayer in favor of the
tenant constituted a 'transfer' as per Section 2(47). This clarified that such transactions
attracted capital gains tax.

Implications:

This case set a significant precedent in the interpretation of 'transfer' for capital gains
tax purposes. It broadened the scope of what constituted a transfer, impacting how
gains arising from such transactions were taxed.

Case Law 4: Indirect Taxes - Goods and Services Tax (GST)

Commissioner of Central Tax v. Bhagyanagar Gas Limited (2020)

Facts:

Bhagyanagar Gas Limited, a company engaged in the supply of natural gas, was denied
input tax credit on certain transactions. The dispute revolved around the interpretation
of Section 16 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, related to input tax
credit.

Legal Issues:

The primary issue was the eligibility and conditions for claiming input tax credit under
Section 16 of the CGST Act.

Court Ruling:

22 | P a g e
TAXATION LAW

The Supreme Court interpreted Section 16 and ruled in favor of Bhagyanagar Gas
Limited, holding that they were eligible for input tax credit on the transactions in
question.

Implications:

This case provided clarity on the eligibility and conditions for claiming input tax credit, a
crucial aspect of the GST regime. It set a precedent for businesses regarding the proper
utilization of input tax credit.

Case Law 5: Taxation and Business - Tax Avoidance vs. Tax Evasion

Union of India v. Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003)

Facts:

Azadi Bachao Andolan, an organization, challenged the imposition of taxes on certain

transactions, contending that they were part of tax planning and not tax evasion.

Legal Issues:

The fundamental issue was to distinguish between legitimate tax planning and tax
evasion, focusing on the legality of the transactions in question.

Court Ruling:

The Supreme Court clarified the distinction between tax planning and tax evasion,
affirming the legality of tax planning within the framework of the Income Tax Act,
1961, while condemning tax evasion through colorable devices or dubious methods.

Implications:

This landmark case provided a significant precedent, emphasizing the legality of tax
planning while discouraging tax evasion through illegitimate means. It influenced tax
planning strategies and compliance practices, promoting tax compliance within the
ambit of the law.

23 | P a g e