Distribution Management Essentials
Distribution Management Essentials
Objectives
After completing this unit you should be able to:
     •        role of channel system as an important link between the manufacturer and the ultimate
              customer
Structure
1. Introduction to Distribution
4. Channels of Distribution
1. Direct Channel
2. Indirect Channel
6. Intermediaries
1. Wholesalers
         2.         Retailers
                                                        1
 7.     Factors determining choice of channels of distribution:
2. Company Characteristics
3. Competitive Factors
4. Market Forces
8. Distribution Strategies
9. Channel System
1. Traditional Elements
2. Emerging Elements
13. Summary
                                                    2
for products comprising of i.e. product, price, place and promotion (generally referred as 4P’s of
marketing mix). While the elements of services marketing does include the same four elements
i.e. product, price, place and promotion and an additional three more elements namely, physical
evidence, process and people (generally referred as 7P’s of service marketing).Which will be
discussed at length in Unit-13 of this course.
If you notice carefully at the elements of marketing mix of both products and services “Place” is
common to both. This suggests that “Place” play a pivotal role to sell the right product/service to
the right customer at right price at and at right time thus assumes significance to every marketer.
Therefore the focus of this unit will be on “Place” wherein all distribution activities and
functions focus on this aspect of the marketing mix. It is one link in the chain, which starts from
suppliers to manufacturers and finally to the point of sale.
Very often we come across that during festive season or on any other happy occasion we tend to
buy gifts for friends and relatives as we all believe in the joy of giving something to someone
near and dear on such joyful celebrations. Assume that your friends or relatives stay in another
city then what do you do? How do you send the gift to them? Yes, you do have a solution to
either send them by courier or by online delivery. Thus, a delivery company is a type of
distribution process. In the same way firms create a distribution system that enhances the reach
of the firm’s offerings to the end customer at the right place and right time which is at the core of
distribution.
                                                  3
Let’s look at a couple of definitions of distribution as per the American Marketing Association,
“distribution refers to the act of marketing and carrying products to consumers. It is also used to
describe the extent of market coverage for a given product. In the 4 Ps, distribution is represented
by the word place or placement”. According to Mossman & Norton “distribution is the operation
which creates time, place and form utility through the movement of goods and persons from one
place to another”.
To sum up, distribution management can be defined as a combination of all activities which
facilitates movement and co-ordination of supply and demand in creation of time, place and
possession utility in goods. It is the art and science of determining requirements, obtaining them,
distributing them and finally maintaining them in an operationally prepared condition. Therefore,
the broad range of activities concerned with the efficient movement of finished products from the
end of the production line to the consumer and also the movement of raw materials from the
source of supply to the beginning of the production line, fall under the domain of Distribution
Management (Fig 12.1)
Distribution Management
                                                 4
headquarters in Kolkata. To reach out to its customers, ITC has an unmatched distribution
network. Its products are available in 4.3 million retail shop/outlets/stores in India. ITC
constantly tries to make the products reach to the retailers as quickly as possible. ITC's
Paperboards and Specialty Papers Division has four manufacturing units, eight regional sales
offices and over sixty dealers in India. At the backend ITC sources good quality raw materials
from 17 states in India through its e-choupal network.
A good distribution system performs the following functions for the company;
   • It helps in tracking the growth and decline in demand of the company’s products/
          services.
      •   It enables to design and implement a joint marketing strategy with the distributor and
          retailers, like customising sales arguments, pricing and discount structures based on the
          local situation/conditions.
      •   The firm can give marketing support, product sales training, after sales support, etc., with
          the help of a good distribution network.
The objectives that need to be kept in mind viz., a viz., distribution are;
  i.      The major objective of distribution is getting the right goods to the right place at the right
          time at the least possible cost.
ii.       To fully make use of the available human and material resources to the maximum
          possible extent without wastage.
iii. To enhance the rapid growth and development of country and organization
Distribution channel has been defined by Hill, “Distribution channel consists of one or more
companies or individuals who participate in the flow of goods and services from the
manufacturer to the final user or consumer” (Hill, 2010.)
Producer of Soap
                                                  6
             Producer of Toothpaste
             Fig 12.2. No intermediary in the distribution process
       b) When there is a channel of distribution involving a retailer: In the above case, even
       if one intermediary (retailer), is involved, the process becomes simplified not only for the
       customer but also for the producer. The product can now be available to a larger number
       of customers, with less effort on the producer’s side.
                                                Retailer
       Producer                               (Soap, Rice,                         Customer
                                              Toothpaste)
Activity 1
a)   List down any six products of the top two FMCG companies in India. Keep in mind that
     these companies have rural as well as urban presence..
b)   Note down the places/ platforms from where you can purchase the products that you have
     listed.
c) Which places/ platforms give you the maximum convenience and why?
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………….
…………………………………………………………………………………………………….
                                                7
12.5    TYPES OF DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS
        1.         Direct Channel – When the producer or the manufacturer directly sells the goods
                   to the customers without involving any middlemen, it is known as direct channel
                   or zero-level channel. It is the simplest and the shortest mode of distribution.
                   Selling through post services, internet or door to door selling etc. are some of the
                   examples of this channel. Nykaa, Homeshop 18 etc. are cases of direct channel .
             (a)   Door to door selling: Very small companies or start-ups sell their products via
                   this method. You might have seen vendors selling “papad”, clothes etc. This
                   method of selling directly to customers is more common and visible in semi urban
                   and rural areas and also in big capital cities across India.
             (b)   Internet selling: Currently, this has become the most common phenomenon
                   among most of the marketers across sectors to tap tech savvy customers. In cases
                   where the target audience is approachable through internet, it is far easier for
                   companies than other methods. Generally it caters to those potential buyers who
                   are interested enough in the firm’s merchandise only approach the company. For
                   example, “HealthifyMe” is selling different types of salads for health conscious
                   people.
             (c)   Mail order selling: As the name suggests that the products are generally sold
                   through mails as they might not be readily available in local markets. In such
                   cases, the goods need to be durable, and of standardised qualities. The delivery
                   costs should also be considerably low. Mostly books and magazines are sold
                   through this method. E.g., Reader’s Digest.
             (d)   Company owned retail outlets: Instead of using other retailers to sell its products
                   to customers, company establishes its own company exclusive retail outlets to
                   cater to customer as one stop shop for all the its merchandise under one roof
                   examples are Raymond’s Shoppe, Calico Mills, Dell computers etc.
                                                    8
                       (e) Telemarketing: The products are promoted for selling through call centres over
                           outbound calls. Sometimes the company can receive calls on a helpline number
                           regarding their products demonstrated on television. These are inbound calls. For
                           example Home shop 18 etc.
                  a)    One Level channel: This channel involves the use of one middleman i.e. retailer
                        who in turn sells them to the ultimate customers. It is usually adopted for speciality
                        goods. For example – Tata sells its cars through company approved retailers.
                  b)    Two Level channel: Under this channel, wholesaler and retailer act as a link
                        between the manufacturer and the customer. This is the most commonly used
                        channel for distributing goods like soap, rice, wheat, clothes etc.
                  c)    Three Level channe: This level comprises of three middlemen i.e. agent,
                        wholesaler and the retailer. The manufacturers supply the goods to their agents who
                        in turn supply them to wholesalers and retailers. This level is usually used when a
                        manufacturer or farmers (growing dry fruits, saffron, etc.,) deals in limited products
                        and yet wants to cover a wide market.
12.6      INTERMEDIARIES
       As mentioned in the earlier section intermediaries can be an agent, a group of people or an
       organization that facilitates the flow of goods from the producer to the final consumer. They can
       be broadly classified as a) Agent middlemen and b) Merchant middlemen
                                                           9
1.Agent Middlemen: If you intend to sell or purchase property may be a flat or a house, generally
 you contact real estate agents who help you in selling or purchasing the desired property.
 Similarly when you want to purchase company stocks or shares from the market, you seek the
 help of brokers. Even online brokerage houses fall under this category. These are called agent
 middlemen. They do not take ownership of what they are selling. They earn money by charging
 a facilitation fee.
2.Merchant Middlemen: Merchants are a set of intermediaries like wholesalers and retailers, buy
 and re-sell their goods. They not only take the ownership of inventory, but they also bear the
 expense of storing and distributing the product. They charge a certain “mark-up” amount to the
 actual cost of the product. For example, they might have purchased a toothbrush at Rs. 20 and
 might sell you the toothbrush at Rs.25. This five rupee difference is called the mark-up which the
 middlemen earn in the transaction for all the tasks that he undertakes from buying to storing to
 distributing the product.
 12.6.1 Wholesalers
 The American Marketing Association has defined the wholesaler as “a business unit which buys
 and resells the merchandise to the retailers and the merchants or to the industrial,
 institutional and commercial users but does not sell insignificant amounts to the ultimate
 consumers.”
 Wholesalers are those merchants who act as intermediaries between the primary producers,
 manufacturers or importers, on one side, and retailers or industrial consumers on the other. They
 buy goods and commodities in large quantities with a view to selling them to retailers in smaller
 quantities. They assemble/collect merchandise from many sources, warehouse/store and regroup
 the goods for convenient buying by retailers. Thus wholesalers make it possible for the
 manufacturer to sell to a large number of retailers to whom the merchandise cannot be easily sold
 directly from the factory. In the light of the business activities they perform they play a dual role
 as a buyer and as well as seller.
                                                  10
The wholesaler performs the following important functions of marketing:
  i.  Assembling-The wholesaler collects varieties of product from different manufacturers
        and keeps them in stock for sale to the retailers at the time when they need them.
 ii.    Dispersion-The products assembled and stocked by the wholesalers are supplied to the
        retailers who may be widely scattered.
        Warehousing-The goods purchased by the wholesalers from the manufacturers and
 iii.
        producers have to be stocked in warehouses pending their sale to the retailers. The
        arrangement for such storage is the responsibility of the wholesalers.
iv.     Transportation-The wholesaler has to move the goods from the various factories to his
        own warehouse and from there to the retail stores. He may do so either by employing his
        own vans or by hiring public carriers or a combination of both.
 v.     Financing-The wholesaler in most cases provides goods on credit to the retailers based
        on the credit worthiness of the retailer.
vi.     Risk-assuming-The wholesaler by virtue of their business model do assume the risk
        arising out of the changes in prices and demand as also loss due to spoilage or destruction
        of goods in his warehouse.
        Grading and Packaging-The wholesaler has to sort out different grades of products
vii.
        according to quality and other considerations and pack the goods into smaller lots for
        retailers.
                                                    11
Services provided by wholesalers to the retailers include:
  i.   The retailer need not stock goods in unduly large proportions and can replenish his
        supplies from the wholesalers as and when necessary.
 ii.    The wholesalers provide goods to the retailers on credit and the retailers need not block
        their funds in idle inventories.
        The wholesalers generally specialise in a few lines of allied goods and try to obtain their
 iii.
        supplies from the best and the cheapest source. The advantages of such specialisation are
        passed on to the retailers in the form of lower prices or may in the form of discount and
        rebate.
iv.     The wholesaler assumes most of the risks involved in marketing functions such as price
        fluctuations and spoilage or pilferage of goods.
 v.     Wholesalers keep the retailer informed of the new types of products that are being
        introduced in the market. This gives the retailers an opportunity to extend their business.
Types of Wholesalers
Depending on the nature of the product/goods, type of industry and the type of market it caters
to, different types of wholesalers can be found. In highly fragmented industries as with
unbranded clothes or farm produce, there could even be different levels of wholesalers.
Wholesalers could also specialize in one function. For instance a wholesaler could specialize in
warehousing. Such a wholesaler maintains a big warehouse and specializes in the storage
function and depends on others for other functions such as transportation, financing insurance
etc.
Dibb et al. (2006) classify wholesalers into two broad classes- (i) merchant wholesalers and (ii)
agents and brokers.
Merchant wholesalers buy goods from manufacturers and sell them to retailers or industrial
buyers. Such wholesalers therefore take up the tide to the goods. This is an important function
that has to be performed for the flow of goods from the manufacturer to the ultimate customer.
                                                 12
 Merchant wholesalers can be classified as either full-service wholesalers or limited-service
 wholesalers. Some of the types of merchant wholesalers that are seen around the world are:
 These intermediaries are sometimes called desk jobbers. They do not take physical possession of
 the goods. They collect orders from retailers or industrial buyers and arrange for these to be
 transported to the customers from the manufacturer. The ownership of the goods will pass on to
 drop shippers from the time the contract is signed with the manufacturer, until the goods are
 received in proper condition by the buyer.
 Such wholesalers are typically seen in commodity markets, where transaction volumes are
 typically very large, such as markets for oil, coal, and iron ore. Drop shippers provide value by
                                                  14
linking several fragmented customers to suppliers who are often based in a totally different
continent.
Agents and brokers typically provide sales support for the manufacturers by offering the services
of a sales force network and related infrastructure. Agents and brokers thus enable manufacturers
to expand their markets without the overhead associated with establishing a sales force. Agents
could represent just one manufacturer or a group of manufacturers who have complementary
products. Clearing and forwarding (C&F) agents are quite common in Indian markets as they
provide a means to avoid multiple sales tax regimes.
Different types of wholesalers therefore facilitate the transactions between different players in
the market. They provide value by performing several activities that are important to the smooth
flow of goods and services from the manufacturer to the end consumer.
In certain industries, the nature of demand and supply provide opportunities for wholesalers to
grow in stature and become the most powerful entity in the market.
12.6.2 Retailers
A retailer is defined as "a middleman who sells mainly to the ultimate consumer. He may sell
to institutions but most of his sales are made to industrial or household consumers. He usually
sells in small lots".
The retailer is the last link and the most important intermediary in the chain of distribution. Mass
production in the present day set-up is geared to the requirements of the ultimate consumer.
Retailers are directly and intimately in touch with the ultimate consumers and thus occupy a
strategic position in the whole chain of distribution. The basic feature of retail trading is the
purchase of goods from wholesalers and selling it in small lots to consumers. Thus retailing
includes all activities directly related to the sale of goods to the ultimate consumers. The retail
shop is one of the oldest and most widely used business establishments in any country. Retail
business originated through the use of peddlers engaged in house to house sales. This was
                                               15 owned by sole proprietors or small
followed by opening up of small retail shops usually
 partnership firms, which are frequented by customers for obtaining their requirements. In course
 of time, large retail stores like department stores, co operative stores, super bazaar etc became
 popular in developing countries.
 In addition, people living in far off places are served by mail order houses who solicit business by
 catalogues, advertisement in popular magazines or correspondence. The latest development is
 retailing through automatic vending machines. Most standard items in standard packs including
 food items are available in most developed countries through automatic vending machines located
 at convenient places like railway stations. Air ports, commercial places etc. Milk-vending machines
 are now being used by Mother Dairy in India.
consumers
relieve the customers of the need for stocking a wide variety of goods which could be
                                                       16
  ii.   By keeping a good assortment of the various varieties of a particular product, say soaps,
        toothpastes, etc. retailers provide a wide variety of choice to their customers.
        By proper display of new products, the retailers keep the consumers informed about the
 iii.
        availability of new products and the variety of different goods.
iv.     Retailers very often guide their customers about the relative merits of the various brands
        of a particular product and thus help them in the selection of goods.
 v.     Retailers may provide special facilities to their customers, for example, free home
        delivery, extension of credit, after-sales service, etc.
• Economical Buying-wholesalers know what, when and how much the retailers
will buy.
amount and frequency of retailer's orders, he can plan his operation in the most
                economical manner.
           •    Economy in selling because the effort involved in selling is substantially reduced.
           •    Economy in office and administrative expenses-the work involved can be better
                planned and organised.
           •    Reduced wholesale expenses permit the wholesalers to quote lower prices to
                retailers and this in turn permits a reduction in retail prices which ultimately
                benefit the consumers
Type of Retailers
There is a wide variety of retail trading establishments. They vary from hawkers and peddlers to
big departmental stores. Hawkers and peddlers move from door-to-door in residential localities
to sell their goods. Pavement shops usually arrange their wares at busy street corners or
pavements of busy streets. Some traders sell their wares at weekly markets which are very
common in rural India, and are not uncommon in urban centers. For example, in every state
                                                   17
capital and in other major locations of every city weekly markets is a common sight. Then there
are fixed shop retailers who operate from shops in busy markets or even in residential areas.
These stores may be either general stores dealing in a wide variety of goods needed by
consumers in their day to day requirement or may be shops dealing in a particular item, as for
example, cloth, shoes, building materials, electrical goods, confectionary, etc. Stores dealing in a
particular line may further specialise, as for example, children's wear in clothing. Then there may
be bigger stores like departmental stores and multiple shops. As all of us are familiar with small
scale retail establishments and their modus operandi, we will confine our discussion to a limited
variety of large-scale establishments.
a) Department Stores
Thus department stores are characterized by their wide product mixes. That is, they carry many
different types of merchandise, which may include clothing, appliances and other items. The
display of this merchandise is done separately within the store. The depth of the product mix
depends on the store, but department stores’ primary uniqueness is the ability to provide a wide
range of products within a single store. For example, if you visit Big Bazaar, you can shop for
clothes, vegetables, utensils, consumer durables, and groceries etc., all in one store/shop.
                                                 18
Advantages
1. Department stores make shopping convenient to consumers by providing them a
turnover. Thus they can afford to make large profits even with smaller margins.
manufacturers and thus buy at a cheaper rate. There are savings in freight charges as
well.
4. Department stores can afford to have effective advertising through press, radioand
television and thus they are able to attract more and more customers.
5. Being large business units, department stores can afford to employ skilled and expert
staff for all their operations and thus they are able to achieve a high degree of
Disadvantages;
   1. The running costs for such establishments are relatively high, as they are centrally
located.
While a chain store is a retail company having more than one branch in one city/ town. Since
there are many retail points of one chain, the retailer gets the advantage of bulk purchasing.
Therefore, they can substantially lower the prices as compared to retailers who have only one
shop or unit. Furthermore, chains were able to attract many customers because of their
convenient locations, made possible by their financial resources and expertise in selecting
locations. For example 7-Eleven, Easy Day, etc.
Advantages
       1.    Multiple shops are able to offer lower prices due to the economics of bulk buying.
       2.    As sales are on cash basis, losses on bad debts are eliminated and accounting is also
             made simpler.
       3.    Rapid turnover and common advertising and promotion strategy for all shops/retail
             outlets make their operations more economical.
       4.    Any shortage of goods faced by one branch can be easily made up by transfer from
             some other branch in the same city.
       5.    Since advertising material and interior layout of each shop is Similar, each shop
             serves to advertise the other shops. This leads to further economy in advertising and
a quicker turnover.
                                                20
Disadvantages
c)   Supermarkets
 Supermarkets are large, self-service stores with central checkout facilities. They carry a wide
range of food items and often non-food products. Supermarkets’ entire approach to the
distribution of food and household cleaning and maintenance products is to offer large
assortments of these goods at each store at a minimal price. For example, Reliance Fresh Stores,
Advantages;
  1. The product assortment is large. A customer can get most of their daily need products at
one place.
shopping.
d)        Discount Retailers
Discount retailers, like Wal-Mart are characterized by their emphasis on price as their main sales
appeal. The assortments in merchandise have a wide range, but most popular items in terms of
                                                21 basis. The stores are large, have adequate
size, colour and packaging are stored on a priority
space for browsing, are open for longer hours, have self-service and facilities like free parking,
etc. Online retailers such as ebay.com, Flipkart have aggregated products and offered them at
deep discounts.
Advantages;
   1.   As the name suggests, the major advantage is in terms of much reduced retail prices.
   2.   All popular items are available, with adequate space for browsing.
Disadvantage;
   1. Only popular items are stocked. Products which are less in demand might not be available.
e)   Warehouse Retailers
 Warehouse retailers provide a bare-bones shopping experience at very low prices. Warehouse
retailers streamline all operational aspects of their business and pass on the efficiency savings to
customers. For example, Costco generally uses a cost-plus pricing structure and provides goods
in wholesale quantities. In India we do not have this format of retailers, although Best Buy can
be a close substitute.
Advantages;
   1.   Products are available in bulk and bulk purchases are encouraged.
   2.   Cost effective.
Disadvantage;
   1.   These stores are not commonly available as they require huge spaces.
   2.   They are generally on the outskirts of towns and cities, so people have to travel long
        distances.
f) Franchises:
The franchise approach brings together national chains and local ownership. An owner purchases
a franchise which gives him the right to use the firm’s business model and brand for a set period
of time. Often, the franchise agreement includes well-defined code of conduct for the owner,
                                                22
training to the staff, and on-going support by the company to the franchiser. The owner, or
franchisee, builds and manages the local business. For example McDonald’s, KFC etc.
Advantages;
   1.   It helps in wider availability of stores.
   2.   Since a code of conduct has to be followed, these stores provide standardized and good
        services.
Disadvantage;
   1. They operate for a set period and in case of disputes with the owner, the shops may have
to close operations.
of products across many stores. If you want to buy a suit or a dress, a mall provides many
alternatives in one location. In big malls in Northern India, like Great India Place, or Select City
Walk, etc you will find many department stores like Spencer’s, Big Bazaar, etc. Strip malls are a
common string of stores along major traffic routes like national highways, while isolated
locations are freestanding sites not necessarily in heavy traffic areas. Stores in remote locations
must use promotion or some other facet of their marketing mix to appeal shoppers.
Advantages;
   1.   The customers can avail greater variety.
   2.   People can shop even while travelling as some malls are located on highways, major
        traffic routes and outskirts of the main city.
Disadvantages;
   1. It cannot be accessed by all the customers. Some less educated customers might not feel
h) Online Retailing:
Online retailing is indisputably a dominant force in the retail industry. Companies like Amazon,
Myntra, etc., complete all or most of their sales online. Many established retailers have also
started their online portal to sell their products. For example Pantaloons have their own retail
                                                  23
outlets in major cities. They have an online platform pantaloons.com, to reach out to those
2. There is wider reach, as customers in distant places can also access the site for shopping/
browsing.
Disadvantage;
   1.   It requires an active internet connection.
   2.   Computer literacy and a certain level of education is a required for shopping online.
i)   Non-store Retailing:
Beyond those mentioned in the categories above, there’s a wide range of traditional and
innovative retailing approaches. Vending machines and point-of-sale kiosks have long been a
popular retail device. Today they are becoming more targeted, such as companies selling easily
forgotten items such as small electronics devices and makeup items to travelers in airports.
Each of these retailing approaches can be customized to meet the needs of the target buyer or
combined to span a range of needs.
Advantage;
   1.   These stores are conveniently located.
   2.   It is good for travelers, in case they have forgotten to pack any gadget or want to
        purchase gifts.
Disadvantage;
   1. These are mainly for urban customers.
To sum up, wholesalers and retailers provide a variety of functions. There are different types of
retailers and wholesalers. Almost all of them provide the functions summarized through a flow
chart in the following figure;
                                                 24
7.        FACTORS DETERMINING CHOICE OF CHANNELS OF DISTRIBUTION
The choice of channel decision is important for two reasons. The costs involved in the use of a
channel enter the price that the consumer has to pay. The channel decision also has a bearing on
other marketing decisions like price of the product and its availability, product line etc. Through
proper market feedback, an appropriate selection of channels can reduce fluctuations in
production. A rational decision regarding choice of channels of distribution should ensure (a)
maximum geographical coverage of the market, (b) maximum promotional efforts and (c)
minimum cost. Thus, choice of distribution channel depends on a variety of factors these can be
product related, company related, market related or competitor related factors. Each of the
factors has been explained in the following sub sections.
     a)   Nature of Product – In case of industrial goods like heavy machinery, radiator, power
          generator etc. short channels like zero level channel or first level channel should be
          preferred because they are usually technical, expensive, made to order and purchased by
          few buyers. Consumer goods like televisions (LEDs), refrigerator can be distributed
          through long channels as they are less expensive, not technical and frequently purchased.
                                                  25
      b)   Perishable and Non-Perishable Products – Perishable products like fruits or vegetables
           are circulated through short channels while non-perishable products like soaps, oils,
           sugar, salt etc. require longer channels.
      c)   Value of Product – In case of products having low unit value such as groceries, long
           channels are preferred while those with high unit value such as diamond jewellery short
           channels are used.
      d)   Product Complexity – Short channels are preferred for technically complex goods like
           industrial or engineering products like machinery, generators like torches while non-
           complex or simple ones can be distributed through long channels.
2.        Company Characteristics:
     a)Financial Strength – The companies having huge funds at their disposal go for direct
b)Control – Short channels are used if management wants greater control on the channel
3.         Competitive Factors
       Policies and channels selected by the competitors also affect the choice of channels. An
enterprise has to decide whether to adopt the same channel as that of its competitor or select
a different one. For example, if Nokia has selected a particular channel say Big Bazaars for
sale of their hand sets, other firms like Samsung and LG have also selected comparable
channels.
4.         Market Factors
      b)   Size of Market – If the number of customers is small like in case of industrial goods, short
           channels are preferred while if the number of customers is high as in case of convenience
           goods, long channels are used.
      c)   Geographical Concentration – Generally, long channels are used if the consumers are
           widely spread while if they are located in a small place, short channels can be used.
      d)   Quantity Purchased – Long channels are used in case the size of order is small while in
                                                       26
           case of large orders, direct channel may be used.
                   Fig 12.5 Channel options in consumer goods market
                                                            1             2
                                                                                          3                       4                            5
SALE
                                                                                          SALE
                                                                          6                                                         AGENT
SALE
                                                                                                                                               SALE
                                                                                                        AGENT
SHORT
                                                                                                                                                                         LONG CHANNELS
           CHANN       OWN SHOP OR                                                    WHOLESALER
            ELS        MAIL ORDER
                                                                                                                                       WHOLESALER
SALE
SALE
                                                                                                                                                              INDIRECT
                                              BIGGER
                            DIRECT
                                              REATAILERS
                                                                                         RETAILER
                                                                       WHOLESALER                                           RETAILER
                                                 INDIRECT
INDIRECT
                                                                                                 INDIRECT
                                                                                                                                                          RETAILER
                                                                                                                                    INDIRECT
                               MANUFACTURER OF INDUSTRIAL
                               GOODS    CONSUMERS
                                                                                                                                       SALE
                                                                           SALE
                                                                                             AGENTS
                                                                SALE
                                                                                                                                                                         CHANNELS
                                                                                                                                                                         LONG
                                                                                                                                AGENTS
        CHANNELS
                                                                                                            INDIRECT SALE
         SHORT
INDIRECT
                                                                  INDUSTRIAL
                                                                  DISTRIBUTORS
                                                                                                                                           INDUSTRIAL
                                                                          INDIRECT
                                                                                                                                           DISTRIBUTORS
                                     DIRECT
BUYERS
                                                                                        27
products available at selected places only. Depending upon the need the overall marketing
strategy, the distribution strategy is developed. The different strategies are as follows;
context refers to wholesale and when the firm decides to sell its products in a huge quantity.
Also, mass distribution means the company does not provide specific retailers or shops where
they sell the product. For example, different snacks and drinks outlets. You can see in different
   b) Selective Strategies
In this case, companies decided to sell their products in very limited stores. When special
services are needed, e.g., certain cosmetics to be sold only through chemists, we have selective
distribution. The number of outlets at each level of distribution is limited in a given geographic
area. If the product has long useful life and consumer brand preference can be established,
   c) Exclusive Strategies
If the buyers are demanding and expect considerable product service, the company opts for
given market. Such a system is very useful for consumer speciality goods and industrial
products. For example, Rolls Royce has very few showrooms all over India. To maintain the
Activity 2
        a) List down all the places/outlets where you28can purchase the following items;
                        1.    Pond’s cold cream/lotion
                        2.    Centre Fruit chewing gum
                    3.   Amul Butter (100gm)
                    4.   Apple MacBook
                    5.   Redmi mobile phones
                    6.   Mercedez-Benz Cars
   c)          What are the reasons for some of the above products are available in some places
        and not in other places? Explain
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        …………………………………………………...........................................................
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        ………………………………………………………………………………………………
        …………………………………………………………………………………………….
        …………………………………………………………………………………………….
                                                29
contractual agreement. One channel member owns the other, has contracts with them so that
they all co-operate. The member who has authority over all the others members can be the
manufacturer, wholesaler or the retailer. They work in cohesion, and there will be no
conflicts whatsoever between channel members. This type of channel came into existence to
avoid disagreements and conflicts among channel member. As independent members try to
force their influence to meet their objectives, there is always a possibility of conflict and
powerful channel member influencing the other. Once the channel operates as a one system
and is managed by one member, there is much clarity and coordination among channel
members to achieve the channel objectives. For example, Ikea, Starbucks, etc. The
economies are achieved through size, bargaining power and elimination of duplicated
services. To sum up a vertical marketing system is the type of cooperation between the
members of a distribution channel. It includes a producer, wholesaler, and retailer
collaborating to deliver customers the necessary product and aims at achieving better
efficiency and economies of scale.
                                             30
12.10 CHANNEL CONFLICT
Even when a company has set up an effective distribution system, some friction may arise
between the channel members or between the company and channel members. This happens
generally due to conflicting business interest. There are generally three types of channel conflict;
   a)       Vertical Channel conflict: It is the conflict between different levels in the same channel.
            For example, conflict between distributor and retailer.
   b)       Horizontal channel conflict: It occurs between members at the same level of the
            distribution channel. For example, two retailers may have a conflict if they target the
            same customers by giving price cuts.
      c)    Multi-channel conflict: When the company selects, two or more channels to sell its
            product in the same market. A company may sell its product to wholesalers and some
            important retailers simultaneously in one market. Here the wholesaler may feel that the
            company is not giving him sufficient attention and is bypassing him.
                                                     31
     v.        Change Resistant: When the channel leader plans to modify the distribution channel, the
               intermediaries may or may not accept this change. Thus, it may result in a condition of
               discord or non-cooperation.
vi.            Improper Geographic or Demographic Distribution: If the sales territory has a narrow
               consumer base, and the channel leader allows many selling partners, they tend to lose
interest.
      a)       Mediation, Arbitration and Diplomacy: To resolve a dispute, the manufacturer can adopt
               a strategy of intervention where a third person intervenes to create harmony. The other
               option is arbitration, where an arbitrator listens to the argument of the parties involved in
               a conflict and declares a decision. Alternatively, the parties can resort to diplomacy
               where the representatives of both the parties discuss and find an amicable solution.
      b)       Co-optation: The manufacturer should hire an expert who has already gained experience
               in managing the channel conflicts in other organizations, as a member of the grievance
               redressal committee or board of directors, for addressing such conflicts.
      c)       Dealer Councils and Trade Associations: To handle the horizontal or vertical conflicts,
               the manufacturer forms a dealer council where the dealers can unanimously put up their
               problems and grievances in front of the channel leader. To bring in unity among the
               channel partners or intermediaries, they can be added as members in trade association
               which safeguards their interests.
      d)       Superior Goals: Establishing a supreme goal of the organization and aligning it with the
               individual goals or objectives of the channel partners may reduce the channel conflicts.
      e)       Regular Communication: The channel leader should take regular feedback from the
               channel partners through formal and informal meetings to know about market trends and
               dynamics. In addition, the channel partner’s issues and conflicts can be addressed through
               frequent interactions.
          f)   Legal Procedure: When the conflict is critical and uncontrollable by the channel leader,
               the aggrieved party can seek legal action, by filing a lawsuit against the accused party.
                                                        32
        g) Fair Pricing: Most of the channel conflicts are a result of the price war, and therefore,
           these can be resolved by ensuring that products have the same price in all the territories
           and a fair margin is given to the channel partners.
 iv.       Product disruptions include product recalls, packaging issues and quality control issues.
           Buyer disruptions include order changes, shipment address changes and product returns.
                                                       33
1.        Traditional Elements:
     i.   Supply Chain- A supply chain is defined as the entire process of making and selling
          commercial goods, including every stage from the supply of materials and the
          manufacture of the goods through to their distribution and final sale. This term was
          coined by Keith Oliver in 1982. APICS, the global association for supply chain
          management professionals, defines supply chain management as: “the design, planning,
          execution, control, and monitoring of supply chain activities with the objective of
          creating net value, building a competitive infrastructure, leveraging worldwide logistics,
          synchronizing supply with demand, and measuring performance globally.”
 ii.      Logistics- It is the business of transporting, supplying and delivering goods. Michigan
          State University’s professors (2020) define logistics as activities which include
          transportation, warehousing, packaging and more – that move and position inventory and
          acknowledge its role in terms of synchronizing the supply chain.
          Purchase order and invoicing system -The creation of a purchase order is the first step in
 iii.
          a business transaction, it is issued by the buyer and authorizes a seller to provide a
          product or service at a specified price. The invoice is a bill issued by the seller when that
          product has been delivered or the service has been completed.
2. Emerging elements:
     i.   Block Chain- Block chain can enable more transparent and accurate end-to-end tracking
          in the supply chain: Organizations can digitize physical assets and create a decentralized
          immutable record of all transactions, making it possible to track assets from production to
          delivery or use by end user.
 ii.      VRM- Vendor relationship management (VRM) is a category of business activity made
          possible by software tools that aim to provide customers with both independence from
          vendors and better means for engaging with vendors. These same tools can also apply to
          individuals' relations with other institutions and organizations.
                                                   34
        CRM- CRM stands for Customer Relationship Management. It's a technology tool used
 iii.
        to manage interactions with customers and potential customers. A CRM system helps
        organisations build customer relationships and streamline processes so they can increase
        sales, improve customer service, and increase profitability.
iv.     IMS- An inventory management system (or inventory system) is the process by which
        you track your goods throughout your entire supply chain, from purchasing to production
        to end sales. It governs how you approach inventory management for your business.
vi.     TMS- A transportation management system (TMS) is a logistics platform that uses
        technology to help businesses plan, execute, and optimize the physical movement of
        goods, both incoming and outgoing, and making sure the shipment is compliant, proper
        documentation is available.
12.13 SUMMARY
 Distribution is an important component of the marketing mix. For an effective implementation
 of the marketing activities, distribution plays an important role. The channel intermediaries,
 namely the wholesalers, retailers, jobbers, C &F agents etc, facilitate the smooth movement of
 goods and services from the manufacturers to the ultimate consumers.
 As the marketing landscape has changed over the years, the roles and responsibilities of
 intermediaries has also changed. Some traditional channels have graduated to modern retail
 concepts like hypermarkets, chain stores etc. Internet technology has been a great disrupter as
 well as enabler in better distribution.
 Supply Chain management has evolved as a fully fledged discipline so also Customer
 Relationship Management, Transport Management are the evolving disciplines in these
 changing times.
                                                  35
12.14 SELF-ASSESSMENT TEST
1. How does distribution add value to the marketing efforts? Take the case of any FMCG
   company and explain the distribution network in urban as well as rural areas.
2. Describe the importance of wholesalers in the distribution process. Explain with the help of
   suitable examples from the textile industry.
3. “The retailing landscape has changed drastically with the advent of digital age”. Elucidate
   citing relevant examples.
4. What are the challenges and opportunities faced by distributors in developing countries? How
   is the distribution system in India different from any developed nation like the USA?
5. Describe the concept of channel systems. Different channel systems can exist within the same
   company leading to Channel conflict. Explain the causes of channel conflict and suggest ways
   of resolution of such conflicts with suitable examples.
6. What kind of distribution channel (direct or indirect) would you recommend for each of these
   products and why?
   a)   Health Drink
   b)   A new, exclusive, premium priced range of sanitary fittings (such as wash basins, bath
        tubs, etc.).
   c)   Textile machinery
   d)   Branded spices
   e)   Industrial lubricant.
                                                                                           wishes
 7. A new toy manufacturing company is planning to launch its toys in the market and
                                                                                         selecting
   to appoint retail outlets in all the major towns. What should be the criteria for
   appropriate outlets? Specify the distinct attributes or features that the
                                                                              company should look
   for in the retail outlets.
                                                  36
12.15 FURTHER READINGS
  2. Krishna K Havaldar and Vasant M Cavale, Sales and Distribution Management, Tata
     McGraw Hill, 2nd Edition, 2011.
  3. Ramendra Singh: sales and distribution management: a practice-based approach, Vikas
     Publication, 2016.
37