Electrocardiography in Rats: A Comparison To Human
Electrocardiography in Rats: A Comparison To Human
933270
REVIEW
P. KONOPELSKI1, M. UFNAL1
1
 Department of Experimental Physiology and Pathophysiology, Laboratory of Centre for Preclinical
Research, Medical University of Warsaw, Warsaw, Poland
                                                                                      1
Heart rate in beats per minute (bpm), other parameters in milliseconds (ms).              – QTc calculated by Fridericia formula,
2
  – QTc calculated by Bazett’s formula.
Table 2. The effect of anesthetics on ECG parameters in Sprague-Dawley and Wistar rats.
 Sprague-Dawley
 Light ether                            340-508                 48-70                11.3-16.1              50-70
 Ketamine and xylazine                  239-272                 56-66                12-15.7                -
 Urethane                               417-451                 48-56                18.5-21.5              60.6-62.5
 Pentobarbital                          387-446                 38-44                20-22                  63-74
 Wistar
 Light ether                            290-378                 52-78                18-28                  57-75
 Ketamine and xylazine                  242-336                 39-57                17-25                  75-95
 Urethane                               357-452                 49-58                14-16                  -
 Pentobarbital                          334-349                 -                    18-19.6                69-76
Heart rate in beats per minute (bpm), other parameters in milliseconds (ms).
sufficient for the general analysis of ECG parameters in             mediastinum. Data from transmitters are gathered
rodents (Farraj et al. 2011, Buschmann et al. 1980),                 wirelessly by a receiver positioned outside the rat cage
whereas precordial leads are used to localize pathological           (Sgoifo et al. 1998). This enables measurements in freely
processes such as myocardial ischemia (Krenek et al.                 moving rats for several weeks. The method provides data
2009).                                                               that are free of anesthesia and stress-induced artefacts
                                                                     (Braga et al. 2011). However, the quality of the
Invasive methods                                                     recordings may be compromised by movement of
         Surface ECG recording is the most commonly                  animals, displacement of the electrodes or inflammation
used technique in anesthetised rats. To obtain a limb                at the site of electrode implantation.
leads recording, the electrodes are placed under the skin                      An in vitro method for recording the electric
of left and right forepaws and the tail. Additionally,               activity from the isolated heart is the method introduced
unipolar leads can be positioned anteriorly at the                   by the Langendorff in 1898. The heart is extracted form
midsternum (Normann et al. 1961). Advantages of this                 terminally anesthetized rat and placed into a perfusion
method include its simplicity, high quality of collected             apparatus. The heart is perfused with a perfusion fluid
data and repeatability, while its main drawback is that              under       physiological     pressures,   keeping     the
measurements may be confounded by anesthetics.                       electromechanical work of the myocardium, functions of
         An ECG recording technique that escapes the                 the valves and coronary blood flow. Advantages of this
effect of anesthesia is telemetry. Telemetry transmitters            technique include a precise recording of the origin and
are implanted subcutaneously in the interscapular region             amplitude of electrical events as well as possibility of
or in the abdominal cavity, whereas electrodes connected             concomitant evaluation of the coronary blood flow and
to the transmitters are placed subcutaneously on the                 contractility of the myocardium. The advantages,
dorsal surface of the xiphoid process and anterior                   however, are limited by the fact that the isolated heart is
2016                                                                                                      ECG in Rats   719
separated from physiological effects of humoral and             and Purkinje fibres, finally reaching ventricular
nervous control (Skrzypiec-Spring 2007, Döring 1989).           cardiomyocytes. A typical ECG tracing mirrors the
                                                                repeating cycle of three major electrical events, including
The effect of anesthesia on ECG                                 atrial depolarization (P wave), ventricular depolarization
         The choice of anesthesia may significantly affect      (QRS complex) and ventricular repolarization (T wave),
the results of experiments, as anesthetics differ in their      (Fig. 1).
effects on cardiomyocytes and conducting system of the
heart. For example, it has been found that inhalation           Heart rate and RR interval
anesthetics may have an arrhythmogenic potential.                         Heart rate (HR) represents the number of heart
Halotane, isoflurane, and enflurane have been shown to          contractions over a specific period of time, most
block Ca2+ channels and Na+/Ca2+ exchange in                    commonly 1 min (beats per minute, bpm). RR interval is
cardiomyocytes (Mayo and Jamali 1999). Cardiotoxic              the time between the consecutive R wave peaks. Under
effects have also been reported after parenteral                physiological conditions, HR can be calculated from RR
anesthesia. Urethane anesthetised rats show a significant       interval according to the following formula: HR=60/(R-R
depression of HR, whereas the effect is not observed in         interval in seconds). In humans HR can also be calculated
rats treated with pentobarbital and thiopental.                 by measuring the time between the consecutive Q waves,
Pentobarbital, however, was found to evoke ventricular          while in rats HR is calculated using RR intervals only.
arrhythmias. In contrast, thiopental was found to possess       This is because rat ECG lacks the Q wave in most leads
antiarrhythmic activity (Zorniak et al. 2010). Ketamine,        and/or the Q wave may be difficult to locate, especially in
another commonly used anesthetic drug, apart from its           noisy and low amplitude ECG.
anti-NMDA activity, interacts with cardiac voltage-                       Mammals have a wide distribution of resting RR
sensitive Ca2+ channels that may also significantly affect      interval. For an adult human, resting RR interval ranges
the electrical activity of cardiomyocytes (Hirota and           from 0.6-1 s (HR≈60-100 bpm) (Hall et al. 2011),
Lambert 1996, Baum and Tecson 1991), (Table 2).                 whereas for matured rats RR interval is 118-251 ms
                                                                (HR≈239-508), (Table 1). In rats HR depends on age, and
Non-invasive systems                                            it has been found to increase during the first 4 weeks after
          An example of a non-invasive method of ECG            the birth (Malfatto et al. 1990, Dickhout and Lee 1998).
recordings is dressing rats in a cotton jacket with two         In newborn restrained Wistar rats, HR is 298-306 bpm
electrodes attached to its inner surface. Before wearing        and then reaches steady values of 429-473 bpm just
the coat, rats’ skin must be shaved in anterior thoracic        before puberty (Malfatto et al. 1990). Therefore, in
region. Measurements are performed in conscious rats            contrast to humans, there seems to be no clear negative
placed in plastic restrainers (Pereira-Junior et al. 2010).     correlation between HR and aging before puberty in rats.
Advantages of this technique include non-invasiveness,          On the other hand, a decrease in HR with aging was
measurements in conscious animals and a significantly           found in postpubertal Wistar rats using chronic telemetry
lower cost in comparison to telemetry. Nevertheless,            recording (Sgoifo et al. 1998).
restraint-stress and difficulties with placing the electrodes             HR seems to be strongly affected by the type of
in the same position in different rats are significant          anesthesia used. In SD rats anesthetised with ketamine
limitations of the method.                                      and xylazine mixture, light ether, urethane and
          Another method is a non-invasive ECG                  pentobarbital heart rate was found to be 239-272 bpm
recording in conscious rats placed in a restrainer also         (Regan et al. 2005, Regan et al. 2007), 340-508 bpm
referred as a tunnel. In this technique paws of the rat are     (Normann et al. 1961), 417-451 bpm (Lin et al. 1997),
placed on ECG sensors embedded in the tunnel floor.             and 387-446 bpm (Sugiyama et al. 2005), respectively.
After short adaptation period up to 6 lead ECG, lasting         HR in Wistar rats was reported as 242-336 bpm under
30-60 min, can be obtained (Mongue-Din et al. 2007).            ketamine and xylazine anesthesia (Miranda et al. 2007),
                                                                290-378 bpm under light ether anesthesia (Fraser et al.
Electrocardiographic parameters                                 1967), 357-452 bpm under urethane anesthesia
         An action potential in the heart is generated in       (Buschmann et al. 1980), and 334-349 bpm in rats
sinoatrial node and subsequently conducted through              anesthetised with pentobarbital (Ahmad et al. 2015).
atrioventricular node, His bundle, His bundle branches
720   Konopelski and Ufnal                                                                                           Vol. 65
undergoing light ether anesthesia the duration of                 T wave may result from myocardial infarction and
ST segment was reported to be 12.3-18.1 ms (Kelishomi             pulmonary embolism.
et al. 2008), while in Wistar rats anesthetized with ether it              Rat ECG shows the upright T wave in limb
was 9.58-14.8 ms (Dragojevic-Simic et al. 2004).                  lead II. Inversion of the parameter in rat ECG was
However, the length of ST segment is of limited                   reported after injection of isoproterenol and myocardial
importance for ECG analysis. First, it is difficult to detect     infarction (Hill et al. 1960). Hypokalaemia in rats was
ST segment in rat ECG as the T wave often rises in                found to produce prolongation and decrease in voltage of
continuity with the S wave (Sambhi and White 1960,                T wave (Akita et al. 1998).
Jensen et al. 1984) (Fig. 1). Second, the prolongation of
ST segment lengthens QT (RT) intervals. Therefore, it is          QT interval
more convenient to analyse the two latter parameters                        QT interval describes the time from the Q wave
rather than ST segment.                                           to the end of the T wave. In rats, this parameter
                                                                  is usually measured from the onset of Rs complex to the
                                                                  end of T wave, due to difficulties with detecting Q waves.
                                                                  QT interval represents the time of depolarization and
                                                                  repolarization      of     ventricular     cardiomyocytes.
                                                                  Pathological duration of this parameter indicates
                                                                  disturbances in electrical activity of the heart due to
                                                                  an intrinsic heart disease or toxic effects of exogenous
                                                                  compounds. For example, QT interval may be prolonged
                                                                  by hypokalaemia, ischemia, myocardial infarction,
                                                                  channelopathies, including Long QT syndrome. Finally,
                                                                  multiple drugs may produce prolongation of QT interval
                                                                  leading to ventricular tachyarrhythmia, including torsade
                                                                  de pointes. Therefore, the prolonged QT interval is
                                                                  considered to be a useful indicator of drug cardiotoxicity
                                                                  (Hanada et al. 1999, Roden et al. 2004). Interestingly,
                                                                  sex-related differences have been observed in
                                                                  susceptibility to drug-induced arrhythmias in both
                                                                  humans and laboratory animals (Makkar et al. 1993, Liu
                                                                  et al. 1999).
                                                                            A number of studies have shown that cardiotoxic
                                                                  drugs prolong QT interval in rodents, and ECG recording
                                                                  in rats has been used as a screening tool in cardiotoxicity
                                                                  studies (Hanada et al. 1999, Ohtani et al. 1996, Król et al.
                                                                  2016). However, it needs to be stressed that the
Fig. 1. Original recording of human (a) and Wistar rat (b) ECG,
II limb lead. RR interval in humans in seconds, in rats in
                                                                  translation of the results of those studies to humans has
milliseconds. Q waves and ST segments in rats are difficult to    limitations. This is because rats’ hearts do not express the
detect.                                                           human Ether-à-go-go-Related Gene (hERG), whereas
                                                                  drugs cardiotoxicity is strongly associated with blocking
T wave                                                            of hERG-related potassium channels (De Bruin et al.
         T wave reflects repolarization of the ventricles.        2005). However, the rats’ hearts express a variant of
The T wave has a positive deflection in the majority of           Ether-à-go-go-Related Gene (rat ERG, also known as
leads including limb lead II. In humans, high                     Kcnh2) (Matus et al. 2015), which may play a role in
voltage/peaking of T wave may be found in                         drug induced cardiotoxicity, but further research is
hyperkalaemia, in early phases of acute myocardial                needed to support this notion.
infarction and in patients with Long QT Syndrome.                           A prolonged QT interval in rats has also been
A decreased amplitude of the T wave may be present in             found in hypokalaemia (Akita et al. 1998) and
hypokalaemia, whereas a negative deflection of the                myocardial infarction (Mackiewicz et al. 2014).
722   Konopelski and Ufnal                                                                                       Vol. 65
References
AHMAD A, SATTAR MZ, RATHORE HA, KHAN SA, LAZHARI MA, HASHMI F, ABDULLAH NA, JOHNS EJ:
       Impact of Isoprenaline and Caffeine on development of left ventricular hypertrophy and renal hemodynamic in
       Wistar Kyoto rats. Acta Pol Pharm 72: 1015-1026, 2015.
AHNVE S: Correction of the QT interval for heart rate: review of different formulas and the use of Bazett's formula in
       myocardial infarction. Am Heart J 109: 568-574, 1985.
AKITA M, KUWAHARA M, TSUBONE H, SUGANO S: ECG changes during furosemide-induced hypokalemia in
       the rat. J Electrocardiol 31: 45-49, 1998.
ATLI O, ILGIN S, ALTUNTAS H, BURUKOGLU D: Evaluation of azithromycin induced cardiotoxicity in rats. Int J
       Clin Exp Med 8: 3681-3690, 2015.
BADOLE SL, JANGAM GB, CHAUDHARI SM, GHULE AE, ZANWAR AA: L-glutamine supplementation prevents
       the development of experimental diabetic cardiomyopathy in streptozotocin-nicotinamide induced diabetic rats.
       PloS One 9: e92697, 2014.
BAILLARD C, MANSIER P, ENNEZAT PV, MANGIN L, MEDIGUE C, SWYNGHEDAUW B, CHEVALIER B:
       Converting enzyme inhibition normalizes QT interval in spontaneously hypertensive rats. Hypertension 36:
       350-354, 2000.
BAUM VC, TECSON ME: Ketamine inhibits transsarcolemmal calcium entry in guinea pig myocardium: direct
       evidence by single cell voltage clamp. Anesth Analg 73: 804-807, 1991.
BAZETT HC: An analysis of the time-relations of electrocardiograms. Heart 7: 353-370, 1920.
BEINFIELD WH, LEHR D: PR interval of the rat electrocardiogram. Am J Physiol 214: 205-211, 1968.
BRAGA VA, BURMEISTER MA: Applications of telemetry in small laboratory animals for studying cardiovascular
       diseases. In: Modern Telemetry. KREJCAR O (ed.), InTech, Rijeka, 2011, pp 183-196.
BUSCHMANN G, SCHUMACHER W, BUDDEN R, KÜHL UG: Evaluation of the effect of dopamine and other
       catecholamines on the electrocardiogram and blood pressure of rats by means of on-line biosignal processing.
       J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 2: 777-795, 1980.
CHRASTINA A, POKREISZ P, SCHNITZER JE: Experimental model of transthoracic, vascular-targeted,
       photodynamically induced myocardial infarction. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 306: H270-H278, 2014.
DE BRUIN ML, PETTERSSON M, MEYBOOM RHB, HOES AW, LEUFKENS HGM: Anti-HERG activity and the
       risk of drug-induced arrhythmias and sudden death. Eur Heart J 26: 590-597, 2005.
DICKHOUT JG, LEE RM: Blood pressure and heart rate development in young spontaneously hypertensive rats. Am J
       Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 274: H794-H800, 1998.
DÖRING HJ: The isolated perfused heart according to Langendorff technique--function--application. Physiol
       Bohemoslov 39: 481-504, 1989.
DRAGOJEVIC-SIMIC VM, DOBRIC SL, BOKONJIC DR, VUCINIC ZM, SINOVEC SM, JACEVIC VM,
       DOGOVIC NP: Amifostine protection against doxorubicin cardiotoxicity in rats. Anticancer Drugs 15:
       169-178, 2004.
DRISCOLL P: The normal rat electrocardiogram. In: The Rat Electrocardiogram in Pharmacology and Toxicology.
       BUDDEN R, DETWEILER DK, ZBINDEN G (eds), Pergamon Press, New York, 1981, pp 1-14.
FARRAJ AK, HAZARI MS, CASCIO WE: The utility of the small rodent electrocardiogram in toxicology. Toxicol Sci
       121: 11-30, 2011.
FRASER RS, HARLEY C, WILEY T: Electrocardiogram in the normal rat. J Appl Physiol 23: 401-402, 1967.
FUNCK-BRENTANO C, JAILLON P: Rate-corrected QT interval: techniques and limitations. Am J Cardiol 72:
       17B-22B, 1993.
HALL JE: Cardiac Arrhythmias and their electrocardiographic interpretation. In: Guyton and Hall Textbook of Medical
       Physiology. HALL JE, GUYTON AC, SCHMITT W (eds), Saunders, London, 2011, pp 143-153.
HAMDY DA, BROCKS DR: Experimental hyperlipidemia causes an increase in the electrocardiographic changes
       associated with amiodarone. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 53: 1-8, 2009.
724   Konopelski and Ufnal                                                                                       Vol. 65
MONGUE-DIN H, SALMON A, FISZMAN MY, FROMES Y: Non-invasive restrained ECG recording in conscious
      small rodents: a new tool for cardiac electrical activity investigation. Pflugers Arch 454: 165-171, 2007.
MOLNAR J, WEISS J, ZHANG F, ROSENTHAL JE: Evaluation of five QT correction formulas using a software-
      assisted method of continuous QT measurement from 24-hour Holter recordings. Am J Cardiol 78: 920-926,
      1996.
NATTEL S, SHIROSHITA-TAKESHITA A, BRUNDEL BJ, RIVARD L: Mechanisms of atrial fibrillation: lessons
      from animal models. Prog Cardiovasc Dis 48: 9-28, 2005.
NORMANN SJ, PRIEST RE, BENDITT EP: Electrocardiogram in the normal rat and its alteration with experimental
      coronary occlusion. Circ Res 9: 282-287, 1961.
OHTANI H, HANADA E, YAMAMOTO K, SAWADA Y, IGA T: Pharmacokinetic-pharmacodynamic analysis of the
      electrocardiographic effects of terfenadine and quinidine in rats. Biol Pharm Bull 19: 1189-1196, 1996.
PEREIRA-JUNIOR PP, MAROCOLO M, RODRIGUES FP, MEDEI E, NASCIMENTO JH: Noninvasive method for
      electrocardiogram recording in conscious rats: feasibility for heart rate variability analysis. An Acad Bras
      Cienc 82: 431-437, 2010.
REGAN CP, CRESSWELL HK, ZHANG R, LYNCH JJ: Novel method to assess cardiac electrophysiology in the rat:
      characterization of standard ion channel blockers. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 46: 68-75, 2005.
REGAN CP, STUMP GL, WALLACE AA, ANDERSON KD, MCINTYRE CJ, LIVERTON NJ, LYNCH JR JJ: In
      vivo cardiac electrophysiologic and antiarrhythmic effects of an isoquinoline IKur blocker, ISQ-1, in rat, dog,
      and nonhuman primate. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 49: 236-245, 2007.
RODEN DM: Drug-induced prolongation of the QT interval. N Engl J Med 350: 1013-1022, 2004.
SAMBHI MP, WHITE FN: The electrocardiogram of the normal and hypertensive rat. Circ Res 8: 129-134, 1960.
SCHWARTZ PJ, WOLF S: QT interval prolongation as predictor of sudden death in patients with myocardial
      infarction. Circulation 57: 1074-1077, 1978.
SGOIFO A, DE BOER SF, BUWALDA B, KORTE-BOUWS G, TUMA J, BOHUS B, ZAAGSMA J, KOOLHAAS J:
      M. Vulnerability to arrhythmias during social stress in rats with different sympathovagal balance. Am J Physiol
      Heart Circ Physiol 275: H460-H466, 1998.
SKRZYPIEC-SPRING M, GROTTHUS B, SZELĄG A, SCHULZ R: Isolated heart perfusion according to
      Langendorff—still viable in the new millennium. J Pharmacol Toxicol Methods 55: 113-126, 2007.
SPEECHLY-DICK ME, MOCANU MM, YELLON DM: Protein kinase C. Its role in ischemic preconditioning in the
      rat. Circ Res 75: 586-590, 1994.
SUGIYAMA A, TAKAHARA A, HONSHO S, NAKAMURA Y, HASHIMOTO K: A simple in vivo atrial fibrillation
      model of rat induced by transesophageal atrial burst pacing. J Pharmacol Sci 98: 315-318, 2005.
WAGNER GS, MACFARLANE P, WELLENS H, JOSEPHSON M, GORGELS A, MIRVIS DM, PAHLM
      O,SURAWICZ B, KLIGFIELD P, CHILDERS R, GETTES LS, BAILEY JJ, DEAL BJ, GORGELS A,
      HANCOCK EW, KORS JA, MASON JW, OKIN P, RAUTAHARJU PM, VAN HERPEN G:
      AHA/ACCF/HRS recommendations for the standardization and interpretation of the electrocardiogram: part
      VI: acute ischemia/infarction: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association Electrocardiography
      and Arrhythmias Committee, Council on Clinical Cardiology; the American College of Cardiology
      Foundation; and the Heart Rhythm Society. Endorsed by the International Society for Computerized
      Electrocardiology. J Am Coll Cardiol 53: 1003-1011, 2009.
ZORNIAK M, MITRĘGA K, BIAŁKA S, PORC M, KRZEMIŃSKI TF: Comparison of thiopental, urethane, and
      pentobarbital in the study of experimental cardiology in rats in vivo. J Cardiovasc Pharmacol 56: 38-44, 2010.