Existential Concerns in Cancer
Existential Concerns in Cancer
                                     Abstract
                                     Cancer patients confront profound existential distress, influenced by the awareness
                                     of mortality, loss of autonomy, isolation, and meaninglessness. This narrative review
                                     explores the application of Irvin Yalom’s existential psychotherapy framework in
                                     understanding these concerns. We conducted a comprehensive literature search
                                     across major academic databases, using keywords such as “cancer,” “existential
                                     concerns,” “Yalom,” “existential psychotherapy,” “logotherapy,” “meaning-centered
                                     psychotherapy,” and “dignity therapy.” The review highlights the heightened death
                                     anxiety among cancer patients linked to demographic and psychological factors
                                     and the challenges to their sense of freedom and autonomy. It also examines the
                                     deep isolation experienced by patients and the existential crisis of meaninglessness.
                                     Empirical evidence supports the efficacy of interventions such as meaning-centered
         ARTICLE INFO                psychotherapy, logotherapy, and dignity therapy in mitigating existential distress
                                     and enhancing psychological well-being. Future research should focus on long-term
      *Correspondence:               outcomes, cultural considerations, and integrating these therapies into standard
         Maryam Farzan               oncology care to improve the quality of life for cancer patients.
     drmaryamfarzan@
               gmail.com
       Isfahan University
     of Medical Sciences,
        Isfahan Province,
                                   Introduction
                                  C
            Isfahan, Iran.              ancer is a major global health problem, with patients not only grappling
                                        with physical challenges but also facing profound existential concerns.
                  Dates:
                                   Confronted with their mortality and the difficulties accompanying the disease,
   Received: 10-08-2024
   Accepted: 23-08-2024
                                   cancer patients often experience existential distress. Our hypothesis is that
   Published: 25-10-2024           addressing these existential concerns is crucial for their overall well-being.
                                       Irvin Yalom’s existential psychotherapy framework provides a comprehensive
              Keywords:            approach to understanding and addressing these concerns. Yalom identifies
      Existential distress,        four primary existential dimensions: death, freedom, isolation, and meaning-
         Meaning-based             lessness. Each of these dimensions is particularly relevant to cancer patients.
  psychotherapy, Cancer
     patients, Existential         The confrontation with death is immediate and personal for them, eliciting
      psychotherapy, I.D.          fears and anxieties about their mortality. The dimension of freedom, which
                    Yalom          is the responsibility of shaping one’s own life, can be overwhelming when
                                   choices seem limited by illness. Isolation, both physical and emotional, is often
             How to Cite:
                                   intensified by the experience of cancer, leaving patients feeling alone in their
     Farzan M, Ebrahimi
              H, Pourali M.
                                   suffering. Finally, the search for meaning becomes acute as patients struggle
     Existential Concerns
     and Interventions in
   Patients with Cancer:           © IJOCP, 2024. Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Sha-
   Insights from Yalom’s           reAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) License, which allows users to download and share the article for
                                   non-commercial purposes, so long as the article is reproduced in the whole without changes, and the original
      Framework. Indian
                                   authorship is acknowledged. If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you must distribute your con-
       Journal of Clinical         tributions under the same license as the original. If your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation
Psychiatry. 2024;4(2): 13-20.      or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a
                                   copy of this licence, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/
 doi: 10.54169/ijocp.v4i02.142
                      Existential Concerns and Interventions in Patients with Cancer: Insights from Yalom’s Framework
Emanuel et al. (2022) suggested that demograph-                          to our knowledge, none has stated that a cancer
ics, religious affiliation, intrinsic religiousness and                  diagnosis might confront patients with their inher-
frequency of prayers were not associated with                            ent freedom. In fact, literature suggests that patients
death anxiety and distress scale (DADDS) results.6                       diagnosed with cancer experience a sense of loss
While religious “struggle” was positively correlated                     of control and autonomy, limiting their freedom of
with death anxiety, similar to dignity-related stress,                   choice.
the negative correlate found by the study was the                            A study by Xiao in 2021 showed that one of the
existential quality of life.                                             ways cancer patients experience and define dignity
    Interventions targeting death anxiety have                           is through autonomy and control.9 Another study by
shown promising results. For instance, Breitbart                         Staat et al. also suggested that patients strongly cor-
et al. (2012) demonstrated that meaning-centered                         related their dignity with having a sense of control
psychotherapy, which addresses existential con-                          and being able to make decisions for themselves.
cerns directly, effectively reduces death anxiety in                     In fact, having the freedom to make choices made
advanced cancer patients. This intervention helps                        the patients feel they had preserved their dignity.10
patients find meaning and purpose despite their                              On the other hand, a systematic review by
illness, thereby alleviating the existential terror asso-                Simard et al. (2013) examined the fear of cancer
ciated with impending death.7                                            recurrence in adult survivors and found that this
    In conclusion, death anxiety emerges promi-                          fear can severely limit patients’ perceived freedom
nently in cancer patients as a result of their confron-                  to make life choices.11 The constant anxiety about
tation with mortality. The literature indicates that                     recurrence can lead to avoidance behaviors and a
this anxiety might be closely linked to psychological                    restricted lifestyle, exacerbating existential distress.
distress, quality of life, and social factors. Moreover,                 The study highlighted the need for interventions
the role of mediating factors such as religiousness                      such as psychoeducation and cognitive-behavioral
and other cultural mechanisms is still argued. Thus,                     therapy to help patients manage these fears and
the complexity of the concept highlights the need                        regain a sense of autonomy.
for further evaluation, as death anxiety can decrease                        In conclusion, the literature highlights that the
patients’ quality of life and mood status. Therefore,                    concept of freedom might be a significant source
meaning-centered therapies are being widely used.                        of existential distress for cancer patients, often
Studies and research currently show these interven-                      closely related to the patient’s sense of dignity. The
tions can play a vital role in improving the psycho-                     perceived loss of autonomy and the responsibility
logical well-being of cancer patients.1,7                                of making life-altering decisions can exacerbate
                                                                         psychological distress.
Freedom
                                                                         Isolation
Irvin Yalom’s existential psychotherapy identifies
freedom as a central theme in understanding                              Irvin Yalom’s existential psychotherapy identifies
human existence. Yalom posits that individuals are                       isolation as a core dimension of human existence,
condemned to freedom, meaning they are respon-                           positing that existential isolation stems from the
sible for making choices in their lives, which can be                    unbridgeable gap between individuals despite our
both liberating and anxiety-inducing.1 For cancer                        best efforts to connect.1 This concept becomes par-
patients, the concept of freedom is often challenged                     ticularly important for cancer patients, who often
by their illness, as they face numerous constraints                      experience profound feelings of isolation due to the
and decisions that impact their lives and sense of                       physical, emotional, and social challenges posed by
autonomy.                                                                their illness.
    Research indicates that cancer patients fre-                              Research highlights that cancer patients fre-
quently experience issues with their sense of                            quently encounter existential distress related to iso-
freedom.8 Yet, literature concentrating solely on the                    lation. A systematic review conducted by Pilleron et
concept of freedom in cancer patients is scarce, and                     al. reviewed several empirical articles assessing lone-
and religiousness on meaning in life in patients with                   ization of breast and gynecology cancer patients.
cancer. 22,23                                                           The intervention group reported better status con-
                                                                        cerning DS-MV subcategories of loss of meaning,
Meaning-based Interventions in                                          dysphoria, helplessness, disheartenment, sense of
Cancer Care                                                             failure and total DS-MV score. 30
As stated by the many studies mentioned, meaning                             Furthermore, studies have also addressed the
can play an important role in cancer patients’ lives.                   effectiveness of existential psychotherapy, the
Several psychotherapy methods have addressed                            method that Yalom first presented, in cancer care.
meaning as a central theme, building their princi-                      A study by Mohammadi et al., followed cancer
ples and techniques upon human’s need for making                        patients receiving existential psychotherapy and
and finding meaning in life. A systematic review                        found improvements in dimensions of psychological
by Park et al., investigated various meaning-mak-                       capital (self-efficacy, hope, resilience, optimism) and
ing interventions for cancer patients. 24 The review                    affective control (anger, depressed mood, anxiety,
synthesized findings from multiple studies and                          positive affect). 31 These findings highlight the poten-
concluded that interventions focusing on enhanc-                        tial benefits of existential psychotherapy in support-
ing meaning significantly reduced psychological                         ing cancer patients’ psychological adjustment.
distress and improved quality of life. Techniques                            Numerous RCTs have demonstrated the effi-
such as life review therapy, dignity therapy, and                       cacy of dignity therapy in improving psychological
narrative therapy were identified as effective in                       well-being and existential distress among terminally
helping patients reconstruct a sense of meaning                         ill cancer patients. Chochinov et al., conducted a
and coherence in their lives.                                           multi-site RCT comparing dignity therapy with stan-
    Of the many meaning-based intervention                              dard palliative care and found significant reductions
methods, few have been tested in cancer patients                        in distress and improved dignity-related outcomes
rigorously. Several RCTs have demonstrated the                          in the intervention group. 32 Subsequent studies
efficacy of MCP in reducing existential distress                        have replicated these findings, supporting the wide-
and improving the quality of life among cancer                          spread adoption of dignity therapy in cancer care.
patients. Breitbart et al., published a manual for                           In conclusion, empirical evidence suggests
delivering this specific type of existential psycho-                    that meaning-based interventions are effective
therapy to advanced cancer and palliative care                          in addressing existential distress and improving
patients. Having assessed the effectiveness of MCP                      psychological well-being among cancer patients.
on cancer patients’ various aspects of well-being in                    RCTs and epidemiological studies provide robust
several RCTs7,24-26 Breitbart suggested that MCP led                    support for the efficacy of meaning-centered psy-
to improvements in spiritual well-being and mental                      chotherapy, dignity therapy, and, to a lesser extent,
health. Similarly, a meta-analysis by Dietrich et al.                   logotherapy. Epidemiological findings about the
confirmed the positive effects of MCP on psycho-                        effectiveness of existential psychotherapy are also
logical outcomes, including depression and anxiety,                     promising, though scarce. While more research
along with spiritual well-being and quality of life. 27                 is needed to establish the effectiveness of these
    There are also a few studies addressing the                         interventions across diverse cancer populations and
effectiveness of logotherapy in cancer patients.                        settings, the existing evidence underscores their
Viktor Frankl first introduced logotherapy follow-                      potential to enhance patients’ quality of life and
ing his seminal work “Man’s search for Meaning”. 28                     promote psychological resilience throughout the
Mohabbat-Bahar et al. conducted an RCT in 2014                          illness trajectory.
to assess the effectiveness of the method on the
anxiety of women with breast cancer. The results
were promising, decreasing the patient’s anxiety
                                                                        Discussion
with the intervention. 29 Another study by Sun et al.                   The results of this review highlight the significance
explored the effect of group logotherapy sessions                       and associated factors of existential distress experi-
and found it effective on depression and demoral-                       enced by cancer patients, particularly in relation to
Yalom’s four dimensions: death, freedom, isolation,                      a sense of meaning and coherence in their lives.
and meaninglessness. The findings highlight the                          These interventions not only reduce psychological
pervasive nature of death anxiety, the challenges to                     distress but also enhance patients’ overall quality
autonomy and freedom, the profound sense of isola-                       of life.
tion, and the crisis of meaning that cancer patients                         The evidence presented in this review highlights
often face. These dimensions are interwoven with                         the effectiveness of meaning-based interventions
patients’ psychological and social experiences, and                      in addressing existential distress among cancer
addressing them is critical for improving their overall                  patients. Meaning-centered psychotherapy, dignity
well-being.                                                              therapy, and logotherapy have demonstrated
    Death anxiety is a prominent concern among                           positive outcomes in reducing existential anxiety,
cancer patients, manifesting in heightened levels                        improving psychological well-being, and enhancing
of fear and distress. Various factors, including                         quality of life. These interventions are grounded in
symptom burden, psychological distress, and a                            the recognition that existential concerns are central
sense of meaninglessness, influence this anxiety.                        to the human experience and must be addressed to
The findings suggest that interventions targeting                        provide holistic care to cancer patients.
existential concerns, such as meaning-centered psy-                          In conclusion, this study shows that existential
chotherapy, can effectively reduce death anxiety by                      concerns might be significant in cancer patients,
helping patients find meaning and purpose despite                        and complicated by many risk factors and poten-
their illness.                                                           tially protective ones. The pervasive nature of death
    The concept of freedom is challenged by the con-                     anxiety, challenges to autonomy, profound isola-
straints imposed by cancer, leading to a perceived                       tion, and crises of meaning highlight the need for
loss of autonomy and control. Studies indicate that                      comprehensive interventions that address these
maintaining a sense of dignity through autonomy                          dimensions. Meaning-centered therapies, particu-
and decision-making is crucial for patients’ psy-                        larly meaning-centered psychotherapy and dignity
chological well-being. Interventions that promote                        therapy, have shown promising results in improving
autonomy and support patients in making informed                         the psychological well-being of cancer patients.
choices can help mitigate the existential distress                       Future research should continue to explore the
associated with a loss of freedom.                                       effectiveness of these interventions across diverse
    Isolation is another significant source of exis-                     cancer populations and settings, further establish-
tential distress for cancer patients, with many                          ing their role in enhancing patients’ quality of life and
experiencing profound loneliness and social discon-                      promoting psychological resilience throughout the
nection. The literature highlights the importance of                     illness trajectory. By integrating these therapeutic
social support and connections in alleviating feelings                   approaches into cancer care, healthcare providers
of isolation. Interventions that foster social connec-                   can better support patients in navigating the exis-
tions, whether through peer support groups, health-                      tential challenges posed by their illness.
care professional interactions, or carefully managed
social media use, can play a vital role in reducing
isolation and improving patients’ quality of life.
                                                                         Limitations
    Meaninglessness is a critical existential concern,                   Limitations of this study include potential biases
particularly for those facing advanced stages                            inherent in the selected literature, variations in study
of cancer. The disruption of a patient’s sense of                        methodologies and populations, and challenges
meaning and purpose can lead to profound psy-                            in synthesizing findings across diverse research
chological distress. Meaning-centered interventions,                     approaches. Additionally, the generalizability of
such as meaning-centered psychotherapy and                               findings may be limited by the specific characteris-
dignity therapy, have been shown to effectively                          tics of the included studies and populations.
address this concern by helping patients reconstruct
      on finding positive benefits from a breast cancer                    28.   Frankl VE. Man’s Search for Meaning: An Introduction to
      diagnosis. Counselling and Spirituality/Counseling et                      Logotherapy. New York: Washington Square Press; 1963.
      spiritualité. 2011.                                                  29.   Mohabbat-Bahar S, Golzari M, Moradi-Joo M, Akbari ME.
24.   Breitbart W. Spirituality and meaning in supportive care:                  Efficacy of group logotherapy on decreasing anxiety
      spirituality-and meaning-centered group psychother-                        in women with breast cancer. Iran J Cancer Prev.
      apy interventions in advanced cancer. Supportive care                      2014;7(3):165-70.
      in cancer. 2002;10:272-80.                                           30.   Sun FK, Hung CM, Yao Y, Fu CF, Tsai PJ, Chiang CY. The
25.   Breitbart W, Pessin H, Rosenfeld B, Applebaum AJ,                          Effects of Logotherapy on Distress, Depression, and
      Lichtenthal WG, Li Y, et al. Individual meaning‐cen-                       Demoralization in Breast Cancer and Gynecological
      tered psychotherapy for the treatment of psycholog-                        Cancer Patients: A Preliminary Study. Cancer Nurs.
      ical and existential distress: A randomized controlled                     2021;44(1):53-61.
      trial in patients with advanced cancer. Cancer.                      31.   mohammadi r, Zebardast A, rezaei s. The Effectiveness
      2018;124(15):3231-9.                                                       of Existential Psychotherapy on Psychological Capital
26.   Breitbart WS, Breitbart W, Poppito SR. Meaning-cen-                        and Affective Control in Cancer Patients Undergo-
      tered group psychotherapy for patients with advanced                       ing Chemotherapy. Journal of Nursing Education.
      cancer: A treatment manual: Oxford University Press,                       2022;10(5):82-95.
      USA; 2014.                                                           32.   Chochinov HM, Kristjanson LJ, Breitbart W, McClement
27.   Dietrich N, Estradé A, Cruzado Rodríguez JA. Efficacy                      S, Hack TF, Hassard T, et al. Effect of dignity therapy
      of Meaning-Centered Psychotherapy in adult patients                        on distress and end-of-life experience in terminally
      with advanced cancer: A systematic review and                              ill patients: a randomised controlled trial. The lancet
      meta-analysis. 2021.                                                       oncology. 2011;12(8):753-62.