Foam Concrete Set-Accelerator Study
Foam Concrete Set-Accelerator Study
net/publication/257389386
CITATIONS READS
43 1,794
2 authors, including:
Ramamurthy K
Indian Institute of Technology Madras
102 PUBLICATIONS 6,733 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Ramamurthy K on 07 January 2018.
Abstract: Foam concrete is suitable for producing lightweight blocks. This paper deals with
identification of suitable set accelerator for foam concrete made using Sodium Lauryl Sulfate
as foaming agent, i.e. facilitating demoulding within 2 hours and also economical. As
conventional accelerators, viz., Calcium chloride, Calcium nitrate, Triethanol amine were
not-effective in foam concrete, Alum and Class-C Fly ash were tried. Demoulding test was
performed to the mixes having optimum density (1200-1300kg/m3). Class-C Fly ash was
1 Introduction
There has been renewed research interest in making use of light weight concrete blocks for
wall construction. Attempts are being made to develop light weight solid, hollow and
interlocking blocks. Foam concrete is more suitable for manufacturing of blocks. In foam
concrete, macroscopic air foamed bubbles are produced mechanically and added to the base
mix mortar during mixing. This type of foam concreting technique is called preformed foam
concrete. Foaming agent required for producing aqueous stable foam can be either natural or
synthetic origin.
Foam concrete is highly flowable and self-compacting in nature. Since the foam
concrete contains air bubbles it cannot be rammed and vibrated in a machine to produce the
blocks. Hence the foam concrete needs to be cast in mould. Normal foam concrete when cast
in moulds, can be demoulded only after 24hours. This imposes constraints on the productivity
1
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
of the block manufacture. This also demands a large number of moulds thereby increasing
high cost and will occupy large space. If the process of demoulding could be facilitated by
reducing cycle time, the block production rate can be increased by reusing a reasonable
number of moulds. Hence there is a need to identify suitable accelerator and its dosage which
would reduce the setting time of foam concrete thereby facilitating early demoulding.
Extensive research has been carried out on the use of set-accelerators in normal concrete.
Most of the studies on foam concrete deal with identification of suitable foaming agent,
properties of foam concrete, influence of filler type on fresh and hardened properties of foam
concrete, air void characterization of foam concrete [1-3]. No study has been reported on use
of set-accelerator in foam concrete. In the case of foam concrete, the type of accelerator and
the type of foaming agent influence its performance. This paper first reviews the studies on
use of a few important set-accelerators in concrete, based on which a few accelerators are
Accelerators influence the rate of cement hydration, leading to a reduction in setting time
reduces and an increase in early age strength of concrete. The accelerators are used for early
low temperature and also prevents damage due to freezing. Acceleration is normally achieved
by i) accelerating the tricalcium aluminate phase (C3A) of Portland cement (Rapid set
accelerators), or ii) accelerating the tricalcium silicate phase in cement (Accelerators for
setting and hardening). Out of the various chemicals reported in literature a brief review of
studies on calcium chloride, calcium nitrate, tri-ethanol amine, lithium salts and calcium
2
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
2.1 Calcium Chloride: It acts as a catalyst and promotes the hydration of C3S and C2S or
reduction in alkalinity of the pore solution promotes the hydration of silicates [4]. Usual
dosage is 2% by the weight of cement [5]. Ramachandran [6] studied the hydration
characteristics of C3S in the presence of CaCl2, and observed that CaCl2 alters the rate of
hydration and also chemical composition of C-S-H. In the mix containing 2% CaCl2 the
setting time is reported to occur at 105 minutes, while it was 790 minutes for the mix without
CaCl2. The presence of CaCl2 leads to corrosion of reinforcement bars [4]. For reactive
aggregates the addition of CaCl2 increases the reactivity of alkali-silica reaction there by
2.2 Calcium Nitrate (CN): Justnes and Nygaard [7] studied the efficiency of CN as a
set-accelerator for different cements at low temperature and observed that the set-accelerator
efficiency of CN increases with an increase in belite content of cement. The optimum dosage
of CN with ASTM type I cement is 3.86% the weight of cement. CN was observed to
accelerate the C3A phase. Hydration mechanisms were modified which resulted in altered
products. Aggoun et al. [8] studied the set-accelerator efficiency of CN and concluded that it
2.3 Triethanolamine (TEA): Depending upon the cement type and addition rate TEA
can produce either set-acceleration or retardation, i.e., it is a dosage sensitive admixture [9].
In the presence of TEA, the reaction between C3A and gypsum gets accelerated and ettringite
is converted into monosulfoaluminate. Ramachandran [10] reported that the initial setting
characteristics were drastically reduced at a dosage of 0.1%, and 0.5% weight of cement.
Aiad et al. [11] studied on alkanoamines on the rheological and setting properties of cement
paste and reported that TEA accelerate the setting time at a dosage of 0.1% only.
2.4 Lithium salts: Novinson and Crahan [12] studied the use of lithium salts as a set
accelerator for refractory concretes. The reaction rates are related to the pH of the lithium
3
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
salts in mixing water. The lithium cation has more effect than other cation (like Na, K)
because of its smaller size, higher hydration energy and simple electronic structure (Lithium
has smaller crystal radii of 0.6 Å, it has higher hydration energy of 123kcal/mol when
compared to sodium or potassium whose crystal radii is 0.95, 1.33 Å having hydration energy
of 97 and 77 kcal/mol receptively). The class of anion is also very important as it controls the
rate of lithium hydration (Lithium acts as a catalyst. Lithium cation is smaller in size when
compared to sodium and magnesium as a result lithium has higher hydration energy and it
coordinate with many water molecule per atom to hydrate faster). Lithium salts is reported to
acts as quick set accelerator with the anion like carbonate, nitrate, fluoride and tetraborate.
2.5 Calcium formate: The solubility of calcium formate at room temperature is 15%.
Singh and Abha [13] concluded that calcium formate accelerates the C3S hydration with the
dosage of 0.5 to 6%. The effect of calcium formate depends up on composition of cement.
For cements with C3A/SO3 ratio higher than 4, calcium formate is reported to process good
The above review has helped in identifying most widely used / studied accelerators,
their behavior, hydration mechanism and dosage ranges to be tried. This paper deals with the
through shape retention while demoulding of cubes) using identified set accelerators. The
objective is to identify accelerators which have the capacity to retain its shape after
demoulding within two hours. As a first stage, the cost effectiveness of the reviewed
accelerators (Calcium chloride (CaCl2), Calcium nitrate (CN), and Triethanolamine (TEA))
based on the dosage recommended in literature have been tried initially. As a next stage, viz.,
Alum (hydrated potassium aluminium sulfate), and Class-C fly ash have also been tried to
explore their potential to serve as an accelerator and to establish their relative performance in
4
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
As the water-solid ratio, surfactant concentration and foam volume are normally varied in
foam concrete, to obtain foam concrete with desired density and workability, the performance
of accelerators under varying conditions of these parameters has also been investigated. The
demoulding time of desired mix whose density ratio (ratio of measured/actual fresh density to
the design density) is approximately one were reported in the following sections.
The raw materials used for foam concrete are cement, sand, water, preformed foam
used throughout this study. The chemical composition of Ordinary Portland Cement and
River sand passing through 2.36mm sieve was used. Based on the earlier study of Ranjani
and Ramamurthy [14] commercially available Sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS), has been used as
foaming agent. Two concentrations of Sodium lauryl sulfate, viz., 2% and 8% were adopted.
(Ex: For 2% surfactant concentration, 1000 gram of water, 20 gram of Sodium lauryl sulfate
is added and mixed thoroughly till a homogeneous solution is achieved). Then the solution is
kept undisturbed for 5minutes and then the required quantity of foaming premix solution is
added to the foam generator to produce the foam. The foam was generated using
The foam volume required to be added to the mix depends on design density of foam
concrete and the density of foam itself. The fresh density of foam concrete was fixed as
1250 kg/m3, allowing a variation of ± 50 kg/m3. The density of foam achieved with SLS is
given in ASTM C796-04 has been adopted for arriving volume of air (Va) and the foam
5
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
WS/FA - Weight of sand/fly-ash, (kg), WTW - Weight of total water including weight of foam,
Having arrived at the foam volume required to produce foam concrete of 1250 kg/m3, as a
next step, the water-solid ratio required to achieve this density needs to be determined
through stability test. At lower water-solid ratio, the mix will be dry and bubbles will escape
resulting in increased density, while at higher water-solid ratio there is again increase in
density as higher water content make the slurry too thin to hold the bubbles resulting in
segregation of the mix. Hence for a stable mix there is a small range of water-solid ratio in
4.1 Stability test: To assess the stability of fresh concrete, the water required was
gradually increased and the fresh density of foam concrete was measured in container of
known volume (0.0012m3) and its density was compared with the design density.
Based on the mix proportion (cement-sand), surfactant concentration (2 and 8%) and
type of accelerator (alum, Fly ash), the specific gravity of the material (when sand is replaced
with fly ash) and the fines in the mix vary, due to which the water demand varies to achieve
the design density of 1250 kg/m3. After determination of the optimal water-solid ratio which
produces a density ratio of closer to one, such mixes are taken up for studying the influence
4.2 Demoulding test: As the objective of this study is to facilitate faster demoulding of
6
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
the interlocking blocks, instead of conventional setting tests it was decided to adopt
demouldability of 50mm cube specimens, i.e., the ability of the cube to retain its shape after
demoulding as a basis for arriving at the relative performance of the accelerator. Totally
12 numbers of 50 mm cubes were cast for each mix (with 3 cubes for each time of
demoulding). The demoulding was started after the top surface of the concrete in the mould
becomes dry and non-sticky. Demoulding of cubes was carried out at 15 minutes interval till
5 Performance of accelerators
concentration and 2% CaCl2 by weight of cement was tried. Soon after the foam was added to
the base mix, bursting of foam bubbles was observed resulting in reduction in the volume of
foam concrete. It was also observed that, for the mixes whose density ratio closer to one,
there was settlement of sand in the bottom of the container. Fig. 1 shows the behavior of
A dosage of 4% CaCl2 was tried with foam concrete mixes of 1:1, 1:2 and 1:3 cement-sand
ratios. The fresh density of foam concrete decreased with an increase in water-solids ratio.
Water demand required to achieve the design density was reduced with increase in sand
content. But at higher water-solid ratio, the settlement of sand and foam bursting occurred at
all the mixes. Such a behavior can be explained through the observations made by Miles and
Ross [15]. They studied the behavior of mixed calcium salts of soaps and anionic detergents,
and reported that for a mix containing solution of sodium lauryl sulfate and calcium chloride
the critical pH value for stable foam is 5.0 to 5.5, while a pH of about 7.0 the foam becomes
unstable and falls to zero. Irrespective of the mix and dosage of CaCl2 the cubes could not be
demoulded up to 4hour 30minutes. Skalny and Maycock [16] reported that pH value of
7
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
concrete containing portland cement and 2% CaCl2 was approximately 12. Hence at this high
pH value foam concrete with SLS as foaming agent, foam become unstable and start bursting
triethanol amine by weight of cement was tried. For these dosages the demoulding time of
foam concrete exceeded 6hour 30minutes. Heren and Olmez [17] studied the effect of
(TEA) on hydration and mechanical properties of white Portland cement. It has been
concluded that ethanolamines showed the retarding effect on setting time of white Portland
cement at various dosage in the order of TEA > DEA > MEA. Similar phenomenon was
observed with foam concrete. A dosage of 3.5% calcium nitrate by weight of cement was
used. The cube could not retain its shape even beyond 4hours. As the conventionally reported
accelerator did not result in reducing the setting time of foam concrete made with SLS as a
5.3 Alum: Alum is hydrated potassium aluminium sulfate. Alum instantaneously reacts
with slaked lime discharged by a hydration reaction of cement to form ettringite and thereby
accelerate the setting and curing [18]. Commercial grade alum was tried as set-accelerator.
Initial studies with an alum dosage of 5% by weight of cement, did not result in accelerating
the setting time. Hence dosage of 10% alum was tried on foam concrete with 1:1, 1:2, 1:3
cement sand mixes and two surfactant concentrations of 2% and 8%. For making the alum in
solution form, small quantity of water from the calculated quantity of water was taken. The
influence of water-solid ratios in the fresh densities for different foam concrete mixes with
two surfactant concentrations are presented in Figs. 2 to 4. In these figures the solid lines
represents the fresh density, while long dash line indicates the density ratio. Dotted line
8
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
It can be inferred from Fig. 2, that for foam concrete with 1:1 cement-sand mix, the water
required to achieve the desired design density is lower for 2% surfactant concentration as
compared to that of 8% surfactant concentration. For 1:2 and 1:3 cement-sand mix
(Figs. 3 & 4) i.e., (with an increase in sand content in the mix) the water required to achieve
the design density of 1250 kg/m3 was same irrespective of surfactant concentration even
though there is variation in profile. For each mix, the range of water-solids ratio which
produces density ratio closer to 1 was noted and demoulding test was carried out within this
For a given foam concrete mix (say 1:1) the surfactant concentration did not influence the
setting time. As expected, the demoulding time reduced with an increase in cement content in
the foam concrete mix i.e., from 185minutes to 140minutes. Alum exhibited potential to
5.4 Class-C Fly ash: Fly ash is an industrial waste available in large quantities.
Conventionally, studies have been made to utilise fly ash as replacement for cement (as a
pozzolanic material), fine aggregate (as filler) in concrete, manufacture of PPC Cement, fly
High calcium fly ash (Class-C) is characterised by its hydraulic activity. The main
constituents of high calcium fly ash are free lime, anhydrite CaSO4, reactive silica and
alumina [19]. Higher the ratio of SO3 to f-CaO is beneficial for self cementing characteristics.
After addition of water to the fly ash, it exhibit setting and hydration characteristics. The
main hydrated product, as a result of reaction between fly ash and water are C-S-H and
ettringite. C-S-H is formed by the reaction between f-CaO and active silica in the ash where
as ettringite is formed by the reaction between f-CaO, active alumina and CaSO4 [20]. In
view of the above observations, an attempt has been made in this study to explore the
9
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
performance of Class-C fly ash by replacing sand with fly ash as an accelerator. The range of
replacement by weight considered are i) Complete replacement of sand by fly ash having
cement-fly ash ratio of 1:1, 1:2 and 1:3. ii) Combination mix by partially replacing the sand
by fly ash for the ratios of 1:2 and 1:3. As the volume of fly ash in the mix increases (i.e., at
higher replacement of sand with fly ash), due to increase in fines, the foam volume was
appropriately enhanced to achieve the design density. Because of its self cementing property
and addition of cement in the mix, the hydration mechanisms gets accelerated which in turn
concrete mixes with Class-C fly ash. With an increase in fines content in the mix due to the
addition of fly ash instead of sand, the water-solids ratio required to achieve design density
was higher than those of cement-sand mix. For 1:1 cement-class-C fly ash mix, the
water-solid ratio required to achieve the design density increased with foam concentration
(Fig. 5). Figs. 6 to 8 indicates that, for 1:2 and 1:3 cement-fly ash mix, as the fines in the mix
was high, the desired density could not be achieved with the calculated quantity of foam. The
desired density in these mixes could be achieved with 150% of foam volume (Figs. 7 and 8).
The range of water-solid ratio which produces density ratio closer to one for various cement-
fly ash mizes are presented in Table-3 along with the corresponding demoulding time.
Though the achieved fresh density was marginally higher 2.3 to 4.5% the demoulding time
almost same for 1:2 cement-fly ash mix with 1.5 times the foam volume. For given cement
fly ash mix, variation in surfactant concentration did not exhibit significant variation in
demoulding time. Keeping the cement content constant, an increase in fly ash content in the
10
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
mix i) demands higher water-solid ratio to achieve the design density, and ii) increases
combination mixes, the study was limited to 2% surfactant concentration. For 1:2 mix, 50%
sand was replaced with Class-C fly ash by weight resulting Cement: Sand: Class-C fly ash in
the ratio 1:1:1. For 1:3 mix, the sand was replaced with Class-C fly ash in two levels. One at
33.3% and other at 66.7% resulting Cement: Sand. i.e., Class-C fly ash in the ratios of 1:2:1
and 1:1:2.
The details regarding demoulding time and optimum mix for combination mixes are
presented in Table-4. It is inferred from Table 2, 3 and 4 that for 1:2 mixes of foam concrete,
the mix containing sand requires lower water-solid ratio and foam volume as compared to
those with fly ash to achieve the desired density. In combination mix (1:1:1), it took longer
time to demould when compared to mixes with 100% fly ash or alum. When compared with
1:3 cement-fly ash mix and combination mix (1:1:2, 1:2:1) the water demand required to
achieve the desired density was lower in combination mix because of higher coarser sand
content. Mix containing higher fly ash content demands higher foam volume because of its
higher fineness. Combination mix containing higher fly ash content was able to be
demoulded quicker when compared with other mixes (90 minutes). It was observed that for
all the mix ratios class-C fly ash could accelerate the demoulding time, even though it
6 Conclusion
The conclusions drawn below are applicable to the materials used and the range of
parameters investigated.
1. Among the conventional accelerators tried, use of i) CaCl2 resulted in instability of foam
concrete mix and mix did not set up to 4hours 30minutes. ii) Triethanol amine and
11
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
Calcium nitrate though produce stable mixes of foam concrete, the setting did not occur
even after 6 hours and 4 hours respectively.
2. Though Alum exhibited its potential to serve as an accelerator for foam concrete with
SLS by facilitating demouldability within 140 minutes to 185 minutes, the dosages
required to such range of setting time makes it uneconomical.
3. Class-C fly ash has been identified as the most appropriate accelerator for foam concrete
mix with SLS. Use of class-C fly ash as (i) complete replacement of sand and (ii)
combination mixes provide flexibility in its adoption as an accelerator.
References
[1] Kearsley EP, Weinwright PJ. Porosity and permeability of foam concrete.
Cem Concr Res 2001;31:805-12.
[3] Ranjani GIS. Investigations on the behavior of preformed foam concrete using two
synthetic surfactants as foaming agent, Ph.D. thesis, IIT Madras, India, 2011.
[4] Neville AM. Properties of concrete. Pearson education Inc., India, 2011.
[5] ACI Committee 212. Chemical admixtures for concrete (ACI 212.3R-91). Detroit:
American Concrete Institute; 1999:10-14.
[6] Ramachandran VS. Chemical admixtures handbook properties, science and technology.
Noyes publications, New Jersey, 2002.
[7] Justness H, Nygaard EC. Technical calcium nitrate as set accelerator for cement at low
temperatures. Cem Concr Res 1995;25:1766-774.
[9] Dodson V. Chemical admixtures. Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1990.
12
Accepted-un-edited manuscript of the paper titled "Identification of set-accelerator for enhancing the productivity of foam concrete block manufacture",
published in "Construction and Building Materials", Construction and Building Materials 37 (2012) 144–152
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.conbuildmat.2012.07.025
[11] Aiad I, Mohammed AA, Abo-EL-Enin SA. Rheological properties of cement paste
admixed with some alkanolamines. Cem Concr Res 2003;33:9-13.
[12] Novinson T, Crahan J. Lithium salt as set accelerator for refractory concretes:
correlations of chemical properties with setting time. ACI Mater J 1988;85:12-16.
[13] Singh NB, Abha K. Effect of calcium formate on the hydration of tricalcium silicate.
Cem Concr Res 1983;13:619-25.
[14] Ranjani GIS, Ramamurthy K. Relative assessment of density and stability of foam
produced with four synthetic surfactants. Materials and Structures 2010;43:1317-325.
[15] Miles GD, Ross J. Mixed calcium salts of soaps and anionic detergents. Industrial and
engineering chemistry 1943;35:1298-301.
[17] Heren Z, Olmez H. The influence of ethanolamines on the hydration and mechanical
properties of Portland cement. Cem Concr Res 1996;26:701-05.
[18] Watanabe Y, et al. Process for producing a concrete product. U.S. Patent 6126875,
2000.
[19] Giergiczny Z. The hydraulic activity of high calcium fly ash. Journal of thermal
analysis and calorimetry 2006;83:227-32.
13