Storytelling
Storytelling
Address for
A ttention deficit hyperactivity is one
of the most prevalent disorders in
children and adolescents.[1] According to
poor social skills. [3] Regarding healthy
functioning, social skills are momentous
achievements and many researchers have
correspondence: recent statistics, this disorder is common in claimed that failures in peer relationships
Dr. Helia Rahnamaei,
Master of Child and 3% to 7% of children.[1] In addition to three affect children’s progress, inter‑personal
Adolescent Clinical core symptoms of ADHD, hyperactivity, success, and happiness[4] Although there
Psychology of Kharazmi have been five evidence‑based treatments for
University, Clinical
This is an open access journal, and articles are
Psychologist, Tehran, Iran. distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
E‑mail: helia.rahnamaei@ Attribution‑NonCommercial‑ShareAlike 4.0 License, which How to cite this article: Karbasi Amel A,
ru.nl allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work Rahnamaei H, Hashemi Z. Play therapy and
non‑commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and storytelling intervention on children's social skills
Received: 31‑07‑2022 with attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder. J Edu
the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
Accepted: 06‑11‑2022 Health Promot 2023;12:317.
Published: 29-09-2023 For reprints contact: WKHLRPMedknow_reprints@wolterskluwer.com
© 2023 Journal of Education and Health Promotion | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow 1
Karbasi Amel, et al.: Play therapy and storytelling for children with ADHD
children with ADHD, based on American Psychological on social skills of 7 to 11 years old children with ADHD
Association including medication or parenting, some in Isfahan.
other interventions such as play therapy have been
claimed to be fruitful to reduce children’s externalizing Materials and Methods
and internalizing behavioral problems. [1] Freer et al.
(2011)[5] suggest that therapeutic medications, although Study design and setting
successful at addressing problems concerning attention This study was a randomized pre‑test–post‑test
and concentration, may not influence higher‑order experimental design (quasi‑experimental design). The
cognitive deficits that these children exhibit. Not all study was performed in Isfahan, Iran, at a child and
children will benefit from medication.[6] adolescent out‑patient psychiatry clinic. There were two
groups, intervention and control. For each participant
Children through art materials can naturally and in the intervention group, 10 sessions of combined
spontaneously express their inner feelings and thoughts, intervention of play therapy and storytelling (two
discover their interests, and gain a sense of control sessions per week in 60 minute sessions) were held
over the environment [7] and deal with emotional by a group consisting of a child psychiatrist, a clinical
stress[8] through playing. Play therapy is a designed psychologist, and a trained art therapist. Major
intervention to meet children’s developmental needs. psychiatric disorders such as post‑traumatic stress
Young children have limited ability to express their disorder, evidence or history of any medical conditions,
concerns meaningfully through words alone, whereas neglect or abuse, borderline IQ or intellectual disability,
play therapy provides them with a non‑verbal and taking medications that might affect children’s social
concrete means of expression that also crosses language skills (for example, SSRIs), and not having the interest
and cultural barriers.[9] Some play therapy research has to cooperate all unmet the criteria.
supported the utilization of this approach to reduce
behavioral problems demonstrated by children.[1] As an Study participants and sampling
intervention, storytelling is designed to actively involve Thirty children between the ages of 7 and 11 with a
the child in the treatment process and motivate the child verified diagnosis of ADHD using DSM‑V criteria met
to be part of the solution.[10] Story and storytelling are the inclusion criteria. Patients who met the study criteria
simultaneously cognitive processes and products of entered the study, and there were not any missing cases.
cognition.[11] Indeed, narrative therapy allows the person They were assigned to one of the intervention or control
to see the problem and think about it as something groups through random blocks, each containing two
outside himself or herself and be actively engaged in the members. The patients were randomly divided into each
expression of difficult emotions such as worry, anger, block using Excel Random Allocation Software, and
and confusion effectively and in a non‑confrontational then, each block was randomly allocated to one of the
manner.[12] study groups with similar software. Parents were also
actively involved in their children’s therapy sessions
Little research has been focused on the combination and contributed greatly to encouragement, feedback,
of play therapy and storytelling for developmental and rewards. Table 1 shows the content of play therapy
disorders, particularly ADHD. On one hand, concrete and storytelling sessions. The participants in the control
materials in play, such as toys, crafts, clay, and other group were on the waiting list by researchers.
play‑based experiences provided in play therapy,
afford children an age‑appropriate and emotionally safe Data collection tool and technique
means to express their difficult experiences.[13] On the In this research, the parents’ form of the Gresham and
other hand, children with ADHD fail in staying focused Elliott (1990) SSRS Questionnaire was used to evaluate
on subjects thoroughly. They often can pay attention children’s social skills. This 55‑item version of the
to some degree; thus, stories can involve them and grading system has two subscales of social skills and
help them pay heed to the content of stories.[14] With problematic behavior. The social skill subscale includes
the importance of their symptoms not yet grasped, 40 items and assesses cooperation, assertiveness,
children seem to struggle with consuming medication responsibility, and self‑control. The problematic
and listening to psychiatrists’ and psychologists’ behavior subscale includes 18 items and is dedicated to
suggestions. According to the authors’ clinical assessing hyperactivity, internal problems, and external
experiences and positive outcomes of play therapy and problems. The scoring of this system is performed with
storytelling regarding disruptive behavioral problems a Likert scale from 0 to 3. Social skills range from 0 to
of children with ADHD, which are all mentioned 120 with a higher score indicating higher social skills
above, this research aims to combine these two fruitful and lower scores indicating poor social skills. The
interventions and determine the effectiveness of required time for filling out the questionnaire is 10 to
combined intervention of play therapy and storytelling 25 minutes. Jason has claimed the internal consistency
2 Journal of Education and Health Promotion | Volume 12 | September 2023
Karbasi Amel, et al.: Play therapy and storytelling for children with ADHD
Table 1: Content of play therapy and storytelling sessions in the intervention group
Session The title of plays and stories Description and goal of each session
1 Introduction and acquaintance Children become familiar with each other, with the setting of the play,
and therapist/building friendship and trust among children/developing
conversational skills/practicing appropriate body posture in social
relationships (self‑ expression)
2 Puppet show/Story of three friends To depict informational material with greater comprehension/to increase
verbal capacity (cooperation/responsibility)
3 Index cards with brief descriptions and labels/the story A more engaging play than reading brochures/expressing anger calmly
of Hussein’s space car (self‑control/responsibility)
4 Dominos placed in a circle/finding the name of the Depict the influence of one action on others/increasing attention to the
story (story of a shy octopus and a kind fish) environment/increasing vocabulary repertoire/gaining comprehension
and listening skills/overcoming loneliness and isolation (self‑expression/
self‑control)
5 Three adolescents or family members and a therapist Each participant has two pieces of yarn, one in each hand, and each
standing at the pinnacle of a triangle/the story of the piece of yarn connects the participant to the next person. Each one states
red cape a maladaptive thought and pulls the string to the right, which triggers the
second person to state a corresponding unpleasant feeling resulting from
the thought, which prompts the third person to name a corresponding
maladaptive behavior: a maladaptive thinking process results in a spiral of
a negative thought, feeling, and behavior (self‑expression/self‑control)
6 Lose the Bruise strategy/the duck’s wrong story Participants are asked to hold both a pretended shield and a plastic
sword using each shield or sword to defend and protect himself or herself
from a negative self‑statement/understanding and expressing different
emotional states/gaining skills in verbally expressing emotions/decreasing
disobedience/overcoming shyness (self‑expression/responsibility)
7 Interactive metaphors and stories/the story of an angry To illustrate adaptive thinking styles: a kind of role‑playing can help children
cat connect helpful and unhelpful statements to various feelings and situations/
controlling anger/saying no to others politely (self‑expression/self‑control)
8 Index cards with photographs/the story of “I am no A non‑verbal way to identify symptoms and issues each participant
longer ashamed” is experiencing/problem‑solving skills/avoiding making fun of others/
overcoming shyness and isolation (responsibility/self‑control)
9 Psychoeducational material such as therapeutic stories Children can be engaged in a battle and say “run ADHD off my land”
with symptoms, adjustments, and coping strategies/the Accepting failure/coping with a rival victory (cooperation/self‑control)
story of the little Sepehr and the dwarf man
10 Painting/the closing ceremony The child is asked to draw specific thoughts, feeling, and behavior that
apply to her or his problem situation/familiarization with various social
roles and the community’s expectations/developing communicational
skills/reviewing past sessions and discussing story points (cooperation/
responsibility)
coefficient based on SSRS total score ranging from 0.86 used as a guide for children to start their stories.[20] Play
to 0.90 and long‑term stability coefficients ranging from therapy sessions were designed to increase cooperation,
0.32 to 0.72 for both parents’ ratings.[15] Based on the Van courage, responsibility, and self‑control to develop
Horn et al.[16] examination, results showed high internal social skills in children with ADHD. Demonstrative,
consistency and moderately high validity for both social role‑playing, and participatory methods were used
skills and problematic behavior scales. In Shiraz, Iran, during the sessions. Also, to increase children’s
in the year 1377, Cronbach’s alpha coefficient of the test cooperation, dependency management techniques
was 0.82 in the parents’ form.[17] In another research such as positive reinforcement, shaping, and so on
by Shahim in the mentally retarded population, were used. Data were computer‑analyzed using
Cronbach’s alpha reliability coefficient of the parent SPSS‑20 and a couple of descriptive and analytic tests
form was reported to be 0.82 in the field of social including ANCOVA. The test was parametric; hence,
skills in general, which was comparable to the original mean descriptors and standard deviations were used
scale (0.87).[18] The main structure of therapy sessions to evaluate the descriptive findings and an analysis
was considered based on the core components of the of covariance was used to evaluate the effectiveness
cognitive behavioral approach in the book “Blending of the intervention. Because of the small sample size,
Play Therapy with Cognitive Behavioral Therapy” by confounding variables did not justify. The primary
Athena A. Drewes,[19] yet some changes were made outcome of this study was to assess and compare the
according to received information and children needs. efficacy of the intervention on the social skill of ADHD
The book ‘Parents’ for solving children’s anxiety patients using the SSRS Questionnaire scale filled at
problems by Karbasi Amel and Arman (2010) was also baseline and the end of the training sessions. Other
Journal of Education and Health Promotion | Volume 12 | September 2023 3
Karbasi Amel, et al.: Play therapy and storytelling for children with ADHD
groups)
(within
59.06±18.37 73.42±15.88 <0.05 18.27±5.82 21.93±3.74 <0.05 12.53±4.86 16.07±4.80 <0.05 15.67±4.11 19.40±3.15 <0.05 12.60±5.57 16.13±5.89 <0.05
>0.05
which increases their happiness and adaptability to
P
Cooperation (X̅ ±SD)
the surrounding environment. This, in turn, reduces
11.47±6.94 11.33±5.76
attention deficit/passivity problems and increases
Post‑test
their internal capacities to adapt to the environment.
<0.05
Meanwhile, storytelling process actually changes the
child’s attention and would alter it from passive to active.
Pre‑test Although they are actively telling their stories, they can
express their emotions by attributing them to the story
characters. It can be regulative and therapeutic when
they find a non‑threatening way to face their thoughts,
groups)
(within
>0.05
fears, and emotions.
P
Responsibility (X̅ ±SD)
Pre‑test
>0.05
P
>0.05
group (n=15)
P (between
Variables
20. Arman S, Karbasi Amel A. How to Help Anxious Youth. Esfahan: 27. Bayat F, Rezaee AM, Behnam B. Comparison of the effectiveness
Kankash; 1390. of play therapy and storytelling on the improvement of Attention
21. Abikoff H, Hechtman L, Klein RG, Gallagher R, Fleiss K, Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder symptoms in students. Qom Univ
Etcovitch J, et al. Social functioning in children with ADHD treated Med Sci J 2018;12:59‑68.
with long‑term methylphenidate and multimodal psychosocial 28. Farzadfard SA, Abdekhodaee MS, Ghenaee Chaman Abadi A.
treatment. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2004;43:820‑9. Effectiveness of combined purposeful play therapy and narrative
22. Abdollahian E, Mokhber N, Balaghi A, Moharrari F. The therapy on pre‑school childrensâ attention and concentration.
effectiveness of cognitive‑behavioural play therapy on the J Fundam Mental Health 2015;17:222‑8.
symptoms of attention‑deficit/hyperactivity disorder in children 29. Meany‑Walen KK, Teeling S. Adlerian play therapy with students
aged 7–9 years. ADHD Atten Defic Hyperact Disord 2013;5:41‑6. with externalizing behaviors and poor social skills. Int J Play Ther
23. El‑Nagger NS, Abo‑Elmagd MH, Ahmed HI. Effect of applying 2016;25:64‑77.
play therapy on children with attention deficit hyperactivity 30. Ashori M, Ghasemzadeh S, Dallalzadeh Bidgoli F. The impact of
disorder. J Nurs Educ Pract 2017;7:104‑19. play therapy based on cognitive‑behavioral model on the social
24. Jafari N, Mohammadi MR, Khanbani M, Farid S, Chiti P. Effect of skills of preschool children with attention deficit hyperactivity
play therapy on behavioral problems of maladjusted preschool disorder. Q J Child Ment Health 2019;6:27‑39.
children. Iran J Psychiatry 2011;6:37‑42. 31. Hosseinnezhad A, Abolghasemi S, Vatankhah HR, Khalatbari J.
25. Mirzaie H, Hassani Mehraban A, Hosseini SA, Ghasemi Fard F, Comparison of the effectiveness of anger management training
Jafari Oori M. Comparison of the effect of filial and Adlerian play based on cognitive behavioral therapy approach and narrative
therapy on attention and hyperactivity of children with attention therapy on academic self‑efficiency and academic resilience in
deficit hyperactivity disorder: A randomized clinical trial. Iran students with attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
Rehabil J 2019;17:341‑50. Q J Child Ment Health 2020;7:1‑16.
26. Arora MS, Joshi U. Effectiveness of Life Skill Training through 32. Yati M, Wahyuni S, Islaeli I. The effect of storytelling in a
the Art of Storytelling on academic performance of Children with play therapy on anxiety level in pre‑school children during
Attention deficit hyperactivity and conduct disorder. J Psychiatr hospitalization in the general hospital of buton. Public Health
Nurs 2015;4:9‑12. Indones 2017;3:96‑101.