Samskara 6
Samskara 6
168
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
169
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
may not have been the same but they LITERATURE REVIEW
all sought to affect one thing i.e.
The significance of the body (life and
change and this was the very thing
lifeless) and the wider implications of
that conservative, moribund India was
the image/object of the body has been
not willing to accept. Devi’s “Douloti
examined by several scholars in
the Bountiful”, despite being set in
anthropological, sociological,
postcolonial post-Independence India,
historical, and political terms.
shows that bonded labour and the
Katherine Verdery (1999) in a riveting
oppression of outcastes still permeate
examination of political burials and
the Indian social structure in spite of
reburials in Eastern Europe and the
India presenting itself/being perceived
Soviet Union tracing back to 1989
as a nation state that accepts all as its
sheds light on the significance of
free and equal citizens and despite the
“bodies as symbolic vehicles” (p. 27)
allusion to change/transformation in
that are able to transcend their
the social setup at the end of Samskara
corporeality/materiality and take on
In this paper, emphasis is placed on new meaning as political symbols.
the images of Naranappa’s and Verdery (1999) brings in the example
Douloti’s corpses to examine the ways of the popularity of relics during
in which they stand as symbols for the medieval times (i.e. the physical
putrefying Indian society and culture, remains of saints) to drive home the
be it pre-Independence or post- point that “bodies have the advantage
Independence India, highlighting the of concreteness that nonetheless
caste-ridden Indian society’s refusal to transcends time, making past
accept change and adopt a more immediately present” (p.27). New
progressive and more humane stance significance and new meaning (of the
towards all human beings. The paper kind that were nonexistent when alive)
seeks to draw lines of comparison can be infused into a dead body which
between the metaphor of the body in thereafter becomes a symbol for the
both works and the overall moribund sociopolitical implications of the world
body politic of Indian culture/nation to it was a part of when alive.
underscore the ways in which both Zoe Crossland (2009) in a paper
works cry out for the dire need for anchored in the field of forensic
transformation in the oppressively anthropology draws upon the
stagnant Indian culture/nation. In discourse of the exhumation and
doing so, the trope of the subsequent analysis of human remains
body/cadaver is taken as a focal point and the wider implications of the said
and examined as a potent process. Crossland (2009) underscores
signifier/symbol of widespread socio- the idea that agency is infused into
political ramifications. human remains that are given “the
ability to speak (truthfully) about their
170
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
histories” (p. 75) endowing them with power/agency by escaping the throes
a “life of [their] own” (p. 76). Michel of the societal forces that had tried to
Foucault (as cited in Crossland, 2009) claw at it when alive.
in The Birth of the Clinic (1973) sheds
DISCUSSION/ANALYSIS
light on the changing practices of
physicians at the end of the eighteenth Analysis of U.R. Ananthamurthy’s
century and underscores the Samskara
developments made by them in
Death permeates the entirety of
diagnosing illnesses based on the
Ananthamurthy’s novel and translator
symptoms displayed by the body.
A.K Ramanujan in his Afterword to
Hence, the dead body became for
Samskara states, “The opening event is
these physicians, a valuable source of
a death, an anti-brahminical brahmin’s
information/insight into the elusive
death and it brings in its wake a
origins of illnesses which in turn
plague, many deaths, questions
brought about a better understanding
without answers…and the rebirth of
of the living (Crossland, 2009, p. 71).
one good Brahmin, Praneshacharya
Foucault (2003) in a lecture dated 17 (Ananthamurthy, 2016, p. 123)”. The
March 1976 spoke of “techniques used term “rebirth” is significant in this
to take control over bodies” in the context since it connotes the meaning
seventeenth and eighteenth centuries of life after death. Praneshacharya, the
with “devices that were used to ensure highly respected Brahmin leader of the
the spatial distribution of individual agrahara at Durvasapura, revered for
bodies (their separation, their miles around as the “Crest-Jewel of
alignment, their serialization, and their Vedic Learning” (Ananthamurthy,
surveillance )” (p. 242) through 2016, p. 16), in the wake of
institutions such as schools, hospitals, Naranappa’s death has a sexual
barracks, etc. Foucault identifies this encounter with Naranappa’s outcaste
seizure of power over the individual mistress Chandri that shatters the
body as the essential first step with the whole of his existence and hitherto
second step following soon after in the held worldviews. One may question
form of mass scale population control whether Praneshacharya’s “rebirth”
through processes such as “the ratio of following his sexual encounter with
births to deaths, the rate of Chandri and the existential crisis that
reproduction, the fertility of a follows which forces him to shed his
population, and so on” (p. 243). Brahminism altogether is a prefiguring
Foucault (2003) further states that of the “rebirth” of India, the new
“death is beyond the reach of power, Indian “nation” that was expected to
and power has a grip on it only in emerge following Independence from
general, overall, or statistical terms” the shackles of British rule.
(p. 245). Hence, one can state that the
body upon death takes on a newfound
171
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
At the very end of the book it is stated dead man was grisly, disfigured”
that “Pranesharya waited, anxious, (Ananthamurthy, 2016, p. 61).
expectant” (Ananthamurthy, 2016, p.
113) as he sat in a cart on his way back He wields just as much influence over
to Durvasapura, uncertain how his the other Brahmins in death as he did
transformation and transgression in life, the stench of his bloated,
would be received by the other decomposing corpse being what rings
Brahmins. Can this be an allusion to the death knell for the agrahara:
the run up to Indian Independence?
“Ayyayyo, look, look!” A vulture on
The tides were swiftly changing, the
the roof was an omen of death.
old order was shifting, and a new
Nothing like it had ever happened
uncertainty had gripped the nation. As
before…Garudacharya lifted his
mentioned previously, the novella was
head and looked into the dazzling
originally published in 1965 and could
heat above. He saw vultures,
thus also be seen as a commentary and
vultures, vultures in the blue blue
a looking back at an independent
sky reeling, gliding, spiraling circle
nation state that had failed to live up
below circle, descending.
to its promise.
(Ananthamurthy, 2016, p. 55)
According to Indubala Pandya (1987),
Meenakshi Mukherjee’s comments
Praneshacharya’s thoughts after he
(1994) are significant in this context:
sleeps with Naranappa’s mistress are
significant: “Naranappa’s death, instead of
being his defeat, turns out to be a
“[he] keeps comparing himself to
victory…the corpse of Naranappa
Naranappa so often that it is clear
seems to swell gradually and fill up
that he identifies himself with that
the whole agrahara in a
unorthodox Brahmin. It would not
metaphorical as well as real sense”
be an exaggeration, therefore, to
(p. 174).
say that the new Praneshacharya
rises out of the dead Naranappa”. Naranappa’s boldness, his unabashed
(p. 144) assertion of his individualism and his
disillusionment with the hypocrisy
Naranappa, the rogue Brahmin
and barrenness of Brahmin society
proudly and openly flouts all rules of
stand out and his rotting cadaver can
orthodox Brahmin society and he is
be considered as symbolic of the
literally a plague on the agrahara in
cadaver of the Hindu Indian culture
death just as he was in life:
against which he rebelled.
“The dead body was reeking. The
Verdery (1999) underscores the
belly was swollen, the face of the
following point about the dead body:
172
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
“a body’s materiality can be critical “Your texts and rites don’t work
to its symbolic efficacy…for anymore. The Congress Party is
instance, a corpse can be moved coming to power, you’ll have to
around, displayed, and open up the temples to all
strategically located in specific outcastes” (Ananthamurthy, 2016,
places” (p. 27). p. 26).
173
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
174
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
was hoped for has not become a them, their sole preoccupation in life
reality, at least for the subalterns of being the struggle for survival.
society. Spivak (1989) speaking of
Nandini Bhattacharya (2007) calls
Mahasweta Devi states that she as a
Bakha, the outcaste protagonist in
writer:
Mulk Raj Anand’s novel Untouchable
“lingers in postcoloniality, in the “the alien within the nation” (p. xi).
space of difference, in decolonized Similarly, Douloti and the others of
terrain. Her material often contains her caste are all “aliens within the
problematic representations of nation”. They do not even know what
decolonization after a negotiated the nation/country is as is evidenced
political independence” [emphasis by Rajbi, the washerwoman’s
given] (p. 105). exclamation:
can I be sixty? I have heard that our hard on him. Tohri hospital is
brave master is fifty? I am Ghasi by eleven miles away. Bhuneswar and
caste, and poor. How can I have others take him there on a wood-
more age than he?” (Devi, 1995, p. and-rope cot. After three months
32). he returns with his body broken
and becomes Crook Nagesia” (p.
The census and the elections play an
34).
important role in the constitution and
rehearsal of the nation state and their For Douloti, the curse of her bonded
utter foreignness to the kamiya prostitution (during which her body is
labourers simply underscores the ploughed and plundered) begins as a
gravity of their plight. Foucault’s view result of her father Ganori’s injury
(2003) of such forms of population which leaves his body broken and
control as a “seizure of power” that is crooked. The responsibility of paying
directed “not at man[sic]-as-body but out the debt falls on Douloti’s
at man[sic]-as-species” (243) is shoulders and as a “kamiya whore”,
significant in this instance. Foucault her body is exploited, over and over
(2003) views such forms of control as again by sexual predators for whom
regulatory mechanisms used to she is nothing but an object to be made
“establish an equilibrium, maintain an use of and discarded:
average, establish a sort of
“Douloti has taken the yoke of
homeostasis” (p. 246) in the society at
Crook's bond-slavery on her
large. In “Douloti the Bountiful”, an
shoulders. Now Latia is her client,
India that was just starting to raise its
her body is tight. Then going down
head from the throes of British colonial
and down Douloti will be as
power makes use of such mechanisms
skeletal as Somni. She will repay
as the census and the elections in a bid
the bond-slavery loan as a beggar
to regain some of the control it had
(Devi, 199, p. 72).
been denied as a nation for so long.
The women in the brothel are not
However, the point of origin for such
considered as humans beings; they are
mass scale control is the individual
merely “kamiya whores” reduced to
and by extension, the individual body
machines, automatons, mere tools
and throughout the story Devi (1995)
existing only to gratify the base desires
uses the metaphor of the body of the
of the high caste men and churn out
kamiya labourer as the ground on
the money.
which sexual and economic
exploitation at the hands of the Rampiyari, the madam of the brothel
privileged upper castes takes place: sings:
“Ganori tries to lift the cart by the “These are all Paramananda's
strength of his shoulders. Trying, kamiyas/ Douloti and Reoti and
he falls on his face. The axle sits Somni /….The boss has turned
176
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
them into land /The boss ploughs “Who will light the fire Prasadji?
and ploughs their land and raises There is no one to light the
the crop/They are all fire…There are people for passing
Paramananda's kamiya” (Devi, laws, there are people to ride jeeps,
1995, p. 59). but no one to light the fire” (Devi,
1995, p. 88).
Their bodies have become land to be
ploughed and made use of. Their Ultimately, Douloti’s plight is no
situation in life as “kamiya whores” is different from the plight of Kalabati,
such that they own absolutely nothing, her predecessor as Latia, the wealthy
not even their own bodies which are at contractor’s personal kamiya whore:
the mercy of those with the power to
“He was much taken by Kalabati.
own them and draw a profit out of
She got a belly in two months. I
them until they are drained of their
dosed her. But the medicine was
very lifeblood:
strong. On the third day passing
“I’m a kamiya whore. I’ll of course blood like water. I ran to the
be kicked out when my carcass medicine man. In the meantime
shrivels” (Devi, 1995, p. 68). Latia, dead drunk, entered
Kalabati’s room…The girl died.
Ironically, not even the political
The police came. Latiaji gave
“activists” who claim to make a case
money and arranged everything.
for tribals and outcastes actually do
(Devi, 1995, p. 61)
something for them. "What is to be
done?" (Devi, 1995, p. 85) asks one The story ends with the heart-
Prasad Mahato several times and the wrenching image of Douloti’s
white missionary, Father Bomfuller damaged body, brutalized by years of
merely takes depositions from the sexual exploitation and infected with
women and claims he has started on a venereal disease:
survey entitled "The Incidence of
“…here lies bonded labor spread-
Bonded Labor" (Devi, 1995, p. 85)
eagled, kamiya-whore Douloti
which is simply filed away in New
Nagesia’s tormented corpse,
Delhi and consigned to oblivion.
putrified with venereal disease,
Only Bono Nagesia, Douloti’s fellow having vomited up all the blood in
villager, his heart aching at the sight of its desiccated lungs…Douloti is all
Douloti’s shriveled form, understands over India” (Devi, 1995, p. 93).
the need for immediate action and
bemoans the lack of it: "You will leave
CONCLUSION
after hearing it all?" (Devi, 1995, p. 87),
he asks and then makes the following Both these stories are located in an
poignant statement: India that is supposedly on the path
towards change and modernity but the
177
Journal of Social Sciences and Humanities Review (JSSHR)
Vol. 5, No. 3 (168-178)
© Author(s) 2020
ISSN: 2279-3933
Original Article
metaphor/symbol for
festering/moribund ideals and a
calling out for the dire need for change
and rejuvenation in the Indian nation
and society.
178