Milestones in The History of Diabetes Mellitus: The Main Contributors
Milestones in The History of Diabetes Mellitus: The Main Contributors
MINIREVIEWS
such as Aretaeus of Cappadocia, Thomas Willis, Claude                   that diabetes affects primarily the rich castes and is
Bernard, Oskar Minkowski, Joseph von Mering, Frederick                  related to the excessive food consumption as the rice,
Banting and Charles Best is mentioned, in an attempt to                 cereals and sweets .
                                                                                            [6]
highlight the development of our current knowledge in                       In ancient China, Chang Chung-Ching (ca. 160-ca.
diabetes mellitus.                                                      219), referred to as “the Chinese Hippocrates”, des
                                                                        cribed polyuria, polydipsia and loss of weight as
                                                                                                                       th
                                                                        symptoms of a specific disease, while in 7 century
Karamanou M, Protogerou A, Tsoucalas G, Androutsos G,                   AD Chen Chuan recorded the sweet urine in diabetes
Poulakou-Rebelakou E. Milestones in the history of diabetes             mellitus and named the disease Hsiao kho ping
mellitus: The main contributors. World J Diabetes 2016; 7(1): 1-7
                                                                        mentioning its characteristic symptoms: intense thirst,
Available from: URL: http://www.wjgnet.com/1948-9358/full/
                                                                        copious drinking and large amounts of urine which is
v7/i1/1.htm DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.4239/wjd.v7.i1.1
                                                                        tasted sweet. In an attempt to treat that disease his
                                                                        colleague Li Hsuan proposed the abstinence from wine,
                                                                                     [6]
                                                                        salt and sex .
                                                                                         th
                                                                            From the 8 century onwards, physicians observed
INTRODUCTION                                                            the tendency of diabetic patients to develop skin
Diabetes mellitus is a group of metabolic diseases                      infections as furuncles, rodent ulcers and troubles of
                                                                                             th
involving carbohydrate, lipid, and protein metabolism.                  the eyesight. In 11 century AD, the celebrated Arabo-
It is characterized by persistent hyperglycemia, as a                   islamic physician Avicenna (980-1037) in his textbook
result of defects in insulin secretion, insulin action or a             El-Kanun (Canon of Medicine) described diabetes and
combination of both, defective secretion and incorrect                  mentioned gangrene and sexual dysfunction as its
action. There are two main types of diabetes mellitus:                  complication. Years later, the medieval scholar Moises
Type 1 (insulin-dependent), and type 2 (non-insulin-                    Maimonides (1138-1204) described in detail diabetes,
                                                                                                            [6]
dependent). Type 1 diabetes results by the autoimmune                   including the symptoms of acidosis .
destruction of the β-cells of the pancreatic islets                         Ancient Egyptians, Indians, Chinese and Arabs tried
and type 2 diabetes is caused from impaired insulin                     to describe the clinical signs and symptoms of diabetes
                                                        [1]
secretion and resistance to the action of insulin .                     mellitus. However, few are the main protagonists in the
Current epidemiological data reveal that 9% of adults,                  history of diabetes mellitus who contributed significantly,
18 years of age and older, has diabetes mellitus while                  not only to its diagnosis and treatment but also to the
it was estimated that in 2012, 1.5 million people died                  development of our current notions on the disease,
due to the disease. According to the World Health                       paving the way for further study and establishing a new
                                       th
Organization, diabetes will be the 7 leading cause of                   medical sub specialty, diabetology.
                [2-4]
death in 2030 .
    The disease has a long history reaching back into
antiquity. However, during that period, due to a poor                   ARETAEUS OF CAPPADOCIA (2nd
knowledge of anatomy, pathophysiology and lack                          CENTURY AD) AND THE FIRST
of diagnostic tools, the disease remained extremely
perplexing to physicians.                                               ACCURATE DESCRIPTION OF DIABETES
    Nevertheless, physicians in antiquity observed the                  Aretaeus, surnamed the Cappadocian, is probably the
distinctive features of diabetes and proposed several                   greatest physician of the Greco-Roman antiquity after
therapeutic approaches. In Ebers papyrus, dated back                    Hippocrates, and at least equal of Galen. He was born
to 1500 BC, we may find passages describing patients                    in Cappadocia, a region in eastern Asia Minor, studied
who suffer from excessive thirst, copious urination and                 medicine in Alexandria and practiced in Rome probably
                                                                                        nd
they are treated by plants’ extracts. However, according                during the 2 century AD. Areataeus’ medical practice
to the Egyptian endocrinologist, historian of medicine                  was based on the principals of the Pneumatic school
and translator of the Ebers papyrus Paul Ghalioungui                    believing not only in the vital role of pneuma (air) but
(1908-1987), the description of a probable diabetes,                    embracing also the theory of the four humors (heat,
in Ebers, is regarded as unsatisfactory and probably                    coldness, moisture, dryness). In his two treatises, De
wrong. In Kahun papyrus (c. 2000 BC) there is just                      causis et signis morborum acutorum et diuturnorum (on
the title of a recipe for the “Treatment of a thirsty                   the causes and symptoms of acute and chronic diseases)
                                  [5]
woman”, but the text is missing . So, we may assume                     and De curatione morborum acutorum et diuturnorum
that ancient Egyptians could not recognize behind the                   (on the cure of acute and chronic diseases), written in
symptoms of specific disease entity such as diabetes.                   Ionic dialect, Aretaeus impresses us by the vividness
                      th
    Around the 5 century BC, the famous Indian                          and the simplicity of his descriptions. Among others
surgeon Sushruta, in his work Samhita, identified                       he described, in an accurate way for his time, leprosy,
diabetes, by using the term madhumeha (honey-like                       asthma, pneumonia cancer, tetanus, hysteria, epilepsy,
                                                                             [7,8]
urine) and pointed out not only the sweet taste of the                  gout       (Figure 1).
urine but also its sticky feeling to the touch and its                      Before Aretaeus, ancient Greek medical authors
                                                                                                             st
ability to attract the ants (!). Sushruta further mention               such as Rufus of Ephesus (c. 1 century AD) and
Figure 3 Sites of punctures of 4th ventricle from Bernard’s book «Leçons       Figure 4 The Nobel laureate Frederick Banting in his laboratory with a
sur la Physiologie et la Pathologie du Système Nerveux», 1858. (Source:        dog. (Source: Wellcome Library, London).
Wellcome Library, London).
                                 th                                        th
                              17 century,                               19 century,
                                                                                                th
       nd
      2 century AD,                                   th
                                                    19 century,                              20 century,
Figure 5 Timeline table presenting the main contributors in the history of diabetes mellitus.
the discovery of a substance capable to control diabetes.                           Leonard Thompson a 14-year-old boy treated for
                                                                                                                     [13]
Influenced by this article, Banting focused on the study                            diabetes in Toronto Hospital . It’s worth mentioning
              [13]
of diabetes . During that period the distinguished                                  that after the introduction of Apollinaire Bouchar
English physiologist Ernest Starling (1886-1927) was                                dat’s (1806-1886) pioneering dietary treatment for
mentioning: “We don’t know yet how the pancreas                                     diabetes, physicians repeated in several generations of
affects sugar production or utilization in the same                                 diabetics his motto: “mangez le moins possible” (eat
                                                                                                          [21,22]
animal. It is generally assumed that it secretes into the                           as little as possible)       . Thomson was also following
bloodstream a hormone which may pass to the tissues                                 a strict fasting diet proposed by Frederick Madison
and enable them to utilize sugar or pass to the liver                               Allen (1879-1964) and he was in critical state. He
and inhibit the sugar production of this organ… but we                              received 15 mL of insulin, injected in his buttock
have been unable to imitate the action of the pancreas                              but he developed abscesses at the injection site and
still in vascular connection with the body, by injection or                         became even sicker. Collip further improved the quality
                                                 [18]
administration of the extracts of this organ” .                                     of insulin and on January 23, Thompson received a
     On 16 May 1921, Banting started to collaborate with                            second injection. The results were excellent. His blood
Charles Best, a young medical student. Experimenting                                glucose from 520 mg/dL fell to 120 mg/dL in 24 h and
in dogs they initially ligate the pancreatic ducts,                                 urinary ketones disappeared. Thompson continued
achieving atrophy of the exocrine region and almost ten                             the treatment with insulin and lived another 13 years.
                                                                                                                               [13]
weeks later they removed dog’s degenerated pancreas.                                He died of pneumonia at 27 years old . Similar is
They crushed the atrophied pancreatic glands in a cool                              the story of Elizabeth Hughes Gossett (1907-1981).
mortar and froze it in salt water. Then the mass was                                Daughter of the United States politician Charles Evans
ground down and added to 100 mL of physiological                                    Hughes, Elisabeth was diagnosed with diabetes at age
salt. Afterwards, they administrated 5 mL of this extract                           11. Initially she was also treated by Allen and in August
intravenously to a depangreatized dog. Within 2 h its                               1922 began the use of insulin. She survived, graduated
blood sugar had considerably dropped. They repeated                                 from College, got married, had three children and died
                                                                                                                               [23]
several times the experiment with other diabetic dogs,                              suddenly of a heart attack at 74 years old .
gaining similar results and they experimented also with                                  The pioneering work of Banting and Best saved
fetal calf pancreas using different ways of administration                          millions of lives and diabetics started to live a normal
                                   [19,20]
such as subcutaneous and rectal            (Figure 4).                              life. Lilly Pharmaceutical Company collaborated with the
     At the end of 1921 the skilled chemist James Collip                            two scientists and in 1923 introduced Iletin, the world’s
                                                                                                                                [13]
joined the team and developed a better extraction and                               first commercially available insulin product .
purification technique. Obtained substance was initially                                 However in 1923 the Nobel Committee decided
named by the team insletin and later on by MacLeod                                  to award Banting and MacLeod for insulin’s discovery.
         [13]
insulin .                                                                           Banting became furious as he believed that he should
     The next step was to test insulin in humans. So                                share the prize with Best instead of MacLeod and he
on 11 January 1922, insulin was administrated to                                    decided to share with Best his cash award. In his turn,
                                                 [13]
MacLeod shared also his award with Collip .                               2     Global status report on non communicable diseases 2014. Geneva:
    Another black spot in the history of insulin discovery                      World Health Organization, 2012
                                                                          3     World Health Organization. Global health estimates: Deaths by
was also the discovery of pancreatin, an extract of
                                                                                cause, age, sex and country, 2000-2012. Geneva: World Health
bovine pancreas discovered by the Romanian Professor                            Organization, 2014
of Physiology Nicolae Constantin Paulescu (1869-1931)                     4     Mathers CD, Loncar D. Projections of global mortality and burden
in 1916, published a few years later because of the war                         of disease from 2002 to 2030. PLoS Med 2006; 3: e442 [PMID:
in 1921 and patented in April 1922. Even if Paulescu                            17132052 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pmed.0030442]
was the first to provide a detailed demonstration of the                  5     Ghalioungui P. The Ebers papyrus: A new English translation,
                                                                                commentaries and glossaries. Cairo: Academy of Scientific
antidiabetic and antiketogenic effect of a pancreatic
                                                                                Research and Technology, 1987
extract, pancreatine was not used in humans and                           6     Peumery JJ. Histoire illustrée du diabète. De l’Antiquité à nos
                    [24]
passed over silently .                                                          jours. Paris: Les Éditions Roger Dacosta, 1987
    A crucial step in the history of diabetes has been                    7     Laios K, Karamanou M, Saridaki Z, Androutsos G. Aretaeus
completed. Over the next years insulin purification                             of Cappadocia and the first description of diabetes. Hormones
methods improved and new insulin formulations were                              (Athens) 2012; 11: 109-113 [PMID: 22450352]
                                                                          8     Adams F. The extant works of Aretaeus the Cappadocian. London:
developed such as Protamine–zinc insulin, a long-acting
                                                                                Sydenham Society, 1856
insulin in 1930s, neutral protamine Hagedorn in 1940s                     9     Furdell EL. Fatal Thirst. Diabetes in Britain until Insulin. Leiden:
                          [13]
and Lente series in 1950s .                                                     Brill, 2009: 81-92
                                                                          10    Willis T. Opera Omnia. Coloniae: Sumptibus Gasparis Storti,
                                                                                1694: 460
CONCLUSION                                                                11    Williamson RT. English Physicians of the past. Newcastle:
                                                                                Andrew Reid and Company, 1923: 47-52
For more than 3000 years physicians quested the
                                                                          12    Grmek M. Le Legs de Claude Bernard. Paris: Fayard, 1997
causes and treatment of diabetes mellitus (Figure                         13    von Engelhardt D, editor. Diabetes: Its medical and cultural
5). However, an important progress has been made                                history. Berlin: Springer-Verlag, 1989: 306-319, 350-358, 411-426
over the last two centuries thanks to the development                     14    Bernard C. Du suc pancréatique et de son rôle dans les phéno
of chemistry, physics and pharmacology. Over the                                mènes de la digestion. C R Soc Acad Sci (Paris) 1850; 1: 99-119
next years scientists continued to make significant                       15    Grmek M. Examen critique de la genèse d’une grande découverte:
                                                                                La piqûre diabétique de Claude Bernard. Clio med 1965; 1:
discoveries: The structure of insulin was delineated in
                                                                                341-350
1955 by the Nobel laureate Fred Sanger (1918-2013);                       16    von Mering J, Minkowski O. Diabetes mellitus nach Pankreas
in 1967 proinsulin was discovered by Donald Steiner                             extirpation. Arch f exper Path u Pharmakol 1889; 26: 371 [DOI:
(1930-2014) and with his colleagues he produced the                             10.1007/BF01831214]
radioimmunoassay for C-peptide which is used today to                     17    Barron M. The relation of the Islets of Langerhans to Diabetes.
measure endogenous insulin production; in the same                              Surg Gynecol Obstet 1920; 31: 437-448
                                                                          18    Medvei VC. The History of Clinical Endocrinology: A Com
year, the first pancreas transplant in a human was
                                                                                prehensive Account of Endocrinology from Earliest Times to the
performed by William Kelly, Richard Lillehei (1927-1981)                        Present Day. New York: Parthenon, 1993: 253
and colleagues at the University of Minnesota; in 1972                    19    Banting FG, Best CH, Collip JB, Cambell WR, Fletcher AA,
the U100 insulin was introduced to promote better                               Macleod JJR, Noble EC. The Effect Produced on Diabetes by
accuracy in administration; ten years later, in 1982,                           Extractions of Pancreas. Transact Ass Amer Physicians 1922; 37:
recombinant human insulin became available and                                  337
                                                                          20    Banting FG, Best CH, Macleod JJR. The internal secretion of the
in early 1990’s insulin pen delivery devices become
                                                                                pancreas. Am J Physiol 1922; 59: 479
popular following by the discoveries of short (1996) and                  21    Karamanou M, Koutsilieris M, Laios K, Marineli F, Androutsos
                                      [1]
long (2001) acting insulin analogues .                                          G. Apollinaire Bouchardat (1806-1886): founder of modern
    Since biotechnology helps medicine to progress,                             Diabetology. Hormones (Athens) 2014; 13: 296-300 [PMID:
nobody knows what the future will bring. We are sure of                         24776631]
just one thing: History of diabetes is being still written.               22    Bouchardat A. De la glycosurie ou diabète sucré. Son traitement
                                                                                hygiénique. Paris: Baillière, 1875
                                                                          23    Cooper T, Ainsberg A. Breakthrough: Elizabeth Hughes, the
                                                                                Discovery of Insulin, and the Making of a Medical Miracle. New
REFERENCES                                                                      York: St Martin’s Press, 2010
1   Kahn CR, Weir GC, editors. Joslin’s diabetes mellitus, 14th ed.       24    Angelescu C, Nicolae C. Paulescu: Omul şi opera sa medicală.
    Philadelphia: Lippincott, 2005                                              Bucuresti: Vremea, 2009