NIBC Global Competition Overview
NIBC Global Competition Overview
1
Team Welcome
Our team is excited to welcome corporate sponsors and partners to the NIBC 2024-2025 Global Competition
NIBCLive.com
1 Learning: Access to online video tutorials, industry templates, presentations and past case examples
2 Networking: Professionals from top tier investment banks and private equity firms to adjudicate the competition
3 Industry Insights: Speeches by company founders, finance executives and sellside & buyside panels
4 Peers: Unique experience to build global network with 350+ career-driven international peers
Merit-Based: NIBC gives recruits from all geographies a merit-based opportunity to enter the First Round and showcase their skills
FIRST ROUND: Oct 2024 – Dec 2024 (ONLINE) with teams of 2-4 FINAL ROUND: Jan, 2025 (IN PERSON) with finalists giving
producing Corporate Valuation & Strategic Review Transaction Advice to Panel of Managing Directors
Successful competitors must submit “client-ready” pitchbooks Live deal environment featuring authentic current transaction
Competitors receive 100-page case package and model template Finalists receive fully-built financial model to analyze transactions
and have 6-8 weeks to prepare online submission and present in boardrooms and Gala Dinner for $10k+ prize
NIBC was founded on the guiding philosophy of giving students from all background a merit-based
opportunity to develop their careers and be recognized on a global stage
TRAINING Online Competitor Portal Access | Industry Templates | Financial Models | Video Tutorials
COMPETITION Equal Access for All Students | 200+ Universities | 2,000+ Competitors | +$10,000 Prize Pool
CONFERENCE High-Profile Keynote Speakers | Deal Presenters | Sellside & Buyside Panelists
AUDIENCE Final Round Gala Dinner | 350+ Students | 150+ Industry Professionals & Alumni
Competition Timeline:
Registration Opening
▪ Online case resources ▪ DCF, Trading Comparables, Precedent ▪ Pre-built models, data sets, transaction
▪ Research guides, video tutorials Transactions, LBOs templates memo for strategic analysis
industry templates, interview training ▪ Pitchbook and valuation model ▪ 8-hour slot to develop boardroom pitch
▪ One-day skills workshop and ▪ 40-60 teams selected for final round ▪ Present to Managing Director panel at
networking in Western Canada Gala Dinner
Case Materials
Information package with key information and relevant data on EA and Take-Two
Fully-built Excel model with pre-set variable inputs and pre-formatted summary outputs
Director memo from "transaction director" suggesting sequence of analysis and topics of slides
Levered Financing Structures and Debt Metrics Bid Security and Price Protection Mechanisms
INTERVIEW ANSWERS
ONE-PAGE SUMMARY
PRACTICE INTERVIEWS Download
Fireside Chat
Winning Team
NIBC INTERVIEWS
Winning Team KEYNOTES & DEAL PRESENTATIONS
INDUSTRY PANELS
Spencer Eliza William Julia Borna Caiden Charlotte Alina Celeste Radovan Aalon Graydon Tara
Peterson Ponomareva Chen Pastana Massoudi Keller Marron Akhmet Wang Morris Tan Lantz Luo
Team Member Responsibilities Experience & Extracurricular Achievements
Spencer Peterson Director, Competition BMO Capital Markets (Calgary) | Sauder JDC West | Trek Excellence Scholar (Top 5%, 2x)
Eliza Ponomareva Director, Conference Goldman Sachs (New York) | CPPIB | Scotia Wealth Management
William Chen Manager, Case National Bank Financial (Toronto) | NIBC Capital Advisory | Trek Excellence Scholar (Top 5%, 2x)
Julia Pastana Manager, Operations Scotiabank Global Banking and Markets (Toronto) | International Impact Award Scholar
Borna Massoudi Manager, Operations BMO Nesbitt Burns | Head Coach North Vancouver Football Club | ROAD Mentorship Class
Caiden Keller Manager, Operations NIBC Capital Advisory | Vancouver Club | VP Judicial Interfraternity Council | UBC Astrophysics
Charlotte Marron Associate Deutsche Bank (London) | Aspect Capital | Professional Acting | UBC Rocket | Full Undergraduate Scholarship
Alina Akhmet Associate BCI | Emerging Women in Finance Executive Team | McKinsey Challenge Best Communicator Award
Celeste Wang Associate NYU Stern Research Assistant | IMES Scholar | Trek Excellence Scholar (Top 5%)
Radovan Morris Associate NIBC Capital Advisory | 2nd Place Junior Achievement Canada
Aalon Tan Associate OTPP (Toronto) | Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan | Trek Excellence Scholar (Top 5%)
Graydon Lantz Associate NBMS Economics | Planet Hatch Entrepreneurship Centre | 2022 Canada Games Volleyball
Tara Luo Associate IMM Fashion | NIBC Case Competition | Summer Sailing Program Instructor
Rishabh Dagar Oversight Goldman Sachs (New York) | BDC Capital | UBC Sailboat & Robotics
Mehtaab Chandi Oversight GoldenTree Asset Management (New York) | Blockworks | hedge Fund | 2x Tech Startup Foundder & Exit
16
First Round Deliverables
After signing up a team, competitors can access online Submissions are graded against industry standard models &
resources to develop investment banking skills pitchbooks prepared by professionals for each case
B. Valuation Model
Outputs & Assumptions Summary
Discounted Cashflows
Trading Comparables
Precedent Transactions
Video
*Final Tutorials
Round Case Templates Interviews Leveraged Buyout
High Valuation & Lagging M&A Cost Control High Share Strengthen
Low Profits
Market Leadership AAA Titles & Strategy & Strong Price & Core Console
& Strong
in Video Games Customer into Mobile Financial Valuation Segment
Competition
(Console) Reviews & Online Performance Multiple through TTWO
2008: Financial 2012-2013: EA faces some critical 2014: Good performance Titles: TTWO would
crisis resulted in poor consumer reviews for slow in traditional core provide EA with most
performance for product releases and excessive franchises with FIFA 14 successful open world role
global publishers charges for add-on content and Battlefield play franchise GTA and
other valuable franchises
Growth: TTWO is a
growth company and GTA
franchise has untapped
potential which matches
EA's current stock profile
Market Share: Combined
with TTWO, EA would
reclaim its #1 position in
console segment and
overall games markets
Asia: EA may take
advantage of TTWO’s
relationships in Asia to
expand outside of core
North American market
2009-2011: Acquisitions of 2012: Star Wars: The Old 2014: Cost reductions
Accretion: 2018 accretion
PopCap Games and Republic falls short of being and shift to digital
of 3.7% to 13.2% possible
Playfish allowed EA to a major game-changer delivery led to EBITDA
based on synergies from
increase revenue mix to despite an estimated $500m margin +42% YoY in
shared overhead
45% digital budget 2014
21
Event Photo Highlights
O p en i ng I ndu s t r y Add res s
Global Head of Investment Banking, RBC
Derek Neldner Derek Neldner is Head of Global Investment Banking at RBC Capital Markets. Mr. Neldner
has oversight for the firm’s investment banking practices in Canada, the U.S., Europe and
the Asia Pacific region, and has senior client coverage responsibility for a number of RBC
Capital Markets’ most important corporate clients. Mr. Neldner is a member of the firm’s
Operating Committee, the Loan Commitments Committee and the M&A Opinion Review
Committee. He is also a board member of The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids)
Foundation and is a member of the Major Individual Giving campaign cabinet for the United
Way of Toronto & York Region. Mr. Neldner holds a Bachelor of Commerce degree in
Finance from the University of Alberta and holds the Chartered Financial Analyst
designation.
Kathy Butler Kathy Butler is a Managing Director and Regional Head of CIBC Capital Markets. She Joined R. Smallwood Randy Smallwood is the President & CEO of Wheaton Precious Metals which is traded on
the firm 20 years ago and has been involved in numerous mergers & acquisitions and debt the NYSE with a market capitalization of close to $11bn as of March 2019. Wheaton was
and equity financings for clients in technology, telecom and consumer retail. Ms. Butler is the world’s most valuable public company per employee with 24 full-time employees. Mr.
on the board of CIBC World Markets Inc., CIBC Children’s Foundation and St. George’s Smallwood holds a geological engineering degree from the University of British Columbia,
Foundation and a Partner of Social Venture Partners Vancouver. She represented the tech and a mine engineering diploma from the British Columbia Institute of Technology. He was
industry on the BC Jobs and Investment Board and is currently on the Board of Governors of involved in the founding of Wheaton Precious Metals and joined Wheaton full time in 2007
the Business Council of British Columbia. She holds an MBA (Honours) from the Rotman and was appointed President in 2010 and Chief Executive Officer in 2011. Prior to that Mr.
School of Management at the University of Toronto and a Bachelor of Commerce in Finance Smallwood was an instrumental part of the team that built Wheaton River / Goldcorp into
(Honours) from the Sauder School of Business at the University of British Columbia. one of the largest, and importantly, most profitable gold companies in the world.
President & CEO Senior Vice President Vice President Vice President
Wheaton SSR TD BMO
Precious Metals Mining Securities Capital Markets
Noam Samuel Jessica Jeffrey Samantha Erica Sam Ralph Joanne Ashton Syed
Gilead Johnson Zhang Feng Wu Seidel Young Yang Gutwinski Herriott Ahmad
Vice President Analyst Associate Analyst Analyst Vice President Senior Associate Associate Associate Director Associate
New York Calgary London San Francisco New York New York New York New York New York Vancouver Victoria
Carrie Kirkman Carrie Kirkman was most recently President of Global Brands Group Canada, one of the
world’s leading branded fashion accessories, footwear and apparel companies. With almost
three decades of experience in the business of fashion, Carrie Kirkman has established
herself as a leader in the fashion industry in Canada. She has previously held the role of
President and Chief Merchant at Sears Canada, President of The Jones Group Canada as
well as interim President of Nine West Canada. Passionate about empowering women, she
is Chair of the Board of Directors for G(irls)20, a social-profit that aims to mobilize girls and
young women for economic advancement locally and worldwide. Ms. Kirkman also serves
as an Independent Director of the board for Whitehouse Design, a Burnaby-based apparel
design and manufacturing company and sits on the board of directors for the Canadian
Club of Toronto, Canada’s preeminent public affairs podium since 1897.
Gala Dinner
Conference
Opening(Hyatt
Reception
Toronto)
Keynote Speakers
Michele Romanow (Dragons’ Den) & NIBC Team Robert Herjavec (Shark Tank) & NIBC Team
Darren Throop (EntertainmentOne) & NIBC Team Frank Giustra (Lionsgate) | Brett Wilson (FirstEnergy) & NIBC Team
David Rawlings (JP Morgan) & NIBC Team Peter Brown (Canaccord) & NIBC Team