1
USHA JAGANATH LAW
ACADEMY
Registered office: No. 32, Narmadha Nathi Street,
Mahatma Gandhi Nagar, Madurai – 625 014.
Ph: 9994449004, 9994449001. Email:
jaganathassociates@gmail.com
FAMILY LAW – II
(The Mohammedan Law, Christian Law &
The Indian Succession Act, 1925)
(NEW BATCH)
BY
P. Jaganathan, MA., MBA., MMM., ML., (Contracts).,
ML.(Admn., & Lab. Laws).,
(Gold Medalist, & University Rank Holder in Law for all the
three years of Law degree Course)
Usha Jaganathan,M.A., M.A., ML.,
J.P. Arjun, M.A., M.B.A., LL.M.,
Advocates
2
FAMILY LAW – II
(The Mohammedan Law, Christian Law &
The Indian Succession Act, 1925)
(NEW BATCH)
(FOR DEC/JAN 2024 LL.B., EXAMINATIONS)
MOST IMPORTANT AND MOST EXPECTED CHAPTERS
AND QUESTIONS -SIMPLE LANGUAGE
1. SOURCES OF MOHAMMADEN LAW (Quron)
MODEL QUESTIONS
1. Explain the sources of Mohammadan law.
2. Explain the judicial application of classical sources of
Mohammadan law in India.
3. Write Short Notes on: a. Quron b.Custom c. Ijmaas d.
Sunna e. Qiyas f. Imamat g. Taqlid.
Answer
A.CLASSICAL SOURCES OF MOHAMMEDAN LAW
There are four main classical sources of Mohammedan
law.
These are:-
I. Quron or the Holy Kuran:
1. The Quron is the religious book of the Muslims. It is
the primary source of Islam.
2. It contains 6000 verses (sentences) arranged in order.
These verses are given by the Angel Gabriel to the
Prophet Mohammed.
3
3. After the death of the Prophet, the verses were
grouped and given to the world by Phophet’s
assistant Abu Baker.
4. The verses of the Quron deal with legal matters like
inheritance, divorce, guardianship, etc.,
5. Quron is the VOICE of God and it was prepared after
the death of the Prophet.
II. Sunna (Traditions):
It contains the USAGE of the Prophet. It deals with the
principles of Islamic religion.
3.Ijmaas:
It is the SIMILAR thinking of of the Muslim religious
leaders.
If the Ijmas is not against Quron or the Sunna, then it is
valid.
4.Qiyas:
It is made by comparing the above three sources. The
Quron, Sunna, and Ijmaa were compared and a new law
was made.
B. CUSTOM IN MOHAMMEDAN LAW
Custom is not a source of Mohammedan law. Since
Hindus came to Muslim religion, custom also became a
source of Mohammedan law.
C. SOURCES OF MUSLIM LAW IN INDIA
1. The following are the sources of Mohammedan Law.
4
a.Musalman Wakf Validating Act, 1964.
b.Muslims Personal law (Shariat) Application Act,
1937.
c.Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act, 1939.
2. The judgements of Supreme Courts and High Courts.
3. Mohammedan law books written by religious leaders.
4. In Shah Banoo’s case, the Supreme Court held that
the Mohammedan law can be altered, if it is not legal.
2. ESSENTIALS OF MOHAMMADEN LAW
OF MARRIAGE (Nikkah or Shadhi)
(Civil contract)(Muta marriage)
(Irregular-fasid)(Void-batil marriage) (Iddat)
MODEL QUESTIONS
1. “According to Mohammaden law, marriage is a civil
contract” Comment.
2. What are the essentials of valid ‘Nikka’ in
Mohammaden Law?
3. What is a meant by Batil, Fasid and Muta marriage in
Mohammaden Law?
4. What are void and irregular marriages in Mohamaden
law?
5. Define Nikkash. Distinguish between valid, irregular
and void marriages under the Mohammedan law.
6. Write short note on: a) ‘Nikka’ b) Batil c) Fasid d)
Muta marriage e) Option of Puberty (Khyar-ul- bulugh
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
5
According to Mohammaden law, the Mohammedan
marriage is a civil contract. So, all the essentials of a valid
contract are required for Mohammaden marriage.
15 years of age is necessary for puberty. Puberty is the
eligibility for Mohammedan marriage.
The money value of Mohammaden marriage is a called
“Dower”. It is amount the wife receives from the husband
at the time of divorce by husband or death of husband.
B. ESSENTIALS OF A VALID MOHAMMEDAN MARRIAGE
1. The parties to the marriage should have reached
puberty.
2. The parties should be of sound mind.
3. There must be an offer and acceptance at a single
meeting. .
4. The parties to the marriage should not be within the
prohibited relationship. Mother and son, grand
mother and grandson, brother and sister, uncle and
niece etc.,
5. A man cannot marry relationship by affinity. They are
ascendants and descendants of his wife.
6. There are some temporary disqualifications. As long
as such disqualifications exist, the marriage between
the parties cannot take place.
For e.g., a Mohammaden can have a maximum of
four wives at a time. He cannot marry a fifth wife
without divorcing any one of the four wives.
6
7. If the Mohammaden man has already a wife in the
relations of bride’s sister, bride’s aunt or bride’s
niece, then only if the first wife is divorced, the new
bride can be married.
8. There can be no marriage between a non-
Mohammaden male and a Mohammaden female. He
must convert himself to Islam and only then, he can
marry a Mohammaden female.
9. Under Sunni Law, a male Muslim can marry a
Christian woman or a Shia Muslim girl, but cannot
marry a Hindu woman. But, in Shia Law, a male
Muslim can marry only a Muslim woman.
C. ‘BATIL’ (Void) and ‘FASID’ (Irregular)
Invalid marriage under Mahomedan law are divided
into Batil and Fasid.
Void marriages are called ‘Batil’. Irregular marriages are
called ‘Fasid’.
Batil:
It is totally a void marriage. There is actually no
marriage. The children of such marriages are illegitimate.
It arises under the following circumstances:
1. When the parties to the marriage have not attained
the age of 15, i.e. puberty, then the marriage is void.
2. When the parties to the marriage are in prohibited
relationship like mother and son, brother and sister
or wife’s mother or wife’s daughter.
Fasid:
7
The marriage is not totally invalid. Due to the
presence of some temporary disqualification, the marriage
is only irregular. After the removal of such
disqualification, the marriage becomes valid.
D. MUTA MARRIAGE
It means a temporary marriage. The marriage is for a
fixed period.
Essentials:
1. The amount of dower must be fixed. If it is not fixed,
then the marriage becomes void.
2. If the marriage is consummated ( if there is physical
relationship between husband and wife), half the
amount of the dower should be paid to the wife.
3. The period of living together must be fixed.
4. The Muta marriage comes to an end when the fixed
period is over.
5. Divorce cannot take place in Muta marriage, but the
husband by paying the full amount of dower, can put
an end to the marriage even before the expiry of the
term.
6. The children born out of Muta marriage are
legitimate. They can inherit the property of the
parents.
E. IDDAT
8
1. Iddat is four months and ten days from the date of
the death of the former husband. There can not be
any marriage with the widow during this period.
2. If she is pregnant at the time of her husband’s death,
Iddat continues till delivery of child.
3. Iddat need not be observed by a woman where
marriage is not consummated.( Physical relationship)
3. DIVORCE (TALAQ) OR TALAK (LIA)
(Talaq –ul-sunnat) (Zihar)
(Khula) (Mubaraat) (Dissolution of marriage)
MODEL QUESTIONS
1. Define ‘Talaq’ what are the different forms of ‘Talak’?
2. ‘Talaq is an arbitrary power of the husband to dissolve
the marriage’ Comment.
3. Write Short Notes On: (a) TalakHasan or Khula,
(b) TalakAhasan or Mubaraat, (c) Talak-ul-biddat
(Irrevocable divorce), (d) Talak- ul- Bain, (e) Divorce by
mutual consent between husband and wife [Khula],
(f) Mubaraat
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
Talaq or divorce is the power of the husband to
dissolve the marriage at any time without going to the
Court and without assigning any reason.
This is an absolute power of the husband under
Mohamaden law.
B. HUSBAND DIVORCING HIS WIFE
9
There are SIX types of divorce of wife by husband.
1. Talak Ahasan or Khula (Talak for single time)
The husband pronounces ‘Talak’ during a tuhr. “Tuhr”
is the interval between two menstruations.
2. Talak hasan or Mubaraat (Talak for three times):
Talak’ is pronounced during a tuhr. In the next tuhr,
the second pronouncement is made. In the third tuhr,
third pronouncement is made.
3. Talak-ul-biddat (Irrevocable divorce):
Once the Talaq is pronounced by the husband, then
immediately the marriage gets dissolved.
4. Talak-ul-Bain:
The husband pronounces Talak three times.
5. Divorce by mutual consent [Khula]:
It is a type of divorce by mutual consent.
6. Mubaraat:
The husband can offer to release the wife. If the wife
offers to release him, then she loses her dower amount.
C. DISSOLUTION OF MUSLIMS MARRIAGE ACT, 1939
It provides new Grounds to wife only.
1. Husband absconded and not heard of for 4 years.
10
2. If the husband fails to provide the wife with
maintenance for 2 years.
3. Husband sentenced for 7 years imprisonment.
4. Husband failing to perform marital duties for 3 years
without reasonable cause.
5. Insanity of husband for 2 years or suffering from
leprosy or veneral disease.
6. For legal cruelty upon the wife, e.g. beating, ill
treatment, forcing her to immorality etc, are
instances of cruelty.
Recently the Supreme Court has held that Talak is
discriminatory and against Equality before Law and hence
invalid.
4. DOWER (Mahr)
UNIVERSITY QUESTIONS
1. ‘Dower is a mark of respect in which the wife is held by
the husband’ - Comment.
2. Distinguish ‘Prompt dower’ and ‘Deferred dower’.
3. What is a meant byMahr? Whether a deferred Mahrcan
be enforced after the divorce or death of the husband
by the wife?
Answer
Dower is a mark of respect in which the husband
holds the wife.
TYPES OF DOWER
Dower may be divided into two types namely.
11
1. Prompt dower
2. Deferred dower
1. Prompt dower:
i. This is payable on demand by the wife, if it is not
stated at the time of the marriage.
ii. The entire dower is considered as prompt dower in
the Shia law whereas half dower as prompt dower and
half as deferred dower in Sunni or Hanafi law.
Musthan Sahib (vs) Assam Bibi
It was held that when the wife makes a demand for
prompt dower, it becomes a debt and as such the wife can
sue for the recovery of the debt within a period of three
years. If she fails to do so, the debt becomes barred by
limitation.
If no demand is made by the wife, on the death of the
husband or divorce, the dower becomes a debt which is
enforceable within three years, immediately after the
husband’s death or divorce from him.
2. Deferred Dower:
1. Deferred dower is payable only on the dissolution of
the marriage or on the death of the husband.
2. The husband enjoys an absolute and arbitrary power
of divorcing the wife at any time without assigning
any reasons whatsoever. So, the deferred dower acts
as a security to the wife and it is usually very high.
3. If there is no divorce, then the deferred dower
becomes payable only on the death of the husband.
4. Immediately on the death of the husband, the
deferred dower becomes a debt, which is recoverable
12
with in a period of three years subject to the law of
limitation.
5. If the wife is in possession of her deceased husband’s
property, then she can claim the debt from the
income of her deceased husband’s property.
C. ENFORCEMENT OF DOWER
The following are the remedies available for a
divorced woman or widow to enforce the dower debt:
1. Enforcement of dower in case of divorce:
i. If the husband is alive and if the wife is not yet
divorced, the prompt dower is immediately payable
on demand by the wife.
ii. However, the deferred dower becomes payable only
after divorce by the husband. The divorce should not
be by the way of Khula (divorce by waiving the dower
amount) or Mubarat (divorce by mutual consent).
iii. The dower debt is an unsecured debt and so, it is an
actionable claim and ranks rateably with the other
unsecured debts of the deceased husband. The
limitation period is three years as in case of a general
debt.
iv. If the wife is in possession of her husband’s property
after the divorce, she can utilise the property to
satisfy her debt. There is no limitation period for this.
v. If the husband, after divorcing the wife, has several
unsecured creditors, the secured wife stands in a
priority position to other creditors. She can claim her
dower amount.
13
vi. If there is no divorce, only the general creditors have
priority over the wife.
2. Enforcement of dower after death (wife’s lien for
dower):
i. When there is no divorce, the deferred dower
becomes payable only after the husband’s death.
ii. If the prompt dower is not demanded by the wife
during her husband’s lifetime, then it becomes
payable only after her husband’s death, and in this
aspect, prompt dower is deemed to be deferred
dower.
iii. If she is in possession of her husband’s property in
lien of her dower debt, she can retain possession
against the other heirs and creditors of her husband.
iv. A possessory lien enables the widow to possess
without going to the Court. On the death of the
widow, the possessory lien is inherited by her heirs.
5. LAW OF MAINTENANCE
(NAFKAH) (PARENTAL RIGHTS)
UNIVERSITY QUESTIONS
1. “The maintenance of wife and children is a primary
obligation under Muslim law”. Explain and state the
conditions subject to the satisfaction of maintenance
which can be enforced in a Court of law.
2. State the provisions of Muslim law relating to
maintenance of wife and children.
14
3. Write short note on: a) Maintenance of Wife
b) Maintenance of Children c) Maintenance of Poor
Relatives d) Maintenance of Aged Parents
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
In legal sense, maintenance means three things:
1. Food
2. Clothing
3. Lodging (House)
B. DUTY OF MAINTENANCE
A person is liable under three heads:
1. Liability for wife
2. Liability for relatives
3. Maintenance of Children
1. The maintenance of wife and children is an important
duty of a person under Muslim law.
2. A Muslim should provide maintenance to their elders
and youngsters.
3. Only persons who are poor are entitled to
maintenance
4. The right of maintenance changes according to
various conditions.
C. MAINTENANCE OF WIFE
1. The wife has an absolute right to maintenance. The
husband is bound to maintain her.
15
2. The husband is bound to maintain his wife, if she has
attained puberty.
3. If the husband refuses to maintain his wife, she may
file a case for maintenance.
D. MAINTENANCE OF WIFE DURING IDDAT
1. Iddat is a period between the death or divorce and
starting of another life by the woman.
2. She is alone and does not marry another person
during such period.
3. A woman is entitled to maintenance during the period
of iddat.
E. NO MAINTENANCE TO WIFE
The wife is not entitled to maintenance under the
following circumstances:
1. If the wife refuses to live with the husband
unreasonably.
2. When she is not obedient and rudely behaves.
3. Due to her own fault, she separates herself from the
husband.
4. If she becomes a widow.
5. In the case of an illegal marriage.
6. When the wife is very young and not fit for sexual
intercourse.
16
F. MAINTENANCE UNDER AGREEMENT
If there is an agreement between the husband and
wife, then she can claim maintenance from her husband.
Mohammaden Ahmed Khan Vs. ShahBano Begum
(Shah Bano’s case)
The Supreme Court held that a wife can claim
maintenance in addition to dower.
The Parliament overruled the above Supreme Court
judgement by passing Muslim Women (Protection of
Rights)on Divorce Act, 1986.
According to this Act, the husband need not pay
maintenance, if the dower is paid in full.
G. MAINTENANCE OF CHILDREN (SON AND DAUGHTER)
1. A father should maintain his sons till they are minors
and to maintain his daughters till they are married.
2. If the child has personal source of income, he cannot
claim maintenance from his father.
3. If the father is very poor and unable to maintain the
children, the mother must maintain them, if she has
income.
4. If father and mother are poor, then the grand father
(maternal or paternal) has to maintain the children.
5. If a daughter refuses to live with father, she cannot
claim maintenance.
17
6. WAKF AND TYPES OF WAKF (MUTAWALLI -
POWERS AND DUTIES)(THE WAKF VALIDATING ACT,
1913)
UNIVERSITY QUESTIONS
1. a) Define “Wakf” and point out the essentials of
“Wakf”
b) What are the changes brought about by the Wakf
Act of 1913.
2. Discuss the salient features of the Mussalman Wakf
Validating Act, 1913. Discuss the circumstance,
which led to the passing of the Act.
3. What is a Wakfalal-aulad (family wakf)? Do they
offend the rule against perpetuity?
4. Short Notes on: Wakf-alal-aulad, Sajjadanashin,
Mosque.
5. Who is a Mutawalli? Examine the scope of his
powers over Wakf property.
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
1. ‘Wakf’ means giving of property to the ownership of
God for religious or charitable ( free) purposes.
2. The person who gives the property is called the
Wakif.
3. The Wakif may appoint a Manager to administrate the
property. Such person is called Mutawalli.
B. CREATION OF WAKF
Creation of Wakf is by the following methods-
a. By giving
18
b. By a will.
C. ESSENTIALS OF VALID WAKF
1. The Wakif should be the owner of giving property.
2. The giving of property should be for religious, or
charitable purposes. Eg., giving property to poor, etc.
3. The property of Wakf must be permanent.
4. It should not be conditional. . If it is conditional, it is
void.
5. The Wakf may be created orally or in writing. If the
value of the Wakf is above Rs. 100/- it must be
written and registered. The written deed is known as
Wakfnama.
D. PROPERTIES OF WAKF
Any movable or immovable property can be given to
Wakf (E.g. Cash, Government promissory note, Share of a
company etc.,).
The property must be certain and specified.
E. RIGHTS OF WAKIF (creator of wakf)
1. The Wakif can pay his debts or pay for his own
maintenance.
2. A Wakif cannot take back any property given to the
Wakf.
3. He cannot change the purpose of the Wakf.
F. BENEFICIARIES OF WAKF
1. A Wakf can be created for the benefit of the following:
19
a.For the rich or poor
b.For the poor only.
c.For the rich in the beginning, but finally for the
poor.
2. Wakf may be for all religious purposes.
3. Any non- Muslim can also be the beneficiary,
G. OFFICE OF MUTAWALLI
1. Wakf is managed by a manager called Mutawalli.
2. The Mutawalli should be a major and of sound mind.
3. The Mutawalli does not own Wakf property. He is only
a Manager and Supervisor.
4. The salary of a Mutawalli is fixed in the Wakfnama. If
it is not specified, the Court can fix his salary.
5. The property of a Wakf is not liable for attachment by
court order.
H. DUTIES OF MUTAWALLI
1. The Mutawalli protects the Wakf property, and must
do his duties with care and honesty.
2. He cannot transfer the Wakf property.
3. A Mutawalli cannot create a permanent lease of the
Wakf property.
4. A Mutawalli cannot transfer his office to another
person.
20
5. Mutawalli should not misuse the Wakf property.
6. The Mutawalli must obtain the Court’s permission for
transferring the Wakf property.
I. POWERS OF MUTAWALLI
1. He can grant a lease not more than 3 years. If it is a
non-agricultural property, he can grant lease for not
more than one year.
2. The power to nominate the succeeding Mutawalli is
given to the first Mutawalli.
3. He can file a case for a declaration that he is the
Mutawalli.
J. MUSSALMAN WAKF VALIDATING ACT, 1913
Due to the protest made by the Muslims, the
Mussalman Wakf Validating Act, 1913 was passed.
According to it, Wakf can be created for the following
purposes also.
1. For the maintenance and support of his family or
children, and
2. It can also be created for his maintenance during his
lifetime or for the payment of his debts.
7. DIVISION OF LEGAL HEIRS IN HANAFI LAW
(SUNNI LAW) AND THEIR SHARES
MODEL QUESTIONS
21
1. Discuss the rights of the father, mother and true
grandfather to inherit the property under Hanafi law.
2. Critically examine the rights of inheritance of the
three principal classes of heirs under Sunni law.
3. State the rules relating to succession among blood
relationship under Hanafi law.
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
The principal heirs are related to the deceased by
marriage and blood.
The legal heirs are divided into three categories.
1. Sharers 2. Residuaries 3. Distant Kindred
The inheritance takes place only in the absence of a
will written by the deceased. This is known as intestate
Succession.
B. DIVISION OF LEGAL HEIRS
I. SHARERS
Sharers include husband, wife, father, mother,
daughter, full brother, full sister, half brother, uterine
brother, consanguine brother, half sister, true grandfather
and true grandmother and son’s daughter.
1. Husband
1. If the wife dies intestate, the husband becomes a
sharer.
2. Under Mohammaden Law, there cannot be more than
one husband.
3. In the presence of child or son’s child, his share is
1/4.
22
4. In the absence of child or son’s child, his share is 1/2.
2. Wife
1. If the husband dies intestate, the wife becomes a
sharer.
2. If there are more than one wife, then the allotted
share is divided equally among the widows.
3. In the presence of child or son’s child, her share is
1/8.
4. In the absence of child or son’s child, her share is 1/4.
3. Father
1. In the presence of child or son’s child, his share is
1/6.
2. In the absence of child or son’s child, he becomes a
residuary.
4. Mother
1. In the presence of child or son’s child, her share is
1/6.
2. In the absence of child or son’s child, but in presence
of two brothers or two sisters or one brother and one
sister, her share is 1/8.
3. If there is father, husband or wife, 1/3rd after
deducting husbands or wife’s share.
5. Daughter
1. In the presence of a son, she becomes a residuary
and her share is in the ratio of 1:2 i.e. half of the
sons, share.
23
2. In the absence of son, her share becomes 1/2.
3. If there are two or more daughters, then their share
is 2/3 equally divided among themselves.
6. Full Brother
1. He is excluded in the presence of child, sons child,
father or true grandfather (both maternal and
paternal).
2. In the absence of the above persons, his share is 1/6.
3. If there are two or more brothers, then their share is
1/3 divided equally among themselves.
4. In the presence of sister, he becomes a residuary and
his share is in the ratio of 2:1.
7. Full Sister
1. She is excluded in the presence of child, son’s child,
father or true grandfather.
2. In the absence of the above persons and brother, her
share is 1/2.
3. If there are two or more sisters, then their share is
2/3 divided equally among themselves.
4. In the presence of a brother, she becomes a residuary
and she takes the property with the brother in the
ratio of 1:2.
8. Half Brother
1. He is excluded in the presence of full brother and full
sister.
24
2. In the absence of the above persons, she gets all the
rights of full brother.
9. Half Sister
1. She is excluded in the presence of a full brother and
full sister.
2. In the absence of the above persons, she gets all the
rights of full sister.
10. True Grand Father (Father’s Father)
1. He is excluded is the presence of father or nearer true
grandfather.
2. In the absence of the above persons, he occupies the
position of the father.
11. True Grand Mother
She is divided into two types:
a. Maternal grand mother.
b. Paternal grand mother.
a. Maternal Grand Mother
1. She is excluded in the presence of mother, nearer
true grand mother and father.
2. In the absence of the above persons, his share is 1/6.
b. Paternal grand mother
1. She is excluded in the presence of mother, nearer
true grand mother and father.
25
2. In the absence of the above persons, her share is 1/6.
12. Son’s Daughter (and son’s son’s daughter)
1. She is excluded in the presence of son.
2. In the presence of son, she becomes residuary.
3. In the presence of the daughter, or nearer son’s
daughter, her share is 1/6.
4. If there are two or more daughters, she is excluded.
5. In the absence of the above persons, her share is 1/2.
6. If there are two or more son’s daughters, then their
share is 1/3 divided equally among themselves.
7. When father and mother are alone left, their share is
1/6 mother and 5/6 father.
II. RESIDUARIES
i. Son, daughter and father are residuaries. They get as
residuaries, after the sharers.
ii. So, if there is no sharer, the whole property is
converted as residuary.
iii. In the order of succession, the Residuaries group is as
follows:
a. Descendants (Son, Son’s Son)
b. Ascendants (Father, true grandfather)
c. Descendants of father (Full brother, Full sister.
Consanguine brother, Consanguine sister, full
brother’s son, Consanguine brother’s son.
d. Descendants of true grandfather, how high so ever
(Full paternal uncle, Consanguine paternal uncle, Full
26
paternal uncle’s son, Consanguine paternal uncle’s
son, Full paternal uncle’s son’s son, Consanguine
paternal uncle’s son’s son).
1. Son
i. Son is always a residuary.
ii. In the presence of daughter, he takes the share in the
ratio of 2:1.
iii. The son’s son, in the absence of son, takes his place
among the sharers.
2. Daughter
In the presence of son, daughter becomes a
residuary. She takes the property in the ratio of 1:2.
3. Father
In the absence of child, or son’s child, the father
becomes the residuary and he takes the remaining
property left out, after the sharers have taken their
shares.
III. DISTANT KINDRED
a. Distant kindred are the relations by blood. They are
neither Sharers nor Residuaries.
b. They succeed either in the absence of both the
Sharers and the Residuaries or when there are no
Residuaries and the only Sharer is the husband or
wife.
c. Similarly, if the surviving relations belong to the class
of distant kindred, the nearer relation excludes the
more remote.
27
They are divided into four Classes for determining
their order of succession:
1. Each class mentioned above excludes the Class
coming later (E.g. Class I excludes II, etc)
2. In each class, the nearer in degree excludes the
remoter ones.
3. In Class II, if claimants are of the same degree,
relationship through sharers exclude those who are
not so.
4. In Class III, Children of residuaries are preferred to
those of distant kindred. Descendant of full brothers
exclude those
8. SUCCESSION CERTIFICATE
(Sec. 370 to 390)
UNIVERSITY QUESTIONS
1. What is Succession Certificate? Is it necessary if the
deceased was a Hindu? When can it be revoked?
2. Describe the procedure for obtaining a Succession
Certificate. Can a ‘Succession Certificate’ be revoked
and if so, under what circumstances?
3. Explain to whom obtaining of “Succession Certificate”,
is made compulsory under the Indian Succession Act.
What are the legal effects of the grant of Succession
Certificate?
Answer
A. INTRODUCTION
28
1. A Succession Certificate is a certificate given by the
civil court to the legal heirs to claim any debt or
security.
2. The Succession Certificate helps to the collect the
debts on succession.
3. Generally, after the death of the elder, there may be
fight among the relatives for the collection of the
debts.
4. The Succession Certificate gives protection to the
debtors of the deceased against the multiple claims
of the debt by different relatives.
5. The Court grants the Succession Certificate to the
right person of the debts given by the deceased
person.
B. EFFECT OF SUCCESSION CERTIFICATE
1. The Succession Certificate gives protection to the
debtor from many claims from different legal heirs.
2. After payment to the succession certificate holder,
the debtor is safe.
3. The holder of Succession Certificate is the legally
authorised person to collect the debts due to the
deceased.
C. GROUNDS FOR THE GRANT OF SUCCESSION
CERTIFICATE
1. In all cases where Probate or Letters Administration
is compulsory, a Succession Certificate is not granted.
29
2. When the deceased person is an Indian Christian
dying without will, then Succession Certificate can be
granted.
3. When the deceased is a Hindu who has lost a will,
then Succession Certificate can be granted.
4. In case of joint family property, Succession Certificate
can be granted.
D. PROCEDURE ON APPLICATION
The District Judge follows the following procedure in
disposing of the application:
1. After the filing of application, the judge fixes a day
for hearing and sends notice to the parties.
2. He decides the right of the parties to the Certificate.
3. If he decides that the applicant has the right for the
Certificate, he orders for the grant of the certificate.
4. If there are more than one applicant for the
Certificate, the Judge may give the certificate to the
eligible applicant.
E. REVOCATION OF SUCCESSION CERTIFICATE
Under the following circumstances, a Succession
Certificate may be revoked:
1. If the proceedings to get the Certificate were
defective.
2. If the Certificate was got fraudulently by making false
information.
30
3. If the Certificate has become useless due to
circumstances.
MOST IMPORTANT AND MOST EXPECTED SHORT NOTES
- SIMPLE LANGUAGE
SHORT NOTE NO – 1
EFFECT OF CONVERSION TO ISLAM AND OTHER
RELIGIONS
Mohammedan law applies to Mohammedans by birth
and Mohammedan by conversion.
Conversion to Islam may be done by a non muslim
who has attained majority and is of sound mind.
Apostacy means abandoning one’s religion.
There are two methods of conversion:
1. The person may just declare that he believes in the
oneness of God and the prophetic character of
Mohammed, or
2. He should go to a mosque and utter kalma (Lailaha-ill-
Allah-Muhammad-ur-Rasoolullah) before the person
who is well versed with the Islamic theology. He is
given a muslim name and then he may profess to be a
Mulsim.
APOSTACY IN MOHAMMEDAN LAW
(Conversion to Muslim law)
1. Conversion must be bonafide and the Court will not
permit any fraud upon the law by pretending to be a
convert to islam, in order to escape from the personal
law.
31
2. Conversion by wife in order to separate from her
Hindu husband was also held to be a fraud upon the
law and invalid.
3. After conversion to Islam, the Mohammedan law
substitutes the original religion of the convert.
4. Apostacy does not have a retrospective effect; it has
an immediate and prospective effect.
5. Succession to the property of a convert is governed
by Muslim law.
EFFECT OF CONVERSION TO ISLAM ON MARITAL
RIGHTS
i. Conversion from Hindu to Islam:
(a) If a Hindu married woman converts to Islam, the
previous marriage does not come to an end. This is
because, both under the Hindu law and Mohammedan
law, a woman cannot marry again while her husband
is alive.
(b) If the converted married woman marries again, she is
punishable for bigamy under Sec. 494 I.P.C.
(c) Only on the death of her husband, the marriage
stands dissolved and she becomes free to marry a
Muslim husband.
(d) An Indian Christian domiciled in India and married to
an Indian Christian girl domiciled in India, embraces
Islamic faith, his contract of marriage with a
Mohammedan woman is valid though his first
marriage subsists.
ii. Conversion from Christianity to Islam:
32
(a) Conversion in the case of a marriage of a christian
male with a Christian female does not dissolve the
marriage, because marriage by a muslim male with a
Christian female is permitted.
(b) On the other hand, if a Hindu married male converts
to Islam, it is doubtful whether he can marry again,
though under the Hindu Marriage Act, monogamy is
introduced and under the Mohammedan Law,
polygamy is permitted.
EFFECT OF CONVERSION TO ISLAM ON RIGHTS OF
INHERITANCE
When a Hindu gets converted to Islam, succession
and inheritance are governed by Mohammedan law except
if there is a custom to the contrary.
CONVERSION FROM ISLAM (APOSTACY)
(a) If a Mohammedan married male converts himself to
another religion, the marriage automatically comes to
an end and the wife can marry again without applying
to the Court for dissolution of marriage.
(b) If a Mohammedan wife converts herself to another
religion, the marriage does not come to an end. She
can marry only after obtaining dissolution of the
previous marriage under Sec.4 of the Dissolution of
Muslim Marriage Act, on some grounds like cruelty,
failure to maintain, etc.
(c) In the case of apostacy by guardian, the apostate
cannot act as a guardian and loses his right to
contract a minor’s marriage.
33
SHORT NOTE NO – 2
SCHOOLS OF MOHAMMADEN LAW
The major divisions of Schools of Mohammedan law
are:
1. Sunni School 2. Shia School
1. Sunni School:
On the death of the Prophet, Mohammed Abubeker
was elected as the successor. Those who supported the
election were called Sunnies. They are predominant
among Muslims in India.
2. Shia School:
Those persons who did not support the election to fill
the vacancy of the Prophet were considered Shias. They
supported the succession to the office by inheritance and
not by election.
SUB SCHOOLS AMONG THE SUNNIES
1. The Hanafi School:
Founded in Kufa (now it is Iraq) by Imam Abu Hanafi
in the 8th century A.D. Two disciples by name Aba Yusuf
and Imam Mohammed were responsible for the growth of
the Hanafi school.
2. The Maliki School:
34
Founded in Madina(now in Saudi Arabia) by Imam
Malik ibn Anasin the 8th century A.D. This school attached
importance to Ijmaa as a source of Mohammedan law.
3. The Shafei School:
Founded in Egypt by Imam Muhammad ibn Idrisash-
Shafe a pupil of Imam Malik ibn Anas in early years of the
9th century A.D.
4. The Hanbali School:
Founded in Baghdad (Now in Iraq) by Immam ibn
Hanbal (a pupil of Shafei) in the 9th century.
5. The Zaydi School:
Named after Imam Zaid.
6. The Jafari School (Ithna Ashari School):
Named after aforesaid Imam Zaid’s nephew Imam
Jafer. After the 11th Imam, his son at the age of 5, was
not seen after entering cave. He was the 12th Imam and
the followers of this School believed that the 12th Imam
would appear one day.
7. The Ismaili School (Fatimi):
Named after the aforesaid Imam Jafer saqiq’s elder
son Imam Ismail. The Ismailies are divided into eastern
ismailies (khojas) and western ismailies.
8. The Ibadi School:
35
Developed by a section of the extinct kawariji and
now found mainly in the Sultanate of Oman.
SCHOOLS PREVALENT IN INDIA
In India, only four of the above-mentioned Schools of
Muslims prevail. They are:
1. The Hanafi School.
2. The Shafi School.
3. The Ithna Ashari (Jafari School)
4. The Ismaili (Fatimi School).
SHORT NOTE NO – 3
THE SHARIAT ACT, 1937
Before the enactment of the Shariat Act 1937,
different enactments were enforced in different parts of
India regulating the application of Muslim Law. Since
there were differences in the application of principles
between the different States, the Shariat Act, 1937 has
substituted all enactments thereby regulating the
application of Muslim Law in the different States of India.
This Act applies only when the person is a Muslim,
and is competent to contract within the meaning of
Section 11 of Indian Contract Act, 1872, and he should be
a resident of India.
This Act applies Muslim Personal Law in a number of
important matters, where parties are Muslims.
According to Section 2 of the Shariat Act, in spite of
the prevailing custom or usage, in all questions (except
questions relating to agricultural land) the rule of decision
36
in cases where the parties are Muslims shall be the
Muslim personal Law (Shariat).
The scope and purpose of Sec. 2 is to abrogate (annul
or invalidate) custom and usage to the extent they have
displaced the rules of Muslim Law.
The following are the subjects expressly declared in
which Muslim personal Law (Shariat) shall be applied:
1. intestate succession,
2. special property of females including personal
property inherited or obtained under contract or gift
or any other provision of personal law of marriage,
3. dissolution of marriage,
4. maintenance,
5. dower,
6. guardianship,
7. gifts,
8. trust and trust properties and Waqfs (other than
charities and charitable institutions and charitable
and religious endowments)
SHORT NOTE NO – 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF PATERNITY
(Legitimacy of a child)
Adoption is unknown to Mohammaden law. The legal
effect of adoption in Hindu law is to legitimize the birth of
the child by the adopter.
The legitimacy of the child is brought by the theory of
acknowledgement of paternity in Mohammaden law. The
37
illegitimate child can be made legitimate by the
acknowledgement of a man that he is the father of the
child.
ESSENTIALS FOR A VALID ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
1. The father should have treated the child as his
legitimate child.
2. Legitimacy must be legally possible. In other words,
the persons acknowledging the child must be capable
of marrying the mother of the child.
3. The acknowledgement of paternity becomes invalid if
the marriage is void or disproved.
4. The mother should not repudiate the
acknowledgement by the person acknowledging.
5. The acknowledger should be an adult and sane i.e.
capable of entering into a contract.
EFFECT OF ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
1. The effect of acknowledgement primarily creates a
presumption that the marriage is deemed to have
taken place in the absence of direct disproof.
2. The child becomes legitimate and gets all rights of
inheritance over the property of the man
acknowledging paternity.
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ACKNOWLEDGEMENT AND
ADOPTION
i. Adoption:
1. The adoptee is a child of another person.
2. Motive of adoption may be for religious purposes or
spiritual purposes
38
3. The adoptee gets transplanted into the adoptive
family from the natural family.
4. Natural descent of the adoptee and the adoptive
father is not considered.
5. The natural parents give their child as a gift to the
adoptive parents.
ii. Acknowledgement:
1. Acknowledgment proceeds on the basis of paternity.
2. No motive is present in Acknowledgement of
paternity.
3. No such change is possible in Acknowledgement.
4. There is actual descent of the acknowledgor in a legal
manner.
5. Acknowledgement is possible, only when the
paternity of the child is not able to be proved.
SHORT NOTE NO – 5
THE INDIAN DIVORCE ACT, 1869
(CHRISTIAN LAW)
The Divorce Act, 1869 is invoked to dissolve the
marriage between the parties professing Christian religion
(or one of the parties was a Christian when the petition
was filed) and who are domiciled in India, even if the
marriage was solemnized out of India.
GROUNDS FOR DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE (Sec. 10)
39
Whether before or after the commencement of the
Indian Divorce (Amendment) Act, 2001, either the
husband or the wife may apply for divorce by presenting a
petition for divorce to the District Court.
The grounds of divorce are:
1. The respondent has committed adultery, or
2. The respondent has converted himself / herself to
another religion, or
3. The respondent has been suffering from an incurable
form of unsoundness of mind for 2 years continuously
immediately preceding the presentation of the
petition of divorce, or
4. The respondent has been suffering from a virulent
and incurable form of leprosy for 2 years continuously
immediately preceding the presentation of the
petition of divorce, or
5. The respondent has been suffering from a venereal
disease in a communicable form for 2 years
continuously immediately preceding the presentation
of the petition of divorce, or
6. If the respondent has not been heard of as being alive
for a period of 7 years or more by people who might
have known naturally if he/she had been alive, or
7. If the respondent has wilfully refused to consummate
the marriage and so, the marriage has not been
consummated, or
8. The respondent has deserted the petitioner for two
years immediately preceding the presentation of the
petition, or
40
9. The respondent has treated the petitioner with so
much of cruelty that the petitioner has been subject
to reasonable apprehension in mind that it would be
harmful or injurious for the petitioner to live with the
respondent.
10. Special ground for woman: A wife may present a
petition for dissolution of marriage if the husband has
been guilty of rape, sodomy or bestiality since
solemnization of the marriage.
DISSOLUTION OF MARRIAGE BY MUTUAL CONSENT
(Sec.10 A)
1. A petition for dissolution of marriage may be
presented to the District Court by both the parties to
a marriage together.
2. The ground of divorce is that they have been living
separately for two years or more and they have not
been able to live together and they have mutually
agreed that the marriage should be dissolved.
3. From 6 months of presentation of the petition and
before 18 months from the date of application of
petition, after inquiry, if the Court is satisfied, then it
passes a decree declaring the marriage to be
dissolved with effect from the date of decree.
NULLITY OF MARRIAGE (Sec. 18)
A husband or wife may present a petition to the
District Court praying that his/her marriage may be
declared null and void.
A marriage may be nullified on the following grounds:
1. The respondent had been impotent at the time of the
marriage and at the time of institution of the suit.
41
2. The petitioner and respondent are in prohibited
degrees of consanguinity or affinity.
3. Either the petitioner or respondent was a lunatic or
idiot at the time of the marriage.
4. The former wife/husband of the petitioner or
respondent was living at the time of the marriage and
the marriage with such former husband or wife was
then in force. (Bigamy)
CUSTODY OF CHILDREN (Sec. 41)
1. In any suit for obtaining a judicial separation, a
dissolution of marriage or decree of nullity of
marriage, the Court may from time to time, before
making its decree, make interim orders, with respect
to the custody, maintenance and education of the
minor children.
2. The application with respect to the maintenance and
education of the minor children pending the suit, is
disposed of within sixty daysfrom the date of service
of notice on respondent.
SHORT NOTE NO - 6
GIFT OR HIBA
(Hiba-bil-iwaz and Hiba ba shartul-iwaz) (Mushaa)
In Muslim law, a gift satisfying certain legal
requirements is called Hiba.
A. ESSENTIALS OF HIBA
1. It must be free or gratuitous.
42
2. There must be immediate delivery of possession by
one person to another.
3. The transfer must be unconditional.
4. The property must be in existence.
5. A future gift is not allowed and it is valid only as a
will.
6. Any restraint against alienation in a Hiba is void and
the gift takes effect unconditionally.
B. SUBJECT MATTER OF HIBA
Regarding the subject matter of gift, the
Mohammedan law recognises the difference between the
two elements of a property namely (1) Corpus and (2)
Usufruct.
Corpus means the absolute right of ownership over
the property, which is heritable and is unlimited in point
of time. Gift of corpus of property is called Hiba. Any
condition which affects from absolute dominion over the
subject of gift is void.
Usufruct means the right of a person to use and enjoy
the property. This right is limited in point of time and not
heritable. Gift of usufruct of property is called ariya.
C. CAPACITY TO MAKE HIBA
1. The donor must be a major and of sound mind.
2. The donor must be the owner of the property, which
is the subject of Hiba.
3. There should be bonafide intention of the owner to
transfer property and it must be made by his free
consent. If a gift is made under undue influence, then
it is void.
4. If a Hiba is made with a clear intention to defraud the
creditors, then it is void.
43
D. CAPACITY TO RECEIVE HIBA
(CAPACITY OF THE DONEE)
1. Hiba can be made in favour of natural persons,
artificial persons, non Muslims - their future heirs,
minors, insane persons, unmarried, divorced or
widowed women.
2. Hiba cannot be lawfully made in favour of an unborn.
Such a Hiba will be void.
E. MUSHAA
1. Mushaa is an ‘undivided share’ in a property.
2. Musha can be the subject matter of gift.
3. A valid gift can be made of musha, if the property is
not capable of division. Here, the donee and the other
co-owner has to own, possess and enjoy the subject
matter jointly.
4. If the property is capable of division and if the gift of
musha is made without actual division, the gift is
irregular and not void. By a subsequent partition, it
can be made valid.
F. REVOCATION OF HIBA
The revocation of gift in every case is governed by
that school of law to which the donor belongs.
When a gift is revocable by the donor, the following
are the conditions to be noted.
1. Intervention of the Court is not necessary, if the
donee agrees to the revocation.
44
2. If the donee does not agree to it, an order of the
Court of cancellation of the gift has to be obtained by
the donee.
3. If the donee agrees for revocation, ownership of the
gifted property reverts to the donor.
4. Inter spousal gifts are irrevocable.
G. ONEROUS BEQUEST
1. If a bequest is made to a person and it consists of
several things i.e. some burdened with obligation and
the rest without obligation, the legatee must accept
the whole bequest.
For e.g. A makes bequest of a house and a land
to B. The house is under mortgage of Rs. 5,000/-.
However, B must accept the full bequest, and he
cannot accept the land alone.
But if the bequest contains 2 or more separate
independent transfers made on different occasions,
then the legatee can accept the beneficial bequest
alone and reject the onerous bequest.
2. If an onerous bequest and a beneficial bequest are
made to a minor or lunatic, the legatee can accept the
beneficial bequest alone and reject the burdensome
bequest.
SHORT NOTE NO - 7
PRE EMPTION
45
1. Pre emption is the first right of one co owner to buy
the jointly owned property.
2. The co owner has the first option to buy the property,
if it sold by the other co owner.
3. The co owner must pay the market value for the
property.
4. Pre emption is not recognised in Muslim law.
The right of Pre-emption is a right to acquire by
compulsory purchase of immovable property in preference
to all other persons.
The object of pre-emption is to prevent the
introduction of a stranger among co-sharers.
Eg: A and B are co-owners of an immovable property.
A sells his share of the property to C instead of selling to
B. Here, by means of the right of pre-emption, B can
compel C to sell the property to him.
ESSENTIALS OF THE DOCTRINE OF PRE-EMPTION
1. It is a right of the “owner” of a certain immovable
property to obtain proprietory possession of certain
other immovable property not his own.
2. Such right is in substitution of the buyer who has
already purchased the other immovable property.
3. The terms of purchase of the immovable property by
the “owner” are the same as that of the purchase by
the other buyer.
4. The objective of pre-emption is the quiet enjoyment
of the property.
CASES IN WHICH THE RIGHT OF
46
PRE-EMPTION ARISES
1. Only in cases of sale, the right of claiming pre-
emption is applicable. Such sale must be valid,
bonafide, and a mere intention to sell can never be a
sale. Sale includes exchange, but not gift, waqf,
inheritance, bequest of a lease in perpetuity.
2. Only on completion of sale, the right of pre-emption
arises, and not before. On payment of the purchase
money and possession of property, the sale is
considered to be complete. The execution of the
instrument of sale is not needed, according to Muslim
law.
Cases in which the right of pre-emption does not arise:
1. Gifts.
2. Waqf.
3. Bequest.
4. Inheritance
5. Lease in perpetuity.
6. Mortgage though by conditional sale.
7. Conditional sale.
CONSTITUTIONAL VALIDITY OF RIGHT OF PRE-EMPTION
Article 19(1)(f) guarantees right to freedom to
alienate property. It was doubtful whether Right of Pre-
emption was a restriction of such freedom.
It is now settled by the Supreme Court that:
Bhau Ram Vs. Baijnathsingh 1961 AIR 1327
1. The Court held that customary right of pre-emption is
void. Statutory as well as customary pre-emption by
47
an adjoining owner on the ground of vicinage is an
unreasonable restriction and not valid.
2. It is valid in the case of co-ownership in undivided
property, where the right of pre-emption is a
reasonable restriction.
3. In the case of easement, whether pre-emption is
reasonable or unreasonable depends upon the nature
of easement and the inconvenience apprehended
(look forward to with fear) by the pre-emptor to his
rights.
WHERE THE RIGHT OF PRE-EMPTION IS LOST
1. Death of the pre-emptor during the pendency of the
suit for pre-emption extinguishes the right of pre-
emption in the case of Sunni law, but in Shia law, the
suit may be carried on by the heirs of the deceased
pre-emptor.
Under the Indian Succession Act, the suit may be
continued by the executor or Administrator, as the
right is not extinguished by the death of the pre-
emptor.
2. Acquiescence: If the pre-emptor either by taking the
lease of the same property from the purchaser or by
failure to make demand, he is deemed to have
acquiesced in the sale and thus loses his right to pre-
empt.
3. If in the suit for pre-emption, the pre-emptor joins
another person as co-plaintiff, but the co-plaintiff has
no right to pre-empt, then the right for pre-emption is
lost.
48
4. If the pre-emptor transfers the immovable property
which is the subject matter of pre-emption, then he
loses the right to pre-empt.
5. Waiver: By entering into a compromise with the
purchaser, if the pre-emptor waives his right of pre-
emption, it is lost.
6. Failure to make demand: If the pre-emptor fails to
make the immediate demand and Confirmatory
demand, then he loses his right of pre-emption.
7. If the pre-emptor releases his right for consideration,
then he loses the right.
SHORT NOTE NO - 8
DOMICILE (Sec. 4 to 22)
1. Domicile is the relationship of a person with a nation.
2. The domicile is different from nationality and
citizenship.
3. Domicile is of 2 types
a. Domicile by birth
It arises due to the birth of a person in a nation.
b. Domicile by choice
Here the domicile arose by choice of a person.
4. The son and daughter get the domicile of father.
49
5. The wife gets the domicile of her husband after
marriage.
6. Domicile is useful to claim the movable and
immovable properties.
SHORT NOTE NO - 9
PRIVILEGED AND UNPRIVILEGED WILLS
(Sec. 63 to 66) (Bequests)
I. UNPRIVILEGED WILL
1. Unprivileged will is ordinary will.
2. The person writing the will is called Testator.
3. The will comes into force only after the death of the
testator.
4. The will should be written by a major of sound mind.
5. It must be in writing, signed and witnessed by two
witnesses.
II. PRIVILEGED WILL
1. It is will made in emergency circumstances.
2. It need not be in writing and it can be written
afterwards.
Examples
Will written in war, at the time of death, sea man in a
ship ands airman in aeroplane.
3. It need not be witnessed.
50
4. It may be orally made to someone nearby. The other
person can write afterwards.
SHORT NOTE NO - 10
LEGACIES
Legacy’ means - a money or property, which is left to
somebody in a will.
These are three types of Legacies:
1. General Legacies
2. Specific Legacies
3. Demonstrative Legacies
1. General Legacies
These legacies are paid out of general assets of the
testator. After payment of debts and necessary expenses,
it is liable to abatement (meaning - If after payment of
debts, the assets are not sufficient to pay all the legacies,
then proportionate reduction of the legacy is done) but
not Ademption (meaning - the legacy cannot take effect by
reason of the subject matter having been withdrawn from
the operation of the will).
2. Specific Legacies
It is a legacy of a particular part of the testator’s
property which is distinguished from all other parts of the
property.
E.g. a gold ornament of the testator. It is not liable to
abatement but liable to Ademption. A bequeaths to B in
the following terms-
a. My gold ring.
51
b. A sum of Rs. 2,000/- in a certain chest.
c. All my shares in the bank
d. All my household items in my residence in K. Street in
Chennai at the time after my death.
In specific legacy, specific property is given to the
legatee.
In demonstrative legacy, legacy is directly to be paid
out of specified property.
E.g. “Rs 10,000 out of the sum of Rs. 20,000/ due to
me by Raman. “Rs 20,000/- out of my estate at Natham
Village”. This is demonstrative legacy.
3. Demonstrative Legacies
1. When a testator bequeaths a certain sum of money or
certain quantity of any other commodity to be paid
out of a primary fund or stock, such legacy is said to
be demonstrative legacy.
2. This is a legacy directed to be paid out of particular
fund. It is not liable to ademption.
3. Even if the funds cease to exist, because the legacy is
not liable to ademption, the legacy will be payable
out of the general assets.
4. It is not liable to abatement when the fund is
sufficient to meet the claim of the legacies.
5. If the fund is insufficient, it is treated as a general
legacy and is liable to abatement.
6. Even in case the property on which a demonstrative
legacy is charged by the will does not exist at the
time of the death of the testator, or has been
converted into property of a different kind, it is paid
52
out of the general assets of the testator and cannot
be adeemed (cannot take effect).
ADEMPTION OF LEGACY
‘Ademption’ means that the legacy cannot take effect
by reason of the subject matter having been withdrawn
from the operation of the will. Only a specific legacy is
liable to Ademption.
Eg., “A sum of Rs.10,000/- from a certain chest of
drawers.” “All the horses in my stable”.
At the death of A, no money is in the chest and no
horses in the stable. This legacy is adeemed (cannot take
effect).
SHORT NOTE NO - 11
FAMILY COURTS ACT, 1984
There is a separate Court to decide family disputes. It
is called Family court.
The objective of family court is mediation and
settlement of family disputes including maintenance.
CONSTITUTION
1. Family Courts are established in a city of population
of more than 10,00,000.
53
2. It is presided by a District Judge or a Judicial Member
of Tribunal member who has 7 years experience or an
Advocate of 7 years bar experience in any High Court.
3. Women are preferred in the appointment of Judges in
the Family Court.
JURISDICTION
Family Courts have jurisdiction on all marriage matters.
The following are the proceedings before the Family
Courts:
1.Divorce
2.Judicial separation.
3.Restitution of Conjugal rights.
4.Nullity of marriage.
5.Maintenance(Alimony.)
6.Custody of children
7.Declaration of legitimacy of a child.
8.Declaration of validity of marriage.
‘IN CAMERA’ PROCEEDINGS
1. In camera proceedings mean that the proceedings are
in private without any entry of the public.
2. They are conducted in closed chambers in the
presence of the Judge with the parties to the
marriage dispute.
3. Usually, the in camera proceedings are followed by
the Family Court, if sensitive questions about the
morality of the woman, etc., are involved.
54
SHORT NOTE NO -12
POWERS OF EXECUTOR OR ADMINISTRATOR
(Sec. 217 to 260)
When a will is written by a testator( will writer), he
appoints a person to distribute the properties mentioned
in the will. The person so appointed is called “Executor”.
If no executor is appointed in the will, then court will
appoint a person to distribute the properties according to
will. He is called “Administrator”.
1. The powers of Executor/ Administrator is that he
should divide the properties as per will and distribute
them to the legal heirs.
2. Till then, he manages the properties.
3. He cannot transfer the properties.
4. He can take reasonable amount as salary for his
functions.
5. He can be removed for misuse of his powers.