Lean Six Sigma
Lean Six Sigma
Focus: Focuses primarily on eliminating waste and Focuses on reducing defects and variability
improving flow in a process. in processes to ensure consistent, high-quality
Its main goal is to make processes faster and more outcomes.
efficient by removing unnecessary steps, delays, Its main goal is to achieve a process where
and redundancies. defects are reduced to 3.4 defects per million
Lean emphasizes continuous improvement by opportunities (near perfection).
streamlining processes and maximizing value for Six Sigma emphasizes using statistical tools
customers. and data analysis to improve process
performance.
Key Goal: -Improve speed and efficiency by reducing -Improve quality by reducing variability and defects.
waste (such as waiting time, excess inventory,
unnecessary motion, etc.). -Focuses on achieving consistent and predictable
results by using data-driven methods to eliminate
-Focuses on increasing value to the customer process errors.
by optimizing the use of resources and
reducing cycle time
3. Methodology: -Lean uses tools and techniques like Value -Six Sigma uses a more statistical and data-driven
Stream Mapping, 5S, Kaizen, Kanban, and approach to identify and analyze root causes of
Just-in-Time to identify and eliminate waste defects, variability, and inefficiencies
-The approach is typically more visual and -It follows the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze,
simplified, aiming for quick improvements. Improve, Control) methodology to guide
improvements.
Tools and Techniques: Common Lean tools include: Common Six Sigma tools include:
o Value Stream Mapping (VSM): o Pareto Chart: Identifies the most significant
Visualizing the entire process to causes of a problem (80/20 rule).
identify waste. o Fishbone Diagram (Ishikawa): Identifies
o 5S: Sort, Set in order, Shine, potential causes of problems.
Standardize, Sustain – a methodology o Control Charts: Monitors process performance
for workplace organization. over time.
o Kanban: Visual signaling system to o DMAIC framework: Define, Measure,
manage workflow. Analyze, Improve, and Control process
o Kaizen: Continuous, incremental improvements.
improvement. o FMEA (Failure Modes and Effects
Analysis): Identifies potential failures and
their impact
5. Approach to Improvement: Lean improvements are often quick wins Six Sigma improvements are often data-driven and
focused on simplifying processes, reducing statistically rigorous, focusing on identifying root
delays, and cutting out unnecessary activities. causes of variability and defects and eliminating them.
Lean emphasizes incremental improvements Six Sigma typically involves more complex analysis
with a focus on efficiency. and longer-term, methodical efforts to reach the goal
of near-perfect performance.
scope of Application: Lean is commonly applied to processes where Six Sigma is often applied to processes where quality
efficiency is the primary concern, such as in and precision are the most important, such as in
manufacturing, supply chain management, healthcare, finance, engineering, and
and service industries. manufacturing.
7. Speed of Results: Lean typically provides quicker results since Six Sigma typically takes longer to implement due to
it focuses on eliminating obvious waste and the detailed data analysis and statistical tools used to
streamlining operations without deep statistical reduce defects and variability
analysis.
Cultural Impact: Lean emphasizes a culture of continuous Six Sigma often involves structured teams led by
improvement and employee engagement Black Belts and Green Belts who are highly trained
through techniques like Kaizen, where in data analysis. It can sometimes be more top-down
employees at all levels are encouraged to in terms of leadership and involvement.
suggest improvements.
Team Structure: Lean teams may involve all employees, as Six Sigma teams typically consist of trained experts,
Lean focuses on creating a culture of such as Black Belts and Green Belts, who use
continuous improvement and collective advanced data analysis techniques.
problem-solving.
Cost vs. Return on Investment Lean tends to have a lower upfront cost since Six Sigma involves a higher initial investment due to
(ROI): it primarily focuses on eliminating waste the need for specialized training and statistical tools.
through simpler tools and process changes.
Slower ROI, as it takes time to identify root causes
Faster ROI due to the quick nature of and implement data-driven improvements
improvements and the reduction of waste.
Lean Six Sigma: A Synergistic When Lean and Six Sigma are combined, they create a powerful methodology known as Lean Six
Approach Sigma. This integrated approach leverages the strengths of both Lean and Six Sigma to achieve faster
processes, higher quality, and greater efficiency. Here's how they work together:
How Lean and Six Sigma
1. Lean’s Focus on Eliminating Waste + Six Sigma’s Focus on Reducing Defects
Work Together:
Lean targets the elimination of waste (non-value-added activities) in a process. This includes
In practice, Lean and Six reducing waiting times, excess inventory, unnecessary motion, overproduction, defects, and
Sigma are often combined unnecessary steps.
into a single methodology Six Sigma, on the other hand, focuses on reducing variability and defects in a process, aiming
known as Lean Six Sigma. to ensure that processes deliver consistent and high-quality outcomes by addressing root causes
of errors or defects.
This integrated approach
leverages the strengths of Together:
both:
Lean improves speed and flow by cutting waste, while Six Sigma ensures quality by reducing
• Lean brings speed and defects and variability. By combining them, organizations can not only accelerate process
efficiency improvements by efficiency but also maintain high-quality outcomes, leading to faster and more reliable
eliminating waste. processes.
• Six Sigma brings a 2. Streamlining Processes with Lean + Data-Driven Decisions with Six Sigma
rigorous, data-driven focus to
Lean tools such as Value Stream Mapping (VSM) and Kanban help visually identify and
improving quality and
streamline process flows, which removes bottlenecks and speeds up work.
reducing variability. Six Sigma tools, such as DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control), rely on
data-driven analysis to understand variability and root causes of defects.
By combining the two,
organizations can achieve Together:
both faster processes and
higher-quality outcomes. Lean's process flow optimization can be powered by Six Sigma's data analysis tools, ensuring
that improvements are both measured and statistically validated. This helps ensure that
changes made to improve flow are sustainable and don't compromise quality.
Together:
The Kaizen culture from Lean encourages ongoing contributions from employees at all
levels, while Six Sigma's structured approach provides the statistical rigor to ensure that
changes lead to measurable, reliable results. This combination allows for continuous,
sustainable improvements in both process speed and quality.
Lean aims for quick improvements by reducing waste and increasing the flow of value to the
customer. This typically leads to faster processes and quicker ROI.
Six Sigma, while also focused on improvement, often requires more time for data collection,
statistical analysis, and root cause identification. However, the goal is to ensure that changes
don't just make processes faster but also make them more predictable and reliable.
Together:
Lean Six Sigma brings the best of both worlds: speed and efficiency from Lean and precision
and quality control from Six Sigma. This enables organizations to achieve faster process cycles
without sacrificing the high quality of the output.
Lean eliminates waste by focusing on activities that add value and removing unnecessary steps
or redundancies.
Six Sigma focuses on reducing variation by addressing the causes of defects and
inconsistencies, aiming for a process that operates at near-perfect levels.
Together:
Lean Six Sigma optimizes processes by removing both waste and variation, ensuring that
processes run more smoothly and more consistently. This leads to better resource utilization,
higher customer satisfaction, and a more predictable product or service.
Lean encourages team-based decision-making, where all levels of employees are involved in
identifying problems and solutions.
Six Sigma often involves specialized roles, such as Black Belts and Green Belts, who are
trained in advanced statistical methods and lead more formal improvement projects.
Together:
Lean Six Sigma blends team engagement with expert-led guidance. Lean’s cross-functional
teams can identify problems on the ground level, while Six Sigma experts use data and
statistical tools to validate and measure improvements. This ensures a holistic approach to
improvement where both frontline staff and data experts contribute to the success of the
project.
Lean tools such as 5S, Kaizen, and Just-in-Time (JIT) streamline processes and reduce
inefficiencies.
Six Sigma tools like DMAIC, Control Charts, and FMEA (Failure Modes and Effects
Analysis) help analyze root causes and monitor performance.
Together:
The combination of Lean tools with Six Sigma tools ensures that improvements are both
operationally efficient and statistically validated. For example, a Value Stream Map (Lean)
can be used to identify waste in a process, while DMAIC (Six Sigma) can be used to analyze
data, identify root causes of inefficiencies, and test potential solutions.
Lean is often seen as an approach that can be applied quickly to smaller processes or projects,
making it suitable for quick wins and small-scale improvements.
Six Sigma typically requires more structured projects and data analysis, making it better
suited for complex processes where precision and quality control are critical.
Together:
Lean Six Sigma is scalable, allowing organizations to apply the Lean approach to smaller, less
complex tasks, and the Six Sigma approach to larger, more complex processes. This flexibility
ensures that improvements can be applied at all levels of an organization.
When combined, Lean Six Sigma brings faster, more efficient processes that are also high quality
and data-driven. Lean provides the tools to streamline and speed up processes, while Six Sigma
ensures those processes are stable, predictable, and free from defects. By blending these two
methodologies, organizations can achieve sustainable improvements that benefit both their bottom line
and their customers.
Six Sigma tools: Six Sigma employs a variety of tools and techniques to help identify, analyze, and improve processes.
These tools are designed to assist in each phase of the DMAIC (Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve,
Control) methodology and are crucial in achieving the desired results. Below is an overview of some of
The Most Frequently Used the most commonly used
Tools in Six Sigma:
1. Process Mapping (Flowchart)
3. Pareto Chart
4. Control Chart
6. Scatter Diagram
Purpose: Analyzes the flow of materials and information across a process or value stream.
Use: VSM identifies and maps out all the steps involved in delivering a product or service, helping to
highlight waste and inefficiencies in the value stream.
When to Use: In the Define or Measure phase to understand current process flow and identify areas
for improvement.
10. 5 Whys
Purpose: Helps identify the root cause of a problem by repeatedly asking "Why?"
Use: This tool involves asking "Why?" multiple times (usually five) until the root cause of a problem is
identified. It's a simple, yet powerful tool for root cause analysis.
When to Use: In the Analyze phase to explore the underlying causes of issues.
Purpose: Visualizes work and optimizes flow by controlling the amount of work in progress (WIP).
Use: A tool used to manage workflow and ensure that work is completed efficiently. It helps visualize
tasks and ensures work is pulled when capacity is available.
When to Use: In the Improve phase, especially for processes with continuous flow or those that need
lean improvement.
Purpose: Monitors and controls a process to ensure it operates at its maximum potential.
Use: SPC uses statistical methods to monitor the performance of a process and identify areas where
improvement is needed.
When to Use: Primarily in the Control phase to ensure that improvements are sustained over time.
Purpose: Measures the time available to produce a product to meet customer demand.
Use: Takt time is the rate at which products must be produced to meet customer demand. It is used to
balance production processes and optimize throughput.
When to Use: In the Improve phase, especially for optimizing production processes.
Summary:
The tools of Six Sigma are varied and versatile, each serving a specific purpose in improving
processes, reducing defects, and optimizing efficiency. By employing these tools, Six Sigma
practitioners can tackle problems systematically, ensure improvements are based on data, and sustain
those improvements over time. Whether used to map a process, identify root causes, monitor
performance, or improve quality, these tools provide the foundation for achieving Six Sigma's goal of
near-perfect process performance.
The most frequently used tool in Six Sigma is arguably the DMAIC framework itself, which serves as
the core methodology for process improvement. However, when looking at specific tools that are
commonly used throughout the Six Sigma process, a few stand out for their widespread application
across various industries.
3. Control Chart
o Why it's popular: The Control Chart is vital for monitoring the stability and consistency of
processes over time. It helps identify variations and understand whether a process is in control
or if there are issues that need addressing.
o When it's used: Used most often in the Control phase to monitor the process after
improvements have been implemented.
5. 5 Whys
o Why it's popular: The 5 Whys tool is simple but powerful. It helps identify the root cause of a
problem by repeatedly asking "Why?" until the underlying issue is discovered.
o When it's used: This tool is frequently used in the Analyze phase to explore the underlying
causes of a problem.
Conclusion:
Among all Six Sigma tools, Pareto Charts, Fishbone Diagrams, Control Charts, and Process
Mapping are arguably the most frequently used because they help identify and analyze problems,
monitor improvements, and visualize processes. These tools are foundational in the DMAIC
methodology and play a central role in ensuring the successful implementation of Six Sigma projects.
Lean Six Sigma in Healthcare refers to the application of the Lean and Six Sigma methodologies to
improve processes, reduce waste, enhance efficiency, and elevate the quality of care in healthcare
settings. Both Lean and Six Sigma focus on different but complementary aspects of process
improvement:
1. Lean focuses on eliminating waste (non-value-added activities) and improving the flow of processes to
make them more efficient.
2. Six Sigma focuses on reducing variation and improving quality by identifying and eliminating causes of
defects and errors in processes.
Together, Lean Six Sigma aims to optimize healthcare delivery by improving patient care, reducing
costs, and enhancing operational efficiency.
Key Segments of Lean Six Sigma in Healthcare
2. Administrative Processes
o Hospitals and clinics often face inefficiencies in administrative tasks such as billing, patient
scheduling, and insurance claims processing. Lean Six Sigma can optimize these processes,
improving accuracy, reducing administrative costs, and enhancing patient satisfaction.
o Example: Streamlining patient admission processes to reduce wait times and eliminate
redundancies.
1. Improved Patient Satisfaction: By reducing wait times, enhancing communication, and delivering more
reliable services, patient satisfaction improves significantly.
2. Cost Reduction: Identifying and eliminating waste leads to a more efficient use of resources, reducing
unnecessary costs and improving financial sustainability.
3. Enhanced Quality of Care: Fewer errors, better patient flow, and consistent care lead to better
outcomes and reduced risks for patients.
4. Faster Response Times: With streamlined processes, healthcare facilities can respond more quickly to
patient needs, emergencies, and changes in patient conditions.
5. Increased Employee Satisfaction: When employees are engaged in process improvements, they are
more likely to feel valued and motivated, leading to improved morale and retention.
Challenges
Resistance to Change: Healthcare environments often have entrenched ways of working, making it
difficult to implement Lean Six Sigma changes.
Training and Expertise: Healthcare professionals need specialized training in Lean Six Sigma tools and
techniques.
Sustainability: While initial improvements may be achieved, sustaining the gains over time requires
continuous monitoring and a culture of continuous improvement.
Overall, Lean Six Sigma provides healthcare organizations with a powerful set of tools to achieve more
efficient, patient-centered care while managing costs and improving outcomes.
One of the key tools used in Six Sigma is the DMAIC process, which stands
for Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, and Control. This process is used to
identify and eliminate defects in any healthcare process
The Define phase is used to identify the problem and set goals for the
project. For example, this could involve identifying a specific area of patient
care that needs improvement, such as waiting in the emergency room
The Measure phase is used to collect data on the current process. For
example, this could involve collecting data on wait times in the emergency
room or on the number of patient readmissions
The Analyze phase analyzes the data collected in the Measure phase. For
example, this could involve identifying the root cause of long wait times in
the emergency room, such as a lack of staff or a bottleneck in the triage
process.
The Improve phase implements solutions to the problem identified in the
Analyze phase. For example, this could involve increasing the number of
staff in the emergency room or implementing a new triage process
The Control phase ensures that the solutions implemented in the Improve
phase are maintained over time. For example, this could involve monitoring
wait times in the emergency room to ensure that they remain low or
monitoring patient readmissions to ensure that they continue to decrease.
Background
The hospital is a large, urban medical center with over 500 beds. The hospital had
been experiencing a high rate of patient complaints and a high rate of readmissions.
As a result, the administration decided to implement Six Sigma to improve the quality
of patient care and reduce costs.
Implementation
The hospital began by training employees in the Six Sigma methodology. The team
included representatives from various departments, such as nursing, laboratory, and
administration. The team then identified areas of the hospital that needed
improvement, such as patient wait times and the accuracy of lab results.
Next, the team collected data on these areas and analyzed them to determine the
root causes of the problems. They then used Six Sigma tools such as process
mapping and statistical analysis to develop solutions to the problems.
For example, the team identified that a lack of triage nurses caused long wait times in
the emergency department. They solved the problem by hiring more triage nurses
and redesigning the triage process. They also implemented a system to ensure that
lab results were accurate and delivered on time.
Results
The implementation of Six Sigma was successful in improving the quality of patient
care and reducing costs at the hospital. For example, patient wait times in the
emergency department were reduced by 50%, and the accuracy of lab results
improved by 99%. The number of patient complaints also decreased by 40%, and the
rate of readmissions was reduced by 25%.
Example 1
One example of Six Sigma being used in healthcare is at the Cleveland Clinic. The
clinic implemented Six Sigma in 2002 and has since used the methodology to improve
various processes, including patient flow, laboratory processes, and supply chain
management. As a result of these improvements, the clinic has seen a reduction in
costs and increased patient satisfaction.
Example 2
Another example is the North Shore-Long Island Jewish Health System. The
system implemented Six Sigma in 2003 and has since been used to improve
processes in the emergency department, reducing wait times and increasing patient
satisfaction.
Conclusion
Six Sigma is a powerful tool that can be used in healthcare to improve patient
outcomes, increase satisfaction, and reduce costs. By utilizing the DMAIC process,
healthcare organizations can identify and eliminate defects, resulting in significant
improvements. Many healthcare organizations have already successfully
implemented Six Sigma and, as a result, have seen significant cost savings and
improvements in patient care.
Lean Six Sigma is a methodology that combines the principles of Lean (focused on waste reduction and
process efficiency) with Six Sigma (focused on reducing variation and improving quality). In
healthcare, Lean Six Sigma aims to improve patient outcomes, streamline processes, and enhance
efficiency. Below are the detailed steps of Lean Six Sigma as applied to healthcare:
1. Define (D):
The first phase involves clearly defining the problem or opportunity for improvement.
Key Activities:
Identify the Problem: Understand the issue affecting patient care, operational efficiency, or safety (e.g.,
long patient wait times or medication errors).
Define Goals: Align improvement goals with organizational objectives, such as improving patient
satisfaction or reducing costs.
Assemble a Team: Include cross-functional members such as physicians, nurses, administrators, and
other staff.
Develop a Project Charter: Document the problem statement, scope, goals, and timeline.
Understand Customer Needs: Identify the "Voice of the Customer" (VOC) through surveys, interviews,
or feedback.
2. Measure (M):
Quantify the problem by collecting relevant data to understand the current performance.
Key Activities:
Map the Current Process: Use tools like process maps or value stream maps to visualize workflows.
Identify Metrics: Determine key performance indicators (KPIs) (e.g., patient throughput, readmission
rates).
Collect Data: Gather baseline data related to the problem (e.g., average patient wait times, error rates).
Assess Process Capability: Evaluate current performance and identify variations or inefficiencies.
3. Analyze (A):
Investigate the root causes of the problem using statistical and analytical tools.
Key Activities:
4. Improve (I):
Key Activities:
5. Control (C):
Sustain improvements and ensure the process remains efficient and effective.
Key Activities:
Reducing Patient Wait Times: Streamlining patient check-in and triage processes.
Improving Medication Delivery: Ensuring accurate and timely medication administration.
Minimizing Surgical Errors: Standardizing pre-operative checklists and workflows.
Optimizing Staffing: Balancing staff schedules to meet patient demand without overstaffing.
By following these steps, healthcare organizations can enhance efficiency, improve patient satisfaction,
and achieve better clinical outcomes.
Here’s an overview of Value Stream Mapping, 5S, Kaizen, Kanban, and Just-in-Time with detailed explanations and how they apply in
healthcare:
Definition:
A Lean tool used to visualize the flow of materials, information, and processes required to deliver a product or service. It identifies value-added
and non-value-added activities.
Application in Healthcare:
Steps:
2. 5S
Definition:
A workplace organization method for improving efficiency by maintaining a clean, orderly environment. The 5S's stand for:
Application in Healthcare:
Organizing supply rooms to ensure essential medical supplies are easy to locate.
Reducing time spent searching for equipment, like IV pumps or surgical tools.
Keeping patient rooms clean and orderly to prevent infections.
3. Kaizen
Definition:
Application in Healthcare:
Key Principles:
4. Kanban
Definition:
A visual management tool for workflow optimization. It uses cards or boards to represent tasks and their progress.
Application in Healthcare:
Patient Flow Management: Use Kanban boards to track patients' status, such as "Admitted," "In Procedure," or "Discharged."
Supply Chain Management: Monitor inventory levels to avoid stockouts or overstocking.
Staff Task Management: Assign and monitor progress on responsibilities like lab tests or documentation.
Steps:
5. Just-in-Time (JIT)
Definition:
A production strategy aimed at reducing inventory and ensuring items or services are available precisely when needed.
Application in Healthcare:
Deliver medical supplies and medications only when required, reducing storage costs and waste (e.g., expired drugs).
Schedule patient appointments and tests to minimize idle time for staff and equipment.
Streamline surgical instrument sterilization to ensure readiness without surplus preparation.
Benefits:
Value Stream Mapping End-to-end process visualization Identifies bottlenecks and waste in patient care.
Kanban Visual workflow management Tracks patient progress and tasks efficiently.
Just-in-Time Delivering services/resources when needed Minimizes waste and reduces inventory costs.
By combining these tools, healthcare organizations can achieve a lean, efficient, and patient-centered approach to care.
What is Lean?
Lean is an approach to quality that focuses on reducing waste, waiting time, and saving money.
The focus on Lean is not necessarily to fix something that has gone wrong, but it is about finding value in a process or
product and maximizing this,
The outcome of Lean is to deliver a process that has higher productivity and efficiency.
The 5 Key Principles of Lean are: Identity value, Map the value stream, Create flow, Establish flow, Seek perfection.
There are a number of tools that can be used within Lean including Kaizen, Gemba, Poke Yoke, 5S, etc.
Lean is not an end state, but a constant. You need to identify how to instil Lean and how to maintain it.
The 8 wastes
1. Defects
2. Overproduction
3. Waiting
4. Non-utilization
5. Transport
6. Inventory
7. Motion
8. Extra processing