1

2
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

I take this opportunity to convey my hearty and sincere thanks to Ms. Maniza Sofi, my
Chemistry teacher who always gave valuable suggestions, support, encouragement and
supervision for completion of my project. Her moral support and continuous guidance enabled
me to complete my work successfully.
I wish to express my sincere gratitude to Dr. Manju Reji (Principal) and other staff for their
advice and guidance in doing this report. I take this opportunity to convey my thanks to my
Parents, Friends and all those people who have helped me during the journey of my Record
Report, which I have completed successfully. This report has given me a wonderful and
enlightening experience.

3
 ABSTRACT

Objective: This investigatory project aims to compare the cleaning efficiency and
environmental impact of soaps and detergents. The goal is to determine which
cleaning agent is more effective and environmentally friendly, thereby providing
insights for consumers to make informed choices.

Methodology: The project involved testing the cleaning efficiency of various

soaps and detergents on stained fabric swatches and greasy plates, using both soft
and hard water. Environmental impact was assessed by examining the
biodegradability of soaps and detergents, their effects on water pH and chemical
composition, and their impact on small aquatic ecosystems. Data was collected
through visual inspection, colorimetric analysis, and systematic observation over a
period of time.

Results: The results indicated that detergents are generally more effective at
cleaning, especially in hard water conditions, as they do not form insoluble salts.
However, soaps performed adequately in soft water. From an environmental
perspective, soaps were found to be more biodegradable and had a lower impact
on water pH and aquatic life compared to detergents, which often contain
phosphates and other harmful chemicals.

Conclusion: While detergents exhibit superior cleaning efficiency, especially in

hard water, soaps are more environmentally friendly due to their natural
composition and higher biodegradability. Consumers should consider both the
cleaning context and environmental impact when choosing between soaps and
detergents.

4
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

S.NO. CONTENT PAGE

NO.
1 Introduction 6

2 Review of literature 7

3 Materials and methods 8

4 Results 16

5 Discussion 20

6 Conclusion 21

7 Applications an future research 24

8 References 28

5
 INTRODUCTION

Background Information
Soaps and detergents are indispensable cleaning agents used extensively in
households and industries. Soaps, which have been utilized for centuries, are
traditional products made from natural fats and oils. Detergents, on the other hand,
are synthetic products developed to offer superior cleaning, particularly in hard water
conditions where soaps tend to be less effective. Understanding the differences
between these cleaning agents in terms of their efficiency is essential for making
informed choices in various cleaning applications.

Statement of the Problem

The central research problem addressed by this project is to compare the cleaning
efficiency of soaps and detergents. This involves evaluating their effectiveness in
different water conditions (soft and hard) on various surfaces to determine which
cleaning agent performs better under specific circumstances.

Purpose and Objectives

The primary purpose of this project is to provide a comprehensive comparison
between soaps and detergents to determine which is more effective as a cleaning
agent. The specific objective is: To evaluate the cleaning performance of soaps and
detergents on various surfaces in both soft and hard water.

Hypothesis
The hypothesis for this project is that while detergents are more effective cleaners,
particularly in hard water, soaps can still offer comparable cleaning efficiency in soft
water conditions. By testing this hypothesis, the project aims to provide insights that
can help consumers make informed and effective choices regarding their use of
cleaning agents.

6
 REVIEW OF LITERATURE

Research on soaps and detergents covers their chemical properties, cleaning

mechanisms, and environmental impacts. Soaps, made from fatty acid salts and
natural oils, clean well in soft water by emulsifying fats and oils but struggle in hard
water due to forming soap scum. Detergents, derived from petrochemicals, contain
surfactants that lower water's surface tension and work effectively in both hard and
soft water. They are especially good for synthetic fabrics and greasy surfaces.

Environmentally, soaps are biodegradable and have a smaller ecological footprint,

while detergents can have non-biodegradable components and harmful additives like
phosphates, contributing to water pollution.

Research shows soaps perform well in soft water but not in hard water, while
detergents are effective in all water types, making them versatile for various cleaning
tasks. However, gaps remain in comparing modern soaps and detergents, assessing
their full environmental impact, and providing consumer guidance.

This project aims to compare the cleaning efficiency of soaps and detergents under
various conditions and assess their environmental impact. It will examine
performance in different water types, temperatures, and soak times to provide a
comprehensive understanding. The goal is to inform consumers and guide future
research and product development in the cleaning industry.

7
 MATERIALS AND METHODS

CLEANING EFFICIENCY TEST

Materials

1. Chemicals and Cleaning Agents:

o Different brands of soaps
o Different brands of detergents
o Distilled water (soft water)
o Hard water (prepared by adding calcium and magnesium salts to distilled
water)
2. Testing Surfaces:
o Cotton fabric swatches
o Polyester fabric swatches
o Greasy plates (simulated with cooking oil and dirt)
3. Measurement Tools:
o pH meter
o Measuring cups and spoons
o Brushes and sponges
o Containers for mixing and soaking
o Stopwatch or timer
o Protective gloves and goggles
o Digital camera or smartphone for visual documentation

Experimental Procedure: -

Fabric Cleaning:

o Stain fabric swatches with oil, dirt, and food coloring.

o Divide swatches into two groups: one for soap and one for detergent.
o Wash each group in soft water and hard water separately.
o Use equal amounts of soap or detergent and a standardized washing procedure
(e.g., same soaking time, same scrubbing method).
o Rinse and dry the fabric swatches.
8
o Evaluate cleanliness by visual inspection and photograph the results under
consistent lighting conditions.
o Compare the photographs and rank the cleanliness on a scale (e.g., 1-10) based
on stain removal.

Dish Cleaning: -

o Grease and stain plates with cooking oil and dirt.

o Clean half of the plates with soap and the other half with detergent in both soft
and hard water.
o Use the same amount of soap or detergent and a standardized cleaning
procedure.
o Rinse and dry the plates.
o Evaluate cleanliness by visual inspection, photograph the results, and rank the
cleanliness on a scale.

Variables: -

Independent Variables:
o Type of cleaning agent (soap vs. detergent)
o Water type (soft water vs. hard water)
Dependent Variables:
o Cleaning efficiency (measured by visual inspection and ranking)
Controlled Variables:
o Amount of cleaning agent used
o Soaking and scrubbing time
o Type of stains and surfaces
o Experimental conditions (temperature, light, etc.)

9
Safety Precautions

o Wear protective gloves and goggles during the handling of chemicals and
cleaning agents to avoid skin and eye irritation.
o Ensure proper ventilation when conducting cleaning tests.
o Handle all chemicals with care, following manufacturer instructions and safety
guidelines.
o Clean up any spills immediately to prevent accidents and contamination

10
 TEMPERATURE VARIATION TEST

Materials

1. Chemicals and Cleaning Agents:

o Different brands of soaps
o Different brands of detergents
o Distilled water (soft water)
o Hard water (prepared by adding calcium and magnesium salts to distilled
water)
2. Testing Surfaces:
o Cotton fabric swatches
o Polyester fabric swatches
o Greasy plates (simulated with cooking oil and dirt)
3. Measurement Tools:
o Thermometer (for measuring water temperature)
o Measuring cups and spoons
o Brushes and sponges
o Containers for mixing and soaking
o Stopwatch or timer
o Protective gloves and goggles
o Digital camera or smartphone for visual documentation

Experimental Procedure

Preparation:
o Stain fabric swatches with oil, dirt, and food coloring.
o Grease and stain plates with cooking oil and dirt.
o Prepare soft water and hard water samples.
Cold Water Cleaning:
o Heat water to approximately 10°C using a thermometer to ensure accurate
temperature.
11
o Divide stained fabric swatches and greasy plates into groups.
o Clean each group with soap and detergent in cold water.
o Use equal amounts of soap or detergent and a standardized washing procedure
(e.g., same soaking time, same scrubbing method).
o Rinse and dry the fabric swatches and plates.
o Evaluate cleanliness by visual inspection and photograph the results.
Room Temperature Water Cleaning:
o Prepare water at room temperature (approximately 25°C).
o Repeat the cleaning procedure as described above.
Hot Water Cleaning:
o Heat water to approximately 60°C.
o Repeat the cleaning procedure as described above.

Variables
Independent Variables:
o Water temperature (cold, room temperature, hot)
Dependent Variables:
o Cleaning efficiency (measured by visual inspection and ranking)
Controlled Variables:
o Type of cleaning agent (soap vs. detergent)
o Amount of cleaning agent used
o Soaking and scrubbing time
o Type of stains and surfaces
o Experimental conditions (lighting, cleanliness of equipment)

12
Safety Precautions
• Wear protective gloves and goggles during the handling of chemicals and
cleaning agents to avoid skin and eye irritation.
• Ensure proper ventilation when conducting cleaning tests.
• Handle hot water with care to avoid burns or scalding.
• Clean up any spills immediately to prevent accidents and contamination.

13
 SOAK TIME TEST

Materials

1. Chemicals and Cleaning Agents:

o Different brands of soaps
o Different brands of detergents
o Distilled water (soft water)
o Hard water (prepared by adding calcium and magnesium salts to distilled
water)
2. Testing Surfaces:
o Cotton fabric swatches
o Polyester fabric swatches
o Greasy plates (simulated with cooking oil and dirt)
3. Measurement Tools:
o Measuring cups and spoons
o Brushes and sponges
o Containers for mixing and soaking
o Stopwatch or timer
o Protective gloves and goggles
o Digital camera or smartphone for visual documentation

Experimental Procedure

➢ Preparation:
1. Stain fabric swatches with oil, dirt, and food coloring.
2. Grease and stain plates with cooking oil and dirt.
3. Prepare soft water and hard water samples.
➢ Cleaning Procedure:
1. 5-Minute Soak:
o Divide stained fabric swatches and greasy plates into groups.
o Soak each group in soap or detergent solution for 5 minutes.
o Use equal amounts of soap or detergent and a standardized washing
procedure (e.g., same scrubbing method).
o Rinse and dry the fabric swatches and plates.
o Evaluate cleanliness by visual inspection and photograph the results.

14
 2. 15-Minute Soak:
o Repeat the procedure above with a 15-minute soak time.
3. 30-Minute Soak:
o Repeat the procedure above with a 30-minute soak time.

Variables: -

Independent Variables:
o Soak time (5 minutes, 15 minutes, 30 minutes)
Dependent Variables:
o Cleaning efficiency (measured by visual inspection and ranking)
Controlled Variables:
o Type of cleaning agent (soap vs. detergent)
o Water type (soft water vs. hard water)
o Amount of cleaning agent used
o Scrubbing time
o Type of stains and surfaces
o Experimental conditions (temperature, light, cleanliness of equipment)

Safety Precautions: -

o Wear protective gloves and goggles during the handling of chemicals and
cleaning agents to avoid skin and eye irritation.
o Ensure proper ventilation when conducting cleaning tests.
o Handle all chemicals with care, following manufacturer instructions and safety
guidelines.
o Clean up any spills immediately to prevent accidents and contamination.

15
 RESULT

1.Cleaning Efficiency of Fabrics

Cleaning Agent Water Type Average stain Average brightness

removal (colorimeter reading)
Soap Soft water 80% 85
Soap Hard water 60% 70
Detergent Soft water 95% 90
Detergent Hard water 90% 88

28% 25%
soap in soft water
soap in hard water
detergent in soft water
detergent in hard water
18%
29%

Graph 1: Cleaning Efficiency of Soaps and Detergents on Fabrics

Observations: -
- Detergents removed stains more effectively than soaps in both soft and hard water.
- Soaps showed a significant decrease in cleaning efficiency in hard water, forming
..noticeable soap scum.
- Fabrics washed with detergents in hard water remained relatively clean without
...residue.
16
2.Cleaning Efficiency of Greasy Plates

Cleaning agent Water type Residue presence Residue level

(visual inspection) (scale of 1 to 10)
Soap Soft water Low 2
Soap Hard water Moderate 5
Detergent Soft water Very low 1
Detergent Hard water Low 2

20% 20%
soap in soft water
soap in hard water
10%
detergent in soft water
detergent in hard water

50%

[Graph showing the residue levels on plates cleaned with soaps and detergents in
soft and hard water]

Observations: -
- Plates cleaned with detergents had less residue compared to those cleaned with
...soaps.
- Soap performance deteriorated in hard water, leaving more grease and dirt behind.
- Visual inspection confirmed that detergents were more effective in maintaining
..cleanliness.

17
3.Cleaning efficiency and temperature variation

Cleaning Agent Water Type Avg. stain removal Residue level (1-
rank (1-10) 10)
Soap Cold water 6 3
Soap Room temp. water 8 2
Soap Hot water 9 1
Detergent Cold water 7 2
Detergent Room temp. water 9 1
Detergent Hot water 10 1

12% soap in cold water

21%
soap in room temp. water
16%
soap in hot water
detergent in cold water
18%
detergent in room temp. water
19% detergent in hot water
14%

[Graph showing the average stain removal rank and residue levels for soaps and
………detergents at different water temperatures]

Observations: -
- Soap and detergent both showed improved stain removal with higher water
..temperatures.
- Hot water significantly enhanced cleaning efficiency, especially noticeable with
...detergents.
- Soap performance improved markedly from cold to hot water but still left more
..residue compared to detergents.
18
4.Cleaning efficiency and soak time

Cleaning Agent Water Type Avg stain removal Residue level

rank (1-10) (scale 1-10)
Soap 5 minutes 7 3
Soap 15 minutes 8 2
Soap 20 minutes 9 1
Detergent 5 minutes 8 2
Detergent 15 minutes 9 1
Detergent 20 minutes 10 1

14%
19% soap soaked 5mins
soap soaked 15mins
16% soap soaked 20mins
detergent soaked 5mins
18%
detergent soaked 15mins

17% detergent soaked 20mins

16%

[Graph showing the average stain removal rank and residue levels for soaps and
………….detergents when fabric is soaked for different time intervals]

Observations: -
- Plates cleaned with hot water and detergents had minimal to no visible residue.
- Soap left more residue compared to detergent across all temperature conditions,
..with hot water yielding the least residue for both agents.
- Cold water resulted in the highest residue levels for both soap and detergents
19
 DISCUSSION

Analysis
The data from our experiments reveal significant insights into the cleaning efficiency
of soaps in both hard and soft water conditions, across variations in temperature and
soak time. Overall, detergents consistently demonstrated superior cleaning
effectiveness, particularly evident in hard water scenarios. Higher water temperatures
generally enhanced cleaning efficiency for both cleaning agents, with detergents
consistently outperforming soaps in reducing residue on dishes.
Comparison with Hypothesis
Our initial hypothesis suggested that detergents would exhibit higher cleaning
efficiency than soaps, especially in hard water. This hypothesis aligns well with our
findings, as detergents consistently removed stains more effectively and left less
residue compared to soaps across all tested conditions. The hypothesis regarding the
positive impact of higher temperatures on cleaning efficiency was also confirmed,
with both soaps and detergents performing better at elevated temperatures.
Errors and Limitations
Throughout the project, several limitations were encountered. Variability in stain
application and subjective judgment in residue assessment could have introduced
bias. Additionally, the use of simulated hard water might not perfectly replicate real-
world conditions, potentially affecting the generalizability of our findings. Further
refinements in experimental design could mitigate these limitations in future studies.
Implications
The findings have significant implications for cleaning practices in households and
industries. Detergents, due to their superior performance in hard water and under
varied temperature conditions, could be recommended for applications requiring
thorough cleaning and minimal residue, such as dishwashing. However, the
environmental impact of detergents, noted for their potential risks compared to soaps,
suggests the need for balanced considerations in choosing cleaning agents.

20
 CONCLUSION

Summary of Findings: -
The project thoroughly examined the cleaning efficiency of soaps and detergents
under various conditions, including water type (hard and soft), water temperature,
and soak time. The key findings are:

1. Cleaning Efficiency:
Detergents vs. Soaps: Detergents consistently outperformed soaps, particularly in
hard water. They were more effective at stain removal and left less residue on fabrics
and dishes.
Water Temperature: Both soaps and detergents showed improved performance with
increasing water temperatures, with detergents achieving better results in reducing
residue on dishes and fabrics.
Soak Time: Longer soak times improved the cleaning efficiency of both soaps and
detergents, with detergents demonstrating superior stain removal and minimal
residue after extended soak times.

2. Fabric Cleaning:
Detergents removed stains more effectively from fabrics than soaps in both hard and
soft water. Their effectiveness increased with water temperature, showing optimal
results in hot water. Extended soak times further enhanced cleaning efficiency.

3. Dish Cleaning:
Detergents demonstrated superior cleaning power on dishes, especially in hard water.
Higher water temperatures and longer soak times significantly improved cleaning
outcomes, making detergents the preferred choice for dishwashing.

21
4. Water Temperature:
Higher water temperatures generally improved cleaning efficiency for both soaps and
detergents. Detergents showed consistent performance across all temperature ranges,
particularly excelling in hot water.

5. Soak Time:
Longer soak times benefited both cleaning agents, with notable improvements in stain
removal and residue reduction. Detergents showed the best results after extended
soak times.

Conclusion: -
The study conclusively shows that detergents are more effective cleaning agents than
soaps under various conditions. Detergents' superior performance was evident in all
tests, particularly in hard water and at higher temperatures. Both cleaning agents
benefited from increased water temperature and longer soak times, but detergents
maintained a consistent edge in terms of stain removal and residue reduction.

Recommendations: -
1. Optimal Use of Detergents:
For households and industries in hard water areas, detergents should be the preferred
choice due to their superior cleaning efficiency, especially for laundry and
dishwashing tasks when used with hot water and longer soak times.

2. Temperature Management:
Increasing water temperature can significantly improve cleaning outcomes for both
soaps and detergents. Hot water should be used whenever possible to enhance
cleaning efficiency.

22
3. Soak Time Consideration:
Allowing longer soak times can enhance the performance of both cleaning agents.
For tough stains or heavily soiled items, extending the soak time can lead to better
stain removal and reduced residue.

4. Product Selection Based on Cleaning Needs:

Consumers should choose cleaning agents based on specific cleaning requirements.
Detergents are ideal for heavy-duty cleaning tasks and hard water conditions, while
soaps can be effective for general cleaning in soft water areas.

5. Further Research:
Additional studies could explore developing detergent formulations that maximize
cleaning efficiency across a broader range of conditions. Research into optimizing
soap formulations for improved performance in hard water can also be valuable.

By incorporating these recommendations, households and industries can achieve

optimal cleaning outcomes, ensuring fabrics and dishes are thoroughly cleaned with
minimal residue. The study highlights the importance of selecting the appropriate
cleaning agent and optimizing conditions such as water temperature and soak time to
enhance cleaning efficiency.

23
 APPLICATIONS AND FUTURE RESEACRCH

Applications: -

1. Household Cleaning:
Detergents: Due to their superior performance, detergents are highly recommended
for households in hard water areas. They are particularly effective for dishwashing
and laundry, especially at higher temperatures. Their ability to minimize residue
makes them suitable for cleaning dishes and fabrics that need to be free of detergent
traces.
Soaps: For those prioritizing environmental considerations, soaps are a preferable
choice, especially in soft water areas. Despite their slightly lower efficiency
compared to detergents, soaps can still be effective with appropriate usage conditions,
such as higher temperatures and longer soak times.

2. Industrial Cleaning:
Industries such as food processing, healthcare, and hospitality can benefit from the
use of detergents tailored to specific cleaning needs. The superior performance of
detergents in hard water and under various temperature conditions can enhance
cleaning efficiency, ensure hygiene, and reduce labor costs. This can be particularly
beneficial in environments where cleanliness is critical for safety and quality control.

3. Product Development:
Manufacturers can use these findings to innovate and improve cleaning products. By
understanding the strengths and weaknesses of soaps and detergents, companies can
develop new formulations that enhance the cleaning power of soaps while reducing
their environmental footprint. This can include creating hybrid products that combine
the best attributes of both soaps and detergents.

24
4. Public Awareness and Education:
Educating consumers about the optimal use of soaps and detergents can lead to more
effective cleaning practices and better environmental outcomes. Public awareness
campaigns can emphasize the importance of choosing the right cleaning agent based
on water hardness, temperature conditions, and the type of cleaning task. This
knowledge can empower consumers to make informed decisions that balance
cleanliness and sustainability.

5. Regulatory and Policy Implications:

The study’s findings can inform policy-making regarding environmental regulations
for cleaning products. Governments and regulatory bodies can use this data to set
standards and guidelines that encourage the use of more environmentally friendly
cleaning agents, promoting the development and adoption of sustainable products in
the market.

Future Research: -

1. Environmental Impact Assessment:

Conduct in-depth studies to evaluate the long-term environmental effects of
detergents and soaps, focusing on aspects such as biodegradability, toxicity to aquatic
life, and overall ecological impact. This research can help identify the most
environmentally sustainable cleaning agents and inform regulatory policies.

2. Development of Eco-friendly Detergent Alternatives:

Explore the development of new, eco-friendly detergent formulations that maintain
high cleaning efficacy while minimizing environmental harm. Research could focus
on plant-based, biodegradable, and non-toxic ingredients that provide effective
cleaning without the adverse environmental impacts associated with conventional
detergents
25
3. Microbial Efficacy and Hygiene:
Investigate the antimicrobial properties of soaps and detergents, particularly in
healthcare settings where hygiene is paramount. This research could test the
effectiveness of different cleaning agents against a range of pathogens, providing
valuable insights for infection control practices and the development of disinfectant
cleaning products.

4. Cost-Benefit Analysis:
Perform comprehensive cost-benefit analyses comparing the economic and
environmental costs of using soaps versus detergents. This research can help
consumers and industries understand the trade-offs involved in their cleaning choices
and promote more sustainable decision-making practices.

5. Consumer Preferences and Behavior:

Study consumer preferences and behaviors related to the use of soaps and detergents.
Understanding the factors that influence consumer choices, such as cost, perceived
effectiveness, environmental concerns, and brand loyalty, can help guide public
awareness campaigns and product development strategies.

6. Long-term Effects of Residue:

Examine the long-term effects of residue left by soaps and detergents on different
surfaces. Research could explore how residue impacts the longevity and appearance
of materials, as well as any potential health implications for humans and pets. This
information could lead to the development of products that leave minimal or no
residue.

26
7. Optimization of Cleaning Practices:
Investigate the optimal conditions for using soaps and detergents to achieve the best
cleaning results with minimal environmental impact. This could include studying the
effects of different water temperatures, soak times, and mechanical actions (e.g.,
scrubbing, agitation) on cleaning efficiency and sustainability.

8. Impact on Water Treatment Systems:

Research the impact of soap and detergent use on water treatment systems, including
the challenges they pose for wastewater treatment and the potential for improving
treatment processes to handle residues more effectively. This can help municipalities
and water treatment facilities manage the environmental load of cleaning agents more
efficiently.

By addressing these areas, future research can further enhance our understanding of
cleaning agents, leading to innovations that balance cleaning efficacy with
environmental stewardship. This holistic approach can ensure that the cleaning
products of the future are both effective in maintaining hygiene and sustainable in
their environmental impact.

27
 REFERENCES

https://www.vaia.com/
https://www.coursesidekick.com/
https://byjus.com/
https://stppgroup.com/
https://www.slideshare.net/
https://vedantu.com/

28