Inheritance Law in Germany
Inheritance Law in Germany
Australia (NSW)
1. Introduction
This article gives an overview of inheritance law in Germany and Australia. The article also
highlights aspects of inheritance laws in both countries and indicates how these laws may
affect, for example, German citizens or expatriates living in Australia as well as Australian
residents with assets in both Germany and Australia and people living in Australia with
relatives in Germany.
This article also provides a general comparison of German and Australian inheritance laws. It
does not deal with specific issues, but outlines some of the basic principles of both systems.
The following areas are dealt with:
In Australia, reference is often made to trusts. A trust is a common law concept which is
largely unknown to the German legal system, and should not be confused with the German
concept of Treuhandverhältnis. Under Australian law, a trust exists where a party (a trustee)
who, despite being registered or recorded as the proprietor or owner of the relevant
property (trust property), holds that property on behalf of another person or entity
(beneficiary) or other legally recognised purpose (object). The trustee accordingly has a duty
to administer the trust property for the benefit of the beneficiary or for the specific purpose.
By comparison, the Treuhandverhältnis under German law is a two party relationship, similar
to a principal-agent relationship. In a Treuhandverhältnis, the owner appoints a so-called
“Treuhänder” who acts in favour of, and only as representative for the owner. The owner
remains at all times the beneficial and legal owner of the relevant asset. There are no
beneficiaries.
2. Statutory Inheritance
In this article, statutory inheritance law refers to the legal rules applying under German and
Australian law respectively if a person dies intestate (i.e. wholly or partly without a legally
effective Will or Testamentary Contract under German law).
Note:
The term “the intestate” is used in this article to mean a person who dies intestate. If a
person has made a legally effective Will or a Testamentory Contract under German law then
he or she is referred to in this article as the “testator”.
2.1. Germany
The deceased’s surviving spouse does not belong to the beneficiaries of the
first or any other order, and is not part of the system of orders. However, he
or she is a statutory beneficiary. A surviving spouse’s entitlement to receive
a share in an estate only flows from the fact of marriage.
A beneficiary can waive his or her claim to an estate within a period of six
weeks after he or she becomes aware of the inheritance. This period is
extended to six months if the deceased’s last place of residence was, or the
beneficiary’s residence is outside Germany.
Under German law, the statutory order of inheritance follows the scheme
described below:
2.1.3.1. the issue of the deceased. The biological and adopted children as
well as children born out of wedlock of the deceased, are the first
in line to inherit. Children always inherit in equal shares;
2.1.3.2. if the deceased has no issue, the estate passes to the beneficiaries
who fall within the second order i.e. the parents of the deceased.
The deceased’s father and mother are each entitled to half of the
estate. If they are no longer alive, the estate falls equally to their
issue, namely the deceased’s siblings;
2.1.3.3. the beneficiaries of the third order are the grandparents of the
deceased. They inherit in equal shares. If one grandparent has
already died, his or her issue will take his or her place; and
2.2. Australia
The position overall is, in Germany, a person who does not want to become
a beneficiary must act within a certain time limit while, in Australia, a person
who wants to claim on an estate must act within a certain time limit if the
executor or administrator of the estate does not otherwise have notice of
the claim.
In the case of full intestacy (i.e. where the deceased did not leave a valid
Will), the entire estate passes under the rules of intestacy. In the case of
partial intestacy (i.e. where the deceased left a valid Will but which did not
dispose of the entire estate), the undisposed part of the estate passes under
the rules of intestacy.
2.2.3.1. spouse;
2.2.3.3. parents;
2.2.3.4. siblings;
2.2.3.7. aunts and uncles (or their children if an aunt or uncle predeceases
the intestate).
2.2.3.3. if the deceased is survived by more than one spouse (e.g. by both
someone to whom the deceased was legally married as well as
another person with whom the deceased was in a domestic
partnership at the time of his or her death), the estate will be
divided between the spouses in accordance with the mechanism
for determining priority between competing spousal interests set
3. Forms of Wills
3.1. Germany
For a simple Will to be valid, it must either be prepared and signed in the
presence of a notary, or the entire text of the Will must be handwritten and
signed by the testator. All other forms of writing (such as printing,
photography etc.) would not satisfy the formal requirements. If the Will is
entirely written by the testator, no witnesses are necessary. If the Will is
made in the presence of a notary, the notary must witness the execution of
the document. The formal requirement for a valid signature will be satisfied
once the testator’s authorship can be established without objection. Thus,
for example, the inscription “Your father” is enough to establish the identity
of the writer. However, careful checks must be made to ensure that the
testator can be identified without ambiguity. The date and place of making
the Will are not legal requirements for a simple Will to be valid, but
nevertheless it is recommended that these details be inserted into the Will.
A Mutual Will is reserved for married couples. It can incorporate the special
feature of making “reciprocal provisions”. This means that the consideration
for one spouse making a testamentary provision is the making of a
testamentary provision by the other spouse. The same formal requirements
apply to a Mutual Will as to a simple Will except that it is sufficient if only
one spouse writes out the Will in his or her own hand and both spouses sign
it.
3.2. Australia
3.2.1. Wills
3.2.1.1. Wills
3.2.2.2. the testator must sign the document in the presence of two
witnesses who are both present at the same time and in the
presence of the testator.
The Will need not, but is usually signed by the testator at the foot of each
page of the document.
4. Executors
4.1. Germany
A testator may in his or her Will, nominate an executor of the Will (called
Testamentsvollstrecker). The main duty of such an executor is to carry out the
provisions of the deceased’s Will. An executor of a Will must declare whether he or
she accepts the appointment. This declaration need not take place within a certain
period of time unless the Probate Court notifies the person named in the Will as
executor to declare his or her acceptance within a certain time.
If the Will does not appoint an executor, the German Probate Court having
jurisdiction in the matter may nominate an administrator (Nachlasspfleger) if the
Court considers it is necessary to do so in order to protect the estate’s assets and the
beneficiaries of the estate are unknown or cannot be found.
4.2. Australia
An executor has a far more important and powerful position in Australia than in
Germany. In fact, the choice of executor is a critical estate planning issue. The role
of an executor entails considerable responsibilities. An executor is able to do all that
is legally necessary in order to achieve the due and proper administration of the
estate. In particular, an executor is required to attend to the following matters in
the administration of the estate:
4.2.2. collect, maintain and protect assets pending the final distribution of the
estate;
4.2.5. pay all debts, funeral and testamentary expenses of the deceased and the
estate;
4.2.6. if the estate has earned income, obtain a tax file number and lodge any tax
returns;
4.2.7. establish and administer any trusts created by the Will for minors; and
4.2.8. distribute the estate in accordance with the provisions of the Will.
Note:
In Australia, on the death of the testator, all the deceased’s assets pass to or vest in
the executor (section 44 PAA) who is responsible to deal with them and distribute
them in accordance with the Will. The transfer of ownership is, in effect, only
confirmed by the grant of probate or administration.
The term statutory or compulsory portion (Pflichtteil) refers to the share of the estate that
must be left to certain members of the deceased’s family under German law.
5.1. Germany
As a classic civil law country with codified civil and inheritance laws, in Germany the
testator’s relatives can claim a fixed statutory portion of the estate against a
beneficiary. The compulsory portion is an amount equivalent to one-half of the
person’s entitlement under statutory succession. The claim to a statutory share
arises at the time of inheritance. The claim is binding on the estate, and attaches to
the estate as a whole. The claim is assignable and can be transmitted to another
person or a specified succession of heirs. The period of limitation is three years from
the time the person becomes aware of the inheritance and the testator’s Will.
The people entitled to a statutory share are the deceased’s issue, his or her parents
and his or her spouse. The attached diagrammatic overview also shows the
respective compulsory portions and free quotas in certain circumstances.
5.2. Australia
Australian inheritance law does not recognize fixed statutory shares as provided for
under German law. As Australian law is founded on the English common law system,
“family provision” (similar in some respects to statutory share) claims by “eligible
persons” are dealt with by the Supreme Court under the Succession Act, but only if a
claim is in fact made. It remains within the Court’s discretion whether, to what
extent and on what basis, family provision claims are to be provided for out of the
estate.
6. Taxes
6.1. Germany
The rate of tax payable depends on the net value of the estate and the tax
class which the beneficiary belongs to.
There are three tax classes under German law. The applicable tax class is
determined by the relationship between the deceased and the beneficiary.
That relationship also determines the amount of allowable deductions under
the legislation.
6.1.1.1. spouse;
6.1.1.3. step-parents;
6.1.1.4. children-in-law;
The lowest tax rate and the highest level of allowable deductions apply to
members of the first tax class. For example, if the net value of the estate
amounts to €512,000.00, the deceased’s spouse would currently receive an
allowable deduction of €306,000.00. Overall in a case like this, a tax rate of
15% would apply.
Germany does not have capital gains tax. Therefore, unlike Australia, no
further “delayed death duty” is payable.
6.2. Australia
Capital Gains Tax (CGT) is a federal tax and accordingly applies throughout
Australia. The rate of CGT is generally dependent on the taxpayer’s marginal
income tax rate for the financial year during which the capital gains tax event
(CGT event) occurs. CGT is not, however, payable on the transfer of assets
under a Will. Accordingly, estate assets may be transferred to beneficiaries
(at least those resident in Australia) without either the estate or the
beneficiaries becoming liable to CGT. If beneficiaries resident overseas are
involved then gifts to them are deemed to be a CGT event which occurred
immediately before the deceased’s death and, as a result, CGT may be
imposed on the estate in respect of the gift.
Liability for, and the amount of CGT payable depends on a number of factors
including the nature of the asset concerned, when the asset was originally
acquired by the testator, when the testator died, when the asset is
subsequently disposed of by the beneficiary, whether the beneficiary is a
natural person or, for example, a corporate entity or a trust, and the
marginal tax rate of the beneficiary at the time of disposal. Certain assets,
such as the testator’s family home, may remain permanently CGT exempt in
the hands of the estate and the beneficiary provided that certain residence
rules are met or the home is disposed of within a particular period after the
testator’s death (generally 3 years).
Generally there is no tax on assets in Australia, except for land tax payable
on certain classes of real property in certain states.
Because of the different taxes levied and not levied in Germany and Australia, estate
planning for people whose estates are affected by both systems involves careful
thought being given to arranging one’s financial affairs and estate matters in a tax
effective way.
7. International Aspects
7.1. Germany
7.2. Australia
Australia does not have a single federal law regulating international conflict of laws
or private international law as it is also called in common law countries; every state
and territory has its own common law rules.
8. Glossary
January 2012
Disclaimer
This article contains comments of a general nature only and is provided as an information service only. The article also
reflects the law as at the date it was written and may not take into account any recent or subsequent developments in the
law. The article is not intended to be relied upon, nor is it a substitute for specific professional advice. No responsibility can
be accepted by Schweizer Kobras, Lawyers & Notaries or the author(s) for any loss occasioned to any person doing
anything as a result of anything contained in the article.
Further Information
Norbert Schweizer
Partner
Michael Kobras
Partner
Schweizer Kobras
Lawyers & Notaries
Level 5, 23 - 25 O’Connell Street
Sydney NSW 2000
Telephone: +61 (0) 2 9223 9399
Facsimile: +61 (0) 2 9223 4729
Email: mail@schweizer.com.au
Website: www.schweizer.com.au
* if the spouses were married under the default matrimonial property regime of accrual. The entitlement would be
different if the spouses were married under the matrimonial property regime of community of property.
** if the spouses lived in a “Civil Union” (civil partnership registered under the Civil Partnership Code
“Lebenspartnerschaftsgesetz”).