Indian Writing
Indian Writing
Chapter I
Introduction
Indian Fiction in English has got a world-wide interest. It is the most characteristic
experiences and ideas of human beings. It is the outcome of a national ferment and upsurge.
It is brought about by the impact of the colonial rule in India. It manifests the cultural and
In the twenty first century, India advances itself in the field of fiction in English.
There are a large number of writers, writing fiction in English. They show their talent in
writing novels. They delineate the hopes and aspirations and failures and frustrations of
the individuals in their writings. Indian fiction in English attracts a widespread interest in
India and abroad. It is not inferior to any other literatures written in English. Indian English
fiction is used as a medium of creative exploration and expression of their experiences in life.
Indian fiction in English has become the most characteristic and powerful medium of
literary expression. The Indian Novel in English is the most acceptable way of embodying
experiences and ideas of human beings. It provides a sort of documentation. It reveals the
social tradition and socio-cultural changes. It concentrates on the changing social patterns.
It exposes the social transformations and values. It reveals the individual’s predicament
in a society in transition. It explores the the life of the ordinary man. It offers a wider
scope for the treatment of motives, feelings and the phenomena of man’s/woman’s inner
life.
2
It gives voice to the lower and middle class characters. Such characters form a
substantive part of the modern India. It developes a widening and deep sympathy with
man as man.
The early nineteenth century marked the beginning of Indian writing in English.
Indian novel in English came into existence in the later part of the nineteenth century.
Bankim Chandra Chatterjee was the first Indian novelist in English in India. He wrote the
points out that “the real beginnings were with the works of the great Bankim Chandra
Chatterjee’s (1838-1894). His first published novel – Rajmohan’s Wife (1864) – was in
English” (351). Later, Rabindranath Tagore, and Sarat Chandra Chatterjee became
well-known novelists in English. K. S. Venkataramani wrote Murugan, the Tiller (1927) and
Kandan, the Patriot (1932). After Venkata Ramani, the well-known novelists are Raj Anand,
R. K. Narayan and Raja Rao. All these novelists write about the middle class. The novel
in English started in Bengal. But immediately, its traces could be seen in Madras,
Bombay and other parts of India. Sumita Ashri in “Ruth Prawer Jhabvala as a Novelist: A
and conditions. The rise of the novel in India like England was not purely
within the society and devoted to the fulfilment of social needs. Hence, it
was associated with social, political and economic conditions, which led
the writers to analyze and express this spectrum of social reality, comparable
to the dynamics of society, with its attendant forces. So, the appearance of
the novel as a literary form in the nineteenth century India, as it did in the
and social reorientations, which followed. Also, its rise was one aspect of
the dawn of what may be called the modern era in Indian Literature-an era,
The entire history of Indian fiction in English is divided under four heads:
One Thousand and One Nights , Toru Dutt’s Bianca and Ramesh Chander
ii. the second head is called ‘Indianization’. It can be seen in the works of
Toru Dutt.
iii. the third head began with the dawn of the new century. It witnessed an
increase in Indianization.
iv. fourth head began with post-independent period. The novels published are
Patriot (1932), Mulk Raj Anand’s Untouchable (1935) and Coolie (1936)
and Raja Rao’s Kanthapura (1938) and The Serpent and the Rope (1960).
4
Indian English fiction in the post-independent India retained the momentum that
the novel had gained during the Gandhian age. Bhabani Bhattacharya wrote So Many Hungers
(1997) and He Who Rides a Tiger (1954). It was followed by Manohar Malgonkar’s novels
The Princes (1963) and A Bend in the Ganges (1964). Khushwant Singh, wrote novels
like Train to Pakistan (1956) and I Shall Not Hear the Nightingale (1959). Arun Joshi
and Chaman Nahal were sensitively alive to the human predicament in the modern times.
They wrote about the absence of values and faith, which have defrauded human beings.
Joshi wrote novels like The Foreigner (1968) and The Last Labyrinth (1981). Chaman
Nahal wrote My True Faces (1973), Azadi (1975) and The English Queens (1979). These
novels deal with the theme of understanding and the relevance of love and feelings in human
life. Vikram Seth and Amitav Ghosh wrote novels like The Golden Gate (1986) and A Suitable
Boy (1993), The Circle of Reason (1986) and The Hungry Tide (2004). These novels explore
various themes. They wanted to write about social change, social justice, freedom,
non-violence and so on. They had shed off their preceding counterparts’ obsession with
idealism, troubles and tribulations. They projected their own native reality. They restored
the identity and roots that had been lost. They are classified into three generations.
1. The first generation had the significant writers like Anand, Narayan and Raja Rao.
3. The third generation consisted of, mostly Contemporary novelists, like Rushdie,
Among the novelists like Anand, Narayan and Rao, “Anand is the novelist as a
reformer, and Narayan the novelist as a moral analyst, Raja Rao is the novelist as a
metaphysical poet” (Walsh, Indian Literature: 31). Anand has the realistic and the socio-
cultural reformatory attitude. Rao writes about the complex philosophical implications of
Indian culture. His fiction is a balanced one. It is a communication of the realities of Indian
life. It expresses the complexities of Indian philosophical thought and orthodoxy. Narayan
gets a place between these polarities. His fiction mixes the reality of Indian life along
Indian English novel has acquired recognition. It has gained a worldwide acclaim.
It is due to the growth of novels written by women. Indian English novel by Indian women
has dealt a variety of themes. It proves their maturity in narrative skill. Indian women
novelists have earned grounds and won critical appraisal and international recognition.
Their works are not considered as something derogatory. They are not melodramatic or
sub-stuff. They have proved that they are born story -tellers. They delve deep into the
inner workings of human mind. They show sympathy, sensitivity and understanding.
They present women as the silent sufferers. Women are presented as the upholders of the
tradition and traditional values of family and society. They have experienced a mighty change.
They present a woman as an individual. She rebels against the traditional roles/images.
They break the silent suffering. They try to move out of the slavish existence to assert their
individual selves. They add a new dimension to Indian fiction in English. They have exquisite
idea of men and matters. Their fiction constitutes a major-segment of the contemporary
Indian Writing in English. Their novels provide insights, understanding and a meaning of
life. They deal with the place and the position of women. They also portray their
6
problems and plights. They analyze the socio-cultural modes and values. They give
Indian women their role and image along with their efforts to achieve a harmonious
relationship with their surroundings. They aim at portraying Indian women’s sense of
Twentieth century noticed a sudden spurt in feminist writing. Indian women novelists
write about their in betweenness, hybridity and multicultural, multi-lingual and multi-
religious social dimensions. While the gynocritics consider that women novelist speak the
same language of silence, Indian women novelists like Gita Hariharan, Meena Alexander
Deshpande, Roy, and Kapur attempted to highlight with the physical, psychological and
emotional stress and syndrome of women. They delineate their inner life and subtle
They also write about the marital bliss and the women’s role at home. It results in the
They show their stronghold and grip. They show the world the unique power of imagination,
spontaneity and lyricism. They detail the depth of human psyche, especially women’s
psyche. They show strong consistency and stamina to locate them in different
perspectives.
The history of Indian women novelists in English starts with Toru Dutt. Her novels
share with the autobiographical elements of her own life. She writes about the agony and
catharsis arising out of the sisterly love and bereavement. After the Second World War,
Indian women novelists like Kamala Markandaya, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala, Anita Desai,
Nayantara Sahgal, and Nergis Dalal enumerated new dimensions and depth to Indian
fiction in English. The flowering of women writers has manifested the birth of an era.
7
It promised a new deal for the Indian fiction in English by women. Some women
novelists dealt with the battle of emancipation. They communicated to the world by
sharing their own bitter experiences through their writings as women. They shared experiences
of Indian women in common. They presented them in fictional form. They started reflecting
the sparks that came from this plight of a woman. They presented a change in her status,
in life and in the society. It could be assessed by reference to her image reflected in
literature in general and literature produced by her in particular. The reason could be
related to the emergence of educated women. They began to feel an increasing urge to voice
their feelings. They intuitively perceived the gender issues upsetting women. They presented
women as individuals, who fight against suppression and oppression of the patriarchy.
Manju Kapur had discussed the women of the 1940s. Her women had no voice to assert
their rights. They raise their voice against the male chauvinism. They want to claim the
rights of economic independence. Her women wrestle against the taboos, social and joint
family restrictions and curb laid by the patriarchy in the traditional life of India.
Women novelists in India are aware of feminism. Women’s liberation does not
mean loss of moral values. It is not to break the social harmony and institutions. Women’s
liberation is a state of mind. The women novelists in India have presented with immense
social and moral concerns. They understand their female characters. It is through the
confines of a novel, one can see what it means to be Indian women. Fiction helps them
see the depths of a woman’s psyche-as a mother, a lover, a victim and always a heroine.
Woman is earth, air, ether, sound; woman is the microcosm of the mind,
the articulation of space, the knowing in the knowledge, the woman is fire;
movement, clear and rapid as the mountain stream; the woman is that which
8
seeks against that which is sought. To Brahma she is Varuna, to Indra, she
is Agni, to Rama, she is Sita; to Krishna she is Radha. Woman is the meaning
of the word, the breath, touch, and act: woman that reminds man of that
which he is and reminds herself through him of that which she is, woman
through woman that one is born; woman rules, for it is she, the Universe.
sustains life, she is the preserver of the home and a protector of culture.
Indian women novelists focus their attention on women’s issues. They have a
Novelists” says:
One of the reasons that women have, in such large number, taken up their
pen is because it has allowed them to create their world. It has allowed them
because it allows them a ‘safe place’ from which they can explore a wide
range of experience of the world, from which they can identify with a range
why women’s writing can share much the same disparaged status as
and prestige. They have given a distinct dimension to the image of women in the family
and in the society. They come to hold the central position in the fictional world of India.
They write about their own experiences in their novels. They present the dilemma, which
modern women face in recent times. They exploit their skill in projecting the agonized
mind of the persecuted women. Their women characters invariably bear authenticity to
their feminist approach, outlook and perspective. They have keen observation of life and
of the Indian women and their interest in the study of their inner mind. It is evidenced by
their clear and scenic portrayal of their plights. They focus on the existential predicament
of the subdued women in a male dominated society. It is governed by strict traditions and
restrictions. They probe deep into the inner mind of the repressed women. They bring out
the virtue of their feminine sensibility and psychological insight. They deal with the issues
that are the outcome of their psychological and emotional imbalances. They write that
Indian women have remained more chained to their circumstances than liberated. They are
presented as tradition-bound than modern and more restricted and confined than
emancipated. They feel restlessness and uneasiness. They have a kind of turbulance in
their inner psyche. It makes them to be at odds. They are in a state of unsettlement. They
seek something which always deceives them. They suffer in life. Arundhati Chatterji in
“Different Facets of the Indian Woman in Nayantara Sahgal and Ruth Prawer Jhabvala” says:
portrayed human poverty, hunger and suffering of the villagers. In all, they
have turned their attention to the individuals, especially the women as the
victims of conflict between the rural and the urban, the East and the West,
10
the tradition and the modernity, the spiritual and the material. Their portraits
are very original and convincing not only because of the fact that they
but also because of the fact that being women their feelings and
experiences are much more authentic. They have a deeper insight into
They portray a woman in a society. They also detail how she is exploited by the
conventions of a patriarchal society. The following are some of the things that Indian
2. They voice their experiences. They also destroy the culture of silence.
6. Their writings exhibit their bodies. The ‘woman speak’ inserts the
8. These writers interrogate every aspect of social order. They write about
traditions.
11
9. They disbelieve history. They point out the exclusion of women from it.
They name for a revisionist history. It is a history from below. Their voice
11. Their works record important shifts in the ways of seeing, showing,
saying and even not saying. They discuss about Indian women, as
Manju Kapur (1948 - ) is a successful Indian women novelist. She was born in
Amritsar in 1948. She got her BA. Degree from the Miranda House University College
for women. She took an MA degree from Dalhousie University, Halifax. Then from
Delhi University, she obtained an M. Phil. She had her career as a Professor of English.
She taught English literature in Miranda House College, Delhi. She is popularly called
the Jane Austen of India. Her novels deal with the modern family and the patriarchal
society. Her novels give a clear picture of the contemporary women’s lives. Her women
are eager to liberate themselves from the domestic walls of their own. They want to build
a life of their own. Her novels present a new woman. Her new woman wants to identify
herself. She deals with the issues of women. She deals with their family problems, domestic
violence, education and their working conditions. She writes about the problems of the
modern world like lesbianism, infidelity, infertility, divorce, adoption and so on. A feministic
tradition can be seen in all her novels. She insists on the search for control over one’s fate.
She voices for the middle-class society. She can be compared with Jane Austen. She presents
her women characters in problematic situations. Her women characters are well-educated.
12
Their education leads them to independent thinking. It helps them take a bold stand
against the society. They are ready to pull down the patriarchal rules and regulations.
They understand the value of education as it is the only way to self-reliance. Her area is
always larger than life. In her novels, she captures the minute details of everything.
She sees her life through the prism of family. All the novels of Kapur is set in the backdrop of
Kapur is a distinguished woman novelist. She is the author of six novels. Her first
novel, Difficult Daughters (1998) won the Commonwealth prize for the first novel
(Eurasia Section). Her second novel A Married Woman (2002) was called ‘fluent and
witty while her third, Home (2006) is a multi-generation family saga. The Immigrant
(2008) has been listed for the DSC Prize for South Asia Literature. Her novel Custody
(2011) talks about women’s lust for a glamorous and luxurious life. Her recent novel
Brothers was published in 2016. In all her novels, male characters affect the psyche of
women characters. It is to such an extent that all her major women characters like Virmati
of Daughters, Astha of Woman, Nisha of Home, Nina of Immigrant, and Shagun and
Ishita of Custody, are on the verge of secludings themselves from the company of men.
They are searching for a place for themselves in the male dominated society. Society,
morality and values are all bondage to them. Her novels account for the complexity of life.
They display different histories, cultures and different structures of values, the woman’s
question and so on. In her novels, women are presented under the patriarchal pressure and
control. Her women characters are discriminated and are biased in lieu of their sex. She writes
about the lives of women. Women live and struggle under the oppressive mechanism of a
closed society. It is reflected in the novels of Kapur. She presents new women. Her new
13
women do not want to be mere puppets for others to move as they like. They defy the
patriarchal notions that enforce them towards domesticity. They affirm their individuality. They
aspire for self-reliance through education. They foster the desire of being independent. They
want to lead lives of their own. They are not silent rebels. They are valiant, outspoken,
Kapur’s debut novel Daughters presents the story of Virmati and it relates her
sincere efforts to get education. It also tells about her love with the married professor
Harish. Her life story is nostalgically remembered in the novel. It is narrated by her
daughter, Ida. Her second novel, Woman, is a revolutionary novel. It traces the emergence
of a new woman from the bondage of sex and marriage. It details the life of Astha.
It also relates her marriage with Hemant, and her lesbian association with Pipeelika.
It also shows her involvement in various social activities. Home is a story of Banwari
Lal’s family. It relates the love story of Nisha. It also details how she comes up in life
and ends with her marriage to Aravind. In Immigrant, Kapur takes sex and brings out the
problems of sex. She portrays Nina, the thirty years old Lecturer in English. The novel
also details her marriage to a dentist Ananda, and her bored sexual life in Canada. It also
explains how she falls in love with Anton in the end. Her Custody is the story of Raman.
He is a marketing executive at a global drink company. Shagun is his wife. They have
two children Arjun and Rashi. Shagun falls in love with Ashok Khanna. He is her husband’s
boss. Ishita falls in love with Raman. So, in all her novels, Kapur focuses on the presentation
of woman in the context of different social involvements. She portrays different kinds of
human relationships. Her main concern is with man-woman relationship and woman-
woman relationship. Her novels can be taken as the journey of a woman. It is from the
14
state of innocence into experience. She is less complicated in her depiction of various issues
related to woman. She raises the issue of social, political and economic independence of
a woman.
Daughters is located in India of the 1940s. The novel raises issues on the idea of
independence. It took almost five years to do research at Nehru Memorial Museum and
Library at Teen Murti house to write this novel. It is a realistic story of a daughter’s
reconstruction of her troubled past. It hinges on her mother’s story. It is a story of a daughter’s
journey. The daughter gets back into her mother’s past to reconstruct memories of her
mother as the daughter she had been. It is an imaginary tale of a Punjabi family. It covers
three generations of women. Ida is the narrator. She has left behind her a disastrous marriage.
She is a divorcee. Virmati married for love an already married Professor. Kasturi is the
mother of eleven children, including Virmati. She has to come to terms with her daughter.
Her daughter insists on studying and spurns marriage. So it is the story of a woman. She
is torn between family duty, the desire for education and an illicit love. In it, Kapur manifests
the non-acceptance of a liberated and modern woman by a tradition bound Indian society.
It is a story of a young woman’s life. Virmati is caught up in the complex web of social
positions. She has her personal desire and the quest for education. It is against the backdrop
of Indian partition.
Amritsar to identify her mother’s roots from her relatives, who says: “What is past is past.
Don’t bother about it, have another Paratha” (DD5). Ida relives her mother’s life. Virmati’s
illicit relationship with a Professor of English is retold by her daughter. Ida has determind
15
not to be like her mother. The story begins with the funeral scene of her mother. Ida is
with memories and ends in a note of melancholy and depression. It is partly a travelogue.
generations. It is covered with historical facts. In it Kapur also gives the regional culture
The title of the novel, Difficult Daughers, indicates that a woman, tries to search
for an identicy. She is branded as a difficult daughter. Ida, Virmati’s daughter, wanted not
to be like her mother. But in the end, after knowing her mother’s story, she admits that
“Nowhere in it Mama and leave me be. Do not haunt me anymore” (DD 259). Ida has faced
disaster in life. She is husbandless and childless after divorce. I. K. Sharma in “Between
Sita and Helen: A Study of Manju Kapur’s Difficult Daughters and Anita Desai’s Fasting
Feasting” says:
The story is organized round the life and personality of Virmati (mother)
who is the central consciousness of the novel. Her life mirrors the struggle
that cherishes old values of arranged marriage and children. The novel
The very title of the book is assertive. By placing the adjective ‘difficult’
before ‘daughters’ (noun), the author sends a signal that characters in the
novels are not soft and pliable. They are not likely to yield to pressures-
16
familial and social-and are sure to carve out the unconventional course in
The theme of the novel is the search for control over one’s destiny. It refers to the
The one thing I had wanted was not to be like my mother. Now she was gone
and I stared at the fire that rose from her shrivelled body, dry-eyed, leaden,
half dead myself, while my relatives clustered around the pyre and wept.
When the ashes were cold, my uncle and I went to the ghat to collect
benches, standing in groups, some with corpses before them, some clustered
around bodies burning on daises. The air was smoky, and the breeze blew
the stench about. It was not a place to linger on, but I felt unable to move,
staring stupidly at the little pile. The inscription on the raised concrete slab
introduced that a Seth Ram Krishna Dalmia had been burnt there, and his
loving widow, brother and children had labelled this spot in commemoration.
On every bench and burning platform, were names and dates, marks of people
gone and people left behind. Not a scrap of cement was left unclaimed. I stared
again at my mother’s ashes and wondered what memorial I could give her.
She, who had not wanted to be mourned in any way (DD 1).
Virmati’s tale is told from the present day perspective by Ida. Ida seeks to reconstruct her
late mother’s life story. It is against the background of the Independence movement of
the 1940’s. In it, the family comprises of Lala Diwan Chand. He has two sons-Suraj
Prakash and Chandar Prakash. Suraj Prakash is married to Kasturi. Chandar Prakash is
17
married to Lajwanti. Kasturi gives birth to Virmati. Virmat’s tale is told in the third person.
In the third person narrative mode, Ida leads a freer life than her mother. She feels some
of the same worries which had tormented her mother. She admits: “No matter how I might
rationalize otherwise, I feel my existence as a single woman reverberate desolately” (DD 3).
Ida achieves more than her mother and her grandmother. In Daughters one cannot listen
to Virmati’s voice. She could not speak out. Virmati’s life is reconstructed by her daughter.
against the backdrop of the Indian Freedom Movement, the Partition of India and the War
between allied and Axis forces. It focuses on the dynamics of man-woman relationship.
It hovers around Amritstar and Lahore. It also hinges on an austere Arya Samaji family of
Lala Diwan Chand. His family runs the jewellery business. He has two sons - Chander Prakash
and Suraj Prakash. His second son and his wife, Kasturi, had a large family to look after.
There had been eleven of them. The girls: Virmati, Indumati, Gunvati, Hemavati, Vidyavati
and Parvati. The boys: Kailashnath, Gopinath, Krishnanath, Prakashnath and Hiranath.
Their eldest daughter, “an increasingly sensitive Virmati” (D 215) is the central character
of the novel. Right from her childhood, she has some uncommon capability. Her sister,
Parvati affirms: “Our mother was always sick and Virmati as eldest, had to run the house
and look after us” (4). She is depicted as a young girl of tremendous academic pursuit. “She
was so keen to study, First FA, then BA, then BT on top of that. Even after her marriage, she
went for an M. A to Govt. College, Lahore . . . The Oxford of the East they called it” (4).
She started her schooling from the Arya Kanya Maha Vidyalaya. She had gone for higher
18
studies to Stratford College, in Civil Lines. “After that, class IX and X, and then two
years to get a Fine Arts degree. And then marriage, said the elders. . . Thirteen-year-old
Virmati listened and felt the thrill of those approaching rites. ” (17)
She did not pass in her FA. Her mother, Kasturi, viewed it differently. “Still, it is
the duty of every girl to get married” (13). A good Samaji family was making inquiries
for Virmati to get married. Their boy, Inderjit, was a canal engineer. Virmati was not at
all interested in marriage. She was drawn towards her cousin, Shakuntala, “to one whose
responsibility went beyond a husband and children” (14). She wanted to liberate herself
like Shakuntala. But her mother remarked “you are getting modern in your thinking”
(13). This was expressed by Virmati too: “Here we are fighting for the freedom of the
nation, but women are still supposed to marry and nothing else” (14-15). She was haunted
by the words of Shakuntala: “Times are changing and women are moving out of the
house, so why not you?” (16). There appeared a Professor in her life. He happened to be
the tenant of her aunt, Lajwanti. He came from Oxford two years ago. He had come to
Amritsar at the request of one of his friends’ father. He was on the board of trustees of
Arya Sabha College, Amritsar. At that time, the college had been searching for a good
English teacher. They needed some professor. They appointed the Oxford returned English
Professor. His name was Harish Chandra. He was given a salary of two hundred and
thirty rupees, twenty rupees more than he was getting at a college in Waltair. He had a
family. Virmati and other female members developed intimacy with the Professor’s
family. It started with the exchange of food items. The Professor sensed that Virmati “has
potential, he found himself thinking” (36). In one of his letters to Virmati he writes: “you
are imprinted on my mind, my heart, my soul so firmly that until we can be united in a
19
more permanent way I lie in a shawdowy insubstantial land” (82). He uses overwhelming
begging, pleading and imploring. He used to say: “you are the air I breathe” (100). For
Prof. Harish’s sake, Virmati also started dreaming more intensely “than she ever had of
her fiance that shadow figure waiting in the wings to marry her” (35). She had to fight
against her family’s decision to marry Inderjit. She was compelled by her mother to marry
Inderjit. She attempted to commit suicide. She was saved and sent to do her Fine Arts
(FA) degree.
She passed her FA examination with some distinction. She went to go to Lahore
to do her BT. It was supported by the elders of her family. Her mother took her to Lahore.
She got her admission in the RBSL School and College, Lahore. Shakuntala was deputed
as her local guardian. “She (Shakuntla) was glad that her family was at last waking upto
the fact that women had to take their place in the world, but must it always be when marriage
had not worked out?” (103). Kasturi really wished “she (Virmati) was to be supervised
like a jailbird on parole. Marriage was accepted to her family but no independence”
(106). But Prof. Harish Chandra continued his clandestine love affairs with her. He went
to Lahore. His close friend, Syed Hussain, was working there. So the Professor could meet
Virmati. Later, he had sex with her at Husain’s house on the campus of Govt. College,
Lahore. They used to meet at regular intervals. They became husband and wife. They
used to declare: “We cannot allow ourselves to be the pawns in the skeins of fate” (141).
Their continual illicit love ended in Virmati’s pregnancy. She had to take her BT examination.
But her pregnancy turned her completely neurotic and desperate. So, on the pretext of her
preparation for her examination, she got a long leave from the college authorities. She
went to her home town. She wanted to meet the Professor. She wanted to report the matter to
20
him. She wanted to find a suitable solution for her pregnancy. But, she could not meet
him as he had already left Amritsar for his village home. He was expected to return after
a long gap. She did not know what to do. She came back to her college hostel. She confided
everything to her roommate, Swarna Lata. She consoled and cheered her up: “Marriage is
not the only thing in life, Viru… women are coming out of their homes, Wake up from
your stale dreams” (139). She also came to her rescue. She aborted her foetus during her
BT examination.
Virmati passed BT in her second attempt. Then she set out for her home. Her family
members hoped that she could concede her family’s decision and express her willingness
for a suitable marriage. But, she proposed her own marriage to Prof. Harish Chandra.
Later when she was in the hill state of Sirmaur Prof Harish Chandra started visiting her
there. He also enjoyed a night stay at her place. It came to the knowledge of Diwan Sahib.
He took a resistance to their misconduct. She had to leave the school. She wanted to go to
Shantiniketan. On her way, she had to wait in Delhi for seventeen hours. She decided to
get the help pf professor’s friend. She agreed to delay her departure for three or four days.
Prof. Harish Chandra came there. On his arrival, they got married. Then, they left for Amritsar.
They received a harsh response from the member’s of the Professor’s family. She understood
that “She could see it was going to be difficult to live separately from everybody else” (198).
She was not at all accepted by Professor’s mother, Kishori Devi, his first wife, Ganga, his
sister, Guddiya, his children from his first wife, Chhotti and Giridhar (nicknamed Munna).
Virmati had to be “alone in a place where her pariah status was announced with every
averted look” (198). Later, Kishori Devi softened towards her. Virmati grew pregnant
again. It did not last long. She suffered a miscarriage in the third month. This landed her
21
reside in Leela’s house in Lahore. Meanwhile, he “had become the Principal of A. S. College,
When a violent Hindu-Muslim riot broke out, “it was agreed that they would leave
first. Harish and Virmati could follow once the house was wound up” (245). There had
been communal unrest in Amritsar and Lahore. Virmati left Lahore to start her life as a
housewife for the first time. She gave birth to a girl, named Ida. Later when Harish got an
offer of principalship in one of the new colleges of Delhi University, “the couple moved
to Delhi and a much smaller house” (257). Giridhar and Chhotti to came to their father,
when their schooling demanded as such. Prof. Harish Chandra carried on everything with
his meager income. Giridhar wanted to do business. He ran a chemist’s shop in Karol Bagh.
He married one of his customers Chhotti fared well in her studies. Further, “she joined
the IAS, mainly for the cheap government accommodation that will enable her mother
and grandmother to live with her” (257). Ida failed to display intellectual brightness. She
never intended to be worthy of her parents’ expectations. She married a scholarly fellow
Patriarchal Ideology: Interpretation of Feminist Vision in the Novels of Anita Desai, Shashi
Deshpande, Arundhati Roy and Manju Kapur” points out that Woman is “a femino-centric
protest against the phallocentred patriarchal culture. The male world imposes unlimited
controls on woman. Traditions and customs provided moral sanctions for such inhuman
and cruel impositions to disempower women. Kapur, however, in this novel empowers
her protagonist Astha to give a strong resistance to patriarchy by denouncing the prescribed
22
norms of a society” (117-18). Kapur’s basic approach to woman’s life in her novels is to
liberate them from the oppressive measures of patriarchy. Her women sustain a lot of
sufferings like physical, emotional and psychological sufferings. Ashok Kumar and Roopali
in “A Married Woman: A Saga of Post- Modernistic Ethics” says that “A Married Woman
may be studied at three levels. First at the feministic level. Second at the historical level
and lastly at the level of deconstruction and post-modernism”. (46. 47). In this novel,
Astha is the replica of Virmati. The novel is a feministic study. Kapur in an interview
with Mona Goel for the question, “Do you believe in women’s liberation?” answers:
believe in all that. And the thing is that women don’t really have that –
equality but you scratch the surface and it is not really equal. So, I do believe
and to believe in their rights. Because I think a lot of problems come from
the way with which we have socialized. We just socialize in a way, you
know, that you take second place, but, you know, the needs – so many needs
come before your own needs so that is the traditional upbringing. (4)
It is set in Delhi. It is against the backdrop of communal unrest. It centered on the controversial
Ram Janma Bhoomi-Babri Masjid. It traces the life of Astha from her childhood to her
forties. It passes through various hopes and despairs, complements and rejections, and
recognitions and frustrations. Astha imbibes a middle class values. She enjoys her mental
23
bliss for a long time. She feels that there is something certainly lacking in her life. She
troubles from a sense of incompleteness, repression and anguish. Her feelings are further
aggravated by her involvement into the outer world of rebellion and protest.
She is brought up in a traditional set up. Her family is a typical middle class family.
Her mother wants to make her a traditional women and religious piety. It could be practised
through proper rituals. Her father is a bureaucrat. He is concerned with her education. He
wants to give her good habits, tasks and manners. But, she has romantic feelings of love.
She develops her love for Bunty. He is an army cadet at NDA, Khargwasala. Astha and
Bunty write letters to each other. Those letters are for her precious possession. They are
to be displayed and boasted of among her friends. Her love with Bunty soon comes to an
end when Astha’s mother complains against it to Bunty’s parents. During the final year
of her graduation, she happens to meet Rohan in his car at the dark corners of the streets.
Astha and Rohan kiss, touch and press each other. She wants to gratify her body. “All she
wanted was for him to start so that the world could fall away and she be lost. This is love
she told herself no wonder they talk much about it (MW 24-25). Rohan has to leave for
Oxford for higher studies. Her mother happens to read about Astha’s feelings as presented in
her personal diary. She has to hide it by saying that she is writing a story. It is all the writings
of imagination. But her mother has felt that the convent education had spoiled her.
Astha’s father is keen to marry his daughter off before his retirement from the Indian
civil service. Astha is a rebellious women. She refuses every suitor in the final year of her
M. A. They even receive a proposal from the son of a bureaucrat in the commerce ministry.
Delhi. He seems to be a perfect match for her. He calls her ‘my baby’. He displays the
24
usual Indian traditional husband’s attitude. He is patronizing, caring and being considerate.
He is good performer in the bed. He reads sex manuals. He wants to prolong his sex
duration. He has a notion that if a woman bleeds on the first night it proves her virginity.
When he remains very busy in his office work, she joins a school teaching job. She does
not of course like it very much in the beginning. Later she becomes pregnant. Her mother
wishes them to have a boy. Hemant condemns her saying that “in America there is no
difference between boys and girls. How can this country get anywhere if we go on treating
our women this way?” (57). the first child is a girl. Hemant wishes to have a son. He is
changed from an American father into an Indian one. He says that if the second child is a
girl, they could go for the third. But, the second one is a boy. Astha also remains busy
with her children and her school job. Hernant also succumbs to the compelling necessity
of materialistic needs and starts his own factory in the name of Astha. She also complains
that he talks of business, house or Anu but not of them. But he says: “Grow up, AZ, one
can’t be courting for ever. ” (66). He convinces her. He promises her to give more time to
family. “She found this soothing, and later scolded herself for being so demanding. Hemant
was busy, he was building their future, she had to be adjusting, and that was what marriage
was all about. ”(67) She tries to suppress her frustrations. She focuses on her duties as a
mother, wife and daughter-in-law. She learns to adjust with her husband and an interfering
mother-in-law. Marital sex takes up her life. She finds herself trapped in her marriage.
She prefers to continue with her school job. There she is appreciated and valued for her
work. Kapur writes: “between her marriage and the birth of her children, she too had
changed from being a woman who only wanted love, to a woman who valued independence.
Besides there was the pleasure of interacting with minds instead of needs. ” (72)
25
To compensate her husband’s lack of time for her. She wants to spend more time to
children. But they are already involved with their grand parents. She feels lonely and
alienated. She complains of this to Hemant. He fails to understand her troubles. He says
“it is all your imagination. Why don’t you have me? You are the one who keep wanting
to stay at home with children, or your school work, or your books when we are invited to
parties, or when I want to go to the club. ” (79). Their discussion usually leads to argument,
distance, and greater misery. They fail to seek a temporary relief through diversion. She
begins to writing poems. She draws sketches. She does there to express her anguish and
alienation. She gets some relief to her pent up emotions. “She wrote about gardens and
flowers, the silent dark faces of gardeners tending plants and never getting credit. She
wrote about love, rejection, desire and longing. The language was oblique, but it was her
own experience endlessly replayed. ” (79). Her poems are all about caged birds, and mice
She feels alienation and marginal existence. It intensifies her mental troubles. Her
mother hands over the money to Hemant to be safely invested for his children. She does
it for the reason that Hemant has proved his managing capability. But Astha has never
proved her merit either before marriage or after that. Moreover “the sad thing was that
she herself would have felt nervous handling a large sum” (97). She begins to give more
time to her school, poetry and painting. It is in order to sooth her bruised feelings.
the women. He praises her script, poetry and painting. She thinks that he is the only one
who can really understand and value her. She also loves him on the stage. His touch on
26
her knee makes in her a kind of sensation and romance. It makes her to brood : “ what did
it mean, did he like her, did he want to have an affair with her, why had she been so startled
Pipeelika is a modern woman. She defies tradition. She works in an NGO. She is
a Hindu. She is attracted by the personality of Aijaz. Their mutual likeness strengthened
their passion. They get married. But Aijaz’s commitment for public awareness and communal
harmony claims his life. His death was followed by long processions, strikes and dharnas
organized by Sampradaykata Mukti Manch. Astha suffers a lot when the Masjid is
demolished. She becomes politically active. She begins to attend the meetings of the Manch.
She devotes herself to a cause beyond her family and her husband. It is during these
activities, she happens to meet Pipeelika. She gets a good recognition. She earns rupees
thirty thousand by an exhibition of her paintings. Her sense of self respect and self
dependence is deeply injured when her husband does not let her purchase an antique
silver box at Goa. He dissuades her. He also frowns upon her on the very mention of the
money that she had earned. His domineering attitude, arrogant and superior wisdom and
lack of interest in her achievement completely shatter her married life. Her suffering
alienates her further from her husband. Astha and Pipeelika begin to move closer to each
other. They understand each other. They feel for each other. They develop even lesbian
company, Astha feels herself stronger. She leaves her children and family. She goes on
the Ekta Yatra from Kashmir to Kanyakumari. It is for the sake of the company of Pipee.
Their closeness makes them crave for each other. During their Yatra, Astha comes to
know of Pipee’s lesbian relations with Neeraj and Sameera. Her demanding passion and
27
her past associations disillusioned her. She is trapped in a terrible dilemma. She tells
pipee that she loves her. She says her that she is so much means to her. She tries to prove
it everymoment they have togetherand she can’t abandon her family. She tells to Pipee:
“I love you, you know how much you mean to me, Itry and prove it every
should not have looked for happiness, but I couldn’t help myself. I suppose
you think I should not be in a relationship but I had not foreseen”. (242)
Later, Astha begins to distance herself from Pipee. In the end, she comes back to her family
and her children as Pipee leaves for higher studies in America. At the end Astha, married
women realises the importance of marriage and her status in her family and society.
Home moves through the conflicting between tradition and modernity, poverty
and prosperity, man and woman concerns. It presents the picture of a joint family-the
Banwari Lals. The family pursues business with all its heart. The family cannot think of
employment opportunities for its sons and grandsons. The two sons of family- Banwari
Lal, Yashpal and Pyare Lal. They are well settled in business. They are married. The former
to Sona and the latter to Sushila. Banwari Lal’s daughter, Sunita, is wedded to Murli.
burning of Sunitha at the age of 32, she leaves behind her only son, Vicky. He is a lean
and thin boy of shy nature. He is left to the care of maternal uncles and their parents.
Sona is a beautiful, but a restless woman. She is issueless. Her younger sister-in-law
is blessed with two sons, Ajay and Vijay. They are married to Seema and Rekha respectively.
This increases her psychic restlessness and mental anxieties. Sona’s younger sister, Rupa
(who is married to Prem Nath), also remains issueless in her life. The latter does not lose
28
her self composure and the gaiety of her spirits. She concentrates on “financial success”
(33) in her pickle business. Rupa “had not suffered like her sister, nor had she fasted and
done penance” (33). Both the sisters are the victims of thwarted maternal instinct. They
take it in a diametrically opposite manner. For long ten years, Sona practises penance and
austerities She is thereafter blessed with Nisha (daughter) and Raju (son). Rupa never seems
to bother about a child. Instead, she comes to the rescue of Sona and Yashpal. They are
extremely worried about the nocturnal screams of Nisha and her increasingly dwindling
health. Rupa takes away Nisha to her house. She nourishes her back to normal health.
arranges for Nisha’s proper education. Even he tutors her in spare hours. He makes her a
Vicky is taken to Delhi by the Lals to bring him up there. It increases Sona’s
responsibilities at home. Vicky is also weak in studies. He is a neglected child. His condunct
towards Nisha is dirty and cruel “deceitful, cunning, his father’s son not poor Sunita’s”
(76). He makes Nisha frightened and fretful by his dirty habit of maturation. Yashpal
suggests that he should be sent back to Bareilly “an only son, he would shine in his parental
home, here he was lost among cousins” (76). He does not agree to this proposal. He threatens
girl of Bareilly. She is the best suitor of Murli. The new weds are installed in the barsati.
It consists of “a small room on the terrace with an added toilet” (105). A son, Virat, is
born to them.
After her schooling, Nisha is brought back to her home to look after the old
grandmother. Her mother is a typical Indian mother. She always thinks that her daughter
29
should be a good women. She also comments, that this is the life of a woman: “to look
after her home, her husband, and her children and give them food she has cooked with her
own hands” (121). She also includes her daughter in all pujas. Nisha also joins Duragbai
College for her English honours. Now, Nisha appears to be a “New Woman”. Her life
changes because for the first time in her life she gets freedom. During her bus journey to
interest in her. He begins to come to her college. It brings them closer. He tells Nisha that
with her haircut she would look like Suriya, the popular film star. She has to face a storm
at home, if she gets her hair cut. She prepares herself for her rebellious thinking, “of the
girls in her class, girls with swishing, open hair, wavy, curly, blow-dried, or hanging straight,
framing feces with fringes, flicks or stray tendrils. ” (148)She becomes a modern girl with
traditional views. She loves Suresh deeply. She never allows Suresh to violate her chastity.
She says to Suresh, “It is just as well there is something left for when we are married. ”
(192). She is not able to pay her attention to her studies. Her percentage is decreasing.
Her attendance is falls short. She is not allowed to take her examinations. Her family members
come to know about her love. She has to face her family. She is broken and frustrated.
She asks her father to help her in starting a business of salwar suits. She wants
one year to show her ability. “Give me a chance to show you what I can do” (287). Her
father suggests a good name for her shop - “Nisha’s Creations”. She becomes a successful
business woman. She starts responding to the issue of her marriage. She gets a proposal
for marriage with Arvind. She gives her consent for marriage on the condition that she
will continue her business. On the wedding night, she finds no pleasure in her husband.
30
Arvind is not sensible enough to realize it. She becomes more assertive to demand her
right. She says, “If you are never going to talk or share things with me, why don’t you
take me back to my mother’s house? You have done your duty, married and made me
pregnant. When, the baby is born you can collect it” (330). Next day, Arvind takes her an
outing with Nisha. They have lunch in a hotel. Ten months after her marriage, she gives
In Immigrant, Nina is an English teacher at Miranda House, New Delhi. She resides
in a one room apartment with her widowed mother. She is financially self-reliant. She
lost her father. Her mother was her only anchorage. She wanted to see her mother happy.
At a mature age of thirty, she had less hope of finding a husband. When a marriage proposal
came for Nina from an NRI, a dentist by profession who settled in Canada, Nina’s mother
is filled with joy. She prayed for the proposal to materilize. Nina finally accepted to marry,
Ananda. “Then Ananda promised her such a future, laced with choice, edged with beautiful
snowflakes that glittered through the distance, promising at the very minimum change,
novelty, excitement” (I78). She agreed “to join legions of women who crossed the seas to
marry men living in unseen lands” (78). Their marriage was attended by his Canadian friend,
Gary, and his wife, Sue, came to attend the marriage. His maternal uncle with his Canadian
wife and children also came to India to attend his marriage. However, “She knew NRIs
did stay in such hotels, but anxiety about money had been her companion since infancy,
and it asserted itself on every possible occasion. Ananda on the other hand was flush with
dollar confidence. His ability to spend in India (unmatched by any such extravagance in
After two days, Ananda left for Canada. He left Nina to join him later after getting
her visa. After three months, she managed to get her visa. She proceeded her journey to
Canada. She felt the first bitter experience of being an immigrant in Canada. When she
reached Toronto, at the immigration clearance counter, she was asked to step aside.
The immigration woman scrutinized each page of her passport suspiciously and asked her
Life in Canada began with a sense of freedom. The solitude was pleasing. It turned
to loneliness with no one to talk to and to share her. Homesickness set in her. She yearned
to have a child. She could not conceive. Ananda suffered from pre-ejaculation. Finally,
she decided to get herself examined. She found everything to be normal on her side. Ananda
secretly made a visit to California. After two weeks, he returned with techniques of
overcoming his inadequacies. Nina felt, hurt and annoyed. The idea of using a surrogate
partner appalled her. His training in California made him a happy man. All these years,
he had run away from the sexually assertive white women. He knew his miserable failures.
He was not able to gratify his sexual pleasures. “From the time he had come to Canada he
had felt strangely attracted to the white women who were totally free of any inhibition
regarding their body. He admired the case with which they remained so unself-conscious
of their bodies even when they were so much uncovered” (38). “‘Sex is no great issue in
the west, here it’s no big deal, but in your culture it must be different’, Sue said to him one day
when she was with him for a date. Sex did not mean commitment” (36), and “nobody
owned anybody” (39). He remained bereft of girlfriends. Now, he wanted to test himself.
her situation and take a decision. She decided to take a library degree. Then she got
32
admission and a fee waiver. “For the next two years Nina felt the comfort of being part of
a student body, no longer the outsider, one of many beyond together by a huge, squat, grey
institutional building…”(244). She had to leave for the university before Ananda came
home late. Library School brought an excitement into Nina’s life. She found everybody
nice and friendly. Anton became her special friend. A trip to national archieve in National
Library made Nina to take the trip to Ottawa. The four day trip was an enjoyable one. On
the last day, they got together to celebrate in a pub. Joining in the fun, Nina held a cigarette
between her finger and had drinks. She felt daring. It was easy to drink and smoke. She
allowed Anton to “take her arms and put it round his waist, doing the same with his own,
fitting her against the contours of his body. They looked like the zillions of couples she
had seen walking around the university campus. Through months of Library Science, she
had gazed covertly at those couples, and now in appearance at least she was one of them”
(258). Anton, had no inhibitions of having sex with Nina. He used to say: “Nobody owns
anybody” (258). She had a sense of her own self. Sex with Anton did not make her feel guilty.
Nina and Ananda carried on with their relationships with Anton and Mandy
respectively. It was “purely meeting of the bodies: a healthy give and take” (269). So, there
was no reason to feel guilty. Nina convinced herself that, “‘I am not taking anything
away from my husband, I am not,’ she rationalized, as it became clear that her trysts with
Anton were not going to stop. All around her she heard of open marriages, of no living
according to the rules of others, her life was her own: she didn’t own anybody any
explanations. If Anton gave her pleasure, if his easy acceptance of her gilded her studies
didn’t she owe it to herself to sleep with him?” (270). Nina adapted herself to the strange
ways of the West. Later the discovery of the ‘yellow hair’, made her realize, that Anton
33
forced himself upon her, and used her for his own pleasures. She freed herself and moved
on. She took a job and left Halifax and her husband. It “was the ultimate immigrant experience
not that anything was steady enough to attach yourself for the rest of your life, but that
you found different ways to belong, was not necessarily lasting, but ones that made your
journey less lonely for a while. For as immigrant there was no going back. She too was
heading towards fresh territories, a different set of circumstances, and a floating resident
of the western world. When one is reinventing oneself, anywhere could be home” (330).
Custody is a story of two shattered families- Shagun’s and Ishita’s. They suffer
due to infidelity and infertility. Shagun and Raman fight for the custody of their children.
Shagun’s affair, leads husband and wife to go through separation, divorce, remarriage
custody of their children. Shagun does not accept her fate. She wants to become a model.
When she meets Ashok Khanna, her dreams again raise in her mind. She wants to do
something to have a luxurious life. She wants something in her life. She always blames
her husband. She has a notion that she had wasted her time. She starts to see her life in
the other way of liberty. But Raman asks her to be a good mother to her children. She
maintains a secret life with Ashok. She can have a modern world. She breaks her marriage
for her love. Extramarital affair gives her a very pleasant experience. It makes her
substaining, self-assured, powerful, and independent and ingenious. She is very much
towards Ashok. It is proved by her letters to her mother. If she marries Ashok, she can get
an oppturnity in film industry. She can go to Bombay. It is not possible with Raman.
She thinks that she can give bright future to her children. She wants to provider her
Raman has heart attack by divorce. Shagun does not care about that. She does not
worry about him. She stays out on the bedroom. He has to spend with his daughter alone.
Even her daughter also seems to be upset of her father’s illness. “Her father’s illness had
upset the child so much that she had begun to have nightmares, she explained to the bemused
parents” (105). She abandons him and his home for the sake of her lover. She does not
Raman becomes lonely by divorce from his wife. Now, the battle starts about the
custody of the children. Shagun, in the absence of her husband, purloins her children.
Their separation has a great impact on the children. Roohi gets nightmares. Arjun gets
In Custody, Shagun’s story runs parallel to Ishita’s story. Ishita agonizes from
infertility. She is forced out from her in-law’s family by her infertility. Her mother-in-law
is pleased to know that her son is not ineffective but her daughter-in-law is infertile.
Later, Ishita finds her happiness in Raman and in his children. She becomes a mistress to
All the female protagonists of Kapur are caught up in the marital bond. In their
marital status, they seems to be not satisfied but rejected and frustrated. Their maladjustment
is very clear in their transgression. Modern world and its system of marriage with more
conveyance make them seek for more space for themselves. Hence, they attempt to
transcend the marital norms. Astha’s marriage to Hemant is a failure and But mere effort
without clear objective, strong will power and planned action, Virumati’s flight from one mode
of life and plunging into another, Nina’s marriage with Ananda, and Shagun’s marriage to
Raman are all disastrous flight. Similarly, Astha’s efforts to seek fulfilment through lesbian
35
relations and Nisha’s dreams of romantic love and marriage and consequent frustrations
are also tragic flights. All her protagonists ultimately end in tragedy. Their world is a
delusory one. They are mere puppets in marriage. They have their own aspirations with
which they want to transgress the marital bond in one way or the other.