Hadji Yesli
Hadji Yesli
Dissertation:
ACADEMIC MASTER
Salem Yesli
Title:
Publically defended
On: 03/05/2017
مذكرة:
ماستر أكاديمي
ميدان :اآلداب واللغات
إختصاص :الترجمة وعلم الترجمة
من إعداد :شيماء حاجي
سالم يسلي
بعنوان:
مذكرة مقدمة الستكمال متطلبات نيل شهادة الماستر في الترجمة وعلم الترجمة
I
Dedication
This dissertation is dedicated with love and affection to;
My cousins
My precious friends
Salem Yessli, for being motivated to finish and perfect this work
internship period.
Chaima Hadji
II
Acknowledgements
III
List of abbreviations
LSP: language for specific purposes
IV
Table of content
Dedication…………………………………………………………………….….I
Acknowledgments………………………………………………………….…. V
List of abbreviations……………………………………………………………V
Table of contents……………………………………………………………... V
Introduction……………………………………………………………………...1
Chapter one
Theoretical part
Introduction……………………………………………………………………..4
1- Specialized translation……………………………………………………….4
3- Terminology………………………………………………………………….6
3-2-Terminological equivalent…………………………………………….….6
4-1- Borrowing………………….…………………………………………..….7
4-1-1-Transliteration…………………………………………………………..7
4-2- Calque…………………………………………………………………..…8
4-3-Transposition………………………………………………………............8
V
4-4-Equivalence at word level ……………………………………………….....8
4-4-1-Functional equivalent…………………………………………………..…8
4-4-2-Descriptive equivalent…………………………………………………….9
4-5- Arabization…………………………………………………………….…...9
4-5-1-Arabiation methodology………………………………………………....10
6-1-Transcription…………………………………………………….……........12
6-4-Coinage …….…………………………………………………..…………13
6-4-1-Revival……………………………...........................................................13
6-4-2-Derivation………………………………………………………….....….13
6-4-3-Neologisms…………………………………………………………..…13
II –Aeronautics industry…………………………….……………………...…14
VI
Chapter two
Practical part
1-Introduction………………………………….……………………….............17
3-Methodology…………………………………….…………………….…......17
Pattern 01…………………………………………….……………….….…......18
Pattern 02...…………………………………………………………….…........19
Pattern 03……………………………………………………………….…........19
Pattern 04……………………………………….…………………….…...……20
Pattern 05………………………………………………………...……..………21
Pattern 06………………………………………………………...……….…….22
VII
Pattern 07………………………………………………………………….……24
Pattern 08……………………………………………………………….………25
5- Findings……………………………………………………………….….….26
6-Conclusion………………………………………………………………...….26
Bibliography……………………………………………………………............34
Summary in Arabic……………………………………………….….................37
VIII
Introduction:
Aeronautics industry always has been a multinational type of industry; its translation has
been existed, since international airlines were introduced in the global market. The contact
between the Arab communities and the rest of the world in various fields urges the need for
translation, especially when it comes to science and technology.
Understanding and interacting with the technical texts concepts requires knowledge about
the idea behind its technical terminology.
Also, intend to define the difficulties that face translators when translating aeronautics
technical terms and to discuss solutions.
Despite the fact that the translators, who deal with the technical translation, should be
experts in the field, and have a reasonable knowledge of the SL and TL at all levels, this study
will try to explore the difficulties that translators encounter when translating aeronautics
technical terms into Arabic.
Research question(s):
1
The hypothesis:
To answer this research questions, it is hypothesized that:
English Aeronautics terminology was borrowed into Arabic.
The difficulties lie in finding the appropriate equivalent word of technical terminology.
Most of the terms have been literally translated.
Corpus &Methods:
Investigating the translatability of aeronautics industry into Arabic, and identifying the
main procedures used in translating technical terminology can be achieved through analytical
method. We randomly selected some terms in books related to the aeronautics field; Yacer
Hanan’s book “Fundamentals of Aaviation”, and P.R.G. Collinson’s book “Introduction to
Avionics systems”, and its translated version “ ”مدخل الى انظمة الكترونيات الطيرانby Dr.
Abdelbasset Kerman, a comparative method has been adopted to identify the problems and/or
difficulties encountered in translating aeronautics terminology.
This study is divided into two chapters. The first part is theoretical and the second is
practical.
Firstly, the part one is divided into two chapters, the first chapter deals with the
technical translation definitions, and the function of technical texts, then we discussed
terminology, and the procedures of translating technical terminology; focusing on arabization,
with analyzing methods of arabizing technical terminology, finally, we shed light on the main
issues faced translating technical terminology, and the main strategies to solve those
problems.
In the second chapter, we discuss the different aspects of aeronautics, starting with an
overview on of aeronautics industry, followed by a demonstration of the differences between
aeronautics and aviation.
Secondly, the practical part, this part which is devoted to the application of the
previous theoretical procedures, and the analysis of the data which was selected from the
corpus “Fundamentals of Aviation” by Yasser Hanan, and the English and Arabic versions of
2
the book “Introduction to Avionics systems” by P.R.G. Collinson, and its Arabic
version “ ”مدخل الى أنظمة إلكترونيات الطيرانby Dr Abd Elbasset Kerman.
3
Chapter one
Theoretical part
Specialized translation and Aeronautics
terminology
Introduction:
1. Specialized translation:
According to Scarpa (2008) as cited in Palumbo (2009) “In English often referred to as
LSP – language for special purposes” (2009, p.108). In general it can be defined as the
translation of very specific text in a specific environment, which involve a pre- knowledge
about the professional field, it deals with translation of scientific, medical, and technical
areas, according to Ioana (2014) specialized translation requires deep knowledge about the
specialized concepts and terms to the field or the environment to which it belongs, therefore
language of that specialized field play an important role in determining its translation.
The specialized translation in the present study about aeronautics industry involves; flight
safety manuals, aircraft systems and airport instructions, which are technically designed to
provide information for the users, and learners of that field.
Specialized texts differ from literary texts, in which they have specific features, according
to Hussein Ali (2007, p. 5) the specialized texts Comprise:
numerical items, symbols, and schemes
Short sentences
Contain no humour
Use specialized terminologies
4
2. Technical translation:
As a type of specialized translation, it involves the translation of documents, produced by
technical writers, and experts ,Williams and Chester man (2002, p.12-13) as cited in Singh
(2016) argued that “Technical translation is a form of specialized translation involving
documents typically produced by technical writers (owner’s manuals, user guides, etc.), or
more broadly , texts which relate to technological subject areas or texts that deal with the
practical application of scientific and technological information”.
In the same sense, Stoian, and Dejica (2016) explained “The terms technical and
technical translation are used to refer to different genres translated or used in various branches
of engineering, for a general or specialized audience, Including; products descriptions, user’s
manuals, technical brochures, technical drawings, technical forms, and technical projects”.
Technical and specialized translation both are concerned with translation of professional
documents and texts in technical and scientific fields. However, Alaoui (2015) has mentioned
that; “It should be differentiated from specialized translation in that it deals with the
application of the knowledge of exact sciences, rather than the scientific knowledge obtained
through experimentation” .
The translation of Technical texts is seen as a way to transfer written and oral messages,
which carry technical information despite its genres, as a means of communication among
people.
5
In this respect, technical texts translation deals not only with meaning of its individual
lexemes and terms; however it goes beyond the whole contextual meaning in order to achieve
an interaction between the human reasonable knowledge and the application of this
knowledge in reality.
3. Terminology:
Baker (2001) states that, “Terminology is the study of terms which refer deliberately to
specific concepts within a particular subject fields. In other words, terms are always studied in
relation to the conceptual system to which they belong and in which they function as
depositors of knowledge” (2001, p. 306). It is an essential unit in technical and scientific
writing, which belong to particular subject or professional field for specific purpose; and it
may vary according to its context, Elmgrab (2016) adds that, in Arabic the meaning of a term
is selected by specialized group and changed according to its purpose.
1. Terms derived from Latin and Greek, such as: ‘aviation’ derived from avis, which
means ‘bird’ in Latin.
2. Terms derived from proper names such as: Mach number, Euler angles.
3. Abbreviations and symbols, like C.G. (Center of Gravity), APT (Airport) used in
airway manual.
4. Terms derived from common linguistic roots, like ‘emission’ (from ‘emit’). (p.21)
Forutanian, and Chalak (2013) explained “the quality of equivalence implies the term
with 3 three features as, TL system and structure, TL culture; and TL discourse, these makes
TL equivalence terminology correctly and accurately, especially technical terminology”.
6
In other words the translated terms should made by the TL main characteristics in order
to achieve an accurate equivalence to the technical terminology.
4.1. Borrowing :
According to Vinay and Darbelnet (1959) "Borrowing is the simplest of all translators
methods , it would be not even merit discussion in this context if translation did not
occasionally need to use it in order to create stylistics effects".
Example:
"It is the alternative transfer of ST expression verbatim into the TT" (Dickins et al.,
2002), i.e. it is a direct translation procedure used when the translator face a lexical gap in
translating from one language to another, translators tend to borrow words from SL to use it
in TL in order to overcome this lacuna.
4.1.1. Transliteration:
Mphahlele (2004) has defined Transliteration as the use of a SL word stem to in order to
coin a TL equivalent (p. 341), from information-theoretical point of view; it is the phonetic
transcription of SL word into TL word, Peetham adds that “transliteration is a mapping from
one system of writing into another, word by word, or ideally letter by letter. Transliteration
attempts to use a one-to-one correspondence and be exact, so that an informed reader should
be able to reconstruct the original spelling of unknown transliterated words”. (2009, para.3)
Example:
Here, the literal translation can’t express the same meaning of these words.
7
4.2. Calque:
Vinay and Darbelnet (1959) mentioned calque in their book as "a special kind of
borrowing whereby a language borrows an expression from another language, but then
translates literally its terms".
Grassili (2016) said that: "More specifically, we use the verb to calque when speaking
about borrowing a word or phrase from another language while translating its components so
as to create a new lexeme in the target language".
4.3. Transposition
Or shift as Catford called it, Newmark (1988) argues that transposition consists of four
types of grammatical changes; the first type concerns the form and the position of words such
as: “furniture” in English translated into Arabic as أثاثhere we notice that the singular form of
the word in English changed to plural in Arabic, concerning the position refers to changes
occurs in words order, which belongs to the TL structure; for instance: red car in Arabic سيارة
حمراءhere the adjective changed its position after the noun from English to Arabic, The
second type concerns the urge for conveying the same meaning of a word in SL which doesn’t
have an equal grammatical structure in TL; the form “ing” in English .
For the third type, Newmark (1988) explained that the literal translation of the word is
available; however it may not accord with the TL usage, for instance; the adverb cruelly in
English shifted to an adverbial phrase بوحشية أو بطريقة قاسيةin Arabic. In The last type, the
translator relies on expanding and clarifying by using a grammatical category in TT as a way
to replace a lexical gap in ST.
8
function in TL, according to the same source “A similar procedure is used when a SL
technical word has no equivalent in TL equivalent ” (p.83)
4.5. Arabization:
According to Ghazala (2013) “Arabization is now a reference to all operations techniques
and methods involved in the process of rendering scientific and technical terms in particular
into Arabic, using generally Arabic and Arabized words and phrases”. (2013, p.26)
Based on the definitions of Hamed (2010) the term 'Arabization', generally is restricted
within 4 main definitions, according to its perspective from which it looked at:
Arabization of education: means the process of English in broader scope in teaching the
scientific and technological disciplines in Arab countries as a source language of the newest
terminologies in the scientific tests, and subjects. as meaning of translating: is to transfer
the text from language to another; keeping the same meaning of the source text, in this sense,
the arabization process is transferring or modulating the linguistic structures of a term, from a
foreign language to the Arabic language.
9
4.5.1. Arabization Methodology:
Bureau of Coordination of Arabization (BCA), along with various national commissions,
devised a set of eighteen (18) ruling principles that cut across the various aspects of
terminology:
1. Establishing a suitable link between the linguistic meaning of the term and its
idiomatic significance, through it is not required in the term to accommodate or
capture the whole scientific meaning.
2. Developing a single term for a single scientific concept, carrying a single scientific
content in a scientific field.
3. Avoiding multiple connotations of the term in one single field, and preferring the
specialized term over the common one.
4. Extrapolating and reviving the Arab linguistic heritage, especially the previously
used and which remains usable to this day.
5. Keeping in line with the international approach in the selection of scientific terms,
which requires:
a. Taking into account the convergence of the terminology between the Arab
speaking world and the international terminology community, so as to facilitate
their use by the scientific and scholarly community.
b. Adopting the international decimal classification system of terms, according to
their fields and affiliations.
c. Dividing, updating, refining, defining, and rearranging of concepts in accordance
with related fields.
d. Actively involving professionals and users in the development of the terminology.
e. Conducting further research and studies to facilitate communication between the
makers and users of the terminology.
f. Using linguistic tools to generate new scientific terminology such as derivation
and localization.
6. Giving preference to initially classical Arabic terms over arabized ones.
7. Avoiding the use of colloquial and informal terminology, except when absolutely
appropriate or necessary. These can only be used if they are shared between many
Arabs dialects and if their dialectal nature is explicitly explained.
10
5. Difficulties in translating aeronautics into Arabic:
As known, technical terminologies are familiar with experts and specialists with a
reasonable knowledge, in that sense Zethsen (1999) argued that there is no urge for a specific
translation strategy as long as the translator is familiar with a field terminology, and the
typical syntax of its texts. (p.69)
Example:
Aerodynamic آيروديناميكي
Translators in that field faced problems in finding lexical and conceptual equivalence of
the technical terminology , which is the main problem in translation into Arabic, according to
Badii بديعin his book ( فقه اللغة العربية1982) the main causes, which defines the problems of
translating terminology into Arabic; first is that the scientific term spreads in its origin
pronunciation (foreign) among people, before the linguists find the suitable equivalence in
Arabic , the second problem resulted from a colonization idea that had rooted in people’s
mind , which claims that Arabic is unable to be the language of any modern science”.
However, Arabic readers have difficulties in gasping this technical terms meaning. In the
same line Hijazi(1993) explained the role of Arabization in expanding and publicize
technical and scientific terms used by specialists and experts in particular field in the world to
be common among Arab speakers (p.149).
Therefore, translators are resorted to arabization methods to introduce new Arabic terms
as an ideal solution for the absence of the Arabic equivalence, and the use of terminology in
different areas and fields.
11
6. Methods of setting English-Arabic technical terminology:
Depending on what is mentioned in Ghazala (2013), all types of language, text and
terminology has to be attended to arabization.
Ghazala (2008) tackled these methods and explain them in his book as solutions to the
problem of translating technical terminology into Arabic.
Examples:
Radar رادار
Fax فاكس
Cabin الكابين
6.2. Naturalization( )التطبيع:
It is the adoption of the English term to Arabic letters, and grammar, by modifying only
a partial of its pronunciation, and using it into various grammar forms (adjective, verb, plural,
feminine....etc).
Example:
Technology : تكنولوجيا
-Technological (adj) تكنولوجية/تكنولوجي
-Technologies (n. /plural) تكنولوجيات
-Technologist (n) )متخصصة في التكنولوجيا/تكنولوجية (متخصص/ تكنولوجي
6.3. Translation:
It is the transmission of English technical terms into existing Arabic lexicon
(equivalence).
Example:
Valve صمام
Airport مطار
Barrier حاجز
12
6.4. Coinage (النحت/ )السك:
It is method of coining new Arabic terminology that has not been in use in Arabic
language before.
There are three main ways for coining new Arabic terminology:
Example:
According to Ghazala (2008), This method played the role in presenting new Arabic
terms, it is based on measurement especially those deal with ‘instrument names’ such as:
Examples:
Example:
13
II. Aeronautics Industry :
1. An overview on aeronautics industry:
Thousand years, people have dreamed of flying and always attempt to try, from Abbes
Ibn Farness to Leonardo Da Vinci, the invention of steam engine changed everything and
contributed to the development of flights.
2. Aeronautics VS Aviation:
According to the same source in Vivian (1920) the history of aviation did not begin with
the Wright brothers, but their successful flight in 1903 in the first heavier-than-air ship was
the start of a revolution. Airports are in every large city and in many small towns. Airlines
schedule flights to cities and towns in America, as well as around the world. Aviation also
includes engineering,
Technical schools and community colleges offer programs that can train you to work in
the aviation industry as mechanics, technicians and in the service end of the business in jobs
such as flight attendant, service desk person, ticket agent or other personnel.
Aeronautic or aerospace can work for government agencies, such as the National
Aeronautic and Space Administration (NASA), as flight engineers, designers and members of
mission control. Aircraft or weapon manufacturers also hire aeronautic engineers to design
airplanes, helicopters, spacecraft, rockets, guidance systems and other defence systems.
3. Conclusion :
This chapter has highlighted the major issues in translating technical terms into Arabic,
through demonstrating the strategies of handling these difficulties, to sum up; technical
terminology is considered as a debated issue in both translation aspects; studies and practices.
Aeronautics translation is a high specialized field, Arabic translators in that field faced major
difficulties (equivalence at word level) which belong to specialised environment, hence the
translator in aeronautics should have a deep knowledge on the mastery of both languages,
combining technical knowledge and linguistic expertise, with respecting the field-specific
jargon, this enable to dissolve language barriers, and ensure learners benefits.
15
Chapter two
Practical part
Analysis and critical study of the corpus
1. Introduction:
After discussing the theoretical part, and gathering the important information about the
case study, the main concern of this chapter is to confirm or disclaim the aforementioned
hypotheses; this part attempted through analyzing and comparing the chosen fragments,
pieces of texts and terms that we have selected randomly from the corpus, and the book
“Introduction to Avionics systems” which is available in Arabic version “ مدخل الى أنظمة
”الكترونيات الطيران.
This 78 pages book in Arabic was written at the University of Aleppo by DR Yasser
Hanan in 2003 as an attempt from mechanical engineering students to explain the structure of
airplanes. This book contains 6 chapters each chapter discuss a different technical and
mechanical aspects of the airplane.
The chosen pieces of texts are taken from the second edition book “Introduction to
Avionics systems” by P.R.G. Collinson 2003 which has a translated version into Arabic
“ ”مدخل الى أنظمة الكترونيات الطيرانby Dr Abd Elbasset Kerman 2012, this book tackled the
principle systems of avionics and illustrate all the updated techniques to meet the world needs
in research and development field.
3. Methodology:
In order to investigate the translated terms from English into Arabic, The methodology
which is adopted in this practical part is a comparison between the chosen technical terms
which were taken from the book “Fundamentals of Aviation” patterns and the texts where
selected from both the English book “Introduction to Avionics systems” by P.R.G.Collinson
and its Arabic version “ ”مدخل الى انظمة إلكترونيات الطيرانby Dr.Abdelbasset Kerman.
4. Corpus Analysis:
Some instructions and information have been translated from English into Arabic
language for the Arabic users (learners, managers…etc), these followings are some of them in
their Source and Target languages.
17
Pattern 01
The following expressions: combustion chamber, gear box, fuel injector were translated by
using calque, also literal translation compressor ضاغط, also the use of paraphrasing in inlet
and turbo-prop in this, whereas he translated the terms; nozzle and turbine by using
Arabization revival technique, the translator referred to the term turbine into Arabic as العنفة
rather than توربينfocusing on translating the function of ST term, also we notice a shift in
register to translate prop in informal for propeller.
18
Pattern 02:
Both turbine thrust reverser and fan thrust reverser were translated by using literal
translation عاكس الدفع للعنفة و عاكس الدفع للمروحة
Pattern 03:
19
Analysis of pattern 03:
Translator used expansion in Landing Gear مجموعة عجالت الهبوط,the terms slat and flat
were translated into قالبات أمامية وقالبات خلفيةhere he paraphrase the terms in order to explain
their function , we notice that he used literal translation to translate ailerons by جنيحات.
Pattern 04:
20
The translator used the literal translation to translate into Arabic:
- Fuselage by بدن الطائرةthat would be inaccurate to use this expression but rather say جسم
الطائرة
Also, he used literal translation to render the meaning of the expression (5): Tail unit into
Arabic by مجموعة الذيلwhich is not appropriate to ensure its implicit meaning ذيل الطائرة
While, in the expression (3) the translator focused on translating according to the function
of terms rather than the lexical meaning of the term itself in the two expressions, he translated
power unit by محركات الدفعwhere he used transposition procedure to translate the term unit
(singular) by the term ( محركاتplural).
Regarding the expression (4) the translator referred to the term landing gear by using its
functional meaning عجالت الهبوط, whereas, he translated the same expression differently by
مجموعة العجالت, for certain purpose.
Pattern 05:
• Flight control: Flight Control Systems exploit electronic system technology in two areas,
namely auto stabilisation (or stability augmentation) systems and FBW flight control
systems. Most swept wing jet aircraft exhibit a lightly damped short period oscillatory
motion about the yaw and roll axes at certain height and speed conditions, known as ‘Dutch
roll’, and require at least a yaw auto-stabilizer system to damp and suppress this motion; a
roll auto-stabilizer system may also be required.
21
Translated version of pattern 05:
The following title “Flight control systems” was translated into Arabic by “ أنظمة التحكم
”بالرحلةthe translator used calque, the two expression “Dutch roll” was translated into Arabic
literally as الدحرجة الهولندية.
Regarding to the translation of the expression “FBW control systems” into Arabic by
“ أنظمة التحكم برحلة الطيران بواسطة االسالكwe noticed that he translates the abbreviation“FBW”
(Fly by Wire) by رحلة الطيران بواسطة االسالكhere he used paraphrasing technique to explain the
meaning of the given abbreviation, also he used expanding technique, by which he add the
term رحلةto provide more explanation to the term “fly”.
The expression “oscillatory motion” was translated by حركة تذبذبيةinstead of حركة متذبذبة
whereby the translator used transposition procedure to shift the adverb in SL to adjective in
TL.
Pattern 06:
• Housekeeping management: The term ‘House keeping’ management has been used to
cover the automation of the background tasks which are essential for the aircraft’s safe and
efficient operation. Such tasks include:
- Fuel management. This embraces fuel flow and fuel quantity measurement and control of
fuel transfer from the appropriate fuel tanks to minimize changes in the aircraft trim.
22
- Hydraulic power supply system management
- Warning systems
The following title “House keeping management” was translated literally into Arabic by
إدارة التدبير المنزلي,which refer to the same functional meaning as; حراسة،حجز،حفظ مراعاة، عناية
Also, He translates the sentence “Fuel tanks” into Arabic by خزانات الوقودhere the
translator used calque procedure to translate fuel by وقود, and tanks by خزاناتwhereas, he
used equivalence as procedure to translate the term “Electric” into Arabic by كهرباء.
Regarding the term “Hydraulic” the translator used borrowing as procedure to translate it
into Arabic by " "الهيدروليكيةbecause of the lack of its equivalent in Arabic language, moreover
he used full borrowing procedure to translate “cabin” into Arabic by “ ”الكابينةand here we
23
notice that translator applied transcription method to translate the term “cabin” On this basis it
is appropriate, to translate it into Arabic by قمرة, while the term cockpit translated literally as
مقصورة
Pattern 07:
HUD accuracy is derived from a chain of elements comprising:-
• Input data
• Installation
The analysis of the two versions of pattern 07 above shows that; the following
abbreviation “HUD” which refers to (Head Up Display), was translated into Arabic by شاشة
الرأس المرتفع, the translator applied paraphrasing procedure in order to add more explanation,
nevertheless, we notice that; the expression “Head Up Display” was translated literally as شاشة
الرأس المرتفعin other situation in the same reference. In addition, the term “symbol” was
24
translated as الرموز, whereas, the translator used transposition procedure to convey the
meaning of SL word.
The term “cathode” was transliterated into Arabic الكاثودthe translator used transcription
method in order to create new Arabic term الكاثود, which is not appropriate; he would rather
used an alternative translation المهبطto avoid ambiguity in TL.
Pattern 08:
The concept of a ‘virtual cockpit’ where information is presented visually to the pilot by
means of computer generated 3D imagery is being very actively researched in a number of
establishments both in the USA and the UK.
25
Analysis of pattern 08:
In this pattern we find the word virtual cockpit translated into المقصورة التقديريةand 3D
translated into ثالثي األبعادand both the expression were translated using calque procedure , the
words visually مرئيand pilot طيارwere literally translated.
5. Findings
Throughout the analysis and the comparison of the translated terminologies in Yasser
Hanan’s book “Fundamentals of Aviation”, and the collinson’s book “Introduction to
Avionics systems” in source language (English), and its Arabic version “ مدخل الى أنظمة
”إلكترونيات الطيران, these following results were deduced from this practical part of the research,
which shows that literal translational is mostly used to translate technical terms of
aeronautics, however in some cases literal procedure failed to express the functional meaning
of the technical terminology, therefore the translator resorted to applied other translation
procedures, such as; borrowing, paraphrasing, transposition, calque, transliteration, and
sometimes descriptive equivalent.
Through the analysis of patterns, we have found that the translator of aeronautics technical
terminology, faced difficulties to find terms equivalents in Arabic, these leads him to
transcribe, and borrow the English terminology, another difficulty which is considered as
major problem in translating aeronautics terminology is acronyms and abbreviations, the
translator adopted paraphrasing as the appropriate procedure.
Finally, it was found that some English technical terms have more than one meaning
(polysemy), and terms shared the same meaning (synonymy) which hold a degree of
ambiguity and vagueness especially for those non-specialist readers.
6. Conclusion
This part was pointed out in order to answer the questions raised by this study, concerning
the translatability of aeronautics technical terminology into Arabic language, and the
appropriate procedures used, in order to reach the closest meaning of the technical
terminology.
26
It can be concluded that, paraphrasing procedure is commonly used to translate non-
equivalents terminology in aeronautics, for the purpose of providing more explanation to the
implicit meaning of the abbreviated term.
27
General conclusion
Translation is considered to be an important factor in transmitting information among
people whatever their language and culture. Even that translation started in common field of
communication, aeronautics in other hand spread widely, just like all the other fields
translation played an important role on its spread, Arab translators used different methods and
procedures to permit the Arab world to explore the aeronautics industry.
The practical part of this research has examined the common procedures that employed to
render the meaning of the specialized terminology; in aeronautics, moreover tackling the
problems that faced the translator in finding the understandable technical equivalent.
28
English & Arabic
Appendices
30
31
32
33
Bibliography:
Alaoui, A. (2015). Knowledge Transfer and the Translation of Technical Texts.International
Journal of Social, Behavioral, Educational, Economic, Business and Industrial
Engineering.
Ashqar ,A. (2013). The Problem of Equivalence: The Translation into Arabic of Specialized
Technological Texts. An-Najah National University. Nablus, Palestine.
Al-Asal, M. S., Smadi, O. M. (2012). Arabicization and Arabic Expanding Techniques Used
in Science Lectures in Two Arab Universities. Asian Perspectives in the Arts and
Humanities (p.21)
Byrne, J. (2012). Scientific and Technical Translation Explained: A Nuts and Bolts Guide for
Beginners. Oxon and New York: Routledge, (pp. 229).
Baker, M. (1998). Routledge Encyclopedia of Translation Studies. London and New York :
Routledge.p306
Dickins, J., Harvey, S., Higgins, I. (2002). Thinking Arabic translation. A Course
inTranslation Method. Arabic to English. London. Routledge.
34
Ghazala, H. (2008).Translation as problems and solutions: special edition, Lebanon: Dar.
El-Ilm Lilmalayin
Ghazala, H. (2013). Arabization Revisited in the Third Millennium. Arabe World English
Journal (AWEJ), College of Social Sciences, Uma Al-Qura University, Saudi
Arabia
Khrisat, A., Mohamed, M. (2014). Language's Borrowings: The Role of the Borrowed and Arabized
Words in Enriching Arabic Language. American Journal of Humanities and Social
Sciences. King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah Vo1. 2, No. 2
Newmark, P. (1988). A Textbook of Translation. London and New York: Prentice Hall
International (UK) Ltd,(p.85-87)
Palumbo, G. (2009). Key Terms in Translation Studies. London. New York: Continuum
International Publishing Group, (p. 212).
35
Arabic references:
دار اآلثار: صنعاء. مدخل الى علم المصطلح.)7002( ع، أ،الرازحي
جامعة حلب. هندسة الطيران:كلية الهندسة الميكانيكية.مدخل في الطيران.)7002( ي،حنان
المنظمة العربية للترجمة: بيروت. نسخة مترجمة:مدخل الى أنظمة إلكترونيات الطيران.)7007( ع،علي
مجمع اللغة العربية الفلسطيني: فلسطين. آليات التعريب و صناعة المصطلحات الجديدة.)7002( ك،غنيم
دار العلم للماليين: بيروت. فقه اللغة العربية و خصائصها.)0897( ب، إ،يعقوب
Webography
Ali, H. (2007).Translation Techniques and Text Types. Student Handbook. The American
University in Cairo .Retrieved from: https://fr.slideshare.net/itquanici/translation-
techniques-and-text-types-45939449
Banjar,Shadya.Y. (2011).Translation Strategies. Retrieved from:
http://wwwdrshadiabanjar.blogspot.com/2011/05
NASA Spacelink. (2002). Aeronautics: an Educator’s Guide. Retrieved form:
https://www.nasa.gov/audience/foreducators/topnav/materials/listbytype/Aeronautics
.html
Grassili, C. (2016).Translation Techniques: calque. Retrieved from:
http://translatorthoughts.com/2016/05/calque
Kesbi, A . Arabization and Translation: Focus on Lexical Issues. University Hassan II
Mohammedia. Casablanca. Retrieved from:
http://uh2c.academia.edu/AbdelazizKesbi 20/03/2017
Mphahlele, M, C. (2004). The Transliteration Principle: Is this the Best Procedure in African
Language Lexicography. Retrieved from:
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-
hqHdcwJUgIJ:lexikos.journals.ac.za/pub/article/v
Peetham, S. (2009).What is transliteration. Retrieved from:
http://www.sringeri.net/?s=whatis+transliteration
The arabization process: Term development and arabization methodology. (2010).
Retrieved from: http://www.arabterm.org/index.php?id=88&L=1
36
ملخص المذكرة باللغة العربية
المقدمة:
تعتبر اللغ ة اإلنجليزية في وقنتا الحالي لغة للعولمة والتطور التكنولوجي ,باعتبارها لغة رسمية في
التبادالت العالمية ,وفي مجال التكنولوجيا ,و العالم العربي كغيره من الدول تأثر بهذا التطور التكنولوجي
والذي بدوره يلعب دورا هاما في خلق و انتشار مفردات تقنية جديدة .
باإلشارة الى اعتماد الدول العربية على غيرها من الدول في العديد من المجاالت و خاصة العلمية
و واقع تهميش اللغة العربية وتبني اللغة االنجليزية بشكل أوسع في شتى المجاالت العلمية.تسعى الدول
العربية الى الترجمة والتي لها السبق في المساهمة في إثراء اللغة العربية بالعديد من المصطلحات العلمية
الجديدة
تهدف هذه الدراسة الى التحقيق في إمكانية ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية في مجال الطيران،ومن ثم
توضح اهم الصعوبات التي تواجه المترجم في عملية الترجمة على مستوى الكلمات ،فيما يخص
ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية و المتخصصة.
الجزء األول:
يتناول الجزء النظري تعاريف كل من الترجمة المتخصصة ،متبوعة بالترجمة التقنية ثم المكافئ
في الترجمة باإلضافة الى المصطلحاتية والمكافئ المصطلحاتي .
الترجمة المتخصصة:
وهي الترجمة التي تختص بالترجمة العلمية ,والطبية ,و الهندسة والمجاالت التقنية...الخ،حيث يقوم
المترجم بترجمة نص علمي او تقني في مجال معين مما يستوجب عليه ان يمتلك خبرة بمعاني و وظيفة
كل مصطلح في هذا المجال.
ينظر الى ترجمة النصوص التقنية على أنها طريقة إليصال رسالة شفهية أو مكتوبة تحمل معلومات
تقنية بغض النظر عن نوعها ،كوسيلة للتواصل بين الناس
2
كما يركزهذا الجزء على أهم التقنيات المستخدمة في ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية من اللغة االنجليزية
الى اللغة العربية ،أهمها:
يعتبر المشكل األهم في ترجمة المفردات التقنية الى اللغة العربية سوء فهم هته المفردات بسبب
الغموض اللغوي و العوائق الثقافية ،وغياب المكافئ في اللغة العربية.
المصطلحية :
وهوعلم دراسة المفردات المنطوية تحت موضوع متخصص وبدورها تحتوي على المفردات
التقنية
لترجمة النص التقني يستعمل المترجمون العديد من الطرق من بينها االقتراض ,النحل ,االستبدال
,والمكافئ ,لتحقيق الغاية من الترجمة ،وهي نقل للمعلومات و المصطلحات من اللغة المصدر الى
اللغة الهدف دون اإلخالل بمعنى ووظيفة المصطلح األصلي.
التعريب:
هوعملية نقل أو تحويل مفردات تقنية أو علمية نحو اللغة العربية من أجل خلق أو إحياء مصطلحات
عربية علمية جديدة ,وهنا نذكر الطرق المتبعة في تعريب المصطلحات الى اللغة العربية:
وقد إعتبرها حسن الغزالة ( )7009كحلول لمشاكل ترجمة المصطلحات العلمية و التقنية الى اللغة
العربية .
في مايخص مشاكل الترجمة التقنية ،تعتبر ترجمة المصطلحات على إختالفها من أكبر المشاكل التي
تؤثر على نقل المعلومات التقنية من لغة الى اخرى وبنفس الوقت تعتبر تحدي للمترجم .
يجد المترجم المتخصص في مجال الطيران نفسه يتعامل مع المفردات التقنية و االختصارات:
3
أردبليو –مدرج. RUNWAY - RWY
الجزء الثاني:
حاول االنسان الطيران مند أالف السنين كانت اولى محاوالته منذ عباس ابن فرناس و ليوناردو
ديفنشي ,لكن باختراع المحرك البخاري تغيرت كل المفاهيم و ساهم ذلك في تطوير مجال الطيران .
إستعمل المخترعون القماش و األسالك المعدنية لتطوير الطائرة تم جاء األخوان رايت وكانا
مهتمان بالطيران بتصميم طائرة بمواد قوية وخفيفة الوزن في نفس الوقت ,بعد اآلالف من التجارب
ومحاوالت البحت عن محرك خفيف الوزن ،قام االخوان بصنع طائرة شراعية وقاموا برحلتهم التاريخية
في 02من ديسمبر .0802
ظهرت أكثر الطائرات تطورا وحداثة مع اندالع الحرب العالمية األولى ،لكنها سرعان ما توقفت
صناعة الطيران مع إنتهاء الحرب بعد أن قام شارل ليندربرغ بالطيران من نيويورك الى باريس في رحلة
دامت 22ساعة هذا ما حفز مخيلة الناس الستكتشاف وبلوغ أفاق جديدة في مجال الطيران.
يتضمن مجال الطيران عموما كل ما يتعلق بصناعة و هندسة الطائرات ،وحتى المجال التجاري و
السياحي .بينما يختص قطاع المالحة الجوية بالهندسة الفضائية ،كما يهتم بدراسة و تصميم الطائرات و
اآلالت الجوية ،وله دور هام في تسيير حركة الطائرات لضمان سالمتها.
4
Abstract
The objective of this study was to investigate the main procedures and methods used to achieve the equivalent terms in
aeronautics industry, and highlighted the difficulties faced translators in that field, this study seeks to investigate the
difficulties in achieving equivalence at word level in Aeronautics industry. It includes two parts; the theoretical and practical
parts. The first part tackles the translatability of aeronautics, and exposes the main procedures of translating its technical
terminology, moreover it discusses the difficulties faced the translator in rendering the meaning of aeronautics terms into
Arabic. In order to answer this study questions. The second part, attempted to apply the information of the first part on a set
of terms, selected from patterns and its translations, which has devoted to analysis and comparison study. The study focused
on analyzing the aeronautics terms used in Yacer Hanan’s book “Fundamentals of Aviation”, and a comparison between
selected terms and fragements in P.R.G. Collinson’s book “Introduction to Avionics systems”, and its Arabic version “ مدخل
”الى أنظمة إلكترونيات الطيرانby Abdelbasset Kerman, The study findings indicated that difficulties lie in finding the appropriate
term, and the effect of translating the function rather than the terms themselves.
For further researches, it is suggested to use a comparative method between the translation of a professional translator
in that field and beginners.
: الملخص
كما،هدفت هذه الدراسة الى التحقيق في أهم األساليب و الطرق المستخدمة لتحقيق التكافؤ على مستوى المصطلحات التقنية في مجال صناعة الطيران
ويتناول الجزء األول قابلية ترجمة. وقد إشتملت هذه الدراسة على فصلين؛ جزء نظري وآخر تطبيقي،أبرزت الصعوبات التي تواجه المترجمين في هذا المجال
أما الجزء الثاني فقد تم تطبيق، كما يناقش الصعوبات التي واجهت المترجم في ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية إلى اللغة العربية،المصطلحات التقنية في مجال الطيران
و كتاب "مدخل الى انظمة الكترونيات،دراسة التحليل والمقارنة على مجموعة من المصطلحات المختارة وترجماتها في كتاب "مدخل في الطيران" لياسر حنان
أظهرت نتائج هذه الدراسة أن الصعوبات الي تواجه المترجم في.عبد الباسط كرمان. ونسخته المترجمة الى العربية من قبل د،الطيران" باالنجليزية لكولينسون
كما اوضحت مدى تأثير ترجمة وظيفة المصطلح بدال من ترجمته بحد ذاته،مجال ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية للطيران تكمن في العثور على المصطلح المناسب لها
.في ترجمة المصطلحات التقنية من اللغة االنجليزية الى العربية
Résumé :
L'objectif de cette étude était d'étudier les principales procédures et méthodes utilisées pour atteindre les termes
équivalents dans l'industrie aéronautique, Et a souligné les difficultés auxquelles sont confrontés les traducteurs dans ce
domaine. Cette étude à étudier les difficultés d'équivalence au niveau des termes technique dans l'industrie de l'aéronautique.
Il comprend deux parties; La partie théorique et le pratique, La première partie sont discutées à la traduction de l'aéronautique
et expose les principales procédures de la traduction de sa terminologie technique. De plus, elle traite les difficultés
rencontrées par le traducteur pour traduire les termes de l'aéronautique en arabes, La deuxième partie a été appliquée
l’analyse et la comparaison des termes sélectionnés dans le livre « Introduction à l'aviation » par Yasser Hanan, et un livre en
anglais par Collinson « Introduction aux systèmes avioniques » et sa version traduite en arabe par le Dr. Abd-Elbasit Kerman.
Les résultats de cette étude ont montré que les difficultés dans la traduction des termes techniques de l'aviation consistent à
trouver l'équivalent approprié de terme en arabe, et a également démontré l'impact de traduise la fonction de terme plutôt que
de lui-même dans la traduction des termes techniques de l'anglais vers l'arabe.