BOMBAY HIGHCOURT
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST
For Wednesday The 19th March 2025
COURT NO. 20
SINGLE
AT 10:30 AM
HON'BLE JUSTICE SHRI ARIF S. DOCTOR
HEADER NOTE :
=======================================================
IT IS HEREBY NOTIFIED for the information of the Advocates and the parties
appearing in person at the Principal Seat at Bombay that praecipe for dispensation
of office objections in non-contentious testamentary matters shall be accompanied
by Order passed by the Testamentary Registrar / O.S.D with Testamentary
Department to that effect.
=======================================================
The Hon'ble Shri Justice Arif S. Doctor.
Website - https://zoom.us
Link - https://zoom.us/my/sbcourt35
Meeting Number - 266 815 2888
==========================================================
SR. NO.901 WILL BE TAKEN AT 2:30 PM.
Sr. CASE NO. PARTIES ADVOCATES
AT 2.30 P.M.
18/03/2025 19:38:23 1/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 2 -
901 NMS/749/2015 NATIONAL SPOT EXCHANGE NAIK NAIK AND COMPANY
[Original] LIMITED -
VS VAISH ASSOCIATES ADVOCATES
M/S. N.K. PROTEINS LIMITED AND DEF NOS 8 & 9
49 ORS. DEF NOS 6,7,10,11,,18 & 19
DEF NOS 15 TO 17
DEF NOS 5.12,21-23, 26-31,33,3-
-41
DEF NOS 1 TO 4
JAYESH MESTRY (DEF.NO.13)
RAVINDRA MUNGEKAR
D-8 AND 9
D-6,7,10,11,18,19
RAVINDRA BAJIRAO MUNGEKAR
M/S. R and M PARTNERS
Paranjape Omkar Sunil
OMKAR PARANJAPE FOR DEF 2 TO
5
DEF NO. 15 TO 17
YOGINI DEEPAK GADA
Def. No. 42 to 44
KHAITAN LEGAL ASSOCIATES
Def. No. 05
12, 21 TO 23, 26 TO 31, 33, 36, 37,
38, 39 TO 41
DEFENDANT 29, 31 AND 38
DEFENDANT 36, 37,39 AND 40
RAVINDRA BAJIRAO MUNGEKAR
DEFENDANT 33,45,49 AND 50
SOMET S SHIRSAT
DEFENDANT 8 AND 9
VM LEGAL
DEF NO. 1 TO 4
Prabhakar Manohar Jadhav
-
SHAH KOMAL BHARAT
NIDHI CHHEDA
-
BAFNA ISHA LALIT
REMARK : AFFIDAVIT DT 16/03/2015 FILED ON DT 29/05/2015 AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY DT 24/04/2015 FILED ON DT
29/05/2015. ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVIT DT 29/04/2015 FILED ON DT 29/05/2015. AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY DT
24/04/2015 FILED ON DT 29/05/2015. AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEF. NO.4 DT 24/04/2015 FILED ON
29/05/2015. AFFIDAVIT OF DISCLOSING IMMOVABLE PROPERTY DEFENDENT NO. 4 DT 16/03/2015 FILED ON
29/05/2015. ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT NO. 4 DT 29/04/2015 FILED ON 29/05/2015.
AFFIDAVIT DISCLOSING IMMOVABLE PROPERTIES ON BEHALF OF DEF NO. 1 DT. 16/3/2015 FILED ON
1/6/2015. ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVIT DISCLOSING MOVABLE PROPERTIES ON BELAF OF DEF NO. 1 DT. 29/4/2015
FILED ON 1/6/2015. ADDITIONAL AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF DEF NO. 1 (ANNEXING BANK STATEMENT DT.
29/4/20215 FILED ON 1/6/2015 AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT NO. 1 DATED 24/4/2015 FILED
ON 2/6/2015. AFFIDAVIT IN REJOINDER FILED ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF TO THE AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON
BEHALF OF DEF NO. 4 DT 25/06/2015 AS PER SHRI. G.S.PATEL J DT 05/08/2015 FILED ON 07/08/2015.AFFIDAVIT
IN REJOINDER FILED ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF TO THE AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEF NO. 3
DT 03/08/2015 AS PER SHRI. G.S.PATEL J DT 05/08/2015 FILED ON 07/08/2015. AFFIDAVIT IN REJOINDER FILED
ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF TO THE AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEF NO. 1 DT 25/06/2015 AS PER
SHRI. G.S.PATEL J DT 05/08/2015 FILED ON 07/08/2015.AFFIDAVIT IN REJOINDER FILED ON BEHALF OF THE
PLAINTIFF TO THE AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEF NO. 2 DT 22/06/2015 AS PER SHRI. G.S.PATEL J DT
05/08/2015 FILED ON 07/08/2015. === ADDITIONAL AFFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF PLAINTIFF DTD. 15/10/2018 AS
PER COURTS ORDER DTD. 30/11/2018 (WRONG PAGINATION AND TOTAL PAGES 13) FILED ON 05/12/2018. ===
AFFIDAVIT IN REPLY ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT NO. 01 AS PER COURTS ORDER DTD. 30/11/2018 (WRONG
PAGINATION AND TOTAL PAGES 21) FILED ON 05/12/2018. ==== ==AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT ON
27/08/2024 AS PER ORDER DATED 14/08/2024==
18/03/2025 19:38:23 2/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 3 -
WITH
IA(L)/2866/2024
N K PROTEINS LIMITED VM LEGAL
(ECHCBM02018852024)
[Original] VS -
NATIONAL SPOT EXCHANGE LI VAISH ASSOCIATES ADVOCATE
MITED S
M/S. R and M PARTNERS
Paranjape Omkar Sunil
OMKAR PARANJAPE FOR DEF 2
TO 5
DEF NO. 15 TO 17
YOGINI DEEPAK GADA
Def. No. 42 to 44
KHAITAN LEGAL ASSOCIATES
Def. No. 05
12, 21 TO 23, 26 TO 31, 3
3, 36, 37, 38, 39 TO 41
DEFENDANT 29, 31 AND 38
DEFENDANT 36, 37,39 AND 4
0
RAVINDRA BAJIRAO MUNGEKAR
DEFENDANT 33,45,49 AND 50
SOMET S SHIRSAT
DEFENDANT 8 AND 9
VM LEGAL
DEF NO. 1 TO 4
Prabhakar Manohar Jadhav
-
SHAH KOMAL BHARAT
NIDHI CHHEDA
-
BAFNA ISHA LALIT
REMARK: ==PRAECIPE DT. 29-01-2024==TO BE HEARD A/W SR. NO. 1 OF THE MAIN BOARD==
WITH
IA/3883/2023 NATIONAL SPOT EXCHANGE LI Vaish Associates
[Orignal] MITED
VS
In N.K. PROTEINS LIMITED AND
COMS/126/2021 49 ORS.
REMARK: ==PRAECIPE DTD-27/01/2023 ==
WITH
NMS/1488/2015 NATIONAL SPOT EXCHANGE LI NAIK NAIK AND COMPANY
18/03/2025 19:38:23 3/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 4 -
[Orignal] MITED -
VS VAISH ASSOCIATES ADVOCATE
In M/S. N.K. PROTEINS LIMITE S
COMS/126/2021 D AND 49 ORS. VM LEGAL
DEF NO. 1 TO 4
M/S. R and M PARTNERS
Paranjape Omkar Sunil
OMKAR PARANJAPE FOR DEF 2
TO 5
DEF NO. 15 TO 17
YOGINI DEEPAK GADA
Def. No. 42 to 44
KHAITAN LEGAL ASSOCIATES
Def. No. 05
12, 21 TO 23, 26 TO 31, 3
3, 36, 37, 38, 39 TO 41
DEFENDANT 29, 31 AND 38
DEFENDANT 36, 37,39 AND 4
0
RAVINDRA BAJIRAO MUNGEKAR
DEFENDANT 33,45,49 AND 50
SOMET S SHIRSAT
DEFENDANT 8 AND 9
VM LEGAL
DEF NO. 1 TO 4
Prabhakar Manohar Jadhav
-
SHAH KOMAL BHARAT
NIDHI CHHEDA
-
BAFNA ISHA LALIT
WITH
CHS/1217/2015 NATIONAL SPOT EXCHANGE LI -
[Orignal] MITED VAISH ASSOCIATES ADVOCATE
VS S
In M/S. N.K. PROTEINS LIMITE NIDHI CHHEDA
COMS/126/2021 D AND 49 ORS. M/S. R and M PARTNERS
Paranjape Omkar Sunil
OMKAR PARANJAPE FOR DEF 2
TO 5
DEF NO. 15 TO 17
YOGINI DEEPAK GADA
Def. No. 42 to 44
18/03/2025 19:38:23 4/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 5 -
KHAITAN LEGAL ASSOCIATES
Def. No. 05
12, 21 TO 23, 26 TO 31, 3
3, 36, 37, 38, 39 TO 41
DEFENDANT 29, 31 AND 38
DEFENDANT 36, 37,39 AND 4
0
RAVINDRA BAJIRAO MUNGEKAR
DEFENDANT 33,45,49 AND 50
SOMET S SHIRSAT
DEFENDANT 8 AND 9
VM LEGAL
DEF NO. 1 TO 4
Prabhakar Manohar Jadhav
-
SHAH KOMAL BHARAT
NIDHI CHHEDA
-
BAFNA ISHA LALIT
FOR DIRECTION
902 TS/23/1993 RAJENDRA K. VORA and ANR. DEFE. NO. 1
[Original] VS G.S. MANASAWALA
PRITHVIDEVI M. THAKUR K.J.VORA VASANT DHAVAN (U/OBJ)
and ORS NITIN H. SHUKLA (U/OBJ
CONSENT OF EARLIER ADV.)
REMARK : ** PRAECIPE DTD. 09/03/2018 ** ORDER ON 18/07 IN NMT/61/15. WILL NO. 172/1993==
PROBATE COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS AND EXAMINATION IN CHIEF FILE ON DT. 15/11/2010.\
COMMISSIONER APPOINTED FOR RECORDING EVIDENCE ON 15/11/2010. AFFIDAVIT OF
GAJENDRAKUMAR VED AND AFFIDAVIT OF KIRAN SHAH FILE ON DT. 09/12/2011.=== COMMISSIONERS
REPORT OF ADELINE RODRIGUES FILED ON 31/08/2017 ====
903 MPT/48/2017 SRISHTI CALCUTTAWALA AND RES.NO. 1
[Original] ANOTHER VIVEK KANTAWALA AND
VS COMPANY
SUNIL KEWALKRISHAN CHOPRA
REMARK : AFFIDAVIT OF SUNIL K.CHOPRA IN REPLY DT.02/06/2017,AS PER COURT ORDER
DT.10/08/2017,FILED ON 10/08/2017 (LAST PAGE NO.50-82). === COMMISSIONERS REPORT OF S.S.
AGATE (COURT COMMISSIONER) DT.05/06/2018,FILED ON 05/06/2018 (PAGE NO.1-66). ==== FURTHER
AFFIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER DT. 30/05/2018 AS PER COURT ORDER DT. 06/06/2018 FILED
ON DT. 06/06/2018 (101 TO 149).=== COMMISSIONER REPORT OF S. S. AGATE DT. 18/11/2019 FILED ON
18/11/2019. ===
with
IA(L)/8558/2025
(AMH20240126904C20250 Srishti Calcuttawala RAHUL KAMERKAR
0003)
[Original] VS RAHUL KAMERKAR
Sunil Kewalkrishnan Chopr
18/03/2025 19:38:23 5/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 6 -
In a
MPT/48/2017
WITH
IA(L)/8558/2025
(AMH20240126904C20250 Srishti Calcuttawala RAHUL KAMERKAR
0003)
[Original] VS RAHUL KAMERKAR
Sunil Kewalkrishnan Chopr
In a
MPT/48/2017
904 TS/32/2018 MADHURI PRAKASH PARANJAPE AMIT S KATE
[Original] AND ANR AMIT SHANKAR KATE
VS FOR CAVEATOR 2
VAISHALI DEVAJI GONDANE AND RAVINDRA NIVRUTTI KACHARE
ANR (CAVEATORS)
905 CRR/27/2019 JAYSUKHLAL N. BHUTA AND ANR DIVYA SHAH and ASSOCIATES
[Original] VS Divya Shah Associates
VASANTABEN R. BHUTA AND ORS. SANJAY UDESHI and CO.
-
-
-
-
Prerna Gandhi
REMARK : R.R.No.: 0860772018I
WITH
NMS/688/2017 JAYSUKHLAL NAGARDAS BHUTA Divya Shah Associates
[Orignal] AND ANR.
VS
In VASANTBEN R. BHUTA (DELET
S/3148/2009 ED SINCE DECEASED) AND 5
ORS.
REMARK: ADDITIONAL REPLY FOR AND BEHALF OF DEF NO. 3 AND 4 DT. 18/9/2018 AS PER COURTS
ORDER DT. 19/9/2018 PAGES 18-20== AFFIDAVIT OF DEF NO. 3 & 4 DT. 31/10/2018 FILED ON
1/11/2018 PAGES 21-46=== FUTHER AFFIDAVIT OF HTE PLAINTIFF NO.1 OF JAYSUKHLAL
NAGARDAS BHUTA DT.18/02/2019 AS PER COURT ORDER DT.03/06/2019 PG NO.43-76 FILED ON
DT.03/06/2019 ===AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT ON 22/12/2021. === AS PER ORDER DTD.
16/06/2023, AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT ON 07/07/2023 ===
R.R.No.: 0860772018I
906 TS/66/2019 ARLENE DSOUZA PLAINTIFF
[Original] VS SANJAY SINHA AND JEFFREY
ARNOLD CARVALHO AND ORS. JOSEPH
ZENOBIA SHAPOOR IRANI
IVOR PETER D\'CRUZ
PETITIONER
VIKAS MISHRA
REMARK : == PRAECIPE DATED 26/02/2020.== == CONSENT TERM DT. 22/07/2019 FILED ON 29/07/2019
== AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE OF RAMESH T YADAV DT. 27/11/2019 FILED ON 27/11/2019 ==
18/03/2025 19:38:23 6/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 7 -
907 COMS/129/2024 M/S GOLD COIN BUILDERS PLAINTIFF
[Original] VS VISHAL S. SHRIYAN
ZARNA VINAY SHAH DEF.NO. 4 (A)
DEF NO.4B AND 4 C
DEFE. NO 1(A)
BHAGWATI & CO [ 1,2,3,4 ]
BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
REMARK : AFF.OF SERVICE DT. 26/03/2008 IS FILED ON 02/05/2008. LC SUIT ORDER DTD 06/05/2010 PER
LD. PROTHO. AND SR. MASTER.W/S OF DEF 1,2,3,4 FILED ON 01/06/10. To dispose of the suit as epeditiously
as possible in any event within one year, Order dt. 22-3-2010, Per. D.B. Presided over by Shri Justice Daveer
Bhandari, J. == NOT TO BE PLACED BEFORE SHRI K.K. TATED, J. ORDER DTD. 20/11/2017 ==AS PER
ORDER DATED 12TH JUNE 2018 AMENDMENT HAS BEEN CARRIED OUT ON 21/06/2018== ADDITIONAL
WRITTEN STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANTS DTD. 05/10/2018 FILED ON 05/10/2018 PAGES
195 TO 214. === COMPLIANCE AFFIDAVIT OF DEFENDANT NO. 02 DTD. 05/10/2018 FILED ON 05/10/2018
PAGES 215 TO 218. === AFFIDAVIT OF DOCUMENT DT.06/10/2018, FILED ON 06/10/2018, PAGES:1-8.===
COMPILATION OF DOCUMENTS (TRUE COPY- VOLUME I-IV) DT.06/10/2018, FILED ON 06/10/2018,
PAGES:1-839.=== AS PER ORDER DTD. 22/01/2019 AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT ON 01/02/2019 AND
CAUSE TITLE UPDATED IN CMIS == WRITTEN STATEMENT OF DEFE. NO 4A DT 02/03/2019 FILED ON
07/03/2018 PAGES 215-217 === WRITTEN STATEMENT ON BEHALF OF THE DEF NO. 4B AND 4C
DT.14/03/2019 PG NO.218-222 FILED ON DT.15/03/2019 === ISSUES FRAMED AS PER ORDER
DT.26/03/2019 PER G.S.PATEL,J== AS PER ORDER DTD.12/07/2019 AMENDMENT CARRIED OUT ON
24/07/2019 == AFFIDAVIT IN LIEU OF EVIDENCE FILED ON 10/10/2019 ==WRIT OF SUMMONS ISSUED ON
03/02/2020 == AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE DT. 10/2/2020 FILED ON 18/2/2020. {SAID AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
IS SERVED TO DEF NO 1(A). SAME SEND TO RECORD ON DATED 26/02/2020}==AS PER ORDER DT.
01/04/2021 BY S. C. GUPTE, J. WITNESS SUMMONS ISSUED ON 09/04/2021 TO MR. PINAKIN D. DESAI
102/C, AGARWAL MARKET, VILEPARLE E MUM-400057.==FRESH WITNESS SUMMONS ISSUED ON
12/10/2021
with
CC/11/2019 DR.D.H. DAVE AND 3 ORS. BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
[Orignal] VS BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
GOLD COIN BUILDERS PLAINTIFF NO.4(A)
In VISHAL S. SHRIYAN
COMS/129/2024 PLAINTIFF
MANDLIK AND PARTNERS
BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
Priyanka Bhatt
DEF.NO. 4 (A)
BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
DEF NO.4B AND 4 C
DEFE. NO 1(A)
BHAGWATI & CO [ 1,2,3,4 ]
WITH
CC/11/2019 DR.D.H. DAVE AND 3 ORS. BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
[Orignal] VS BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
GOLD COIN BUILDERS PLAINTIFF NO.4(A)
In VISHAL S. SHRIYAN
COMS/129/2024 PLAINTIFF
MANDLIK AND PARTNERS
18/03/2025 19:38:23 7/8
DAILY SUPPLEMENTARY CAUSELIST COURT NO 20-FOR WEDNESDAY THE 19TH MARCH 2025 BOMBAY HIGHCOURT - 8 -
BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
Priyanka Bhatt
DEF.NO. 4 (A)
BHAGWATI TRIVEDI
DEF NO.4B AND 4 C
DEFE. NO 1(A)
BHAGWATI & CO [ 1,2,3,4 ]
908 S/1/2025 KGN DEVELOPERS AMOL JOSHI
[Original] VS -
AAFIYAH REALTORS EVENTA ANDREA GONSALVES
Sanjay Udeshi and Co
Reyden Gonsalves
REMARK : Writ of summons issued on 13/01/2025=
with
IA(L)/37505/2024 KGN DEVELOPERS AMOL JOSHI
[Original] VS
AAFIYAH REALTORS
In
S/1/2025
REMARK: == PRAECIPE DTD. 03-01-2025 ==
909 TP(L)/5462/2025 PRAJAKTA SANJAY PARUI SHAH VIPUL JINENDRA
[Original] VS
(AMH20220000962C20250 SHANTI VENKATDAS SHANBHAG
0003) (ALIAS SHANTI SHANBHAG)
INTERIM APPLICATION
910 IA(L)/22403/2024 NARESH CHANDAN Rajiv Hingu
[Original] VS Rajiv Hingu
(ECHCBM02141622024) SRI HARSH DEVELOPERS DUBEY DHANANJAY VIDYADHAR
DUBEY DHANANJAY VIDYADHAR
Dhananjay Dubey
Hedgehog and Fox LLP
18/03/2025 19:38:23 8/8
