New Steel Construction
New Steel Construction
com
January 2016
Retaining Leicester Square
Vol 24 No 1
Cover Image
International Bomber Command
Centre, Lincoln
Main client: International Bomber
Command Centre Trust
Architect: Place Architecture
Main contractor: Lindum Construction
Structural engineer:
Alan Wood and Partners
Steelwork contractor: S H Structures
5 Editor’s comment The UK’s constructional steelwork supply chain will remain robust and well able to
provide the world leading service that it is recognised for in 2016 and beyond says Editor Nick Barrett.
6 News Two new steel bridge design guides and a web-based frame stability tool are now available.
10 Art A 31m-high weathering steel spire is the centrepiece at the International Bomber Command
Centre.
12 Heathcare Structural steelwork takes on a vital role as Liverpool’s largest hospital undergoes a multi-
million pound rebuild.
14 Education A steel-framed vocational college campus is rapidly taking shape in Sunderland city centre.
18 Mixed-use Within a large retained façade, a new steel-framed development will overlook London’s
world-famous Leicester Square.
22 Commercial Large cantilevering elements dominate the City of London’s latest high-rise commercial
scheme.
24 Technical Mark Lawson of the SCI discusses some of the recent research and developments in
modular construction.
28 Advisory Desk AD 393 – Minimum requirements for column splices in accordance with Eurocodes.
30 50 Years Ago Our look back through the pages of Building with Steel features steel-framed domestic
dwellings.
32 BCSA Members
NSC
January 16 3
Comment
Design guidance
tradition strengthened
At the start of last year the steel construction sector was confidently reporting to clients that
there was plenty of capacity in the sector to ensure that expected demand increases during
2015 would be easily accommodated. That confidence was proven to be well founded as
despite tales of shortages of labour and materials affecting other sectors, steel construction
prices rose modestly and there were no stresses evident along the supply chain.
Later in the year the BCSA reassured clients that the steel construction supply chain remains
strong and efficient despite the problems assailing makers of raw / rolled steel.
Full support was pledged to steelmakers in their bid to combat any dumping of raw / rolled
Nick Barrett - Editor steel into the UK market and to convince government of the need for level playing fields in
energy prices and carbon related taxes. The UK government has given signs that it is listening
to the industry’s case for help, and some action has already been taken.
The outlook for 2016 is for further modest increases in the price of fabricated steelwork,
but nothing out of line with construction price inflation generally. Looking over the horizon to
2016, it is clear that the constructional steelwork supply chain will remain robust and well able
to provide the world-leading service that it is recognised for internationally.
While these are interesting times for steelmakers, for most of us it has been business as
usual, as we can see in this month’s News pages. Providing up-to-date design guidance has
been a key part of the steel sector’s support for engineers and architects for over 30 years, and
this tradition is strengthened by the latest design guidance that has just been released by the
Steel Construction Institute, with financial support from Tata Steel and the BCSA.
All bridge engineers will want to familiarise themselves with P185 – Guidance notes on
best practice in steel bridge construction (6th Issue) as they represent important updates
and align guidance with the latest UK and European standards. Although aimed at bridge
designers, many of the Notes offer general information that will be helpful to all designers of
structural steelwork
Also of interest to structural engineers is the new web-based design tool that evaluates
the frame stability of multi-storey builings in accordance with the Eurocodes – another useful
addition to the ever-growing suite of software available on www.steelconstruction.info
Both represent the sort of support that designers need to have at their fingertips in their
day-to-day to work, the state-of-the-art guidance that the steel sector has always been
committed to providing, and which continued uninterrupted through several recessions.
The forecast that can be confidently made at the start of 2016 is that this support will
continue to be developed.
NSC
January 16 5
News
NSC
6 January 16
News
Frame stability tool available online members, who have become the
newest recruits involved with
A new web-based frame stability tool single vertical bracing system, which is have two or more bracing systems. the company’s apprenticeship
that evaluates the stability of multi- assumed to be a vertical Pratt truss. “The single bracing system analysed in scheme. The latest intake takes
storey braced frames, in accordance Beam and column members may be the tool will therefore carry only part of the Metsec one-step closer to its
with BS EN 1993-1-1 is now available at: selected from the full range of UKB and UKC lateral load and part of the vertical load.” ambition of achieving a 20%
www.steelconstruction.info sections respectively, and bracing members Wind load is assumed to be distributed home-grown workforce by 2020.
The parameter αcr is determined may be circular or square hollow sections. uniformly over the full height of the bracing
using the combination of the Equivalent Abdul Malik of the Steel Construction and is converted into point loads applied Architect Renzo Piano and
Horizontal Forces (EHF) and wind loads Institute said: “The programme requires at the nodes. In complex buildings with developer Sellar Property Group
on the frame, in conjunction with the the user to provide the lateral and vertical bracing systems of differing stiffness, it will have unveiled plans for a steel-
vertical loads. loading associated with the bracing be necessary to determine the proportion of framed 65-storey, £1bn mixed-use
The calculations are performed for a system – generally any structure will load carried by each bracing system. scheme for Paddington, west
London. The scheme at 31 London
Street has already been dubbed
North Wales steelwork contractor continues to the ‘skinny Shard’, as the team
NSC
January 16 7
News
NSC
8 January 16
News
Diary
For SCI events contact Jane Burrell, tel: 01344 636500 email: education@steel-sci.com
Tuesday 19 January 2016 Tuesday 9 February 2016 Wednesday 10 February 2016 Wednesday 24 February 2016
Steel Connection Design Simple Beam & Column Simple Beam & Column Portal Frame Design
This course is for designers Design to EC3 Design to EC3 This course provide in-depth
and technicians wanting NEW – Four hour course NEW – see previous entry for coverage of the major issues
practical tuition in steel containing minimum theory description. surrounding the analysis,
connection design. and maximum hands-on Sheffield. design and detailing of portal
Swindon. member design – focussing frames.
Tuesday 23 February 2016
on practical design using the Leeds.
Tuesday 26 January 2016 Design of Portal Elements
Blue Book. The course is
Moment Connections 1 hour lunchtime webinar free Tuesday 8 March 2016
aimed at designers of
1 hour lunchtime webinar free to BCSA and SCI members, Essential Steelwork
orthodox structures where the
to BCSA and SCI members, considering design of portal Design - 2 days
resistance tables are the
offering an overview on elements. This course introduces the
preferred way of selecting
moment connections. Webinar. concepts and principles of
members.
Webinar. steel building design to EC3.
Leicester.
Birmingham.
NSC
January 16 9
Art
Inspiring
took place on 2 October
memorial
A 31m-high weathering steel spire forms the
centrepiece of a memorial to those who served
with Bomber Command.
A
total of 27 Bomber Command
bases were located in
Lincolnshire during the Second
World War, more than in any
other shire, and earning it the title of
‘Bomber County’.
The area’s flat topography has very few
obvious landmarks with the exception
of church spires and towers. To this end,
Lincoln Cathedral provided an important
marker for crews both leaving and
returning from missions.
With this in mind it is fitting that, in
recognition and remembrance of those that
served in the Royal Air Force during the
War, the International Bomber Command
Centre is being constructed on an
escarpment overlooking Lincoln.
Because of the hilltop location, the
principal element of the Centre – the
31m-high weathering steel Memorial Spire
- is visible for miles around and from many
sites within Lincoln itself.
Place Architecture won the design
competition for the Spire and Project
Architect Stephen Palmer says the brief was
for a contemporary memorial.
The steel structure is said to represent
wing fragments with its height being the
overall wingspan of a Lancaster Bomber
with its base, at 5m wide the same width as
a Lancaster’s wing.
“By using weathering steel we fulfilled
the brief, but we also created a multi-layered
sculpture that references flight, aircraft
manufacture and is also a nod to nearby
Lincoln Cathedral,” says Mr Palmer.
“Weathering steel also allowed us to
design a sculpture with an organic feel and
one that has a changing hue, which is ideal
for its countryside setting.”
The structure was fabricated and
installed by S H Structures from 32
weathering steel plates. Perforated panels,
again reflecting the engineering principles
used in airframe construction connect
the rolled external plates. Built in jigs to
maintain the shape during welding the
NSC
10 January 16
Art
NSC
January 16 11
Healthcare
C
urrently under construction, the the first phase of the redevelopment. The
new Royal Liverpool University new Acute Hospital building is being
Merseyside
emergency departments in the north west. structure, as plant enclosures, screens
Being built on land adjacent to the and one internal atrium are created using
existing hospital, this multi-million structural steelwork.
pound project is vital in regenerating and The largest steel element of phase
hospital
transforming an area that acts as a gateway one is the five-storey CSSB and its two
into Liverpool city centre. link bridges, a contract that has required
Overall the project has been divided Elland Steel Structures to fabricate, supply
into three phases; the first and current and erect more than 900t of structural
phase includes the building of a new Acute steelwork.
Structural steelwork is playing a Hospital building, a separate Clinical “Trust requirements had to be adhered
Services Support Building (CSSB) and two to when choosing which material to use,
crucial role in the redevelopment of link bridges, one spanning between the but after an appraisal steel was opted for on
the CSSB because of its speed and quality
one of the largest hospitals in the Acute and CSSB and the other linking the
CSSB to an existing multi-storey car park. of construction,” says Carillion Project
north of England. The new buildings are scheduled to be Manager Stuart Loftus.
complete by early 2017. Phase two will then The CSSB will accommodate storage
kick off with the hospital decamping its
Right: One of the services into the completed new structures,
20m-long service yard
girders allowing demolition of the existing 1960s
hospital to commence.
Far right: Level 5 steps Once demolition has been carried out,
back but could be
infilled in the future phase three will begin and this consists of
to create more usable constructing a large steel-framed public
space realm and car park (see box).
A hybrid design has been chosen for
NSC
12 January 16
Healthcare
FACT FILE
Royal Liverpool University Hospital
Main client: Royal Liverpool and Broadgreen
University Hospitals NHS Trust
Architect: NBBJ; HKS
Main contractor: Carillion
Structural engineer: TPS
Steelwork contractor: Elland Steel Structures
Steel tonnage: 1,770t
Phase three
O
nce the existing hospital has been The public realm on top of the podium will
demolished a steel-framed podium, be formed with a 700mm fill within which there
accommodating a ground level car park will be numerous plants and trees, many of
with a public realm above will occupy the which will be in large planters.
large cleared space. Paths, leading to and from the surrounding
Founded on pad foundations, the steel podium will buildings, will crisscross the realm and public
measure 110m-long × 90m-wide, with a series of 305 access will be via a flight of stairs. Because of
UC columns erected around a 7.5m × 7.8m grid pattern. the site’s sloping topography, the CSSB will
This column spacing, with a floor-to-ceiling height of overlook the realm and will be linked to it via a
4.5m is considered to be ideal and the most efficient for ramp.
the car park. Gardens will provide solitude and a relaxing
Spanning the columns, a series of 610 UBs environment, while a café situated in the
facilities for medical supplies, laboratories supporting precast planks will form the roof. middle of the realm will offer drinks and snacks.
and offices. It is also the hub for many of the “The steelwork has been designed around the heavy Elland Steel Structures will erect
vital services that power the main hospital. loadings generated by the podium’s deep landscaping approximately 700t of galvanized steelwork for
Many of the power duct routes from the build-up,” explains TPS Structural Engineer Duncan Gray. this phase, with work due to begin in 2019.
onsite energy centre go into the CSSBs own
substation and then onwards into the Acute used to lift four 2m-deep girders, spanning
Hospital building. 20m and each weighing 17t, that form the
The CSSB has a footprint measuring yard’s open plan space.
60m × 40m and the steelwork has ben A series of 10m-high, 559mm diameter
erected around a regular 9.9m × 6.6m CHS sections, with 25mm thick walls,
grid pattern. support the girders. Once each CHS section
Two structural steel masonry lined was installed, Carillion had to concrete
cores provide the majority of the steelwork’s fill each member to add to the overall
stability, along with bracing. The main robustness of the column supports.
core was installed as part of the first steel Level two of the CSSB wraps around the
erection phase, as this then provided the loading yard, and so the first floorplate to
steel erectors with sufficient temporary cover the entire footprint is level three.
stability which all other areas of the This floor accommodates laboratories and
structure could be erected from. Five the connections to the two link bridges
phases, working to the full height of the
building were needed to complete the
(see box).
Level four is more or less identical to Link Bridges
structure. level three, while five steps back and only Connecting the CSSB to the Acute Hospital is a 42.7m-long
A large part of the ground floor of the occupies half of the CSSB’s footprint. x 5.7m wide steel link bridge. The structure is supported by
CSSB incorporates a double height service “We’ve added some flexibility into the a single 10m-high V-shaped column, positioned slightly of-
yard. This part of the erection programme structure as extra steelwork could be added centre due to a service road that runs beneath the bridge.
involved the project’s heaviest steel in the future to complete level five if the The steelwork for this bridge was brought to site in
members. hospital wants to expand the building,” says individual sections, which were then assembled on site using
Elland Steel Structures used a variety Mr Loftus. temporary support frames to minimize crane requirements.
of different mobile cranes for the job. The The entire project (including phase Also on level three, linking the CSSB to the adjacent multi-
biggest capacity crane was a 100t unit three) is due to be complete by 2020. storey car park, is another 21m-long bridge.
NSC
January 16 13
Education
Steel passes
college test The second of
the two teaching
wings is erected
and a car repair service, all of which will be Stone walls, polished blockwork and
A steel-framed college campus forms accessible to the public. metal cladding will give the Campus a
Principal at Sunderland College Anne modern exterior, while to utilise the plot
a major element of Sunderland city Isherwood says: “The City Campus has been a steel-framed structure incorporating a
centre’s regeneration. Martin Cooper designed to combine industry-standard 120m-long retaining wall was chosen as the
facilities and outstanding teaching for our best design choice.
reports. vocational and apprenticeship students, The retaining wall allows the steel-
and will equip them with the skills and framed structure to adapt to the site’s tricky
A
multi-million pound steel- practical experience they need for their topography and thereby include a
FACT FILE
Sunderland College, framed vocational campus future careers. basement level along the entire south facing
Holmside Vocational is being built in the heart of “As well as providing a wide range of classroom block.
Campus Sunderland to accommodate up professional and technical courses, it will “A steel-framed solution was selected for
Main client: to 2,000 students and more than 120 staff. also be home to the college’s commercial a number of reasons such as programme
Sunderland College Covering 12,500m2, the state-of-the- ventures and we are looking forward and cost. However the main driver was the
Architect: art City Campus will house vocational to welcoming members of the public to flexibility that this provided for services
Red Box Design courses, transferred from the nearby Hylton these facilities. We are confident that our distribution and for modification in
Main contractor:
Campus, including advanced engineering, flagship campus will enhance the vibrancy the future. Many of the classrooms and
BAM Construction NOTES:
manufacturing, construction trades, of the city centre and will be of benefit to workshops are heavily serviced and these
1) UNDER NO CIR
SCALED FROM
automotive trades, travel and tourism, and Sunderland for many years to come.” require extensive ductwork for specialist
BROUGHT TO T
4) THIS DRAWING
catering and hospitality. In order to achieve these aims, the Campus equipment. If the location of these changed
ARCHITECTUR
Brinckerhoff
REPRODUCED
WRITTEN PERM
Rev Description
Steelwork contractor: The well-equipped campus will also building’s design not only had to stand in the future, openings in floors and walls
1 Updated as
Review & Cl
document
2 Updated as
Review & Cl
feature hair, beauty and barbering facilities; out within its urban surroundings but also
3 Issued for R
Walling Pac
4 General upd
GA's to date
[Engineers]
5 Updated to r
a spa; a bakery; a travel agency; restaurant maximise the space within its confined plot. a steel-frame than a concrete structure,” 16
1:50 elevatio
NSC
14 January 16
CO
Education
R
ailway lines along one elevation and a city centre pedestrianized “However due to some design changes, we’ve had to sequence the
zone along another mean there is only one access route into the site erection programme and erect the furthest point of the structure last. We
for all materials. then bring our cranes out via the central courtyard before finally erecting a
On a tight and confined site such as this, logistics are a key factor in footbridge that links to the two teaching wings.”
successfully completing a project and Sunderland College is no exception. With little or no room for materials to be stored on site, especially
“Ideally we would have started the steel erection at the farthest end towards the end of the steel erection programme, steelwork contractor
from the site’s entry point, which is the entrance block, and worked our way Harry Marsh [Engineers] has delivered steel to site in 20t loads, which were
out,” says BAM Project Manager Jason Kelly. generally erected in one day.
NSC
16 January 16
Mixed-use
Steel construction
gets the red carpet
One of Europe’s largest retained façades is being incorporated
into a new steel-framed mixed-use development on London’s
famous Leicester Square. Martin Cooper reports.
R
etaining London’s listed façades attaining this on a plot, which has a listed
has become a widespread feature of façade, is to demolish the buildings innards
construction projects in the capital while propping and retaining the perimeter
during the last decade. walls. A new modern structure can then be
Recent examples include Oxford Street’s built behind the walls and incorporate the
ongoing redevelopment which is largely historic or listed façade.
being carried out behind retained façades, One of Europe’s largest retained façades
while the busy thoroughfare of Kingsway and is currently being incorporated into the
the City’s Finsbury Circus have both seen redevelopment of LSQ London in central
major developments that have incorporated London.
retained elements. Formerly known as Communications
Whether projects involve partial or House this 1920s building, which overlooked
complete façade retentions, the importance one of London’s most famous squares,
of keeping these historic, and quite often was said to have many attractive features.
listed, street frontages is vital in maintaining However over the past 90 or so years it has
London’s traditional streetscape. been enlarged several times and had become
Developers and tenants alike want inefficient in terms of maximum utilisation
modern spacious offices and the best way of of space.
NSC
18 January 16
Mixed-use
Steel to steel
connections
The steel-framed façade at LSQ London
mostly dates from the 1920s and 1930s,
however some areas, were added during
the 1960s.
The steel columns are all encased in
Portland stone and consequently in good
condition. However, steelwork originating
from various decades required extensive
laboratory tests to determine its make-up
prior to making the welded connections
for new brackets.
“We’ve installed a total of 250 brackets
that connect the new steel-frame to the
retained façade’s steel-framed columns,”
explains Bourne Steel Divisional Manager
Kevin Springett.
“The lab tests allowed for a trouble-
free onsite welding process and as we
were sure of the existing columns make-
up it meant works onsite ran smoothly
and efficiently,” adds Brookfield Multiplex
Project Director Asif Hashmi.
“Our brief was to create a high-spec office piled wall and the main central bearing FACT FILE
building and we felt that the goal was not piles. Then we excavated and enlarged the LSQ London
just to reimagine but reinvent, while also existing basement into a two-level deep Main client:
retaining the look and feel of the original facility, removing 13,000m3 of overburden in Linseed Assets
building, which is liked and admired by so the process,” explains Brookfield Multiplex Architect: Make
many people,” says Make Lead Architect Project Director Asif Hashmi. Main contractor:
Frank Filskow. Once this preliminary work and Brookfield Multiplex
Construction Europe
“Our design makes the best of the existing construction of the two main raft slabs were
Structural engineer:
building by retaining the historic façades, completed, steelwork contractor Bourne
Waterman Structures
and sensitively restoring them to maintain Steel was able to begin erecting the new steel Steelwork contractor:
The new frame the integrity of the original architectural frame that begins at lower basement level.
rises up within the
Bourne Steel
retained façades features and details. “Getting the steel-frame erected and Steel tonnage: 2,000t
“The design of the building naturally subsequently tied into the existing façade is
Visualisation of leant itself to using steel for the primary vital, and it is one of the main drivers of the
the completed LSQ structural elements. The design of the new scheme,” adds Mr Hashmi.
London
steel structure introduced a new central core, “Once the frame connecting into the
and enabled clear, open-plan floorplates, retained façade was erected and the concrete
improving the office spaces within the floors cast, we were able to begin removing
building.” the extensive façade retention steelwork
Waterman Structures Director Jody that surrounds the site and start work on
Pearce agrees and says: “One of the key renovating the original stonework and
aspects of a façade retention scheme is installing new windows.”
the alignment of new floors with existing The new steel frame is structurally
window openings. We promoted the use of a independent and gains its stability from
steel frame as it offered the flexibility needed two steel braced cores. Once the temporary
to suit the various interfaces that occur with propping was removed the new steel frame
the existing façade.” supports and restrains the four retained
“By integrating the suspended services façades, and so before the propping could
within the structural downstand beam zone, be removed a large number of connecting
the depth of the floor zone against the façade brackets had to be installed [see box].
was minimised, thus assisting the alignment The project’s new steel frame forms two
of new floors with existing windows further.” basement levels and a ground floor, which
The project’s main contractor Brookfield will accommodate high-end retail outlets
Multiplex started on site during November and a main entrance lobby.
2014, by which time the demolition work Above the ground floor there are seven
had been completed leaving four propped floors of office accommodation, five of which
façades surrounding a cleared site. are incorporated into the retained façade.
“Our first task was to construct a secant An elegant new curved roof will enclose
NSC
January 16 19
Mixed-use
the two uppermost floors, offering a unique box sections measuring 650mm × 450mm in turn supports a lightweight aluminium
21st Century interpretation of the traditional with a 25mm thickness. The sections were frame and glazing.
London mansard style. brought to site in 3.5m-long sections each This new and elegant curved mansard
The steelwork has been erected around a weighing 3t. roof encloses the building and offers a
regular grid pattern with internal office spans “The box section ring beam performs modern interpretation of the traditional
of up to 15m. Cellular beams have been two functions,” says Bourne Steel Divisional mansard style where arch geometry sits atop
utilised throughout for service integration Manager Kevin Springett. “The columns for a classical base.
and to minimise the structural void the feature roof are supported by the beam as “This respectful, contemporary addition
between floors. these are not aligned with the main columns to the building composition reduces the
The new fifth floor will be clad with for the rest of the building, and the stone existing top-heavy visual mass. The curve
Portland stone to integrate with the retained cladding for the sixth floor is also hung from also seeks to ensure the building blends in
façade below. This floor level’s steelwork is the beam.” seamlessly with the surrounding buildings of
topped with a ring beam that goes around The steel feature roof slopes outwards Leicester Square,” sums up Mr Filskow.
the entire perimeter of the building. from the two centrally positioned cores and LSQ London is scheduled for completion
The ring beam is formed from jumbo is formed with a cranked steel frame, which in the third quarter of 2016.
T
he façade retention at 48 Leicester procedure is appropriate and can be used with necessary to make special arrangements for site
Square demonstrates that when confidence. welding. Safe access is an obvious issue, but it
properly thought through, site welding The site welding must follow, in every may also be necessary to provide protection
is an entirely appropriate technique aspect, the parameters, consumables, welding from the weather.
– and also demonstrates the adaptability of position etc. that were proved by the welding Non-destructive testing should follow
steelwork structures. Site welding is sometimes procedure specification. Welding must only be the completion of the welding as the final
thought of as slightly suspicious, but this carried out by properly qualified personnel – for operation to assure the quality of the welding.
notion is misguided – the proposition should the welding process, material, joint type and The National Structural Steelwork Specification
be that with proper consideration, site welding welding position. In some circumstances it is is recommended as the default acceptance
has the same high quality results as welding in criteria for both shop and site welding.
the workshop. In other parts of the world, site Although site welding to existing steelwork
welding is very common. may not be common, it can be completed
When welding existing material, the original safely and with confidence in the final result.
material must be investigated and tested. For For designers, there is a range of support
this project, the original dates of around 1920 resources that cover material and section sizes
makes it very likely that the material was steel likely to be found in existing buildings, with
– slightly older and there would be a possibility guidance on the design assumptions at the
that the beams were of wrought iron rather time that may assist in any assessment of the
than steel. The key to successful welding (there existing structure. Specific guidance is available
being no difference between shop and site) is covering site welding.
to demonstrate that a successful test weld can
be produced in circumstances that very closely Resources:
reflect the ‘final’ weld. A preliminary welding • Historical Structural Steelwork Handbook,
procedure specification will be developed, BCSA
fully describing the material, all the electrical • Appraisal of Existing Iron and Steel
parameters, the consumables, the joint type Structures, SCI
and welding orientation. The material used • Guide to Site Welding, SCI
in the test should be that encountered in the • Typical Welding Procedure Specifications for
real situation – in this case the steel from the Structural Steelwork, BCSA
façade. The test piece is subject to a number of • National Structural Steelwork Specification,
tests, which if successful, demonstrate that the (Fifth Edition, CE Marking Version), BCSA
NSC
20 January 16
Commercial
Storey-high trusses
support 2 London Wall
Place’s cantilever over
the adjacent road
L
ondon Wall Place will be a new
Cantilevering
destination in the City of London,
offering an acre of landscaped public
realm set between two landmark
office buildings with more than 46,000m2
of Grade A office space. The realm features
London Wall
remains from the Roman City Wall and a
Saxon church, surrounded by gardens, water
features and suspended walkways.
The project covers an area of more than
15,000m2, on a plot previously occupied by
Transfer structures supporting cantilevers abound on this City of numerous buildings including the 1960s
built 20-storey high St Alphage House.
London commercial development, reports Martin Cooper. Work started on site in 2013 with main
contractor Brookfield Multiplex demolishing
How the multiple all of the existing buildings, while protecting
cantilevers will look on the historic structures, and then enlarging
1 London Wall Place
the site’s existing basement to create a two-
level deep zone.
A portion of the high-level pedestrian
walkways, known as the Barbican and City
Highwalks, originally crossed the site and
were removed as part of the demolition
programme. These will be reinstated with
a series of new weathering steel bridge-like
walkways as part of the overall scheme
(see box).
Both buildings, to be called 1 and
2 London Wall Place are steel-framed
structures rising to 12 and 16 storeys
respectively. Structurally independent
they will however be linked by one of
the weathering steel walkways that will
eventually span the centrally positioned
public realm.
NSC
22 January 16
Commercial
NSC
January 16 23
Technical
Modular construction has established itself in the UK for medium vertical loads. A configuration of modules using this principle
and high-rise residential buildings, such as student residences is illustrated in Figure 2 in which 8 apartments comprising 16
and hotels, in which there is often need to provide open plan modules are placed around the core. Access to each apartment is
space at the ground floor level and for basement car parking. The provided from the central core.
structural system generally adopted is to support the modules on
a steel-framed podium or transfer structure in which the beams
align with the load-bearing walls of the modules and columns
are placed at multiples of the module width. This article reviews
some of the design considerations in planning modular buildings
when supported by a steel framework and is based on the results
of a recent research project called MODCONS, which was carried
out with support from the European Commission.
Planning guidelines
The following information may be useful in planning a modular
project supported by a steel-framed structure:
NSC
24 January 16
Technical
(a) Deflection (exaggerated) of steel frame supporting modules (b) Deflection when internal column is removed to simulate robustness
should be agreed at the planning stage as they will • A characteristic line load of 15 kN/m per module wall and
influence the optimum design solution. per storey may be used for scheme design to determine the
• For internal planning purposes in residential buildings, an loads acting on the beams at the podium level.
internal module width of 3.3m to 3.9m is efficient. Openings • Columns should be placed at typically twice the module
in the side walls of modules can be introduced, depending width along the building façade. A spacing of 7.5m to 8.0m
on the loads that are transferred. would provide for 3 car park spaces below.
• A combined wall width of 300mm and a combined floor • Beam spans equal to the room length plus the corridor
and ceiling depth of 450mm should be allowed for in the width will usually be most efficient (typically 7.5m to 10m
planning of modular systems although these dimensions span).
may reduce for some modular systems. • The modules will also act to stiffen the beams and so the
• A rigid welded frame often using RHS sections can be actual deflection response will be 20% to 30% less than
introduced at the ends of the modules if a fully glazed for the beams acting alone. The deflection of the beams
façade or large patio doors are required. These RHS under the weight of the modules and imposed loads should
members can also be used to provide support to balconies. be limited to span/360 but not exceeding 30mm to avoid
• Installation rates of 6 to 8 modules per day may be used damage to the finishes to the modules.
in planning, although times of working, bad weather and • The vertical services within the modules are often
winter working will influence this rate. distributed horizontally at the podium level through web
• Beams at the transfer level should support a composite floor openings in the beams. A separate service zone may be
slab (also needed for diaphragm action) and should align required above the podium level in cases of mixed tenure,
with the load bearing walls of the modules. such as housing above a supermarket.
NSC
26 January 16
Technical
Figure 4:
Completed modular
hotel on Lavington
Street, Southwark
showing the use
of a first floor steel
podium structure
Case example From a sustainability view point the impact of the construction
A good example of this form of construction is a hotel near the operation on noise and local traffic was much reduced as modules
busy Southwark Street on London’s south bank which consists were delivered ‘just in time’ for lifting directly from the lorry into
of 192 rooms and corridors integrated within the Futureform position. The number of workers on site was reduced to one third
modules of 15m length. The completed hotel is shown in Figure 4. of those required in more traditional concrete frame construction.
The modules are supported by a single storey steel frame with the SCI also carried out an embodied carbon study of the modular
hotel reception and restaurant at ground floor. system and found it had 20% less embodied carbon than a
A fully glazed façade wall was created by a welded frame using concrete frame with blockwork infill walls.
80 x 40 RHS sections. This rigid frame provides resistance to
horizontal loads acting on the five-storey assembly of modules,
and also provides the attachment points between the modules. Acknowledgements
Modules were lifted into place at an average rate of 6 per day by a The information presented in this article is only a small part of the work undertaken
500T mobile crane with a long boom positioned on the roadside during the MODCONS project. The project was funded under the European Commission
at Lavington Street. The installation of the modules took only Framework Programme 7 (FP7) for support to SMEs and was coordinated by SCI. The
5 weeks out of a nine-month construction programme, saving other partners in the project were Futureform Ltd, HTA Design (both UK), Tecnalia,
an estimated 6 months relative to more traditional concrete- AST and IA3 (all Spain), University of Coimbra and Cool Haven (Portugal), NEAPO and
framed construction. This led to estimated savings of 1% of the Technical University of Tampere (Finland). Further information about the project is
construction cost per month for the hotel operator. provided at www.modcons-research.eu.
NSC
January 16 27
Advisory Desk
AD 393:
Minimum requirements for column splices
in accordance with Eurocodes.
Clause 6.2.7.1(14) of BS EN 1993-1-8:2005 specifies minimum • To provide a connection capable of carrying the design forces.
requirements for component in bearing type splices. The Standard The design forces should include the second order effects
specifies splice material to be provided to transmit at least 25% of described in Advisory Desk notes 243, 244 and 314;
the maximum compressive force in the column. This requirement • To ensure the members are held accurately in position relative
can be satisfied relatively easily in medium rise structures. For very to each other;
large structures, accumulating load from a number of storeys, the • To provide a degree of continuity of stiffness about both axes;
compression in the column can be very significant, resulting in • To provide sufficient strength and stiffness to hold the upper
large and expensive splice details. column shaft during erection;
It is understood that the requirements in the Eurocode are • To provide resistance in tension, if the structure is to be
to provide a degree of continuity of stiffness about both axes. designed for vertical tying.
Previously, UK designers would have observed the recommended
detailing practice in the Green Books, where minimum As many designers will be aware, the Eurocodes are to be revised;
component sizes were specified to achieve this continuity of this clause, and 6.2.7.1(13) covering non-bearing splices, have
stiffness. been proposed for revision. Unfortunately, any revisions are some
SCI recommend that if the Eurocode rules lead to splices years away, so to wait for the revised Standard is not a solution.
which are significantly larger than previous practice, the issue
should be discussed between the connection designer and the
Engineer with responsibility for the overall design. It may be that Contact: Abdul Malik
agreement can be reached to detail the splices in a way which Tel: 01344 636525
meets the essential requirements, which are: Email: advisory@steel-sci.com
*
SUBSCRIBE TO THE FREE
PRINT EDITION OF NSC
Existing Digital NSC Subscribers New NSC Subscribers
Visit www.steelconstruction.info Visit www.steelconstruction.info
Login using the normal ‘Login / create Click the ‘Login / create account’ button
account’ button in the top left corner in the top left corner
(If you don’t remember your password,
and get an error message, you can create Click the ‘Create an account’ blue link in
a temporary replacement by clicking on ‘E the Login box
mail new password’. The system will send Enter the required details to create an
By popular demand, NSC is being printed again. you a temporary password to the address account
* UK and Ireland addresses only
It’ll still be available online as a digital magazine at entered in the email box)
Ensure that the box to ‘Receive printed
www.newsteelconstruction.com with all the videos Once logged in you will be returned to NSC magazine’ is ticked
and multimedia links you’ve come to expect, but the site’s homepage. Go to the ‘Toolbox’
it is now accompanied by a printed edition once sidebar menu on the lower left hand side Click ‘Save’
again. Select ‘My Profile’ to edit your profile
Subscriptions are now available for free* online at Tick the box to ‘Receive printed NSC
www.steelconstruction.info - the same place the magazine’, and enter your address details
digital subscriptions are handled at.
Click ‘Save’
Here’s how to register for your copy.
NSC
28 January 16
New and revised codes & standards
From BSI Updates November and December 2015
NSC
30 January 16
50 Years Ago
wardrobes and storage shelves and with a high the external appearance. Some systems offer a
quality finish. choice of roof styles and other features giving
individuality to the houses and avoiding the
Steel-framed Houses ‘factory made’ look.
5M was the prototype design but in many later As a rule the steelwork is supplied to the site
systems frames are now all steel. The factory- suitable treated against corrosion. For instance,
made frames require no special skill to erect and in one system the parts are first degreased and
the structure is dimensionally accurate. then immersed on a red oxide/zinc chromate
Stress calculations can be made with accuracy paint and stoved. A second similar treatment is
and the greater strength of steel work has a given after fabrication into major components.
number of advantages, an important one being its The amount of steelwork naturally varies with
ability to withstand unequal ground subsidence. the design of the system but figures ranging up
Reduced fire hazard, freedom from distortion to two tons per house are typical.
with age and freedom from insect and fungoid Erection times vary according to the size
attack are other features. and design of the house but as a guide it may
In some cases the frames are supplied to site be mentioned that one firm claims that the
as completely rigid bolted or welded structures, complete structural cladding assembly for one
though the normal practice is to deliver as pair of their semi detached houses can be erected
separate components to be assembled on site: and temporarily waterproofed in 10 hours and
these are suitably marked to withstand unequal completed in 21 days at the most. Another states
ground subsidence. Reduced fire hazard, freedom that in 14 days six men can put up a pair of their
from distortion with age and freedom from insect semi-detached houses ready for occupation. A
and fungoid attack are other features. third firm claims that, on prepared foundations,
In some cases the frames are supplied to site the frame, walls and roof can be erected in one
as completely rigid bolted or welded structures, day by a team of six men and that the total
though the normal practice is to deliver as separate construction time per house can be as little as
components to be assembled on site: these are two weeks. Prices compare advantageously with
suitable marked to facilitate quick erection by the more orthodox type of dwelling.
unskilled labour. This makes unnecessary the To meet the rapidly increasing demand for
need for heavier cranes as two men can normally industrialised buildings a number of firms have
handle all items without difficulty. laid down production lines which in some cases
Columns and girders vary somewhat from are comparable in efficiency with those of the
company to company and in some cases are automobile industry. One organisation in the
of patented design. Considerable use is being north of England already has three such lines
made of square, rectangular and circular hollow capable of producing a total of 1,000 steel-
steel sections in the construction of frames and framed dwellings a year and by the end of the
for columns, floor beams, rafters, bracings and year will have in operation a new factory with an
certain architectural details. annual output of 6,000 of their ‘system’ buildings
In general the external walls are made as well as large quantities of components for the
up of panels of standard sizes, in many cases building industry in general.
steel framed. However, as will be evident from For general utility value and to supply a
the accompanying illustrations, many types gaping need this type of dwelling will be in great
of cladding are available. The modular sized demand. Constant care must be applied to ensure
windows are normally available in a variety of that good design is always in step with and even
designs, a feature which permits variation of ahead of utility.
NSC
January 16 31
Listings
Applicants may be registered in one or more Buildings category to undertake the fabrication and the responsibility for any Notes
design and erection of: (1) Contracts which are primarily
steelwork but which may include
C Heavy industrial platework for plant structures, bunkers, Q Specialist fabrication services (eg bending, cellular/ associated works. The steelwork contract
hoppers, silos etc castellated beams, plate girders) value for which a company is pre-qualified
D High rise buildings (offices etc over 15 storeys) R Refurbishment under the Scheme is intended to give
E Large span portals (over 30m) S Lighter fabrications including fire escapes, ladders and guidance on the size of steelwork contract
F Medium/small span portals (up to 30m) and low rise catwalks that can be undertaken; where a project
buildings (up to 4 storeys) lasts longer than a year, the value is the
G Medium rise buildings (from 5 to 15 storeys) FPC Factory Production Control certification to BS EN 1090-1 proportion of the steelwork contract to be
H Large span trusswork (over 20m) 1 – Execution Class 1 undertaken within a 12 month period.
J Tubular steelwork where tubular construction forms a major 2 – Execution Class 2
part of the structure 3 – Execution Class 3 Where an asterisk (*) appears against any
K Towers and masts 4 – Execution Class 4 company’s classification number, this indicates
L Architectural steelwork for staircases, balconies, canopies etc QM Quality management certification to ISO 9001 that the assets required for this classification
level are those of the parent company.
M Frames for machinery, supports for plant and conveyors SCM Steel Construction Sustainability Charter
N Large grandstands and stadia (over 5000 persons) (l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member)
NSC
32 January 16
Listings
Corporate Members
Corporate Members are clients, professional offices, educational establishments etc which support the development of national specifications,
quality, fabrication and erection techniques, overall industry efficiency and good practice.
NSC
January 16 33
Listings
Industry Members
Industry Members are those principal companies involved in the direct supply to all or some Steelwork Contractor Members of components,
materials or products. Industry member companies must have a registered office within the United Kingdom or Republic of Ireland.
1 Structural components 8 Steel stockholders CE CE Marking compliant, SCM Steel Construction Sustainability
2 Computer software 9 Structural fasteners where relevant: Charter
3 Design services M manufacturer l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member
4 Steel producers (products CE Marked)
5 Manufacturing equipment D/I distributor/importer
6 Protective systems (systems comply with the CPR)
7 Safety systems N/A CPR not applicable
Steelwork contractors
for bridgeworks
The Register of Qualified Steelwork Contractors Scheme for Bridgeworks (RQSC) is open to any Steelwork Contractor who
has a fabrication facility within the European Union.
Applicants may be registered in one or more category to undertake the fabrication and the responsibility for any design and erection of:
FG Footbridge and sign gantries AS Ancilliary structures in steel associated with bridges, Notes
PG Bridges made principally from plate girders footbridges or sign gantries (eg grillages, purpose-made (1) Contracts which are primarily steelwork but which
may include associated works. The steelwork contract
TW Bridges made principally from trusswork temporary works) value for which a company is pre-qualified under the
BA Bridges with stiffened complex platework QM Quality management certification to ISO 9001 Scheme is intended to give guidance on the size of
(eg in decks, box girders or arch boxes) steelwork contract that can be undertaken; where
CM Cable-supported bridges (eg cable-stayed or FPC Factory Production Control certification to BS EN 1090-1 a project lasts longer than a year, the value is the
suspension) and other major structures 1 – Execution Class 1 2 – Execution Class 2 proportion of the steelwork contract to be undertaken
(eg 100 metre span) 3 – Execution Class 3 4 – Execution Class 4 within a 12 month period.
Where an asterisk (*) appears against any company’s classification
MB Moving bridges SCM Steel Construction Sustainability Charter number, this indicates that the assets required for this classification
RF Bridge refurbishment (l = Gold, l = Silver, l = Member) level are those of the parent company.
NSC
34 January 16
Listings
NSC
January 16 35