0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 41 views 7 pages Simultaneous Elections
The document discusses the concept of simultaneous elections in India, proposing that Lok Sabha and state assembly elections be held together every five years to enhance efficiency and reduce costs. It outlines the historical context of elections, the advantages of simultaneous elections, and the potential challenges and criticisms associated with this idea. The document also mentions various political figures and commissions that have advocated for this approach over the years.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Go to previous items Go to next items
Save Simultaneous Elections For Later Pe Ye
TE © stanton wee M se
we CONES * 4 Inb ND”
= Ss 2 one nation — one election” Slogon spk fonoand by
ese cea ting panty supped
eC
+E posed 4 NiTl Ange reper on simubkaneou® cho
Me a we Rasen seehe a[A— veffered 0 Le fev prathicallt
ee
podem
An election is _& formal _greuP deuision-
tpcal bodied out{ dieurien
gabe suite making pmecess by which _o Pe
Bs ce individual to held public of fece- Elections heave
ay d
RE WHE the. usual meconism bY modem ceprcseentie
co
on
democracy has operated the centuadty. Mg
ee also used
3 to Fal
pulatibn chooses a0
been
which
gince
legislative bedion BAF
corporedone
go
rot “only use
in business ovganizakions , clubs ond.
History of Elechions &
HS ee
wene Used 69 early in history
Elections
sn vedic, poust
ancent Romans ord ancient Greek *
fF co gora (tribal organization
gona: Even dining Songer
by carting their
tied to
cs)
of Indio , The Roja o} acer
appenently elecked by the,
people elected their
pores (usually a pet) See
age representative
votes and the ballot
a sope and sealed:
The modern * eleckian” which consists of
public electors of gr offirials , didnt emoge unt
: be beginning of wath centuory with the ideo of
_ Nepaes entahive gove kook hell in orth Ameduica and BPE”
5 :
edd yal the Furst Ualeckion in gribieh, Tnclia 0%
in 1920 _ bo elect members to Imporial legédoi”
oer: . . council & poseeee
ro :
© scanned with OKEN Scanneree i
Concept of Sirultaneour electtons -
Ne a
India has Steyr governance suystery =!
Palimene ak cenbial level, stake ascemblice ab stale lest
and local bodied oF Village] muncipabity level Al The above
3-Her govl's have dived election mostly fer eudty 5yeo%:
Idea now in discussion as conducking, simubkaneo
lectins 10 Loxgabha and -stabe legislate aonemblieds
Simultaneously once in a. Five yous: Local bodies
At present elections t LS & SLAs are
Not _being held Girmubtaneourly + sometiones elechon» to
Sore SLAs ray happen together with_election» fo Ls
For example in 301q, elections 40 sts of Ap, AYP,
odisha and cikKim were held sirmubtanessdly ails
Ls enero eleckion »
Idea of Simalkoneous Elechons
Iden Of, Ss oe
Bey Or aa Ge
ow
oo India: In (ASl-32> (sk general elechony to LS Was
‘
a’ 7 . * ‘
woe simudtaneoo wih all state aueribhien THES gallie &
practise of SE Continued EI the genera elector Be 6
of. 14640 Ke
6 ote ne 06
this prachse got SSMPEE
On premature _dissdukion oF
we premature dis :
agserblich in 1465- Lok sabha
vee Prema in [atoe AS o ‘vesulk eleckins 10
whats and slis we being held coperakely snd bsesla
eletedtions lost Sync in due
© scanned with OKEN Scannery eit ' a The idea of SE was floated long bak
mer tlepuky © prime Thi Jindse
ime Tninister of Indio ond. vena
Be
olitici ‘i
Politician LK Advani» In 1999 bare commiggion al$0
on SE- In 2012 also LK Adwani
disused the dea Mh
veceptive OS
or yenssr
orn susrsere fe is wes
be weet Te in his blog thak he
° er: =
n personne, pin ¢ president uk Hey bol one a
mittee
pablic grievances, %
per LK Advani+ Later in 2015 standing OM
~ Recently FM
Laws sushce
2 on Law also gave epere_ On se
Feasibility oF foe pm _petenda rad, sted ma
holdevg SE to : 3
Lsgslas Robionale behind simubtanees? Elechons ‘-
pect semen pue to its vast size oF democrany , county |S
o\Q BY on continous _elecden mode in one stake ov another
® s which was causing poliany policy ponolysis
cons in every geo
jdea agin’
in I.
av gy 2'5=7 SLA ele
st
2 To save public mene and moachinaney— co!
life Fralse perpetuate
\
wi
, ; : waite
3. Frequent elechans dishwles Pe tl gion corn pal we
Advantages coh SE ay ee
1. cost _of_eleckion®
t& of elechers
cawed PY
will be decreated- Cost
2 ig Expenditwe im
(4 has two com ponent wom
fue Ire Ec! ard aE cxpeitae inqwmed bi polite partied
©) 28) e
7 2 A large number of geve employers ond public bob Bg?
Te- peRi : 5 nes
ie aye diverted Prom thet veg ufo vosponsibitie® for
ite " F h apes or
election dutted - SE yeduces & Sw uman :
dubied —
(C2Xb) ._ diverrion for election
2¢ ae Premature disgelutroy .
© scanned with OKEN Scanner|
+ Hodel code of ,
Model code of conduct (dec) pa
onduck (Yee) which comes into operation -
an obstecls 72°
ow
dosti X
ng election seaton is seen oS
Jolt sewice delivery mechanisine
he ‘ .
Dusting elechions, politicall convenience tones precedence
over public _inkereat- Te Ture wolers , poliftah
Concede to il
populon demands without ary ons
public interest. SE Yeducen such opportanity fy
posrede
5: SE promotes national pocspetve_over regione Fe
(hich is important. fer nity oF indiae
indirectly
6. cies Gel primes tenes rate
Veduted (us ee ee gd on naxre>
sigevatton 4
pastes:
Yeduces mushyeomi IEP polka peated _bese
Vore bank peli
Ayguments Again SEI
a a nrraaeas
incumed by Ect, bub Ihow is
expenditare
ital paxtr will reduce
1. SE may veduce
no quanantee thak expendi of pol
Q- centre and stake ove equal aod gcoveretgn
of Stale elechord
Furisdicion SE MAY yediund NOP eee
SLAs
within Thay
2. requires thal Ls]
date ¢ its Pes
os thee
pte
B under constitehan 63(2) § IF
be in existence for Syer® fron the
meeting" unless digsdved eatlir’ + SE
rpould be ne oppertunity f° gigobe Us|slas
h. sé will negleds “veg! -
@bich completely, ignored idea oF dwerbity of. Endine
5. SE will also face _logiehes challenge,
© scanned with OKEN Scanner
ignored thisand betere
cingegee
@
1. congtébuktonal chablenge — TT implement this jaca, tenure &
Gome clas needs to be cuntatled - heolts doit oben
of legidledone is ablg enallenge!
io the event of
ence vate iS abi
gar enjoys , confidence
2. How te presee Ihe simultone
vole of n° confidence oY presi
qpestion
whvle counhy
pogishicn challenge :
3. Even Foy conducting _& easel *
phare wise palling + now F fr +I
oe _ave bevy OO al
Toate @allenge-
TD qhele counhry —pese®
4. secutily challenge — paya. millitery & police
Ye als
“ensure — SoFe & gece alechioms 18
fetly oe ee en
Lei undey B:S: Choshan, yeleased
- a daft nepore 09
on Aug go, 208"
gj thak” §
may be conducted to isk s
Taal lessees aha |
© scanned with OKEN Scannereer Os
ahe .
MEommisgion vecommented
thvee abkennadived 0. synchronis
elections in Trdca + The “thee abternalive Ye bse!
' . y il i stakes’
1) advancing | postparing election Herings (9 TE 2oay.
Bold and 2021
Baie in syezrs
ieee eee
2) if state adsembly elechon ott bald in
the elechiond will only need to be conducted
eqao8t ar og ine ee
3) SEheatent falling under an calender your >
Se
commission alse eaggeted a change 40 “o-cnfce mehor
ete onghauchive vote of ne-—confdents’ throug’ emendent«
o
In a conshuchve vote of no confedence Ie govt a ly
i ce 1 it yr: Also
vernoved if Ihee 1° confidence alternative J ae
limit number of such moins Our g-
suggested ko time ng
term of House /nssembly
~ commiggion also suggétted * change He tom a
midterm of election in the events of Hang Fat
for yeraining poriad not for SyerS
conclusion i= ag per” IDRC _instiluke study i 215
‘ Dey :
at chances ore inere fey winning of coat a
jin: poxliment/SLA if se ome hebd- Keeping io ore
t ain)
Ire diversity oF tndia , Teo of SEM goo
i i i ie.
u of nation peink of vi ;
nity ee ane. nation -one pall” is geod
a é
for ndion polity but its feanility needs. 1
idea
ecg, ezine
in cetale @ daoasian! Tso cesived goal ee
only one election every "yeu Cera tes
overnight In. “the prevailing _ chron
ie be eaves See
Kypoglowerdi,
© scanned with OKEN Scanner
‘\Ran, ath Kovind Reps
* Bos consktukion -> to enable SE in be bills
A> SE fev LS & stale omemblivs , (re satieckion by stab)
Q-> Electiony to MP wilhin voodeups of se to LS &SLAS
G need stakes vation «
A 1S amendments fo Conshhution oF Indda
i} se"
82A > New onbdle —> new paiocens
83§ 12> $34) G1 204) - team unexpired
tom"
324A — emp palinent te ensue ™]p eachion
g nilh
LOSLAS
* Single chechrl roll § 1p — Ect
Sy chebes tebfcadan
" Ated
¥ prematune di clubion —3 testy of houde
¥ sinchwnischin of dlechon—> President St sittiy ks
Sy nchyonis of elle > eae
andd §28 > all SLA condudes with evpiy |
Ls pull Fade,
© scanned with OKEN Scanner