Article 297
Article 297
Indian Journal of Science and Technology, Vol 9(48), DOI: 10.17485/ijst/2016/v9i48/107324, December 2016 ISSN (Online) : 0974-5645
Abstract
Objectives: The Indian government’s ‘Make in India’ campaign and the accelerated growth in the economy has highlighted
the demand for skilled manpower in the country. The objective of this article to understand the current state of vocational
education and training and review the vocational training models of the emerging economies. Methods/Statistic Analysis:
The Skill development model of India is studied in detailed with reference to the ‘Make In India’ campaign. The vocational
training model of the China and Brazil is also reviewed for the study as they are a part of the BRICS countries and also the
emerging economies of the world. Singapore’s vocational education model is also studied to gain additional insights on
the skill development initiatives and policies. Findings: The “demographic dividend” explains for India being the youngest
workforce country in the world. The country will have the lowest median age much below that of China and Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Countries. It means that India can be the largest provider of workforce
to the world. But still, India has difficulty to fill up jobs due to a shortage of applicants with the right skills and knowledge.
It also brings out the difficulty the country faces with matching the jobs to the skills available. India is still behind countries
like China and Singapore in imparting skills. The paper aids in analyzing the current skill gaps in the country and the areas
where there is a huge scope of supply of skilled workforce. It aims to identify the challenges faced in development of skills
in the country and highlighting the employment opportunities arising in the different sectors with emphasis on the Make
in India campaign. Conclusion/Improvements: There is a huge scope of generating skilled workforce in the country and
utilize the ‘demographic dividend’. The branding activities and active involvement of Public Private Partnership ensure a
better supply of skilled workforce.
India, on the other hand will have a surplus of 56 mil- of skilled workforce. It aimed at establishing and lying
lion working people. India will be able to gain advantage down of consistent and common standards of teaching
of the increased working population if they able to equip and collaborating the efforts of the organization aiming at
its workforce with the appropriate skills. In this respect, development of skills2. It also focuses on bringing all the
skills development emerges as one of the most critical other ministries to come together and function in a uni-
aspect of India’s economic policies. fied manner towards skill development. It lays down the
objectives and the expected outcomes and also ascertains
the different institutions that will ensure that the expected
2. Objectives of the Study outcomes are achieved. The set-up of Skills Development
The skill development model forms the basis of the study. with major parties involved in appropriately designed. It
The objectives of the study are mentioned below: includes a lot of parties involved in the skill development
• To study the present system of regulation of in the country (Refer Figure 4). The Ministry works in
the Vocational Education, Training and Skill close collaboration with the National Skill Development
Development sector in India Corporation (NSDC). It helps training institutes map the
• To review the system adopted by countries like skill sets, involves in the market research and design the
China, Brazil and Singapore relevant curriculum. It aims at bridging the gap between
• To know the challenges with respect to the skill the skills demand and supply by boosting the skill devel-
development in India opment initiatives2.
• To assess the opportunities available for skill In India, the skill acquisition is by through two chan-
development in India nels which include both formal and informal methods.
Both the Public and Private Sector aims at imparting the
formal training. In addition to this, the government is also
3. Review of Literature looking at the Public and Private Partnership known as
In order to understand the Skill Development system, the the PPP model. The Industrial Training Institutes known
Skill Development Model of India has been studied. The as ITIs are run by government and is a major channel of
skill development model of China, Brazil and Singapore is gaining Vocational training in the country. Apart from
also studied in order to gain an international perspective this, there are privately run Industrial Training Centres
to skill development. China and Brazil have been chosen known as ITCs and vocational schools. In India, the
for the study as they are a part of BRICS countries and are Labour Laws also ensures that the students going for tech-
the emerging economies of the world like India. Singapore nical education are trained through the Apprenticeship
has been ranked as the 2nd highly skilled country of the training provided by the Industry. Though there is a lot of
world1 in the year 2015-16. So for understanding the participation from the private sector on skill development
model of a highly skilled country, Singapore’s Vocational but the public sector dominates the skill development
and Technical Education model is being studied. programs in the country. The informal channel is more
unstructured and can be imparted through working on
3.1 Skill Development System in India the job or through experiential learning.
The government of India designed a policy framework
India experiences a huge advantage by having a young which aimed at developing the skills in the country. The
workforce, which means it high scope of providing skill development eco system includes the Apprentices
manpower to the labour market. After assessing the Act, 1961, a formal way of skills acquisition. It also
high demand for the skilled workforce in the world, the includes, The National Skill Policy, which lays down the
Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship was policies and procedures for skill enhancement and the
formed. The ministry was announced in June 2014. The National Skills Qualification Framework (NSQF)3. The
Prime Minister of India, Shri Narendra Modi felt the need Apprentice Act, 1961 ensures that there is participation
to focus on skill development considering the changes from the Industry in the skill development of the students
happening in the labour market and hence the ministry undergoing a formal technical education. The Industry
was established. It focused on working in close collabo- professionals are well equipped to train the students on
ration with other ministries to meet the huge demand skill development. The Act aims at making it mandatory
2 Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Lavina Sharma and Asha Nagendra
for establishments in the private and the public sector completely heterogeneous in nature. The skill enlargement
to train the students. The Industry has to provide on in India is classified into two categories. They are Skill
the job training to the students hence giving them a real Education and Skill based Vocational Training. Figure
world exposure to skills and processes and making them 1 explains the varied structure of Skill Development in
employable in the labour market. India.
The National Policy on Skill Development was framed The Ministry of Human Resource Development gov-
in 2009 with an aim to strengthen the skill develop- erns the Educational and Vocational Training in India. It
ment initiatives of the country. It is a Public Private governs the elementary, secondary and higher education
Partnership model which falls under the Ministry of Skill in the country. The Universities and Higher education
Development and Entrepreneurship. It was established in centres focuses on the college education. The examples of
order to promote skill development by creating large and it are disciplines like Arts, Commerce and Science etc3.
exceptional quality vocational institution with the appro- The Technical education is provided through the engi-
priate training infrastructure. India has a lot of aspirants neering colleges and the polytechnic institutions. The
but it doesn’t have the required infrastructure to meet the functioning of both the education Universities and col-
requirements of vocational education and training and leges is regulated by the University Grants Commission
hence the government involved more of such partnership (UGC). They grant funds, ascertain and ensure com-
to ensure the model is successful in imparting the voca- mon standards are established for teaching, learning and
tional training. evaluation in the Universities. The technical institutes in
The National Skills Qualifications Framework (NSQF) India are regulated by the All India Council for Technical
was enacted on 27th December 2013. The framework in Education (AICTE)3.
built on the latest concept of competencies which analyses
the knowledge, skills and aptitude needed at each quali-
fication. The levels are graded from one to ten and are
defined in terms of learning outcomes for each level. It is
regardless of whether the skills are possessed through for-
mal, informal and non-formal learning. The framework is
based on competency modelling, which is considered to
be highly effective method of mapping the skills needed
for a particular role3.
Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 3
Skill Development in India: Challenges and Opportunities
focused to be developed through the PPP model. The also train themselves on vocational training through the
Skill Development Initiative (SDI) under the Ministry of three year participation in the vocational scheme edu-
Skill Development and Entrepreneurship focused on the cation (Refer Figure 2). The Industry input is ensured
increasing the number of Public Private Partnerships4. through the participation in the entire TVET system6.
The Scheme is a 5 years project scheme aiming at train- China being known for its manufacturing excellence
ing of one million persons. The scheme aims at providing in the world has to have a skilled workforce readily avail-
people with the skills to perform the job effectively. It able. In order to meet the increasing demand for skilled
not only focused on the existing employees and students, workforce in the country, they have a robust skill develop-
but also focused on providing skills to school leavers and ment model that has a support from the government too.
young graduates. The PPP model looked promising by China is governed by the Vocational Education Law of
generating a pool of skilled workforce thus reducing the 1996 which formulates the legal structure for the effective
supply and demand gap2. It aims to design and develop and proper functioning of the technical education and
syllabi for various levels and trades, development of rel- training system in the country8. It explains the functions
evant and interactive instructional material, training the and responsibilities of the Ministry of Human Resources
trainers, the staff and faculty and ensuring a collaborative and Social Security and Ministry of Education in the
environment for the training. vocational training. The law also discusses the roles and
responsibilities of the local government, industry/private
3.3 China’s Technical and Vocational participation and the vocational training institutes in skill
Education and Training System (TVET) development in the country. It reflects that the country is
highly focused on skill development and makes it com-
China has been a country which has a reasonably good
pulsory from the school level itself. The implementation
number of trained manpower. The TVET of China is a
of the law is dealt with utmost dedication so as to ensure
very broad and effective method of providing technical
the implementation of skill development in the country.
and vocational training to the people. The TVET of China
In China, the enterprises also support the skill devel-
is classified into two institutional setting. One of it focuses
opment to a great extent. The occupational standards are
on education in schools while the other aims at providing
clearly mentioned and there is a strong integration with
vocational training. The school education falls under the
the education and economy. The Law makes it obligatory
Ministry of Education (MOE) and whereas the vocational
for the industries to provide for compulsory skill training
training falls under the purview of Ministry of Human
and employment.
Resources and Social Security (MOHRSS)5. The curricu-
China ensures that there is optimum participation
lum of vocational training of the school is designed in line
from the Industry in vocational education and training.
with the theoretical concepts and knowledge of the dif-
The Vocational Education Law, 1996 ensured that it hap-
ferent theoretical frameworks for a particular trade. The
pens. Below are the Articles from the law which reflects
other section that falls under the MOHRSS focuses on
the Country’s focus on skill development through the
post-school and pre-employment training of people. Its
Industry participation9.
major emphasis is on practical and experiential learning “Article 20: Enterprises shall, in accordance with their
through workplace training initiatives and also training actual situation, provide vocational education in a planned
and re-training of school dropouts and unemployed peo- way for their staff, workers and persons to be employed.
ple. The vocational education forms an integral part of the Enterprises may jointly run or run on their own voca-
educational programs of China which mandates through tional schools and vocational training institutions; they
Education Law 1986 nine year of compulsory education may also entrust vocational schools or vocational training
including three year of vocational training6. The institu- institutions with the vocational education of their staff,
tional setting of vocational education broadly provides workers and persons to be employed by them9.
for pre-employment, post-school, and on-the-job-prac- Article 29: If any enterprise fails to conduct vocational
tical training besides training for school drop outs and education in accordance with Article 20 of this Law, the
a massive scale of vocational training for different levels local people’s government at the county level or above
of employees through Technical/Skilled Worker Schools. shall order it to make correction; if the enterprise refuses
Thus, even senior secondary vocational school students to make corrections, the vocational educational funds
4 Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Lavina Sharma and Asha Nagendra
that the enterprise should bear may be collected, and such sarily technical high school. Technological courses tend
funds shall be used for vocational education in the local- to last three years.
ity.”9 Brazil is also focused on creating skills at the school
level. They offer programme especially the Technical ones
which can be offered to the students from the same insti-
tute. Due to which, the number of students enrolling for
the program are high11. The Vocational Training Program
offered by them PRONATEC is focused to promote social
and productive inclusion. It has a heavy social policy
component, clearly stating as its goal “to promote training
opportunities to teenagers, workers and the beneficiaries
of the cash transfer programs.”10
Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 5
Skill Development in India: Challenges and Opportunities
6 Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology
Lavina Sharma and Asha Nagendra
Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology 7
Skill Development in India: Challenges and Opportunities
to reach a larger audience will make a difference in the 5. Vocational Education Law of the People’s Republic of
employment scenario of the country. India has a ‘demo- China. Available from: http://www.china.org.cn/english/
graphic dividend’ and it has to work toward making it education/184662.htm Date accessed: 14/10/16
useful for the country. It will not only add value to the 6. Kanth, A. K. Brief Note on Vocational / Educational Training
economy of the country but will be supporting the ‘Make in China. Availiable from: http://www.prayaschildren.org/
pdf/Attachmentbrief_note_about_the_vocational_techni-
in India’ campaign by providing the skilled workforce in
cal_education_in_china.pdf Date accessed: 14/10/16
the country. Like China, our vocational training programs
7. UNESCO TVET. Available from: http://www.sh-dz.net/
should be included at the school level itself. The Public what-is-tvet-unesco-unevoc.html Date accessed: 13/10/16
Private Partnership plays a key and an important role in 8. Santosh Mehrotra AG. Estimating the skill gap on a realis-
the development and enhancement of skills. NSDC has tic basis for 2022. Institute of Applied Manpower Research.
made some progress in improving the training infrastruc- 2013 Feb.
ture in the private sector by having more and more Public 9. Vocational Education Law of the People’s Republic of
Private Partnership. There has been a growth in such part- China. (n.d.). Available from: http://www.china.org.cn/
nership over a few years. Such partnerships are also being english/education/184662.htm Date accessed: 14/10/16
encouraged in rural areas which consist of a considerable 10. Souza AP, Lima L, Arbage A et al. Vocational Education
high number of aspirants. It becomes extremely impor- and Training in Brazil, Knowledge sharing forum on devel-
tant to strengthen the tie-ups with the training institutes opment experiences:Comparative Experiences of Korea
and Latin America and Caribbean. 2015 Jun.
to ensure that the quality is maintained and the model
11. Jaganatthan S. Skill Development: Promises, Approaches
is sustainable too. Since, there will be a huge demand in
in Developed Countires and Emergining Economies, ADB
the Retail and the Hospitality Sector so the government
Briefs. 2013 Nov; (19):1–8
needs to focus on the non-technical skills too. The Skilled 12. Kuruvilla S, Erickson C, Hwang A. An assessment of
India initiatives need to focus and develop more entrepre- Singapore Skills Development System: Does it consti-
neurship skills amongst the workforce in order to ensure tute a viable model for other developing nations? Cornell
more job generation in the country. The Startup India and Univeristy; ILR School. 2001 May. Available from: http://
Stand up India schemes need to be advertised well in the digitalcommons.ilr.cornell.edu/articles/214 Date accessed:
market in order to have more people taking advantage of 15/10/16
such a model. The NSDC should also focus on the unor- 13. ICRA Management Consulting Services Limited.The
ganized sector in order to make the Skill India campaign Skill Development Landscape in India and Implementing
a successful model. Hence, the Make in India campaign Quality Skills Training; 3rd Global Skill Summit of the
will be successful from skill point of view and India will Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce & Industry
(FICCI). 2010 Aug.
achieve its mission of “Koushal Bharat, Kushal Bharat”.
14. FCCI and KPMG Report;Skilling India a look back at the
progress, challenges and the way forward. Available from:
7. References https://www.kpmg.com/IN/en/.../FICCI-KPMG-Global-
Skills-Report-low.pdf Date accessed: 19/10/16
1. The World’s Top Countries for high- skilled employ- 15. Wheelbox. India Skills Report. 2016. Available from:
ment. (n.d.). Available from: http://www.forbes.com/sites/ https://wheebox.com/logo/ISR-2016-small.pdf Date
niallmccarthy/2015/06/01/the-worlds-top-countries-for- accessed: 16/10/16
high-skilled-employment-infographic/#796c442d31b0. 16. Patil A. Skill Development in India: Challenges and
Date accessed: 19/10/16 Strategies, ISAS Working Paper. 2009 Sep.
2. Ministry of Skill Development and Entrepreneurship. 17. Young E. Knowledge paper on skill development in India:
(n.d.). Available from: http://www.skilldevelopment.gov.in/ Learner first. Available from: http://www.ey.com/in/en/
nationalskilldevelopmentcorporation.html Date accessed: industries/india-sectors/education/knowledge-paper-on-
10/10/16 skill-development-in-india---where-are-we-on-skills Date
3. National Skill Development Corporation. Available from: accessed: 17/10/16
http://www.nsdcindia.org/Date accessed: 10/10/16 18. Santosh Mehrotra KD. Understanding Skill Development
4. Planning Commission, XII Five Year Plan, Employment and Training in China: Lessons for India, Institute of
and Skill Development. Applied Manpower Research. 2013 Dec.
8 Vol 9 (48) | December 2016 | www.indjst.org Indian Journal of Science and Technology