Unit 5
Unit 5
Module 5 Expressive
within a group context can involve connecting group members with each other through group
projects and/ or through the sharing of art products made during the session.
Universality
Groups offer the opportunity for participants to learn that others have similar problems, worries,
and fears and that people’s experiences are more similar than different. While experiences may
be universal, images people create also may carry universal meaning, but in a personal or unique
way. Sharing common symbols and/or experiences is an important function of an art therapy
group and helps to reduce isolation through communication and exchange of mutual concerns.
Altruism
Group therapy emphasizes helping one another through difficult times. This sense of altruism
can be a healing factor both for the person who gives help as well as for the person who receives
the help. Art therapy groups reinforce positive support and exchange between group members by
offering creative activities through which people can interact in positive and helpful ways.
   •   These “curative” characteristics apply to most group art therapy and a therapist may
       capitalize on any or all of these healing potentials found in group work through art
       experientials.
   •   In some art therapy groups the therapist takes an active role in determining themes and
       directives for the group, designing group art activities with particular goals in mind and
       based on what the therapist has observed about the participants. The group may also be
       asked to identify problems or themes which they would like to explore through art.
reveal their difficulties through their here-and-now behavior, the “here and now” being where the
therapy takes place. Disclosure may take place, possibly of “secrets” or significant events from
the past and present outside the group, and this may be important in understanding the behavior
of that individual in the group. The act of disclosing (and this may happen indirectly through
image making) often releases tension and enables defenses to be lowered and relinquished.
Feedback from members of the group and the therapist, illuminating aspects of the self which
have become obvious to others, but which are not recognized by oneself, is essential. To be
effective it must be well timed and delivered with sensitivity. In this respect the therapist is an
important role model, demonstrating a positive critical approach as opposed to a negative and
judgmental one, observing and commenting on behavior and images and their effects on the
process of the group.
There are some fundamental processes of an interactive group that are often enhanced by the
addition of image making. These include projection, mirroring, scapegoating, parataxic
distortion, and projective identification. Projection involves group members having feelings and
making assumptions about other members which are not based on their here-and-now
experience. For example, one member might experience another as his critical mother and make
assumptions about that person’s feelings toward him. Mirroring entails a member having strong
feelings and emotions about another’s behavior, which is in fact an aspect of the member’s
behavior.
Projection and mirroring are often accompanied by splitting—by experiencing a group member,
the facilitator, or the whole group as all good or all bad. Scapegoating occurs when the group
tries to put all its difficulties onto one member and to get rid of them. The members’ tendency to
distort their perceptions of others (parataxic distortions) provides valuable material for the group
to consider. An important and often disturbing phenomenon is projective identification, which
can result in one member projecting his or her own (but actually disowned) attributes onto
another toward whom they feel “an uncanny attraction–repulsion” (Yalom, 1985, p. 354). These
attributes may be projected so strongly that the other person’s behavior begins to change.
For example, murderous feelings may be projected so that the other begins to feel murderous,
whereas the projector has no awareness of such a feeling. The group itself, as a social
microcosm, also takes on patterns of behavior as if it were an individual and the facilitator must
understand these processes and comment on them, with the aim being for members themselves to
learn and to understand about these phenomena (see Rutan & Stone, 2001)
Some of the techniques commonly used in group art therapy include:
   1. Free Drawing: Participants are asked to draw whatever comes to mind without any
      constraints or guidelines. This helps to promote self-expression and creativity.
   2. Collage Making: Participants are asked to create a collage by cutting out and pasting
      various images from magazines or other sources onto a piece of paper. This can help to
      explore emotions and themes that may be difficult to express through words alone.
   3. Mandala Making: Participants are asked to create a circular design using various colors
      and patterns. This can promote relaxation and mindfulness.
   4. Group Murals: Participants work together to create a larger piece of artwork, such as a
      mural. This promotes collaboration and can help to build a sense of community within
      the group.
   5. Sculpture Making: Participants are asked to create three-dimensional objects using
      materials such as clay, paper-mache, or found objects. This can help to explore and
      express emotions in a tactile way.
   6. Guided Imagery: Participants are asked to close their eyes and imagine a specific
      scenario or scene, and then create artwork based on that image. This can help to promote
      relaxation and visualization.
   7. Storytelling: Storytelling can be used in art therapy to explore family narratives and
      history, as well as to promote communication and understanding between family
      members.
Overall, the techniques used in group art therapy can vary depending on the needs and goals of
the group, and are often adapted to suit the unique needs of individual participants.
Art therapy with parents is a collaborative process that involves using art materials and creative
expression to explore and address issues that may be impacting the parent-child relationship or
the family as a whole. Here are some ways in which art therapy can work with parents:
   1. Building rapport and trust: Art therapy provides a non-threatening, non-judgmental
      space for parents to explore their emotions and concerns, which can help to build trust
      and rapport between the parent and therapist.
   2. Enhancing communication: Art therapy can be especially helpful for children who have
      difficulty expressing themselves verbally. Through the use of art materials, children and
      parents can communicate their thoughts and feelings in a more tangible way, which can
      improve communication and understanding.
   3. Developing coping skills: Art therapy can help parents and children develop coping
      skills to deal with difficult emotions, such as stress, anxiety, and depression. Through the
      use of art materials and creative expression, parents and children can learn new ways to
      manage their emotions and work through challenges.
   4. Strengthening the parent-child relationship: Art therapy can be used to strengthen the
      parent-child relationship by promoting positive interactions and building a shared sense
      of accomplishment. This can lead to a stronger bond and improved communication
      within the family.
   5. Exploring family dynamics: Art therapy can be used to explore family dynamics and
      identify patterns of behavior that may be contributing to conflicts or other issues within
      the family. By exploring these dynamics through creative expression, parents and
      children can gain new insights into their relationships and work toward positive change.
The therapist begins by asking the family to work together to create a large painting. The parents
and children take turns adding different colors and shapes to the painting, with the therapist
guiding the process and encouraging communication and collaboration.
As the painting progresses, the therapist encourages each family member to express their
emotions and thoughts about what they are creating. The therapist may also ask the family to
share stories or memories that are triggered by the artwork.
Through this process, the family begins to open up and share their feelings with each other. The
children express their fear and sadness about their parents' arguments, while the parents share
their own struggles and frustrations. The therapist helps the family to listen to each other,
validate each other's feelings, and work together to find solutions.
Over time, the family begins to use the skills they have learned in family art therapy to
communicate more effectively with each other. They develop a deeper understanding of each
other's emotions and perspectives, and are better equipped to work through conflicts and
challenges together.
Family art therapy is a form of therapy that can involve a variety of creative techniques to help
families explore their emotions, improve communication, and strengthen relationships. Here are
some common techniques used in family art therapy:
   1. Collaborative art-making: Collaborative art-making involves having family members
      work together to create a piece of artwork. This can help to promote communication,
      cooperation, and empathy within the family, as well as encourage creativity and self-
      expression.
   2. Family sculptures: Family sculptures involve creating three-dimensional representations
      of the family using clay or other materials. This can be a powerful way to explore family
      dynamics and relationships, as well as promote understanding and empathy.
   3. Family drawings: Family drawings involve creating a drawing of the family together.
      This can help to explore family relationships and dynamics, as well as promote
      communication and collaboration.
   4. Narrative storytelling: Narrative storytelling involves using stories or myths to explore
      family relationships and dynamics. This can be a creative and engaging way to promote
      communication and understanding within the family.
   5. Therapeutic games: Therapeutic games involve using games or activities to explore
      family dynamics and relationships. For example, a therapist may use a board game that
      encourages communication and cooperation to help the family work through conflicts or
      challenges.
   6. Sand tray therapy: Sand tray therapy involves creating a scene using miniature objects
      in a tray of sand. This can be a powerful way to explore emotions and relationships, as
      well as promote relaxation and mindfulness.
Overall, family art therapy can be a creative and engaging way to help families explore their
emotions, improve communication, and strengthen relationships. The techniques used will
depend on the specific needs and goals of each family, and the therapist will work
collaboratively with the family to tailor the therapy to their unique needs.
contributing to the final piece. The therapist provides a variety of art supplies, such as paint,
markers, and paper, and asks the couple to begin creating.
As the couple works on the art project, the therapist observes their interactions and provides
guidance as needed. They may ask the couple questions about their art, such as what inspired
them to create a particular image or color. The therapist may also encourage the couple to talk to
each other about the art, asking them to describe what they see in their partner's art and how it
makes them feel.
As the session progresses, the therapist may use the art as a tool to facilitate communication and
problem-solving within the relationship. For example, if the couple is struggling with a particular
issue, the therapist may ask them to create art that represents their feelings or perspectives on the
issue. The therapist can then use this art as a way to help the couple communicate and work
through the issue together.
At the end of the session, the therapist and the couple review the art they have created and
discuss their experiences. The therapist may ask the couple to reflect on how the art-making
process impacted their relationship, and how they might continue to use art to strengthen their
connection in the future.
Overall, art therapy with couples can be a powerful tool for improving communication,
promoting understanding and empathy, and identifying and addressing issues within the
relationship. Through collaborative art-making, couples can explore their emotions and
perspectives in a nonverbal way, which can ultimately improve their relationship.
The creation of the Diagnostic Drawing Series (DDS) in the early 1980s was a response to three
important questions facing the field of art therapy:
   1. can we accurately differentiate diagnoses through art, particularly by generalizing from
      the art of a group of people?
   2. how shall we assess people through art?
   3. can the form of art tell us as much or more about the artist as its content?
The Diagnostic Drawing Series (DDS) is a projective assessment tool used in art therapy to help
identify and evaluate an individual's emotional and psychological state. Administering the DDS
involves a specific set of steps that are designed to create a safe and supportive environment for
the participant to express themselves creatively.
The DDS offers a way to contribute to accurate differential diagnosis and provides a structure for
participating in sound diagnostic research because reliable diagnostic information was collected
when the art was made (Cohen, 1983). The DDS art interview has a protocol that clearly
specifies which art materials are to be used and how it is to be administered (Cohen, 1983). It is
the first art therapy assessment with an accompanying rating system that focuses primarily on the
structure or formal qualities of the picture (Cohen, 1986a).
drawing is saved as a part of the Series. To end the session and to gain important information, his
or her thoughts and associations about the drawings should be discussed.
The DDS is designed to be administered in one 50-minute session; however, most people
complete it in about 20 minutes. It can be used with individuals age 13 and older. A number of
researchers have worked with younger children using a variety of versions of a modified DDS.
Diagnostic of DDR
The DDS is “diagnostic” in that an art therapist trained in it and familiar with its research basis
has the ability to contribute sound, clear-cut, practical information to the diagnostic process. The
name of the assessment does not mean that simply administering the assessment will lead to a
diagnosis. That is dependent on the DDS-specific knowledge of the assessors and whether they
are allowed to give or contribute to a diagnosis
The DDS is also “diagnostic” in that its objective is to “detect . . . and classify the client’s
pathology, focusing primarily on its causes, symptoms, severity, and prognosis” (Bruscia, 1988,
p. 5). The point is to see what configurations have been drawn on the three pages and to inform
clinicians how to identify them accurately (Dawes, Faust, & Meehl, 1989), not to interpret them
in terms of a particular theory.
However, clinicians can and do bring the skills and constructs that aid them in their work into
assessment sessions. Information from the art interview as a whole may contribute to treatment
planning. For example, one can and should see clients’ strengths by means of their DDSs (Cohen
& Mills, 1994). Strengths may be defined in part as the presence of formal elements associated
with the DDSs of nonpatient controls, or the absence of criteria found in the DDSs of any
diagnostic group.
   3. Wide Applicability: The DDS can be used with a wide range of populations, including
      children, adolescents, and adults. It is also used with individuals who have various
      emotional and psychological issues, including depression, anxiety, trauma, and addiction.
   4. Projective Assessment: The DDS is a projective assessment tool, which means that it
      allows individuals to project their unconscious thoughts and feelings onto the drawings.
      This can provide insights into issues that may not be apparent through other forms of
      assessment.
Limitations:
   1. Interpretation: One of the limitations of the DDS is that the results require interpretation
      by a trained and experienced art therapist. The interpretation process can be time-
      consuming, and the results may not be immediately apparent.
   2. Cultural Differences: The DDS is a Western-based assessment tool, which means that it
      may not be culturally appropriate or relevant for individuals from non-Western cultures.
   3. Subjectivity: The DDS is a subjective assessment tool, which means that the results can
      be influenced by the personal biases and perceptions of the art therapist administering the
      assessment.
   4. Limited Validity: The validity of the DDS as a diagnostic tool has been questioned by
      some researchers. While the DDS can provide insights into an individual's emotional and
      psychological state, it may not be sufficient as a standalone diagnostic tool.
In conclusion, while the DDS has several strengths as a standardized, nonverbal, projective
assessment tool, it also has limitations related to interpretation, cultural differences, subjectivity,
and limited validity. It is important for the art therapist to consider these strengths and limitations
when using the DDS as part of a comprehensive assessment and treatment plan.
The SDT uses “stimulus drawings” to prompt responses that solve problems and represent
concepts. These stimulus drawings consist of line drawings of people, animals, places, and
things. Some are explicit, while others are ambiguous to encourage associations. The SDT
includes two sets of 15 stimulus drawings.
   2. Content Themes Scale: This scale assesses the underlying themes and content of the
      drawing, such as the portrayal of family dynamics, self-image, or emotional expression.
      The therapist may look for recurring themes or symbols, such as images of animals,
      people, or objects that have personal significance to the individual. They may also look
      for common themes related to family relationships, personal identity, or life experiences.
   3. Emotional Content Scale: This scale assesses the emotional expression in the drawing,
      including the use of color, facial expressions, and body language. The therapist may look
      at the use of warm or cool colors, as well as the intensity of the colors used. They may
      also look at the facial expressions and body language of any figures depicted in the
      drawing, including their posture, gestures, and facial expressions.
   4. Cognitive Integration Scale: This scale assesses the individual's ability to integrate
      cognitive information into the drawing, such as the use of symbols or perspective. The
      therapist may look for the use of symbols or metaphors that represent complex ideas or
      emotions. They may also assess the use of perspective, such as the placement and size of
      objects in relation to each other, to gain insight into the individual's cognitive
      functioning.
   5. Stress Tolerance Scale: This scale assesses the individual's ability to cope with stress
      and adversity, as reflected in the drawing. The therapist may look for signs of stress or
      anxiety in the drawing, such as tense or jagged lines, dark or muted colors, or chaotic or
      cluttered composition. They may also look for signs of resilience or coping, such as
      images of support or sources of strength.
   6. Reality Testing Scale: This scale assesses the individual's ability to differentiate between
      reality and fantasy, as reflected in the drawing. The therapist may look for signs of
      distortion or delusion in the drawing, such as unrealistic or impossible scenarios. They
      may also assess the use of symbolism or metaphor, to gain insight into the individual's
      perception of reality.
   7. Self-Concept Scale: This scale assesses the individual's perception of self, body image,
      and self-esteem, as reflected in the drawing. The therapist may look for images of the self
      or representations of the individual's body, as well as any indications of self-esteem or
      self-criticism.
   8. Social-Interpersonal Scale: This scale assesses the individual's social and interpersonal
      functioning, including the portrayal of relationships, communication, and social skills.
      The therapist may look for images of other people or representations of social situations,
      as well as any indications of communication or interaction between figures in the
      drawing. They may also assess the quality of these interactions, looking for signs of
      conflict, intimacy, or distance.
These scales are used to provide a comprehensive assessment of the individual's cognitive and
emotional functioning, and to identify areas of strength and weakness that may need further
exploration or intervention.
The initial version of the MARI assessment consisted of a set of mandala templates with specific
instructions for drawing, such as creating a mandala that represents the individual's current
emotional state. Kellogg also developed a scoring system for analyzing the mandalas, based on
factors such as the use of color, shape, and symbols.
The MARI (Mandala Assessment Research Instrument) is a projective assessment tool that is
used to explore an individual's personality traits, coping mechanisms, and life experiences. The
assessment is based on the use of mandalas, which are circular drawings that serve as a
representation of the self and the individual's experiences.
The MARI assessment typically consists of several stages.
      First, the individual is provided with a blank mandala template and asked to create a
       mandala based on a specific set of instructions. For example, the individual may be asked
       to create a mandala that represents their current emotional state or their perception of
       their family relationships.
      Once the individual has completed the mandala, a trained professional (such as a
       psychologist or therapist) will analyze the drawing and identify key themes and patterns.
       The therapist will look at various aspects of the drawing, such as the use of color, shape,
       and symbols, to gain insight into the individual's inner world and underlying
       psychological processes.
For example, if an individual creates a mandala with a lot of red and black colors and jagged
lines, this may suggest that they are experiencing a lot of anger or emotional turmoil. If the
mandala includes images of water or waves, this may suggest that the individual is feeling
overwhelmed or out of control.
The therapist will also look for recurring themes or symbols in the mandala that may reflect the
individual's coping mechanisms or life experiences. For example, if an individual repeatedly uses
images of birds or flight in their mandalas, this may suggest a desire for freedom or a need to
escape from difficult situations.
In addition to the initial mandala drawing, the MARI assessment may also include other tasks or
exercises, such as a visual perception test or a writing exercise, to further explore the individual's
psychological processes.
Overall, the MARI assessment can provide valuable insight into an individual's personality,
coping mechanisms, and life experiences. It can help identify areas of strength and weakness, as
well as underlying psychological issues that may need further exploration or intervention.