Kümen
Kümen
1
Metrohm White Paper
Propylene oxide
Production methods
There are several production processes available, however the
majority of PO is still co-produced along with styrene mono-
mer (approximately one third of PO production worldwide).1
Other methods include the chlorohydrin process, epoxidation
of propylene with hydrogen peroxide, epoxidation of propyl-
ene with organic peroxides, and even epoxidation using mol-
ten salts.1–6
PO is derived from crude oil and is used in several industrial
applications, however it is mainly consumed for the produc-
Process depends on market needs
tion of polyols which are the building blocks for polyurethane
PO production methods are available both with and without
plastics. The primary reactant used is propene (propylene),
byproduct materials. Depending on the market for these by-
though there are several different production processes cur-
products, one or more processes may be in major use globally
rently in use on the market.1–6
at any one time.
Derivative markets
Many different markets utilize PO to manufacture other prod- Processes with co-products:
ucts. Some of the top derivative markets are: • Chlorohydrin (CH-PO)
• polyols • Styrene (SM-PO)
• propylene glycol • Methyl tert-butyl ether / Tert-butyl alcohol (MTBE-PO / TBA-PO)
• propylene glycol ethers
Derivative-free processes:
• Cumene (CU-PO)
• Hydrogen peroxide (HP-PO)
2
Metrohm White Paper
Overview of the major PO production processes
The first large-scale process developed for the production of Waste from CH-PO process
propylene oxide was based on the chlorohydrin route in the Wastewater resulting from the chlorohydrin process needs
earlier part of the 20th century. The chlorohydrin process has complicated and elaborate treatment methods. Salt resulting
been in decline since the 1950’s, though it still accounts for from the dechlorination procedure can be disposed of in the
a significant proportion of PO production volume globally.3,4 wastewater as well, though it is possible through chlor-alkali
High costs are involved both on the environment from the electrolysis to recover caustic and chlorine (at increased cost).3
massive amounts of wastewater and for utilities to generate
the large amounts of electricity needed to produce the
feedstock. CH-PO – Byproducts produced per ton of PO:1–5
• 100–150 kg 1,2-dichloropropane
Production method • 2.1 tons NaCl or 2.2 tons CaCl2
This method of PO manufacture is shown in Figure 1 and • 40 tons wastewater
Figure 2. The selectivity for producing propylene oxide is near
90%, however hundreds of kilograms of byproducts without
any significant sales market are obtained per ton of PO.1–3
Cl OH
OH Cl
2 + 2 HOCl +
Propylene 2-Propylene chlorohydrin 1-Propylene chlorohydrin
Cl OH
O
OH Cl
+ + Ca(OH)2 2 + CaCl2 + 2 H2O
2-Propylene chlorohydrin 1-Propylene chlorohydrin Propylene Oxide
Figure 1. Chemical process behind the chlorohydrin route to produce propylene oxide. Adapted from Bernhard et al.3
Figure 2. Schematic process diagram outlining the chlorohydrin method for co-production of propylene oxide. Adapted from Nijhuis et al.2
3
Metrohm White Paper
The styrene process (organic peroxide process)
+ O2
OOH
Ethylbenzene Ethylbenzene Hydroperoxide
OOH + + OH
Ethylbenzene Hydroperoxide Propylene Propylene Oxide 1-Phenylethanol
Al2O3
+ H2O
OH
1-Phenylethanol Styrene (monomer)
Figure 3. Chemical process behind the styrene (SM-PO) route to produce propylene oxide.3,4
4
Metrohm White Paper
Figure 4. Schematic process diagram outlining the styrene method for co-production of propylene oxide. Adapted from Nijhuis et al.2
5
Metrohm White Paper
Propene
Co-products
Hypochlorite Chlorohydrin
production formation epoxidation
tert-Butanol separation
Water
Chlorine
Caustic
purification
Brine
Electrolysis
Treatment
Propylene Oxide
Hydrogen
Figure 6. Schematic process diagram outlining the propylene oxide-tert-butyl alcohol (PO-TBA, also TBA-PO, MTBE-PO, or PO-MTBE in
literature) co-production method. Adapted from Trent.1
6
Metrohm White Paper
Byproduct-free methods to produce PO
The cumene process (organic peroxide process) Cumene in the chemical industry
The cumene to propylene oxide process (CU-PO) was Cumene is an aromatic hydrocarbon which is mainly used (in its
developed by Sumitomo Chemical. This PO production purified form) to produce cumene hydroperoxide (CMHP) —a
method is shown in Figure 7 and Figure 8. valuable intermediate for several other industrially processed
chemicals. Among these are phenol and acetone, detailed
Advantageous production method more in the related process application note, and later on in
Besides not being dependent on a separate co-product the applications section of this paper.
market, yet another advantage for CU-PO over SM-PO (and
other methods of PO production with byproducts) is the
stability of the hydroperoxide intermediate (CMHP).5 Related application note:
Determination of sulfuric acid in acetone and phenol:
AN-PAN-1008
https://www.metrohm.com/en/applications/AN-PAN-1008
Air
OOH
Cumene
Cumene Oxidation Hydroperoxide
(CMHP)
H2O
Hydrogenation Epoxidation Propylene
OH
H2
O Propylene
Oxide
α,α-dimethyl benzyl alcohol
Cumyl Alcohol (CMA)
Figure 7. Chemical process behind the cumene route to produce propylene oxide.5,7
7
Metrohm White Paper
Propene
Propene
recycle
Crude
PO
Make-up extractor
Cumene
H2O, light
CMHP lights, O2,
NaOH ends
Cumene H2O
Air Propene
light
Cumene recycle ends CMA
extractor
Cumene Heavily Propylene
Heavies H2O heavies oxygenated
H2 Oxide
Recycle compounds
Figure 8. Schematic process diagram outlining the cumene-propylene oxide (CU-PO) method for byproduct-free production of PO. Adapted
from Nemeth and Bare.7
8
Metrohm White Paper
The hydrogen peroxide process
H2
OH O
Hydrogenation
R R
R-anthraquinone
OH O
(R-AQ)
R-hydroxyanthraquinone
(R-HAQ) Air Oxidation H2O2
Propylene
Epoxidation
O
H2O
Propylene
Oxide
Figure 10. Chemical process behind the hydrogen peroxide route to produce propylene oxide.5
9
Metrohm White Paper
Environmental benefits Related application note:
The HP-PO process has the smallest environmental footprint Online analysis of peroxide in HPPO process: AN-PAN-1007
compared to all other existing technologies which produce https://www.metrohm.com/en/applications/AN-PAN-1007
propylene oxide at an industrial scale.4
• Wastewater reduction: 70–80%
• Energy savings: up to 35%
• Smaller industrial footprint
• Simpler raw material integration
• No byproducts, only H2O created beside PO
Makeup xylene
separation
reactor
& quinones
Oxygen
purge
flash
Hydrogen
L/L separation
epoxidation
Diluted
separation
H2O2
Propene Makeup
methanol
purge Methanol recycle Propene glycols
Figure 11. Schematic process diagram outlining the hydrogen peroxide-propylene oxide (HP-PO) method for byproduct-free production of
PO. Adapted from Nijhuis et al.2
10
Metrohm White Paper
Benefits of online process analysis
Typically, laboratory analysis for several key process parameters Inline and online process analysis also tie into closed-loop
is the norm to keep the production facility running smoothly control which brings production back in specification automat-
and safely. Manual sampling from various points along the ically with feed-forward chemical replenishment. Out-of-spec-
process is a necessity, which takes up valuable time. Delays in ification readings immediately trigger a warning at the control
sampling, analytical measurement, and data sharing due to room, ensuring the fastest response times. Analysis occurs at
these offline measurement strategies can have serious detri- the sampling point, leading to more accurate and reproducible
mental effects on production efficiency and overhead costs. results by the elimination of human bias and sample degra-
dation from transport delays. Reduction of manual sampling
lowers costs, saves time, and increases the safety of plant
operations.
Sampling Point
Process
Laboratory
$
SAVE
MONEY
Utilization of more effective methods which increase process Several online and inline application solutions exist for the
efficiency leads to higher productivity. Improvement of product production of propylene oxide. Titration, photometry (colo-
quality can be achieved much easier with the implementation rimetry) and even reagent-free spectroscopy all play signifi-
of automated process analysis, which increases profitability cant roles in these production processes.
for manufacturers.
Each PO production method is unique and requires a com-
bination of analytical techniques to cover the entire process,
from monitoring the raw material purity and environmental
ITY
TIV contaminants in the effluent up to and including stripping and
UC
OD recovery of reactants from the different process streams.
PR
HP-PO: High concentration H2O2 in effluent of the pri- heads and must be measured accurately. The measurement
mary reactor (reaction outlet line) is performed online with photometric titration, with all data
In the HP-PO process, hydrogen peroxide present in a metha- sent immediately to the control room for immediate process
nol solvent is used as the sole oxidizing agent and is the criti- adjustment measures in case of higher H2O2 concentrations.
cal feedstock and parameter to measure the complete con-
version rate to PO. Thus the high demand for accurate and Related application note:
robust online process monitoring throughout the whole reac- Online analysis of peroxide in HPPO process: AN-PAN-1007
tion process. https://www.metrohm.com/en/applications/AN-PAN-1007
Considering the dangerous nature of this area of the process, Figure 12. Titration curve for the determination of caustic soda
online measurement techniques are key. Hydrogen peroxide (NaOH) in a chemical manufacturing process. Data provided by a wet
is present in low concentrations in the finishing reactor over- chemical process analyzer from Metrohm Process Analytics.
12
Metrohm White Paper
SM-PO: Monitoring TBC levels accurately in the styrene Performing this measurement online with titration in an in-
storage tank according to ASTM D4590 dustrial process analyzer allows the control room to monitor
In the SM-PO process, styrene is manufactured along with the long-term trends, optimize the process, and keep a close
propylene oxide. Styrene is a monomer, which polymerizes to watch on concentrations of these chemicals outside of their
form polystyrene, used in a wide array of industrial and con- programmed warning levels.
sumer goods. The stabilizer 4-tert-butylcatechol (TBC) plays
a crucial role in preventing premature polymerization during
storage and transport of styrene, butadiene, vinyl acetate, and
other reactive monomers. Cumene: sulfuric acid in acetone & phenol (cleavage
reactor)
TBC is a free radical inhibitor which requires oxygen to pre- The CU-PO process requires cumene as a reactant. Cumene
vent the monomers from polymerizing. In the presence of the is produced from benzene and propylene, and can be used
correct amount of TBC, peroxide radicals are scavenged. Oth- as an intermediate in the production of other basic chemi-
erwise, the peroxide radicals react with styrene monomers to cals. Phenol, one of the products from the cumene produc-
form peroxide chains (polyperoxides) until the oxygen is com- tion process, is a precursor for the production of bisphenol A
pletely depleted. (65%) which is used to make polycarbonates. Other products
are phenolic resins and cyclohexanol. The production process
These radical species are especially hazardous during purifica- has three stages:
tion processes (distillation) due to the instability of peroxides
at increased temperatures. In order not to compromise the • production of cumene from benzene and propylene
product quality, the TBC concentration in styrene must stay • conversion of cumene to cumene hydroperoxide (same
above 10–15 mg/L. To control TBC depletion and ensure opti- process as in CH-PO)
mal storage conditions, close monitoring of its concentration • decomposition of cumene hydroperoxide to phenol and
is required. acetone
ASTM D4590 describes the specifications required to In this last stage, small amounts of sulfuric acid (H2SO4) are
accurately measure TBC inhibitor in styrene monomer within used to catalyze the reaction. Since the last reaction is very un-
this range, using colorimetry.9 Automated online photomet- stable, the cleavage reactor must operate under strict temper-
ric analysis of TBC is possible 24/7 with an explosion-proof ature and acidity control with a high level of acetone reflux. To
industrial process analyzer. Accurate data is provided around prevent the formation of color bodies and other undesirable
the clock, warning operators immediately if TBC levels are too byproducts, and to minimize corrosion, it is then necessary to
low. remove these traces of sulfuric acid prior to downstream dis-
tillation and purification. Therefore accurate and timely mea-
surement of sulfuric acid plays an important role in cumene
Related application note: production (found concurrently with the CU-PO process).
Monitoring of 4-tert-butylcatechol in styrene in
accordance with ASTM D4590: AN-PAN-1027 This analysis can be performed online via titration with a
https://www.metrohm.com/en/applications/AN-PAN-1027 process analyzer for both the cleavage effluent (lower con-
centrations) and for downstream production stages (higher
concentrations).
13
Metrohm White Paper
Finished Product: Analysis of low-level moisture in Polyols: Measuring OH in filter feed tank discharge
propylene oxide Approximately 70% of PO produced globally is used to make
Propylene oxide is a hazardous, flammable substance and polyether polyols, important raw materials for polyurethane
therefore must be treated with extreme caution. Measure- production. Hydroxyl (OH) is an important functional group
ment of moisture and other impurities in the final product and knowledge of its content is required in many intermediate
(as well as along the manufacturing process at critical points) and end-use products such as polyols.
is necessary to overcome unwanted side reactions or poor
yields. Manual laboratory analysis methods can be quite cum- Analysis of KOH in the production of polyols is necessary in
bersome and can introduce bias depending on the analyst. order to more tightly control the process and avoid unwanted
reactions from occurring. Manual sampling and analysis can-
The hygroscopic nature of PO necessitates inline or online not accurately monitor hydroxyl levels on a regular, contin-
analysis of water content for the most precise results. Addi- uous basis. Data transfer is slow and in the meantime, the
tionally, «real-time» analysis is a requirement for high through- uncorrected production process leads to suboptimal product
put PO production because this gives short response times in quality or lower yields.
case of process changes or increased water content in the
final product. Online measurement of OH concentrations is made simple us-
ing, for example, an explosion-proof (ATEX) industrial process
Fast, inline analysis of low moisture content is possible with analyzer configured for conductivity measurements. Time is
reagentless techniques such as near-infrared spectroscopy saved with the elimination of manual sampling procedures,
(NIRS). Suitable NIRS process analyzers are available for use and process optimization can be achieved more quickly when
in dangerous ATEX environments with robust stainless steel precise measurements of the hydroxyl content are consistently
flow cells. performed.
Summary
Propylene oxide is a key industrial product, manufactured via Manual sampling and laboratory analysis methods are slow
several different methods for use in various industries. With and can introduce human error and bias, which puts em-
global production of more than 7 million tons per year, PO is ployees at risk (health and safety). Additionally, the liberated
a major necessity for our modern lives. End products such as samples are no longer completely representative of the man-
polyester, polyurethane, and several types of solvents would ufacturing process, as many factors differ from the process
be much more difficult to manufacture without this raw after manual sampling such as temperature or pressure.
material.
Online and inline analysis techniques performed with
PO production is achieved either with or without the creation robust and rugged industrial process analyzers can overcome
of marketable co-products. The chlorohydrin process (CH-PO) many challenges which face every industry. There are several
was the first large-scale production route developed, however automated solutions currently available on the market to
large volumes of wastewater are produced and utility costs provide these services 24/7. When utilizing online titration,
are exorbitant, which has led to a decline in the popularity of photometry, ion chromatography or even inline spectroscop-
this method. Styrene (SM-PO) and methyl tert-butyl ether / ic techniques such as NIR analysis, companies can increase
tert-butyl alcohol (MTBE-PO / TBA-PO) production routes have the efficiency of their operations and reduce downtime due to
grown in popularity relative to the demand and sale price of unforeseen events. Results are more reliable and accurate
the byproducts created during manufacture. With the grow- with automation, as human error is removed from the equa-
ing pressure to become more environmentally friendly, deriv- tion. Company assets are protected through automated
ative-free processes such as cumene (CU-PO) and hydrogen process control and direct data transfer for immediate
peroxide (HP-PO) have been developed and are fast growing adjustments in critical situations. Improvement in the safety of
in this sector. the employees is an added bonus through the elimination of
manual sampling and analysis.
14
Metrohm White Paper
References
[1] Trent, D.L. Propylene Oxide. Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical Technology; online edition, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.:
New York, 2001. doi:10.1002/0471238961.1618151620180514.a01.pub2
[2] Nijhuis, T.A.; Makkee, M.; Moulijn, J.A.; Weckhuysen, B.M. The Production of Propene Oxide: Catalytic Processes and
Recent Developments. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 2006, 45, 3447–3459. doi:10.1021/ie0513090
[3] Bernhard, M.; Anton, J.; Schmidt, F.; Sandkaulen, F.; Pascaly, M. Vom Chlor zum Sauerstoff: Über den Technologiewandel in
der Propylenoxid-Herstellung. Chem. Unserer Zeit, 2017, 51, 198–209. doi:10.1002/ciuz.201700764
[4] Best Available Techniques (BAT) Reference Document for the Production of Large Volume Organic Chemicals; European
Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control Bureau (EIPPCB), Publications Office of the European Union: Luxembourg City,
Luxembourg (2017). http://eippcb.jrc.ec.europa.eu/reference/
[5] Tsuji, J.; Yamamoto, J.; Ishino M.; Oku, N. Development of New Propylene Oxide Process; Technical report translated from
"Sumitomo Kagaku" volume 2006-I: Sumitomo Chemical Co., Ltd., 2006.
[6] ThyssenKrupp Uhde. Propylene Oxide. The Evonik-Uhde HPPO technology: Innovative - Profitable - Clean. ThyssenKrupp
Industrial Solutions AG: Dortmund, Germany, 2015.
[7] Nemeth, L.; Bare, S.R. Science and Technology of Framework Metal-Containing Zeotype Catalysts. Advances in Catalysis,
2014, 57, 1–97.
[8] To, J.; Sokol, A.A.; Bush, I.J.; Catlow, R.A.; van Dam, H.J.J.; French, S.A.; Guest, M.F. QM/MM modelling of the TS-1 catalyst
using HPCx. J. Mater. Chem., 2006, 16, 1919–1926.
[9] Standard Test Method for Colorimetric Determination of p-tert-Butylcatechol In Styrene Monomer or AMS
(α–Methylstyrene) by Spectrophotometry; ASTM D4590-18; ASTM International: West Conshohocken, PA (2018).
https://www.astm.org/Standards/D4590.htm
WP-048EN by Metrohm, published 08-2019
Contact: 041-info@metrohm.com
15