Mini Project Final Report
Mini Project Final Report
ENGINEERING
VASAVI COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING
TITLE:
SUBMITTED BY:
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the mini project report entitled “Identifying the Optimal
Methods for Tuning a Vehicle to Enhance Overall Performance.” is a Bonafide
record of a mini project work carried out by,
It gives us immense pleasure to express our heartfelt gratitude and appreciation to all
those who have contributed to the successful completion of our mini project titled
“Identifying the Optimal Methods for Tuning a Vehicle to Enhance Overall
Performance.”
We are thankful to the principal Dr. S. V. Ramana, Vasavi college of engineering, for
permitting us to undergo our theme-based project. we are highly grateful to Dr.T.
Ram Mohan Rao, HOD of the Mechanical Department, for his kind support and for
Permitting us to complete our project.
We thank our Guide Dr. J Anjaneyulu, for his guidance and constant supervision
throughout the mini project. We would like to thank her for inspiring us guiding us by
providing constructive criticism for the successful completion of the project.
Finally, we would like to thank our families and friends for supporting, understanding,
and encouragement throughout this project. Their unwavering belief in us has been a
source of inspiration and motivation.
INDEX
This research investigates the effects of turbocharger and ECU tuning on vehicle
performance. By employing computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis and engine
simulation, we aim to increase air-fuel ratio (AFR), boost pressure, and overall engine
power output. The CFD analysis focuses on calculating the contribution it makes
towards Air Fuel Ratio.
By comparing the performance gains and trade-offs associated with different tuning
strategies, we aim to identify the optimal approach for enhancing vehicle performance.
1
METHADOLOGY
➢ Review:
ECU and turbocharger tuning are key modifications for enhanced performance.
ECU remapping optimizes engine parameters like fuel injection and ignition
timing for increased power and efficiency. Turbocharger upgrades, such as
larger turbos or upgraded internals, boost airflow into the engine, significantly
increasing power output. Together, these modifications can dramatically
improve a vehicle's acceleration, top speed, and overall driving experience.
However, it's crucial to balance performance gains with reliability and safety.
Professional tuning and high-quality components are essential to ensure optimal
results.
➢ Objectives:
1. Compare Turbocharging and ECU Remapping and gauge the Best.
2. Develop a way to visualize the performance through software.
3. Conclude the findings through proper Analysis.
4. Perform CFD analysis on Turbocharger
5. Simulate and Compare Tuned and Non-tuned Engines
6. Utilize MATLAB Vehicle composer tool to enhance the analysis.
2
INTRODUCTION
3
COMPARISON
4
Various Tuning Methods
Performance tuning is the tuning of an engine for motorsports. In this context, the
power output (e.g. In horsepower), torque, and responsiveness of the engine are of
premium importance, but reliability and fuel efficiency are also relevant. In races, the
engine must be strong enough to withstand the additional stress placed upon it and the
automobile must carry sufficient fuel, so it is often far stronger and has higher
performance than the mass-produced design on which it may be based. The
transmission, driveshaft and other load-transmitting powertrain components may need
to be modified to withstand the load from the increased power.
There are many techniques that can be used to increase the power and/or efficiency of
an engine. This can be achieved by modifying the air-fuel mixture drawn into the
engine, modifying the static or dynamic compression ratio of the engine, modifying
the fuel used (e.g. higher octane, different fuel types or chemistries), injection of water
or methanol, modifying the timing and dwell of ignition events, and compressing the
intake air. Air fuel ratio meters are used to accurately measure the amount of fuel in
the mixture. Fuel weight will affect the performance of the car, so fuel economy (thus
efficiency) is a competitive advantage.
➢ Replacing a stock throttle body with either a larger throttle body (Since it
increases airflow due to its larger bore size), an electronic throttle body that
opens quickly so that it can access airflow sooner (Which improves throttle
response), or a combination of both.
➢ Increasing the size of the poppet valves in the engine, thus decreasing the
restriction in the path of the fuel–air mixture entering the cylinder and the
exhaust gases leaving it. Using multiple valves per cylinder results in the same
5
effect, though it is often more difficult to fit several small valves than to have
larger, single valves due to the valve gear required. It can also be difficult to
find space for one large valve in the inlet and a large valve on the outlet side,
and sometimes a large exhaust valve and two smaller inlet valves are fitted.
➢ The larger bore may extend through the exhaust system using large-diameter
piping and low back pressure mufflers, and through the intake system with
larger diameter airboxes and high-flow, high-efficiency air filters. Muffler
modifications will change the sound of the engine, usually making it louder.
➢ Increasing the valve opening height (lift) by changing the profiles of the cams
on the camshaft or the lever (lift) ratio of the valve rockers in overhead valve
(OHV) engines, or cam followers in overhead cam (OHC) engines.
➢ Raising the compression ratio by reducing the size of the combustion chamber,
which makes more efficient use of the cylinder pressure developed and leading
to more rapid burning of fuel by using larger compression height pistons or
thinner head gaskets or by using a milling machine to "shave" the cylinder head.
High compression ratios can cause engine knock unless high-octane fuels are
used.
➢ Using a fuel with higher energy content and by adding an oxidizer such as
nitrous oxide.
➢ Using a fuel with better knock suppression characteristics (race fuel, E85,
methanol, alcohol) to increase timing advance.
6
➢ Reducing losses to friction by machining moving parts to lower tolerances than
would be acceptable for production, or by replacing parts. This is done In
overhead valve engines by replacing the production rocker arms with
replacements incorporating roller bearings in the roller contacting the valve
stem.
➢ Changing the location of the air intake, moving it away from the exhaust and
radiator systems to decrease intake temperatures. The intake can be relocated to
areas that have higher air pressure due to aerodynamic effects, resulting in
effects similar to forced induction.
7
APPLICATIONS
8
➢ Drift Racing
9
WORKING OF TURBOCHARGER
NEED OF TURBOCHARGER
The aim of a turbocharger is to improve an engine's volumetric efficiency by
increasing density of the intake gas (usually air) allowing more power per engine
cycle. The turbocharger's compressor draws in ambient air and compresses it before it
enters into the intake manifold at increased pressure. The purpose of a turbocharger is
to increase the power output of an engine by supplying compressed air to the engine
intake manifold so increased fuel can be utilized for combustion.
10
OPERATING PRINCIPLE
In normally aspirated piston engines, intake gases are pushed into the engine by
atmospheric pressure filling the volumetric void caused by the downward stroke of the
piston (which creates a low-pressure area), similar to drawing liquid using a syringe.
The amount of air actually sucked, compared to the theoretical amount if the engine
could maintain atmospheric pressure, is called volumetric efficiency. The objective of
a turbocharger is to improve an engine's volumetric efficiency by increasing density of
the intake gas (usually air).
The turbocharger's
compressor draws in
ambient air and
compresses it before it
enters into the intake
manifold at increased
pressure. This results in
a greater mass of air
entering the cylinders
on each intake stroke.
The power needed to
spin the centrifugal
compressor is derived
from the kinetic energy
of the engine's exhaust
gases. The pressure
volume diagram shows
the extra work done by turbocharging the diesel engine.
11
ADVANTAGES OF TURBOCHARGER
13
DISADVANTAGES OF TURBOCHARGER
14
TYPES OF TURBOCHARGERS
15
BMW X5 M and X6 M, dual-displacement turbos are used, one on each side of the
V8.
Advantages
• For twin parallel turbos on ‘V’ shaped engines, the benefits (and drawbacks) are
very similar to single turbo setups.
• For sequential turbos or using a turbo at low RPM and both at high RPM, this
allows for a much wider and flatter torque curve. Better torque at low revs, but
power won’t drop at high RPM like with a small turbo.
Disadvantages
• Cost and complexity, since it almost doubles the turbo components.
• There are lighter and more efficient ways to achieve similar results (as
explained below).
3. Dual scroll turbo
Twin-scroll turbochargers are better in almost every way than single-scroll
turbochargers. By using two scrolls, the escape pulses are split. For example, in four-
cylinder engines (firing order 1-3-4-2), cylinders 1 and 4 can be fed to a turbo scroll,
while cylinders 2 and 3 are fed to a separate scroll. Why is this beneficial? Let’s say
cylinder 1 is ending its power stroke when the piston approaches bottom dead center
and the exhaust valve begins to open. While this is happening, cylinder 2 ends the
exhaust stroke, closes the exhaust valve, and opens the intake valve, but there is some
overlap. In a traditional single-displacement turbo manifold, the exhaust pressure from
cylinder 1 will interfere with cylinder 2 sucking in fresh air, as both exhaust valves are
temporarily open, reducing how much pressure reaches the turbo and interfering with
the amount of air. pulling cylinder 2. By dividing the scrolls, this problem is
eliminated.
Advantages
• More energy is sent to the exhaust turbine, which means more power.
• A wider effective boost RPM range is possible based on different displacement
designs.
• Greater valve overlap is possible without hampering exhaust cleanliness, which
means greater adjustment flexibility.
Disadvantages
• It requires a specific engine layout and exhaust design (for example: I4 and V8
where 2 cylinders can be fed at each turbo displacement, at uniform intervals).
• Cost and complexity compared to traditional individual turbos.
16
4. Variable Geometry Turbocharger (VGT)
Perhaps one of the rarest forms of turbocharger, VGTs have limited production
(though quite common in diesel engines) as a result of cost and exotic material
requirements. The internal vanes within the turbocharger alter the area-to-radius (A /
R) ratio to match RPM. At low rpm, a low A / R ratio is used to increase the speed of
the exhaust gases and rapidly accelerate the turbocharger. As revs increase, the A / R
ratio increases to allow more airflow. The result is low turbo lag, low boost threshold,
and a wide, smooth torque band.
Advantages
• Wide, flat torque curve. The turbocharger is effective over a very wide RPM
range.
• It requires a single turbo, which simplifies a sequential turbo setup into
something more compact.
Disadvantages
• It is usually only used in diesel applications where the exhaust gases are lower
so that the vanes are not damaged by heat.
• For gasoline applications, cost generally keeps them out, as exotic metals must
be used to maintain reliability. The technology has been used in the Porsche
997, although very few VGT gasoline engines exist as a result of the associated
cost.
5. Variable double scroll turbocharger
Could this be the solution we were waiting for? While attending SEMA 2015, I
stopped by the BorgWarner booth to see the latest in turbochargers, among the
concepts is the variable twin-scroll turbo as described in the video above.
Advantages
• Significantly cheaper (in theory) than VGTs, making it an acceptable case for
gasoline turbocharging.
• Allows for a wide and flat torque curve.
• More robust in design than a VGT, depending on material selection.
Disadvantages
• Cost and complexity compared to using a traditional single turbo or dual scroll.
• The technology has been played around with before (ex: fast spool valve) but it
doesn’t seem to be succeeding in the production world. There are likely to be
additional challenges with technology.
17
6. Electric turbochargers
Aeristech’s patented all-electric turbocharger technology is a new enabling technology
that will help vehicle manufacturers comply with future stricter emissions legislation,
while providing excellent response throughout the engine’s operating range, even at
low engine revolutions and vehicle speed. FETT is the ultimate solution for extreme
engine downshifting and improved engine efficiency using a single stage turbocharger.
Throwing a powerful electric motor into the mix eliminates almost all the downsides
of a turbocharger. Turbo lag? Gone. Not enough exhaust fumes? No problem. Turbo
can’t produce low-end torque? You can now! Perhaps the next phase of modern
turbocharging, to be sure, there are also downsides to the electric route.
Advantages
• By connecting an electric motor directly to the compressor wheel, insufficient
turbo lag and exhaust gases can be virtually eliminated by rotating the
compressor with electric power when needed.
• By connecting an electric motor to the exhaust turbine, wasted energy can be
recovered (as is done in Formula 1).
• A very wide effective RPM range with uniform torque throughout.
Disadvantages
• Cost and complexity as you now have to factor in the electric motor and make
sure it stays cool to avoid reliability issues. That also applies to additional
drivers.
• Packaging and weight become an issue, especially with the addition of an on-
board battery, which will be required to supply enough power to the turbo when
needed.
• VGTs or twin rolls can offer very similar benefits (though not to the same level)
for significantly less cost.
18
WORKING OF ECU
What is an ECU?
The use of the term ECU may be used to refer to an Engine Control Unit, however
ECU also refers to an Electronic Control Unit, which is a component of any
automotive mechatronic system, not just for the control of an engine.
In the Automotive industry, the term ECU often refers to an Engine Control Unit
(ECU), or an Engine Control Module
(ECM). If this unit controls both an
engine and a transmission, it is often
described as a Powertrain Control
Module (PCM).
20
Precise fuel management
An ECU has to deal with many variables when deciding the correct mixture ratio.
• Engine demand
• Engine/Coolant temperature
• Air temperature
• Fuel temperature
• Fuel quality
• Varying filter restriction
• Air pressure
• Engine pumping efficiency
These require a number of sensors to measure such variables and apply them to logic
in the programming of the ECU to determine how to correctly compensate for them.
An increase in engine demand (such as accelerating) will require an increase in the
overall quantity of mixture. Because of the combustion characteristics of the fuels in
use, it also requires a change in the ratio of this mixture. When you press the
accelerator pedal, your throttle flap will open to allow more air in to the engine. The
increase in airflow to the engine is measured by the Mass Air Flow sensor (MAF) so
the ECU can change the amount of fuel that’s injected, keeping the mixture ratio
within limits.
It doesn’t stop there. For best power levels and safe combustion, the ECU must change
the ratio of the mixture and inject more fuel under full throttle than it would during
cruising – this is called a ‘rich mixture’. Conversely, a fuelling strategy or a fault that
results in less than a normal quantity of fuel being injected would result in a ‘lean
mixture’.
In addition to calculating the fuelling based on driver demand, temperature has a
considerable part to play in the equations used. Since petrol is injected as a liquid,
evaporation has to occur before it will combust. In a hot engine, this is easy to
manage, but in a cold engine the liquid is less likely to vapourise and more fuel must
be injected to keep the mixture ratio within the correct range for combustion.
Flashback: Prior to the use of the ECU, this function was managed by a ‘choke’ on the
carburetor. This choke was simply a flap that restricted the airflow into the carburetor
increasing the vacuum at the jets to promote more fuel flow. This method was often
inaccurate, problematic and required regular adjustment. Many were adjusted
manually by the driver while driving. The temperature of the air also plays a role in
combustion quality in much the same way as the varying atmospheric pressure.
21
Perfecting Combustion
Since a car engine spends most of its
time at part throttle, the ECU
concentrates on maximum efficiency
in this area. The ideal mixture, where
all of the injected fuel is combusted
and all oxygen is consumed by this
combustion, is known as
‘stoichiometric’ or often as ‘Lambda’.
At stoichiometric conditions, Lambda
= 1.0.
The Exhaust Gas Oxygen Sensor (Lambda sensor, O2 Sensor, Oxygen Sensor or
HEGO) measures the amount of oxygen left over after combustion. This tells the
engine whether there is an excess of air in the mixture ratio – and naturally whether
there is excessive or insufficient fuel being injected. The ECU will read this
measurement, and constantly adjust the fuel quantity injected to keep the mixture as
close to Lambda = 1.0 as possible. This is known as ‘closed loop’ operation, and is a
major contribution to the advanced efficiency that comes from using engine ECUs.
Because of the strict emissions regulations now in force, there are many other systems
on an engine that help to reduce fuel consumption and/or environmental impact. These
include:
• Exhaust Gas Recirculation (EGR)
• Catalytic converter and Selective Catalytic Reduction
• Exhaust Air Injection Reaction (AIR)
• Diesel Particulate Filters (DPF)
• Fuel Stratification
• Exhaust Additive Injection (Such as AdBlue)
• Evaporative emissions control (EVAP)
• Turbocharging and supercharging
• Hybrid powertrain systems
• Variable Valvetrain Control (Such as VTEC or MultiAir)
• Variable Intake Control
Each of the above systems affect engine operation in some way and as a consequence
need to be under full control of the ECU.
22
ADVANTAGES OF ECU
23
DISADVANTAGES OF ECU
1. Warranty Concerns
One of the primary drawbacks of ECU tuning is that it can void the manufacturer’s
warranty on your vehicle. Most car manufacturers strictly prohibit any modifications
to the ECU, as it can potentially compromise the reliability and safety of the vehicle. If
you have a newer car and are still covered under warranty, it’s crucial to weigh the
potential performance gains against the risk of losing your warranty protection.
2. Increased Stress on Engine Components
ECU tuning typically involves pushing the engine beyond its factory settings to
achieve higher levels of performance. While this may result in a noticeable increase in
power, it can also put additional stress on various engine components. Over time, this
increased stress can lead to accelerated wear and tear, and potentially increase the risk
of mechanical failures.
3. Reduced Longevity of Engine
The higher stress levels caused by ECU tuning can also impact the longevity of your
engine. Pushing the engine to its limits on a regular basis can result in premature wear
and decrease the overall lifespan of the engine. It’s important to consider this trade-off
when deciding whether or not to proceed with ECU tuning, especially if you plan on
keeping your vehicle for an extended period.
4. Potential for Higher Maintenance Costs
Modifying the ECU can often lead to increased maintenance requirements and costs.
The additional strain placed on the engine may necessitate more frequent oil changes,
spark plug replacements, and other maintenance tasks. It’s essential to factor in these
potential costs when evaluating the overall value of ECU tuning.
5. Difficulty in Reverting Changes
Once the ECU has been tuned, reverting the changes back to the original settings can
be a complicated and time-consuming process.
24
TYPES OF ECU
25
Engine Simulator
Our motive behind using this software is visualize a Tuned and Non-Tuned Engine of
the same car model. In order to demonstrate this, we are using Ferrari F40 Engine.
The Ferrari F40 (Type F120) is a mid-engine, rear-wheel drive sports car engineered
by Nicola Materazzi with styling by Pininfarina. It was built from 1987 until 1992, The
specs are given below,
⚬ Engine: Twin-
turbocharged 2.9L V8.
⚬ Horsepower: 471 hp @
7,000 rpm.
⚬ Torque: 426 lb-ft @
4,000 rpm.
⚬ Acceleration: 0-60mph in 3.8 seconds.
⚬ Top Speed: 201 mph.
26
The code is accessible in Visual Studio Code Editor, we can change various values
which directly affects the overall engine characteristics.
Changes made:
• Increased stroke length from 69.5 to 79.5.
• Increased volume from 2.936 L to 3.436 L.
• Increased Maximum RPM from 8100 RPM to 10500 RPM.
• Increased Starter torque from 50 Nm to 450 Nm.
• Increased Starter speed from 800 RPM to 5000 RPM and reduced 100Kg mass.
27
In the above screenshot, the software is running the Tuned version of the engine
With the listed changes. As you can see, The Dyno test is on, to calculate the
maximum horsepower and maximum RPM. The values are highlighted in yellow and
enclosed in a box.
It produces 822 HP which almost doubles its stock engine performance. Performance
tests like these are very costly and difficult to perform.
Through this software, we can have an idea of engine characteristics after changes.
All Gauges displayed work or update in real time. There are few Graphical
trajectories which monitor various aspects of the engine. We can even calculate the
fuel consumed, Intake and Exhaust, etc.
The software greatly visualizes the Piston movement of the engine, Ignition cycles of
the engine.
28
DESIGN OF TURBOCHARGER
Turbocharger Construction
Centre-Housing
29
Bearings
The turbocharger
bearing system appears
simple in design, but it
plays a key role in a
number of critical
functions. Some of the
more important ones
include: the control of
radial and axial motion
of the shaft and wheels
and the minimization of
friction losses in the
bearing system.
Seals
Seals are located at both ends of the bearing housing. These seals represent a difficult
design problem due to the need to keep frictional losses low, the relatively large
movements of the shaft due to bearing clearance and adverse pressure gradients
under some conditions.
These seals primarily serve to keep intake air and exhaust gas out of the centre
housing. The pressures in the intake and exhaust systems are normally higher than in
the turbocharger’s centre housing which is typically at the pressure of the engine
crankcase.
30
Turbo Bearing Housing
The turbocharger bearing housing is a crucial component that supports and protects the
rotating shaft and wheels within the turbocharger. It is a complex part designed to
withstand extreme conditions of high temperatures, high pressures, and rapid
rotational speeds.
Key Functions of the Bearing Housing:
1. Support and Alignment:
o Provides a precise and stable platform for the turbine and compressor
wheels to rotate.
o Ensures proper alignment of the rotating shaft to minimize friction and
wear.
2. Lubrication:
o Houses the bearings that provide lubrication to the rotating components,
reducing friction and heat generation.
o Maintains optimal lubrication conditions to prolong the life of the
turbocharger.
3. Sealing:
o Incorporates seals to prevent leakage of oil and exhaust gases, ensuring
efficient operation and minimal environmental impact.
4. Heat Dissipation:
o Designed to dissipate heat generated by the high-speed rotation of the
components, preventing overheating and damage.
31
Turbo Fan
The turbocharger rotor assembly is the heart of the turbocharger system. It's
responsible for boosting the engine's performance by compressing more air into the
combustion chamber. This leads to:
• Increased power and torque: More air means more fuel can be burned, resulting in
greater power output.
• Improved fuel efficiency: By utilizing the waste energy from the exhaust gases,
turbochargers can improve fuel economy.
• Reduced emissions: More efficient combustion can lead to lower emissions of
pollutants.
The design and materials used in the rotor assembly are crucial for its performance
and durability. Engineers must carefully consider factors like blade shape, material
selection, and balancing to optimize the turbocharger's efficiency and longevity.
32
Turbo Compressor Fan
33
Turbo Compressor Cover
The compressor cover is a crucial part of a turbocharger, responsible for directing the
airflow into and out of the compressor wheel. It plays a significant role in the overall
efficiency and performance of the turbocharger.
1. Airflow Direction: The cover guides the incoming air into the compressor wheel,
ensuring optimal airflow and minimizing turbulence.
2. Pressure Build-up: It helps to create a pressure differential between the inlet and outlet
of the compressor, which is essential for efficient air compression.
3. Sealing: The cover seals the compressor wheel, preventing air leaks and maximizing
efficiency.
4. Structural Support: It provides structural support for the compressor wheel and
bearings, ensuring their correct alignment and preventing damage.
34
Turbo Housing
The turbocharger housing is a critical component that encloses the turbine and
compressor wheels, providing structural support and protection. It also plays a vital
role in directing airflow and managing heat.
1. Structural Support: The housing provides a rigid framework to support the rotating
components, ensuring proper alignment and preventing damage.
2. Airflow Management: It guides the airflow through the turbine and compressor,
optimizing their performance.
3. Heat Dissipation: The housing helps to dissipate heat generated by the high-speed
rotation of the turbocharger components, preventing overheating.
4. Sealing: It seals the turbocharger, preventing leakage of oil and exhaust gases, which
can reduce efficiency and increase emissions.
35
TURBOCHARGER ASSEMBLY
36